MADHU PREMANATHAN vs State of Tamil Nadu

Court
Madras High Court

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON : 08.10.2026
PRONOUNCED ON : 17.11.2026
CORAM :
THE HONOURABLE MR. SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI,
CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE G.ARUL MURUGAN
W.P.Nos.31800, 31541, 32446, 34213 & 35768 of 2026
and
W.M.P.Nos.34960, 34962, 34963, 34673, 34677, 35666, 35668, 37611,
37613, 39981 & 39982 of 2026
AND
W.P.(MD) Nos.21931, 22304, 22569, 22929 & 23455 of 2026
and
W.M.P.(MD) Nos.16361, 16712, 16608, 16609, 16823, 16824, 17076,
17077, 17460 & 17464 of 2026
WP No.31800 of 2026 :
CNR: {HCMA011867212026}
Madhu Premnathan
D.No.4, No.489, Ungati,
Doripalli, Shoolagiri Taluk
Krishnagiri District.
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1. State of Tamil Nadu
Represented by the Principal Secretary to
the Government,
Natural Resources Department, (MMD.1)
Fort St. George, Chennai 600 009.
2. The Director
___________
Page 1 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
Department of Geology and Mining,
Guindy, Chennai 600 032.
3. Deputy Director
Department of Geology and Mining,
Krishnagiri, Tamil Nadu.
4. The District Collector
Hosur District, Tamil Nadu.
5. Crusher Owners’ Federation,
Hosur.
(Reg No.112 of 2018),
nd
No.136/1, 2 Floor, Raghavendra Towers,
Inner Ring Road, Hosur- 635109.
..Respondent(s)
Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
praying (i) to declare the amendment to the Tamil Nadu Prevention of
Illegal Mining, Transportation and Storage of Minerals and Mineral
Dealers’ Rules, 2011 inserting Rule 3-A vide G.O.Ms.No.15 dated
09.07.2026 and notified in the official gazette on 09.07.2026 as ultra
vires to Articles 301 and 304(b) of the Constitution of India and Section
23-C(1) of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act,
1957; (ii) for issuance of a writ of Certiorari calling for the records
relating to the impugned proceedings in Rc.No.4104/MM2/2026 dated
27.07.2026 passed by the second respondent and quash the same.
For Petitioner(s): Mr.AR.L.Sundaresan
Senior Counsel
Assisted by Mr.D.Prabhu Mukunth Arun Kumar
for Mr.B.Rabu Manohar
___________
Page 2 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
For Respondent(s): Mr.Vijay Narayan
Advocate General
Assisted by Mr.J.Lenin
Spl. Govt. Pleader
and Mr.Akash Srinanda,
Govt. Advocate For R1 to R4
Mr.Srinath Sridevan
Senior Counsel
for Mr.U.Baranidharan For R5
COMMON ORDER
G. ARUL MURUGAN, J.
This batch of writ petitions seek to declare Rule 3-A of the Tamil Nadu
Prevention of Illegal Mining, Transportation and Storage of Minerals and
Minerals Dealers’ Rules, 2011, (hereinafter referred to as “2011
Rules”), introduced by amendment vide G.O.Ms. No.15, Natural
Resources Department (MMD.1), dated 09.07.2026, notified in the
Gazette on 09.07.2026, as unconstitutional and ultra vires of the Mines
and Minerals (Development and Regulations) Act, 1957 (in short
“MMDR Act”) and to quash the proceedings of the Director of Geology
and Mining, dated 27.07.2026, imposing a temporary ban on
transportation of rough stone and aggregates to other States for three
months.
2. Since the issues raised in all the writ petitions pertain to the
constitutional validity of Rule 3-A of the 2011 Rules and the order
___________
Page 3 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
dated 27.07.2026 imposing temporary ban, the cases were
analogously heard and are disposed of by this common order.
3.1. The petitioners are either leaseholders or crusher operators
who hold valid mining leases and possess all other statutory
clearances required for carrying on mining and crushing activities. The
minerals, mostly rough stone quarried through valid mining leases,
after payment of royalty and seigniorage fee, are transported to
crushing units where boulders are reduced in size through crushing
into M-sand, metal jelly, ballasts, mill stones, etc., and transported for
sale. The entire activity from mining to dispatch for sale, are carried on
pursuant to valid lease and required statutory clearances.
3.2. The State, by invoking the powers conferred under Section
23-C of the MMDR Act, had enacted the Tamil Nadu Prevention of Illegal
Mining, Transportation and Storage of Minerals and Minerals Dealers’
Rules, 2011. While so, now through G.O.Ms. No.15, Natural Resources
Department (MMD.1), dated 09.07.2026, had brought in amendment to
the 2011 Rules by inserting Rule 3-A, which deals with transportation of
rough stone to other States. Rule 3-A of the 2011 Rules, reads as
follows:
___________
Page 4 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
“3-A. Transportation of rough stone, etc., to other States:
The Director of Geology and Mining shall regulate the transport of
rough stone including Khandas, boulders, size reduced (broken or
crushed) materials including M-Sand, metal jelly, ballasts, mill
stones, hand chakais and building and road construction stones
across the border to other States, which may include imposition of
temporary ban, to ensure their availability for adequate supply
within the State”.
3.3. Invoking the powers conferred under Rule 3-A, the Director
of Geology and Mining, by proceedings dated 27.07.2026, imposed a
temporary ban of three months for transporting rough stone and
aggregates to other states, except Puducherry and Karaikal Districts.
Relevant portion of the said proceedings is extracted below:
“In exercise of the powers delegated under rule 3(A) of the
Tamil Nadu Prevention of Illegal Mining, Transportation and
Storage of a precautionary Minerals and Minerals Dealers Rules,
2011, as measure to ensure uninterrupted supply of minerals
within the State, ensure protection of the environment and
ecology and also prevent illegal mining and transportation of
___________
Page 5 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
minerals, the transportation of rough stone and aggregates to
other States except Puducherry and Karaikal Districts of
Puducherry UT, is hereby, temporarily banned for three months
with immediate effect. The contravention of the ban by any
person will attract stringent action as per the existing Act and the
rules made there under.”
3.4. The petitioners, who sell rough stone and its products, both
intra and inter-State, aggrieved by the ban have assailed Rule 3-A,
which empowers the authority to impose temporary ban and also the
consequential temporary ban imposed.
4. We have elaborately heard learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioners and learned Advocate General appearing for the State.

5. Learned Senior Counsel, Mr.Srinath Sridevan,
Mr.AR.L.Sundaresan, Mr.Satish Parasaran, Mr.Ajmal Khan along with
learned counsel, Mr.Sanjeevi and Mr.Puhazh Gandhi, appearing for the
petitioners, broadly made the following submissions:
i. Section 15 of the MMDR Act empowers the State to make rules
___________
Page 6 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
for regulating the grant of quarry leases in respect of minor minerals,
which authority would be available only at the stage of granting the
lease and does not extend to excavated minerals after mining
operations have been completed.
ii. Section 23-C of the MMDR Act, introduced by way of an
amendment with effect from 18.12.1999, empowers the State to make
rules strictly for the prevention of illegal mining, transportation and
storage and does not extend to minor minerals that have been lawfully
mined and transported.
iii. After the grant of lease and payment of royalty on the mined
mineral, the property vests with the lessee and the State has no
further role to deal with the excavated mineral. Reliance is placed on a
Three-Judge Bench decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of
1
Tamil Nadu v. M.P.P. Kavery Chetty , explicitly holding that no power is
conferred on the State to exercise control over minor minerals after
they have been excavated.
iv. Rule 3-A is beyond the rule-making power conferred on the
State under Sections 15 and 23-C of the MMDR Act, suffers the vice of
1
(1995) 2 SCC 402
___________
Page 7 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
legislative competence and is, therefore, ultra vires the parent Act. The
delegated legislation has to confine to the powers conferred and
cannot travel beyond the scope.
v. Impugned Rule 3-A, which allows temporary prohibition for
transportation of minerals beyond the State, is unconstitutional, as it
restricts free trade and commerce beyond the State and suffers vice of
Article 301 of the Constitution of India.
v. The impugned Rule is unconstitutional as the power to impose
restrictions on trade inter-State is within the exclusive domain of the
Union under Article 302 of the Constitution of India. Furthermore, any
bill which even seeks to impose reasonable restrictions on the freedom
of trade beyond the State in the public interest under Article 304(b),
can be introduced in the State Legislature only with the previous
sanction of the President.
vi. By virtue of delegated rule-making power, the State can only
regulate the mineral at the pre-excavation stage and it cannot regulate
the mineral after it has undergone processing. The decisions of the
___________
Page 8 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
Andhra Pradesh High Court in M/s.Novel Granites Ltd. and Others. v.
2
Government of A.P. and Others and this Court, in D. Sivakumar v.
3
State of Tamil Nadu , which held that the State can regulate excavated
minerals by exercising powers under Section 23-C, have been explicitly
overruled by a decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of
4
Gujarat and Others v. Jayeshbhai Kanjibhai Kalathiya and Others .
vii. The issue regarding lack of legislative competence on the
State to ban inter-State trade on excavated minerals, tracing powers to
Section 23-C of the MMDR Act, is no longer res integra and stands
settled by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kalathiya (supra).

viii. Rule 3-A and the order of the Director of Geology and Mining
imposing a temporary ban to transport rough stone and its aggregates
to other States, are manifestly arbitrary, as the action of the State has
no rationale or reasonable nexus to the object that is sought to be
achieved.
6. Mr. Vijay Narayan, learned Advocate General for the State
broadly made the following submissions:
2
W.P.No.5871 of 2005 decided on 30.10.2008
3
(2009) 3 CTC 97
4
(2019) 16 SCC 513
___________
Page 9 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
i. The power of the State to introduce Rule 3-A in the 2011 Rules
is traceable to the rule-making power delegated to the State under
Section 15, more particularly, Section 23-C of the MMDR Act,
introduced on 18.12.1999, which enables the State to regulate the
minor minerals.
ii. Sub-Section (c) of Section 23 of the MMDR Act empowers the
State to regulate mineral being transported from the area granted
under a mining lease. Hence, Rule 3-A falls within the rule-making
power of the State.
iii. Once the Parliament has delegated the power to the State to
regulate minerals and a rule is framed by tracing its authority to
Sections 15 and 23-C of the MMDR Act, such a State rule becomes part
of the parent enactment itself. In support of this principle, reliance is
placed on a decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Tamil
5
Nadu v. M/s. Hind Stone and Others .
iv. The State had framed the 2011 Rules on 25.01.2011 in
exercise of the powers conferred under Section 23-C of the MMDR Act.
5
(1981) 2 SCC 205
___________
Page 10 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
Since the power to ban or regulate transport had not been explicitly
incorporated at that time, Rule 3-A was introduced through an
amendment on 09.07.2026 with the object of regulating transport in
the larger public interest. The power of the State to regulate minor
minerals includes the power to prohibit, as held by the Hon'ble
6
Supreme Court in K.Ramanathan v State of Tamil Nadu and Another .
v. Rule 3-A was introduced with the object of balancing State
needs, public safety and domestic requirements against excessive
inter-State transportation, which had resulted in minerals being
predominantly diverted to Middle East countries and the rule,
therefore, serves larger public interest addressing domestic needs and
public safety.
vi. Since the decision in Kalathiya (supra) did not consider the
decisions in Hind Stone (supra) and K.Ramanathan (supra) , which are
earlier judgments delivered by benches of co-equal strength, in view of
the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union Territory of
Ladakh and Others v. Jammu and Kashmir National Conference and
7
Another , the earlier judgments in Hind Stone (supra) and
6
(1985)2 SCC 116
7
2023 INSC 804
___________
Page 11 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
K.Ramanathan (supra), which validates the rule are to be followed.
vii. The proceedings of the Directorate of Geology and Mining
dated 27.07.2026, which imposed a temporary three-month ban, have
effectively worked themselves out. As the ban period is coming to an
end, the present challenge has almost rendered infructuous.
7. We gave our anxious consideration to the rival submissions
and considered the materials available on record.
8. Entry 54 of List I in the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of
India, deals with the regulation of mines and mineral development,
vesting control in the Union to the extent declared by Parliament in the
public interest. Entry 54 reads as follows:
“54. Regulation of mines and mineral development to the
extent to which such regulation and development under the
control of the Union is declared by Parliament by law to be
expedient in the public interest.”
9. As regulation of mines and mineral development falls under
Entry 54 of the Union List, the Parliament had enacted the MMDR Act.
___________
Page 12 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
Section 2 of the MMDR Act contains a declaration that it is expedient in
the public interest that the Union should take under its control the
regulation of mines and mineral development. Section 2 reads thus:
“2. Declaration as to the expediency of Union control:
It is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public
interest that the Union should take under its control the regulation
of mines and mineral bearing lands and the development of
minerals to the extent hereinafter provided.”
10. By the MMDR Act, the regulation of mines, mineral bearing
lands and development vests with the Central Government. While the
major minerals are regulated by the MMDR Act, Section 15 of the
MMDR Act enables the State Governments to make rules in respect of
regulating the grant of minor minerals. Section 15 of the MMDR Act
reads as follows:
“15. Power of State Governments to make rules in respect
of minor minerals:
(1) The State Government may, by notification in the Official
Gazette, make rules for regulating the grant of quarry leases,
___________
Page 13 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
mining leases or other mineral concessions in respect of minor
minerals and for purposes connected therewith.
(1-A) In particular and without prejudice to the generality of the
foregoing power, such rules may provide for all or any of the
following matters, namely:-
(a) the person by whom and the manner in which,
applications for quarry leases, mining leases or other mineral
concessions may be made and the fees to be paid therefor;
(b) the time within which, and the form in which,
acknowledgement of the receipt of any such applications
may be sent;
(c) the matters which may be considered where
applications in respect of the same land are received within
the same day;
(d) the terms on which, and the conditions subject to
which and the authority by which quarry leases, mining
leases or other mineral concessions may be granted or
renewed;
(e) the procedure for obtaining quarry leases, mining
leases or other mineral concessions;
(f) the facilities to be afforded by holders of quarry
leases, mining leases or other mineral concessions to persons
___________
Page 14 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
deputed by the Government for the purpose of undertaking
research or training in matters relating to mining operations;
(g) the fixing and collection of rent, royalty, fees, dead
rent, fines or other charges and the time within which and
the manner in which these shall be payable;
(h) the manner in which rights of third parties may be
protected (whether by way of payment of compensation or
otherwise) in cases where any such party is prejudicially
affected by reason of any prospecting or mining operations;
(i) the manner in which rehabilitation of flora and other
vegetation, such as trees, shrubs and the like destroyed by
reason of any quarrying or mining operations shall be made
in the same area or in any other area selected by the Stale
Government (whether by way of reimbursement of the cost
of rehabilitation or otherwise) by the person holding the
quarrying or mining lease;
(j) the manner in which and the conditions subject to
which, a quarry lease, mining lease or other mineral
concession may be transferred;
(k) the construction, maintenance and use of roads,
power transmission lines, tramways, railways, aerial
ropeways, pipelines and the making of passage for water for
mining purposes on any land comprised in a quarry or mining
lease or other mineral concession;
___________
Page 15 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
(l) the form of registers to be maintained under this
Act;
(m) the reports and statements to be submitted by
holders of quarry or mining leases or other mineral
concessions and the authority to which such reports and
statements shall be submitted;
(n) the period within which and the manner in which
and the authority to which applications for revision of any
order passed by any authority under these rules may be
made, the fees to be paid therefor, and the powers of the
revisional authority; and
(o) any other matter which is to be, or may be
prescribed.
(2) Until rules are made under sub-section (1), any rules
made by a State Government regulating the grant of quarry
leases, mining leases or other mineral concessions in respect of
minor minerals which are in force immediately before the
commencement of this Act shall continue in force.
(3) The holder of a mining lease or any other mineral
concession granted under any rule made under sub-section (1)
shall pay royalty or dead rent, whichever is more in respect of
___________
Page 16 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
minor minerals removed or consumed by him or by his agent,
manager, employee, contractor or sub-lessee at the rate
prescribed for the time being in the rules framed by the State
Government in respect of minor minerals:
Provided that the State Government shall not enhance the
rate of royalty or dead rent, whichever is more in respect of any
minor mineral for more than once during any period of three
years.
(4) Without prejudice to sub-sections (1), (2) and sub-
section (3), the State Government may, by notification, make
rules for regulating the provisions of this Act for the following,
namely -
(a) the manner in which the District Mineral Foundation shall
work for the interest and benefit of persons and areas
affected by mining under sub-section (2) of Section 9-B;
(b) the composition and functions of the District Mineral
Foundation under sub-section (3) of Section 9-B; and
(c) the amount of payment to be made to the District Mineral
Foundation by concession holders of minor minerals under
Section 15-A.”
___________
Page 17 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
11. Further, with a view to curb illegal mining, the Central
Government introduced Section 23C of MMDR Act with effect from
18.12.1999, empowering the State Government to make rules for
preventing illegal mining, transportation and storage of minerals.
Section 23-C reads as follows:
“23C. Power of State Government to make rules for
preventing illegal mining, transportation and storage of minerals:
(1) The State Government may, by notification in the Official
Gazette, make rules for preventing illegal mining, transportation
and storage of minerals and for the purposes connected
therewith.
(2) In particular and without prejudice to the generality of
the foregoing power, such rules may provide for all or any of the
following matters, namely:-
(a) establishment of check-posts for checking of
minerals under transit;
(b) establishment of weigh-bridges to measure the
quantity of mineral being transported;
(c) regulation of mineral being transported from the
area granted under a prospecting licence or a mining lease or
a quarrying licence or a permit, in whatever name the
___________
Page 18 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
permission to excavate minerals, has been given;
(d) inspection, checking and search of minerals at the
place of excavation or storage or during transit;
(e) maintenance of registers and forms for the
purposes of these rules;
(f) the period within which and the authority to which
applications for revision of any order passed by any authority
be preferred under any rule made under this section and the
fees to be paid therefor and powers of such authority for
disposing of such applications; and
(g) any other matter which is required to be, or may be,
prescribed for the purpose of prevention of illegal mining,
transportation and storage of minerals.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in section 30, the
Central Government shall have no power to revise any order
passed by a State Government or any of its authorised officers or
any authority under the rules made under sub-sections (1)
and (2).“
12. For taking any other action towards regulatory measures,
Section 4A of the MMDR Act deals with termination of prospecting
licences or mining leases, where sub-section (2) empowers the State
Government to request the Central Government to make premature
___________
Page 19 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
termination of a minor mineral lease for preservation of natural
environment, control of floods, prevention of pollution, to avoid
damage to public health, ensure safety, etc. Section 4A(2) reads as
follows :
“4-A. Termination of prospecting licences, exploration
licences or mining leases:
(2) Where the State Government is of opinion that it is
expedient in the interest of regulation of mines and mineral
development, preservation of natural environment, control of
floods, prevention of pollution or to avoid danger to public health
or communications or to ensure safety of buildings, monuments or
other structures or for such other purposes, as the State
Government may deem fit, it may, by an order, in respect of any
minor mineral, make premature termination of prospecting
licence or mining lease with respect to the area or any part
thereof covered by such licence or lease.”
13. In exercise of the powers conferred under Section 15 of the
MMDR Act, the State enacted the Tamil Nadu Minor Mineral Concession
Rules, 1959, which govern the regulation and grant of mining leases for
minor minerals. The grant, termination and regulation of all minor
___________
Page 20 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
minerals are governed strictly under the aforesaid rules. Further,
tracing to powers conferred under Section 23-C of the MMDR Act, the
State framed the 2011 Rules. In the said 2011 Rules, the impugned
Rule 3-A as extracted earlier was recently inserted, authorising the
Director of Geology and Mining to regulate the transportation of rough
stone and aggregates to other States, which purports to include the
power to impose a temporary ban.
14. The impugned rule is challenged on the ground of legislative
competence, ultra vires the Parent Act as the delegated legislation
exceeds the rule-making power vested in the State. The primordial
contention of the petitioners is that Sec.23-C of the MMDR Act only
deals with illegal mining and the State lacks the power to regulate or
deal with an excavated mineral after the lease has been granted. This
issue was already considered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kavery
Chetty (supra) , wherein the amendments made to the Tamil Nadu
Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1959, introducing Rules 8-D and
19-B, were declared unconstitutional. The Hon'ble Supreme Court held
that no power is conferred upon the State under the MMDR Act to
exercise control over minor minerals after they have been excavated.
___________
Page 21 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
15. Relevant portion of the aforesaid decision, is extracted
hereunder:
“19. The High Court quashed Rules 8-D and 19-B principally
on the ground that Section 15 of the said Act gave no power to
the State Government to frame rules to regulate internal or
foreign trade in granite after it had been quarried. Section 15 also
did not empower the State Government to frame rules to enable a
State Government company or corporation to fix a minimum price
for granite.
… …
24. There is no power conferred upon the State Government
under the said Act to exercise control over minor minerals after
they have been excavated. The power of the State Government,
as the subordinate rule-making authority, is restricted in the
manner set out in Section 15. The power to control the sale and
the sale price of a minor mineral is not covered by the terms of
clause (o) of sub-section (1-A) of Section 15. This clause can relate
only to the regulation of the grant of quarry and mining leases
and other mineral concessions and it does not confer the power to
regulate the sale of already mined minerals.
___________
Page 22 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
25. In our view, therefore, the High Court was clearly right in
striking down Rules 8-D and 19-B as being beyond the purview of
the rule-making power of the State Government. These rules
having been struck down. The High Court was also right in striking
down Government Order No. 214 to the extent that it prescribed
these rules and Government Order No. 216 made in pursuance of
these rules”.
16. Next the impugned Rule is challenged as unconstitutional, on
the ground that it suffers from vice of Part XIII of the Constitution,
particularly Article 301, 301 and 304(b) in imposing a temporary ban
on transporting mineral inter-State. By the impugned rule, the State
had authorised the Director of Geology and Mining to impose a
temporary ban on transporting minerals outside the State. Learned
Advocate General placed heavy reliance on the decisions of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Hind Stone (supra) and K.Ramanathan
(supra) to contend that once a rule is framed, it becomes part of the
parent enactment itself and, therefore, the impugned rule is protected
under Articles 301 to 304 of the Constitution of India.
17. At this juncture it is opposite to refer to Part XIII of the
___________
Page 23 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
Constitution of India, which deal with trade, commerce and intercourse
within the territory of India. Articles 301, 302 and 304 are extracted
hereunder for easy reference:
“301. Freedom of trade, commerce and intercourse :
Subject to the other provisions of this Part, trade, commerce and
intercourse throughout the territory of India shall be free.
302. Power of Parliament to impose restrictions on trade,
commerce and intercourse :
Parliament may by law impose such restrictions on the
freedom of trade, commerce or intercourse between one State
and another or within any part of the territory of India as may be
required in the public interest.
304. Restrictions on trade, commerce and intercourse
among States :
(1) Notwithstanding anything in article 301 or article 303,
the Legislature of a State may by law -
(a) impose on goods imported from other States 1 [or the
Union territories] any tax to which similar goods manufactured or
produced in that State are subject, so, however, as not to
___________
Page 24 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
discriminate between goods so imported and goods so
manufactured or produced; and
(b) impose such reasonable restrictions on the freedom of
trade, commerce or intercourse with or within that State as may
be required in the public interest:
Provided that no Bill or amendment for the purposes of
clause (b) shall be introduced or moved in the Legislature of a
State without the previous sanction of the President.”
18. Part XIII of the Constitution of India ensures free trade within
the States for the balanced development of the country. Article 301
allows free trade and commerce throughout the territory of India.
Article 302 allows Parliament to impose such restrictions on the
freedom of trade between the States, as may be required in the public
interest. Article 304(b) allows the Legislature of the State to bring in a
law to impose such reasonable restrictions on the free movement of
trade in the public interest beyond the State, subject to the proviso
that no bill or amendment under Article 304(b) shall be introduced in
the Legislature without the previous sanction of the President.
19. The impugned Rule 3-A allows the Director of Geology and
___________
Page 25 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
Mining to regulate transportation by imposing a temporary ban on
transporting rough stone and aggregates to other States. Rule 3-A is
directly in contravention of Part XIII of the Constitution of India and
suffers from the vice of violating Articles 301, 302, and 304(b), as no
bill imposing a ban inter-State or beyond the State could even be
introduced without the prior sanction of the President.
20. The issue with respect to the legislative competence of the
State in imposing a ban inter-State for the mined mineral by framing
rules, tracing powers to Section 23-C of the MMDR Act, is no longer res
integra and the issue has been settled by the decision of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Kalathiya (supra) . The following issues were framed
therein by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, which read as under:
“34. From the subject-matter of these appeals as well as
arguments noted above, it clearly follows that the main issues
that arise for consideration are as under:
34.1. Whether the impugned Rules framed by the State of
Gujarat as a delegate of Parliament are beyond the powers
granted to it under the MMDR Act? In other words, whether the
impugned rules are ultra vires Sections 15, 15-A and 23-C of the
___________
Page 26 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
MMDR Act?
34.2. Whether the impugned Rules are violative of Part XIII
of the Constitution of India?”
21. The Hon'ble Supreme Court considered the decisions in
8
Kavery Chetty (supra) and K.T. Varghese v. State of Kerala , wherein it
was held that the rule-making power of the State does not extend to
exercising control over minor minerals after they have been extracted.
The Supreme Court distinguished the decisions in Amritlal Nathubhai
9
Shah v. Union of India and Hind Stone (supra) on the ground that
those cases concerned measures bearing a direct nexus with the grant
or refusal of a lease, rather than the sale of already excavated minerals
belonging to the lessee.
22. The Court further held that a prohibition on the transport or
sale of lawfully mined minerals outside the State bears no rational
nexus with the object of the MMDR Act. It further held that Section
23-C deals exclusively with the prevention of illegal mining,
transportation, storage and does not empower the State to make rules
8
(2008) 3 SCC 735
9
(1976) 4 SCC 108
___________
Page 27 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
regulating the transport of lawfully excavated minerals. Accordingly,
the Court declared the impugned rules imposing an inter-State transit
ban to be unconstitutional. The relevant portion of the decision in
Kalathiya ( supra ) is extracted hereunder:
“39. In Amritlal Nathubhai Shah [Amritlal Nathubhai Shah v.
Union of India, (1976) 4 SCC 108], D.K. Trivedi & Sons [D.K. Trivedi
& Sons v. State of Gujarat, 1986 Supp SCC 20] and Hind Stone
[State of T.N. v. Hind Stone, (1981) 2 SCC 205], the measures in
question had a direct nexus with the grant or the refusal to grant
a lease. In the instant appeals, which concern the sale of already
excavated minerals that belong to the lessee, a prohibition by the
State Government on sale thereof outside the State is not
permissible under the MMDR Act. In Hind Stone [State of T.N. v.
Hind Stone, (1981) 2 SCC 205], this Court succinctly stated the
scope and ambit of the MMDR Act, highlighting that the Act is
aimed at the “conservation and the prudent and discriminating
exploitation of minerals”. The following passage from the said
judgment shows that as a method of regulation, prohibition is
clearly permissible, provided, however, that it has a direct nexus
with the conservation, exploitation and excavation of minerals:
(Hind Stone case [State of T.N. v. Hind Stone, (1981) 2 SCC 205] ,
___________
Page 28 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
SCC p. 217, para 10)
“10. … The statute with which we are concerned, the
Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, is
aimed, as we have already said more than once, at the
conservation and the prudent and discriminating exploitation
of minerals. Surely, in the case of a scarce mineral, to permit
exploitation by the State or its agency and to prohibit
exploitation by private agencies is the most effective method
of conservation and prudent exploitation. If you want to
conserve for the future, you must prohibit in the present. We
have no doubt that the prohibiting of the leases in certain
cases is part of the regulation contemplated by Section 15 of
the Act.”
40. On the other hand, the prohibition on the transport or
sale of the already mined minerals outside the State has no direct
nexus with the object and purpose of the MMDR Act which is
concerned with conservation and prudent exploitation of minerals.
41. Insofar as Section 23-C of the MMDR Act is concerned, it
was inserted by the 1999 Amendment Act with the objective to
prevent illegal mining. That is clearly spelled out in the Statement
of Objects and Reasons. We may reproduce a portion thereof
again:
“(iii) A new provision is proposed to be inserted in the
Act prohibiting transportation or storage or anything causing
transportation or storage of any mineral except under the
due provisions of the Act, with a view to preventing illegal
___________
Page 29 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
mining. Further, the Act is proposed to be amended to cover
the breach of the provisions of the proposed new provision of
the Act to be punishable. It is also proposed to insert a new
provision to provide for anything seized under the Act as
liable for confiscation under court orders. A new section is
proposed to be inserted to empower the State Governments
to make rules for preventing illegal mining, transportation
and storage of minerals and for purposes connected
therewith.”
(emphasis supplied)
42. It is in this context the words “transportation” and
“storage” in Section 23-C are to be interpreted. Here the two
words are used in the context of “illegal mining”. It is clear that it
is the transportation and storage of illegal mining and not the
mining of minor minerals like sand which is legal and backed by
duly granted licence, which can be regulated under this provision.
Therefore, no power flows from this provision to make rule for
regulating transportation of the legally excavated minerals.“
23. The Hon'ble Supreme Court further by considering as to
whether the rule imposing a ban inter-State is violative under Article
301 of the Constitution of India, held that once the State permits
mineral to be excavated, neither can it legally restrict its movement
within the territory of India nor it is constitutionally permissible. The
relevant portion is extracted hereunder:
___________
Page 30 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
“43. As far as Issue (b) above is concerned, we are also of
the considered opinion that the impugned Rules violate Part XIII of
the Constitution as the effect thereof is to fetter the freedom of
trade, commerce and intercourse under Article 301 of the
Constitution. Under this Article, the expression “freedom” must be
read with the expression “throughout the territory of India”. Under
Article 302, Parliament may impose restrictions on the freedom of
trade, commerce or intercourse between one State and another
as may be required in the public interest. The expression “public
interest” may include a regional interest as well. However, Article
302 is qualified by Article 303 which prohibits Parliament and the
State Legislatures from making any law that gives preference to
one State over another or discriminates between one State and
another. Situations of scarcity are to be dealt with by Parliament
under Article 302(2). The power of the State Legislature to impose
reasonable restrictions on the freedom of trade, commerce or
intercourse, as may be required in the public interest, requires
such a Bill or amendment to be moved in the State Legislature
only after receiving previous sanction from the President. The
President, being the head of the State and the guardian of the
___________
Page 31 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
federation, must be satisfied that such a law is indeed required
and, thus, acts as a check on the promotion of provincial interests
over national interest. Going by the aforesaid scheme of this
Chapter, it becomes apparent that when there are such
restrictions on a State Legislature, then the State Government
could not have imposed such a prohibition under a statute whose
object is to regulate mines and mineral development, and not
trade and commerce per se.
44. That apart, we find force in the submission of the
learned Additional Solicitor General that Part XIII of the
Constitution is a code on checks and balances on the legislative
power intended to achieve the objective of economic integration
of the country. This was emphasised in Video Electronics (P) Ltd. v.
State of Punjab [Video Electronics (P) Ltd. v. State of Punjab,
(1990) 3 SCC 87 : 1990 SCC (Tax) 327] wherein this Court held:
(SCC p. 104, para 20)
“20. … In our opinion, Part XIII of the Constitution
cannot be read in isolation. It is part and parcel of a single
constitutional instrument envisaging a federal scheme and
containing general scheme conferring legislative powers in
respect of the matters relating to List II of the Seventh
Schedule on the States. It also confers plenary powers on
States to raise revenue for its purposes and does not require
___________
Page 32 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
that every legislation of the State must obtain assent of the
President. The Constitution of India is an organic document. It
must be so construed that it lives and adapts itself to the
exigencies of the situation, in a growing and evolving society,
economically, politically and socially. The meaning of the
expressions used there must, therefore, be so interpreted
that it attempts to solve the present problem of distribution
of power and rights of the different States in the Union of
India, and anticipate the future contingencies that might
arise in a developing organism. The Constitution must be
able to comprehend the present at the relevant time and
anticipate the future which is natural and necessary corollary
for a growing and living organism. That must be part of the
constitutional adjudication. Hence, the economic
development of States to bring these into equality with all
other States and thereby develop the economic unity of India
is one of the major commitments or goals of the
constitutional aspirations of this land. For working of an
orderly society economic equality of all the States is as much
vital as economic unity.”
Freedom of movement of goods, services and the creation of a
common market must be understood contextually and as
necessary for creating an economic union.
45. It is also rightly contended by all the respondents that
balanced development of the country is an equally vital facet of
economic integration. No doubt, Part XIII permits some forms of
differentiation, for example, to encourage a backward region or to
create a level playing field for parts of the country that may not
___________
Page 33 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
have reached the desired level of development. In this context,
Part XIII envisions a two-fold object:
(i) Facilitation of a common market through ease of
trade, commerce and intercourse by erasing barriers; and
(ii) Regulations (or restrictions) which may have the
effect of differentiating between States or regions which may
be necessary not only in emergent circumstances of scarcity,
etc. or but even for development of economically backward
regions or otherwise justified in the public interest.
46. That Part XIII is not about “freedom” alone but is a code
of checks and balances, intended at achieving economic unity and
parity. Such a desired objective for economic integration through
checks and balances was also articulated in Video Electronics (P)
Ltd. [Video Electronics (P) Ltd. v. State of Punjab, (1990) 3 SCC
87 : 1990 SCC (Tax) 327] : (SCC p. 113, para 36)
“36. … Economic unity is a desired goal, economic
equilibrium and prosperity is also the goal. Development on
parity is one of the commitments of the Constitution.
Directive principles enshrined in Articles 38 and 39 must be
harmonised with economic unity as well as economic
development of developed and underdeveloped areas. In that
light on Article 14 of the Constitution, it is necessary that the
prohibitions in Article 301 and the scope of Articles 304(a)
___________
Page 34 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
and (b) should be understood and construed. The
Constitution is a living organism and the latent meaning of
the expressions used can be given effect to only if a
particular situation arises. It is not that with changing times
the meaning changes but changing times illustrate and
illuminate the meaning of the expressions used. The
connotation of the expressions used takes its shape and
colour in evolving dynamic situations. A backward State or a
disturbed State cannot with parity engage in competition with
advanced or developed States. Even within a State, there are
often backward areas which can be developed only if some
special incentives are granted. If the incentives in the form of
subsidies or grant are given to any part of (sic or) units of a
State so that it may come out of its limping or infancy to
compete as equals with others, that, in our opinion, does not
and cannot contravene the spirit and the letter of Part XIII of
the Constitution. However, this is permissible only if there is a
valid reason, that is to say, if there are justifiable and rational
reasons for differentiation. If there is none, it will amount to
hostile discrimination.”
47. In order to justify any “preference” or “discrimination”
under Article 303, a scarcity of goods would have to be made out.
It is a matter of record that the Study Group's report on which
reliance is placed by the appellant, focuses on the need to restrict
the export of sand outside India and not within India. In any case,
nothing prevents the appellant from restricting the quantum of
sand being excavated. However, once the appellant State permits
sand to be excavated, neither can it legally restrict its movement
___________
Page 35 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
within the territory of India nor is the same constitutionally
permissible. Likewise, there is no restriction on the State
importing sand from other States. If it is the case that the demand
of any State is not being met, it may purchase sand from other
States. In any event, the market will dictate trade in sand
inasmuch as it may make no business sense for mining company
to transport and sell its sand in a faraway destination after
incurring large costs on transportation.”
24. In the decisions of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Novel
Granites (supra) and this Court in D. Sivakumar (supra) , the Courts
relied on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Hind Stone
(supra) to hold that if minerals were allowed to be transported outside
the State, it would only increase illegal exploitation. Accordingly, they
held that the State acted within its authority to impose a transit ban
under its regulatory powers, thereby validating the State's competence
to frame rules concerning the transportation of excavated minor
minerals. However the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kalathiya (supra)
explicitly overruled the decisions in Novel Granites (supra) and
D. Sivakumar (supra) .
___________
Page 36 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
25. In the instant case, the impugned rule authorizing a
temporary restriction is stated to be framed in response to
representations made by the contractors' association regarding
scarcity of rough stones, after evaluating domestic needs and the
structural impact on local infrastructure. On this basis, the
consequential three-month temporary ban is said to have been issued
by the authority solely in the public interest.
26. As held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kalathiya (supra) ,
once the State has permitted mining and allowed the excavation of
minerals, imposing a temporary ban on their transport to other States
has no rationale or reasonable nexus with the object that is sought to
be achieved. When mining and excavation are carried out on the basis
of a valid mining lease and transportation complies with all statutory
requirements, the ownership of the mineral vests entirely with the
lessee.
27. Therefore, introduction of Rule 3-A to impose a temporary
ban on the transport of excavated minerals beyond the State by
tracing powers to Section 23-C of the MMDR Act is completely
misplaced. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has explicitly held that Section
___________
Page 37 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
23-C deals exclusively with illegal mining and cannot be applied to
minerals being transported pursuant to a valid lease and upon the
payment of seigniorage. Therefore, the impugned rule allowing to
impose temporary ban to transport rough stone and aggregates
beyond the State suffers the vice of Part XIII of the Constitution of India
and also lacks legislative competence and is ultra vires Sections 15
and 23-C of the MMDR Act.
28. Further, the issue regarding the transport of rough stone and
aggregates was considered by the Madurai Bench of this Court in the
case of C. Stephen v. State of Tamil Nadu and Others (W.P.(MD) Nos.
5081 of 2019 and 17092 of 2020, decided on 11.02.2021) , where the
Division Bench, after elaborately considering the decision in Kalathiya
(supra) , held that the State has no power to regulate or prevent the
transport of minerals outside the State. Therefore, if at all the State
intends to regulate, it can only do so while granting the mining lease
and even if some regulation is sought to be introduced in the public
interest, it can only be by measures like prescribing maximum load,
speed, and reasonable restrictions for public safety or invoke
provisions under Sec.4-A of the MMDR Act, rather than directly
interfering with sales or banning transport beyond the State.
___________
Page 38 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
29. Any measure of the State to ban transport of mineral to other
States or restrict sales except as provided under Part XIII of the
Constitution of India, is unconstitutional and would also traverse
beyond the legislative competence. The delegated legislation must
restrict itself and strictly confine to the powers conferred upon it and
cannot exceed them. Under these circumstances, the impugned Rule 3-
A of the Tamil Nadu Prevention of Illegal Mining, Transportation and
Storage of Minerals and Mineral Dealers' Rules, 2011, is declared
unconstitutional and ultra vires the parent Act. Consequently, the
impugned proceedings dated 27.07.2026 of the Director of Geology
and Mining imposing a temporary ban of three months based on Rule
3-A is quashed.
30. Accordingly, these writ petitions are allowed. There shall be
no order as to costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petitions
are closed.
(SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI, CJ) (G.ARUL MURUGAN,J)
17.11.2026
___________
Page 39 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
Index : Yes
Neutral Citation : Yes
gya
To
1.The Principal Secretary to the Government
State of Tamil Nadu
Natural Resources Department, (MMD.1)
Fort St. George, Chennai 600 009.
2.The Director
Department of Geology and Mining
Guindy, Chennai 600 032.
3.Deputy Director
Department of Geology and Mining
Krishnagiri, Tamil Nadu.
4.The District Collector
Hosur District, Tamil Nadu.
___________
Page 40 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )

2026:MHC:4591
W.P.No.31800 of 2026 etc. batch
THE HON'BLE CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
G.ARUL MURUGAN , J.
gya
Pre-Delivery Common Order in
W.P.Nos.31800 of 2026 etc. batch

.11.2026 17
___________
Page 41 of 41
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 01:34:51 pm )