SMT. TIPPAVVA W/O SIDDAPPA ADAPATTI vs SMT. SHIDDAVVA W/O DYAMAPPA KAMBALI

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD

TH
DATED THIS THE 18 DAY OF NOVERMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI


REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 100007 OF 2024 (FDP)

BETWEEN:

1. SMT. TIPPAVVA
W/O. SIDDAPPA ADAPATTI,
AGE: 60 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: NARASAPUR, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN-587201.

2. SMT. GANGAVVA
D/O. SIDDAPPA YANKANCHI,
AGE: 55 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587201.

3. PANDAPPA
S/O. GUNDAPPA BELLIKUPPI,
AGE: 60 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: YANKANCHI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587 201.

4. SIDDAPPA
S/O. BHIMAPPA ASAPPANAVAR,
AGE: 40 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587 201.

5. SMT. MALLAVVA
W/O. YALLAPPAGOUDA ASAPPANAVAR,
AGE: 50 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587201.













Digitally
signed by
BHARATHI
H M
Date:
2026.11.19
16:03:21
+0530
BHARATHI
H M

- 2 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024


6. SMT. RUKMAVVA
W/O. HANAMAPPA YANKANCHI,
AGE: 50 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: YANKANCHI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587201.

…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI S.C. HIREMATH, ADVOCATE)


AND:

1. SMT. SHIDDAVVA
W/O. DYAMAPPA KAMBALI,
AGE: 57 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O: WADDATTI, TQ: BADAMI
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN – 587 201.
2. SMT. SIDDAVVA
W/O. VITTAL MUSTIGERI,
AGE: 42 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587201.
3. YALLAPPA
S/O. CHANDAPPA YANKANCHI,
AGE: 40 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: HULASAGERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587201.

4. HANAMANT
S/O. CHANDAPPA YANKANCHI,
AGE: 38 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: HULASAGERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587 201.

5. DYAMAWWA
W/O. SHIDDAPPA MUSTIGERI,
AGE: 67 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,

- 3 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587201.

6. YAMANAVVA
W/O. HOLIYAPPA MUSTIGERI,
AGE: 49 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587201.

7. GANGAPPA
S/O. SHIDDAPPA MUSTIGERI,
AGE: 37 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587201.

8. VITTAPPA
S/O. SIDDAPPA MUSTIGERI,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587 201.

9. BASAPPA
S/O. SHIDDAPPA MUSTIGERI,
AGE: 32 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587 201.

10. HANAMAWWA
W/O. SHIDDAPPA MUSTIGERI,
AGE: 50 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587 201.

11. SHIDDAWWA
W/O. HANAMAPPA HANAMANERI,
AGE: 37 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587 201.

12. SHIDDALINGAWWA
W/O. MUTTAPPA HANAMANERI,
AGE: 32 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,

- 4 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587 201.

13. SHIDDAPPA
S/O. HOLIYAPPA MUSTIGERI,
AGE: 42 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587 201.

14. DYAMAPPA
S/O. BUTTAPPA @ BHUTAPPA MUSTIGERI,
AGE: 70 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: NEERALAKERI, TAL: BADAMI,
DIST: BAGALKOT, PIN: 587 201.

…RESPONDENT
(BY SMT. GAYATRI S.R., ADVOCATE FOR R1;
V/O DATED 15.02.2024 SERVICE OF NOTICE TO
R2 TO R14 IS DISPENSED WITH;
R3, R4, R13 & R14 ARE SERVED;
V/O DATED 12.02.2026 SERVICE OF NOTICE TO
R2, R5 TO R12 ARE HELD SUFFICIENT)

THIS RSA IS FILED U/SEC. 100 OF CPC., PRAYING TO
SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 15.12.2023 IN
R.A.NO.9/2021, ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE
AND JMFC., BADAMI DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND
CONFIRMING THE ORDER AND FINAL DECREE DATED
26.02.2021 IN FDP NO.05/2011 ON THE FILE OF PRL. CIVIL
JUDGE, AND JMFC., BADAMI AND DISMISS THE SUIT IN THAT
BEHALF.

THIS APPEAL COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, HAVING
BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT ON 20.08.2026,
THIS DAY, THE COURT PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI

- 5 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

CAV JUDGMENT

This regular second appeal is filed praying to set-aside
the judgment and decree dated 15.12.2023 passed in R.A.
No.9/2021 on the file of learned Senior Civil Judge and JMFC,
Badami, dismissing the appeal and confirming the Order dated
26.02.2021 passed in FDP No.5/2011 on the file of learned
Principal Civil Judge and JMFC, Badami.

2. Brief facts leading to this second appeal are as
under:

(i) The plaintiffs namely Smt. Yallavva and her
daughter Shiddavva instituted the suit in O.S. No.130/1995 for
the relief of partition and separate possession claiming their
half share in properties bearing R.S. No.63 measuring 11.35
acres, R.S. No.75/2 measuring 5.12 acres and the house
property bearing VPC Nos.239A and 239B situated at
Neeralakeri Village of Badami Taluk. Smt. Yallavva, Plaintiff
No.1, died during the pendency of the said suit. Hence, Smt.
Shiddawwa, Plantiff No.2, proceeded with the suit.

(ii) The plaintiffs filed the suit against Sri Buttappa
(Defendant No.1), his wife Smt. Manavva (Defendant No.4) and
his children namely Dyamappa (Defendant No.2) and

- 6 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

Rukmavva (Defendant No.3). Defendant No.1 died during the
pendency of the suit and the suit proceeded against the
remaining defendants.

(iii) After contest, the suit came to be decreed on
19.07.2005 holding that Plaintiff No.2 is entitled to half share in
the suit properties. The defendants, i.e., Defendant Nos.2 to 4,
preferred the appeal in RA No.8/2006 challenging the judgment
and decree of the trial court. The first appellate court dismissed
the said appeal vide its judgment dated 22.10.2009. The
appeal filed by Defendant Nos.2 and 3 in RSA No.5124/2010
against the judgment and decree in R.A. No.8/2006 was
dismissed on 05.06.2014 at the admission stage itself.

(iv) Afterwards, Plaintiff No.2 filed the petition in FDP
No.5/2011 praying to draw a final decree in terms of the
preliminary decree in OS No.130/1995. In the proceeding,
Plaintiff No.2 brought the legal representatives of deceased
Defendant Nos.3 and 4 on record. On service of the notice, all
the respondents [except Respondent No. 2(b)] entered
appearance before the trial court through their Counsel.
Further, Respondent Nos.5 to 11 filed a memo before the trial
court stating that they have no objection to allot shares to the

- 7 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

parties to the proceeding as per the preliminary decree.
Defendant No.2 contested the petition by filing his objection.

(v) The trial court appointed the court commissioners
to obtain reports regarding feasibility of the division of the
properties in terms of the preliminary decree and held enquiry
in the matter. Then, the trial court heard the arguments
canvassed on both sides and disposed of the petition on merits
of the case vide its Order dated 26.02.2020. The trial court
accepted the reports of the court commissioners and ordered to
draw final decree accordingly.

(vi) Being aggrieved by the said order, Defendant No.2
preferred the appeal in RA No.9/2021. The first appellate court,
after reweighing the materials on record concurred with the
findings recorded by the trial court and its conclusion. In view
of the same, the first appellate court dismissed the appeal on
15.12.2023.

(vii) Feeling aggrieved, Defendant No.2 filed RSA
No.100001/2024 praying to set aside the judgment and decree
dated 15.12.2023 passed in RA No.9/2021. The said appeal
came to be dismissed on 8.1.2024 with an observation that the
appeal lacks merit.

- 8 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024


(viii) The appellants herein were not parties in any of the
earlier proceedings referred herein above. During pendency of
RA No.9/2021, an application i.e., IA No.V came to be filed
praying to implead the appellants as the defendants in the
case. The first appellate court rejected the said application vide
its Order dated 18.11.2023.

(ix) The appellants filed a writ petition in WP
No.107013/2023 challenging the rejection of the application.
During pendency of the said writ petition, the appellants
preferred this regular second appeal praying to set aside the
judgment dated 15.12.2023 passed in RA No.9/2021.

3. This Court admitted the regular second appeal on
22.02.2024 to consider the following substantial question of
law:
“Whether the appellants being the grand children
were entitled to a share in the suit properties in
view of the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in
the case of Vineeta Sharma V. Rakesh Sharma and
Others (2020) 9 SCC 1? If yes, whether the
judgment/s and decree/s passed in FDP No.5/2011
and RA No.9/2021 require reconsideration?”


4. Undisputedly, one Holiyappa was the propositus of
the family. He had five children namely Butappa (Defendant
No.1), Ramappa, Lakshamavva, Dodda Bhimavva and Sanna

- 9 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

Bhimavva. The plaintiffs are the wife and daughter of Ramappa.
They maintained the suit in O.S. No.130/1995 for partition and
separate possession of their half share in the suit properties
without joining the daughters of Holiyappa, i.e., the sisters of
Butappa and Ramappa. It was the contention of the plaintiffs
that those three daughters of Holiyappa have no manner of
right in the suit properties as Holiyappa died in the year 1948
itself, and that even those daughters expired long ago. The
defendants contested the suit even on the ground that it is bad
for non-joinder of the daughters as parties to the suit. The trial
court negatived such a contention, which was affirmed by the
appellate courts in RA No.8/2006 and RSA No.5124/2010.
Thereafter, Plaintiff No.2 initiated the final decree proceeding in
FDP No.5/2011.

5. Sri S. C. Hiremath, learned Counsel for the
Appellants heavily relied on the decision in Vineeta Sharma
Vs Rakesh Sharma and Others , reported in AIR 2020 SC
3717 , and vehemently submitted that the first appellate court
ought to have allowed the application for the impleadment of
the appellants as parties to the suit, as the daughters born
prior to passing of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 have right to
share in the ancestral properties when there was no division in

- 10 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

the family. Hence, he strenuously contended that there is a
need to issue a direction to implead the appellants as parties in
the final decree proceeding or to remand the case for the
determination of the rights of the appellants.

6. Per contra, Ms. Gayathri S. R., learned Counsel for
Petitioner vigorously submitted that the first appellate court
dismissed the application in question for not producing
documents to show that the appellants are the legal
representatives of the daughters of Sri Holiyappa and that the
said aspect cannot be gone into in this regular second appeal.
She further submitted that the appellants have filed this appeal
when the executing court issued delivery warrant in pursuance
of the final decree and there is no bonafide in maintaining the
appeal.

7. As pointed out earlier, during pendency of RA
No.9/2021, IA No.V was filed by showing Defendant No.2 as
the applicant, praying to implead the appellants herein as the
defendants in the case. The affidavit accompanying the
application shows that it was prepared in the name of
“Mallappa S/o Siddappa Yankanchi” but it was sworn to by
“Rukmavva W/o Hanamappa”. The first appellate court
considered the said application on its merits and rejected the

- 11 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

application vide its Order dated 18.11.2023 with the following
observation:
“16. On careful scrutiny of the application and
annexed affidavit in the cause title of the application
the applicant name shown as Dyamappa S/o Butappa
Mustageri who is the appellant in this case. But
affidavit annexed to the application is sworn by one
Rukmavva W/o Hanamappa Yankanchi. This affidavit
prepared in the name of Mallappa S/o Siddappa
Yankanchi, while mentioning the name of Mallappa in
the bracket it is mentioned the deponent name as
Mallappa (myself). So, it is very clear that, this
application prepared on the strength of the appellant
and the affidavit of Mallappa S/o Siddappa Yankanchi,
but later the name of Mallapa Yankanchi strikeout by
writing the name of Rukmavva W/o Hanamappa. In
the affidavit, it is clearly mentioned that, in the
written statement the defendant has already taken
the defence that the daughters are not made as
parties and hence the suit is bad for non joinder of
necessary parties. This issue has been answered in
Negative. Against the judgment and decree the
appellant herein has preferred appeal in RA
No.8/2006 the same was also dismissed and even the
RSA No.5124/2010 is also dismissed. As on the date
of disposal of RA No.8/2006 and RSA No.5124/2010
the amendment of section 6 of Hindu Succession Act
was taken place. In spite of it the point was non
joinder of necessary parties was determined in the
appeal also and confirmed the judgment of the trial
court. If really the intention of the applicants to
implead them as necessary parties, there was no
difficulty for them to implead in the regular appeal
and also in RSA. The appellant herein is the master
mind in filing this application, he knows the things but
he kept quite for a long time. Since the suit is for
partition and separate possession, all the plaintiffs
are the defendants and the defendants are also the
plaintiffs, under such circumstances, the defendant
who is appellant herein could have filed the necessary
application in the original suit or in the appeal. No
doubt, as per the amendment provisions of section 6

- 12 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

of Hindu Succession Act and as per the land mark
decision of Hon’ble Apex Court i.e., Vineetha Sharma
V/s Rakesh Sharma it is held that the daughters can
be claimed their share even in the appeal also. But in
this case, neither the appellant nor the applicants
have produced any documents to show that the
proposed defendants are the legal heirs of the
daughters of deceased Holiyappa S/o Ramappa
Mustigeri, as because the trial court in the original
suit, this court in the RA No.8/2006 and the Hon’ble
High Court of Karnataka in RSA No.5124/2010 has
decided that the suit is not bad for non joinder of
necessary parties. Under such circumstances, the
proposed defendants must produced cogent
documents like G-tree or any other documents to
show their relationship as contended in the
application but no such documents is produced.”


8. The appellants herein filed a writ petition in WP
No.107013/2023 challenging the rejection of the impleading
application. During pendency of the said writ petition,
Defendant No.2 filed RSA No.100001/2024 praying to set aside
the judgment and decree dated 15.12.2023 passed in RA
No.9/2021. In the said appeal Defendant No.2 raised a
contention that in final decree proceeding the court ought to
have taken into consideration of the judgment of the Hon’ble
Apex Court in Vineeta Sharma Vs Rakesh Sharma and
others reported in (2020) 9 SCC 1 and must have allotted
share to the daughters of the propositus also. This Court, while
considering the said contention, held as under:

- 13 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

“6. It is undisputed that the propositus died in
the year 1948 leaving behind the plaintiff and the
defendants as his surviving coparceners. It is also
not in dispute that there was no alienation or
partition of the suit properties until 20.12.2004. It
is also not in dispute that all the properties are
ancestral properties in the hands of the plaintiffs
and the defendants. The suit in O.S. No. 130/1995
and the R.S.A. No. 5124/2010 were disposed off
declaring the shares to which the plaintiff was
entitled to as on that date. Now that the Apex
Vineeta Sharma
Court has held in the case of
(supra), that the daughters are also entitled for an
equal share in the suit properties, it cannot be said
that they are not entitled for a share in the suit
properties and the final decree court must have
considered the same if a request was made by the
daughters. In the present appeal, the appellant is
only the defendant no.1 and not the daughters,
who were the other defendants.

7. In that view of the matter, the appellant
cannot raise any ground to seek redistribution of
the shares to which the plaintiff and defendant no.1
are entitled to, more particularly when the appeal
filed by him in R.S.A. No. 5124/2010 was disposed
of upholding the preliminary decree.”

Accordingly, this Court proceeded to hold that the appeal filed
by Defendant No.2 lacks merit and dismissed the appeal vide
its judgment dated 8.01.2024. Subsequently, i.e., on
16.01.2024 the appellants herein filed the present appeal.

9. It is true that in Vineeta Sharma’s case referred
supra Hon’ble Apex Court has held that the provisions
contained in substituted Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act,
1956 confer status of coparcener on the daughter born before

- 14 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

or after amendment in the same manner as son with same
rights and liabilities. In the said decision, Hon’ble Apex Court
has held the said provisions of the substituted Section 6
required to be given full effect and clarified that
notwithstanding of passing a preliminary decree, the daughters
are to be given share in coparcenary equal to that a son in
pending proceeding for final decree or in an appeal.

10. The factual aspects of the case indicate that the
law laid down in Vineeta Sharma’s case referred supra cannot
be applied straight away. It is because the case papers reveal
that the suit in OS No.130/1995 came to be filed for the relief
of partition and separate possession on the ground the suit
properties originally belong to Sri Holiyappa, who died on
05.04.1948 and thereafter Defendant No.1 namely Butappa
and his brother Ramappa continued in joint possession and
enjoyment of the suit properties. Though the defendants
contested the suit, they did not dispute the above contention of
the plaintiffs. On the other hand, they claimed that Ramappa
had executed a registered Will bequeathing the suit properties
in favour of Defendant No.2 and thereby, after the death of
Ramappa Defendant No.2 became the absolute owner of the
suit property. Based on the pleadings of the parties, the courts

- 15 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

decided the contentions of the parties on the premise that the
schedule properties originally belonged to Sri Holiyappa and
that after his death Defendant No.1 and Ramappa succeeded to
suit properties. It is to be noted that even in the affidavit
accompanying IA No.V filed in RA No.9/2021 it is stated Sri
Holiyappa was the original owner of the property involved in
the case. Thus, there is no sufficient material on record to
show that the suit properties were the coparcenary properties
as claimed by the appellants.

11. Further, admittedly the daughters of Holiyappa
were not the parties to the suit. Though the defendants
disputed maintainability of the suit on the ground of non-
joinder of necessary parties, the courts did not accept the said
contention. Added to it, neither the defendants nor the legal
representatives of the daughters maintained any application
seeking permission to bring those daughters or their legal
representatives on record, though the proceeding was pending
between 27.11.1995 and 04.10.2023. Ultimately, the
impleading application, i.e., IA No.V was filed in RA No.9/2021
which was filed challenging drawing up of final decree. The
contents of IA No.V and the affidavit accompanying the
application unerringly support the observation of the first

- 16 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

appellate court that Defendant No.2 was the master mind in
filing such application and it was filed with sole intention of
prolonging the matter.

12. The contents of the affidavit accompanying IA No.V
go to show that the deponent has not whispered anything
about the relevant aspects required to decide the prayer for
impleadment of the appellants except claiming that the
daughters of Holiyappa are necessary parties to the suit and
that the appellants are the sharers. The affidavit does not
disclose the date on which the appellants succeeded to the suit
properties or the reason for which they could not approach the
court for legal remedy at the earliest point of time. In addition,
no document was produced before the first appellate court to
prime facie show that the appellants are the legal
representatives of the daughters of Holiyappa.

13. The first appellate court observed that though
Plaintiff No.2 got a decree for partition, Defendant No.2 did not
allow her to enjoy the fruits of the decree for almost 28 years
by initiating one or the other proceedings. At this stage, it is
relevant to note that though Defendant No.2 filed W.P.
No.107013/2023 challenging rejection of IA No.V, he got the
said writ petition dismissed on 04.03.2024 as infructuous.

- 17 -
RSA No. 100007 of 2024

Thus, the facts and circumstances of the case give an
impression that such an application was filed only with an
intention of depriving share to Plaintiff No.2 in the suit
properties than for asserting the rights of the appellants in
those suit properties, if any. For the foregoing reasons, it is
held that the first appellate court was justified in rejecting IA
No.V in the absence of necessary materials to support the claim
of the appellants. Hence, the substantial question of law framed
in the appeal is answered in the negative.

14. In the result, this Court proceeds to pass the
following:
ORDER
The regular second appeal is dismissed .
Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of, as they do
not survive for consideration.


SD/-
(B. MURALIDHARA PAI)
JUDGE


HMB/RH/ASN
CT-ASC