Mehar Das Another vs District Magistrate-Cum-Appellate Tribunal, Panipat Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CWP-27638-2026 and CWP-16699-2026 -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH

CWP-27638-2026
(1)
Reserved on: 03.11.2026
Date of decision: 17.11.2026
MEHAR DAS AND ANOTHER ...Petitioners
Versus
DISTRICT MAGISTRATE-CUM-APPELLATE TRIBUNAL UNDER THE
MAINTENANCE AND WELFARE OF PARENTS AND SENIOR
CITIZENS ACT, 2007, PANIPAT AND OTHERS
...Respondents
CWP-16699-2026
(2)
AJIT SINGH AND ANOTHER ...Petitioners
Versus
APPELLATE TRIBUNAL CUM DEPUTY COMMISSIONER PANIPAT,
DISTRICT PANIPAT AND OTHERS
...Respondents
1 The date when the judgment is reserved 03.11.2026
2 The date when the judgment is pronounced 17.11.2026
3 The date when the judgment is uploaded on the website 17.11.2026
4 Whether only operative part of the judgment is Full
pronounced or whether the full judgment is pronounced
5 The delay, if any, of the pronouncement of full judgment, N.A.
and reasons thereof.
CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE KIRTI SINGH
Argued by: Mr. Vaibhav Vats, Advocate
for the petitioners (in CWP-27638-2026)
Mr. Gaurav Grover, Advocate and
Ms. Charu Sharma, Advocate
for the petitioners (in CWP-16699-2026) and
for respondent Nos.5 and 6 (in CWP-27638-2026)
None for respondent No.7 (in CWP-27638-2026)
Ms. Saumya Ahluwalia, Sr. DAG Haryana
Mr. Vaibhav Vats, Advocate
for respondent Nos.3 and 4 (in CWP-16699-2026)
None for respondent No.5 (in CWP-16699-2026)
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment


CWP-27638-2026 and CWP-16699-2026 -2-
KIRTI SINGH, J.
1. Since both the above-mentioned writ petitions arise out of the
same proceedings initiated under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and
Senior Citizens Act, 2007 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act'), and involve a
challenge to the orders dated 20.03.2025 and 25.03.2026 passed by the
Maintenance Tribunal, Israna, and the Appellate Tribunal, Panipat,
respectively, the same are being taken up together and disposed of by this
common order.
2. In CWP-27638-2026, the petitioners, who are senior citizens,
seek appropriate directions for protection of their rights in respect of House
No.1090, Sector 8, HUDA, Panipat, including restoration of possession and
cancellation of the conveyance deed dated 12.06.2019, besides questioning the
manner in which their claim under the Act has been dealt with by the
authorities below. In the connected petition, CWP-16699-2026, Ajit Singh and
his wife, who are the son and daughter-in-law of the petitioners in the
connected writ petition, assail the very same orders, primarily on the ground
that the proceedings before the Maintenance Tribunal were not conducted by a
duly constituted Tribunal and that the directions issued therein are otherwise
unsustainable.
3. Briefly stated, as per the pleaded case, petitioner No.1, Mehar
Dass, aged about 73 years, and petitioner No.2, Soma Devi, aged about 69
years, are husband and wife. Petitioner No.1 retired from National Fertilizers
Limited in June, 2010. It is their case that the house in question was purchased
and constructed from the savings and retirement benefits of petitioner No.1,
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP-27638-2026 and CWP-16699-2026 -3-
though the conveyance deed bearing Vasika No.2822 dated 12.06.2019 came
to be executed in the names of their sons.
4. The petitioners allege that, despite having contributed towards the
acquisition and construction of the property, they were subsequently deprived
of their peaceful residence therein. It is pleaded that after the relationship
between the family members became strained, the petitioners were not
permitted to enter the house and were compelled to seek accommodation
elsewhere. They further allege that their belongings remained inside the
premises and that the respondents failed to discharge their obligations towards
them.
5. It is further their case that the transfer of the property in favour of
their sons was accompanied by an understanding that they would be looked
after and maintained. According to them, the failure of the transferees to
provide basic amenities and physical needs, coupled with their alleged
conduct towards the petitioners, attracts the provisions of Section 23 of the
Act.
6. In these circumstances, proceedings were instituted under the Act
seeking, inter alia, maintenance, protection of residence, cancellation of the
conveyance deed dated 12.06.2019 and restoration of possession of the
disputed house. The matter was taken up by the Maintenance Tribunal, Israna,
which passed an order dated 20.03.2025. The said order, while dealing with
the claim for maintenance and residence, did not return any specific and
reasoned finding on the substantive relief concerning the conveyance deed and
the consequential claim of the petitioners.
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP-27638-2026 and CWP-16699-2026 -4-
7. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order, an appeal was preferred under
Section 16 of the Act. The Appellate Tribunal, Panipat, vide order dated
25.03.2026, directed payment of maintenance at the rate of Rs.10,000/- per
month by each of the two sons and further directed that the petitioners would
be entitled to reside in the disputed house and would not be subjected to
harassment or eviction therefrom. However, the controversy concerning the
conveyance deed and the consequential reliefs sought by the petitioners
remained without a conclusive adjudication.
8. This led to the filing of the present writ petitions, one by the
senior citizens seeking effective adjudication and protection of their rights and
the other by their son and daughter-in-law challenging the legality of the
aforesaid orders.
9. Learned counsel for the petitioners in CWP-27638-2026 contends
that the authorities below have failed to address the real controversy raised
before them. It is submitted that the petitioners had approached the statutory
forum seeking not merely monthly maintenance but also relief in respect of
the property transferred in favour of their sons. The specific plea was that the
transfer was subject to an obligation to maintain and look after the transferors
and that, upon failure to discharge such obligation, the consequences
contemplated under Section 23 of the Act would follow. It is argued that the
authorities below have neither examined the circumstances in which the
conveyance deed came to be executed nor considered the material placed on
record in support of the petitioners' claim. The directions regarding
maintenance and residence, though beneficial in nature, have not resulted in
an effective resolution of their grievance. It is further submitted that the
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP-27638-2026 and CWP-16699-2026 -5-
petitioners continue to face difficulties in enjoying peaceful residence in the
disputed house. Learned counsel, therefore, seeks fresh adjudication of the
entire claim by the competent statutory authority, with appropriate interim
protection.
10. Per contra, learned counsel for respondents in the said petition
and the petitioners in CWP-16699-2026 submits that the impugned orders are
fundamentally defective. The principal objection is that the Maintenance
Tribunal, Israna, which passed the order dated 20.03.2025, was not constituted
in accordance with the Haryana Maintenance of Parents and Senior Citizens
Rules, 2009 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules’). Reference is made to Rule
3 thereof, which mandates constitution of a three-member Tribunal comprising
one official and two non-official members. It is contended that the order dated
20.03.2025 was passed by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate alone, without
participation of the two non-official members, and is, therefore, without
jurisdiction. It is further argued that the Appellate Tribunal failed to examine
this fundamental objection and proceeded to issue further directions without
addressing the defect in the original proceedings.
11. On merits, learned counsel submits that the disputed property was
acquired and constructed from the personal resources of the answering
respondents and that the petitioners have wrongly asserted that the same was
purchased from the retirement benefits of petitioner No.1. Reliance is placed
upon the mutual agreement dated 02.08.2017, bank statements, balance sheets
and other financial documents to contend that the petitioners have suppressed
material facts. It is also pointed out that the dispute concerning the property is
the subject matter of civil proceedings. It is accordingly urged that the writ
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP-27638-2026 and CWP-16699-2026 -6-
petition filed by the senior citizens deserves dismissal and the impugned
directions deserve to be set aside.
12. Learned State counsel has also been heard. He does not dispute
the lack of jurisdiction of the authority which passed the impugned order.
13. I have heard the Learned counsel for the parties and perused the
relevant material on record.
14. The controversy in the present petitions raises issues concerning
the constitution of the Maintenance Tribunal and the Appellate Tribunal under
the Rules, as also the adequacy of the adjudication of the substantive claims
raised by the original applicants under the Act. These issues go to the root of
the validity of the impugned proceedings and, therefore, warrant
consideration.
15. The first and foremost issue concerns the constitution of the
Maintenance Tribunal which passed the order dated 20.03.2025. Rule 3(1) of
the Rules’ specifically provides that each Maintenance Tribunal shall consist
of three members, one of whom shall be an official member, not below the
rank of Sub-Divisional Magistrate, who shall be its Chairperson, while the
other two shall be non-official members nominated and notified in accordance
with the Rules.
16. The statutory prescription is significant. The adjudicatory
authority contemplated under the Rules is the Maintenance Tribunal
constituted in the manner prescribed therein and not merely the officer
designated as its Chairperson. The presence of the Chairperson is undoubtedly
necessary, but the requirement of the two other members cannot be treated as
dispensable or reduced to a mere formality.
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP-27638-2026 and CWP-16699-2026 -7-
17. A perusal of the order dated 20.03.2025 reveals that the same
bears the signature of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Israna, alone. The order
does not disclose the participation of the two non-official members
constituting the Tribunal under Rule 3(1) of the Rules.
18. It is true that Rule 4(3) of the Rules contemplates that the
Chairperson may take a decision in an emergent situation when the Tribunal is
not sitting. However, such a decision is expressly made subject to ratification
by the Tribunal at its next sitting. The provision, therefore, constitutes a
limited exception and cannot be construed as conferring an unrestricted power
upon the Chairperson to routinely exercise the jurisdiction vested in the three-
member Tribunal.
19. In the present case, the order itself does not record that it was
passed in an emergent situation, nor does the material available on record
disclose any subsequent ratification by the duly constituted Tribunal. No
material has been pointed out to this Court to establish compliance with the
requirements of Rule 4(3) of the Rules. In these circumstances, the objection
regarding the constitution of the original Maintenance Tribunal cannot be
brushed aside as a mere technical irregularity. The proceedings were required
to be conducted in the manner prescribed by the statutory Rules. In the
absence of any material demonstrating compliance either with the prescribed
constitution of the Tribunal or with the limited exception contemplated under
Rule 4(3) of the Rules, the legality of the adjudication stands seriously
impaired. This infirmity was overlooked by the learned Appellate Tribunal
while passing the impugned order dated 25.03.2026, rendering the same as
unsustainable.
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP-27638-2026 and CWP-16699-2026 -8-
20. There is yet another aspect which warrants consideration. The
original proceedings were not confined merely to a claim for monthly
maintenance. The senior citizens had also raised a specific claim concerning
the transfer of the property, the circumstances in which the conveyance deed
dated 12.06.2019 came to be executed and the consequences flowing from the
alleged failure of the transferees to fulfill their obligations towards them.
21. Section 23(1) of the Act provides for a declaration of a transfer of
property as void where a senior citizen, after commencement of the Act, has
transferred property by way of gift or otherwise, subject to the condition that
the transferee shall provide basic amenities and physical needs to the
transferor, and the transferee refuses or fails to do so. In such circumstances,
the transfer is deemed to have been made by fraud, coercion or undue
influence and is liable to be declared void at the option of the transferor. The
applicability of this provision necessarily requires examination of the nature of
the transfer, the existence of the condition contemplated therein and the
alleged failure of the transferee to discharge the corresponding obligation.
22. In the present case, the senior citizens assert that the property was
acquired from their resources and that the transfer in favour of their sons was
accompanied by an obligation to maintain and look after them. On the other
hand, the contesting respondents dispute the very foundation of this claim and
rely upon the mutual agreement dated 02.08.2017, bank statements and other
financial documents to contend that the property was acquired and constructed
from their own resources.
23. These are material and disputed pleas which require examination
on the basis of the evidence led by the parties. The competent statutory
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP-27638-2026 and CWP-16699-2026 -9-
authority was required to examine the relevant documents, ascertain the nature
and circumstances of the transaction and return specific findings on the
applicability of Section 23 of the Act.
24. A perusal of the impugned orders further indicates that the
original claim has not culminated in a comprehensive adjudication. The order
dated 20.03.2025 does not adequately address the substantive reliefs raised in
the application concerning the property and the claim founded upon Section
23 of the Act. The appellate order dated 25.03.2026 enhanced the maintenance
allowance to Rs.10,000/- per month from each of the two sons and issued
directions regarding residence and protection against harassment and eviction.
However, the principal controversy concerning the conveyance deed and the
relief claimed under Section 23 of the Act has still not received a reasoned
determination.
25. The object of the Act is not merely to secure a monetary
allowance for senior citizens. It is also intended to ensure that parents and
senior citizens are able to live with dignity and are not deprived of their basic
necessities, security and lawful entitlements. The statutory mechanism must,
therefore, be made effective by ensuring that the grievances brought before it
are adjudicated in accordance with law and within a reasonable period.
26. It would not be appropriate for this Court, in exercise of its writ
jurisdiction, to undertake a first-instance determination of these disputed
factual issues. At the same time, the pendency of civil proceedings concerning
the property would not, by itself, absolve the statutory authority of its
obligation to examine the reliefs falling within its jurisdiction under the Act.
The Tribunal shall, however, remain conscious of the limits of its statutory
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP-27638-2026 and CWP-16699-2026 -10-
jurisdiction and shall not undertake adjudication of questions which fall
exclusively within the domain of the competent Civil Court.
27. This Court is also conscious of the fact that the original applicants
are senior citizens aged about 73 and 69 years respectively. The proceedings
were initiated in June, 2024 and the dispute has continued for a considerable
period. The parties were also afforded an opportunity to explore an amicable
settlement through mediation.
28. However, as is evident from the report received from the
Mediation and Conciliation Centre of this Court and noticed in the order dated
30.09.2026, the mediation proceedings did not result in an amicable settlement
and the matter consequently came to be remitted to this Court.
29. The failure of mediation is unfortunate, particularly when the
dispute is between parents and their children. Nevertheless, once an amicable
resolution has not materialised, the parties cannot be left to remain embroiled
in litigation indefinitely. The statutory remedy must now be pursued to its
logical conclusion through a lawful and effective adjudication.
30. This Court is also mindful of the fact that the Appellate Tribunal
had directed payment of maintenance at the rate of Rs.10,000/- per month
from each of the two sons and had permitted the senior citizens to reside in the
disputed house, while also directing that they should not be subjected to
harassment or eviction. These directions were intended to ensure that the
senior citizens were not left without financial support or a place of residence
during the pendency of the dispute.
31. The subsequent proceedings before this Court also indicate that
the senior citizens continued to express apprehension regarding their ability to
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP-27638-2026 and CWP-16699-2026 -11-
peacefully reside in the disputed premises. The interim protection extended by
this Court and the directions issued for ensuring compliance with the
arrangement already made cannot be rendered ineffective merely because the
matter is being remitted for fresh adjudication.
32. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the
considered view that the impugned orders cannot be sustained and that the
appropriate course would be to remit the original proceedings for fresh
adjudication by a duly constituted Maintenance Tribunal. Such a course would
ensure that the matter is decided by the statutory authority in accordance with
the prescribed procedure, after considering the entire material on record and
returning findings on all the substantive issues raised by the parties.
33. Consequently, both the writ petitions are allowed. The orders
dated 20.03.2025 passed by the Maintenance Tribunal, Israna, and 25.03.2026
passed by the Appellate Tribunal, Panipat, are hereby set aside. The original
application instituted by Mehar Dass and Soma Devi is remitted to the
Maintenance Tribunal, Israna, Panipat, duly constituted in accordance with
Rule 3 of the Rules and the applicable Government notifications, for fresh
adjudication in accordance with law.
34. The learned Maintenance Tribunal shall consider the entire
controversy afresh, after affording adequate opportunity of hearing to all
concerned parties. The parties shall be at liberty to place such additional
material as may be permissible in law. The Tribunal shall pass a reasoned and
speaking order dealing with the respective claims and objections of the parties.
It shall not be influenced by any observations made in the earlier orders or in
the present order on the merits of the rival claims.
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP-27638-2026 and CWP-16699-2026 -12-
35. Having regard to the advanced age of the original applicants and
the fact that the proceedings have already remained pending for a considerable
period, the learned Maintenance Tribunal is directed to conclude the
proceedings expeditiously, preferably within a period of three months from the
date of appearance of the parties before it. The parties are directed to appear
before the learned Maintenance Tribunal on 01.12.2026. The Tribunal shall
endeavour to avoid unnecessary adjournments and proceed with the matter
expeditiously.
36. This Court is conscious that setting aside the impugned orders
should not result in the senior citizens being deprived of the protection which
had already been extended to them. The very purpose of the Act would stand
defeated if the original applicants are left without maintenance or a secure
place of residence during the fresh adjudication. Accordingly, till the matter is
decided afresh by the Maintenance Tribunal or further orders are passed by a
competent court, the following interim arrangement shall remain operative:
(i) The direction contained in the appellate order dated 25.03.2026
regarding payment of maintenance at the rate of Rs.10,000/- per month by
each of the two sons to the original applicants shall continue to operate. The
amount shall be paid regularly, without default, in the manner already
directed.
(ii) The original applicants shall be permitted peaceful access to and
residence in House No.1090, Sector 8, HUDA, Panipat, in terms of the
protective arrangement contained in the appellate order dated 25.03.2026.
They shall not be dispossessed, obstructed or subjected to any harassment in
relation to their peaceful residence therein.
(iii) The Superintendent of Police, Panipat, shall ensure that the aforesaid
arrangement is effectively implemented and that no untoward incident or
obstruction is caused to the senior citizens. The concerned Station House
Officer shall extend necessary assistance whenever required.
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment

CWP-27638-2026 and CWP-16699-2026 -13-
37. The aforesaid arrangement is purely interim in nature and shall
not confer any final right of ownership or possession upon either side. It shall
remain subject to the final adjudication by the competent forum.
38. It is clarified that the observations made in this order are confined
to the necessity of fresh adjudication in accordance with the statutory
provisions and preservation of interim protection for the senior citizens. No
opinion is being expressed on the merits of the respective claims regarding
ownership, source of consideration, validity of the conveyance deed or
applicability of Section 23 of the Act. All such issues shall remain open for
determination by the competent Tribunal in accordance with law.
39. Both the writ petitions stand disposed of in the above terms.
40. Miscellaneous applications, if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(KIRTI SINGH)
November 17, 2026 JUDGE
Ithlesh

Whether speaking/reasoned:- Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment