TATA AIG GENERAL INSURANCE CO.LTD., vs SMT SHIVAKKA W/O NURAPPA HATTI

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18475
MFA No. 104369 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020149702024



IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD


TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE USHARANI

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 104369 OF 2024 (MV-D)

BETWEEN:
TATA AIG GENERAL INS. CO.LTD.,
RD
HALA MARK BUILDING, 3 FLOOR, DESAI CROSS,
HUBBALLI 580020
REPT. BY AUTHORISED SIGNATORY
…APPELLANT





(BY SRI. MADHUKESHWAR DESHPANDE, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. SMT SHIVAKKA W/O NURAPPA HATTI
AGE. 53 YEARS, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. MABANUR, TALUK. SAUNDATTI,
DISTRICT. BELAGAVI 591117

2.
SHIDLINGAPPA S/O NURAPPA HATTI
AGE. 26 YEARS, OCC. COOLIE,
R/O. MABANUR, TALUK. SAUNDATTI,
DISTRICT. BELAGAVI 591117

3. MAHADEVAPPA S/O SATTEPPA KANABARAGI
AGE. MAJOR, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. MADLUR, SAUNDATTI,
DISTRICT. BELAGVI 591117
…RESPONDENTS






Digitally
signed by
YASHAVANT
NARAYANKAR
Date:
2026.11.18
10:17:12
+0530
YASHAVANT
NARAYANKAR

(BY SRI. H.M. DHARIGOND, ADV., FOR R1 AND R2;
NOTICE TO R3 IS SERVED)
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.173(1) OF MOTOR VEHICLES ACT,
1988, PRAYING TO CALL THE RECORDS, HEAR THE PARTIES AND

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18475
MFA No. 104369 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020149702024


ALLOW THE APPEAL AS PRAYED FOR BY MODIFYING THE JUDGMENT
AND AWARD DATED 26.04.2024 PASSED BY PRINCIPAL SENIOR
CIVIL JUDGE AND MACT, SAUNDATTI IN MVC NO. 1704/2019 WITH
COST IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE USHARANI

ORAL JUDGMENT

1. This appeal is filed by the Insurance Company
challenging the quantum of compensation awarded in MVC
No.1704/2019 by the Principal Senior Civil Judge and
Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Saundatti
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the Tribunal’ for short) vide
judgment and award dated 26.04.2024.
2. Claim petition has been filed under Section 166 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short ‘M.V.Act’) by the legal
heirs of the deceased-Nurappa. The occurrence of accident and
the liability fixed on the insurance company to pay the
compensation to the legal heirs of the deceased-Nurappa is not
in dispute. Upon considering oral and documentary evidence

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18475
MFA No. 104369 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020149702024


produced by both the parties before the Tribunal, it has
awarded compensation as follows:
Head Amount in
Rs.(₹)
Loss of dependency 8,06,400/-
Funeral Expenses 15,000/-
Loss of consortium 40,000/-
Loss of estate 30,000/-
Medical Expenses 3,00,611/-
Total 11,92,011/-

3. Learned counsel for the Insurance Company
contends that the Tribunal has wrongly fixed income of the
deceased as ₹12,000/- instead of ₹11,750/-. Further, though
the Tribunal has rightly applied multiplier ‘7’ considering the
age of the deceased i.e., 65 years, it has erred in adding 20%
of his income towards future prospects. Further, the Tribunal
has erred in fixing the rate of interest at 7% per annum instead
of 6% per annum.
4. Per contra , learned counsel for the claimants
contended that the actual age of the deceased was 55 years,
but the claimants could not produce the relevant documents
before the Tribunal. Hence, considering the fact that there is
unbearable loss due to the death of eldest member in the

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18475
MFA No. 104369 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020149702024


family, addition of 20% of income towards future prospects
need not be interfered with. It was pointed out that the
Tribunal has awarded compensation under the head of ‘loss of
consortium’, which is on lower side.
5. Heard the arguments of learned counsels for both
the parties and perused the materials on record.
6. It is important to note here that the occurrence of
accident on 14.01.2018 is not disputed. The claimants claimed
that the deceased was working as an agriculturist and
shepherd, but no documents were produced to substantiate the
same. Hence, the notional income of ₹11,750/- per month
prescribed in the notional income chart issued by the Karnataka
State Legal Services Authority for the year 2018 is taken into
consideration and the same is fixed as income of the deceased
herein.
7. As per the FIR-Ex.P1 and postmortem report-Ex.P5,
the age of the deceased was shown as 65 years at the time of
his death. Though claimants have taken up a contention that
deceased was aged 55 years at the time of his death, PW1 has

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18475
MFA No. 104369 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020149702024


admitted in his cross-examination that, in the postmortem
report-Ex.P5, the age of the deceased is shown as 65 years.
Further, he has admitted that he does not possess any
document relating to the age of the deceased. Hence, the
Tribunal has rightly considered the age of the deceased as 65
years and applied multiplier ‘7’. However, Tribunal has erred in
adding 20% of income towards future prospects. In the
absence of documents relating to age of the deceased, afore-
discussed evidence, Ex.P1 and Ex.P5 have to be considered and
arguments submitted by the learned counsel for the claimants
rd
cannot be accepted. After deducting 1/3 of the income
towards personal expenses of deceased and applying multiplier
7, the claimants are entitled to ₹6,57,972/- under the head of
‘loss of dependency’.
8. The Tribunal has lost sight of the fact that the
deceased has left behind two of his family members, while
awarding compensation under the head of ‘loss of consortium’.
The compensation awarded under the head ‘funeral expenses’
is on a lower side, whereas compensation awarded under the
head ‘loss of estate’ is on higher side. In light of the above

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18475
MFA No. 104369 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020149702024


findings, the compensation awarded under the heads of ‘loss of
consortium’, ‘loss of estate’ and ‘funeral expenses’ have been
re-assessed in accordance with the judgment in the case of
1
National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi
by factoring in 10% enhancement every three years. This Court
also places reliance on the case of Rojalini Nayak v. Ajit
2
Sahoo , wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court has reckoned the said
enhancement as on the date of its judgment and the amount
fixed under the conventional heads in the year 2017 were
enhanced by 10% twice by then.
9. The compensation awarded under the head of
‘medical expenses’ is just and proper and does not require
interference as there is no dispute with regard to the same by
either of the parties.
10. At this juncture, learned counsel for the Insurance

Company submits that, since claimants have not come up with
an appeal or cross-objection, the compensation awarded by the
Tribunal cannot be enhanced. If the compensation awarded by

1
(2017)16 SCC 680.
2
2024 INSC 584

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18475
MFA No. 104369 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020149702024


the Tribunal and this Court is juxtaposed, there is no overall
enhancement. Even otherwise, by invoking the provisions of
Order 41 Rule 33, this Court has merely followed the principles
laid down in the case of Pranay Sethi (supra) , while awarding
compensation under conventional heads.
11. In view of the above discussion , the claimants
are entitled to compensation as follows:
Head Amount in
Rs.(₹)
Loss of dependency 15,98,000/-
Loss of consortium (₹53,240x 2) 1,06,480/-
Towards Funeral Expenses 19,965/-
Towards Loss of Estate 19,965/-
Medical Expenses 3,00,611/-
Total 20,45,021/-
12. With regard to interest fixed b y the Tribunal, I
opine that interference is not required. Hence, the
following:

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18475
MFA No. 104369 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020149702024


ORDER
(i) The MFA No.104369/2024 is allowed in part.
(ii) The judgment and award dated 26.04.2024 in
MVC No. 1704/2019 passed by the Principal
Senior Civil Judge and Additional Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Saundatti is
modified to the extent that the claimants are
entitled to the compensation of ₹20,45,021 /-
with interest at the rate of 7% per annum from
the date of petition till realization.
(iii) The Insurance Company shall deposit the
compensation, together with accrued interest,
before the jurisdictional Tribunal within a period
of eight weeks from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this judgment.
(iv) The amount in deposit, if any, made by the
appellant-Insurance Company is directed to be

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18475
MFA No. 104369 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020149702024


transmitted to the concerned Tribunal along with
Trial Court Records forthwith.
(v) Registry to draw modified award accordingly.

Sd/-
(USHARANI)
JUDGE




YAN
CT:CNB
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 29