M/S Suresh Kumar Nitin Kumar & Anr vs Karan Singh (Since Deceased) Through Lrs

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CR-3717-2026 (O&M) -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND
HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
215
CR-3717-2026 (O&M)
Date of decision: 20.11.2026
M/s Suresh Kumar Nitin Kumar & another ...Petitioners
Versus
Karan Singh (Since Deceased) through LRs ...Respondent
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIRINDER AGGARWAL
Present:- Mr. Saurabh Garg, Advocate
for the petitioners.
Mr. Upender Prasher, Advocate
for the respondent.
VIRINDER AGGARWAL, J. (Oral)
1. The present civil revision petition has been instituted under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, invoking the supervisory
jurisdiction of this Court, to assail the order dated 09.04.2026 (Annexure P-
7), passed by the Civil Judge, Kaithal, whereby the petitioner’s application
seeking leave to adduce additional evidence was declined. The petitioner
seeks to assail the legality and propriety of the impugned order and prays for
its setting aside, with a consequential direction permitting the petitioner to
lead the additional evidence sought to be brought on record through the
aforesaid application (Annexure P-5).
2. Briefly stated, the petitioners-plaintiffs instituted a suit for
recovery of 8,68,000/-, along with pendente lite and future interest, on the ₹
basis of a pronote and receipt. The suit was contested by the defendant, who
denied the execution of the pronote and receipt and alleged that the
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.21 12:09
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-3717-2026 (O&M) -2-
petitioner-plaintiffs might have obtained their thumb impressions on blank
papers under the pretext of their having sold their produce at the petitioners’
shop. It was further alleged that the pronote, receipt and corresponding
entries in the account books were forged and fabricated.
2.1. Upon completion of the pleadings, issues were framed and the
parties were called upon to lead their respective evidence. During the course
of the proceedings, the petitioner-plaintiffs moved an application seeking
specimen thumb impressions of the defendants, which was allowed vide
order dated 12.08.2022. In compliance thereof, the defendant furnished their
specimen thumb impressions, which were subsequently got examined by the
petitioner-plaintiffs through a handwriting and fingerprint expert, namely
Sh. Shamsher Singh Malik, who submitted his report dated 10.02.2023.
2.2. Thereafter, the matter continued at the stage of plaintiffs’
evidence. During the pendency of the proceedings, one of the defendant
expired, whereupon an application for bringing his legal representatives on
record was allowed vide order dated 20.12.2024, and the amended memo of
parties was duly filed. The petitioner-plaintiffs ultimately closed their
evidence on 15.09.2025 without examining the fingerprint expert to prove
his report. Subsequently, when the matter had proceeded to the stage of
defendants’ evidence, the petitioner-plaintiffs moved an application seeking
permission to lead additional evidence by examining the said expert to prove
and substantiate his report dated 10.02.2023. The said application came to be
dismissed by the Trial Court vide the impugned order.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioners-plaintiffs contends that the
impugned order is legally unsustainable, particularly in view of the fact that
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.21 12:09
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-3717-2026 (O&M) -3-
the disputed thumb impressions appearing on the pronote and receipt had
already been compared with the specimen thumb impressions of the
defendant through a duly appointed fingerprint expert. It is submitted that
the petitioners-plaintiffs, though having inadvertently omitted to examine
the expert who had furnished the report, ought not to be deprived of an
opportunity to prove the same, particularly when the expert’s testimony
would materially assist the Court in arriving at a just and effective
adjudication of the controversy.
4. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent-defendant
submits that the impugned order suffers from no illegality or infirmity
warranting interference. It is contended that the petitioners-plaintiffs had
ample opportunity to examine the fingerprint expert during the course of
their evidence but failed to avail themselves of the same. The application,
having been moved at a belated stage, was rightly declined, as permitting the
proposed additional evidence would unnecessarily reopen the trial and
virtually result in a de novo exercise.
5. Having considered the rival submissions and the material
available on record, this Court finds that certain peculiar circumstances of
the present case warrant a measured indulgence in favour of the petitioners-
plaintiffs. Significantly, the respondent-defendant and the Trial Court were
aware, from the inception of the proceedings, of the petitioners-plaintiffs’
intention to establish the genuineness of the disputed thumb impressions
through expert evidence. The petitioners-plaintiffs had, at an earlier stage,
moved an application seeking specimen thumb impressions of the
defendants, which was duly allowed vide order dated 12.08.2022. Pursuant
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.21 12:09
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-3717-2026 (O&M) -4-
thereto, the specimen thumb impressions were obtained during the course of
judicial proceedings and were subsequently compared with the disputed
impressions appearing on the pronote and receipt by the fingerprint expert,
Sh. Shamsher Singh Malik, who furnished his report dated 10.02.2023.
Thus, the proposed additional evidence does not introduce any new or
previously undisclosed line of defence or controversy, but is confined to
formally proving an expert report already obtained during the pendency of
the suit.
5.1. The omission on the part of the petitioners-plaintiffs to examine
the expert while leading their evidence may, at best, be attributed to
inadvertence or lack of due diligence. However, such omission, in the
peculiar facts of the present case, ought not to result in the exclusion of
potentially material evidence, particularly when the testimony of the expert
may assist the Trial Court in effectively adjudicating the central controversy
concerning the execution and genuineness of the pronote and receipt. It is
equally significant that the respondent-defendant has not yet concluded their
evidence and would, therefore, have an adequate opportunity to controvert
the expert’s report, cross-examine the expert and, if so advised, lead rebuttal
evidence. Consequently, permitting the proposed additional evidence would
neither occasion an irreversible prejudice to the respondent-defendant nor
necessitate a de novo trial.
5.2. At the same time, the inconvenience and delay occasioned to
the respondent-defendant cannot be disregarded and can appropriately be
compensated by imposing costs and placing suitable conditions upon the
petitioners-plaintiffs. This Court is, therefore, of the considered opinion that
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.21 12:09
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-3717-2026 (O&M) -5-
the ends of justice would be adequately served by permitting the petitioners-
plaintiffs one final opportunity to examine Sh. Shamsher Singh Malik,
Fingerprint Expert, subject to payment of costs and the further condition
that, in the event of the suit being decreed in their favour, the petitioners-
plaintiffs shall not be entitled to pendente lite interest for the period
commencing from the date of filing of the application seeking additional
evidence until the date on which the testimony of the aforesaid expert is duly
recorded.
6. In view of the foregoing discussion, the present revision petition
is allowed . The impugned order is set aside and the application seeking
permission to lead additional evidence is allowed, subject to the following
conditions:-
(i) The petitioners-plaintiffs shall be afforded one final
opportunity to examine Sh. Shamsher Singh Malik,
Fingerprint Expert, for proving his report dated 10.02.2023.
(ii) The petitioners-plaintiffs shall pay costs quantified at
₹ 25,000/- to the respondent-defendant.
(iii) In the event of the suit being decreed in favour of the
petitioners-plaintiffs, they shall not be entitled to claim
pendente lite interest for the period commencing from the
date of filing of the application for additional evidence until
the date on which the testimony of the aforesaid expert is
recorded.
6.1. Needless to observe, the Trial Court shall afford the respondent-
defendant a full and effective opportunity to cross-examine the expert and, if
so advised, adduce evidence in rebuttal, thereafter it shall proceed to
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.21 12:09
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CR-3717-2026 (O&M) -6-
adjudicate the suit on its merits, independently and in accordance with law.
7. It is clarified that the observations made hereinabove are
confined strictly to the adjudication of the present revision petition and shall
not be construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the underlying
dispute. The Trial Court shall adjudicate the suit independently, uninfluenced
by any observation made herein, and in accordance with law.
8. In view of the final disposal of the present petition, all pending
miscellaneous applications, if any, also stand disposed of accordingly. No
further orders are called for.
20.11.2026 (VIRINDER AGGARWAL)
GAURAV SOROT
JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.21 12:09
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document