Ms Smriti vs KENDRIYA VIDYALAYA SANGATHAN (KVS)

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1 O.A No. 4307/2026
Item 7 (C-3)
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI

O.A. No. 4307/2026

Reserved on : 30.10.2026

Pronounced on : 19.11.2026

Hon’ble Mrs. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (J)
Hon’ble Dr. Sumeet Jerath, Member (A)

Ms. Smriti, Aged about 34 years,
D/o. Shri Brijender Kumar
Rio. 55A DDA FLATS, GROUND FLOOR,
POCKET C SIDDHARTHA EXTENSION
NEW DELHI-110025 ..…Applicant
(By Advocate : Mr. S. K. Das)

Versus

1. Commissioner, Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan,
18, Institutional Area, Shaheed Jeet Singh Marg
New Delhi-110016

2. Assistant Commissioner (Recruitment),
Kendriya Vidyalya Sangathan,
18, Institutional Area, Shaheed Jeet Singh Marg
New Delhi-11016

3. The Controlling Officer, Verification Committee,
Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan, PMShri KV No.1,
Hathibarkala, Salawala, Dehradun,
Uttarakhand 248001 ……Respondents

(By Advocate : Mr. S. Rajappa with Mr. Dilbagh Singh with Mr. U. N. Singh)


ORDER

Hon'ble Dr. Sumeet Jerath, Member (A) :

The instant OA has been filed by the applicant under section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 seeking the following reliefs:-



2026.11.19
MAYA B TARAGI
17:46:05+05'30'

2 O.A No. 4307/2026
Item 7 (C-3)
“A. Quash the impugned Order dated. 12.10.2026 declaring the
same to be unlawful, arbitrary and discriminatory with all
consequential benefits under law;
B. pass such further or other orders as may be deemed fit and
proper in the facts and circumstances of the case and also in the
interest of justice.”

2. The factual matrix of the case as per the counsel for the applicant
is that the applicant had completed her M.Sc. in the year 2015 and
thereafter pursued B.Ed. (Special Education) from Lady Irwin College, which
she successfully completed in the year 2017. She claimed that she
possessed the requisite educational qualifications for appointment to the
post of TGT (Special Educator). According to her, Recruitment Notification
No. 01/2025 dated 13.11.2025 had been issued inviting applications for
various teaching and non-teaching posts in KVS and NVS, including the post
of Special Educator (TGT). The last date for submission of online
applications, initially fixed as 04.12.2025, had subsequently been extended
to 11.12.2025. The applicant submitted her online application on
09.12.2025 for the post of TGT (Special Educator) under the Scheduled
Caste category. In her application, she declared that she possessed the
essential qualifications prescribed for the post and had also stated that she
was registered with the Rehabilitation Council of India with a valid CRR
number. The applicant further stated that one of the essential eligibility
requirements for the post was registration with RCI and possession of a valid
CRR number. Since she had not obtained the requisite CRR registration
certificate, she had also submitted an online application on 09.12.2025 to
RCI for issuance of the Central Rehabilitation Register certificate and had

2026.11.19
MAYA B TARAGI
17:46:05+05'30'

3 O.A No. 4307/2026
Item 7 (C-3)
paid a registration fee of Rs.5,500/-. The applicant contended that after
payment of the registration fee, she was required to download the
Certificate of Authentication form from the RCI portal, get it authenticated
by the concerned institution and upload the same for further processing of
her registration. However, according to her, owing to technical glitches and
maintenance of the RCI portal, she could not download the requisite form
despite repeated attempts. She had claimed that she had regularly tried to
access the portal and had also contacted the reception of RCI over
telephone. She further stated that she had personally visited the office of
RCI on several occasions during January, March and May 2026, but was not
permitted to enter the premises and was informed over telephone that the
portal was undergoing maintenance. In the meantime, the applicant
received an admit card for appearing in the Tier-I examination scheduled on
11.01.2026. She appeared in the said examination and had qualified for
the Tier-II examination, which was conducted on 29.03.2026. She also
appeared in Tier-II and had been successful therein. Thus, on the basis of
her performance in the two stages of the examination, she had been
shortlisted for the interview. The applicant further stated that when she
accessed the RCI portal in July 2026, she came to know that her earlier
application dated 09.12.2025 for issuance of the CRR certificate had been
rejected. She thereafter contacted the RCI office and, according to her,
was verbally advised to submit a fresh application. She also claimed that
the amount of Rs.5,500/- deposited by her with the earlier application was
not adjusted or refunded. Consequently, she had been compelled to submit
a fresh application for CRR registration and deposit another amount of

2026.11.19
MAYA B TARAGI
17:46:05+05'30'

4 O.A No. 4307/2026
Item 7 (C-3)
Rs.5,500/-. In this regard, the documents annexed with the O.A,
particularly the representation dated 05.10.2026 submitted by the applicant
to RCI, were relevant as in the said representation, the applicant herself had
referred to her earlier CRR application bearing Application ID RCI-2025-
380237-A and had stated that the application status was showing
"Application Rejected". The reason reflected against the said application
was that she was required to scan and attach the original Certificate of
Authentication bearing her photograph and duly signed and stamped by the
Head of the Institution where she had completed her course. According to
her, although she possessed the requisite authentication certificate, she was
unable to access the relevant page of the portal to upload the same. She
consequently sought guidance from RCI as to whether her earlier application
could be reopened, whether the fee already deposited could be adjusted and
whether she was required to apply afresh for CRR registration. The above
document was significant because it disclosed that the earlier application
had not culminated in the issuance of a CRR certificate. The reason
communicated through the RCI portal was non-submission of the prescribed
Certificate of Authentication. The applicant attributed her inability to
complete the process to technical difficulties and had stated that she was
unable to access the portal. However, the fact remained that her earlier
application had been rejected and the requisite registration had not been
completed through that application. She thereafter submitted a fresh
application for CRR registration. The documents placed on record indicated
that the fresh application had been submitted on 19.09.2026 and that a
payment of Rs.5,500/- had been made towards the registration fee. The

2026.11.19
MAYA B TARAGI
17:46:05+05'30'

5 O.A No. 4307/2026
Item 7 (C-3)
applicant also obtained a Certificate of Authentication dated 15.09.2026
from the Head of her Institution and had uploaded the same in connection
with her fresh application. The RCI portal acknowledgement dated
19.09.2026 reflected the ID No. A126597 in respect of the applicant's fresh
application. It was the case of the applicant that the aforesaid
acknowledgement established that her CRR application had been approved
and that the ID number allotted to her was ultimately the same as the CRR
number subsequently appearing on the certificate. She contended that
although the registration had been approved, the e-CRR certificate was not
immediately generated or made available for download on the RCI portal.
According to her, the delay in generation and uploading of the certificate
was attributable entirely to the functioning of the RCI portal and was beyond
her control. She also stated that on 18.09.2026 she had received an email
from the examination authorities informing her that she had been shortlisted
for the interview for the post of TGT (Special Educator). The call letter
dated 18.09.2026 had required her to appear for the interview on
12.10.2026 at PM SHRI Kendriya Vidyalaya No. 1, Hathibarkala, Salawala,
Dehradun, Uttarakhand, at 8:30 AM. The call letter had specifically
instructed the candidates to bring their original certificates and mark sheets
in support of their educational qualifications, age, experience and other
eligibility requirements. It further stipulated that the candidates were
required to produce all relevant certificates and supporting documents in
original relating to their educational qualifications, experience, age, category
and other eligibility requirements at the time of interview. It had also
specifically stated that candidates who failed to provide any required

2026.11.19
MAYA B TARAGI
17:46:05+05'30'

6 O.A No. 4307/2026
Item 7 (C-3)
document or certificate in original would not be allowed to attend the
interview. The call letter had further clarified that if any particulars
furnished by a candidate in the application or prescribed bio-data form were
found incomplete or incorrect upon verification, the candidature could be
summarily rejected. The applicant appeared at the designated interview
centre on 12.10.2026. After completion of biometric verification, she
appeared before the Verification Committee for scrutiny of her original
documents. At that stage, the Controlling Officer had required her to
produce the CRR registration certificate issued by RCI which she was unable
to produce. However, she produced the acknowledgement dated
19.09.2026 issued by RCI, bearing ID No. A126597, and had requested the
authorities to accept the same as sufficient proof of her registration. The
applicant further stated that she had explained to the Controlling Officer that
the said ID number was the same as the CRR number subsequently allotted
to her and that the certificate had not been generated or uploaded on the
RCI portal. She requested that she be permitted to participate in the
interview provisionally or on the basis of an undertaking to submit the final
certificate within a reasonable period. However, the Verification Committee
had not accepted her request and had declared her ineligible on account of
non-submission of the CRR certificate. The impugned checklist dated
12.10.2026, annexed as Annexure A-1 to the O.A, recorded the result of
verification of the applicant's documents. Against the column relating to
the reasons for ineligibility, it had specifically been recorded that the CRR
certificate had not been submitted by the candidate and that she had
produced only the acknowledgement receipt dated 19.09.2026. On that

2026.11.19
MAYA B TARAGI
17:46:05+05'30'

7 O.A No. 4307/2026
Item 7 (C-3)
basis, the applicant had been declared not eligible for the post of TGT
(Special Educator). Aggrieved by the aforesaid decision, the applicant
submitted representations dated 13.10.2026 and 14.10.2026 to the
Commissioner, KVS, requesting reconsideration of her candidature and
another opportunity to complete document verification and appear in the
interview. She reiterated that she had initially applied for CRR registration
on 09.12.2025 and had paid the requisite fee before the extended closing
date of the recruitment process. She attributed the failure of the earlier
application to technical difficulties in the RCI portal and had requested that
the date of her original application be taken into consideration. The
applicant had also stated that when she accessed the RCI portal on
14.10.2026, the status of her fresh application continued to display the
message "Certificate Not Generated Yet". She, therefore, approached the
Assistant Commissioner (Recruitment), KVS, on 15.10.2026 and had
forwarded her representation through WhatsApp, requesting that she be
granted an opportunity to appear for the interview. Thereafter, on
16.10.2026, the applicant submitted another representation to RCI
requesting early generation and issuance of her CRR certificate. The
documents annexed to the O.A indicated that on the same date she had
received an email from RCI informing her that her fresh application bearing
Application ID rci-2026-424203-A had been considered and that registration
number A126597 had been allotted to her in the Central Rehabilitation
Register. However, later she could download the e-CRR certificate on
16.10.2026. The e-CRR certificate dated 16.10.2026 placed on record by
the applicant showed CRR No. A126597. It also reflected the date of

2026.11.19
MAYA B TARAGI
17:46:05+05'30'

8 O.A No. 4307/2026
Item 7 (C-3)
registration as 09.10.2026 and the validity of the registration up to
09.10.2033. The certificate recorded the applicant's qualification as B.Ed.
Special Education (Mental Retardation), obtained in 2017, and her
registration category as Special Educator (Mental Retardation). After
obtaining the aforesaid certificate, the applicant submitted yet another
representation dated 19.10.2026 to the Commissioner, KVS, requesting that
she be permitted to participate in the interview in view of the fact that the
CRR certificate had since been issued. She contended that the CRR number
appearing on the certificate was identical to the ID number reflected in the
acknowledgement produced by her before the Verification Committee on
12.10.2026. She added that the interview process was still continuing and
that permitting her to participate would not cause any prejudice to the
respondents or other candidates. According to her, she could not be
penalised for the failure of the issuing authority to generate and upload the
certificate in time. She argued that the authorities ought to have taken a
liberal and reasonable view and permitted her to participate in the interview
provisionally, subject to production of the final certificate within a reasonable
period. She also contended that she possessed the requisite educational
qualifications and had successfully cleared both Tier-I and Tier-II
examinations. Therefore, rejection of her candidature at the final stage of
the recruitment process, without granting her an opportunity to produce the
certificate subsequently, had resulted in miscarriage of justice. According
to the applicant, the impugned action was discriminatory and violative of
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. She submitted that since
she had ultimately obtained the CRR certificate and the interview process

2026.11.19
MAYA B TARAGI
17:46:05+05'30'

9 O.A No. 4307/2026
Item 7 (C-3)
was continuing, the respondents ought to have permitted her to participate
in the interview, as no prejudice would have been caused to any other
candidate. The applicant accordingly prayed for quashing of the order
dated 12.10.2026 declaring her ineligible and for consequential reliefs. She
also sought an appropriate direction for making necessary arrangements to
enable her to participate in the interview for the post of TGT (Special
Educator).
3. The counsel for the applicant argued assiduously on the following
grounds :-
“1. The impugned order dated 12.10.2026 is unsustainable both
on facts and law, hence is liable to be quashed.
2. The Respondent No.3 has acted erroneously and without due
application of mind in as much as he has failed to take notice of
the fact that default if any; lies on the part of the issuing
authority for its failure to generate and upload the Certificate on
its portal to enable the applicant to download and produce the
same at the time of verification of the credentials. Thus, the
Respondent No.3 is not correct to penalise the Applicant who has
acted bonafide and in the absence of any intentional mistake on
her part.
3. The Respondent No.3 failed to take liberal view of the matter in
as much as during the verification of the documents Applicant
produced the Acknowledgement issued by the Rehabilitation
Council of India containing the approval for issuance of the
Application submitted by the Applicant and allotment of ID No.
which was eventually same as the CRR No. allotted to her. Under
such circumstances, the Applicant ought to have been allowed for
the interview either provisionally or on the basis of a valid
undertaking to produce the Certificate within a reasonable period
of time. Since the same has not been done or allowed to have
been done, the Respondent No.3 has acted arbitrarily in the
absence of a reasonable cause or rhyme, rendering thereby the
impugned order unsustainable.
4. The Respondents failed to take into consideration the fact that
the Applicant is otherwise Eligible in terms of the educational
qualifications provided under the Recruitment Notification and
meritorious which evident from the result of TIER-1 and TIER-2
examination cleared by her. Thus, rejecting her candidature at
the fag end of the recruitment process and that too without


2026.11.19
MAYA B TARAGI
17:46:05+05'30'

10 O.A No. 4307/2026
Item 7 (C-3)
allowing her time to submit the Certificate which was uploaded by
the Council on a date subsequent to the date of Interview, results
in miscarriage of justice and fair play.
5. The Respondents have failed to consider the fact highlighted in
her representations evidencing the bonafide acts of the Applicant
and her sincere efforts made to get the CRR Certificate issued by
the Council on time and in such view of the matter, the
Respondents should have accorded a chance for interview of the
Applicant. However, all her representations have evoked no
response from the side of the Respondents even though diligently
pursued by the Applicant.
6. The action of the respondents in declaring the applicant
ineligible and denying her participation in the interview per se
unsustainable being violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India
7. Applicant is entitled to a fair chance of participation in the
Interview which is continuing as of now in view of the availability
of the Certificate containing CRR No. issued by the Rehabilitation
Council of India and allowing the Applicant's participation would
cause no grievous prejudice either to the Respondents or any
other participants."

4. The matter came up for consideration at the admission stage.
After hearing learned counsel for the applicant and examining the pleadings
and documents placed on record, the matter had been reserved for orders
on the very first date of hearing itself. No notice had been issued to the
respondents for filing a counter-reply and, consequently, no reply had been
filed on their behalf. We, therefore, proceeded to examine the matter on
the basis of the averments made in the O.A and the documents annexed
thereto. It is made clear that the absence of a counter-reply could not, by
itself, be treated as an admission of the allegations made by the applicant,
and the legality of the impugned action had to be examined on the basis of
the material available on record.


2026.11.19
MAYA B TARAGI
17:46:05+05'30'

11 O.A No. 4307/2026
Item 7 (C-3)
5. We have carefully gone through the pleadings of the applicant's
counsel and noticed that the applicant did not exercise enough / due
diligence in a timely manner to generate a valid Central Rehabilitation
Register (CRR) number so as to be registered with the Rehabilitation Council
of India (RCI). Her repeated claims that she had failed to generate the CRR
number from the portal of RCI due to technical glitches and even after
having gone to the RCI office on several occasions are not convincing. In
any selection process, the onus of submitting all the necessary and
supporting documents clearly lies on the applicant and no way can the
applicant shift the blame elsewhere. We have observed that the
respondents have acted correctly in denying the applicant the opportunity to
participate in the interview for the post of TGT (Special Educator) as the
applicant had failed to produce the necessary and relevant documents at the
time of document verification.
6. In the light of the above, we are of the considered opinion that the
balance of convenience in the instant OA clearly lies with the respondent.
The instant OA is devoid of merit; deserves to be dismissed and is
accordingly dismissed. MAs if any are also disposed of in similar manner.
However, there will be no order as to costs


(Dr. Sumeet Jerath) (Harvinder Kaur Oberoi)
Member (A) Member (J)


/Mbt/
2026.11.19
MAYA B TARAGI
17:46:05+05'30'