Ahsan vs Shambhu Lal Vaishnav
- Court
- Supreme Court
- Case type
- Civil Appeal
- Decided on
- 17-02-2026
<div> 2026 INSC 354<br /> NON-REPORTABLE<br /> IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA<br /> CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION <br /> CIVIL APPEAL NO.1702 OF 2026<br /> (@ SLP (C) NO.19981 OF 2025)<br /> AHSAN APPELLANT <br /> VERSUS<br /> SHAMBHU LAL VAISHNAV AND ORS. RESPONDENTS <br /> O R D E R <br /> ATUL S. CHANDURKAR, J. <br /> 1. Leave granted.<br /> 2. The appellant is aggrieved by the partial enhancement in<br /> the amount of compensation granted to him vide judgment dated<br /> 05.05.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge of the Rajasthan<br /> 1<br /> High Court in S.B. Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No.1424 of 2008. <br /> 3. On 15.11.2005, when the appellant was travelling on his<br /> Signature Not Verified<br /> scooter, the first respondent gave him a dash with the car that<br /> Digitally signed by<br /> ANITA MALHOTRA<br /> Date: 2026.04.11<br /> 10:08:58 IST<br /> Reason:<br /> 1 For short, the High Court<br /> Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No.19981 of 2025 Page 1<br /><br /> was alleged to have been driven rashly and negligently by him.<br /> The said car was owned by the second respondent and insured<br /> with the third respondent. As a result of the said accident, the<br /> appellant suffered head injury which resulted in paralysing his<br /> body. The appellant approached the Motor Accident Claims<br /> 2<br /> ₹<br /> Tribunal seeking compensation of an amount of 20,54,000/-<br /> from the driver of the vehicle, its owner and the insurance<br /> 3<br /> company under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 . <br /> 4. In support of his claim, the appellant examined three<br /> witnesses and produced various documents. The respondents did<br /> not adduce any evidence whatsoever. Vide award dated<br /> 04.10.2007, the Claims Tribunal awarded compensation in the<br /> following manner:<br /></div><table><thead><tr><th>Head of Compensation</th><th>Granted by Tribunal</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>Permanent Disability</td><td>₹3,82,464/- (16 x 2400 x<br>12 x 83/100)</td></tr><tr><td>Simple injuries</td><td>₹7,000/-</td></tr><tr><td>One grievous injury</td><td>₹5,000/-</td></tr><tr><td>Transportation, diet and other<br>relevant expenses during treatment</td><td>₹9,000/-</td></tr><tr><td>Reimbursement of medical<br>expenses</td><td>₹52,876/-</td></tr><tr><td>Total</td><td>₹4,56,340/-</td></tr></tbody></table><div><br /> 2 For short, ‘the Claims Tribunal’<br /> 3 For short, the Act<br /> Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No.19981 of 2025 Page 2<br /><br /> 5. The appellant, not being satisfied with the award of<br /> compensation of ₹ 4,56,340/- by the Claims Tribunal, preferred<br /> appeal under Section 173 of the Act. The High Court, after<br /> reappreciating the evidence on record, was pleased to enhance<br /> the amount of compensation by ₹ 3,88,780/- in the following<br /> manner:<br /></div><table><thead><tr><th>Head of Compensation</th><th>Granted by High Court</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>Annual income (100%<br>disability)</td><td>₹2400/- x 12 x 16 =<br>₹4,60,800/-</td></tr><tr><td>Future prospects (+) 40%</td><td>₹1,84,320/-</td></tr><tr><td>Pain & Suffering/Special Diet<br>(+)</td><td>₹1,00,000/-</td></tr><tr><td>Attendant Charges/Future<br>Treatment (+)</td><td>₹1,00,000/-</td></tr><tr><td>Total</td><td>₹8,45,120/-</td></tr><tr><td>Already Awarded Amount (-)</td><td>₹4,56,340/-</td></tr><tr><td>Enhanced amount of<br>compensation</td><td>₹3,88,780/-</td></tr></tbody></table><div><br /> 5.1. Not being satisfied with the partial enhancement in the<br /> amount of compensation, the appellant has preferred the present<br /> appeal. <br /> Mr. Arjun Garg, learned counsel for the appellant submitted<br /> 6.<br /> that the annual income of the appellant has been assessed on<br /> Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No.19981 of 2025 Page 3<br /><br /> the lower side notwithstanding the fact that the appellant was<br /> ₹<br /> earning an amount of 6,000/- per month. He submitted that<br /> the appellant having suffered 100% disability, the said aspect<br /> was required to be borne in mind while awarding just<br /> compensation. Even the age of the appellant was taken on a<br /> higher side as 35 years despite the fact that the appellant was<br /> aged about 26 years when the accident took place. Similarly,<br /> under other heads such as pain and suffering, attendant charges<br /> as well as loss of income, lesser amounts had been awarded. It<br /> was, thus, submitted that the appellant having claimed fair<br /> amount of compensation in his claim petition, that amount ought<br /> to be awarded to him.<br /> 7. On the other hand, Mr. Aditya Kumar, learned counsel<br /> appearing for the insurance company supported the impugned<br /> judgment. According to him, the High Court determined fair<br /> amount of compensation on the basis of evidence led by the<br /> appellant. There is no scope for any further enhancement in the<br /> amount of compensation. The age of the appellant was rightly<br /> taken as 35 years since that was the age mentioned in his<br /> discharge tickets. There was no evidence whatsoever to hold that<br /> Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No.19981 of 2025 Page 4<br /><br /> ₹<br /> the appellant was earning 6,000/- per month. The income of<br /> ₹<br /> 2,400/- per month which was the minimum income for a skilled<br /> labour was thus rightly taken. It was, therefore, submitted that<br /> there is no scope whatsoever for any further enhancement in the<br /> amount of compensation. The appeal is, thus, liable to be<br /> dismissed.<br /> 8. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have<br /> perused the documents on record. Having given due<br /> consideration to the manner in which the amount of<br /> compensation has been determined by the Courts below, we find<br /> that insofar as the notional income of the appellant is concerned,<br /> the same has rightly been taken at ₹ 2,400/- per month since<br /> that was the prevalent minimum income for skilled labour in<br /> 2005 when the accident took place. The appellant could not place<br /> any material on record to justify his claim that he was earning<br /> ₹ 6,000/- per month.<br /> 8.1. As regards application of the multiplier of 16 is concerned,<br /> the same is in accordance with the age of the appellant which<br /> has been taken to be 35 years, the same being mentioned in his<br /> discharge ticket at Exhibit 11.<br /> Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No.19981 of 2025 Page 5<br /><br /> ₹<br /> 8.2. The appellant has been awarded a sum of 52,876/-<br /> towards reimbursement of medical expenses on the basis of<br /> documentary evidence. Since the appellant was aged 35 years<br /> when the accident took place, the provision towards future<br /> medical expenses considering average life expectancy deserves to<br /> ₹<br /> be granted as 7,00,000/-. <br /> 8.3. Insofar as attendant charges are concerned, the High Court<br /> ₹<br /> has granted an amount of 1,00,000/- under this head. In our<br /> view, this amount is on the lower side especially in view of the<br /> fact that the appellant suffers from functional disability to the<br /> extent of 100%. The nature and extent of his disability would<br /> require performing his daily activities with the aid of attendants.<br /> On the rough estimate of ₹ 3,500/- per month towards attendant<br /> charges, the annual expenditure under that head would be<br /> ₹ 42,000/-. With the multiplier of 16, the amount payable<br /> towards attendant charges would be ₹ 6,72,000/- ( ₹ 42,000 x 16). <br /> 8.4. An amount of ₹ 2,00,000/- is also found admissible for loss<br /> of amenities. The High Court has not awarded any amount under<br /> this head. Thus, enhancement in the amount of compensation<br /> from that as granted by the High Court would be as under:<br /> Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No.19981 of 2025 Page 6<br /><br /></div><table><thead><tr><th>Enhancement in the amount of compensation payable</th><th></th><th></th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>S.No.</td><td>Particulars</td><td>Amount</td></tr><tr><td>A.</td><td>Annual Income (₹ 2400 x 12)</td><td>₹28,800/-</td></tr><tr><td>B.</td><td>Loss of Earning Capacity (100%)</td><td>₹28,800/-</td></tr><tr><td>C.</td><td>Loss of Future Income<br>(B x Multiplier “16”)</td><td>₹4,60,800/-</td></tr><tr><td>D.</td><td>Loss of Future Income with Future<br>Prospects @ 40%<br>(C + ₹ 1,84,320/-)</td><td>₹6,45,120/-</td></tr><tr><td>E.</td><td>Medical Expenses Reimbursement</td><td>₹52,876/-</td></tr><tr><td>F.</td><td>Future Medical Expenses</td><td>₹7,00,000/-</td></tr><tr><td>H.</td><td>Attendant Charges<br>(₹ 3500 x 12 x 16)</td><td>₹6,72,000/-</td></tr><tr><td>I.</td><td>Pain and Suffering</td><td>₹1,00,000/-</td></tr><tr><td>J.</td><td>Loss of amenities</td><td>₹2 ,00,000/-</td></tr><tr><td>Total</td><td></td><td>₹23,69,996/-</td></tr></tbody></table><div><br /> 9. In the aforesaid manner, we find that the appellant would be<br /> entitled to further enhancement in the amount of compensation<br /> from what has been assessed by the High Court. Thus, the total<br /> compensation now payable to the appellant would be<br /> ₹ 23,69,996/-. The enhanced amount of compensation shall carry<br /> interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing the claim petition<br /> before the Claims Tribunal till realization of the said amount. The<br /> enhanced compensation be paid to the appellant within a period<br /> of twelve weeks from today. If the details of the appellant’s bank<br /> Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No.19981 of 2025 Page 7<br /><br /> account are available with the Claims Tribunal, the amount be<br /> credited therein accordingly. The Civil Appeal is allowed in<br /> aforesaid terms with no order as to costs. Pending application(s),<br /> if any, shall also stand disposed of. <br /> …..………………………..J.<br /> [ RAJESH BINDAL ]<br /> .…..………………………..J.<br /> [ ATUL S. CHANDURKAR ]<br /> NEW DELHI,<br /> FEBRUARY 17, 2026. <br /> Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No.19981 of 2025 Page 8</div>