Dr Umesh Chandra Garga vs HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
Central Admi
inistrative Tribunal
Bench, New Delhi
Principal B

O.A. No. 2806/202

24 with M.A. No. 2237/202
25
th
This the 30
h
day of October, 2026
Hon’ble Mr. Manish Gar

g, Member (J)
Dr. Umesh Chandra Garga Age
Late Shri Parmanand Garga R/o
K-71 2nd Floor, Hauz Khas En
ed about 67 years S/o
o Parma Nand Garga,
nclave, Delhi-110016

(By Advocate: Mr. Mudit Gupt
...Applican
ta, Ms. Priya Agarwal)
nt

V
Versus

1. Union of India Ministry o
of Health and Family
Secretary, Room no.
Welfare, Through its S
201-D, Nirman Bhawan N

2. Dr. Ram Manohar Lohi
New Delhi - 110011
ia Hospital Through
Medical Superintendent
Rd, Ram Manohar Lohi
Connaught Place - Delhi

Baba Kharak Singh
a Hospital, Type III,
110001
...Responde

wal, Mr. Arun Mr. Sourabh Rai)
ents.

(By Advocate: Mr. Jalaj Agarw














Pa
age 1 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
ORDE
ER (ORAL)

Hon’ble Mr. M
Manish Garg, Member (J):-
-

M.
.A. No. 2237/2025
The present Miscellane
eous Application has been
filed by
the
e applicant seeking permissi
ion to place on record the a
amended
Me
emo of Parties.
2.
For the reasons state
ed in the application, M
M.A. No.
223
37/2025 is allowed . The am
mended Memo of Parties is t
taken on
rec
cord.
O.A
A. No. 2806/2024
In the present Original
Application, filed under Se
ection 19
of
the Administrative Tribun
nals Act, 1985, the applic
cant has
pra
ayed for the following relief
fs:
“a) Pass an order directing
per annum on the Earned L
01.07.2021 to 01.09.2022;
due till the date of actual pa
g the Respondents to pay intere
est at 18%
Leave Encashment of the Appli
cant from
me became
i.e the date on which the sam
ayment thereof;
b) Pass an order directing
per annum on the Gratu
01.07.2021 to 11.08.2022,
due till the date of actual pa
g the Respondents to pay interes
st at 18%
cant from
me became
uity entitlement of the Applic
i.e the date on which the sam
ayment thereof,
c) Pass an order directing
per annum on the Comm
Applicant from 01.07.2021
same became due till the da
g the Respondents to pay interes
st at 18%
nt of the
which the
mutation of Pension entitlemen
to 03.08.2022. i.e the date on
ate of actual payment thereof;
d) Pass any other order w
and proper under the facts
which this Hon'ble Tribunal thin
nks is just
”
and circumstances of the case.”
Pa
age 2 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
2.
Highlighting the facts
of the case, learned coun
nsel for the
app
plicant submits that the ap
pplicant was working as a
a Consultant
(Ca
ardiology) at RML Hospital
l. An FIR bearing No. 04/2
2019 came to
be
registered under Section 3
306 of the Indian Penal Co
ode, 1860, in
con
nnection with the investig
gation into the alleged sui
icide of Dr.
Poo
onam Vohra, Consultant (R
Radiology). During the pen
dency of the
inv
vestigation, the applicant a
ttained the age of superan
nnuation and
reti
ired from service on 30.06.
.2021. Learned counsel fur
rther submits
tha
at, upon the applicant's sup
erannuation, the responden
nts issued an
Off
fice Order dated 06.08.202
21, whereby only his entitl
ement under
the
Central Government E
Employees Group Insuran
nce Scheme
(CG
GEGIS), amounting to Rs. 2
2,90,926/-, was released. Th
he remaining
reti
iral benefits, namely, gra
atuity, earned leave enca
ashment and
com
mmutation of pension, wer
re withheld on account of
the criminal
pro
oceedings pending against t
the applicant. Subsequently
y, the police
file
ed a Closure Report in th
he aforesaid criminal case,
, which was
acc
cepted by the learned Me
etropolitan Magistrate, Pa
atiala House
Cou
urts, New Delhi, vide order
r dated 17.12.2021.
3.
Learned counsel for the
applicant further submits t
that, in terms
of
the Office Order dated 06.
.08.2021, the remaining ret
tiral benefits
wer
re required to be relea
ased upon closure of th
he criminal
pro
oceedings. However, despit
te the closure of the crimin
nal case, the
Pa
age 3 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
resp
pondents failed to release
the said benefits within a
a reasonable
tim
me. In this regard, the appli
icant also addressed variou
us e-mails to
the
respondents on 17.08
.2021, 30.05.2022 and
01.06.2022,
req
questing release of his outst
anding retiral dues. It is sub
bmitted that,
not
twithstanding the closure
e of the criminal proc
ceedings on
17.
12.2021, the respondents
s released the retiral be
enefits only
bel
latedly and without payme
ent of any interest. The de
etails of the
pay
yments received by the appl
licant are as follows:
Ben
Co
Gra
Ear
nefit Amoun
mmutation of Pension Rs. 46,
atuity Rs. 20,
rned Leave Encashment Rs. 30,
nt Date of Rec
26,870/- 03.08.2022
00,000/- 11.08.2022
40,000/- 01.09.2022
ceipt
4.
Learned counsel for th
he applicant further submi
its that even
tho
ough the applicant has rec
ceived his share of retirem
ment benefits
from
m the hospital authoritie
es, however, the interest
on delayed
pay
yments has not been paid to
o him. In pursuance to this, t
the applicant
ma
ade a representation dated
d 23.03.2023 to the respo
ondent no.2,
clai
iming interest on his post r
retirement dues. However, t
the same has
not
t been considered till date.
5.
Opposing the grant
of relief, learned couns
sel for the
resp
pondents relies upon the av
verments made in the coun
nter affidavit.
He
has also taken us through t
the chronological sequence
e of events to
exp
plain the circumstances lead
ding to the delayed release
of the retiral
Pa
age 4 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
ben
nefits. It is submitted that, o
on 28.11.2020, the pension p
papers of the
app
plicant were uploaded on th
he e-Bhavishya portal and
the file was
forw
warded for vigilance clea
arance. Thereafter, on 03.1
12.2020, the
Vig
gilance Cell requested H
HA-I Section to furnish
information
reg
garding the issuance of any
y charge-sheet in connectio
on with FIR
No
. 04/2019 dated 07.02.201
9, registered under Section
n 306 of the
IPC
C at Police Station North A
Avenue, Delhi, in relation to
o the suicide
of
Dr. Poonam Vohra, Con
nsultant (Radiology). Learn
rned counsel
furt
ther submits that reminder
r letters dated 02.03.2021,
, 29.04.2021
and
d 27.05.2021 were address
sed to the SHO, Police St
tation North
Av
venue, seeking the status of t
the aforesaid FIR. In respon
nse thereto, a
com
mmunication dated 11.06
.2021 was received from
m the SHO,
info
forming the hospital that th
e names of Shri U.C. Garg
ga, Shri Anil
Tan
neja and Smt. Shibani M
Mehra had figured in the i
investigation
con
ncerning the death of Dr. P
Poonam Vohra. It was furth
her intimated
tha
at the final report, by way
y of a Closure Report, had
d been filed
bef
fore the Court of the lea
arned Metropolitan Magist
trate, Patiala
Ho
use Courts, New Delhi,
and that the matter w
was pending
con
nsideration, with the next da
ate of hearing fixed for 30.1
11.2021. It is
furt
ther submitted that, in th
he absence of vigilance
clearance, a
com
mmunication dated 06.08.20
021 was issued to the Pay a
and Accounts
Off
fice for sanction of provisio
onal pension. Accordingly,
the Pay and
Pa
age 5 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
Acc
counts Office issued the req
quisite authority for provisi
onal pension
on
09.08.2021. Learned coun
sel for the respondents fur
rther submits
tha
at, on 28.12.2021, Dr. U.C.
Garga, former Consultant,
submitted a
rep
presentation along with the
order dated 17.12.2021 pa
assed by the
lear
rned Patiala House Court
t, stating that the final re
eport/Closure
Rep
port in FIR No. 04/2019
9 dated 07.02.2019, regis
stered under
Sec
ction 306 of the IPC, h
had been accepted and t
the criminal
pro
oceedings had consequently
y been closed. The applica
ant requested
rele
ease of all his retiral bene
efits along with the Pensi
ion Payment
Ord
der (PPO). Pursuant theret
to, on 30.12.2021, the file
e was again
forw
warded to the Vigilance C
ell for obtaining vigilance
clearance in
vie
ew of the applicant's represe
entation dated 28.12.2021. H
However, on
07.
01.2022, the Vigilance Cel
ll returned the file with the
e observation
tha
at, as per the available reco
ords, a Committee had been
n constituted
und
der the Directorate Gener
ral of Health Services (D
DGHS) vide
Min
nistry of Health and Famil
y Welfare letters dated 07.
02.2019 and
08.
02.2019, and that the upda
ated status of the matter, alo
ong with the
inq
quiry report, if any, was req
quired before vigilance clea
arance could
be
considered.
6.
Learned counsel for th
e respondents further subm
mits that, on
14.
01.2022, a communication
was addressed to the Unde
er Secretary,
CH
HS-IV Section, Ministry of
f Health and Family Welf
fare, seeking
Pa
age 6 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
vig
gilance clearance and the up
pdated status of the matter
r, along with
the
inquiry report, if any. Sub
bsequently, an e-mail dated
d 10.02.2022
wa
s received from the concer
rned Section Officer, CHS-
IV, Ministry
of H
Health and Family Welfare
e, seeking details in Annex
xure-I for the
pur
rpose of processing the
vigilance clearance. Acco
ordingly, on
24.
02.2022, the requisite letter
r along with Annexure-I wa
as forwarded
to
the concerned Section O
Officer. Thereafter, on 06
6.05.2022, a
com
mmunication dated 02.05.2
022 was received from the
e Ministry of
Hea
alth and Family Welfare re
egarding vigilance clearanc
ce in respect
of
Dr. U.C. Garga, along wi
ith a copy of the Ministry
y's Vigilance
Sec
ction Office Memorandum d
dated 07.04.2022. On 10.05
5.2022, HA-I
Sec
ction forwarded the file t
to the Vigilance Cell alon
ng with the
afo
oresaid communication fo
or necessary action. Eve
entually, the
Vig
gilance Cell issued the
vigilance clearance ce
ertificate on
05.
07.2022. On 06.07.2022, th
he Medical Superintendent a
approved the
pro
ocessing of the pensionary/r
retiral benefits of the applic
cant, and the
dul
ly signed pension papers w
were forwarded to the Pay an
nd Accounts
Off
fice on 14.07.2022 for fu
further necessary action. I
It is further
sub
bmitted that a communic
cation dated 20.07.2022
was again
add
dressed to the Pay and Acco
ounts Office, intimating tha
at provisional
pen
nsion had been sanctioned
to the applicant up to Jun
ne 2022. The
pay
yment towards commutation
n of pension was thereafter
made by the
Pa
age 7 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
Pay
y and Accounts Office on
n 02.08.2022. Learned cou
unsel for the
resp
pondents further submits th
hat the applicant submitted
his No Dues
Cer
rtificate on 03.08.2022, pu
ursuant to which an Office
Order dated
04.
08.2022 was issued confirm
ming the clearance. Thereaf
fter, payment
of D
Death-cum-Retirement Gra
tuity (DCRG) was made by
y the Pay and
Acc
counts Office on 10.08.202
22. An Office Order dated
d 29.08.2022
wa
s also issued regarding relea
ase of earned leave encashm
ment, and the
cor
rresponding payment was m
made by the Pay and Accoun
nts Office on
31.
08.2022. It is, thus, conten
nded that the applicant furni
ished the No
Du
ues Certificate to the concern
ned Administrative Departm
ment only on
03.
08.2022 and that, in acco
ordance with the applicable
e procedure,
pay
yment of gratuity could
be released only after ob
btaining the
req
quisite No Dues Certificate
e from the applicant. Acco
ordingly, the
resp
pondents contend that th
he payment of DCRG w
was released
pro
omptly thereafter.
7.
During the course of he
earing, it was noticed that,
vide Record
of
Proceedings dated 03.09
.2026, this Tribunal had
passed the
foll
lowing directions:
“2. Learned proxy couns
instructions regarding the d
for the respondents that as p
02.08.2022 whereas in the
number 14 is blank.”
el for the applicant is direc
discrepancy pointed out by the le
cted to obtain
earned counsel
iven to them on
cant the serial
per the records the NOC was gi
e NOC furnished by the applic
Pa
age 8 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
8.
In compliance with the
aforesaid direction, a clar
rification has
bee
en placed on record by the
e applicant along with the
original No
Du
ues Certificate. The same is r
reproduced hereinbelow:

Pa
age 9 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
9.
A perusal of the aforesa
aid No Dues Certificate rev
veals that the
req
quisite clearances from vario
ous departments were recor
rded between
08.
07.2021 and 19.07.2021.
The controversy, howe
ver, centres
aro
ound Column No. 14 of the
said certificate, which was
s found to be
bla
ank and was specifically ad
dverted to in the Record of
Proceedings
dat
ted 03.09.2026. We shall d
deal with this aspect in the
e subsequent
par
rt of this order.
10.
In rejoinder to the argu
uments put forth by the lear
rned counsel
for
the respondents, learned co
ounsel for the applicant sub
bmits that the
Pay
y and Accounts Office
had already been requ
uested, vide
com
mmunication dated 27.07.20
022, to release the admissib
le payments.
It i
s, therefore, contended that
t the subsequent plea of the
e respondents
tha
at the No Dues Certificate
e was furnished only on
03.08.2022,
ow
wing to the alleged non-ha
anding over of the keys,
is of little
con
nsequence and cannot justify
fy the delay in processing th
he applicant's
reti
iral dues.
11.
Learned counsel for th
he applicant places relianc
ce upon the
jud
dgment of the Hon'ble Sup
preme Court in S.K. Dua
a v. State of
Ha
aryana and Another , (2008
) 3 SCC 44, in support of h
his claim for
inte
erest on delayed payment of
f retiral benefits.

Pag
ge 10 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
12.
Learned counsel for the
e applicant has also drawn m
my attention
to
Rule 68 of the CCS (Pen
sion) Rules, 1972, which
provides for
pay
yment of interest on delay
yed release of gratuity in
cases where
dep
partmental or judicial p
proceedings are pending
against a
Go
vernment servant on th
he date of his retiremen
nt and the
Go
vernment servant is subseq
quently fully exonerated. Fo
or the sake of
rea
ady reference, the relevant p
provision is reproduced here
ein below:
“ 68. GOVERNME
ENT OF INDIA’S DECISIONS
S
(1) Admissibility of intere
judicial/departmental proce
est on gratuity allowed after
conclusion of
eedings -
1. Under the rules, gratuity
case of a Government serv
finalizing pension and deat
onwards
y becomes due immediately on
retirement. In
d time-table for
ant dying in service a detailed
th gratuity has been laid down
n vide Rule 77
2. Where disciplinary or j
servant are pending on the d
the conclusion of the pro
thereon. The gratuity if allo
on the conclusion of the pro
the date of issue of orders by
judicial proceedings against a
date of his retirement. no gratui
a Government
ity is paid until
ceedings and the issue of the
owed to be drawn by the compe
oceedings will be deemed to have
e final orders
etent authority
e fallen due on
y the competent authority.
3. In order to mitigate the h
the conclusion of the pro
decided that the interest on
also be allowed in their
instructions. In other words
have fallen due on the da
purpose of payment on in
benefit of these instructions
Government servants who d
proceedings against them
consequently dropped.
hardship to the Government ser
oceedings are fully exonerated
rvants who. on
d. it has been
nt gratuity may
n delayed payment of retiremen
cases. in accordance with
s, in such cases. the gratuity wil
the aforesaid
ll be deemed to
rement for the
f gratuity. The
ate following the date of retir
nterest on delayed payment of
s will however not be available
die during the pendency of judici
to such of the
ial/disciplinary
oceedings are
m and against whom pro
Pag
ge 11 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
13.
Learned counsel for th
e respondents, in response
e, has drawn
my
y attention to the Office O
rder dated 04.08.2022, wh
hich reads as
und
der:
“No Dues Certificate in r
Consultant (Radiology) of
various departments of thi
against Dr. Umesh Chand
time of retirement on atta
30.06.2021 except Govt. Acc
respect of Dr. Umesh Chandr
f this hospital has been obtai
ra Garga, Ex-
ined from the
ng outstanding
diology) at the
is hospital and there is nothin
dra Garga, Ex-Consultant (Rad
aining age (65 years) of super
rannuation on
commodation.”
14.
We have heard learned
d counsel for the parties a
and carefully
per
rused the pleadings and mat
terial available on record. T
The principal
que
estion that arises for cons
sideration is whether the
applicant is
ent
titled to interest on account
of delayed release of his re
etiral benefits
and
d, if so, the period for which
h such interest is payable. A
At the outset,
we
may advert to the No Du
ues Certificate placed on re
ecord by the
app
plicant. As noticed hereinab
bove, the controversy prim
marily relates
to C
Column No. 14 thereof, wh
hich was stated to be blank
k in the copy
ava
ailable with the responden
nts. During the course of
f arguments,
lear
rned counsel for the respon
ndents clarified that the sign
nature of the
Reg
gistrar was available again
nst the said column, beari
ing the date
02.
08.2022, and, therefore, the
e column could not be treat
ted as blank.
Ho
wever, we also take no
ote of the handwritten
endorsement
app
pearing below the signatur
re of the Registrar, dated
14.07.2021,
wh
hich reads as follows:
Pag
ge 12 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
“As per direction of HS the
room to PS to Director on th
incumbent is required to submi
he last date of working.”
it the key of the
15.
A plain reading of the a
aforesaid endorsement indic
cates that the
Reg
gistrar had taken the view
that the No Dues Certific
ate could be
issu
ued only upon the applican
nt handing over the key of
f the room to
the
PS to the Director on his
s last working day. Howev
ver, the said
end
dorsement does not take in
nto account the undisputed
fact that the
app
plicant had already superan
nnuated on 30.06.2021. In
other words,
the
requirement of handing o
over the key on the last w
working day
oug
ght to have been assessed
with reference to the appli
icant's actual
dat
te of superannuation. Had
d the applicant continued
d in service
bey
yond the stipulated date and
d failed to hand over the ke
ey on his last
wo
rking day, the contention o
of the respondents might h
have merited
con
nsideration. However, such
is not the factual position in
n the present
cas
se.
16.
We now proceed to exam
mine whether the delay in r
release of the
reti
iral benefits can be justifie
d in the facts and circumst
tances of the
pre
esent case, particularly in vi
iew of the submissions adva
anced by the
resp
pondents regarding the p
ending criminal proceedin
ngs and the
sub
bsequent requirement of o
obtaining vigilance clearan
nce. In this
reg
gard, the chronological seq
quence of events placed b
before us by
lear
rned counsel for the resp
ondents assumes significa
ance. As per
the
ir own showing, a commun
nication dated 11.06.2021 w
was received
Pag
ge 13 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
from
m the SHO, Police Station
n North Avenue, informing
the hospital
tha
at the applicant's name had
figured in the investigation
n concerning
the
death of Dr. Poonam
Vohra. Thereafter, the ap
pplicant, on
28.
12.2021, submitted a repr
resentation along with the
order dated
17.
12.2021 passed by the lear
rned Patiala House Court, in
nforming the
resp
pondents that the Closure
Report in FIR No. 04/20
19 had been
acc
cepted and the criminal pro
oceedings had accordingly
come to an
end
d. Pursuant thereto, the mat
tter was again referred to th
he Vigilance
Cel
ll on 30.12.2021 for obtaini
ing the requisite vigilance cl
learance.
17.
We find that, despite th
he closure of the criminal
proceedings
and
d the applicant having br
rought the same to the n
otice of the
resp
pondents, the requisite vig
gilance clearance was ultim
mately issued
onl
ly on 05.07.2022. The perio
od between 30.12.2021 and
d 05.07.2022
wa
s substantially consumed
in obtaining administrativ
e clearances
and
d processing interdepartmen
ntal communications among
g the various
sec
ctions of the respondents.
In my opinion, the time c
consumed in
suc
ch interdepartmental corresp
pondence and administrativ
ve processing
can
nnot, in the facts of the pres
sent case, be attributed to th
he applicant.
On
nce the applicant had furnish
hed the requisite informatio
on regarding
clo
sure of the criminal proceed
dings, the respondents were
e expected to
tak
ke expeditious steps to co
omplete the remaining form
malities and
rele
ease his admissible retiral
benefits. We are also cons
scious of the
Pag
ge 14 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
fac
t that the applicant has reli
ied upon Rule 68 of the CC
CS (Pension)
Rul
les, 1972, as well as the jud
dgment of the Hon'ble Supre
eme Court in
S.K
K. Dua (supra). The aforesa
aid judgment recognises the
e entitlement
of a
a retired employee to claim
m interest on delayed paym
ent of retiral
due
es, subject to the applicable
e rules and the facts and ci
ircumstances
of t
the case.
18.
Having regard to the f
factual matrix, particularly
the date on
wh
hich the criminal proceeding
gs came to an end, the subs
equent delay
in
obtaining vigilance clea
arance and the time co
onsumed in
adm
ministrative processing, we
e are of the considered vi
iew that the
app
plicant deserves to be grant
ted partial relief. According
gly, we hold
tha
at the applicant shall be enti
itled to interest on the delay
yed payment
of h
his retiral benefits for the p
period commencing from 01
1.01.2022 till
the
respective dates of actual
payment, at the rates appl
icable to the
Gen
neral Provident Fund (GP
PF). The respondents are
directed to
calc
culate and release the afor
resaid interest to the applic
cant within a
per
riod of two months from th
he date of receipt of a certi
ified copy of
this
s order. We have also consi
idered the contention of lear
rned counsel
for
the applicant that, sin
nce the applicant supera
annuated on
30.
06.2021 and the Closure R
Report had subsequently be
een accepted
by
the competent court, he
is entitled to interest fro
om the date
imm
mediately following his re
etirement. However, we ar
re unable to
Pag
ge 15 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT

Item No. 52 (Court-4)
O.A. No. 2806/2024
acc
cept the said contention in it
ts entirety, having regard to
o the peculiar
fac
ts and circumstances of th
he present case, particularly
y the dispute
con
ncerning the handing over o
of the keys and the fact that
the criminal
pro
oceedings came to an end o
only on 17.12.2021. We, th
herefore, find
no j
justification for extending t
the period of interest to the
entire period
com
mmencing from the date of
superannuation.
19.
In view of the above, th
he Original Application is di
isposed of in
the
aforesaid terms. All pendi
ing Miscellaneous Applicat
tions, if any,
sha
all also stand disposed of ac
ccordingly. There shall be n
no order as to
cos
sts.




(Manish
h Garg)
mber (J)

Mem


/sb/
Pag
ge 16 of 16

SURAJ
BISHT
SURAJ
BISHT