Sudhir Kumar Hundet vs Mp Madhya Kshetra Vidyut Vitrana Companay Ltd
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:60013
1 WA-369-2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANAND PATHAK
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE B. P. SHARMA
rd
ON THE 3 OF AUGUST, 2026
WRIT APPEAL No. 369 of 2024
SUDHIR KUMAR HUNDET
Versus
MP MADHYA KSHETRA VIDYUT VITRANA COMPANY LTD AND
OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Hemant Shrivastava - Senior Advocate assisted by Shri Rajiv
Mishra - Advocate for the appellant.
Shri Harpreet Singh Gupta - Advocate for the respondents No.1 and 2.
Shri Rajesh Tiwari - Government Advocate for the respondent
No.3/State.
ORDER
Per: Justice B. P. Sharma
With consent, heard finally.
This appeal under Section 2(1) of the Madhya Pradesh Uchcha
Nyayalaya (Khand Nyayapeeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 has been
preferred by the appellant assailing the order dated 03.01.2024 passed by
learned Single Judge in Writ Petition No.20198/2020 (Sudhir Kumar Hundet
Vs. MPMKVVC and Others) whereby the writ petition challenging the order
dated 15.10.2019 withholding the appellant's pension was dismissed.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
JAIN
Signing time: 8/17/2026
6:28:54 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:60013
2 WA-369-2024
2. The appellant, Sudhir Kumar Hundet, was employed as a Junior
Engineer in Madhya Pradesh Madhya Kshetra Vidyut Vitaran Company
Limited (MPMKVVCL). While in service, a criminal case was registered
against him by Lokayukta Police vide Crime No.460/2014 alleging offences
under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988. During pendency of criminal trial, he attained the age
of superannuation and retired from service on 30.06.2017. Since the judicial
proceedings were still pending, respondent-Company sanctioned provisional
pension to him under Rules 9 and 64 of Madhya Pradesh Civil Services
(Pension) Rules, 1976 (hereinafter referred as to ‘Rules, 1976’) by order
dated 30.08.2017. Subsequently, by judgment dated 31.08.2019 passed by
the Special Judge (PC Act), Bhopal in Special Case No.40/2015, the
appellant was convicted for offences punishable under the aforesaid sections
and was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment with fine. The
appellant challenged the conviction by filing Criminal Appeal No.7505/2019
before High Court, which is pending for adjudication.
3. Thereafter, relying upon the conviction, the respondent No.2 passed
the order dated 15.10.2019 under Rule 8(2) of the Pension Rules, 1976
directing that the appellant's pension be withheld and consequently
discontinued the provisional pension that had earlier been sanctioned.
Aggrieved thereby, he filed W.P. No.20198/2020 seeking quashment of the
order dated 15.10.2019, release of pension and gratuity together with
interest. Learned Single Judge, however, dismissed the writ petition holding
that the respondents were justified in invoking Rule 8(2) of the Pension
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
JAIN
Signing time: 8/17/2026
6:28:54 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:60013
3 WA-369-2024
Rules after the appellant's conviction.
4. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant submitted that
learned Single Judge committed an error in affirming the order dated
15.10.2019 by overlooking the true scope of Rules 8, 9 and 64 of the Rules,
1976. It is argued that the appellant had already retired during the pendency
of criminal proceedings, therefore, his case was governed by Rule 9 read
with Rule 64 and not Rule 8(2) of the Rules, 1976, under which provisional
pension had rightly been sanctioned. Once provisional pension had been
granted under Rule 64, the respondents could not subsequently invoke Rule
8(2) to withdraw the same merely because appellant was convicted in trial.
5. It is further contended that Rule 8(2) applies only to pension granted
after retirement and contemplates future good conduct of a pensioner,
whereas the appellant's case squarely fell within Rule 8(3) and Rule 9
governing judicial proceedings pending against a retired employee. The
competent authority under Rule 9 is the Governor or the Full Board of the
respondent-Company and not respondent No.2, who lacked jurisdiction to
withhold the pension. It is argued that the criminal appeal against conviction
is a continuation of the original proceedings and since Criminal Appeal
No.7505/2019 has been admitted and the sentence has been suspended, the
judicial proceedings cannot be said to have attained finality. Consequently,
the appellant remained entitled to provisional pension until the criminal
appeal is finally decided.
6. It is further submitted that the respondents illegally withheld not only
the pension but also the gratuity without passing any independent order. It is
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
JAIN
Signing time: 8/17/2026
6:28:54 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:60013
4 WA-369-2024
contended that under Rule 64, gratuity could at best remain deferred during
the pendency of trial and, after conclusion of the trial; the appellant became
entitled to its release together with interest. On these submissions, it is
prayed that the order of learned Single Judge as well as the order
withholding pension be set aside and the respondents be directed to restore
pension and release gratuity with consequential benefits.
7. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents contended that the
appellant stands convicted by the competent Court for serious offences under
the PC Act, 1988 and such conviction constitutes sufficient ground for
exercise of power under Rule 8(2) of the Rules, 1976.It was argued that Rule
8(2) specifically authorises the pension sanctioning authority to withhold or
withdraw pension where a pensioner is convicted of a serious crime.
Suspension of sentence by the appellate court does not obliterate the
conviction and, therefore, pendency of the criminal appeal cannot confer any
right upon the appellant to continue receiving pension.
8. The respondents further submitted that provisional pension sanctioned
under Rule 64 was payable only till the stage when the criminal proceedings
culminated in conviction. Once the appellant was convicted, the respondents
were legally justified in discontinuing provisional pension and invoking Rule
8(2). It is also contended that the appellant had no enforceable right to claim
gratuity during the pendency of criminal appeal and learned Single Judge
rightly held that payment of gratuity was governed by the provisions of the
Pension Rules; therefore, no ground for interference in appeal was made out.
9. Heard counsel for the parties and have carefully perused the record.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
JAIN
Signing time: 8/17/2026
6:28:54 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:60013
5 WA-369-2024
10. We have no hesitation in holding that the conviction of appellant
under the PC Act, involving corruption, involves moral turpitude and
constitutes grave misconduct. Such conduct strikes at the very foundation of
public service and directly attracts the doctrine of "future good conduct"
embodied in Rule 8 of the Pension Rules. Pension is undoubtedly a statutory
right; nevertheless, it remains subject to the conditions prescribed by the
statute itself. Rule 8(2) expressly authorises withholding or withdrawal of
pension upon conviction for a serious crime and, therefore, the action of the
respondents is firmly rooted in statutory authority.
11. Learned Single Judge has rightly held that Rules 8 and 9 of the Rules,
1976 operate in distinct fields. Rule 9 governs cases where departmental or
judicial proceedings are pending against a retired employee and empowers
grant of provisional pension during the pendency of such proceedings.
However, once the judicial proceedings culminate in a judgment of
conviction for a serious crime, the matter ceases to be governed by Rule 9
and squarely falls within the ambit of Rule 8(2), which specifically
empowers the pension sanctioning authority to withhold or withdraw pension
where the pensioner is convicted of a serious crime or found guilty of grave
misconduct. Rule 8 further declares that future good conduct is an implied
condition for grant and continuance of pension. Thus, the statutory scheme
itself contemplates a distinction between a pending judicial proceeding and a
concluded criminal trial resulting in conviction.
12. The appellant's submission that Rule 9 alone would continue to govern
the matter till disposal of the criminal appeal cannot be accepted. Though, a
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
JAIN
Signing time: 8/17/2026
6:28:54 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:60013
6 WA-369-2024
criminal appeal may be a continuation of criminal proceedings for certain
purposes, the conviction recorded by the competent criminal court continues
to operate unless it is stayed or set aside by appellate court. In the present
case, admittedly only the sentence has been suspended by order dated
03.10.2019; the conviction itself has neither been stayed nor obliterated.
Consequently, the statutory consequence flowing from Rule 8(2) became
operative immediately upon conviction and the respondents were fully
justified in exercising the power vested under the Rules.
13. The further submission that the respondents ought to have initiated
separate proceedings or afforded a prior opportunity of hearing before
withholding pension is equally devoid of merit. The issue is no longer res
integra. Learned Single Judge has rightly relied upon Larger Bench decision
of this Court in Lal Saheb Bairagi Vs. State of M.P. & Others (Writ Petition
No.16549/2016) wherein it has been held that where action is taken under
Rule 8(2) after conviction of a pensioner for a serious crime, the elaborate
procedure contemplated under Rule 8(3) stands expressly excluded and no
prior notice is required to be issued. The Larger Bench has held that Rule
8(2) and Rule 8(3) occupy different fields and the principles of natural
justice cannot be read into Rule 8(2) in view of the express statutory
exclusion.
14. Learned Single Judge has further noticed that while exercising powers
under Rule 8(2), the competent authority is required to examine the judgment
of conviction and determine whether the conduct leading to conviction
warrants withholding or withdrawal of pension. Such consideration is to be
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
JAIN
Signing time: 8/17/2026
6:28:54 PM
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:60013
7 WA-369-2024
made on the basis of the criminal court judgment itself and not after
conducting a fresh enquiry. This proposition has been accepted by the Larger
Bench by placing reliance upon the Constitution Bench judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India vs. Tulsiram Patel (1985) 3 SCC
398, wherein it has been held that in exceptional situations the principles of
natural justice may stand excluded by statutory provision.
15. We also concur with the view taken by learned Single Judge that no
direction for release of gratuity can be issued. Rule 64 itself contemplates
that gratuity shall remain subject to the outcome of departmental or judicial
proceedings. The appellant cannot claim release of gratuity contrary to the
statutory scheme when the proceedings have culminated in his conviction
and the consequences under Rule 8(2) have already come into operation.
16. In view of the foregoing discussion, we are of the considered opinion
that learned Single Judge has rightly upheld the order dated 15.10.2019
withholding the appellant's pension consequent upon his conviction under
the PC Act, 1988. The appellant has failed to demonstrate that Rule 8(2) of
the Rules, 1976 was wrongly invoked or that the impugned action suffers
from any legal infirmity.
17. Accordingly, finding no merit in the present writ appeal, the same
deserves to be and is hereby dismissed.
(ANAND PATHAK)
(B. P. SHARMA)
JUDGE
JUDGE
@shish^
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
JAIN
Signing time: 8/17/2026
6:28:54 PM