Suber Ahmed vs State Of Haryana Etc.

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

-1-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
*
226
Date of Decision: 18.11.2026

1. RFA-1048-2022 (O&M) with XOBJR-37-2023 (O&M)
SUBER AHMAD
…Appellant
Versus

STATE OF HARYANA & OTHERS
…Respondents
And

Sr.
No.
Case No. Appellant(s) Respondent(s)

2. RFA-1049-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-42-2023
(O&M)
NARESH ALIAS
NARESH GARG &
OTHERS
STATE OF HARYANA
& OTHERS

3. RFA-1050-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-28-2023
(O&M)
SHAHEED AHMED @
SAEED AHMED &
OTHERS
STATE OF HARYANA
& OTHERS

4. RFA-1051-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-26-2023
(O&M)
MOHAMMAD HASAN STATE OF HARYANA
& OTHERS

5. RFA-1052-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-35-2023
(O&M)
SANJAY GARG & STATE OF HARYANA
OTHERS & OTHERS

6. RFA-1053-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-39-2023
(O&M)
RAM KISHAN
(DECEASED)
THROUGH LRS
STATE OF HARYANA
& OTHERS

7. RFA-1054-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-36-2023
(O&M)
NAZAR MOHD.
(DECEASED)
THROUGH LRS &
OTHERS
STATE OF HARYANA
& OTHERS

8. RFA-1055-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-29-2023
(O&M)
ABDUL REHMAN
(DECEASED)
THROUGH LRS &
OTHERS
STATE OF HARYANA
& OTHERS

9. RFA-1056-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-40-2023
(O&M)
NASSIR AHMED
(DECEASED)
THROUGH LRS
STATE OF HARYANA
& OTHERS

10. RFA-1057-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-31-2023
(O&M)
NAZAR MOHAMMAD
(DECEASED)
THROUGH LRS &
OTHERS
STATE OF HARYANA
& OTHERS

11. RFA-1058-2022 (O&M) SUSHILA @ SUSHILA STATE OF HARYANA
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-2-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-41-2023 DEVI & OTHERS
(O&M)

12. RFA-1059-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-25-2023
(O&M)
DEENA & OTHERS STATE OF HARYANA
& OTHERS

13. RFA-1060-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-48-2023
(O&M)
PARVINDER SINGH & STATE OF HARYANA
OTHERS & OTHERS

14. RFA-1061-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-43-2023
(O&M)
VIDYA DEVI @ BIDYA STATE OF HARYANA
DEVI & OTHERS & OTHERS

15. RFA-1062-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-52-2023
(O&M)
NOOR MOHAMMAD & STATE OF HARYANA
OTHERS & OTHERS

16. RFA-1065-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-53-2023
(O&M)
AAMEEN KHAN @
AAMIN (DECEASED)
THROUGH LRS
STATE OF HARYANA
& OTHERS

17. RFA-1085-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-49-2023
(O&M)
IBRAHIM STATE OF HARYANA
& ANOTHER

18. RFA-1086-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-46-2023
(O&M)
ALLADIN
(DECEASED)
THROUGH LRS &
OTHERS
STATE OF HARYANA
& ANOTHER

19. RFA-1087-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-51-2023
(O&M)
HARUN @ HAROON STATE OF HARYANA
& ANOTHER

20. RFA-1088-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-34-2023
(O&M)
TEK CHAND GUPTA STATE OF HARYANA
@ TEK CHAND & OTHERS

21. RFA-1094-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-38-2023
(O&M)
NIHALA (DECEASED) STATE OF HARYANA
THROUGH LRS & OTHERS

22. RFA-1108-2022 (O&M)
with XOBJR-33-2023
(O&M)
GOVIND PARSAD
ALIAS GOVIND
PRASAD & OTHERS
STATE OF HARYANA
& OTHERS

23. RFA-47-2023 (O&M)
with XOBJR-27-2023
(O&M)
KHUDA BUX ALIAS
KHUDA BAKSH &
OTHERS
STATE OF HARYANA
& OTHERS

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JAGMOHAN BANSAL

Present:- Mr. Ashish Aggarwal, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Pavan Malik, Advocate (through V.C.) and
Mr. Saket Bhandari, Advocate for appellant(s)

Mr. Abhinash Jain, Additional Advocate General, Haryana

*
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-3-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)

JAGMOHAN BANSAL, J. (ORAL)

1. These appeals under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 (for short ‘1894 Act’) are directed against awards passed by learned
Additional District Judge, Nuh (hereinafter called as ‘Reference Court’). The
landowners are seeking enhancement of amount of compensation whereas
the State is claiming otherwise.

2. As common issues are involved in the captioned appeals and
cross-objections, with the consent of both sides, the same are hereby
disposed of by this common order. For the sake of brevity and convenience,
facts are borrowed from RFA-1048-2022 .

3. The State Government issued notification dated 01.08.2011
under Section 4 of the 1894 Act for the acquisition of 20.86 Acres land
situated in two Villages i.e. Nalhar and Nuh, District Mewat for the
construction of New Express Road leading from Gurgaon-Alwar Road to
Medical College. The said notification was followed by notification dated
14.10.2011 issued under Section 6 of 1894 Act.

4. The Land Acquisition Collector (for short ‘Collector’) vide
award dated 30.12.2011, in terms of provisions of 1894 Act, determined
compensation payable to the landowners. Market value of the acquired land
₹ ₹
was determined @ 20,00,000/- per acre for Village Nalhar and 38,00,000/-
per acre for Village Nuh. Landowners were held entitled to solatium and
other statutory benefits. Feeling dis-satisfied from the aforesaid awards,
landowners preferred petitions before the Collector which were referred to
the Court under Section 18 of the 1894 Act.
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-4-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)

5. The landowners as well as State, in support of their contentions,
led their evidence. State attempted to justify market value determined by the
Collector, however, landowners vehemently pleaded that value of their land
has been assessed on lower side.

6. The Reference Court while appreciating evidence led by the
landowners, by impugned awards adjudicated reference petitions. The
Reference Court by impugned award dated 02.04.2022 has assessed market
₹
value of the land in question @ 60,50,000/- per acre for Village Nalhar and
₹
72,60,000/- for Village Nuh.

7. Tabulated details of the assessment made till date read as: -
Date of notification under Section 4 01.08.2011
Date of notification under Section 6 14.10.2011
Purpose of acquisition Construction of New Express Road leading
from Gurgaon-Alwar Road to Medical
College, Nalhar, Mewat
Location Villages - Nalhar & Nuh
District - Mewat
Area (Total in Acres) 20.86
Date of Collector (LAC) Award 30.12.2011
₹
Market value as per LAC ( per acre) 20,00,000/- (Nalhar)
38,00,000/- (Nuh)
Date of Reference Court (RC) Award 02.04.2022
₹
Market value as per RC ( per acre) 60,50,000/- (Nalhar)
72,60,000/- (Nuh)


8. Mr. Ashish Aggarwal learned Senior Advocate appearing for
the landowners submits that the Reference Court has rightly preferred sale
deed dated 08.07.2011 (Ex. P-40) than sale deeds Exhibits R-11, R-12 &
R-13 executed on 23.02.2011 & 05.07.2011. Exhibit P-40 was executed on
08.07.2011 and notification under Section 4 was issued on 01.08.2011. Sale
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-5-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
deed Ex. P-40 was much close to the date of notification under Section 4
than other sale deeds, thus, Court was bound to rely upon Ex. P-40. The
Reference Court has made glaring mistake while imposing 70% cut. As land
comprised in Ex. P-40 is situated within the municipal limits and area
involved is 456 Sq. yards, the Court could impose cut, however, 70% is
unjustified. The Reference Court has wrongly considered that there should
be development cut because the State has to develop an express road which
requires expenses for raising the level of ground, construction of road,
installation of poles, wires, divider and drainage system. The landowners are
least concerned with the mode & manner of the utilization of the acquired
land. Cost of future development cannot be ground to impose cut over the
available value. The acquired land is situated close to the offices of
Irrigation, Health, BDO, SDM and Court complex. This shows that land was
potential and value could not be determined applying aforesaid 70% cut.

9. Mr. Pavan Malik, Advocate appearing for the landowners
submits that another piece of land of the Village Nuh was acquired in 2009
₹
and the Reference Court has determined market price @ 1,85,14,286/- per
acre. In the aforesaid case 10% cut has been applied. In the present case, land
was acquired in August’ 2011, thus, escalation @ 12% per annum is required
to be extended. If escalation of 2 years is granted, the market value of the
₹
acquired land would come to more than 2 crore per acre. In 1981, the area
in question, under Section 4 of the Punjab Scheduled Roads and Controlled
Areas Restriction of Unregulated Development Act, 1963 (for short ‘1963
Act’) was declared as controlled area. The notification was extended in 1990.
The State in Draft Development Plan of 2005 has shown land in question as
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-6-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
part of the residential zone. As per award passed by the Collector, there was
construction in the part of acquired land which shows that the land was used
for residential purpose.

10. Per contra , learned State counsel submits that the Reference
Court has wrongly relied upon sale deed Ex. P-40. The sale deeds submitted
by the State are more reliable because of proximity and size. Exhibits R-11,
R-12 & R-13 cannot be ignored. Land comprised in Exhibits R-11, R-12 &
R-13 is 2420 Sq. yards each. Market value as per Ex. R-11 & R-12 comes to
₹ ₹
36 lakh per acre and 50 lakh per acre as per Ex. R-13. The Reference Court
has mechanically ignored sale deeds produced by the State particularly
Exhibits R-11, R-12 & R-13. The acquired land was agricultural land and
relied upon sale deed Ex. P-40 comprised residential property. The acquired
land is situated outside the municipal limits whereas Ex. P-40 is situated
within the municipal limits. Land comprised in Ex. R-13 is situated at 100
meters away from the starting point of the acquired land. Land comprised in
Ex. R-11 & R-12 is situated outside the municipal limits and within 250
meters from the starting point of the acquired land. Land comprised in
Ex. P-40, as per aerial distance, is situated at 950 meters away from the
acquired land. Walking distance comes much more.

11. Learned counsel for the parties are ad idem that delay in filing
any appeal/cross-objections which is part of present bunch may be condoned.
Accordingly, delay, if any, in any case, stands condoned. The landowners
shall not be entitled to interest for the delayed period.
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-7-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)

12. All the arguments raised by both sides were recorded in the
presence of counsel for the parties. They did not raise any other argument.

13. Heard the arguments and perused the record.

14. From the perusal of record, it is evident that the Reference Court
₹
has relied upon sale deed Ex. P-40 disclosing market price @ 2,42,11,000/-
per acre. The Court with respect to Village Nuh has imposed 70% cut and
75% in case of Village Nalhar. The Court has considered multiple reasons
while imposing aforesaid cut. The Court has not imposed cut on account of
one reason whereas Court has assigned eight reasons. Few of them may be
irrelevant but all the reasons are not irrelevant. The landowners are claiming
that quantum of cut should be reduced. They are relying upon award which
was passed with respect to acquisition effectuated in 2009. For the
₹
acquisition of 2009, the market price was determined @ 1,85,14,286/- per
acre.

15. The Supreme Court in Manoj Kumar & Ors. Vs. State of
Haryana & Anr., 2018 (13) SCC 96 has held that market value cannot be
mechanically determined as per previous award. As per judgment of
Supreme Court in Ram Krishan (Since Deceased) Vs. State of Haryana,
2025 SCC OnLine SC 715 previous award may be considered. It need not
be outrightly ignored. The Apex Court has made aforesaid observation after
noticing its earlier judgment in Manoj Kumar (supra) . The Apex Court in
Ram Kishan (supra) has held: -
“29. In Manoj Kumar (Supra) , this Court in Para
11,12,13,14 and 16 held as under.
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-8-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
"11. In our opinion, the High Court could not have
placed an outright reliance on Swaran Singh v. State
of Haryana, 2012 SCC Online P&H 19044 , without
considering the nature of transaction relied upon in
the said decision. The decision could not have been
applied ipso facto to the facts of the instant case. In
such cases, where such judgments/awards are relied
on as evidence, though they are relevant, but cannot
be said to be binding with respect to the determination
of the price, that has to depend on the evidence
adduced in the case. However, in the instant case, it
appears that the land in Swaran Singh case was
situated just across the road as observed by the High
Court as such it is relevant evidence but not binding.
As such it could have been taken into consideration
due to the nearness of the area, but at the same time
what was the nature of the transaction relied upon in
the said case was also required to be looked into in an
objective manner. Such decisions in other cases
cannot be adopted without examining the basis for
determining compensation whether sale transaction
referred to therein can be relied upon or not and what
was the distance, size and also bona fide nature of
transaction before such judgments/awards are relied
on for deciding the subsequent cases. It is not open to
accepting determination in a mechanical manner
without considering the merit. Such determination
cannot be said to be binding.
12. We have come across several decisions where the
High Court is adopting the previous decisions as
binding. The determination of compensation in each
case depends upon the nature of land and what is the
evidence adduced in each case, may be that better
evidence has been adduced in later case regarding the
actual value of property and subsequent sale deeds
after the award and before preliminary notification
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-9-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
under Section 4 are also to be considered, if filed. It is
not proper to ignore the evidence adduced in the case
at hand. The compensation cannot be determined by
blindly following the previous award/judgment. It has
to be considered only a piece of evidence, not beyond
that. The court has to apply the judicial mind and is
supposed not to follow the previous awards without
due consideration of the facts and circumstances and
evidence adduced in the case in question. The current
value reflected by comparable sale deeds is more
reliable and binding for determination of
compensation in such cases award/judgment relating
to an acquisition made before 5 to 10 years cannot
form the safe basis for determining compensation.
13. The awards and judgment in the cases of others
not being inter partes are not binding as precedents.
Recently, we have seen the trend of the courts to follow
them blindly probably under the misconception of the
concept of equality and fair treatment. The courts are
being swayed away and this approach in the absence
of and similar nature and situation of land is causing
more injustice and tantamount to giving equal
treatment in the case of unequals. As per situation of a
village, nature of land, its value differ from distance to
distance, even two to three kilometre distance may
also make the material difference in value. Land
abutting highway may fetch higher value but not land
situated in interior villages.
14. The previous awards/judgments are the only piece
of evidence on a par with comparative sale
transactions. The similarity of the land covered by
previous judgment/award is required to be proved like
any other comparative exemplar. In case previous
award/judgment is based on exemplar, which is not
similar or acceptable, previous award/judgment of
court cannot be said to be binding. Such determination
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-10-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
has to be outrightly rejected. In case some mistake has
been done in awarding compensation, it cannot be
followed; on the ground of parity an illegality cannot
be perpetuated. Such award/judgment would be
wholly irrelevant.
16. To base determination of compensation on a
previous award/judgment, the evidence considered in
the previous judgment/award and its acceptability on
judicial parameters has to be necessarily gone into,
otherwise, gross injustice may be caused to any of the
parties. In case some gross mistake or illegality has
been committed in previous award/judgment of not
making deduction, etc. and/or sufficient evidence had
not been adduced and better evidence is adduced in
case at hand, previous award/judgment being not inter
parties cannot be followed and if land is not similar in
nature in all aspects it has to be outrightly rejected as
done in the case of comparative exemplars. Sale deeds
are on a par for evidentiary value with such awards of
the court as court bases its conclusions on such
transaction only, to ultimately determine the value of
the property."
30. Even in Manoj Kumar (Supra) , this Court did
not hold that awards in other cases which are relevant
cannot be relied upon at all. What is held was such
awards will be relevant as a piece of evidence and not
be conclusive in nature.”
[Emphasis supplied]


16. In view of above-cited judgments, the previous award cannot
be mechanically relied upon. The landowners had cited exemplar sale deeds.
The State had also produced exemplar sale deeds. Previous award could be
considered, in the absence of exemplar sale deeds. In the case in hand, the
landowners and State had submitted 35 sale deeds which were executed
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-11-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
during 2010-11 and Section 4 notification was issued on 01.08.2011. In the
wake of availability of aforesaid number of sale deeds, there was no occasion
to rely upon previous award. This Court also does not deem it appropriate to
rely upon previous award. Matter needs to be adjudicated as per available
sale deeds.

17. During hearing, counsel for the parties primarily relied upon
sale deeds Exhibits P-40, R-11, R-12 & R13. Tabulated details of sale deeds
relied upon by the landowners and State during hearing read as: -

i. Sale deeds relied upon by the landowners: -
₹
Exhibit Sale deed Dated Area (In Sq. Total sale Value per acre ( )
₹
No. Yard) consideration ( )
P-40 1888 08.07.2011 456 22,80,000/- 2,42,11,000/-


ii. Sale deeds relied upon by the State: -
Sr. Ex. Sale deed Dated Area (In Sq. Total sale Value per acre
₹ ₹
No. No. yard) consideration ( ) ( )
1. R-11 3329 23.02.2011 2420 18,00,000/- 36,00,000/-
2. R-12 3330 23.02.2011 2420 18,00,000/- 36,00,000/-
3. R-13 1830 05.07.2011 2420 25,00,000/- 50,00,000/-


18. During the course of hearing, learned State counsel produced
site plan which is undisputed. As per site plan as well as sale deeds produced
by both sides, most of the sale deeds were executed with respect to land
situated within MC area. In the sale deeds, there is recital with respect to the
type of land. It is duly recorded in the sale deeds whether land is agricultural
or residential or commercial. In case of sale deeds comprising very small
area, it is duly mentioned in the sale deed that it is a shop e.g. area involved
in Ex. P-22 and P-35 is 30 Sq. yard and 25 Sq. yard respectively and these
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-12-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
are shops. Ex. P-40 has been relied upon by the Reference Court. The
landowners are also vehemently pleading that sale deed executed close to
Section 4 notification should be preferred than any other sale deed. It is only
sale deed Ex. P-40 which was executed one month prior to Section 4
notification. Ex. P-28 also comprises 500 Sq. yard area, however, it was
executed on 04.03.2011. Market price as per aforesaid sale deed comes to
₹
1,93,93,939/- per acre. Neither Reference Court has relied upon aforesaid
sale deed nor landowners wish to rely upon aforesaid sale deed, thus,
question remains of cut. The landowners are claiming that 70% cut is
unrealistic and unjustified.

19. The State vide notification dated 01.08.2011 has acquired 7.62
Acre land situated in Village Nuh and 13.24 Acre in Village Nalhar, District
Mewat. The exemplar sale deeds cannot be mechanically relied upon. It is
settled law that sale deeds comprising different type of land and comprising
small area cannot be made basis to determine market price of a large tract.
There is need to rationalize value declared in small pieces of land. In ‘Lal
Chand Vs. Union of India & Anr.’, (2009) 15 SCC 769 , Supreme Court has
laid down principles with respect to application of cut. The Court has
appreciated that land situated in industrial area cannot be at par with
commercial. Land situated in commercial area cannot be at par with
residential area. Land situated in residential area cannot be at par with
agricultural land. Unapproved colonies cannot be treated at par with
approved colonies. In case of approved colonies, area ear-marked for
different facilities is always much more than unapproved or unauthorized
colonies. The Court has held: -
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-13-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
“7. On careful consideration, we are of the view that such
allotment rates of plots adopted by Development Authorities
like DDA cannot form the basis for award of compensation
for acquisition of undeveloped lands for several reasons.
Firstly market value has to be determined with reference to
large tracts of undeveloped agricultural lands in a rural area,
whereas the allotment rates of development authorities are
with reference to small plots in a developed lay out falling
within Urbana. Secondly DDA and other statutory authorities
adopt different rates for plots in the same area with reference
to the economic capacity of the buyer, making it difficult to
ascertain the real market value, whereas market value
determination for acquisitions is uniform and does not
depend upon the economic status of the land loser. Thirdly
we are concerned with market value of freehold land,
whereas the allotment "rates" in the DDA Brochure refer to
the initial premium payable on allotment of plots on leasehold
basis. We may elaborate on these three factors.
8. First factor: The percentage of 'deduction for
development' to be made to arrive at the market value of large
tracts of undeveloped agricultural land (with potential for
development), with reference to the sale price of small
developed plots, varies between 20% to 75% of the price of
such developed plots, the percentage depending upon the
nature of development of the lay out in which the exemplar
plots are situated. The 'deduction for development' consists of
two components. The first is with reference to the area
required to be utilised for developmental works and the
second is the cost of the development works. For example if a
residential layout is formed by DDA or similar statutory
authority, it may utilise around 40% of the land area in the
layout, for roads, drains, parks, play grounds and civic
amenities (community facilities) etc. The Development
Authority will also incur considerable expenditure for
development of undeveloped land into a developed layout,
which includes the cost of levelling the land, cost of providing
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-14-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
roads, underground drainage and sewage facilities, laying
waterlines, electricity lines and developing parks and civil
amenities, which would be about 35% of the value of the
developed plot. The two factors taken together would be the
'deduction for development' and can account for as much as
75% of the cost of the developed plot. On the other hand, if
the residential plot is in an unauthorised private residential
layout, the percentage of 'deduction for development' may be
far less. This is because in an unauthorized lay outs, usually
no land will be set apart for parks, play grounds and
community facilities. Even if any land is set apart, it is likely
to be minimal. The roads and drains will also be narrower,
just adequate for movement of vehicles. The amount spent on
development work would also be comparatively less and
minimal. Thus the deduction on account of the two factors in
respect of plots in unauthorised layouts, would be only about
20% plus 20% in all 40% as against 75% in regard to DDA
plots. The 'deduction for development' with references to
prices of plots in authorised private residential layouts may
range between 50% to 65% depending upon the standards
and quality of the layout. The position with reference to
industrial layouts will be different. As the industrial plots will
be large (say of the size of one or two acres or more as
contrasted with the size of residential plots measuring 100
sq.m. to 200 sq.m.), and as there will be very limited civic
amenities and no playgrounds, the area to be set apart for
development (for roads, parks, playgrounds and civic
amenities) will be far less; and the cost to be incurred for
development will also be marginally less, with the result the
deduction to be made from the cost of a industrial plot may
range only between 45% to 55% as contrasted from 65 to
75% for residential plots. If the acquired land is in a semi-
developed urban area, and not an undeveloped rural area,
then the deduction for development may be as much less, that
is, as little as 25% to 40%, as some basic infrastructure will
already be available. (Note: The percentages mentioned
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-15-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
above are tentative standards and subject to proof to the
contrary).
9. Therefore the deduction for the 'development factor' to
be made with reference to the price of a small plot in a
developed lay out, to arrive at the cost of undeveloped land,
will be for more than the deduction with reference to the price
of a small plot in an unauthorized private lay out or an
industrial layout. It is also well known that the development
cost incurred by statutory agencies is much higher than the
cost incurred by private developers, having regard to higher
overheads and expenditure. Even among the layouts formed
by DDA, the percentage of land utilised for roads, civic
amenities, parks and play grounds may vary with reference
to the nature of layout - whether it is residential, residential-
cum-commercial or industrial; and even among residential
layouts, the percentage will differ having regard to the size of
the plots, width of the roads, extent of community facilities,
parks and play grounds provided. Some of the layouts formed
by statutory Development Authorities may have large areas
earmarked for water/sewage treatment plants, water tanks,
electrical sub-stations etc. in addition to the usual areas
earmarked for roads, drains, parks, playgrounds and
community/civic amenities. The purpose of the aforesaid
examples is only to show that the 'deduction for development'
factor is a variable percentage and the range of percentage
itself being very wide from 20% to 75%.
[Emphasis supplied]


20. In the case in hand, the acquired land was agricultural land as
per revenue record. The landowners are claiming that there was construction
over land which was abutting existing National Highway. It is apt to notice
that land in question was acquired to construct a road so that Medical College
may be connected to the National Highway. It was a linear acquisition and
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-16-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
total acquired land was more than 20 acres. As per revenue record, it was
agricultural land and in any case such a large tract cannot be assumed to be
a non-agricultural piece of land. Land situated within municipal limits may
also be agricultural land which is evident from the sale deed Ex. R-13.
Though land may be notified under Section 4 of 1963 Act yet it remains
agricultural till its status and utilization is not changed in the revenue record.
The land may be further falling within residential zone as per Draft
Development Plan. In any case, market value has to be determined on the
basis of sale deeds of the nearest vicinity area.
20.1 The acquired land is situated near to the Government offices
and District Court Complex, Nuh. Government offices and District Court
Complex fall within municipal limits whereas acquired land is situated
outside the municipal limits.
20.2 As per site plan as well as impugned award, the aerial distance
between Ex. P-40 and acquired land is 536 meters. The aforesaid distance is
aerial distance and as per State, actual aerial distance is almost one kilometer
because there are 16 Kilas in between the acquired land and Ex. P-40. It is
apt to notice that while adjudicating reference petitions of Village Nalhar,
the Reference Court has noticed 926 meters aerial distance. A perusal of site
plan reveals that Exhibits R-11, R-12 & R-13 are situated very close to the
acquired land whereas Ex. P-40 is located close to the Village Abadi. As per
impugned award, aerial distance between the acquired land and Ex. P-40 is
536 meters. The Court has relied upon Lay Out Sazra. There are 16 Kilas in
between the acquired land and Ex. P-40. The Court has not considered
walking distance which is more important than aerial while determining
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-17-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
location and type of the land. Land situated abutting the highway and having
front portion at highway is going to fetch substantially more price than land
abutting the highway but having front portion on the other side. The aerial
distance would be negligible, however, value would be substantially
different.

21. Sale deed (Ex. P-40) is comprising residential piece of land.
This fact has been duly recorded in the sale deed itself. Once in the sale deed
it is recorded that land in transaction is residential, there is no occasion to
treat aforesaid piece of land as agricultural. The area comprised in Ex. P-40
is 456 Sq. yard i.e. less than 1 Kanal. Area acquired of both the villages is
more than 20 Acres i.e. more than 320 Kanal. Ex. P-40 is situated within
municipal limits and it is close to Abadi. Plot is meant for residential
purpose. Type of construction is not recorded in the sale deed though type of
land is recorded as residential. As per judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Lal Chand (supra) , cut has to be imposed on account of size of the
exemplar sale deed as well as location and type of the land. Sale deed Ex. P-
40 comprises residential property, area involved is 456 Sq. yard and it is
located close to the Village Abadi. Area acquired is more than 20 Acres, it
is an agricultural land, thus, value disclosed in the sale deed Ex. P-40 is
required to be discounted on account of size, type of the land and location.
It is not clear whether Ex. P-40 comprises simple plot or there was
construction. Even if it is assumed that there was no construction, cut is
required to be imposed on account of aforesaid three factors i.e. type, size
and location. Due to aforesaid factors, as per judgment of Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Lal Chand (supra) , 70% cut is not unjustified.
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-18-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)

22. The matter needs to be examined from another angle. The
respondent-State produced multiple sale deeds, however, during hearing, the
State counsel has vehemently relied upon Exhibits R-11, R-12 & R-13.
Exhibits R-11 & R-12 are comprising land situated outside the municipal
limits, however, within 250 meters from the acquired land. The aforesaid
distance is not an aerial distance. Exhibit R-13 is situated within 100 meters
from the acquired land and it is falling within municipal limits. The
Reference Court has ignored Exhibits R-1 to R-12 on the ground that these
were executed much prior to the Section 4 notification. Exhibits R-11 &
R-12 were executed on 23.02.2011 and Section 4 notification was issued on
01.08.2011, thus, it cannot be concluded that these deeds were executed
much prior to the date of notification. It is true that sale deeds Ex. R-1 to
R-10 were executed during 2010, thus, could be ignored. Ex. R-11 & R-12
are comprising 2420 Sq. yards area each. The aforesaid area is much more
than area comprised in Ex. P-40. Both the sale deeds are comprising land
situated outside the municipal limits and close to the acquired land. Market
₹
price as per both sale deeds comes to 36 lakh per acre. Ex. R-13 was
₹
executed on 05.07.2011. Market price as per aforesaid deed comes to 50
lakh per acre and area comprised therein is 2420 Sq. yards. This deed
represents land situated within 100 meters from the acquired land. As per
sale deed, it is an agricultural land and falls within the municipal limits. The
Reference Court has rejected aforesaid sale deed on the ground that out of
₹ ₹
sale consideration of 25 lakh, a sum of 22 lakh was paid in the month of
March’ 2011 and June’ 2011. It shows that parties entered into transaction
in the month of March’ 2011 and sale deed was executed in July’ 2011. It is
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-19-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
normal practice that some period is granted to make final payment. There is
always gap between the date of agreement to sell and execution of sale deeds.
Even if it is assumed that parties entered into transaction in March’ 2011,
sale deed executed in July’ 2011 could not be ignored because there was gap
of just 4-5 months between Section 4 notification and originating of the
aforesaid sale transaction. There is no dispute with respect to payment of
consideration as well as execution of sale deeds. Mandate of Section 51A
cannot be ignored. If for the sake of adjudication and to arrive at correct
market price, it is assumed that market price between March’ 2011 and July’
2011 has increased, it would not be as much as claimed by the landowners.
₹
It cannot be beyond 70 lakh even if it is assumed that there was 40% growth
on account of one or another reason which is practically impossible.
Therefore, the Reference Court has rightly imposed 70% cut over value
declared in Ex. P-40.

23. The Reference Court has determined market value for land of
Village Nalhar while relying upon sale deed which is foundation of
determination of market value for land of Village Nuh. The Reference Court
has imposed cut of 70% while determining market value for the land of
Village Nuh whereas 75% cut has been imposed while determining market
value for the land of Village Nalhar.

24. It was a linear acquisition. By common notification and for the
common purpose land of 2 villages was acquired. The Apex Court in
‘HSIIDC Vs. Pran Sukh & Ors.’, 2010(11) SCC 175 and ‘Ali Mohammad
Beigh & Ors. Vs. State of J&K’, 2017(4) SCC 717 has held that whereby
common notification and for common purpose land of different villages is
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-20-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
acquired, the Court may determine one rate for all the villages. Relevant
extracts of Ali Mohammad Beigh (supra) read as: -
“13. When the lands are more or less situated nearby and
when the acquired lands are identical and similar and the
acquisition is for the same purpose, it would not be proper to
discriminate between the land owners unless there are strong
reasons. In Union of India v. Bal Ram and Another (2010) 5
SCC 747, this Court held that if the purpose of acquisition is
same and when the lands are identical and similar though
lying in different villages, there is no justification to make any
discrimination between the land owners to pay more to some
of the land owners and less compensation to others. The same
was the view taken in Union of India v. Harinder Pal Singh
and Others. (2005) 12 SCC 564, where this Court held as
under:-
“15. We have carefully considered the submissions
made on behalf of the respective parties and we see no
justification to interfere with the decision of the
Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High
Court which, in our view, took a pragmatic approach
in fixing the market value of the lands forming the
subject-matter of the acquisition proceedings at a
uniform rate. From the sketch plan of the area in
question, it appears to us that while the lands in
question are situated in five different villages, they can
be consolidated into one single unit with little to
choose between one stretch of land and another. The
entire area is in a stage of development and the
different villages are capable of being developed in the
same manner as the lands comprised in Kala Ghanu
Pur where the market value of the acquired lands was
fixed at a uniform rate of Rs. 40,000 per acre. The
Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High
Court discarded the belting method of valuation
having regard to the local circumstances and features
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-21-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
and no cogent ground has been made out to interfere
with the same. 16. In our view, in the absence of any
contemporaneous document, the market value of the
acquired lands of Village Kala Ghanu Pur which were
acquired at the same time as the lands in the other five
villages was correctly taken to be a comparative unit
for determination of the market value of the lands
comprising the lands forming the subject-matter of the
acquisition proceedings under consideration.......””


25. In view of aforesaid judgments including ‘Surinder Ahuja &
Anr. Vs. State of Punjab & Anr.’, 2026 (4) RCR (Civil) 417 , it would be
unfair to determine market value for the land of one village at higher rate
than another village. Thus, market price for the land of both the villages is
determined at par.

26. In the wake of above discussion and findings, this Court finds
that the Reference Court has rightly assessed market value for the acquired
land. Contention of the State that the Reference Court has assessed market
value at the higher rate deserves to be rejected and accordingly rejected.
Severance Charges:

27. The landowners are claiming that despite raising claim of
severance charges, the Reference Court has not awarded severance charges.
Their unacquired land has been bifurcated into two parts. A perusal of the
impugned award passed by the Reference Court reveals that Reference Court
has mechanically awarded 50% severance charges and that too of the
assessed market value of the acquired land. This is a bunch of appeals and
50% of the market value cannot be mechanically granted as severance
charges. There is possibility that area bifurcated from the unacquired area is
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-22-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
so small that 50% of the amount of compensation may be more than total
value of the bifurcated area. This may be understood with an example. A
landowner is having five acres land and four acres are acquired. The
remaining area is divided into two parts i.e. ¾ acre on one side and ¼ acre
on the other side. Value of ¼ acre or even unacquired 1 acre land may be less
than 50% of the compensation. If 50% of the compensation is awarded as
severance charges, it would be apparently bad because it would be in the
public interest if bifurcated ¼ acre or 1 acre land is also acquired. Similarly,
50% of the compensation may be more than total value of the unacquired
land. The Reference Court is supposed to ascertain area owned and possessed
by the claimants, area vivisected from the unacquired area, utilization of the
land prior to the acquisition and post-acquisition, change in the value of
unacquired land on account of construction of bypass road because value of
unacquired land normally multiplies on account of construction of national
highway/bypass road/link road etc.

28. It is not possible for this Court to examine record of each
appellant. There may be many appellants/landowners who have not raised
claim of severance charges. They cannot raise said issue at this stage. If any
landowner has raised question of bifurcation of his unacquired land, his
claim needs to be quantified. It is made clear that as held by the Apex Court
in Surinder Ahuja (supra) benefits available under Section 23(1A) and
23(2) are not available on the severance charges.

29. This Court finds that without ascertaining afore-stated factual
and legal position, severance charges cannot be determined. In the normal
circumstances, matters are not remanded to the Reference Court, however,
SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-23-

RFA-1048-2022 (O&M)
in the present case it is inevitable to remand the matter to the Reference Court
so that factual and legal position with respect to bifurcation of the unacquired
land may be ascertained and severance charges may be determined. Ordered
accordingly. It is made clear that remand is limited to the determination of
severance charges qua those landowners who had raised claim in the
reference petition and led evidence. The Reference Court would not be
required to take additional evidence unless and until it is inevitable to
ascertain the severance charges.

30. Appeals/cross-objections of both sides are disposed of in above
terms.

31. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.

(JAGMOHAN BANSAL)
JUDGE
18.11.2026
SDK

Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No

SUDEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document