Sarfraz Sabir Ali Khan @ Bhura vs State Of Maharashtra And Ors
- Court
- Bombay High Court
CNR No : HCBM010276192026
2026:BHC-AS:46128-DB
1 of 13 307-WP-2892-2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 2892 OF 2026
Sarfraz Sabir Ali Khan @ Bhura … Petitioner
Versus
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. ... Respondents
__________
Mr. Ayaz Khan i/by Ms. Zehra Charania a/w Mallika Sharma for the
Petitioner.
Ms. M. M. Deshmukh, APP for Respondent-State.
Mr. Shahajirao R. Shinde for Respondent No. 4.
__________
CORAM : SARANG V. KOTWAL &
RANJITSINHA RAJA BHONSALE, JJ.
th
DATE : 19 NOVEMBER 2026
JUDGMENT (PER SARANG V. KOTWAL, J.) :-
1) The Petitioner is seeking a Writ of Habeas Corpus and
directions for quashing and setting aside the Order of Detention dated
th
20 March 2026, bearing No. PSA-0326/C.R.-97/SPL-3(A), under the
Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as PITNDPS Act) passed
by the Detaining Authority and Principal Secretary (Special), Home
Department, Government of Maharashtra.
2) Heard Mr. Ayaz Khan, learned counsel for the Petitioner,
Ms. M. M. Deshmukh, learned APP for Respondent-State, and Mr.
Sagar Magar
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 15:11:15
2 of 13 307-WP-2892-2026
Shahajirao Shinde, learned counsel for Respondent No. 4 – Union of
India.
3) The Petitioner was served with the Grounds of Detention
along with the Detention Order. At the outset, in Paragraph No. 3 of the
Grounds of Detention, the Detaining Authority has specifically stated
that Paragraph Nos. 4 to 6 are merely a brief narration of the
Petitioner's past criminal record and are not the actual grounds for
detention and have not been relied upon by the Detaining Authority for
issuing the Order of Detention.
4) Paragraph 4 mentions seven offences registered against the
Petitioner. Out of them, six offences were in respect of Mephedrone (for
short, M.D.), which is a psychotropic substance. Only in one offence the
contraband was Ganja and in one more offence it was Ketamine and
Charas. Paragraph Nos. 4.1 to 4.7 briefly record the facts of those
particular offences. Paragraph 7 is preceded by the heading "Relied
Upon Case". Paragraph 7 specifically refers to C.R. No. 87 of 2025
registered with the Anti-Narcotics Cell, under Sections 8 (c) read with
Sections 22 (b) and 29 of the NDPS Act, 1985. The offence relates to
th
the incident dated 4 October 2025, which had taken place at around
12.10 A.M. The Police Officers, while on patrolling duty, apprehended
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 15:11:15
3 of 13 307-WP-2892-2026
one Farid Chuha. After completing the formalities, the officers seized 5
grams of a suspicious substance from him. The said accused, Farid, led
the police team to the premises of another co-accused, i.e., Akbar Khau,
where further 59 grams of a suspicious substance was recovered. Both
of them were arrested. The FIR was lodged. The investigation revealed
that Akbar Khau had purchased the said contraband from the present
Petitioner. During the investigation itself, it was revealed that the
Petitioner was already in judicial custody in connection with C.R. No. 68
of 2025 of the ANC, Ghatkopar Unit. This particular offence has a
bearing on the present Detention Order. The said offence was registered
under Section 8(c) read with Sections 22(c) and 29 of the NDPS Act.
The Chemical Analyzer’s Report regarding the suspicious substance
confirmed that it was Mephedrone. The Petitioner was granted bail by
th
the learned Special Judge, NDPS, Mumbai, vide Order dated 6
February 2026, but the Petitioner continued to remain in judicial
custody in connection with C.R. No. 68 of 2025 registered with the
ANC, Ghatkopar Unit.
5) The Grounds of Detention further mention in Paragraph 8
that the Petitioner had managed to obtain bail in six cases. Various
preventive actions had failed to deter the Petitioner from committing
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 15:11:15
4 of 13 307-WP-2892-2026
similar offences. Despite being granted bail, the Petitioner repeatedly
violated the bail conditions.
6) Paragraph 9 of the Grounds of Detention is important in the
context of the submissions made before us and, therefore, it is
reproduced as follows:
“9. I have carefully gone through the material placed before
me and am satisfied that you are still engaging in illicit trade
in violation of the provisions of the Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985. I am further aware that
you are presently on bail in ANC, Ghatkopar Unit, C.R. No.
87/2025, under Section 8(c) read with Sections 22(b) and
29 of the NDPS Act, 1985. However, you continue to remain
in judicial custody in ANC, Ghatkopar Unit, C.R. No.
68/2025, under Section 8(c) read with Sections 22(c) and 29
of the NDPS Act, 1985. In view of your persistent tendencies
and inclinations, as reflected in the offences committed by
you and considering the possibility of you being granted bail.
Considering your criminal tendencies, you are likely to
possess, transport and engage in the sale of narcotic drugs in
the future as well. Such activities are prejudicial to the
maintenance of public order. Therefore, keeping in mind the
interest and welfare of society at large, it is necessary to
detain you to prevent you from acting in such a prejudicial
manner in the future. Hence, this order of detention under
Section 3(1) of the PIT NDPS Act, 1988, is being issued.”
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 15:11:15
5 of 13 307-WP-2892-2026
Based on this subjective satisfaction the impugned Detention Order was
passed by the Detaining Authority.
7) Though various grounds are raised in the present petition,
Mr. Ayaz Khan, learned counsel for the Petitioner pressed only one point
as follows:
Mr. Khan submitted that the Detaining Authority had not
recorded its subjective satisfaction based on cogent material that there
was an imminent possibility of the Petitioner being released on bail and,
therefore, his detention under the preventive detention law was
necessary.
In support of his contentions Mr. Khan relied on the observations
of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the following judgments.
i) Mortuza Hussain Choudhary v. State of Nagaland, as
reported in AIR 2025 SC 1685.
ii) Amritlal v. Union Govt., as reported in (2001) 1 SCC 341.
iii) Binod Singh v. District Magistrate, Dhanbad, as reported
in (1986) 4 SCC 416.
8) The learned APP appearing for Respondent Nos. 2 and 3
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 15:11:15
6 of 13 307-WP-2892-2026
and the learned counsel for Respondent No. 4 opposed these
submissions. They submitted that the Petitioner has a long list of
incidents. He was indulging in similar activities despite the preventive
actions taken in the past and despite being arrested multiple times and,
therefore, the authorities had no option but to pass the Detention Order.
They therefore, justified the passing of the Detention Order.
9) We have considered these submissions. The judgments
cited before us by Mr. Khan specifically deal with the issues raised by
him in his favour. In the case of Binod Singh v. District Magistrate,
Dhanbad , the relevant portion in Paragraph 5 is as follows:
“5. …..It, however, appears that after the order of
detention was passed and before the actual service of the
order of detention, the petitioner was taken into custody.
From the affidavit of the District Magistrate it does not
appear that either the prospect of immediate release of the
detenu or other factors which can justify the detention of a
person in detention were properly considered in the light of
the principles noted in the aforesaid decision and especially
in the decisions in Rameshwar Shaw v. District Magistrate,
Burdwan [AIR 1964 SC 334 : (1964) 4 SCR 921 : 1964 (1)
Cri LJ 257] and Ramesh Yadav v. District Magistrate, Etah
[(1985) 4 SCC 232 : 1985 SCC (Cri) 514] , though there
was a statement to the effect that the petitioner was in jail
and was likely to be enlarged on bail. But on what
consideration that opinion was expressed is not indicated
especially in view of the fact that the detenu was detained
in a murder charge in the background of the facts
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 15:11:15
7 of 13 307-WP-2892-2026
mentioned before. His application for bail could have been
opposed on cogent materials before the court of justice.”
Paragraph 7 further elaborates this position which is as follows :-
“7. It is well settled in our constitutional framework that the
power of directing preventive detention given to the
appropriate authorities must be exercised in exceptional
cases as contemplated by the various provisions of the
different statutes dealing with preventive detention and
should be used with great deal of circumspection. There
must be awareness of the facts necessitating preventive
custody of a person for social defence. If a man is in custody
and there is no imminent possibility of his being released,
the power of preventive detention should not be exercised.
In the instant case when the actual order of detention was
served upon the detenu, the detenu was in jail. There is no
indication that this factor or the question that the said
detenu might be released or that there was such a
possibility of his release, was taken into consideration by
the detaining authority properly and seriously before the
service of the order. A bald statement is merely an ipse dixit
of the officer. If there were cogent materials for thinking
that the detenu might be released then these should have
been made apparent. Eternal vigilance on the part of the
authority charged with both law and order and public order
is the price which the democracy in this country extracts
from the public officials in order to protect the fundamental
freedoms of our citizens……”
10) Binod Singh’s Judgment is followed in Amritlal v. Union
Govt. case. Paragraphs 4 and 6 in the said judgment are as follows :-
“4. In Agustin decision [1994 Supp (1) SCC 597 : 1994
SCC (Cri) 354] this Court also placed strong reliance on an
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 15:11:15
8 of 13 307-WP-2892-2026
earlier but oft-cited decision of this Court in Binod Singh v.
District Magistrate, Dhanbad [(1986) 4 SCC 416 : 1986
SCC (Cri) 490] wherein it was held that if a person is in
custody and there is no imminent possibility of his being
released therefrom, the power of detention should not
ordinarily be exercised. This Court held that there must be
cogent materials before the officer passing the detention
order that the detenu is likely to be released on bail. The
inference must be drawn from the available material on
record and must not be the ipse dixit of the officer passing
the order of detention. It is in this perspective as above,
that the recording of the officer concerned in the matter
under reference ought to be noticed and the same reads as
below:
“Even though prosecution proceedings under the
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act,
1985 have been initiated against Shri Amritlal I am
satisfied that there is compelling necessity in view
of the likelihood of his moving an application for
bail and in the event of his being granted bail, the
likelihood of his indulging in illicit traffic in
narcotic drugs as is evident from the trend of his
activities, to detain him under the Prevention of
Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1988.”
6. The requirement as noticed above in Binod Singh case
[(1986) 4 SCC 416 : 1986 SCC (Cri) 490] that there is
“likelihood of the petitioners being released on bail”
however is not available in the reasoning as provided by
the officer concerned. The reasoning available is the
“likelihood of his moving an application for bail” which is
different from “likelihood to be released on bail”. This
reasoning, in our view, is not sufficient compliance with
the requirements as laid down.”
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 15:11:15
9 of 13 307-WP-2892-2026
11) Again in Mortuza Hussain Choudhary v. State of Nagaland,
Binod Singh’s judgment was followed. The relevant paragraph are 8 and
10 are as follows :-
“8. We may now note precedential law on the subject. In
Kamarunnissa v. Union of India 1 , the detenus were
already in judicial custody at the time the orders of
preventive detention were passed against them. This
Court affirmed that detention orders could be validly
passed against detenus who were in jail, provided the
officers passing the orders were alive to the factum of the
detenus being in custody and there was material on
record to justify the conclusion that they would indulge in
similar activities, if set at liberty. Reference was made to
the earlier decision of this Court in Binod Singh v. District
Magistrate, Dhanbad, Bihar, wherein it was held that there
must be cogent material before the officer passing the
detention order to infer that the detenu was likely to be
released on bail and such an inference must be drawn
from the material on record and must not be the ipse dixit
of the officer passing such order. This Court, therefore,
emphasized that before passing the detention order in
respect of a person who is in jail, the concerned authority
must satisfy himself and such satisfaction must be reached
on the basis of cogent material that there is a real
possibility of the detenu being released on bail and,
further, if released on bail, the material on record must
reveal that he/she would indulge in prejudicial activity
again, if not detained.
…
10. Earlier, in Union of India v. Paul Manickam, this Court
observed that, where detention orders are passed against
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 15:11:15
10 of 13 307-WP-2892-2026
persons who are already in jail, the detaining authority
should apply its mind and show awareness in the grounds
of detention of the chances of release of such persons on
bail. It was observed that the detaining authority must be
reasonably satisfied, on the basis of cogent material, that
there is a likelihood of the detenu's release and in view of
his/her antecedent activities, which are proximate in point
of time, he/she must be detained in order to prevent
him/her from indulging in such prejudicial activities. It
was held that an order of detention would be valid in such
circumstances only if the authority passing the order is
aware of the fact that the detenu is actually in custody;
the authority has a reason to believe, on the basis of
reliable material, that there is a real possibility of the
detenu being released on bail; and that, upon such
release, he/she would, in all probability, indulge in
prejudicial activities; and it is felt essential to detain
him/her to prevent him/her from so doing. This principle
was again reiterated and applied in Union of India v.
6
Dimple Happy Dhakad .”
12) The analysis of all these judgments indicates that the
Detaining Authority must be reasonably satisfied, on the basis of cogent
material, that there is a likelihood of the detenu being released on bail
and, in view of his activities, which are proximate in time, he must be
detained in order to prevent him from indulging in such prejudicial
activities.
13) In the present case, the past activities would indicate that,
if released on bail, the Petitioner was likely to indulge in similar
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 15:11:15
11 of 13 307-WP-2892-2026
activities. However, the crucial fact that there was reasonable likelihood
of his release on bail was not mentioned on the basis of cogent material.
There is a vague reference in Paragraph 9 of the Grounds of Detention.
At the cost of repetition, we reproduce the relevant reference as follows:
“In view of your persistent tendencies and inclinations, as
reflected in the offences committed by you and considering
the possibility of you being granted bail. Considering your
criminal tendencies, you are likely to possess, transport and
engage in the sale of narcotic drugs in the future as well.”
(reproduced as mentioned in the Grounds).
Thus, there is only a vague reference to the fact that the
Detaining Authority had considered the possibility of the Petitioner
being granted bail. The Detaining Authority has not recorded its
satisfaction based on cogent material on record that the Petitioner was
likely to be released on bail. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has specifically
laid down that such an inference must be drawn from the material on
record and must not be the ipse dixit of the officer passing such an
order. The possibility of being released on bail has to be a real
possibility and cannot be a vague consideration. The Detaining
Authority has not even referred to the Order rejecting the bail
application of the Petitioner in connection with C.R. No. 68 of 2025
registered with the ANC, Ghatkopar Unit. The Grounds of Detention do
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 15:11:15
12 of 13 307-WP-2892-2026
not refer to any material based on which the Detaining Authority has
recorded its satisfaction that there was a real possibility of the Petitioner
being released on bail. In fact, the Detaining Authority has specifically
mentioned that it has taken into consideration only C.R. No. 87 of 2025
of the ANC, Ghatkopar Unit.
14) Hence, we find that the requisite satisfaction of the
Detaining Authority and his appreciation of cogent material to reach the
satisfaction that the Petitioner is likely to be released on bail in
connection with C.R. No. 68 of 2025 of the ANC, Ghatkopar Unit, are
clearly missing. Therefore, based on the law laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in this behalf in the judgments referred to hereinabove,
the Detention Order is not sustainable.
15) Based on the above discussion, we are satisfied that the
Detention Order is required to be set aside. Hence, the following order:
ORDER
i) Rule is made absolute in terms of prayer clause (a)
which reads as follows :-
“a) Issue a Writ of Habeas Corpus or any other
appropriate writ, order or direction quashing and
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 15:11:15
13 of 13 307-WP-2892-2026
setting aside the said order of detention dated
20/03/2026 bearing PSA-0326/C.R.-97/SPL-3(A)
and pleased to direct that the Petitioner be set at
liberty if not required in any other case.”
ii) It is needless to add that the Petitioner cannot
further be detained pursuant to the impugned detention
Order.
iii) This order passed in the present petition shall not
affect the Petitioner’s custody in connection with any
other subject matter or any other offence.
iv) Petition is disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
(RANJITSINHA RAJA BHONSALE, J.) (SARANG V. KOTWAL, J.)
SAGAR
SANTOSH
MAGAR
Digitally signed by
SAGAR SANTOSH
MAGAR
Date: 2026.11.21
14:54:09 +0530
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 15:11:15
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)