ANDALAMMAL vs DJEALATCHOUMY
- Court
- Madras High Court
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved On:
Delivered On:
11-11-2026
16-11-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE N.ANAND VENKATESH
C ivil R evision P etition No.3767 of 2023
CMP.N & o .23434 of 2023
CNR:{HCMA011824392023}
1. Andalammal
W/o. Late.Krishnan,
No.14, Pillaiyar Koil Street,
Manvely, Ariyankuppam,
Pondicherry
2. Aruna, D/o. Krishnan
W/o. Dhanasekaran
No.18, Vinayakar Koil Street,
Saram, Pondicherry - 7
3. Anandhi, D/o. Krishnan
W/o. Ilangovan, No.14,
Pillaiyar Koil Street, Manvely, Ariyankuppam,
Pondicherry.
4. Vanathy, D/o. Krishnan
W/o. Murugan, Bodi Chetty Theru,
Thirupapuliyur, Cuddalore.
5. Lakshmipathy @ Mukundan
__________
Page 1 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
S/o. Krishnan, No.14,
Pillaiyar Koil Street, Manvely, Ariyankuppam,
Pondicherry.
...Petitioners
Vs
Djealatchoumy
W/o. Irussappane
No.21, Pillaiyar Koil Street,
Manvely, Ariyankuppam,
Pondicherry - 7
...Respondent
PETITION under Article 227 of The Constitution of India against
the fair and decretal order dated 29.8.2023 in I.A.No.10 of 2023 in
O.S.No.184 of 2000 on the file of the Principal Subordinate Court,
Puducherry.
For Petitioners: Mr.Sharath Chandran
For Respondent: Mr.P.Dinesh Kumar for
Mr.D.Ravichander
ORDER
This civil revision petition has been filed under Article 227 of
The Constitution of India against the order dated 29.8.2023 in I.A.
No.10 of 2023 in O.S.No.184 of 2000 on the file of the Principal
Subordinate Court, Puducherry (for short, the Court below) wherein
__________
Page 2 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
the application filed by the petitioners/D5 to D9 to make necessary
corrections in the order of witnesses and marking of documents,
came to be dismissed.
2. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners/D5 to D9 and
the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent/plaintiff.
3. This Court has carefully considered the submissions of the
learned counsel on either side and perused the materials available
on record and more particularly the impugned order.
4. The respondent - plaintiff filed the said suit seeking for the
relief of partition and for allotment of 1/5th share in the suit
properties. The said suit came to be dismissed by the Court below
vide judgment and decree dated 19.1.2017. Aggrieved by that, the
respondent/plaintiff filed A.S.No.12 of 2017 before the Principal
District Court, Puducherry and it was allowed vide judgment and
decree dated 13.2.2019 and the case was remanded to the file of
the Court below for fresh disposal.
5. After remand, one Mr.Babu was examined in chief on
03.2.2023 as P.W.1 and Ex.A.1 to Ex.A.16 were marked through him.
__________
Page 3 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
According to the petitioners/D5 to D9, this witness should have been
examined as P.W.2 since he was examined in that capacity in the
said suit prior to remand. Hence, they filed the said application to
set right the records, rank of the said Mr.Babu as P.W.2 and set right
the marking of documents through this witness.
6. However, by the impugned order, the Court below came to
the conclusion that after the remand of the case by the Appellate
Court directing re-trial, the evidence is taken afresh, that therefore,
the said Mr.Babu was examined as P.W.1 and that the documents
were marked through him as Ex.A.1 to Ex.A.16. Aggrieved by this
order, the above revision has been filed before this Court.
7. The main issue that is involved in the present case is as to
whether, on remand made by the Appellate Court, the evidence
recorded earlier gets wiped off and a fresh trial has to be conducted
or as to whether the evidence recorded and the documents marked
after remand will be considered as additional evidence/additional
documents, which will be considered along with the evidence
already recorded and the documents already marked in the said suit
before remand.
__________
Page 4 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
8. The learned counsel for the petitioners/D5 to D9 traced the
history of Order XLI Rule 23 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) and
submitted that the Select Committee on the Bill to consolidate and
amend the law relating to the procedure of the Court of Civil
Judicature submitted a report on 21.3.1903 wherein the relevant
portion is extracted as hereunder :
“Clause 562.-Exception has been taken to
the expression "grounds other than the merits"
which, in paragraph (a) as provisionally drafted,
it was proposed to substitute for the words
“preliminary point” on the authority of certain
cases [Sheoambar Singh v. Lallu Singh, referred
to in Sohawan v. Babu Nand (1886 I.L.R. 9 All.
26, note at P.32; Muhammad Allahdad Khan v.
Muhammad Ismail Khan (1888), I.L.R. 10 All.
289; Ramachandra Foishi v. Hasi Kassim (1892).
I.L.R. 16 Mad. 207; Kanakammal v. Rangachariar
(1896), I.L.R. 20 Mad. 25)]. It may often happen
[Habib Baksk v. Baldeo Prasad (1901), I.L.R. 23
All. 167] that a remand is necessary in a case in
which there has been a decision upon a part of
the merits, but the point determined does not, in
the opinion of the Appellate Court, amount to a
complete and effectual adjudication on the
whole matter in controversy. It has been
reported to us that the practice in various
__________
Page 5 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
Provinces differs on the question whether
evidence recorded in the proceedings leading up
to the decree set aside under section 562 is in
itself available as evidence during the retrial or
whether it can only be made admissible, in the
case of witnesses attending at the hearing, by
examining them upon their previous depositions
as statements recorded in a different
proceeding. We are of opinion that, subject to all
just exceptions, such depositions should, of their
own force, be available as evidence.”
9. The above report resulted in Notes on Clauses in the year
1908 wherein for Order XLI Rule 23, the statement of object and
reasons was recorded as hereunder:
“Or. XLI, R. 23 - After due consideration
the Committee have thought it safer not to give
legislative sanction to the views enunciated in
Habib Bakhsh v. Baldeo Prasad, (I.L.R. 23A 167).
The power of reversal and demand is liable to be
abused, while the procedure under S.566 is free
from this liability and at the same time furnishes
an effectual remedy.
The words at the end of the rule have
been added to clear up a doubt which is stated
by the Select Committee to exist as to whether
evidence recorded at the original trial can be
used on the trial after remand.”
__________
Page 6 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
th
10. The 14 report of the Law Commission of India was
submitted in the year 1958 and in so far as Order XLI Rule 23 was
concerned, the Law Commission recommended an amendment and
the relevant portion is extracted as hereunder:
“46. The power of remand by an appellate
Court is regulated by Rules 23 and 25 of Order
XLI. The power under Rule 23 is a strictly limited
power. A case can be remanded under that rule
only when the lower Court has disposed of the
case upon a preliminary point and the finding on
that point is reversed in appeal. In practice,
cases often arise in which a remand is
necessitated for some other reason. In such
cases, in order to make a remand, the Courts
have resorted to their inherent power under
Section 151 of the Code. This is not a
satisfactory position. Further, an order of remand
under the inherent power of the Court is not
appealable like an order under rule 23. An
attempt has been made to get over this difficulty
by the High Courts of Allahabad, Andhra Pradesh
and Madras by empowering the appellate Court
to remand a case if it thinks it "necessary in the
interest of justice" (Madras) or "where an
appellate Court has reversed a decree and all
questions arising in the case have not been
decided" (Allahabad). The Uttar Pradesh Judicial
__________
Page 7 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
Reforms Committee has recommended an
amendment to Rule 23 on the lines of the
amendment made in Madras. We recommend an
amendment of the rule empowering the
appellate Court to remand a case whenever it
thinks it necessary in the interests of justice.”
11. It is clear from the above that apart from Order XLI Rule
23, which was incorporated providing power of remand to an
Appellate Court in a case where the Trial Court disposed of the suit
upon a preliminary point and which was reversed in the appeal and
remanded, there are many other circumstances, which necessitated
the remand of cases and in such circumstances, the Courts started
resorting to inherent power under Section 151 of the CPC.
12. In the meantime, there was also a reference to the Madras
Amendment, which happened in the year 1930. For proper
appreciation, the said Madras Amendment is extracted as
hereunder:
“MADRAS
Substitute the following for Rule 23:
‘23. Where the Court from whose decree
an appeal is preferred has disposed of the suit
upon a preliminary point and the decree is
__________
Page 8 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
reversed in appeal, or where the Appellate Court,
in reversing or setting aside the decree under
appeal considers it necessary in the interests of
justice to remand the case, the Appellate Court
may by order remand the case, and may further
direct what issue or issues shall be tried in the
case so remanded and shall send a copy of its
judgment and order to the Court from whose
decree the appeal is preferred, with directions to
re-admit the suit under its original number in the
register of civil suits, and proceed to determine
the suit; and the evidence (if any) recorded
during the original trial shall, subject to all just
just exceptions, be evidence during the trial after
remand.’
[R.O.C.No. 5105 of 1930.]”
13. Taking into account those provincial amendments made,
recommendations were made to the Law Commission of India to
amend the rule, empowering the Appellate Authority to remand a
case whenever it thinks fit and necessary in the interests of justice.
14. As a step forward, the Law Commission of India submitted
th
the 27 report recommending to insert Order XLI Rule 23A wherein
the relevant portions read thus:
“ Order XLI, Rule 23A (New)
__________
Page 9 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
After Rule 23 of Order XLI of the First
Schedule to the principal Act, the following rule
shall be inserted, namely:-
"23A. Where the Court from whose decree
an appeal is preferred has disposed of the case
otherwise than on a preliminary point, and the
decree is reversed in appeal and a re-trial is
considered necessary, the Appellate Court shall
have the same powers as it has under Rule 23."
...…
Order XLI, Rule 23A (New)
This carries out the recommendation
made in the 14th Report, and is intended to
widen the powers of the appellate court to
remand a case in the interests of justice.
See also the Allahabad, Andhra and
Madras Amendments to Order XLI, Rule 23 and
Punjab Order 41, Rule 23A. Under-mentioned
cases on these Amendments are helpful.
Kewalram v. Mihilal, A.I.R. 1960 All. 655.
Veerbhadrappa v. Venkatappa, A.I.R. 1961
Α.Ρ. 226.
Ramkrishna v. Rangayya, A.I.R. 1954 Mad.
783. ”
15. Ultimately, Order XLI Rule 23A came to be incorporated in
the 1976 amendment and the said provision is extracted as
hereunder:
__________
Page 10 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
“23A. Remand in other cases— Where the
Court from whose decree an appeal is preferred
has disposed of the case otherwise than on a
preliminary point, and the decree is reversed in
appeal and a retrial is considered necessary, the
Appellate Court shall have the same powers as it
has under Rule 23.”
16. The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the
Legislature has consciously incorporated under Rule 23A that the
Appellate Court shall have the same powers as it has under Rule 23;
that therefore, the last portion in Rule 23 after the semi colon, which
provides that the evidence (if any) recorded during the original trial
shall, subject to all just exceptions, be evidence during the trial after
remand, will apply and when the matter is remanded otherwise than
on a preliminary point and a retrial is ordered, the evidence, which is
already recorded in the said suit before remand does not get effaced
and it remains on record and at the best, further evidence can be
recorded and further documents can be marked, which will be
considered as an additional evidence and which will be dealt with
along with the evidence that is already available on record.
17. In order to substantiate the said submission, the learned
__________
Page 11 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
counsel for the petitioners relied upon the judgment of the First
Bench of the Delhi High Court in Amal Mal Sindhi Vs. Ram
Prakash [S.A.O.No.103 of 1973 dated 08.11.1978] and
specifically relied upon the following portions :
“WHAT IS RETRIAL:
9. Order XLI Rule 23 of the Code of Civil
Procedure says that when the decree is reversed
in appeal on a preliminary point the appellate
court may remand the case with a direction to
readmit the suit under the original number in the
register of civil suits and to proceed to determine
the suit. The evidence (if any) recorded during
the original trial shall, subject to all just
exceptions, be evidence during the trial after
remand. Rule 23A inserted by the Civil Procedure
Code (Amendment) Act, 1976, expressly uses
the word "retrial" in ordering the remand
otherwise than on a decision on a preliminary
point.
10. It is clear that a retrial does not mean
the reinstitution of the suit. The suit is already
pending. It had come to an end by being
dismissed or allowed, but is revived by the order
of remand made by the appellate court. Of
course, in a broader sense even the appeal in
which the order of remand is made is a
continuation of the suit for certain purposes, but
with that we are not concerned. For our purposes
__________
Page 12 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
we are concerned only with the proceeding
which is pending in a trial court or before a
Controller under the Delhi Rent Control Act. It is
the pendency of this proceeding which had
ended and which is revived by the order of
remand. The pendency begins with the filing of
the petition. The defence of the tenant and the
evidence recorded (if any) by the Controller are
also parts of the proceedings without them the
Controller could not have proceeded to dispose
of the petition.
11. The question is whether the
interlocutory order passed under Section 15(1)
or Section 15(2) is a part of the proceeding. The
test for determination of what is a part of the
proceeding is that such a part must form part of
every proceeding. An order under Section 15(1)
is such an inevitable part of the proceeding in
which the petition for eviction is pending. For, it
must be passed by the Controller in a proceeding
for eviction based on non-payment of rent. We
can say, therefore, that just as a petition by the
landlord and the defence by the tenant as also
evidence given by them form a part of the
proceeding an order under Section 15(1) also
form part of the proceeding.”
18. The learned counsel for the petitioners also relied upon
the judgment of a learned Single Judge of the Calcutta High Court in
__________
Page 13 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
Sampa Acharyya Vs. Malay Acharyya [S.A.No.129 of 2022
dated 30.6.2023] wherein the relevant portions read thus:
“29. The suit, it goes without saying can
be remanded under Order 41 Rule 23, Rule 23A
and Rule 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure which
enunciate :-
‘23.Remand of case by appellate court.—
Where the court from whose decree an appeal is
preferred has disposed of the suit upon a
preliminary point and the decree is reversed in
appeal, the appellate court may, if it thinks fit,
by order remand the case, and may further
direct what issue or issues shall be tried in the
case so remanded, and shall send a copy of its
judgment and order to the court from whose
decree the appeal is preferred, with directions to
readmit the suit under its original number in the
register of civil suits, and proceed to determine
the suit; and the evidence (if any) recorded
during the original trial shall, subject to all just
exceptions, be evidence during the trial after
remand.
23-A. Remand in other cases.—Where the
court from whose decree an appeal is preferred
has disposed of the case otherwise than on a
preliminary point, and the decree is reversed in
appeal and a retrial is considered necessary, the
appellate court shall have the same powers as it
has under Rule 23.
__________
Page 14 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
25. Where appellate court may frame
issues and refer them for trial to court whose
decree appealed from.—Where the court from
whose decree the appeal is preferred has
omitted to frame or try any issue, or to
determine any question of fact, which appears to
the appellate court essential to the right decision
of the suit upon the merits, the appellate court
may, if necessary, frame issues, and refer the
same for trial to the court from whose decree the
appeal is preferred, and in such case shall direct
such court to take the additional evidence
required; and such court shall proceed to try
such issues, and shall return the evidence to the
appellate court together with its findings thereon
and the reasons therefor within such time as
may be fixed by the appellate court or extended
by it from time to time.’
30. Rule 23 of Order 41 of the Code of
Civil Procedure unerringly indicates that the
evidence recorded during the original trial shall
be evidence during the trial after remand. The
principle laid down under Rule 23 is applicable to
Rule 23A of Order XLI of the Code of Civil
Procedure.
31. Rule 25 enunciates the Appellate
Court may frame issues and refer the same for
trial to the Court from whose decree the appeal
is preferred, and in such case shall direct such
Court to take additional evidence required; and
__________
Page 15 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
such Court shall proceed to try such remand, and
shall return the evidence to the Appellate Court
together with its finding therein and the reason
thereafter within such time may be fixed by the
Appellate Court or extended by it from time to
time.
In this regard, we may also rely upon the
decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in J. Balaji
Singh vs. Diwakar Cole & Ors. (supra) wherein
Hon’ble Supreme Court held :-
‘14.2. So far as Rule 23-A is concerned, it
enables the Appellate Court to remand the case
to the Trial Court when it finds that though the
Trial Court has disposed of the suit on all the
issues but on reversal of the decree in appeal, a
re-trial is considered necessary by the Appellate
Court.
14.3. So far as Rule 25 is concerned, it
enables the Appellate Court to frame or try the
issue if it finds that it is essential to the right
decision of the suit and was not framed by the
Trial Court. The Appellate Court in such case
may, accordingly, frame the issues and refer the
same to the Trial Court to take the evidence and
record the findings on such issues and return to
the Appellate Court for deciding the appeal. In
such cases, the Appellate Court retains the
appeal to itself.’
32. Therefore, it can safely be said upon
perusal of the aforesaid provisions, that law does
__________
Page 16 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
not permit the Court to shut its eyes to the
evidence already recorded by the Court during
trial before the order of remand was passed, of
course subject to just exception.
This ‘just exception’ shall have to be
indicated by the learned Court while passing the
order of remand, taking lumen from Rule 23, or
23A of Order XLI of the Civil Procedure Code, it
cannot be imported from nowhere.
33. It is expedient to reproduce the order
of remand to appreciate the follow up action,
taken by learned Trial Court. It was held by
learned Appellate Court :-
‘Since remand only on the point of counter
claim may invite further complications in
disposal of the entire matter completely and
effectively, and since the points of plaint and
counterclaim are interrelated to each other, let
there be an open remand for adjudication of the
suit and the counter claim fresh.
Hence it is
O R D E R E D
that the instant appeal be and the same is
hereby allowed on contest but without any order
as to costs. The judgment and decree dated
28.05.2009 passed by the learned Civil Judge,
Senior Division, 2nd Court at Barasat, North 24
Parganas in Title Suit No- 69 of 2007 is set aside.
The matter is sent back on remand for
adjudication afresh, on both the plaint and the
__________
Page 17 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
counter claim.
The Learned trial court shall assess the
court fees on counter claim within 15 days of the
first appearance of the parties and the defendant
shall pay the court fees upon the same within 15
days thereafter. If the defendant brings any
application for amendment of counterclaim, the
same shall be filed at the earliest opportunity
and would be disposed of by the learned trial
court in accordance with law. Then Learned
Court shall frame the issues afresh after giving
opportunity to the plaintiff to file written
statement to the counter claim and shall
determine the suit and the counter claim on
hearing the evidence afresh, as per law, and
would endeavour to dispose of the same as
expeditiously as possible, without granting
unnecessary adjournments to any of the parties,
preferably within six months from the date of
communication.
Send down the L.C.R. with copy of this
judgment at once. Both the parties are directed
to appear before the learned trial court on
29.2.2012 for receiving appropriate direction.’
34. Upon plain reading of the order it
appears that purpose of remand was to allow the
defendant to amend his counter claim and to
adduce evidence, and also an opportunity was
given to the plaintiff to file written statement
and to adduce further evidence, if necessary. It
__________
Page 18 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
was never spelt out that the evidence already on
record, should be expunged or to be treated as
non-est. In absence of such mandate, it was not
open to learned Trial Court to act in such a
manner that would cause infraction to the
procedural law.
35. Learned Appellate Court while passing
the impugned judgement did not consider the
relevant procedure as laid down under Order XLI
Rule 23, 23A and 25 of the Code of Civil
Procedure. Rule 23 and 23A envisage the
evidence on record, subject to all just
exceptions, be evidence during the trial after
remand. Rule 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure
speaks of recording additional evidence upon
issues framed by learned Appellate Court.
36. It goes without saying that when law
mandates a course of action in a particular
manner, it is to be done in that manner only and
not otherwise. In this regard, we can rely upon
the judgement of Privy Council in the case of
NAZIR AHMED VS. KING EMPEROR reported in
1936 SCC OnLine PC 41 wherein it is held :-
‘...... that where a power is given to do a
certain thing in a certain way the thing must be
done in that way or not at all. Other methods or
performance are necessarily forbidden.’
37. In CHANDRA KISHORE JHA VS.
MAHAVIR PRASAD & ORS. reported in (1999) 8
SCC 266, Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under :-
__________
Page 19 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
‘17.................... It is a well-settled salutary
principle that if a statute provides for a thing to
be done in a particular manner, then it has to be
done in that manner and in no other manner.
(See with advantage: Nazir Ahmad v. Kind
Emperor [(1935-36) 63 IA 372 : AIR 1936 PC
1253 (II)].’
38. In the case of CHIEF SECRETARY,
GOVERNMENT OF ANDHRA PRADESH & ORS.
reported in (2015) 13 SCC 722 Hon’ble Apex
Court held :-
‘14. Where the law prescribes a thing to
be done in a particular manner following a
particular procedure, it shall be done in the same
manner following the provisions of law without
deviating from the prescribed
procedure................’
39. Therefore, in absence of any direction,
indicating just exception, both the Courts below
had no reason to dismiss the suit and appeal
only because the documents already admitted
into evidence were not “re-exhibited”. There was
no reason for the learned Trial Court and learned
First Appellate Court to hold that evidence on
record got wiped out as an aftermath of order of
remand by operation of law.
The plaintiff had no obligation to tender
the documents, already admitted into evidence
and taken on record as exhibits 1 to 6, to
reexhibit the same, pursuant to the order of
__________
Page 20 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
remand. The interlocutory order no. 54 was
passed and virtually affirmed ignoring the
provisions as laid down under Order XLI Rule 23A
of the Code of Civil Procedure. The oral
testimony of the witness, after an order of
remand, unless otherwise directed, is nothing
but additional evidence.
40. Section 105 of the Code of Civil
Procedure says :-
‘Section 105 of Code of Civil Procedure
1908 "Other orders"
(1) Save as otherwise expressly provided,
no appeal shall lie from any order made by a
Court in the exercise of its original or appellate
jurisdiction; but, where a decree is appealed
from, any error, defect or irregularity in any
order, affecting the decision of the case, may be
set forth as ground of objection in the
memorandum of appeal.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in
sub-section (1), where any party aggrieved by an
order of remand from which an appeal lies does
not appeal therefrom, he shall thereafter be
precluded from disputing its correctness.’
41. Upon plain reading of the provision, it
appears that every order, be it appealable or
not, except an order of remand, may be assailed
in an appeal from final decree on the following
ground :-
a. that it is erroneous
__________
Page 21 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
b. and such error affects the decision of
the suit. Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
NAWAB SHAQAFATH ALI KHAN & ORS. VS.
NAWAB IMDAD JAH BAHADUR & ORS. reported in
(2009) 5 SCC 162 held:-
‘38. It may be true that in terms of Section
105 of the Code of Civil Procedure when an
appeal against the final decree is passed,
legality of the said order could be challenged in
the appeal. Only because a civil revision
application has not been filed, the same, in our
opinion, would not attract the principle of res
judicata as an appeal from the final decree could
still be maintained.’
42. In this case, as it is already pointed
out by Mr. Mukherjee and quite correctly, the
judgement impugned, is based on the reasoning
given in the interlocutory order 54 dated 18th
September, 2013. Therefore, provision of Sub-
Section 1 of Section 105 of the Code of Civil
Procedure is applicable.
43. Learned Courts below had no reason
to insist for re-exhibiting the documents, already
exhibited, while recording evidence of P.W. 1,
after remand. Both the learned Trial Court and
learned First Appellate Court committed grave
error by holding that the evidence on record got
obliterated with the order of remand. The
evidence recorded by the learned Trial Court
prior to the order of remand, by no stretch of
__________
Page 22 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
imagination can be said to have crossed the
Oblivion with all the probative value of the
documents admitted as exhibit 1 to 6.
44. Be that as it may in my humble
opinion in the absence of any specific direction
to expunge the evidence already on record, such
evidence, be that oral and documentary,
recorded before the order of remand shall have
to be considered as evidence on record after
remand. There was no cogent reason to pass the
judgement impugned, on the ground that
documents already on record were not re-
exhibited. Such finding is perverse.”
19. The learned counsel for the petitioners again relied upon
the judgment of a learned Single Judge of the Kerala High Court in
Murikyal Pavithran Vs. Murikyal Rohini [O.P.(C) No.114 of
2026 dated 27.1.2026] wherein the relevant portions read thus:
“ 2. The counsel for the petitioner
submitted that Order 41 Rule 23 of the Code of
Civil Procedure which deals with remand of cases
by appellate court specifically says that evidence
(if any) recorded during the original trial, shall,
subject to all just exceptions, be evidence during
the trial after remand. It is hence evident that
unless the court had specifically stated that the
evidence already recorded shall not be looked
into, there is no question of fresh evidence being
__________
Page 23 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
let in to exclude what has already been placed
on record. The court below appears to have
taken a stand that if the appellate court had not
made any observations then it is necessary that
there should be a de novo trial ignoring the
evidence which is already on record. The
understanding of the court below does not
appear to be correct. To that extent, the
petitioner is entitled to succeed. This Court had
only permitted additional pleadings to be
incorporated and directed a fresh consideration.
Any additional evidence can only be with regard
to the additional pleadings incorporated. As far
as the pleadings which are already on record
evidence has already been recorded and it is not
proper to exclude the entire evidence and go
ahead with new evidence. ”
20. By relying upon the above judgments, it was submitted on
the side of the petitioners that the term ‘re-trial” cannot be
equated to ‘ de novo trial ’ and on remand, the Trial Court can
record further evidence, which will be considered as additional
evidence and the same will be appreciated along with the evidence
that is already recorded in the suit before remand. To substantiate
this submission, reliance was also placed on the judgment of a
learned Single Judge of the Orissa High Court in Sanatan
__________
Page 24 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
Mohapatra Vs. Hakim Mohammad Kazim Mohammad
[reported in AIR 1977 Orissa 194] wherein the relevant portions
are extracted as hereunder:
“7. ……….
It was not case of an Appellate Court
framing certain specific issues and referring
them for trial to the trial Court, in which case the
trial Court’s jurisdiction is confined to determine
those specific issues and not all the issues.
Neither Rule 23 nor Rule 25 of Order 41 is
applicable. This appears to me to be a remand
under Order XLI Rule 23A of the Code of Civil
Procedure. This rule speaks of an open remand
and, in this case, after reading the remit order of
the first appellate court, I am satisfied that the
remit order is an open remand. The only
restriction is that the trial Court is not to take
fresh evidence on any matter involved in the
issues, either old or new, except on the question
of validity of the two registered sale deeds.
8. The effect of the remand order is to
relegate the suit to a stage where evidence has
been collected on a number of issues and a fresh
issue is framed and parties are allowed liberty to
lead evidence on one aspect of that issue. In
other words, the suit is relegated to the stage of
trial where trial has commenced but is not
concluded. The direction for a fresh disposal
__________
Page 25 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
obviously means a direction to dispose of the
suit in accordance with law. There is nothing in
the remit order nor is that order susceptible to
an interpretation as amounting to prohibition to
amend the pleadings, even though a case for
amendment arose. As already indicated, the
power and jurisdiction of the Munsif exercisable
under the various provisions of the Code of Civil
Procedure had not been whittled down at
all………..”
21. The learned counsel for the petitioners also relied upon the
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Satyajit Banerjee Vs.
State of West Bengal [reported in 2005 (1) SCC 115] and
placed reliance upon paragraph 27, which reads as follows:
“ 27. So far as the position of law is
concerned we are very clear that even if a retrial
is directed in exercise of revisional powers by the
High Court, the evidence already recorded at the
initial trial cannot be erased or wiped out from
the record of the case. The trial Judge has to
decide the case on the basis of the evidence
already on record and the additional evidence
which would be recorded on retrial. ”
22. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent/plaintiff
submitted that the precursor for Order XLI Rule 23 of the CPC is
__________
Page 26 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
Section 562 of the 1882 CPC. This provision, which was incorporated
in the 1908 CPC, only provided for remand where the Trial Court
disposed of the suit upon a preliminary point and the decree was
reversed in appeal. In view of the fact that many other
circumstances arose for remanding the case to the Trial Court,
Courts started invoking Section 151 of the CPC. In view of the same,
there were divided rulings pronounced by various High Courts.
23. The Madras High Court, in order to end this impasse,
brought in the Madras Amendment in the year 1930. This
amendment widened the discretion to remand cases and it prevailed
till 1976 when Order XLI Rule 23A was incorporated in the CPC.
24. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent/plaintiff submitted that the term ‘ re-trial ’ used in Rule
23A will only mean a ‘ de novo trial’ since the decree of the Trial
Court was set aside and the suit was remanded back to the Trial
Court to be decided afresh; that the last limb of Rule 23 to Order XLI
will not apply to the remand made under Order XLI Rule 23A since
the last limb only contemplates a case where the evidence is let in
on all the issues whereas the Trial Court decides only a preliminary
issue, which gets reversed by the Appellate Court and the matter is
__________
Page 27 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
remanded to the Trial Court for considering all the issues and at that
point of time, the evidence that is recorded earlier will remain intact
to decide the remaining issues; and that it is not the scenario that
arises where the remand is made under Order XLI Rule 23A.
25. The submissions made by the learned counsel on either
side boil down to understanding the term ‘ re-trial’ used under
Order XLI Rule 23A of the CPC. In order to understand this term, it is
not necessary for this Court to place reliance upon the last limb of
Order XLI Rule 23 after the semi colon portion. That provision
confines itself to those cases where the Trial Court only decides the
preliminary issue and the same is set aside by the Appellate Court
and the matter is remanded back to the Trial Court for trying all the
issues. Order XLI Rule 23A was specifically brought in by the
Legislature to deal with the remand made by the Appellate Court
other than a situation contemplated under Order XLI Rule 23.
Therefore, this provision has to be dealt with independently without
attempting to read the last limb of Order XLI Rule 23 into Order XLI
Rule 23A.
26. A careful reading of the judgments of the Delhi High Court,
__________
Page 28 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
the Calcutta High Court and the Kerala High Court makes it clear
that the term ‘ re-trial ’ does not mean re-institution of the suit.
There is a marked difference between a re-trial and a de novo
trial. In a de novo trial, the entire evidence gets wiped off and the
suit is decided afresh on merits.
27. At this juncture, it is relevant to point out that the
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Satyajit Banerjee, even
though arose out of criminal proceedings, gives a fair idea as to the
difference between a re-trial and a de novo trial . The Hon’ble
Apex Court held that a de novo trial can be ordered only by the
Constitutional Courts in cases where the trial was found to be a
farce, which was described as a mock trial and that in so far as the
re-trial is concerned, the entire trial cannot be erased or wiped off
from the records and it has to be considered along with the
additional evidence recorded by the Trial Court after remand.
28. The scheme of Order XLI Rule 23A of the CPC does not vest
the Appellate Court with the power to order de novo trial. At the
best, the Appellate Court can only order for re-trial for those cases,
which fall within the purview of Order XLI Rule 23A.
__________
Page 29 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
29. In view of the same, in no case where the Appellate Court
remands the matter to the Trial Court in exercise of jurisdiction
under Order XLI Rule 23A, the evidence already recorded gets wiped
out. It will remain intact and after remand, the evidence that is
recorded will only be considered as additional evidence, which will
be taken into consideration along with the original evidence
recorded at the time of appreciation of the evidence.
30. To make the above proposition of law even more clearer,
the Trial Court has to carefully read the judgment of the Appellate
Court to find out the areas identified by the Appellate Court
justifying the remand, record evidence and mark documents
regarding those specific areas/issues identified by the Appellate
Court to answer those issues effectively.
31. At this juncture, the judgment of the learned Single Judge
of the Orissa High Court in Sanatan Mohapatra gives a clear
indication that once a suit is relegated, the Trial Court must confine
recording evidence to those issues identified by the Appellate Court
and it should not take fresh evidence of all the other issues.
__________
Page 30 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
32. To appreciate the above proposition of law in the decision
of the Orissa High Court in Sanatan Mohapatra, the judgment
passed by the Appellate Court dated 13.2.2019 in the present case
assumes significance wherein the relevant portions read thus:
“20. ………….
Therefore, from the evidence of PW1, it
reveals that some of the properties were left
over and not included in the suit schedule.
Further DW4 in his evidence, stated that "In
Manaveli Village R.S.No.5/6B to an extent of 1
Are 7 Centiares was acquired for ECR Road and a
sum of Rs.60,874/- was awarded to Kadiresan,
Adinarayanan and Ramkrishnan. Further, he
stated that 88 Centiares land was acquired by
the Government in the name of Ramakrishnan
and a sum of Rs.37,906/- was awarded. The
above said amount was adjusted to Excise
Department. Therefore, from the above said
evidence it reveals that already some of the
lands were acquired by the Government and the
amount was awarded to D1 but the said amount
has not been added in the suit. The plaintiff also
not claimed the above said amount. Therefore, it
is clear that the plaintiff has failed to include all
the properties of Sababapthy Counder. But the
lower court failed to frame proper issues and not
given opportunity to the plaintiff to add all the
parties in the suit. Without the presence of all
__________
Page 31 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
the co-sharers the suit cannot be decided
effectively and thereby it is appropriate remand
back the case to the lower court for fresh
disposal by affording chances to the plaintiff to
implead all the parties who purchased the
properties of Sababathy Counder from D1 and to
include all the properties of Sababathy Counder
by framing proper issues as to decide according
to law. Thus Point No.3 is answered accordingly.
21. POINT NOS. 1,2, 4 & 5:
This court has already decided in the
previous point that the suit is bad for non joinder
of necessary parties and thereby the case has to
be remanded back to the lower court for fresh
disposal by affording chances to the plaintiff to
implead all the parties and the properties of the
father of the plaintiff according to law thereby
the other Points regarding joint family properties
of the plaintiff and the defendants, Plaintiff's
joint possession and enjoyment over the
properties, the validity and genuinity of the Will
dated 28.9.1983 executed by Sabapathy
Counder, and plaintiff's entitlement of 1/5th
share in the suit properties cannot be decided
without the proper evidence and the presence of
proper parties. Thus the Points are answered
accordingly.
22. POINT NOS. 6 & 7:
Since this court has decided in the earlier
Points that the case has to be remanded back for
__________
Page 32 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
fresh disposal, it is appropriate to set aside the
Judgment and Decree passed by the lower court
by allowing this appeal. Point Nos.6 and 7 are
answered accordingly.
23. POINT NO.8:
As discussed above, the case is remanded
back to the lower court for fresh disposal by
affording chances to the plaintiff to implead all
the parties and the properties of the father of the
plaintiff according to law. The lower court
Judgment and Decree are liable to be set aside
and the appeal is liable to be allowed. Point No.8
is answered accordingly.
24. In the result, the appeal is allowed and
the Judgment and Decree in O.S.No .184/ 2000
passed by the Learned Principal Sub-Judge,
Puducherry on 19.1.2017 are hereby set aside,
and the case is remanded back to the lower
court for fresh disposal by affording chances to
the plaintiff by impleading all the parties and
including all the properties of the father of the
plaintiff. The lower court is directed to expedite
the trial proceedings and dispose the case as
early as possible preferably within six months in
accordance with law. The parties are directed to
appear before the lower court on 22.4.2019.”
33. It is clear from the said judgment of the Appellate Court
dated 13.2.2019 that the matter has been remanded to the Court
__________
Page 33 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
below only to enable the respondent/plaintiff to implead all the
parties and include all the properties. The Court below was also
directed to expedite the trial proceedings after affording opportunity
and deliver a final judgment in six months.
34. At the risk of repetition, this Court holds that whenever a
remand is made under Order XLI Rule 23A, the Trial Court must first
assess those grounds, on which, the Appellate Court remanded the
matter back to the file of the Trial Court and focus on recording of
evidence and marking of documents on those identified grounds.
While doing so, the same witnesses, who were examined earlier, can
be recalled and if any additional documents are marked apart from
those documents that were already marked, they can be assigned
proper document numbers. The rank of the witnesses already
examined must be maintained even when they are recalled for
further evidence. New rank to the witnesses shall be assigned only
in case where additional witnesses are examined by either of the
parties. Under no circumstances, the earlier evidence recorded
before remand can be eschewed and the appreciation of evidence
must take place by assessing the entire evidence, which includes
both the earlier evidence as well as the additional evidence recorded
after remand.
__________
Page 34 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
35. In the light of the above discussions, the above civil
revision petition is allowed and the impugned order dated
29.8.2023 in I.A.No.10 of 2023 in O.S.No.184 of 2000 on the file of
the Principal Subordinate Court, Puducherry is set aside. The Court
below is directed to record additional evidence of the witnesses, who
were already examined in the same rank that was assigned to them
prior to remand and in so far as the marking of documents is
concerned, only if any new documents are marked, a new serial
number shall be assigned and the existing documents that have
already been marked need not be once again marked. If any new
witnesses are examined, they shall be assigned a new rank. As
stated supra, the entire evidence namely the evidence already
recorded before remand and the additional evidence recorded after
remand shall be assessed at the time of appreciation of the evidence
and the purpose of remand by the Appellate Court shall be kept in
mind and a final judgment shall be delivered in O.S.No.184 of 2000
within a period of four months from the date of receipt of a copy of
this order. No costs. Consequently, the connected CMP is closed.
__________
Page 35 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
16-11-2026
Index: Yes
Speaking Order
Neutral Citation: Yes
To
The Principal Subordinate
Court, Puducherry.
RS
__________
Page 36 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4565
CRP.No.3767 of 2023
N.ANAND VENKATESH,J
RS
CRP.No.3767 of 2023&
CMP.No.23434 of 2023
16-11-2026
__________
Page 37 of 37
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 12:58:13 pm )