Life Insurance Corporation Of India vs The Insurance Ombudsman And 2 Ors
- Court
- Gauhati High Court
Page No.# 1/9
GAHC010269502022
2026:GAU-AS:16917
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/135/2023
LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY
ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER,
NE LEGAL CELL, L.I.C. OF INDIA,
GUWAHATI.
VERSUS
THE INSURANCE OMBUDSMAN AND 2 ORS
OFFICE OF THE INSURANCE OMBUDSMAN,
STATE OF ASSAM, MEGHALAYA, MANIPUR, MIZORAM, ARUNACHAL
PRADESH, NAGALAND AND TRIPURA.
JEEVAN NIVESH, 5TH FLOOR,
NEAR PANBAZAR OVERBIRDGE,
GUWAHATI- 781001.
2:SMTI. KRISHNA ADHIKARY
W/O- LT. HARI PRASAD ASHIKARY
HAWAI CIRCLE
ANJAW
HAWAI
ARUNACHAL PRADESH
PIN- 792104.
3:STATE BANK OF INDIA
HAWAI BRANCH
P.O. AND DIST- ANJAW
ARUNACHAL PRADESH
Page No.# 2/9
PIN- 792102
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
For the Petitioner(s) : None appears
For the Respondent(s) : Mr. M. Bhuyan, Amicus Curiae
· Date on which Judgment was reserved : NA
· Date of Pronouncement of Judgment : 12.11.2026
· Whether the pronouncement is of
the Operative Part of the Judgment : NA
· Whether the full Judgment has been
Pronounced : Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
None appears on behalf of the petitioner as well as the
respondents when the matter is called.
2. Mr. M. Bhuyan, the learned counsel appointed as Amicus
Curiae by this Court vide order dated 07.09.2026, has appeared.
3. The present writ petition has been filed by the petitioner
challenging the Award dated 05.08.2022 passed by the respondent
No. 1 in Complaint Ref. No. GUW-L-029-2223-0093.
Page No.# 3/9
4. The brief facts of the instant case are that one Hari Prasad
Adhikary (since deceased) obtained a policy from the petitioner,
being Policy No. 403121414. The said policy commenced w.e.f.
18.07.2018. The monthly premium payable under the policy was
Rs. 1,369/-, and the due date for payment of the insurance
th
premium was the 18 day of every month. In addition to that, an
amount of Rs. 31/- per month was payable towards GST and
accordingly, the total monthly premium was Rs. 1,400/-.
5. The policy continued and amounts of Rs. 1,400/- per month
were being deducted from the bank account of Late Hari Prasad
Adhikary maintained with the respondent No. 3. Monthly premiums
th
for 28 months were paid. When the premium for the 29 month
fell due on 18.11.2020, an invoice dated 22.11.2020 was
generated by the petitioner in its system and sent to the
respondent No. 3 through the petitioner's nodal bank via the RBI.
However, the said amount was dishonoured on 23.11.2020 due to
"balance insufficient".
6. Unfortunately, on 16.12.2020, Late Hari Prasad Adhikary
expired in a road accident. The Respondent No. 2, being the
nominee under Policy No. 403121414 submitted a claim along with
the relevant documents. The claim of the respondent No. 2 was
Page No.# 4/9
repudiated on 08.03.2022 on the ground that the policy was in a
lapsed condition at the time of the policy holder's death.
7. Under such circumstances, the respondent No. 2 approached
the Insurance Ombudsman, i.e., the respondent No. 1 by filing a
complaint on 18.07.2022. The Insurance Ombudsman vide the
impugned Award dated 05.08.2022 directed the petitioner to pay
the applicable sum assured of Rs. 2,00,000/- and the accidental
benefit of Rs. 2,00,000/- subject to submission of the required
documents. Being aggrieved, the petitioner has approached this
Court by filing the present writ petition.
8. The policy in question is enclosed as Annexure-A to the writ
petition. Clause 2 of the Conditions and Privileges of the policy is
reproduced hereinunder:
“ 2. Payment of Premiums : A grace period of one month but not less than
30 days will be allowed for yearly, half-yearly, quarterly modes and 15 days for
monthly mode of premium payment.
If the premium is not paid before the expiry of the days of grace, the Policy
lapses.
If the death of the Life Assured occurs within the grace period but before the
payment of the premium then due, the policy will still be valid and the benefits
shall be paid after deductions of the said unpaid premium as also the unpaid
Page No.# 5/9
premium/s falling due before the next anniversary of the policy.
If the policy has not lapsed and the claim is admitted in case of death under a
Policy where the mode of payment of premium is other than yearly, unpaid
premiums, if any, falling due before the next policy anniversary shall be
deducted from the claim amount.
The premium payable will be total installment premium which includes
(i) Installment premium for Basic Plan and
(ii) Installment premium for LIC’s Accidental Death and Disability Benefit Rider,
if LIC's Accidental Death and Disability Benefit Rider option has been
exercised.”
9. From a perusal of the above quoted clause, it would be seen
that a grace period of one month, but not less than 30 days is
provided for yearly, half-yearly and quarterly modes of premium
payment and 15 days for the monthly mode of premium payment.
It is also mentioned that if the premium is not paid before the
expiry of the grace period, the policy lapses.
th
10. In the instant case, it is seen that the 29 premium fell due
on 18.11.2020. The invoice generated on 22.11.2020 was
dishonoured on 23.11.2020. There was no subsequent attempt to
make the payment within 03.12.2020 which was the grace period
Page No.# 6/9
of 15 days from the due date of payment of the premium. The
husband of the respondent No. 2, Late Hari Prasad Adhikary met
with a road accident on 16.12.2020 and succumbed to his injuries
and expired.
11. In the backdrop of the above, the question that arises is
whether the petitioner would be liable to pay the sum assured
along with the accidental benefit as directed vide the impugned
Award dated 05.08.2022.
12. The issue in the present case appears to be well settled by the
Supreme Court in the case of Life Insurance Corporation of India
Vs. Mani Ram (2005) 6 SCC 274
reported in . Paragraph Nos. 12, 13
and 17 being relevant, are reproduced hereinunder:
“ 12. In this connection, it may be profitable to refer to the terms and conditions of
the policy. The policy stated that the date of commencement was 28-4-1995 and
the date of maturity would be 28-4-2010 as it was for a period of fifteen years. It
is further stated that the policy of assurance “shall be subject to the conditions and
privileges” printed on the back of the policy. On the back of the policy, those
conditions and privileges have been printed. Condition 2 thereof, is material for our
purpose and reads thus:
“ 2. Payment of premium.—A grace period of one month i.e. not less than 30
days will be allowed for payment of yearly, half-yearly, or quarterly premiums
and 15 days for monthly premiums. If death occurs within this period and before
the payment of the premium then due, the policy will be valid and the sum
Page No.# 7/9
assured paid after deduction of the premium as also the unpaid premium(s)
falling due before the next anniversary of this policy. If the premium is not paid
before the expiry of the days of grace, the policy lapses.”
(emphasis supplied)
13. From the above condition, it is abundantly clear that payment of premium due
had to be made within a grace period of one month. If such payment was made
within the said period, the policy would be treated as valid and the assured would
be paid the amount to which he was entitled after deducting the premium amount.
But it was also made clear that if the premium was not paid before the expiry of
the days of grace, the policy would lapse. As we have already observed
hereinabove, the material date was not the date of deposit/payment of premium
amount which was 21-8-1995, but the date of policy which was 28-4-1995. Since it
was yearly, the payment was due on 28-4-1996, but the assured was entitled to
grace period of one month up to 28-5-1996. Neither the premium was paid on 28-
4-1996 nor on 28-5-1996. As per condition 2, the policy lapsed on 28-5-1996. In
the eye of law, there was no subsisting policy, on 2-8-1996. The Insurance
Company was, therefore, wholly justified in rejecting the claim of the complainant
and no exception can be taken against such a decision.
17. In the instant case, condition 2 expressly provided the period during which the
payment was to be made. It also in no uncertain terms stated that if premium was
not paid before the expiry of grace period, the policy would lapse. In our view, the
ratio in Dharam Vir Anand would support the Insurance Company rather than the
complainant. If all the terms and conditions of the policy (contract between the
parties) have to be kept in mind and given effect to, acceptance of argument on
behalf of the complainant would make the last part of condition 2 redundant,
otiose and inoperative; and a court of law cannot construe a document in the
manner suggested by the counsel for the complainant. As the premium was due
on 28-4-1996 and was not paid till 28-5-1996, the policy lapsed. The fora below
hence, committed an error of law in allowing the complaint of the respondent
Page No.# 8/9
herein and the orders are liable to be set aside.”
13. In the instant case, the proposition of law laid down by the
Supreme Court squarely applies. Accordingly, it is the opinion of
this Court that the impugned Award dated 05.08.2022 passed by
the respondent No. 1 directing the petitioner to pay the sum
assured as well as the accidental benefit under a lapsed policy is
contrary to the policy conditions and is, therefore, liable to be
interfered with.
14. Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands disposed of with
the following observations and directions:
(i) The Policy bearing No. 403121414 had lapsed on account
of non-payment of the premium by 03.12.2020.
(ii) Late Hari Prasad Adhikary expired on 16.12.2020, when
Policy No. 403121414 was in a lapsed condition.
(iii) The impugned Award dated 05.08.2022 directing the
petitioner to pay the sum assured along with the accidental
benefit is contrary to the policy conditions and the settled
principles of law. Accordingly, the impugned Award dated
05.08.2022 is set aside and quashed.
Page No.# 9/9
(iv) There shall be no order as to costs.
(v) This Court duly appreciates the assistance rendered by
Mr. M. Bhuyan, the learned Amicus Curiae.
JUDGE
Digitally signed by Satyam Sharma
Date: 2026.11.17 22:43:03 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant