Parmatma Rai vs Central Bureau Of Investigation Acb Lucknow

Court
Allahabad High Court

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
LUCKNOW
CRIMINAL REVISION No. - 188 of 2025
Parmatma Rai
.....Revisionist(s)
Versus
Central Bureau Of Investigation Acb Lucknow
.....Opposite
Party(s)
Counsel for Revisionist(s) : Santosh Kumar Shukla
Counsel for Opposite Party(s) : Aakash Prasad
[A.F.R.]

Court No. - 13
HON'BLE SUBHASH VIDYARTHI, J.
1. Heard Sri Santosh Kumar Shukla, the learned counsel for the revisionist
and Sri Aakash Prasad assisted by Sri Yash Joshi and Sri Shreshtha
Srivastava, the learned counsel for the respondent-CBI.
2. By means of the instant revision, the revisionist has challenged the
validity of a judgment and order dated 06.01.2025 passed by the learned
Special Judge, Prevention of Corruption Act, CBI, Court No.4, Lucknow in
Criminal Case No.16000002 of 2006 arising out of RC No.0062005A0014
under Section 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(e) of Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1988 (which will hereinafter be referred to as 'the PC Act') and Section
109 of IPC registered at Police Station- CBI/ACB, District- Lucknow,
whereby an application (B-259) filed by the revisionist-accused challenging
the validity of the prosecution sanction order, has been rejected.
3. A copy of the application which has been rejected by the impugned order
has not been brought on record and, therefore, this Court has to rely on the
narration made in the impugned order regarding contents of that application.
The sanction for petitioner's prosecution was granted by Shri Sarvesh Singh,
Director, Telecommunication Department on behalf of the Hon'ble President
of India and the sanction order was proved by the testimony of PW-1.
4. The trial Court rejected the application holding that the Director,
(Vigilance-I), Telecommunication Department, has granted sanction on
behalf of the Hon'ble President of India for prosecution of the revisionist.
The prosecution sanction order mentions that prima facie it appears that the
revisionist had acquired properties, the value whereof exceeded his known
sources of income by an amount of Rs.62,00,843.70.

CRLR No. 188 of 2025
2
5. The prosecution sanction order (Exhibit A-1) has been proved by Shri
Sarvesh Singh, Director, Telecommunication Department the Director, who
has been examined as PW-1 and who stated that he had sent the relevant
documents for grant of the prosecution sanction to the Hon'ble Minister, who
granted sanction for the petitioner's prosecution on the file. After the grant of
sanction by the Hon'ble Minister, the file was received in his office and after
seeing the relevant documents, PW-1 had passed the order granting sanction
for the petitioner's prosecution.
6. The trial court held that the sanctioning authority has granted prosecution
sanction after due application of mind and after perusal of the entire relevant
facts and materials.
7. The petitioner has paced reliance on an Office Order dated 31.05.2004
issued by the Government of India, Ministry of Tele-Communication and
Information Technology, a copy whereof has been filed before the trial
Court alongwith the objections filed by the CBI. Clause 2 of the Office
Order dated 31.05.2004 mentions "all policy matters, including disciplinary
action and vigilance matters regarding any of the above subjects will be
submitted to MOC&IT through MOS(C&IT)" and the learned Counsel for
the revisionist has submitted that the sanction for prosecution will be
covered by this clause and the Minister of State should have submitted the
matter to the Minister of Communication and Information Technology as he
does not have the power to grant sanction for prosecution of the revisionist.
8. Per contra, the learned Counsel for the CBI has invited attention of the
Court to Section 19 (1) of the PC Act, which provides as follows: -
" 19. Previous sanction necessary for prosecution.— (1) No court
shall take cognizance of an offence punishable under Sections 7,
11, 13 and 15 alleged to have been committed by a public servant,
except with the previous sanction-
(a) in the case of a person who is employed, or as the case may be,
was at the time of commission of the alleged offence employed in
connection with the affairs of the Union and is not removable from
his office save by or with the sanction of the Central Government,
of that Government;
(b) in the case of a person who is employed, or as the case may be,
was at the time of commission of the alleged offence employed in
connection with the affairs of a State and is not removable from
his office save by or with the sanction of the State Government, of
that Government;
(c) in the case of any other person, of the authority competent to
remove him from his office."

CRLR No. 188 of 2025
3
9. The learned Counsel for the CBI has submitted that as per Section 19 (1)
of the PC Act, the prosecution sanction has to be granted grant by the
authority competent to remove the person from his office. Removal of the
person will fall within service and disciplinary matters, which is covered by
Clause 1.ii of the Office Order dated 31.05.2004, which provides that: -
Matters on the following subjects will be decided at MOS level
" 1.
subject to overall superintendence and guidance of the Minister of
Comununications & Information Technology(MOC&IT):-
*
ii. All service and disciplinary matters and also appointments of
officers below and including the level of JAG."
10. The learned counsel for the respondent CBI has placed reliance upon a
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Madhya
; (1970) 1 SCC 108, wherein it was
Pradesh and Ors. v. Shardul Singh
held that: -
" ... The expression "conditions of service" is an expression of
8.
wide import. As pointed by this Court in Pradyat Kumar Bose v.
Hon'ble Chief Justice of Calcutta High Court [(1955) 2 SCR 1331]
the dismissal of an official is a matter which falls within
"conditions of service" of public servants. The Judicial Committee
of the Privy Council in North West Frontier Province v. Suraj
Narain Anand [(1948) LR 75 IA 343] took the view that a right of
dismissal is a condition of service within the meaning of the words
under Section 243 of the Government of India Act, 1935. ..."
11. Sri Akash Prasad, the learned counsel for the respondent-CBI has
submitted that Section 19(1)(c) of the PC Act provides that " no court shall
take cognizance of an offence punishable under Section 7, 11, 13 and 15
alleged to have been committed by a public servant, except with the previous
sanction of the authority competent to remove him from service." Removal
from service would fall within the scope of the phrase " All service and
disciplinary matters" occurring in clause 1 (ii) of the Office Order dated
31.05.2004.
12. Sri. Prasad has also placed reliance on the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the case of 2025
Dashrath v. State of Maharashtra;
INSC 654, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that grant of sanction is
an administrative function based on the subjective satisfaction of the
sanctioning authority after due application of mind to the material placed
before him.
13. The learned Counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance on a judgment

CRLR No. 188 of 2025
4
in the case of : 2010) 10 SCC 539,
Mohammd Yunus Khan v. State of UP (
wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that: -
" 15. We have to proceed, keeping in mind the trite law that
holding disciplinary proceedings against a Government employee
and imposing a punishment on his being found guilty of
misconduct under the statutory rules is in the nature of quasi-
judicial imposing a punishment on his being found guilty of
misconduct under the statutory rules is in the nature of quasi-
judicial proceedings. Though, the technical rules of procedure
contained in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 and the provisions
of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 do not apply in a domestic
enquiry, however, the principles of natural justice require to be
observed strictly. Therefore, the enquiry is to be conducted fairly
and reasonably and the enquiry report must contain reasons for
reaching the conclusion that the charge framed against the
delinquent stood proved against him. It cannot be an ipse dixit of
the inquiry officer. Punishment for misconduct can be imposed in
consonance with the statutory rules and principles of natural
justice."
14. I have considered the facts and circumstances of the case, the law laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the aforementioned cases and the
submissions of the learned counsel for the parties.
15. Section 19(1) of the PC Act categorically provides that a public servant
cannot be prosecuted for having committed the offences under Sections 7,
11, 13 and 15 without a valid sanction order. Section 19(1)(c) of the PC Act
provides that such sanction order may be granted by the authority competent
to remove such a public servant from his office. Removal of a public servant
from service falls within the ambit of the expression "all service and
disciplinary matters" occurring in Clause 1(ii) of the Office Order dated
31.05.2004, which allocates such matters to be dealt with by the Minister of
State for Communication and Information Technology.
16. The phrase " All policy matters including disciplinary action and
vigilance matters"
falling in clause 2 of the Office Order dated 31.05.2004,
contains provisions for policy matters regarding disciplinary action and
vigilance matters, regarding subjects mentioned in clause 1 of the Office
Order dated 31.05.2004. Therefore, a combined reading of clause (1)i and
clause 2 of the Office Order dated 31.05.2004 makes it clear that the service
and disciplinary matters of officers up to the level of JAG, will be dealt with
by the Minister of State whereas policy matters relating to service matters
will be dealt with by the Minister of Communication and Information
Technology. Grant of sanction for prosecution of an individual officer or
refusal thereof, cannot be said to be a policy matter regarding disciplinary
action and vigilance matters rather it is a matter relating to service and

CRLR No. 188 of 2025
5
disciplinary action of an officer which clearly falls within the purview of
clause 1 (ii) of the Office Order dated 31.05.2004.
17. Therefore, I am of the considered view that as per the provisions
contained in the Office Order dated 31.05.2004, all service and disciplinary
matters relating to officers up to the level of JAG, fall within the purview of
powers of the Minister of State and it would, obviously, include the power to
remove the petitioner from service. When the Minister of State has the
power to remove the petitioner from service, he would certainly have the
power to grant or refuse sanction for the prosecution of the petitioner.
18. Therefore, I find no force in the submission of the learned Counsel for
the petitioner that the Minister of State did not have the power to grant
sanction for prosecution of the petitioner. The judgment in the case of
Mohammd Yunus Khan v. State of UP (supra) cited by the learned
Counsel for the revisionist has no bearing on the points involved in the case,
19. The trial court has not committed any error or illegality in rejecting the
petitioner's application raising objections against the validity of the sanction
order on the ground of lack of power.
20. The revision lacks merit and the same is .
dismissed
November 16, 2026
-Amit K-
(Subhash Vidyarthi,J.)
Whether the judgment is speaking :- Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable :- Yes
.
(Subhash Vidyarthi,J.)
Digitally signed by :-
AMIT KUMAR
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad,
Lucknow Bench