M/S Lamba Exports Pvt. Ltd. vs M/S Dhir Global Industries Pvt. Ltd.
- Court
- Supreme Court
<div> 2026 INSC 275<br /> <b>REPORTABLE </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA </b><br /> <b>CIVIL APELLATE JURISDICTION </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>MISC.APPLICATION NO.1256 OF 2025 </b><br /> <b>IN </b><br /> <b>SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 12264 OF 2024 </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>M/S.LAMBA EXPORTS PVT. LTD. …PETITIONER </b><br /> <b>VERSUS </b><br /> <b>M/S.DHIR GLOBAL INDUSTRIES </b><br /> <b>PVT. LTD. AND ORS. </b> <b> </b> <b> …RESPONDENTS </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>WITH </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>MISC. APPLICATION NO. 1257 OF 2025 </b><br /> <b>IN </b><br /> <b>SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 12264 OF 2024 </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>J U D G M E N T </b><br /> <b>VIKRAM NATH, J. </b><br /> <br /> 1. The present Miscellaneous Application No. 1256 of <br /> 2025 (hereinafter referred to as the “MA”) has been <br /> filed in Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 12264 of 2024 <br /> (hereinafter referred to as the “SLP”) seeking recall of <br /> the order dated 25.02.2025 passed by this Court, <br /> Signature Not Verified<br /> Digitally signed by<br /> SHIPRA NARANG<br /> Date: 2026.03.23<br /> 17:54:05 IST<br /> Reason:<br /> whereby the SLP filed against the judgment and order <br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>1</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> <br /><br /> dated 06.05.2024 passed by the High Court of Punjab <br /> and Haryana at Chandigarh in Civil Revision No. 3916 <br /> of 2022 came to be dismissed. The case set up in the <br /> MA is that subsequent developments, including the <br /> alleged non-disclosure of the proposal for a One Time <br /> Settlement (hereinafter referred to as the “OTS”), the <br /> eventual settlement arrived at between the secured <br /> creditor and the corporate debtor, and the withdrawal <br /> of the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process <br /> (hereinafter referred to as the “CIRP”) under Section <br /> 12A of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 <br /> (hereinafter referred to as the “IBC”), have a material <br /> bearing on the foundation on which the matter <br /> proceeded earlier and warrant reconsideration of the <br /> order dated 25.02.2025. <br /> <br /> 2. The facts giving rise to the present MA are as follows: <br /> 2.1. The dispute between the parties arises out of an <br /> Agreement to Sell dated 13.08.2021 in respect of <br /> the subject property owned by Respondent No. 1. <br /> The applicant claims rights on the basis of the said <br /> agreement. The respondents, on the other hand, <br /> dispute the enforceability of the said arrangement <br /> and contend that the agreement did not survive in <br /> the manner asserted by the applicant. <br /> <br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>2</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> <br /><br /> 2.2. The applicant instituted Civil Suit No. 1248 of 2022 <br /> seeking specific performance of the Agreement to <br /> Sell dated 13.08.2021, along with consequential <br /> reliefs of declaration, mandatory injunction, and <br /> permanent injunction. The case set up by the <br /> applicant was that the suit property, bearing UV-<br /> 375, Udyog Vihar, Phase-IV, Gurugram, was <br /> agreed to be sold for a total sale consideration of <br /> Rs.21,00,00,000/-. It was alleged that the <br /> applicant had paid Rs.30,00,000/- as earnest <br /> money, Rs.1,20,00,000/- to Respondent No. 4 <br /> Bank towards the upfront amount for the proposed <br /> OTS, and a further sum of Rs.30,00,000/- to <br /> Respondent Nos. 1 to 3. According to the applicant, <br /> Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 thereafter sought to resile <br /> from the Agreement to Sell by legal notice dated <br /> 25.03.2022 on the ground that the proposed OTS <br /> had not been accepted by the Bank, whereas the <br /> applicant maintained that the Agreement to Sell <br /> was not liable to be rescinded on that basis and <br /> that it had always been ready and willing to <br /> perform its part of the contract. <br /> <br /> 2.3. Along with the suit, the applicant moved an <br /> application seeking interim injunction restraining <br /> Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 from selling, alienating, <br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>3</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> <br /><br /> encumbering, or otherwise creating third party <br /> rights in respect of the suit property during the <br /> pendency of the suit. By order dated 19.07.2022, <br /> the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Gurugram <br /> allowed the said application and granted interim <br /> protection in favour of the applicant. Aggrieved <br /> thereby, Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 preferred an <br /> appeal, which came to be allowed by the learned <br /> Additional District Judge, Gurugram by order <br /> dated 06.09.2022, whereby the order dated <br /> 19.07.2022 passed by the Trial Court was set <br /> aside. <br /> <br /> 2.4. The applicant thereupon challenged the appellate <br /> order before the High Court of Punjab and Haryana <br /> at Chandigarh in Civil Revision No. 3916 of 2022. <br /> By judgment and order dated 06.05.2024, the High <br /> Court dismissed the revision petition. The High <br /> Court held, in substance, that the Agreement to <br /> Sell dated 13.08.2021 was itself contingent in <br /> nature, inasmuch as its performance was <br /> predicated upon the acceptance of the OTS by the <br /> Bank. The High Court noted that the suit property <br /> was mortgaged, that the Bank was not a party to <br /> the Agreement to Sell, and that without the Bank’s <br /> approval to the OTS, Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 were <br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>4</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> <br /><br /> not in a position to convey title in respect of the <br /> property. On that reasoning, the High Court held <br /> that no prima facie case for grant of interim <br /> injunction was made out and that, at the highest, <br /> the applicant could claim recovery of the amounts <br /> paid by it, but could not, at that stage, insist upon <br /> specific performance of an agreement the <br /> performance of which had become uncertain in the <br /> absence of the Bank’s approval. <br /> <br /> <br /> 2.5. It appears that the underlying suit for specific <br /> performance, being Civil Suit No. 1248 of 2022, <br /> continues to remain pending, the proceedings <br /> before this Court having arisen from orders passed <br /> on the interlocutory application seeking interim <br /> protection. <br /> <br /> 2.6. When the SLP came up before this Court on <br /> 04.06.2024, notice was issued. This Court also <br /> directed the applicant to deposit a sum of <br /> Rs.13,00,00,000/- (Rupees Thirteen Crores Only) <br /> with the Registry of this Court within four weeks <br /> and to file an undertaking to deposit an additional <br /> amount of Rs.13,00,00,000/- (Rupees Thirteen <br /> Crores Only) within four weeks after Respondent <br /> No. 4 entered appearance. It is the case of the <br /> applicant that, in compliance with the said order, a <br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>5</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> <br /><br /> total sum of Rs.26,00,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty-<br /> Six Crores Only) came to be deposited with the <br /> Registry of this Court. <br /> <br /> <br /> 2.7. The SLP was ultimately dismissed by order dated <br /> 25.02.2025. The present MA has thereafter been <br /> filed seeking recall of the order dated 25.02.2025 <br /> on the basis of subsequent events which, according <br /> to the applicant, have a direct bearing on the <br /> matter. The respondents have raised a preliminary <br /> objection to the maintainability of the MA and <br /> contend that no such recall application would lie <br /> after dismissal of the SLP. <br /> <br /> 2.8. The subsequent events relied upon in the MA are <br /> that during the pendency of the SLP, Respondent <br /> No. 1 is stated to have addressed a proposal dated <br /> 14.02.2025 to Respondent No. 4 for an OTS and for <br /> withdrawal of the CIRP under Section 12A of the <br /> IBC. It is further the case of the applicant that an <br /> OTS was thereafter concluded on 21.03.2025 for an <br /> amount of Rs.34.85 crore, and that the Committee <br /> of Creditors (hereinafter referred to as the “CoC”), <br /> in its meeting dated 05.04.2025, approved <br /> withdrawal of the CIRP under Section 12A of the <br /> IBC. The applicant also relies upon an email dated <br /> 23.03.2025 addressed by it to the Resolution <br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>6</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> <br /><br /> Professional expressing its willingness to <br /> participate in the process. <br /> <br /> 2.9. It is on the strength of the aforesaid developments <br /> that the applicant alleges suppression of material <br /> facts and seeks recall of the order dated <br /> 25.02.2025. The respondents dispute the said <br /> allegations. Their stand is that the proceedings <br /> before the National Company Law Tribunal were <br /> independent of the proceedings arising from the <br /> suit for specific performance, that the MA is not <br /> maintainable after dismissal of the SLP, and that <br /> the OTS has already been acted upon. <br /> <br /> 3. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and <br /> having perused the material placed on record, we are <br /> of the considered view that the present MA does not <br /> merit acceptance. <br /> <br /> 4. The first obstacle in the way of the applicant is one of <br /> maintainability. The order dated 25.02.2025, recall of <br /> which is sought, is not an executory order. It merely <br /> records that this Court was not inclined to interfere <br /> with the impugned judgment and order and, <br /> accordingly, dismissed the SLP. The present MA does <br /> not seek correction of any clerical or arithmetical <br /> error. Nor is it a case where directions contained in an <br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>7</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> <br /><br /> executory order of this Court have become impossible <br /> of implementation by reason of subsequent events. <br /> The settled position is that a post-disposal <br /> miscellaneous application can be entertained only in <br /> rare situations of that nature. The present case does <br /> not fall within that limited class. <br /> <br /> <br /> 5. In <b><i>Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd. v. Adani Power </i></b><br /> <b><i>1</i></b><br /> <b><i>Rajasthan Ltd.</i></b> <b><i>,</i></b> <i> </i> this Court has held in clear terms <br /> that, once a matter stands disposed of, the Court <br /> becomes functus officio and does not retain <br /> jurisdiction to entertain an application except in the <br /> narrow situations recognized by law. The same <br /> position was reiterated in <b><i>Ajay Kumar Jain v. The </i></b><br /> <b><i>2</i></b><br /> <b><i>State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr.</i></b> <i>, </i> where this Court <br /> deprecated the growing practice of filing miscellaneous <br /> applications in disposed of proceedings and clarified <br /> that such an application would be maintainable only <br /> in the limited situations already noticed above. The <br /> maintainability objection, therefore, goes to the root of <br /> the matter and cannot be brushed aside merely <br /> because notice had been issued in the present MA. <br /> <br /> 6. That apart, the controversy which is now sought to be <br /> projected in the present MA travels well beyond the <br /> <br /> 1<br /> (2024) 19 SCC 353 <br /> 2<br /> 2024 INSC 958 <br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>8</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> <br /><br /> four corners of the proceedings from which the SLP <br /> had arisen. The SLP arose from a suit-based dispute <br /> concerning the Agreement to Sell dated 13.08.2021 <br /> and the correctness of the order passed by the High <br /> Court in Civil Revision No. 3916 of 2022. The present <br /> MA, however, seeks to found a case for recall on the <br /> basis of later developments said to have taken place in <br /> the insolvency proceedings, including the proposal for <br /> One Time Settlement, the subsequent settlement, the <br /> decision of the Committee of Creditors, and the order <br /> passed by the National Company Law Tribunal under <br /> Section 12A of the IBC. Whether those later steps were <br /> proper or otherwise cannot be examined collaterally in <br /> an MA filed in a disposed of SLP arising out of a civil <br /> revision. If the applicant is aggrieved by any act done <br /> or order passed in that separate statutory framework, <br /> it is always open to the applicant to avail of such <br /> remedy as may be permissible in law before the <br /> competent forum. <br /> <br /> 7. At this stage, we may also clarify that we are not <br /> inclined to accept the broad submission that the <br /> dismissal of the SLP on 25.02.2025, by itself, attracted <br /> the doctrine of merger. The law is clear that an order <br /> refusing special leave to appeal, whether speaking or <br /> non-speaking, does not attract merger. However, that <br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>9</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> <br /><br /> does not carry the matter any further for the applicant. <br /> The absence of merger does not mean that a disposed <br /> of SLP can be reopened through a miscellaneous <br /> application on grounds which do not satisfy the settled <br /> parameters of maintainability. <br /> <br /> 8. Much emphasis was placed by the applicant on alleged <br /> suppression and on the submission that the order <br /> dated 25.02.2025 deserves to be recalled on the <br /> ground that fraud was practiced upon this Court. <br /> There can be no quarrel with the principle that fraud <br /> vitiates all proceedings and that a Court is not <br /> powerless where its order has been procured by fraud. <br /> But the exception is a serious one and cannot be <br /> invoked on the basis of assertion alone. In the present <br /> case, the order dated 25.02.2025 is a non-speaking <br /> order dismissing the SLP. The order dated 25.02.2025 <br /> does not indicate that the dismissal turned upon any <br /> specific representation which is now alleged to have <br /> been suppressed. The material now relied upon, even <br /> if taken at its highest, may at best furnish the <br /> applicant with a separate grievance arising out of <br /> subsequent or parallel proceedings. It does not <br /> persuade us to hold, in the present proceedings, that <br /> the order dated 25.02.2025 itself was procured by <br /> practicing fraud on this Court. <br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>10</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> <br /><br /> 9. There is yet another aspect of the matter. The <br /> challenge to the judgment and order dated 06.05.2024 <br /> passed by the High Court had to be considered on the <br /> record and circumstances as they then stood. <br /> Subsequent developments in another forum, <br /> howsoever strongly relied upon by the applicant, <br /> cannot retroactively render the earlier adjudicatory <br /> exercise vulnerable in a disposed of SLP. A later event <br /> may, in a given case, furnish an independent cause of <br /> action. It cannot, by itself, be used to reopen finality <br /> in proceedings of a different character and origin. <br /> <br /> 10. Even otherwise, we are unable to accept the <br /> applicant’s attempt to invite this Court, in the present <br /> MA, to comparatively assess the alleged superiority of <br /> its offer vis-à-vis the settlement which came to be <br /> accepted in the insolvency process. The statutory <br /> scheme of Section 12A of the IBC contemplates <br /> withdrawal of the insolvency process, after <br /> constitution of the CoC, only upon approval by the <br /> requisite voting share of the CoC. Once the matter <br /> enters that domain, the decision whether to accept a <br /> settlement, whether to continue with the process, or <br /> whether to adopt one commercial course over another, <br /> falls essentially within the realm of the collective <br /> commercial wisdom of the CoC. In <b><i>K. Sashidhar v. </i></b><br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>11</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> <br /><br /> <b><i>3</i></b><br /> <b><i>Indian Overseas Bank</i></b> <b><i>, </i></b> this Court emphasized that <br /> the legislature has consciously made the commercial <br /> wisdom of the financial creditors non-justiciable and <br /> that the adjudicating and appellate authorities do not <br /> sit in appeal over such business decisions. <br /> <br /> 11. The same principle was reiterated and explained in <br /> <b>Essar Steel (India) Ltd. Committee of Creditors v. </b><br /> <b>4</b><br /> <b>Satish Kumar Gupta</b> <b>,</b> where this Court held that it <br /> is the commercial wisdom of the majority of the CoC <br /> which determines, through negotiations and <br /> assessment of viability, how and in what manner the <br /> corporate insolvency resolution process is to proceed. <br /> More particularly, this Court observed that the <br /> adjudicating authority cannot make any inquiry <br /> beyond the limited statutory parameters, nor can it <br /> issue directions in relation to the exercise of <br /> commercial wisdom of the CoC, whether in approving, <br /> rejecting, or otherwise dealing with a proposal. <br /> Likewise, in <b><i>Vallal RCK v. Siva Industries & </i></b><br /> <i>5</i><br /> <b><i>Holdings Ltd.</i></b> <b><i>, </i></b> this Court reiterated that where a <br /> withdrawal under Section 12A of the IBC has received <br /> the requisite approval, the scope of interference <br /> remains narrow and the commercial decision of the <br /> <br /> 3<br /> (2019) 12 SCC 150 <br /> 4<br /> (2020) 8 SCC 531 <br /> 5<br /> (2022) 9 SCC 803 <br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>12</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> <br /><br /> CoC is not to be displaced except on grounds known <br /> to law. <br /> <br /> 12. At the same time, it is necessary to state that primacy <br /> of commercial wisdom does not mean that every action <br /> taken in the insolvency process is altogether immune <br /> from scrutiny in every situation. Where a challenge is <br /> laid in an appropriate proceeding on a legally <br /> sustainable foundation, such as statutory illegality or <br /> a jurisdictional infirmity, the matter would naturally <br /> be considered in accordance with law. However, that <br /> is not the exercise which can be undertaken in the <br /> present MA. In these proceedings, which arise out of a <br /> disposed of SLP in a civil revision concerning an <br /> Agreement to Sell, this Court cannot be called upon to <br /> sit over the comparative financial attractiveness of <br /> rival offers or to substitute its own view for the <br /> business decision taken by the CoC in the statutory <br /> process under the IBC. The mere assertion by the <br /> applicant that its offer was higher would not, by itself, <br /> furnish a ground to reopen the dismissal of the SLP or <br /> to unsettle steps taken in a separate insolvency <br /> framework. <br /> <br /> 13. For all the aforesaid reasons, we are not persuaded to <br /> entertain the present MA as a vehicle either for <br /> reopening the dismissal of the SLP dated 25.02.2025 <br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>13</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> <br /><br /> or for examining the legality of the subsequent steps <br /> taken in the insolvency proceedings. <br /> <br /> 14. Accordingly, Miscellaneous Application No. 1256 of <br /> 2025 is dismissed. In view of the same, MA No. 1257 <br /> of 2025 for ad-interim relief is not required to be dealt <br /> with. <br /> <br /> 15. It is, however, clarified that we have expressed no <br /> opinion on the merits of any proceedings undertaken <br /> under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, <br /> including the order dated 14.05.2025 passed by the <br /> National Company Law Tribunal, or on the merits of <br /> Civil Suit No. 1248 of 2022, which, as per the record <br /> before us, remains pending. All rights and contentions <br /> of the parties in such proceedings are left open to be <br /> urged before the competent forum in accordance with <br /> law. <br /> <br /> 16. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of. <br /> <br /> <br /> <b>………………………………………..J. </b><br /> <b>[VIKRAM NATH] </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>………………………………………..J. </b><br /> <b>[SANDEEP MEHTA] </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>NEW DELHI </b><br /> <b>MARCH 23, 2026 </b><br /> MA 1256/2025 in SLP(C)No.12264/2024 With connected mater Page <b>14</b> of <b>14</b> <br /> </div>