GIRIDHAR AND ORS vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020



IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA



KALABURAGI BENCH

TH
DATED THIS THE 17 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL

WRIT PETITION NO. 226535 OF 2020 (LB-RES)

C/W

WRIT PETITION NO. 204920 OF 2018 (LB-RES)



IN WP No. 226535/2020

BETWEEN:
1. GIRIDHAR S/O BHIMRAO PATIL KUMSI
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
OCC: AGRICULTURE
R/O DEGAON VILLAGE-585316
TQ: ALAND, DIST: KALABURAGI

2. KALYANRAO S/O SHIVALINGAPPA BIRADAR
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS
OCC: AGRICULTURE
R/O DEGAON VILLAGE-585316
TQ: ALAND, DIST: KALABURAGI

3. SHIVAKUMAR S/O AMBARAYYA DOLE
AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS
OCC: AGRICULTURE
R/O DEGAON VILLAGE-585316
TQ: ALAND, DIST: KALABURAGI
…PETITIONERS






Digitally signed by
SWETA KULKARNI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

(BY SRI. SHIVAKUMAR KALLOOR, ADVOCATE)

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


AND:

1 THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT OF PANCHAYAT RAJ
VIDHAN SOUDHA, BENGALUR
BY ITS SECRETARY-586101

2. THE REGIONAL COMMISSIONER
KALABURAGI DIVISION
KALABURAGI-585102

3. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
KALABURAGI-585102

4. THE TAHSILDAR
ALAND, DIST: KALABURAGI-585316

5. ASHOK S/O BASAVANTRAYA MULGE
AGE: MAJOR, OCC: AGRICULTURE
R/O HALTADKAL VILLAGE
TQ: ALAND, DIST: KALABURAGI-585316

6. VITHAL BUJURKE S/O SHVAJIT BUJURKE
AGE: MAJOR, OCC: AGRICULTURE
R/O HALTADKAL VILLAGE
TQ: ALAND, DIST: KALABURAGI-585316

7. RAJKUMAR S/O NAGUNDE
AGE: MAJOR, OCC: AGRICULTURE
R/O SANAGUNDA VILLAGE
TQ: ALAND DIST: KALABURAGI-585316

8. AMBARAYA S/O RAMANNA MELINKERI
AGE: MAJOR, OCC: AGRICULTURE
R/O KUNISANGAVI VILLAGE
TQ: ALAND, DIST: KALABURAGI-585316

9. GUNDERAO S/O SRIMANT TODAD
AGE: MAJOR, OCC: AGRICULTURE

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


R/O BILAGUNDA VILLAGE
TQ: ALAND, DIST: KALABURAGI-585316

10. CHANNABASAPPA S/O S. SAGARE
AGE: MAJOR, OCC: AGRICULTURE
R/O DEGAON VILLAGE
TQ: ALAND, DIST: KALABURAGI-585316

11. SHEKAPPA S/O NAGAPPA DOLE
AGE: MAJOR, OCC: AGRICULTURE
R/O DEGAON VILLAGE
TQ: ALAND, DIST: KALABURAGI-585316
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. MALLIKARJUN SAHUKAR AGA FOR R1 TO R4;
NOTICE TO R6 AND R9 DISPENSED WITH;
R7, R8, R10 AND R11 ARE SERVED;
SRI.A.M.NAGARAL ADV., FOR R5)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 OF
THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO CALL FOR
RECORDS AND ISSUE: A) ISSUE WRIT OF CERTIORARI
QUASHING THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED 19.11.2018 PASSED
BY THE REGIONAL COMMISSIONER I.E. RESPONDENT NO.2 IN
NO. VIDE ANNEXURE-D AND
PÀA/¥ÁæDPÀ/f.¥ÀA/ªÉÄîä£À«/276/2014-15/8962
ALSO THE IMPUGNED NOTIFICATION DATED 21.08.2020 IN
NO.KUM/ELECT/GP/76/2019-20 PASSED BY RESPONDENT NO.3
ANNEXURE-H IN SOFAR IT RELATES TO HALTADKAL GRAM
PANCHAYAT IS CONCERNED; B) ISSUE ANY WRIT ORDER OR
DIRECTION AS THIS HONOURABLE COURT DEEMS FIT IN THE
CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE, IN THE ENDS OF JUSTICE.
IN WP NO. 204920/2018
BETWEEN:
1. CHANNABASAPPA S/O S. SAGRE
AGE: 38 YEARS, OCC: AGRI.,
R/O DEGAON, TQ: ALAND
DIST: KALABURAGI-585316

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


2. SHEKAPPA S/O NAGAPPA DOLE
AGE: 43 YEARS, OCC: AGRI.,
R/O DEGAON, TQ: ALAND
DIST: KALABURAGI-585316
...PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. SHIVAKUMAR H. MANNUR, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY ITS REVENUE SECRETARY
M.S.BUILDING, BENGALURU-560001

2. THE REGIONAL COMMISSIONER
OFFICE OF THE REGIONAL COMMISSIONER
KALABURAGI-585104

3. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
OFFICE OF DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
KALABURAGI-585104

4.
ASHOK S/O BASAVANTRAYA MULGE
AGE: 42 YEARS, OCC: LEGAL
PREACTITIONER, R/O HALTADKAL
TQ: ALAND, DIST: KALABURAGI
AND ALSO RESIDING AT PLOT NO.52/8
NGO LAYOUT, BIDDAPUR COLONY
KALABURAGI-585103

5.
KARNATAKA STATE ELECTION COMMISSION
BY ITS UNDER SECRETARY, KRISHI BHAVAN
CUNNINGHAM ROAD
BENGALURU-560001

6. VITTAL BUJURKE S/O SHIVJAT BUJURKE
AGE: 35 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS
R/O HADTADKAL TQ: ALAND
DIST: KALABURAGI-585316

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


7. RAJKUMAR S/O B. NAGUNDE SANAGUNDA
AGE: 43 YEARS, OCC: AGRI.,
R/O SNAGANGUNDA
TQ: ALAND, DIST: KALABURAGI-585316

8. AMBARAYA S/O RAMANNA MELINKERE
AGE: 32 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE
R/O KUNISANGAVI TQ: ALAND
DIST: KALABURAGI-585316

9. GUNDERAO S/O SRIMANTH TOTAD
AGE: 38 YEARS, OCC: AGRI.,
R/O BILGUNDA, TQ: ALAND
DIST: KALABURAGI-585316
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI.MALLIKARJUN SAHUKAR, AGA FOR R1 TO R3;
SRI.ABDUL MUAHTADIR ADV., FOR R6;
SRI.A.M.NAGARAL ADV., FOR R4;
SRI.P.S.MALIPATIL ADV., FOR R5;
NOTICE TO R7 IS DISPENSED WITH;
SRI.A.M.NAGARAL ADV., FOR R5;
R8 AND R9 SERVED)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO I)
ISSUE A WRIT IN NATURE OF CERTIORARI OR ANY OTHER
SUITABLE WRIT QUASHING ANNEXURE-A I.E, THE ORDER
DATED 19.11.2018 PASSED BY THE REGIONAL
COMMISSIONER, THE RESPONDENT NO.2 HEREIN, IN
NO.PRAAGU/JEE.PAM/MELAMANVI/276/2014-15, AND TO
ALLOW THE WRIT PETITION BY CONFIRMING THE ORDER
DATED 04.02.2015 PASSED BY THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER,
KALABURAGI IN NO.GRAP/67/2014-15 VIDE ANNEXURE-B; II)
PASS ANY SUCH FURTHER ORDER OR RELIEFS OR
DIRECTIONS BE GRANTED TO WHICH THE PETITIONER
WOULD BE FOUND ENTITLED TO ON THE FACTS AND
CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE
AND EQUITY.

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


THESE PETITIONS IS BEING HEARD AND RESERVED ON
13.11.2026, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDERS
THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:-
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL

CAV ORDER
WP.N No.226535/2020 is filed seeking the following
prayers:
“a) Issue a writ of certiorari quashing
the impugned order dated 19.11.2018
passed by the Regional Commissioner i.e.
Respondent No.2 in
No: /276/2014-15/8962
PÀA/¥ÁæDPÀ/f.¥ÀA/ªÉÄîä£À«
vide Annexure-D and also the impugned
Notification dated: 21.08.2020 in
No:KUM/Elect/GP/76/2019-20 passed by
Respondent No.3 vide Annexure-H in so
far it relates to Haltadkal Gram Panchayat
is concerned, in the interest of justice.
b) Issue any writ order or direction as
this Hon’ble Court deems fit in the
circumstances of the case, in the ends of
justice.”


2. WP.No.204920-921/2018 is filed seeking
following prayers:
“i) Issue a writ in nature of certiorari or
any other suitable writ quashing Annexure-
“A” i.e., the Order dated 19.11.2018 passed
by the Regional Commissioner, the
Respondent No.2 herein, in
No.PraAGu/Jee.Pam/Melamanvi/276/2014-
15, to allow the writ petition by confirming

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


the order dated 04.02.2015 passed by the
Deputy Commissioner, Kalaburagi in
No.No.GraPa/67/2014-15 vide Annexure-B.
ii) Pass any such further order or reliefs
or directions be granted to which the
petitioner would be found entitled to on the
facts and circumstances of the case, in the
interest of justice and equity.”


3. The petitioners are the residents of Degaon
Village, Aland Taluk, Kalaburagi District, assailing order
dated 19.11.2018 passed by the Regional Commissioner
(hereinafter referred as ‘RC’ for short), Kalaburagi
Division, Kalaburagi, wherein Degaon village has been
included as one of the village in Haltadkal Grama
Panchayat instead of declaring Degaon as a Gram
Panchayat headquarters.


4. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners
submits that the petitioners are the residents of Degaon
village and the Deputy Commissioner passed an order
dated 04.02.2015, declaring Degaon as a Gram Panchayat
by including Haltadkal and other villages. The said order
was modified by the RC, which was challenged before this

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


Court and the writ petition was dismissed. In appeal, the
matter was remitted back for fresh consideration by the
RC and now the RC, contrary to the material facts passed
the order declaring Haltadkal as a Gram Panchayat
including Degaon and other villages in the said Gram
Panchayat. It is further submitted that the RC had not
applied his mind to the facts of the case, including the
location and convenience of the villagers. It is also
submitted that the petitioners’ village Degaon is more than
15 km away from Haltadkal. However, the present Gram
Panchayat Munnolli is about 5.5 km. It is contended that
the RC has no power to declare the Gram Panchayat under
Section 4 of the Karnataka Gram Swaraj Panchayat Raj
Act, 1996 (for short ‘ the Act ’) and the order is without
jurisdiction and is contrary to the material on record. It is
further contended that the population of Degaon is 1,539
and population of Haltadkal is 1,373. Hence, this factor
would weigh in favour of the petitioners. Hence, seeks to

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


allow the writ petition by setting aside the impugned
orders.


5. Per contra , learned AGA appearing for the
respondent-State and counsel representing the private
respondents support the impugned orders and submit that
the RC after remand had heard all the stakeholders,
considered various documents and came to a conclusion
that Haltadkal should be a Gram Panchayat along with
other villages and the same does not call for any
interference. It is submitted that the Haltadkal has been
newly declared as headquarters of the Panchayat by
considering the fact that Haltadkal is a revenue village and
is a convenient place for all the surrounding villages. It is
further submitted that the population is not the sole basis
to declare a village as headquarters of the Gram
Panchayat. In support of their contentions, they place
reliance on the decision of this Court in the case of

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


Sharanabasanagouda Naregal v. State of Karnataka
1
and Others . Hence, they seek to dismiss the petitions.


6. I have heard the arguments of the learned
counsel appearing for the petitioners, the learned AGA, the
learned counsel appearing for private respondents and
meticulously perused the material available on record. I
have given my anxious consideration to the submissions
advanced.


7. The material on record indicates that the
Deputy Commissioner (hereinafter referred as ‘DC’ for
short), Kalaburagi passed an order dated 04.02.2015
under Section 4(2)(c) of the Act declaring Degaon as a
headquarters of the Gram Panchayat by including Degaon,
Haltadkal, Valavandawadi, Nasirwadi and Barakhed
villages. The RC vide order dated 10.03.2015 by exercising
power under Section 4(3) of the Act sets aside the Deputy

1
(2017) 1 AKR 228

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


Commissioner’s order dated 04.02.2015 by declaring
Haltadkal Gram Panchayat as a headquarters.


8. The petitioners in WP.Nos.204920-921/2018
assailed the order of the RC dated 10.03.2015 before this
Court in WP.No.201920-201928/2015 (LB-RES). This
Court, vide order dated 13.03.2017 dismissed the said writ
petitions. Being aggrieved, they filed a Writ Appeals in
WA.Nos.200063/2017 and 200088-091/2017 (LB-RES).
The Division Bench of this Court vide order dated
05.09.2018 allowed the appeals in part, order of the
learned Single Judge was set aside and the matter was
remitted for reconsideration a fresh by the RC with the
direction to pass speaking order in accordance with law
after extending reasonable opportunity of hearing to all
the concerned by taking into consideration all the relevant
government notifications and pass an order within a period
of eight weeks from the date of receipt of the copy of the
said order. After remand, the RC passed the impugned

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


order dated 19.11.2018 declaring Haltadkal as
headquarters of the Gram Panchayath by including
Haltadkal, Valavandawadi, Nasirwadi, Degaon and
Barakhed villages within its limits. The said order is called
in question.


9. The contention of the learned counsel appearing
for the petitioners that the RC has no power under law to
declare the headquarters of a Gram Panchayat and that
Degaon is more convenient than Haltadkal, as it is a
revenue village, alone cannot be a basis for such
declaration and that population of Degaon is much more
than Haltadkal has no merit as the RC has assigned
detailed reasons for declaring Haltadkal as the Gram
Panchayat headquarters.


10. For the convenience, Section 4 of the Act is
extracted herein below:
“ 4. Declaration of panchayat area
and establishment of Grama
Panchayats .-

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


(1) Subject to the general or special
orders of the Government, the Deputy
Commissioner, if, in his opinion, it is
expedient to declare any area comprising a
village or group of villages having a
population of 1[not less than five thousand
and not more than seven thousand]1 to be a
panchayat area, may, after pervious
publication, declare such area as a panchayat
area for the purposes of this Act and also
specify its headquarter:
Provided that the Government may
order that an area with a population of 1[not
less than two thousand five hundred]1 may
be so declared as a panchayat area in such
areas of the districts of Belgum,
Chickmagalur, Dakshina Kannada, Dharwar,
Hassan, Kodagu, Shimoga , 2[Udupi ,
Haveri]2 and Uttara Kannada as may be
specified by the Government:
Provided further that irrespective of
population, wherever it is found necessary,
the Government, as a special case, may,
order that an area within 1[a radius of five
kilometers (diameter of ten kilometers)]1
from the centre of a village may be so
declared as a panchayat area in such areas

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


of the districts of Belgaum, Chickmagalur,
Dakshina Kannada, Dharwar, Hassan,
Kodagu, Shimoga 1[Udupi , Haveri]1 and
Uttara Kannada as may be specified by the
Government:
Provided also that the Deputy
Commissioner may, with, the previous
permission of the Government declare any
area comprising a village or group of villages
having a population of 1[either less than five
thousand or more than seven thousand]1 to
be a panchayat area.
(2) Subject to the general or special
orders of the Government and the provisions
of this Act, the Deputy Commissioner may, at
the request of the Grama Panchayat
concerned, or otherwise, and after previous
publication of the proposal by notification, at
any time,-
(a) increase the area of any panchayat
area by including within such panchayat area
any village or group of villages;
(b) diminish the area of any panchayat
area by excluding from such panchayat area
any village or group of villages;
(c) alter the head quarters of any
panchayat area;

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


(d) alter the name of any panchayat
area; or
(e) declare that any area shall cease to
be a panchayat area.
(3) The Commissioner may either on
an application made within thirty days from
the date of the notification by any person
aggrieved by such notification, or suo moto,
and after giving a reasonable opportunity of
being heard to the applicant or the Grama
Panchayat concerned revise the orders of the
Deputy Commissioner under sub-section (1)
or sub-section (2) and may also if he
considers necessary, modify it as provided in
the third proviso to sub-section (1). Every
order so passed revising or modifying the
order of the Deputy Commissioner shall be
published in the Official Gazette.
(4) In every panchayat area declared
as such under this section, there shall be
established a Grama Panchayat.”


11. The aforesaid section makes it clear that the
Deputy Commissioner subject to the general or special
order of the Government is of the opinion that it is
expedient to declare any area comprising a village or

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


group of villages to be a panchayat area and specify its
headquarters after previous publication. The aforesaid
section confers power on the Deputy Commissioner to
declare a village or group of villages as a panchayat area,
include a village in the existing Gram Panchayat, exclude a
village from existing Gram Panchayat as well as change
the headquarters of Gram Panchayat. Section 4(3)
provides a revisional remedy before the RC. The RC may
either on an application made by an aggrieved person
within 30 days from the date of notification passed by the
DC under Section 4(1) or suo moto after giving reasonable
opportunity of hearing to the applicant or the Gram
Panchayat concerned, revise the order of the Deputy
Commissioner passed under Section 4(1) or 4(2) of the
Act and every order so passed by the RC after revising or
modifying the order of DC shall be published in the official
gazette. Section 4(3) of the Act confers power on the RC
to alter/modify the order of DC passed under Section 4(1)
and 4(2) of the Act and such order shall be notified.

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


Hence, the contention that the RC has no jurisdiction is
without merit.


12. It is to be noticed that the RC after remand has
considered the submissions advanced by the parties,
material placed by them and by securing the reports from
concerned has passed the impugned order. The RC in the
impugned order has clearly recorded the reasons to
declare the headquarters of the Gram Panchayat with
relevant factors such as the population of the village,
availability of basic amenities, road connectivity,
geographical location, communication facilities,
accessibility and the distance of other villages to the
proposed headquarters of the Gram Panchayat. The RC
has further recorded a clear reason that, although the
Haltadkal is less populated than the Degaon, however,
Haltadkal is situated on the state highway, which is
centrally located among the cluster of villages which forms
a part of the newly created Gram Panchayat, and consists

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


of primary health care center and other facilities which
makes it more suitable to be declared as a headquarters
for administrative purposes. The RC has also recorded the
reason that Haltadkal is approximately 17km away from
Taluka headquarters, whereas, Degaon is 20 km away
from the Taluka headquarters. The RC taking into
aforesaid factors by well reasoned order declared
Haltadkal as a headquarters of Gram Panchayat by
including Degaon and other villages within the extent of
the said Gram Panchayat. The decision in the case of
Sharanabasangounda Naregal referred supra clearly
indicates that the population is not the sole criteria to
decide the headquarters of a Gram Panchayat.


13. It is to be observed that this Court, while
exercising the power under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India is required to examine the process of decision
making of the executive and not the merits of the
decision. If the decision making process is flawed by

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


violation of principles of natural justice, without
jurisdiction by considering irrelevant material or excluding
relevant material, under such circumstances, the judicial
review is permissible. This Court cannot be expected to sit
as an appellate authority and to examine each of the
reasoning assigned by the RC in the impugned order. It is
not in dispute that the executive is the best authority to
determine the headquarters of the Gram Panchayat by
taking into various factors into account. This Court has no
expertise to revise such a decision based on the
statements of the interested persons in the writ
proceedings. Hence, on this ground, this Court does not
propose to interfere with the impugned order by extending
judicial review which would otherwise amount to usurping
the administrative powers of the RC. This Court after
careful consideration of the submissions made, material
placed on record and the impugned order, is of the view
that the impugned order does not suffer from any

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12325
WP No. 226535 of 2020
C/W WP No. 204920 of 2018


CNR: KAHC030215792020


perversity or illegality calling for interference. For the
aforementioned reasons, I proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
The writ petitions are devoid of merits and
the same are rejected .
No order as to costs.



Sd/-
(VIJAYKUMAR A. PATIL)
JUDGE


ABK
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 2