Rattan Kumar And Another vs Monika And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
FAO-1780-2026 (O&M) -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
135 FAO-1780-2026 (O&M)
Date of decision: 12.11.2026
Rattan Kumar and another ....Appellants
Vs.
Monika and others ....Respondents
CORAM : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER
Present: Mr. Nikhil Vats, Advocate
for the appellants.
*
HARSH BUNGER J. (Oral)
CM-6590-CII-2026:
Present application is filed seeking condonation of delay of 434
days in filing the main case i.e. FAO-1780-2026.
For the reasons mentioned in the application, delay of 434 days
in filing the main case i.e. FAO-1780-2026 is condoned.
Application is accordingly disposed of.
FAO-1780-2026 (O&M):
1. The present appeal has been filed by the owners of the truck
dumper, which was involved in a motor vehicular accident, seeking setting
aside of the award dated 15.10.2024 passed by the learned Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal, Jind (hereinafter referred to as 'the Tribunal') in
MACP No. 34 of 2022.
2. Briefly, respondents No. 1 and 2 herein, filed a claim petition
under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (in short, '1988 Act')
seeking compensation on account of death of Sh. Tinku son of Sh. Suresh, in
a motor vehicular accident.
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
FAO-1780-2026 (O&M) -2-
2.1 The aforesaid claim petition was filed by respondents No. 1 and
2 herein/claimants, on the plea that on 14.10.2021, Tinku was coming to his
village Karela from Julana Dairy on his motorcycle bearing
No. HR-12AN-5876 to collect milk, and in between 4:30 AM to 6:00 AM,
when he reached near RPS School situated on Karela-Julana Road, Rakesh
Kumar (proforma respondent No. 4 herein) caused accident by driving his
truck dumper bearing registration No. HR-63E-7535 (hereinafter referred to
as 'the offending vehicle') in a rash and negligent manner and at a very high
speed, by dashing the same into the motorcycle of Tinku. The accident is
stated to have taken place due to rash and negligent act of Rakesh Kumar,
wherein Tinku expired. A case FIR was got registered on the basis of
statement of Sh. Monu (brother of deceased - Tinku).
2.2 In the aforesaid backdrop, respondents No. 1 and 2
herein/claimants filed the claim petition seeking compensation, which was
opposed by the present appellants being owner of the offending vehicle as
well as by Rakesh Kumar (driver of the offending vehicle). Even the
Insurance Company opposed the claim by filing its separate written
statement.
3. From the pleadings of the parties, the learned Tribunal framed
the following issues:-
“1. Whether accident in question took place due to rash and
negligent driving of driver of Truck Dumpher (HIWA),
TATA 2825 SIGNA, No.HR-63E-7535 i.e. respondent No.1?
OPP
2. Whether the claimants are entitled to compensation
claimed. If so, how much and from whom?OPP
3. Whether respondents No.1 to 3 have violated the terms and
conditions of Insurance Policy? OPR-4
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
FAO-1780-2026 (O&M) -3-
4. Whether respondent No.1 was not holding a valid and
effective driving license on the date of accident? OPR-4
Relief.”
4. Thereafter, the parties led their respective evidence on the
aforesaid issues.
5. The learned Tribunal returned the finding under issue No. 1 that
the negligence of Rakesh Kumar (driver of the offending vehicle) in causing
the accident is proved. It was held that the deceased Tinku suffered injuries
in the accident, which was caused due to rash and negligent driving of
Rakesh Kumar while driving the offending vehicle.
6. Further, under issue No. 2, the learned Tribunal assessed the
compensation amount as under:
Srl.
No.
Heads of claim Amount assessed in
rupees
1 Income
₹ 9803/-per month
2 40% future prospects
₹ 3921.2 (in round figure)
₹ 3921/-
3 Total Income
₹ 13,724/- per month
4 1/3rd deduction towards
₹ 4574.66 (in round figure)
₹ 4575/-
5 After deduction, income
₹ 9149/- per month
6 Annual income of deceased
₹ 9149 x 12 = 1,09,788/- ₹
7 Compensation after applying
personal and living expesnes
₹ 1,09,788 x 16 =
₹ 17,56,608/- (A)
8 Funeral expenses
₹ 18,150/- (B)
9 Loss of estate
₹ 18,150/- (C)
10 Spousal consortium
₹ 48,400/- (D)
11 Filial consortium
₹ 48,400/- (E)
Total (A+B+C+D+E) ₹ 18,89,708/-
7. However, as regards the issue as to who is liable to pay the
multiplier of 16
compensation to the petitioners, the learned Tribunal returned the following
findings:-
“26. Now it is to be decided as to who is liable to pay
compensation to the petitioners. The respondents no.1 to 3
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
FAO-1780-2026 (O&M) -4-
being the driver, registered owner, and subsequent power of
attorney holder of offending vehicle and respondent No.4 being
insurer of the offending vehicle are liable to pay the
compensation amount in favour of the claimants. However, the
respondent No.4 shall be entitled to recover the amount of
compensation paid to the petitioners as the offending vehicle
was being plied without route permit. The Tribunal derives
support from Amrit Paul Singh & Anr. Vs. TATA AIG General
Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors. Civil Appeal No.2253 of 2018 date
of decision: May 17, 2018 wherein Hon'ble Supreme Court of
India on Section 66 of Motor Vehicle Act held that use of a
vehicle in public place without permit is a fundamental
statutory infraction. Nothing brought on record by insured to
prove that he had a permit of vehicle. In such a situation, onus
cannot be cast on insurer. Direction issued to insurance
company to pay compensation to claimants with stipulation that
insurer shall be entitled to recover same from owner and driver.
However, the liability to make payment of the compensation to
the claimants shall be several and joint of all the respondents.”
8. Even under issue No. 3, the learned Tribunal held that the driver
as well as the owners of the offending vehicle have violated the terms and
conditions of the insurance policy, as they were plying the offending vehicle
without a valid route permit. Accordingly, vide the award dated 15.10.2024,
the learned Tribunal held all the respondents in the claim petition as jointly
and severally liable to pay the compensation, however, it was observed that
at the first instance, the Insurance Company shall pay the compensation,
however, it shall have the right to recover the same from the driver and
owners of the offending vehicle.
9. Feeling aggrieved against the aforesaid findings, whereby the
recovery rights have been given to the Insurance Company, the present
appeal has been filed by the owners of the offending vehicle.
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
FAO-1780-2026 (O&M) -5-
10. I have heard learned counsel for the appellants and perused the
paperbook with his able assistance.
11. During the course of hearing of this appeal, it is not disputed by
the learned counsel for the appellants that on the date of accident
i.e. 14.10.2021, the appellants were not holding any valid route permit.
12. Here, it would be apposite to refer to a judgment rendered by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of “Branch Manager, The National
Insurance Co. Ltd v. Avipsa Pathak (Minor)”, [Civil Appeal Nos. 7082 -
7083 of 2025 (Arising from SLP(C) Nos.14889-14890 of 2024).
D/d.21.05.2025.] ; wherein it has been observed:-
“11. As is evident from paragraph 13 of the impugned award,
which is extracted as under, the Insurer was held liable in the
following terms:
"13. In the case at hand, it is evident that all other
documents of the vehicle were in order. The Respondent
No.4 on 08-10-2018 had applied for the "route permit"
much before the accident which occurred on 22-10-2018.
The owner of the vehicle cannot be held to ransom for the
tardiness in ministerial and administrative works of the
concerned Department and he cannot be foisted with
paying the Appellant on their satisfying the claims of the
Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 in the absence of wilful
violation of the terms of insurance on his part. Once the
vehicle is validly insured with the Insurance Company and
no terms therein are flouted by the insured, it is the sole
responsibility of the Insurance Company to pay the
compensation."
12. Such a finding, we find to be erroneous and not borne out
from the record. The vehicle in question did not have a valid
route permit as on the date of occurrence of the accident, which
was on 22.10.2018. Mere submission of application to obtain a
route permit prior to the occurrence of the accident, ipso facto,
would not make the vehicle worthy of being plied, as a stage
carriage, on the road. The route permit for plying such a vehicle
ANKIT is a condition precedent under the provisions of the Motor
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
FAO-1780-2026 (O&M) -6-
Vehicles Act, 1988. Hence, the aforesaid findings need to be
reversed to this effect. As such, we hold that even though the
appellant (Insurer) would pay the amount to the claimants but
would be entitled to recover the same, both from the owner and
the driver of the vehicle in question…”
12.1 Further, in “K. Nagendra v. New India Insurance Co. Ltd.”,
2025 AIR (SC) 5281 ; Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under:-
“6. The question that comes up for consideration before this
Court in these appeals is whether any deviation from the
prescribed route as per the permit granted by the state
transportation authority, would impact on the liability of the
Insurance Company for any accident which may take place
while the vehicle is on such a deviated route. An answer to this
question would by itself justify the correctness or lack thereof,
of the order of the High Court which employs the 'pay and
recover' principle.
XXX XXX XXX
8. Now, let us consider the instant case. The record reveals that
the offending vehicle did not have the permit to enter
Channapatna City, where the accident took place. This position
is not in dispute. Unquestionably, therefore, the terms of the
permit have been deviated.
9. The purpose of an insurance policy in the present context is
to shield the owner/operator from direct liability when such an
unforeseen/unfortunate incident takes place. To deny the
victim/dependents of the victim compensation simply because
the accident took place outside the bounds of the permit and,
therefore, is outside the purview of the insurance policy, would
be offensive to the sense of justice, for the accident itself is for
no fault of his. Then, the Insurance Company most certainly
ought to pay.
10. At the same time though, when an Insurance Company takes
on a policy and accepts payments of premium in pursuance
thereto, it agrees to do so within certain bounds. The contract
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
FAO-1780-2026 (O&M) -7-
lays down the four corners within which such an insurance
policy would operate. If that is the case, to expect the insurer to
pay compensation to a third party, which is clearly outside the
bounds of the said agreement would be unfair. Balancing the
need for payment of compensation to the victim vis-a-vis the
interests of the insurer, the order of the High Court applying the
pay and recover principle, in our considered view, is entirely
justified and requires no interference…”
13. When the case in hand is seen in the light of the judgment
rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Branch Manager,
The National Insurance Co. Ltd (supra) as well as K. Nagendra (supra),
no fault can be found with the findings returned by the learned Tribunal
below, so far as grant of recovery rights to the Insurance Company is
concerned.
14. In view of the above, I see no cogent reason which may warrant
interference by this Court in the present proceedings.
15. Resultantly, the present appeal fails and the same is accordingly,
dismissed .
16. All the pending application(s), if any, shall also stand closed.
(HARSH BUNGER)
12.11.2026 JUDGE
Ankit
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh