Sushila And Others vs Amarjeet Singh And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
-1-
110 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
FAO-595-2000
FAO-1981-2001 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 17.11.2026
FAO-595-2000
SMT. RAJESH AND ORS
...Appellants
Versus
AMARJEET SINGH AND ORS
...Respondents
FAO-1981-2001 (O&M)
SUSHILA AND ORS
...Appellants
Versus
AMARJEET SINGH AND ORS
...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PARMOD GOYAL
Present: Mr. Sahil Gupta, Advocate
for the appellants (in both appeals).
Mr. Pranav Arora, Advocate for
Mr. Aditya Sanghi, Advocate
for respondent Nos.1 and 2A.
Dr. Anjali Bansal, Advocate and
Mr. D. R. Bansal, Advocate
for respondent-Insurance company (in both appeals).
PARMOD GOYAL, J. (ORAL)
Present appeals have been preferred by appellants-claimants
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-595-2000
-2-
FAO-1981-2001
being aggrieved by impugned award dated 03.01.2000 passed by learned
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Narnaul (hereinafter referred to as
‘ Tribunal ’) whereby claim petitions preferred by appellants-claimants were
dismissed..
2. Appellants-claimants in FAO No.595 of 2000 being wife,son
and parents of Jitender Kumar (hereinafter referred to as ‘deceased’) and in
FAO No.1981 of 2001 being wife and four children of Shrawan Kumar
(hereinafter referred to as ‘deceased’) had sought compensation on account
of untimely death of deceased persons in accident dated 08.06.1998 by
alleged rash and negligent driving of respondent-driver while driving Tata
four wheeler bearing registration No.HR-35/0595 (hereinafter referred to as
‘offending vehicle’).
3. It was the claim of appellants-claimants in their respective
claim petitions that accident was result of rash and negligent driving of
respondent-driver while driving offending vehicle whereas, on the other
hand respondents had denied their liability and had also denied rash and
negligent driving on the part of respondent-driver.
4. From the pleadings of the parties, following issues were
framed:-
1. Whether the accident in question took place due to the
rash and negligent driving of tata four wheeler bearing
registration No.HR-35/0595 by respondent No.1 as
alleged in the petition?OPR.
2. If issue No.1 is proved whether Jitender son of Bhola
Ram and Sharwan son of Rameshwar died and Basti Ram
sustained injuries in the said accident? OPP.
3. If issues No.1 and 2 are proved whether the petitioners
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-595-2000
-3-
FAO-1981-2001
are entitled for compensation, if so, to what amount and
from whom? OPP.
4. Whether respondent No.1 was not holding a valid and
effective licence at the time of accident? OPR.
5. Whether the petitions are not maintainable in the present
form?OPR.
6. Whether the petitioners of all the consolidated petitions
have not locus standi to file present petitions? OPR.
7. Relief?
5. Learned Tribunal had decided issue No.1 against appellants-
claimants holding that it was deceased-Jitender Kumar who was driving ill-
fated jeep bearing registration No.DL-2-CG-9326 rashly and negligently,
therefore, respondent-driver was not at fault.
6. The above-noted findings were recorded by learned Tribunal
after appreciating evidence of PW-1-Kuldeep Kumar, who claimed to be
eye-witness, PW-4 Investigating Officer of FIR and testimony of PW-8
Basti Ram on whose statement FIR was lodged. Learned Tribunal had also
taken in consideration FIR Ex.PA and had concluded that evidence of PW-1
and PW-8 were totally contrary to each other and therefore, case of
appellants-claimants that accident was result of rash and negligent driving
on the part of respondent-driver while driving offending vehicle could not be
established.
7. It was the case of appellants-claimants that deceased-Jitender
Kumar was driver of ill-fated jeep bearing registration No.DL-2CG-9326
and deceased-Shrawan Kumar along with others had occupied the same at
the time of accident on 08.06.1998. It was the case of appellants-claimants
that jeep driven by deceased-Jitender Kumar along with other occupants had
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-595-2000
-4-
FAO-1981-2001
left Narnaul for Mahendergarh and on their way they had lifted number of
persons namely Basti Ram and Shrawan Kumar etc. It was claimed that jeep
was being driven by deceased-Jitender Kumar at a moderate speed. That
when the jeep had crossed Government College, Mahendergarh a Tata four
wheeler bearing registration No.HR-35/0595 driven by respondent-driver
came from side of Mahendergarh, and was being driven rashly and
negligently. That offending vehicle had hit the ill-fated jeep resulting into
multiple injuries to its occupants resulting into death of Jitender Kumar and
Shrawan Kumar. It was also claimed by appellants-claimants that on the
statement of Basti Ram FIR Ex.PA was got lodged against respondent-
driver. That police had duly investigated the same and had filed challan
against respondent No.1 for causing the accident.
8. The above-noted manner of accident was duly asserted by
Kuldeep Kumar PW-1 who had asserted that it was respondent-driver of
offending vehicle who was at fault for causing the accident. PW-8 Basti
Ram who was author of FIR, however had not supported the case of
appellants-claimants, rather asserted that it was deceased-Jitender Kumar
who was negligent for causing the accident while driving the ill-fated jeep.
Basti Ram (PW-8 had) duly asserted that offending vehicle i.e. Tata four
wheeler bearing No.HR-35/0595 was parked lying on the kaccha portion of
the road when deceased-Jitender Kumar got perplexed and had struck
against the Tata four wheeler vehicle resulting in damage to the jeep as well
as injuries to its occupants.
9. It is worth noticing that in FIR, Basti Ram (PW-8) had
disclosed the manner of occurrence differently than he had disclosed it while
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-595-2000
-5-
FAO-1981-2001
appearing as PW-8. In FIR, he had made the statement to the police that it
was respondent-driver who had caused the accident. However, while
appearing as PW-8, he had duly admitted that jeep had suffered damage on
its front portion whereas offending vehicle had suffered no damage on its
front portion, rather, the offending vehicle had suffered damage on its back
portion as its rear tyres had got detached on account of impact of accident.
10. On re-appreciation of evidence especially that of PW-1, PW-4,
PW-8 as well as contents of FIR Ex.PA, I find that the conclusion drawn by
learned Tribunal cannot be faulted with. Appellants-claimants had failed to
prove their case even as per standard of proof of preponderance of
probabilities, as PW-1 and PW-2 are totally in variance to each other. As per
PW-1 as well as PW-8 both the vehicles were coming from opposite
directions and if both the vehicles were coming from opposite directions
then it was required to be explained by appellants-claimants/PWs examined
by appellants-claimants as to how jeep had suffered damage on its front
portion whereas offending vehicle had suffered damage on its rear portion.
Damage to the offending vehicle belies the manner of accident as stated in
FIR as well as was stated by PW-1. The testimony of PW-8 on oath appears
to be correct version wherein he had clearly stated that accident had
occurred on account of rash and negligent driving by deceased-Jatinder
Kumar.
11. In view of above discussion, I do not find any error in the
findings of learned Tribunal on issue No.1, accordingly, same are affirmed.
12. Faced with above conclusion, learned counsel for the
appellants-claimants has argued that despite the fact that respondent-driver
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-595-2000
-6-
FAO-1981-2001
was not at fault, however, from evidence of PW-1, PW-4 as well PW-8, it is
clearly made out that accident was result of collision between ill-fated jeep
driven by deceased-Jatinder Kumar and offending vehicle being driven by
respondent-driver.
13. Learned counsel for respondent-driver has raised the contention
that learned Tribunal had wrongly rejected the contention raised on behalf of
respondent-driver that offending vehicle was not involved in the accident as
ill-fated jeep had hit a Nilgai. Even, PW-8 who had supported the case of
respondents had specifically denied involvement of Nilgai, rather he had
stated in clear terms that accident had taken place between jeep as well as
offending vehicle though he stated that it was on account of negligence on
the part of deceased-Jatinder Kumar. Therefore, the plea taken by
respondent-driver that offending vehicle was not involved in the accident
was rightly not accepted by learned Tribunal.
14. In view of fact that both the vehicles i.e. jeep as well as
offending vehicle had met with the accident, learned counsel for the
appellants-claimants has argued that even though appellants-claimants are
not entitled to compensation under Section 166 for fault liability in view of
findings of learned Tribunal on issue No.1 even then, appellants-claimants
are entitled to no fault liability under Section 140 of Motor Vehicles Act,
1988. He further submits that since Section 140 has been omitted and new
Section 166 has been enacted w.e.f. 01.04.2022 wherein for no fault liability
lumpsum amount of Rs.5,00,000/- is payable, therefore, appellants-claimants
are entitled to seek compensation under Section 164 of Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 which came in force from 01.04.2022 as same is retrospective in nature
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-595-2000
-7-
FAO-1981-2001
being procedural amendment.
15. Learned counsel for the respondents, however, have resisted the
claim under no fault liability under Section 164 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
on the ground that accident had occurred on 08.06.1998 and therefore
provisions of Section 164 are not applicable in the present case.
16. However, issue whether compensation under Section 164 is
payable in a case where the accident had taken place prior to 01.04.2022, is
not res intergra . Hon’ble Supreme Court in Roopa Vs. The Manager, Orix
Auto Infrastructure Service Ltd. and Anr. , Civil Appeal No.6797 of 2026
decided on 27.04.2026; The New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Urmila
Halder , 2025 ACJ 244; and K.R. Jagadish and Anr. Vs. M/s. National
Insurance Company Ltd. And Anr. , 2025 ACJ 188 has dealt this very
issue and has concluded that since 1988 Act is beneficial legislation and
amendment under Section 164 is procedural in nature, therefore, the
compensation as amended under Section 164 can be awarded to appellants-
claimants who had filed their petition in accident which had occurred prior
to 01.04.2022. In view of authoritative pronouncement by Hon’ble Supreme
Court, it is clearly made out that Section 164 of 1988 Act being procedural
amendment would be retrospective in nature and appellants-claimants would
be entitled to receive compensation mandated therein.
17. Appeals are accordingly, allowed. It is held that appellants-
claimants in FAO No.595 of 2000 are entitled to Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees Five
Lakhs only) and appellants-claimants in FAO No.1981 of 2001 are entitled
to Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees Five Lakhs only) as compensation under Section
164 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The compensation shall be payable along
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-595-2000
-8-
FAO-1981-2001
with interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing of claim petition till its
realization as was awarded by Hon’ble Supreme Court in case titled K.R.
Jagadish and Anr. Vs. M/s. National Insurance Company Ltd. And Anr.
(supra) . Liability to pay compensation shall be on respondents jointly and
severally.
18. Pending application(s), if any, is/are disposed of accordingly.
(PARMOD GOYAL)
17.11.2026 JUDGE
Ravinder
Whether Speaking/Reasoned : Yes
Whether Reportable : Yes/No
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document