Vlcc Personal Care Limited vs Sudhir Solvent Private Limited

Court
Delhi High Court

* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 03.11.2026
Date of Decision: 17.11.2026
Date of Uploading: 17.11.2026

# CNR No. DLHC010378642023
+ CM(M) 1564/2023, CM APPL. 49348/2023, CM APPL.
64765/2026 & CM APPL. 67868/2026
VLCC PERSONAL CARE LIMITED .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Rajshekhar Rao, Sr. Adv.
with Mr. Shantanu Awasthi and
Mr. Shikhar Mittal, Advs.
versus

SUDHIR SOLVENT PRIVATE LIMITED .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Pramod Kumar Sharma,
Mr. Sidhant Aeron, Mr. Sahil
Aeron, Mr. Prakhar Vashisht
and Ms. Vaishnavi Singh,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY DIGPAUL
J U D G M E N T
%
1. The present petition assails the orders dated 01.09.2022 and
07.07.2023 passed by the learned District Judge (Commercial Court),
North District, Rohini Courts, Delhi, in CS (COMM.) 246/2021, titled
Sudhir Solvent Pvt. Ltd. v. VLCC Personal Care Pvt. Ltd. By the first
impugned order dated 01.09.2022, the learned Trial Court held the
petitioner to have been duly served with summons on 16.02.2022 and,
upon finding that no written statement had been filed within the
prescribed period, struck off its defence. The application subsequently
filed by the petitioner seeking recall of that order was dismissed by the
second impugned order dated 07.07.2023.
Signature Not Verified

CM(M) 1564/2023 Page 1 of 13

Signed By:GAURAV
SHARMA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:57:15


2. The respondent/plaintiff instituted the underlying suit on
26.07.2021, seeking recovery of Rs.1,69,32,511.49/-, along with
interest, towards amounts allegedly due for goods supplied to the
petitioner.
3. The recovery suit was taken up by the learned Trial Court on
24.12.2021, when the Court noted that the respondent had completed
the requisite compliances under the Commercial Courts Act, 2015,
and that the suit file was complete in all respects. Summons for
settlement of issues were accordingly directed to be issued to the
petitioner through PF, registered post, speed post, courier, email and
WhatsApp returnable on 28.04.2022.
4. On 28.04.2022, the respondent had also moved an application
under Order VIII Rule 10 CPC, seeking that the petitioner's defence be
struck off on the ground that summons had already been served upon
it through WhatsApp on 16.02.2022, but no written statement had
been filed. As the said application was not mentioned in the order
passed on that date, the respondent moved an application under
Section 151 CPC on 09.05.2022, bringing the omission to the
attention of the learned Trial Court. On 04.07.2022, the learned Trial
Court noted that the application under Order VIII Rule 10 CPC was
already on record and had inadvertently not been mentioned in the
previous order. It accordingly directed that the application be
considered on merits.
5. While considering the application under Order VIII Rule 10
CPC on 04.07.2022, the learned Trial Court noted that, as per the
respondent, summons had been served upon the petitioner through
WhatsApp on mobile number 981880XXXX. Since the petitioner was
a company, the respondent was directed to clarify in whose name the
Signature Not Verified

CM(M) 1564/2023 Page 2 of 13

Signed By:GAURAV
SHARMA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:57:15

said number was registered and the relationship of that person with the
petitioner. The respondent was also directed to send the plaint and the
entire set of documents to the petitioner through email at the two
email addresses mentioned in the affidavit filed by its counsel. The
matter was accordingly listed for further consideration of the
application on 01.09.2022.
6. In compliance with the said direction, the respondent's counsel
sent an email dated 23.07.2022 from her email account,
[email protected] , to five email addresses stated to belong to
the petitioner. In the affidavit of service dated 31.08.2022, filed by
Ms. Alisha Ahuja, counsel for the respondent, she affirmed that the
plaint had been sent to the petitioner at the following addresses:
(i) [email protected] ; (ii) [email protected] ;
(iii) [email protected] ;
(iv) [email protected] ; and
(v) [email protected] . The affidavit further
stated that mobile number 981880XXXX belonged to Mr. Manish Jha,
Chief Business Officer of the petitioner company, and was being used
by him, and that summons had been served on the said number
through WhatsApp on 16.02.2022.
7. When the matter was taken up on 01.09.2022, the learned Trial
Court considered the affidavit filed by the respondent's counsel, which
stated that mobile number 981880XXXX belonged to and was being
used by Mr. Manish Jha, Chief Business Officer of the petitioner
company, and that, in compliance with the order dated 04.07.2022, the
plaint and accompanying documents had also been emailed to the
petitioner at the five addresses mentioned above. On the basis of the
affidavit, the material placed on record and the submissions advanced,
Signature Not Verified

CM(M) 1564/2023 Page 3 of 13

Signed By:GAURAV
SHARMA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:57:15

the learned Trial Court held the petitioner to have been duly served on
16.02.2022. Noting that no appearance had been entered and no
written statement had been filed within the period prescribed under the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015, it struck off the petitioner's defence
and partly allowed the respondent's application under Order VIII Rule
10 CPC. The learned Trial Court, however, did not pronounce
judgment in favour of the respondent and instead posted the matter for
PE.
8. The petitioner stated that it discovered an email relating to the
suit in its spam folder on or about 19.10.2022 and ascertained the
status of the proceedings on 20.10.2022. It entered appearance on
22.11.2022, when the respondent's witness was partly examined-in-
chief, and filed an application under Section 151 CPC seeking recall
of the order dated 01.09.2022. In the application dated 22.11.2022
seeking recall of the order dated 01.09.2022, the petitioner inter-alia
contended that the respondent’s service by email was defective as
three out of five emails on which the petitioner was served belonged
to a sister concern of the petitioner, and the remaining two emails
belonged to employees of the petitioner, who were not the principal
officers of the petitioner.
9. By way of the order dated 07.07.2023, the learned Trial Court
dismissed the application, holding that the circular dated 17.01.2022
passed by the administrative side of this Court, had revived electronic
service and, since summons had been issued on 18.01.2022, service
through WhatsApp was valid. It further held that Mr. Manish Jha,
whose association with the petitioner as its Chief Business Officer was
not disputed, was a principal officer within the meaning of Order
XXIX Rule 2(a) CPC. Finding no patent error or infirmity in the order
Signature Not Verified

CM(M) 1564/2023 Page 4 of 13

Signed By:GAURAV
SHARMA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:57:15

dated 01.09.2022, it declined to recall the same. Aggrieved by the
orders dated 01.09.2022 and 07.07.2023, the petitioner has invoked
the supervisory jurisdiction of this Court under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
10. Mr. Raj Shekhar Rao, learned senior counsel for the petitioner,
submitted that the petitioner could not have been deemed to have been
served on 16.02.2022, as the WhatsApp message sent to Mr. Manish
Jha contained only a photograph of the summons and was not
accompanied by the plaint or the documents filed with it. He drew
attention to the order dated 28.04.2022, which recorded that the
process issued through the process server had not been received back
and directed fresh summons to be issued through all modes. He further
pointed out that, by order dated 04.07.2022, the learned Trial Court
itself directed the respondent to send the plaint and the entire set of
documents to the petitioner by email. The respondent complied with
that direction only on 23.07.2022. Thus, even on the respondent's own
case, the plaint and documents had not accompanied the WhatsApp
summons dated 16.02.2022. Reliance was placed on Order V Rule 2
CPC, which requires every summons to be accompanied by a copy of
the plaint. He also relied upon the order dated 10.07.2020 passed by
the Supreme Court in In Re: Cognizance for Extension of
1
Limitation , which permitted service through instant messaging
applications such as WhatsApp only where the documents were also
served by email simultaneously on the same date. That requirement,
he submitted, had not been fulfilled
11. Mr. Rao next submitted that service of the WhatsApp message
upon Mr. Manish Jha could not constitute service upon the petitioner

1
Suo Motu Writ Petition (C) No. 3 of 2020
Signed By:GAURAV
SHARMA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:57:15
Signature Not Verified

CM(M) 1564/2023 Page 5 of 13

company within the meaning of Order XXIX Rule 2 (a) CPC. The
provision contemplates service upon a corporation through its
secretary, any director or other principal officer, or by leaving the
summons at, or sending it by post to, its registered office. Mr. Jha was
neither a director nor a principal officer authorised to receive
summons on behalf of the petitioner. He was merely its Chief
Business Officer. Learned senior counsel emphasised that the
respondent had itself impleaded the petitioner through three named
directors, namely, Mr. Sanjay Mehta, Mr. Sandeep Ahuja and Mr.
Jayant Khosla, but had not served any of them. Reliance was placed
2
on Shalimar Rope Works v. Abdul Hussain , and Sobran Singh v.
3
Sadhan Sahkari Samiti , to submit that service upon a corporation
must conform to the modes prescribed under Order XXIX Rule 2 (a)
CPC and that service upon an employee, who does not fall within the
categories specified therein, cannot be treated as service upon the
company.
12. He has further challenged the reliance placed on the email dated
23.07.2022. Of the five email addresses to which the respondent
claimed to have sent the plaint, the petitioner contended that three—
[email protected] , [email protected] and
[email protected] —were associated with its sister
concerns and were not regularly used by the petitioner. The remaining
two— [email protected] and
[email protected] —were email accounts
operated by employees and did not belong to any director, principal
officer, authorised representative or person authorised to receive

2
AIR 1980 SC 1163
3
1985 AWC 1045
Signed By:GAURAV
SHARMA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:57:15
Signature Not Verified

CM(M) 1564/2023 Page 6 of 13

summons on behalf of the company. Service through these addresses,
therefore, did not satisfy Order XXIX Rule 2 (a) CPC.
13. Mr. Rao lastly submitted that striking off the petitioner's
defence had consequences far beyond a procedural default. The
petitioner would be required to face adjudication of a claim exceeding
Rs.1.69 crores, along with interest, without being permitted to place
its defence on record or contest the respondent's claim on merits. The
petitioner disputed the amounts claimed, including on the grounds that
the goods supplied were allegedly adulterated and that certain supplies
had failed quality tests. The inability to file a written statement would
thus deprive the petitioner of a meaningful opportunity to defend the
suit. Learned senior counsel urged that procedural requirements
governing service must be observed, but procedural infirmities ought
not to be applied in a manner that defeats substantive justice,
particularly when the petitioner had entered appearance and sought
recall of the order upon learning of the proceedings.
14. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the
petitioner had been duly served with summons on 16.02.2022 through
WhatsApp on mobile number 981880XXXX, which belonged to Mr.
Manish Jha, its Chief Business Officer. He submitted that Mr. Jha was
not an ordinary employee but a principal officer of the petitioner
company, being in charge of its business affairs and directly reporting
to its head. Service upon him, therefore, constituted valid service upon
the company under Order XXIX Rule 2(a) CPC.
15. Learned counsel next submitted that, in any event, the petitioner
had also been served with the plaint and the accompanying documents
through email dated 23.07.2022. Of the five email addresses to which
the email was sent, as mentioned in the affidavit of service dated
Signature Not Verified

CM(M) 1564/2023 Page 7 of 13

Signed By:GAURAV
SHARMA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:57:15

31.08.2022, [email protected] was reflected in the
Ministry of Corporate Affairs records as the registered email address
of the petitioner company. The petitioner could not disown service at
its own registered email address by describing it as belonging to a
sister concern. It was further submitted that
[email protected] and [email protected] were regularly
operated by the key managerial personnel of the petitioner and that the
group companies shared the same registered office and management.
The remaining two email addresses, namely,
[email protected] and
[email protected] , were admittedly operated
by employees of the petitioner. The respondent thus contended that the
petitioner's denial of the email addresses was evasive and could not
invalidate the service effected upon it.

16. Learned counsel further disputed the petitioner's explanation
that the email was discovered in its spam folder only on 19.10.2022.
He pointed out that the email containing the plaint and the
accompanying documents had been sent on 23.07.2022, nearly three
months before the date on which the petitioner claimed to have
discovered it. While relying on a printout of the settings for Gmail, he
submitted that emails received in the spam folder are automatically
deleted after 30 days and, therefore, the petitioner's assertion that the
email had remained there until 19.10.2022 was inherently improbable
and practically infeasible. The respondent contended that the
petitioner could not rely upon its own alleged failure to monitor its
email accounts to explain its absence from the proceedings,
particularly when the plaint and documents had been sent to the email
addresses associated with the company.
Signature Not Verified

CM(M) 1564/2023 Page 8 of 13

Signed By:GAURAV
SHARMA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:57:15


17. Learned counsel also submitted that the petitioner's conduct had
delayed the adjudication of the suit despite service of summons having
been effected on 16.02.2022. Even after the order dated 01.09.2022
striking off its defence, the petitioner entered appearance only on
22.11.2022 and thereafter sought recall of the said order. The
respondent contended that the petitioner's repeated objections to
service, despite the WhatsApp service upon its Chief Business Officer
and the subsequent transmission of the complete plaint and documents
by email, had obstructed the progress of the suit. Such conduct, it was
submitted, was contrary to the object of the Commercial Courts Act,
2015, which seeks to secure expeditious and effective adjudication of
commercial disputes. A defendant could not be permitted to frustrate
that object by raising successive objections to service after failing to
participate in the proceedings.

18. Learned counsel lastly submitted that, once service of summons
was established, the petitioner was bound by the timelines prescribed
for filing a written statement in a commercial suit. Under Order VIII
Rule 1 CPC, as amended by the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, the
written statement could not be taken on record beyond 120 days from
the date of service of summons. Reliance was placed on SCG
Contracts India Pvt. Ltd. v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure Pvt.
4
Ltd , wherein the Supreme Court held that the 120-day period is
mandatory and that, upon its expiry, the defendant forfeits the right to
file a written statement and the Court has no power to extend the time.
Since the petitioner had been served on 16.02.2022 but did not enter
appearance or file its written statement within the prescribed period,

4
(2019) 12 SCC 210
Signed By:GAURAV
SHARMA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:57:15
Signature Not Verified

CM(M) 1564/2023 Page 9 of 13

the learned Trial Court had rightly struck off its defence by order
dated 01.09.2022.
19. Heard. Perused the records.
20. The primary question which arises for consideration is whether
the service of summons through electronic modes on 16.02.2022 and
emails dated 23.07.2022, as stated in the affidavit of service dated
31.08.2022, amounted to valid service upon the petitioner. If the
service by the emails are held to be valid, then the stringent timeline
of 120 days under Order VIII CPC, as enforced by the SCG Contracts
(Supra) case, must necessarily be enforced.
21. However, before adverting to whether the petitioner was validly
served by email on 23.07.2022, it is necessary to examine whether
they were served on 16.02.2022 as summons were sent to Mr. Manish
Jha on WhatsApp. The petitioner, while relying on the summons
report, has submitted that the summons were served without a copy of
the plaint and the same runs afoul of Order V Rule 2 CPC which
requires the summons to be served with the entire plaint. The
respondent has also not led any evidence to show that the summons
were sent along with the copy of the plaint on 16.02.2022 so as to
fulfil the rigours of Order V Rule 2 CPC. It is also borne from the
record that despite said service, the learned trial court ordered fresh
service of summons on 28.04.2022, thereby implying the need for
issuance of fresh summons due to defective issuance and service of
summons on 16.02.2022. Thus, this Court is of the view that the
service dated 16.02.2022 is defective and improper.
22. It is borne from the record that attempts have been made to
serve the petitioner on two occasions viz. 16.02.2022 and 23.07.2022.
Even though the service dated 16.02.2022 has been held to be
Signature Not Verified

CM(M) 1564/2023 Page 10 of 13

Signed By:GAURAV
SHARMA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:57:15

improper, but as there admittedly has been a service by email, this
Court deems it relevant to consider the contemporaneous service viz.
23.07.2022.
23. As regards the email service, the address
[email protected] was reflected in the MCA records as
the petitioner’s registered email address. The petitioner has stated that
the address was also used by its sister concerns and was, therefore,
inaccessible to it. This explanation, however, was not supported by
any material demonstrating that the petitioner had no access to, or
could not receive communications at, the said address. The
prerogative of the respondent/plaintiff was to serve the plaint and
accompanying documents at the registered email address reflected in
the MCA records, and had, in fact, done so. Once a particular email
address is reflected on the petitioner’s own portal with the MCA, it is
the duty of the petitioner to ensure that they have continuous and
uninterrupted access to the same, and if there is any change to the
email address, then there must be prompt efforts by the petitioner to
make the necessary changes on the MCA portal, which has not been
done in the present case. The petitioner cannot be allowed to claim
that they did not have access to their own email ID, without making
any efforts to make the requisite changes on the portal.
24. The respondent had also sent the email to four other addresses,
namely, [email protected] , [email protected] ,
[email protected] and
[email protected] . All four addresses formed part of the
memo of parties filed with the suit. The petitioner subsequently stated
that the second and fourth addresses were associated with sister
concerns, while the other two belonged to its employees. However,
Signature Not Verified

CM(M) 1564/2023 Page 11 of 13

Signed By:GAURAV
SHARMA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:57:15

their inclusion in the memo of parties had remained uncontroverted
until the petitioner filed its application seeking recall of the order
dated 01.09.2022. The respondent had thus not confined its efforts to a
single email address. It had sent the plaint to the registered email
address reflected in the MCA records and to the four additional
addresses disclosed in the memo of parties.
25. In the absence of any material establishing that these addresses
were inaccessible to the petitioner, the respondent had sufficiently
demonstrated its bona fides and discharged its burden of
communicating the plaint and accompanying documents to the
petitioner. The learned trial court has, after appreciating the affidavit
of service and the submissions made at bar, passed a reasoned order
regarding the factum of service, and this Court under Article 227 does
not sit as a court of appeal over disputed questions of fact.

26. Even though the service dated 16.02.2022 was improper,
however, the same does not mean that the petitioner was not validly
served at all. The petitioner, on 23.07.2022, had been served with
copy of the summons and the entire plaint on 5 email IDs, including
the MCA registered email ID, thus, the petitioner would be deemed to
be validly served. Once it is established that the petitioner was validly
served, the necessary rigours of Order VIII, as mandated by the SCG
Contracts (Supra) case must necessarily follow.
27. The SCG Contracts (Supra) case mandates that the 120 day
time period from the date of receipt of summons must be strictly
enforced, especially in cases of commercial suits. In the present case,
since the petitioner has been served, and has received summons, on
23.07.2022 and their 120 days expired on 20.11.2022. The petitioner
has filed their application for recall on 22.11.2022, as seen by the
Signature Not Verified

CM(M) 1564/2023 Page 12 of 13

Signed By:GAURAV
SHARMA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:57:15

affidavit attached thereto. Thus, even aside from the fact that the
petitioner has not shown any cogent reasons for the delay, they were
either ways beyond the statutory time period of 120 days, which is
rigorously enforced with no scope for condonation outside of the 120
days.
28. Thus, from a perusal of the affidavit of service dated
31.08.2022 which clearly mentions that the summons along with the
plaint were served on the MCA registered email ID of the petitioner,
this Court is of the opinion that the petitioner was validly served on
23.07.2022. The email ID as declared on the MCA portal is not just a
mere formality, but signifies the relevant address on which the
petitioner could be contacted. Since the email service has been held to
be proper, there is no quarrel with the fact that the stringent timeline
under Order VIII CPC must be enforced, and the petitioner/defendant
accordingly forfeits their right to file a written statement.
29. The present petition is dismissed accordingly. Pending
applications, if any, also stand dismissed.
30. The judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.


AJAY DIGPAUL, J.

NOVEMBER 17, 2026
gs/sg
Signature Not Verified

CM(M) 1564/2023 Page 13 of 13

Signed By:GAURAV
SHARMA
Signing Date:17.11.2026
19:57:15