JUSTIN vs RAJAN
- Court
- Madras High Court
CMA(MD) No. 139 of 2023
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
Reserved On 15.09.2026
Pronounced On 20.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE K.K. RAMAKRISHNAN
CMA(MD) No. 139 of 2023
CNR:{HCMD010928602022}
Justin
S/o.Rathinam
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. Rajan
S/o.Antony Pitchai
2. The New India Assurance Company Limited,
Through its Divisional Manager,
Pillars Gate, Opposite to Anna Stadium,
Nagercoil.
..Respondent(s)
PRAYER: This Civil Miscellaneous Appeal has been filed under
Section 173 of Motor Vehicle Act, to allow this appeal and enhance the
award amount in M.C.O.P.No.1672 of 2018 on the file of the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, (Special Sub Court Dealing with MCOP
Cases) Tirunelveli, dated 12-04-2022.
For Appellant(s) : Mr.T.Selvakumaran
For Respondent(s) : Mr.C.Deepak for R2
: No Appearance for R1
__________
Page 1 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:31:58 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 139 of 2023
JUDGMENT
The claimant in M.C.O.P.No.1672 of 2018 on the file of the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-Special Subordinate Court, Tirunelveli,
has filed the present Civil Miscellaneous Appeal in C.M.A.(MD)No.139
of 2023, seeking enhancement of the compensation awarded by the
Tribunal by its judgment dated 12.04.2022.
2.Facts of the case:
2.1.The case of the claimant is that, on 20.07.2018 at about
1.15 am, he was travelling in a Mahindra Bolero pickup Truck bearing
Registration No. TN-75-V-3837, which was insured with the second
respondent Insurance Company. The deceased Sahaya Rixon was also
travelling in the vehicle as the owner of the fish being transported. While
the vehicle was proceeding along the Kanyakumari–Rajakamangalam
Main Road, the driver suddenly applied the brakes in a rash and negligent
manner, and the vehicle capsized. As a result, the claimant sustained
grievous injuries to his right leg and other parts of his body, while Sahaya
Rixon died at the spot.
2.2.The claimant filed the claim petition seeking compensation for
the injuries sustained by him. The Insurance Company filed a counter
disputing the manner of the accident and denying negligence on the part
__________
Page 2 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:31:58 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 139 of 2023
of the driver of the insured vehicle. It was therefore contended that the
Insurance Company was not liable to pay compensation.
2.3.Before the Tribunal, the claimant examined P.W.1 to P.W.3
and marked Exs.P1 to P17. On the side of the Insurance Company, R.W.1
and R.W.2 were examined and Exs.R1 to R3 were marked. The disability
certificate was marked as Ex.C1, assessing the claimant’s physical
disability at 45%.
3.Findings of the Tribunal:
3.1.Upon considering the oral and documentary evidence, the
Tribunal fixed negligence on the driver of the offending vehicle and
awarded compensation of Rs.5,84,352/-.
Sl.No. Heads Amounts in Rs.
1 Disability at Rs.5000/- x 45% 2,25,000/-
2 Transport Expenses 10,000/-
3 Attendance Charges 10,000/-
4 Pain and Suffering 50,000/-
5 Extra Nourishment 45,000/-
6 Loss of Convenience 50,000/-
7 Loss of Income 10,000/-
8 Medical Expenses 1,84,352/-
Total Compensation Awarded Rs.5,84,352/-
3.2.Not being satisfied with the quantum of compensation, the
claimant has preferred the present appeal seeking enhancement.
__________
Page 3 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:31:58 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 139 of 2023
4.Submissions of the learned counsel appearing for the
appellant / claimant:
4.1.The learned counsel appearing for the claimant submitted that
the claimant sustained crush injuries to his right leg and underwent
surgery and skin grafting. It was further submitted that, owing to the
nature of the injuries and the resultant impairment of mobility, the
claimant was unable to continue his avocation as a deep-sea fisherman
which also seriously affected his fish-merchandising business. The
learned counsel contended that the Tribunal failed to assess the loss of
earning capacity by applying the multiplier method, awarded an
inadequate amount towards pain and suffering, did not award any amount
towards future medical expenses, and fixed compensation for permanent
disability at only Rs.5,000/- per percentage. It was therefore prayed that
the compensation be enhanced.
5.Submissions of the learned counsel appearing for the
Insurance Company:
5.1.The learned counsel appearing for the Insurance Company
opposed the appeal, contending that no sufficient material had been
produced to justify enhancement of the compensation awarded by the
Tribunal. The learned counsel therefore sought dismissal of the appeal.
__________
Page 4 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:31:58 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 139 of 2023
6.This Court considered the rival submissions and perused the
materials available on record.
7.Point for determination:
Whether the claimant is entitled to enhancement of compensation,
having regard to the nature of the injuries, the percentage of disability and
the consequent loss of earning capacity?
8.Discussion and findings:
8.1.The medical records, particularly the discharge summary and
the other medical documents marked as exhibits, disclose that the
claimant sustained serious injuries, including crush injuries to his right
leg. He underwent surgery and skin grafting. The nature of the injuries
and the treatment undergone demonstrate that the claimant suffered
substantial physical impairment affecting his mobility.
8.2.The disability certificate, marked as Ex.C1, assessed the
claimant’s physical disability at 45%. However, the assessment of
compensation cannot rest solely on the percentage of physical disability
certified by the medical expert. The Court must also examine the effect of
the disability on the claimant’s earning capacity, having regard to the
nature of his occupation and the activities required to carry it on.
8.3.The claimant was engaged in deep-sea fishing and the fish-
__________
Page 5 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:31:58 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 139 of 2023
merchandising business. The injuries sustained by him, particularly the
impairment of his right leg, would undoubtedly affect his capacity to
undertake physically demanding fishing activities. Even if he continues to
carry on his fish business, the reduced mobility would place substantial
restrictions on his ability to perform his erstwhile occupational activities.
At the same time, the evidence does not warrant a finding that his entire
earning capacity has extinguished.
8.4.In these circumstances, this Court considers it appropriate to
assess the claimant’s functional loss of earning capacity at 25%,
notwithstanding the medical assessment of physical disability at 45%.
The compensation under the head of loss of future earning capacity is
therefore recalculated by applying the multiplier method.
8.5.The monthly income of the claimant is fixed at Rs.10,000/-. By
adding 40% towards future prospects, the monthly income works out to
Rs.14,000/-. Applying the multiplier of 17 and taking the functional loss
of earning capacity at 25%, the compensation is calculated as follows:
Rs.14,000 X 12 X 17 X 25% = Rs.7,14,000/-
8.6.Accordingly, a sum of Rs.7,14,000/- is awarded towards loss of
future earning capacity.
8.7.As regards pain and suffering, the claimant sustained crush
__________
Page 6 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:31:58 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 139 of 2023
injuries to his right leg and underwent surgery and skin grafting. Having
regard to the nature of the injuries, the treatment undergone and the
resulting physical discomfort, the sum of Rs.50,000/- awarded by the
Tribunal is wholly inadequate. This Court therefore enhances the
compensation under this head to Rs.1,50,000/-.
8.8.The claimant may also require further medical treatment in
view of the nature of the injuries and the treatment already undergone.
Considering the medical evidence and the possibility of future treatment,
a sum of Rs.50,000/- is awarded towards future medical expenses.
8.9.As regards compensation for permanent physical disability, the
Tribunal awarded Rs.5,000/- per percentage of disability. Having regard
to the nature of the injuries and the continuing impairment, this Court
considers it appropriate to enhance the rate to Rs.7,000/- per percentage.
Accordingly, for 45% disability, the compensation under this head is
recalculated as follows:
45% X 7000 = Rs.3,15,000/-
8.10.It is needless to note that, as per decision of Hon’ble Supreme
Court, in the case K. Suresh v. New India Assurance Company Limited ,
reported in (2012) 12 SCC 274 , it is permissible to award compensation
under both head of loss of earning capacity and permanent disablity.
__________
Page 7 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:31:58 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 139 of 2023
8.11.The remaining heads of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal are confirmed, except to the extent modified herein.
SI.
No
Heads Amount
awarded by
the Tribunal
(Rs.)
Re-quantified
amount by
this Court
(Rs.)
Status
1 Permanent Disability
(Rs.5000/- X 45% by
Tribunal)
(Rs.7000/- X 45% by this
Court)
2,25,000/- 3,15,000/- Enhanced
2 Transport Expenses 10,000/- 10,000/- Confirmed
3 Attendance Charges 10,000/- 10,000/- Confirmed
4 Pain and Suffering 50,000/- 1,50,000/- Enhanced
5 Extra Nourishment 45,000/- 45,000/- Confirmed
6 Loss of Convenience 50,000/- 50,000/- Confirmed
7 Loss of future earning
capacity
10,000/- 7,14,000/- Enhanced
8 Medical Expenses 1,84,352/- 1,84,352/- Confirmed
9 Future Medical Expenses ----- 50,000/- Awarded
Total Compensation
Rs.5,84,352/- Rs.15,28,352/- Enhanced
Awarded
8.11.The compensation awarded by the Tribunal is enhanced by
recalculating the loss of future earning capacity at Rs.7,14,000/-,
enhancing compensation for pain and suffering to Rs.1,50,000/-,
awarding Rs.50,000/- towards future medical expenses and enhancing
__________
Page 8 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:31:58 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 139 of 2023
compensation for permanent physical disability to Rs.3,15,000/-. The
total compensation shall be recalculated after substituting these amounts
for the corresponding amounts awarded by the Tribunal and ensuring that
there is no duplication between overlapping heads.
9.Result:
9.1.In the result, the C.M.A.(MD).No.139 of 2023 is partly
allowed .
9.2.The award dated 12.04.2022 in M.C.O.P.No.1672 of 2018 on
the file of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Special Sub Court
Dealing with MCOP Cases, Tirunelveli is modified and the compensation
is enhanced from Rs.5,84,352/- to Rs.15,28,352/-, together with interest
at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim petition.
9.3.The second respondent / Insurance Company is directed to
deposit the modified award amount of Rs.15,28,352/- , together with
interest at the rate fixed by the Tribunal, after giving credit to any amount
already deposited, within eight weeks from the date of receipt of a copy
of this judgment.
9.4.Upon such deposit, the claimant is permitted to withdraw the
amount due to him in accordance with law.
__________
Page 9 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:31:58 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 139 of 2023
There shall be no order as to costs.
20-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
aas
To
1.The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
The Special Sub Court,
Tirunelveli.
2.The Section Officer,
VR Section,
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court, Madurai.
__________
Page 10 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:31:58 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 139 of 2023
K.K.RAMAKRISHNAN, J.
aas
CMA(MD) No. 139 of 2023
20-11-2026
__________
Page 11 of 11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 05:31:58 pm )