K SUDHAKAR REDDY vs KRISHNA BHAGAYA JALA NIGAM LIMITED REPRESENTED BY ITS

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025
R


CNR: KAHC030129272025



IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA



KALABURAGI BENCH

TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA R

WRIT PETITION NO.203087 OF 2025 (GM-CPC)


BETWEEN:

K. SUDHAKAR REDDY
S/O LATE MUDDUKRISHNA REDDY,
AGE: 66 YEARS, OCC: ENGINEERING CONTRACTOR,
R/O. PLOT NO.156, ROAD NO.10,
JUBILEE HILLS, HYDERABAD-500 033.

…PETITIONER

(BY SRI. MANVENDRA REDDY, ADVOCATE)

AND:




1.










Digitally signed
by SHIVALEELA
D UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
KRISHNA BHAGYA JALA NIGAM LIMITED,
REPRESENTED BY ITS

THE MANAGING DIRECTOR,
KRISHNA BHAGYA JALA NIGAM LIMITED,
RD
PWD ANNEXUE BUILDING, 3 FLOOR,
K.R. CIRCLE, BENGALURU-560 001.

2. THE CHIEF ENGINEER,
KBJNL, CANAL ZONE NO.1,
BHEEMARAYANGUDI,
TQ. SHAHAPUR, DIST. YADGIRI-585 201.

3. THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
KBJNL, SBC O AND M DIVISION,

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025


KHANAPUR, RAICHUR DISTRICT-584 113.

…RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. KRUPA SAGAR PATIL, ADVOCATE)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 227 OF
THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO I) ISSUE A WRIT
IN THE NATURE OF THE CERTIORARI THEREBY QUASHING/SET
ASIDE THE IMPUGNED ORDER ON I.A. NO.IV DATED
26.09.2025 VIDE ANNEXURE-E PASSED BY THE PRINCIPAL
DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, RAICHUR IN COM. O.S.
NO.3/2021. II) ISSUE A WRIT IN THE NATURE OF MANDAMUS
TO REJECT THE APPLICATION IN I.A. NO.IV VIDE ANNEXURE-E
AND ETC.

THIS PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED ON
04.11.2026 AND COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF
ORDER, THIS DAY, THIS COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA R

CAV ORDER
This petition is filed seeking the following reliefs:
“I) Issue a Writ in the nature of the certiorari
thereby quashing/set aside the impugned order on
I.A.No.IV dated 26.09.2025 vide Annexure-E passed
by the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Raichur
in Com.O.S.No:3/2021, in the interest of justice and
equity.
II) Issue a Writ in the nature of mandamus to
reject the application in I.A.No.IV vide Annexure-E,
in the interest of justice and equity.
III) Issue any other suitable Writ or order or
direction which the Hon'ble Court may deems fit in

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025


the circumstances of the case, as stated above, in
the interest of justice and equity.”


2. The brief facts leading to the filing of this Writ
Petition are that the Petitioner has filed Commercial
O.S.No.3/2021 against the Respondents herein for the relief of
a decree directing the Respondents to pay a sum of
Rs.50,14,17,195/- towards the amount of claims settled by the
Court for the work relating to “Construction of SBC distributary
No. 21-A, including its Branches, Laterals, Sub-Laterals, Field
Irrigation Channels and Appurtenant Works” as per the Contract
Agreement dated 05.12.1989, along with interest at the rate of
18% per annum from the date of filing of the suit till the date of
its realisation.

3. It is stated that Respondent No.3/Defendant No.3
filed a written statement refuting the averments of the plaint,
and the co-defendants, i.e., Respondent Nos.1 and
2/Defendants Nos.1 and 2 herein, adopted the said written
statement. It is pleaded that the Petitioner-Plaintiff examined
himself as PW1 and had 103 documents marked as Exs.P1 to
P103. The cross-examination of the Petitioner-Plaintiff as PW1

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025


was deferred on several occasions at the
Respondents/Defendants’ request. It is stated that the
Petitioner-Plaintiff further examined himself and had two
documents marked as Exs.P104 and P105. Again, at the
request of the Respondents/Defendants, the cross-examination
of PW1 was deferred, and he was partly examined on
29.08.2022. At the request of the Respondents/Defendants, the
further cross-examination of the Petitioner-Plaintiff was finally
deferred, and the Petitioner/Plaintiff was fully cross-examined
on 17.10.2022.

4. It is stated that the Respondents/Defendants’
witness DW1 was partly examined on 24.01.2025 and
10.02.2025, and the cross-examination was deferred. It is
further stated that the cross-examination of DW1 was
completed on 29.03.2025, and the matter was posted for the
respective parties’ arguments. It is also stated that the Plaintiff-
Petitioner submitted written arguments with citations after
concluding his arguments, and the matter was posted for the
Respondents-Defendants’ arguments, which were adjourned
from time to time at the Respondents-Defendants’ request. At

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025


that stage, Respondent No.3/Defendant No.3 filed IA No. IV
under Order 18 Rule 17 read with Sec.151 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (for short, ‘CPC’), to recall the order dated
17.10.2022, recall the Petitioner-Plaintiff witness, i.e., PW.1,
and permit the Respondents/Defendants to further cross-
examine.

5. The Petitioner-Plaintiff opposed the application filed
by the Respondents/Defendants. However, the Trial Court, after
hearing both sides, allowed the application by order dated
26.09.2025, thereby recalling the order dated 17.10.2022 and
permitting further cross-examination of the Petitioner-Plaintiff
PW1, subject to payment of costs of Rs.10,000/-, with a
direction that the further cross-examination shall be completed
within 1 or 2 hearings, failing which, the right of the
Respondents/Defendants is deemed to have been forfeited. The
order passed by the Trial Court on 26.09.2025 is impugned in
the present Writ Petition.

6. Sri. Manvendra Reddy, learned counsel for the
Petitioner, submits that the impugned order passed by the Trial
Court is wholly unsustainable, in view of the fact that, upon

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025


conclusion of the recording of the evidence of the witnesses on
both sides, the matter was posted for arguments and the
arguments on the Plaintiff's side were also addressed.
Accordingly, the application filed by the
Respondents/Defendants for recalling and permitting further
cross-examination of the Petitioner-Plaintiff PW1 ought not to
have been entertained by the Trial Court.

7. It is further submitted that the provision for
recalling witnesses shall not be invoked to rectify deficiencies or
lacunae that arose during the recording of evidence;
accordingly, the Trial Court committed a serious error in
entertaining the application and permitting further cross-
examination of PW1. The learned counsel would also submit
that the provision invoked by the Respondents/Defendants is
unavailable to a party and that such a provision would enable
the Trial Court; the said provision can only be invoked by the
Courts.

8. Learned counsel further submits that the suit filed
before the Commercial Court is governed by the provisions of
the Commercial Courts Act, and that the impugned order

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025


passed by the Trial Court does not conform to the object and
provisions of the Commercial Courts Act and the Code of Civil
Procedure. Accordingly, learned counsel prays that the order
passed by the Trial Court dated 26.09.2025 be set aside by
allowing the present petition.

9. Per contra , Sri. Krupa Sagar Patil, learned counsel
appearing for the Respondents/Defendants, submits that the
Petitioner-Plaintiff has filed the suit for recovery of
Rs.50,14,17,195/- from the Defendants, and that the
Defendants have filed a written statement denying the Plaintiff's
claim. It is further submitted that the Respondents/Defendants
have cross-examined the Petitioner-Plaintiff PW1 and have
closed the cross-examination. However, learned counsel
submits that, upon the surfacing of certain documents and to
establish the case on behalf of the Respondents/Defendants, it
has become necessary for the Respondents/Defendants to file
an application seeking recall of the order and permission to
further cross-examine PW1.

10. It is further submitted that there is no mala fide
intention on the part of the Respondents/Defendants to protract

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025


the litigation, and that the Defendants, being Government
officials with no personal interest, have, in bona fide intention,
preferred the application seeking further cross-examination of
PW1 to demonstrate that the claim made by the Petitioner-
Plaintiff is unsustainable. With the aforementioned submissions,
the learned counsel would seek the dismissal of the Writ
Petition.

11. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and
perused the materials placed on record.

12. It is necessary to draw attention to the provisions
invoked by the Respondents/Defendants, as set out in the
application filed in IA No. IV under Order 18 Rule 17 of the CPC,
which is extracted hereunder:
“ 17. Court may recall and examine witness.- The
Court may at any stage of a suit recall any witness
who has been examined and may (subject to the law of
evidence for the time being in force) put such question
to him as the Court thinks fit .”

On a plain reading of the provision, it would without any
ambiguity establish that Rule 17 is an enabling provision for the
Court to recall any witness at any stage of the suit, including

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025


one who has already been examined, and to put such questions
as the Court thinks fit for the purpose of seeking clarification.
The said provision is not available to the parties to the suit to
seek either further examination or further cross-examination. In
essence, the parties to the suit cannot invoke Order 18 Rule 17
to recall and examine witnesses for further examination or
cross-examination.

13. The elucidation of law by the Hon'ble Apex Court,
having considered the provision under Order 18 Rule 17, in the
1
case of Shubhkaran Singh vs. Abhayraj Singh and Others ,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:
“8. The said rule, in our opinion, makes it
abundantly clear that the right to put questions to
the witness recalled under Rule 17 is given only to
the court and even cross-examination is not
ordinarily permitted on the answers given to such
questions, without the leave of the court. Under
that rule therefore, a witness cannot be recalled at
the instance of a party for the purpose of
examining, cross examining or re-examining, and
that rule is not intended to serve such purpose, and
the purpose for which that rule can be invoked is
the one that is indicated above.”


1
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1028

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025



14. In a recent decision, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
the case of K. Bharathamma vs. Bandaru Sakku Bai and
2
Others has laid down the ratio as follows:
“5.7 A frequent resort to use of Order XVIII Rule
17, CPC, has the tendency to develop into an abuse
of process of the court and procrastination of
litigation. The court should not allow this provision
to become a handy tool for a party to the suit
proceedings to prolong the litigation. This aspect
was highlighted by this Court in Gayathri vs. M.
Girish, in which the court emphasized on
completion of trial within a time schedule,
observing that the interlocutory applications
containing prayers for reopening of the evidence
and recalling of witnesses have to be considered
only in compelling facts and on acceptable reasons.
5.7.1 It was therefore observed in K.K. Velusamy
(supra) that the power under Order XVIII Rule 17,
CPC as also under Section 151, CPC, is not intended
to be used in a routine manner and merely for
askance. If permitted to be so used, it would defeat
the very purpose of expediting the trial, in addition
that a dishonest litigant would gain undue
advantage by prolonging the proceedings under the
pretext of recalling of witnesses or reopening of
evidence.
5.8 It is laid down as trite principle that the
provision of Order XVIII Rule 17, CPC, cannot be
invoked on the spacious ground that recalling the
witness or reopening the evidence would not
prejudice the other side. In Vadiraj Naggappa
Vernekar (supra), the court observed thus,
“The power under the provisions of Order 18
Rule 17 CPC is to be sparingly exercised and
in appropriate cases and not as a general rule

2

2026 SCC OnLine SC 1484

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025


merely on the ground that his recall and re-
examination would not cause any prejudice to
the parties. That is not the scheme or
intention of Order 18 Rule 17 CPC.”
(Para 28)
5.9 This Court in Ram Rati v. Mange Ram (Dead)
through Legal Representatives and Others,
reemphasized that the power under this Rule
cannot be invoked to fill up the gaps in the evidence
already led or on the ground that no prejudice
would be caused to the parties thereby. In the said
case, this Court took the exception to the order of
the trial court, where the trial court exercised the
powers on the consideration that recalling of
witness was necessary for left out points.
5.9.1. The Court observed thus,
“The settled legal position under Order
18 Rule 17 read with Section 151 CPC,
being thus very clear, the impugned
orders passed by the trial court as
affirmed by the High Court to recall a
witness at the instance of the
Respondent “for further elaboration on
the left out points”, is wholly
impermissible in law.”
(Para 18)
6. Summing up on the scope, nature and
applicability of the provision of Order XVIII Rule 17,
CPC, on the basis of the provisions of law laid down
in the judicial decisions highlighted above, this
provision is in the nature of power- cum-discretion
vested in the court. It aims to become an aid to the
court in the adjudicating process of the suit. The
provision is in the nature of a facilitator to the court
in the suit proceedings, to be used and invoked
within the discipline of the trial and within the
bounds of the rules of evidence.
6.2 It is not permissible that the evidence by a
party already led and settled is allowed to be

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025


improved by reopening the evidence or recalling the
witness under this Order of CPC. The provision is
not a tool whereby a party can embellish the
evidence, fill in the omissions therein or refine the
evidence at a later stage.
6.3 Also, it is no valid yardstick to be employed for
permitting reopening the evidence or allowing
recalling of a witness that such a course would not
prejudice any party. It is no valid ground for
invoking the powers under Order XVIII Rule 17,
CPC that a party to the proceedings will not be
prejudiced. Not the absence of prejudice but an
independent justification must exist before the
court can legitimately take resort to Order XVIII
Rule 17, CPC.
7.2 In any case and in any view, it was not
permissible in law for the court to exercise the
powers under Order XVIII Rule 17, CPC permitting
the Plaintiffs to recall their witnesses and reopen
the evidence. The directions passed by the High
Court per se did not fell within the purview and
parameters of exercisable powers under Order
XVIII Rule 17, CPC.
7.3 The direction in ‘b’ passed in the impugned
order by the High Court is to complete the cross-
examination of PW-1 within stipulated time.
Indeed, this direction is completely beyond the
scope of Order XVIII Rule 17, CPC. The Bombay
High Court in Balkrishna Shivappa Shetty vs.
Mahesh Nenshi Bhakta and Others, was more
specific in making a statement of law in paragraph
5 of the judgment to observe that Order XVIII Rule
17, CPC does not permit a party to cross-examine a
witness. The position is akin to one obtained in the
facts of the case.
7.3.1 This Court endorses to the following
observations made by the Bombay High Court in
that regard in Balkrishna Shivappa Shetty (supra),

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025


“…The said provision of law apparently does
not deal with the subject of allowing the
parties to cross-examine the witness after
such witness being recalled in exercise of
powers thereunder. In other words, the
provisions contained in Order 18, Rule 17 of
the Code do not empower the Court to recall
the witness for the purpose of cross-
examination by either of the parties though it
does permit recall of witnesses for the
purpose of examination by the Court itself…”
(Para 5)
7.4 It became evident that the Plaintiffs, by filing
interim applications under Order XVIII Rule 17, CPC
for recalling witnesses and seeking to produce
documents under Order VII Rule 14, CPC read with
Section 151, CPC, admitted, and wanted to, fill up
the gaps in the evidence which was already led and
closed, utilising the provision for curing the
lacunae, which was not permissible.
7.5 The frontline reasoning which pervaded the
orders passed by the Trial Court allowing three
interim applications was that no prejudice would be
caused to any party if the Plaintiffs were permitted
to recall the witnesses and the evidence is
reopened. This premise, as stated above, could not
have been the ground to invoke the provision of
Order XVIII Rule 17, CPC. The theory of “no
prejudice” cannot be conveniently applied to justify
invocation of the provision of Order XVIII Rule 17,
CPC.”


15. The Trial Court, without examining the provision of
Order 18 Rule 17 CPC, has perfunctorily entertained the
application filed by the Respondents/Defendants in IA No. IV
solely on the observation that if the Defendants are permitted

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025


to cross-examine PW1, it will not cause any harm or prejudice
to the Plaintiff . On the other hand, it may help the Court
adjudicate the dispute effectively once and for all. Such an
observation by the Trial Court cannot be approved.

16. Indeed, it is pertinent to observe that the decision
of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Shubhkaran Singh, supra ,
though cited, was not properly appreciated by the Trial Court,
despite the Trial Court's own observation that applications
under Order 18 Rule 17 of the CPC cannot be allowed routinely.
It has come on record that such applications are to be
entertained only in special circumstances and with caution.
Notwithstanding the observations in the order, the Trial Court
erred in entertaining the application without finding any special
circumstances that prevailed or compelled the
Respondents/Defendants to invoke Order 18 Rule 17 to recall
PW1 for further cross-examination. Irrespective of any
prejudice that may or may not have been caused, it is not a
ground for entertaining applications under Order 18 Rule 17
without any justification or circumstances compelling the party
to invoke the aforementioned provision.

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025



17. In light of the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court referred to above , this Court is of the
considered view that the Trial Court erred in entertaining the
application to recall PW1 for further cross-examination. It
appears that the Trial Court has lost sight of the fact that the
suit filed by the Petitioner herein is before a Commercial Court,
and that suits filed under the provisions of the Commercial
Courts Act, read with the provisions of the Code of Civil
Procedure, must be decided expeditiously.

18. The suit was filed in 2021 and remains pending
adjudication. Accordingly, the arguments of the learned
counsel for the Petitioner are well-founded, namely, that the
Trial Court committed a serious error by entertaining the
application in a commercial suit and recalling PW-1 for further
cross-examination.

19. In view of the foregoing reasons, this Court is of the
view that the order passed by the Trial Court dated 26.09.2025
in I.A. No. IV is unsustainable and liable to be set aside.

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12218
WP No. 203087 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030129272025



20. Hence, this Court would proceed to pass the
following:
ORDER

(i) The Writ Petition is hereby allowed .

(ii) The order dated 26.09.2025 passed in
Com.O.S.No.3/2021 on I.A. No. IV by the Prl.
Dist. & Sessions Judge, Raichur, is hereby set
aside .


Sd/-
(SUBRAMANYA R)
JUDGE


SDU
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 1
CT: AK