G.Harinath Goud vs The State of Telangana

Court
High Court for the State of Telangana

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA, HYDERABAD
*
WRIT PETITION No. 35654 OF 2026
)
(CNR No. HBHC010731522026
DATE: 12.11.2026
Between :
G. Harinath Goud, S/o. G.Krishna, Aged about 39 years,
Occu: Business, R/o. H.No. 18-3-510, Hamambowli,
Chatrinaka, Hyderabad.
… Petitioner
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal
Secretary, Home Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The Director General of Police, State of Telangana,
Lakdikapul, Hyderabad.
3. The Commissioner of Police, Hyderabad City, Hyderabad.
4. The Deputy Commissioner of Police, South Zone,
Hyderabad,
5. The Assistant Commissioner of Police, Chatrinaka
Division, Hyderabad.
6. The Station House Officer, Police Station Chatrinaka,
Hyderabad.
… Respondents.

ORDER PRONOUNCED ON: 12.11.2026
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N. TUKARAMJI

1. Whether Reporters of Local newspapers
may be allowed to see the Judgment? : Yes

2. Whether the copies of judgment may be
Marked to Law Reporters/Journals? : Yes

3. Whether His Lordship wishes to
see the fair copy of the Judgment? : Yes


________________
N. TUKARAMJI, J

2
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


* THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE N. TUKARAMJI
+ WRIT PETITION No. 35654 OF 2026
(CNR No. HBHC010731522026 )
% 12.11.2026

# Between:

G. Harinath Goud, S/o. G.Krishna, Aged about 39 years,
Occu: Business, R/o. H.No. 18-3-510, Hamambowli,
Chatrinaka, Hyderabad.
… Petitioner

AND
1. The State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal
Secretary, Home Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The Director General of Police, State of Telangana,
Lakdikapul, Hyderabad.
3. The Commissioner of Police, Hyderabad City, Hyderabad.
4. The Deputy Commissioner of Police, South Zone,
Hyderabad,
5. The Assistant Commissioner of Police, Chatrinaka
Division, Hyderabad.
6. The Station House Officer, Police Station Chatrinaka,
Hyderabad.
… Respondents.


! Counsel for the petitioner : Mr. Bommagani Prabhakar,

^Counsel for respondents : Mr. Sridhar Bhuvanagiri, learned
Assistant Government Pleader for
Home, appearing for all the
respondents.

<GIST:
> HEAD NOTE:
? Cases referred
Samala Srinivas Reddy v. State of Telangana , W.P. No. 28545 of 2022,
dated 18.07.2022;

3
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


Modem Mallesham v. Government of Andhra Pradesh , W.P. No. 36878 of
2013, dated 21.11.2025;
Ujwal @ Jagdish v. Commissioner of Police , W.P. No. 16865 of 2025,
dated 23.04.2026;
Kharak Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh , AIR 1963 SC 1295;
Gobind v. State of Madhya Pradesh , (1975) 2 SCC 148;
Malak Singh v. State of Punjab and Haryana , (1981) 1 SCC 420;
Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India , (2017) 10 SCC 1;
Sunkara Satyanarayana v. State of Andhra Pradesh , (1999) 6 ALT 249.

4
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N.TUKARAMJI

WRIT PETITION No. 35654 OF 2026
(CNR No. HBHC010731522026 )
DATE: 12.11.2026

Between :

G. Harinath Goud

… Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal
Secretary, Home Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad, and
five others.

… Respondents.

O R D E R:
This Writ Petition is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India seeking the following relief:
“…to issue an appropriate Writ, Order or Direction, more
particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus, declaring the
action of the respondents in continuing the Rowdy Sheet in the
name of the petitioner at PS Chatrinaka, without any subsisting
material and without periodic review despite acquittal from all the
criminal cases, is illegal, arbitrary and violative of Articles 14 and
21 of the Constitution of India and of the applicable Police
Standing Orders and consequently direct the respondents to
remove the Rowdy Sheet by considering the representations

5
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


dt.16-3-2024, 27-12-2025 and 1-9-2026, and to grant such other
relief or reliefs…”

2. I have heard Mr. Bommagani Prabhakar, learned counsel for the
petitioner and Mr. Sridhar Bhuvanagiri, learned Assistant Government
Pleader for Home, appearing for all the respondents.

3.1. Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the rowdy
sheet opened against the petitioner in the year 2008 on the basis of an
F.I.R. dated 14.09.2008, is being continued for 18 years without any
subsisting material warranting its continuation. It is contended that the
petitioner was acquitted in C.C. Nos. 536 of 2009, 715 of 2009 and 644 of
2011, while in C.C. No. 811 of 2010 only a fine was imposed in
connection with a neighbourhood quarrel and the proceedings in C.C. No.
5824 of 2019 were stopped under Section 258 of the Criminal Procedure
Code, 1973 (CrPC), on 07.09.2022. Since no criminal case has been
registered or pending against the petitioner thereafter, there is no
justification for treating him as a habitual offender or continuing the rowdy
sheet in the absence of any material indicating the likelihood of
disturbance to public order.

3.2. Learned counsel would further submit that the respondents have
neither disclosed the reasons for opening or continuing the rowdy sheet
nor demonstrated that periodical reviews were undertaken in accordance

6
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


with the applicable Police Standing Orders. The continued surveillance,
repeated summoning to the Police Station and social stigma have
adversely affected on the petitioner’s reputation, dignity, privacy and
peaceful family life, thereby infringing his fundamental rights guaranteed
under Constitution. It is further contended that police surveillance cannot
be continued indefinitely as a measure of punishment or harass,
particularly when the petitioner has been leading a peaceful family life.
Therefore, though the petitioner has submitted representations
dated 16.03.2024, 27.12.2025 and 01.09.2026 to the Police Authorities
including the Commissioner of Police, Hyderabad, seeking deletion of his
name from the rowdy sheet, respondents have neither considered the
same nor passed any reasoned order, contending that the continued
maintenance of rowdy sheet is arbitrary, disproportionate and contrary to
the principles of natural justice. The petitioner has, therefore, seeking a
direction to the respondents to delete his name from the rowdy sheet
maintaining at Chatrinaka Police Station.


4.1. Learned Assistant Government Pleader for Home, appearing for all
respondents, would submit that the petitioner having criminal antecedents
and was involved in seven criminal cases relating to offences affecting
public peace and tranquility. It is contended that out of the said cases,
two ended in acquittal, one resulted in conviction, two were compromised,

7
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


one resulted in binding over proceedings and one was discharged under
Section 258 of CrPC, in particular the petitioner was convicted in C.C. No.
100811 of 2010 arising out of Crime No. 402 of 2009 of Chatrinaka Police
Station for the offences punishable under Sections 324, 452 and 504 of
the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC). It is a relevant consideration for
continuing rowdy sheet.

4.2. Learned Assistant Government Pleader would further submit that
the rowdy sheet was opened against the petitioner pursuant to the
directions of the Assistant Commissioner of Police, Falaknuma Division,
dated 31.12.2016 and being maintained up to 31.12.2026 after following
the prescribed procedure under the Andhra Pradesh Police Manual
Orders 599 to 602 and the Circular issued by the Director General of
Police, Hyderabad, dated 22.07.2022. It is further contended that the
petitioner is allegedly continuing indulging in activities causing nuisance
and affecting public peace and tranquility and that members of the public
out of fear reluctant to lodge complaints against the petitioner. Therefore,
continued police surveillance is necessary to monitor his activities and
prevent recurrence of offences of disturbance of public order. He would
also submit that the respondents are merely discharging their legitimate
duties and have neither harassed nor threatened the petitioner nor
interfere with the personal life and liberty and nor they have taken any

8
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


coercive steps. It is further contended that the petitioner has not
disclosed complete particulars and outcome of the criminal cases
registered against him and thereby failed to place entire factual position.
In view of his criminal antecedents, the conviction, alleged continuing
activities affecting public peace and tranquility, respondents contend that
continuance of rowdy sheet is justified and that the writ petition being
devoid of merit is liable to be dismissed.

5. I have carefully considered the rival submissions and perused the
material placed on record.

6. The essential question that arises for consideration is whether the
respondents are justified in continuing the rowdy sheet against the
petitioner for nearly eighteen years, notwithstanding the conclusion of the
criminal proceedings, and whether such continued surveillance is
supported by relevant material and preceded by periodic reviews
undertaken in accordance with the applicable Police Standing Orders.

7. The power of the police to open and maintain a rowdy sheet is
preventive in nature and is intended to protect public peace and maintain
law and order. However, such power is not unfettered and must be
exercised strictly in accordance with the relevant Police Standing Orders
and the constitutional guarantees enshrined under Articles 14, 19 and 21

9
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


of the Constitution of India. Mere past involvement in criminal cases, by
itself, cannot constitute an indefinite justification for opening or continuing
a rowdy sheet or subjecting an individual to surveillance.

8. Standing Order No. 601 of the Telangana State (Andhra Pradesh)
Police Manual, prescribes the categories of persons who may be
classified as rowdies and against whom rowdy sheets may be opened.
Clause (A) thereof includes persons who habitually commit, attempt to
commit or abet the commission of offences involving breach of peace and
disturbance to public order and security. Thus, habituality of conduct and
the existence of relevant material indicating that the activities of an
individual are likely to disturb public peace are relevant considerations for
opening and maintaining a rowdy sheet. Consequently, mere registration
or pendency of criminal cases, without anything more, cannot
automatically justify classifying an individual as a rowdy or continuing a
rowdy sheet against him.

9. This Court, in a number of decisions, has reiterated that
involvement in a solitary criminal case, in the absence of material
establishing habitual criminal activity, would not, by itself, justify the
continued maintenance of a rowdy sheet.

10
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


10. The requirements governing the continuation, discontinuance and
reopening of rowdy sheets are contained in Standing Order Nos. 602 and
735, read with Standing Order No. 742(2) of the Telangana State (Andhra
Pradesh) Police Manual. Standing Order No. 602 requires the competent
authority to consider whether a history sheet or rowdy sheet should be
continued, discontinued or reopened for a further period, in accordance
with the prescribed conditions. Under Standing Order No. 602(2), mere
absence of criminal involvement during the preceding five years does not,
by itself, preclude continuation of a history sheet or rowdy sheet, provided
the competent authority forms a considered opinion, on the basis of
relevant material, that the individual’s activities are prejudicial to the
maintenance of public order or affect peace and tranquillity in the area, or
that victims are unwilling to lodge complaints owing to threats or
intimidation.

11. Further, Standing Order No. 735 prescribes the procedure to be
followed for discontinuance of a history sheet or rowdy sheet and requires
an appropriate order to be passed by the competent authority. Standing
Order No. 742(2) extends the relevant procedural requirements to rowdy
sheets as well. Therefore, continuation of a rowdy sheet cannot be
mechanical or automatic. It must be preceded by periodic review,
supported by relevant material and founded upon the considered

11
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


satisfaction of the competent authority, in accordance with the applicable
Standing Orders.

12. In Samala Srinivas Reddy v. State of Telangana , W.P. No. 28545
of 2022, dated 18.07.2022, this Court emphasised the necessity of
examining whether the activities of an individual continue to be prejudicial
to the maintenance of public order while considering continuation of a
rowdy sheet. Similarly, this Court has directed closure of rowdy sheets in
cases where no subsequent criminal activity or material indicating a threat
to public peace was established. Further, in Modem Mallesham v.
Government of Andhra Pradesh , W.P. No. 36878 of 2013, dated
21.11.2025, this Court reiterated that concluded criminal proceedings and
vague apprehensions cannot, by themselves, justify indefinite
surveillance. Likewise, in Ujwal @ Jagdish v. Commissioner of Police ,
W.P. No. 16865 of 2025, dated 23.04.2026, this Court held that continued
maintenance of a rowdy sheet, without sufficient justification, particularly
in the absence of pending criminal cases, is unsustainable.

13. The constitutional limitations governing police surveillance have
been explained by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in a catena of decisions. In
Kharak Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh , AIR 1963 SC 1295; Gobind v.
State of Madhya Pradesh , (1975) 2 SCC 148; and Malak Singh v. State of

12
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


Punjab and Haryana , (1981) 1 SCC 420, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
recognised the legitimate power of the police to maintain surveillance for
the prevention of crime, but emphasised that such surveillance must be
discreet and must not become an instrument of harassment or unjustified
interference with the personal liberty of an individual. Further, in Justice
K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India , (2017) 10 SCC 1, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court authoritatively recognised the right to privacy as a
fundamental right forming an intrinsic part of Article 21 of the Constitution
and laid down the three-fold test of legality, legitimate State interest or
necessity, and proportionality, which must be satisfied whenever State
action infringes the right to privacy. In Sunkara Satyanarayana v. State of
Andhra Pradesh , (1999) 6 ALT 249, the erstwhile High Court of Andhra
Pradesh also emphasised the necessity of relevant material, independent
application of mind and recorded reasons for opening or retaining
surveillance records. It was further held that surveillance cannot be
resorted to as a means of harassing an individual and that a person
cannot be compelled to attend the Police Station merely because his
name finds place in a rowdy sheet.

14. Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present case,
the petitioner contends that the rowdy sheet was opened against him in
the year 2008, whereas the respondents rely upon the proceedings of the

13
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


Assistant Commissioner of Police to justify its continuation. According to
the respondents, the petitioner was involved in several criminal cases, out
of which two ended in acquittal, two were compromised, one resulted in
binding-over proceedings, one was discharged under Section 258 CrPC,
and one resulted in conviction. In particular, the respondents rely upon
the alleged conviction in C.C. No. 100811 of 2010 for offences punishable
under Sections 324, 452 and 504 IPC. However, the petitioner contends
that the said Calendar Case resulted only in the imposition of a fine in
connection with a neighbourhood quarrel. The discrepancy regarding the
case number and its actual outcome, including the nature of the
conviction, if any, therefore requires due consideration and verification.

15. Nevertheless, even an isolated conviction cannot, by itself,
establish the present necessity for continued surveillance. Similarly,
proceedings terminated under Section 258 CrPC cannot be treated as an
acquittal on merits, though the circumstances surrounding such
termination may be relevant while examining the subsequent conduct of
the individual.

16. The petitioner specifically asserts that no criminal case has been
registered or is pending against him since 2022. Though the respondents
contend that the petitioner has continued to indulge in activities affecting

14
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


public peace and that members of the public are afraid to lodge
complaints against him, they have not placed on record any specific
incident, complaint, occurrence report, preventive proceedings or other
documentary material substantiating such allegations.

17. Further, the annual renewal proceedings produced by the
respondents do not disclose any reasoned order or recorded satisfaction
of the competent authority demonstrating compliance with Standing Order
Nos. 602 and 735. A mere assertion that the prescribed procedure and
the Deputy General Circular dated 22.07.2024 have been followed cannot
substitute the actual review proceedings or the relevant material on the
basis of which the decision to continue the rowdy sheet was taken.

18. The material furnished by the respondents discloses that the
Station House Officer recommended continuation of the rowdy sheet on
the ground that the petitioner was “active and energetic and that a close
watch has been kept on him”. The reviewing authority, namely, the
Assistant Commissioner of Police, merely endorsed the proposal by
stating that “The proposal is hereby permitted to continue the rowdy sheet
up to 31.12.2026.” Such an endorsement, ex facie, does not demonstrate
independent application of mind or establish compliance with Standing
Order Nos. 602 and 735.

15
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


19. It is also relevant to note that the respondents contend that the
rowdy sheet has been continued up to 31.12.2026. Such continuation
cannot be justified merely by referring to the circumstances prevailing at
the time when the rowdy sheet was originally opened. The object of
surveillance is preventive and not punitive. Its continued maintenance, in
the absence of sufficient and contemporaneous justification, would result
in unwarranted interference with the personal liberty of the individual and
may also expose him to social stigma.

20. Further, the petitioner’s representations dated 16.03.2024,
27.12.2025 and 01.09.2026, seeking deletion of his name from the rowdy
sheet, have not resulted in any communicated and reasoned decision by
the competent authority. Failure to consider those representations and
independently examine the continuing necessity for surveillance is
inconsistent with the procedural safeguards governing the exercise of
such power.

21. In view of the absence of any subsequent criminal activity, the
conclusion of the earlier criminal proceedings, the absence of specific
material substantiating the allegations made by the respondents and,
more particularly, their failure to establish that meaningful periodic
reviews were undertaken and supported by reasoned orders of the

16
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


competent authority, this Court is of the considered view that the
continued maintenance of the rowdy sheet against the petitioner is
arbitrary, disproportionate and unsustainable under the applicable Police
Standing Orders and the fundamental rights guaranteed under the
Constitution of India. Accordingly, the respondents have failed to
establish sufficient justification for further continuation of the rowdy sheet
against the petitioner.

22. In view of the foregoing discussion and having regard to the several
judgments rendered by this Court reiterating the manner in which rowdy
sheets are required to be opened, periodically reviewed, continued and
closed in accordance with Standing Order Nos. 601, 602, 735 and 742(2)
of the Telangana State (Andhra Pradesh) Police Manual, as well as the
principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and this Court in the
judgments referred to hereinabove, this Court considers it appropriate to
issue the following operative directions for strict compliance by the police
authorities:

I. PROCEDURE FOR OPENING A ROWDY SHEET:
A. Verification of eligibility: Before proposing the opening of a rowdy
sheet, the Station House Officer (SHO) concerned shall independently
verify whether the individual falls within any of the categories specified

17
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


under Standing Order No. 601 and identify the specific provision
applicable to the case. Mere registration of FIRs, involvement in an
isolated criminal case or past criminal antecedents shall not, by
themselves, justify the opening of a rowdy sheet.
B. Collection and assessment of material: The SHO shall collect and
verify the particulars of all relevant criminal cases, including their crime
numbers, dates, nature of allegations, specific role attributed to the
individual, present status and outcome. The SHO shall assess the
frequency, continuity and nature of the alleged activities and examine
whether the material establishes habitual criminal conduct, wherever
required, and its nexus with disturbance of public peace, public order or
tranquillity, as contemplated under Standing Order No. 601. Fresh
complaints, incidents and other credible material, if any, shall also be
taken into consideration.
C. Submission of a reasoned proposal: Where the eligibility requirements
are satisfied, the SHO shall submit a detailed proposal specifying the
applicable category under Standing Order No. 601, particulars and
outcomes of the criminal cases, material establishing habituality and the
necessity for preventive surveillance. Vague, general or stereotyped
allegations shall not be relied upon.
D. Independent approval: The competent authority shall independently
scrutinise the proposal, verify whether the prescribed eligibility criteria are

18
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


satisfied and examine the material establishing the necessity for
surveillance. It shall not mechanically approve the recommendation of the
SHO and shall record specific reasons for authorising the opening of the
rowdy sheet. The proposal shall be rejected if the requisite conditions are
not established.

II. PROCEDURE FOR PERIODICAL REVIEW AND SEEKING
RENEWAL:
E. Timely review: Every rowdy sheet shall be reviewed periodically in
accordance with Standing Order No. 602, read with Standing Order Nos.
735 and 742(2). The SHO shall initiate the review sufficiently before the
expiry of the prescribed period and submit the renewal proposal within the
stipulated time. Renewal shall not be treated as a routine administrative
formality.
F. Preparation of a comprehensive review report: Before
recommending renewal, the SHO shall undertake a fresh assessment
and furnish a report containing the following particulars:
(a) The date and grounds for the original opening of the rowdy sheet and
the category under Standing Order No. 601;
(b) Particulars of all criminal cases, including those registered after the
opening of the rowdy sheet, together with their present status and
outcomes;

19
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


(c) Whether the individual has figured as an accused in any criminal case
during the preceding five years;
(d) The date of the last criminal case or incident and the period elapsed
thereafter;
(e) Details of fresh complaints, incidents, preventive actions or other
credible material indicating continued involvement in activities warranting
surveillance;
(f) The individual’s conduct during the intervening period and whether the
circumstances that originally necessitated the opening of the rowdy sheet
continue to exist; and
(g) Specific material, if any, indicating that victims or members of the
public are unwilling to lodge complaints owing to threats, intimidation or
fear.
G. Consideration of criminal cases and subsequent conduct: The SHO
shall examine the nature, outcome and relevance of each criminal
proceeding. Acquittals, discharges, compromises, closure reports and
other forms of termination of criminal proceedings shall be duly
considered. The period elapsed since the last criminal case or incident,
the individual’s subsequent conduct, the absence of fresh complaints and
any circumstances indicating cessation of the alleged activities shall also
be taken into account. Old criminal cases, previous entries or an isolated

20
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


conviction from the distant past shall not, by themselves, justify continued
surveillance.
H. Specific consideration of the five-year period: While undertaking the
review under Standing Order No. 602(2), the SHO shall specifically
ascertain whether the individual has figured as an accused in any criminal
case during the preceding five years. If no such case exists, the same
shall be expressly recorded. Though such absence may not automatically
require closure of the rowdy sheet, any recommendation for its
continuation shall identify relevant and current material demonstrating
that the individual’s activities remain prejudicial to public peace, public
order or tranquillity, or that victims are unwilling to come forward owing to
threats or intimidation, as contemplated under the said Standing Order.
I. Reasons for recommending renewal: The renewal proposal shall
clearly distinguish the material forming the basis for the original opening
of the rowdy sheet from the subsequent material justifying its
continuation. Mere repetition of old criminal cases, previous renewal
orders or general apprehensions of future unlawful activities shall not
suffice. Where no fresh criminal case or incident has occurred, the SHO
shall specifically identify and substantiate the other circumstances, if any,
warranting continued surveillance.



21
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


III. INDEPENDENT SCRUTINY BY THE RENEWAL AUTHORITY:
J. Independent application of mind: The competent Gazetted Officer
shall independently scrutinise the entire renewal proposal and the
supporting material and shall not treat the SHO’s recommendation as
conclusive. The authority shall verify whether the individual originally
satisfied the requirements of Standing Order No. 601 and whether the
circumstances justifying the opening of the rowdy sheet continue to
subsist.
K. Verification of criminal antecedents and subsequent conduct: The
renewal authority shall examine the nature of the allegations, the specific
role attributed to the individual, and the status and outcome of each
criminal case relied upon. It shall also assess the period elapsed since
the last criminal case or incident, the individual’s conduct during the
intervening period and the existence of fresh complaints or other credible
material. Mere registration of FIRs or repetition of previous case
particulars shall not, by themselves, establish continuing habitual criminal
activity.
L. Scrutiny of the preceding five years: The renewal authority shall
specifically ascertain whether the individual has figured as an accused in
any criminal case during the preceding five years and expressly address
that circumstance in its order. Where no such criminal involvement exists,
continuation shall be permitted only upon recording a considered opinion,

22
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


supported by relevant and current material, that the individual’s activities
nevertheless remain prejudicial to public peace, public order or
tranquillity, or that victims are unwilling to come forward to lodge
complaints owing to threats or intimidation, as contemplated under
Standing Order No. 602(2). Any allegation of fear or intimidation shall be
independently verified and supported by credible material. A general or
repeated assertion shall not suffice.
M. Assessment of continuing necessity and proportionality: The
renewal authority shall independently determine whether continued
surveillance is necessary in the prevailing circumstances and whether the
available material justifies its continuation. The longer the period of
absence of criminal involvement or adverse conduct, the greater shall be
the need for specific and convincing material supporting renewal. A rowdy
sheet shall not be continued as a punitive measure or indefinitely on the
basis of past conduct alone.
N. Reasoned order granting or refusing renewal: Every renewal
decision shall reflect independent application of mind and specifically
address the eligibility category under Standing Order No. 601, the
relevant criminal cases and their outcomes, subsequent conduct, the
period elapsed since the last incident, the five-year consideration, the
existence of fresh or continuing material and the reasons establishing the
necessity for further surveillance. A stereotyped endorsement or

23
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


mechanical approval shall not constitute valid compliance. Where the
prescribed eligibility requirements or the necessity for continued
surveillance are not established, renewal shall be refused and the rowdy
sheet discontinued in accordance with the applicable Standing Orders.

IV. REPRESENTATIONS, PERSONAL LIBERTY AND
MAINTENANCE OF RECORDS:
O. Consideration of representations: Any representation seeking
deletion of an individual’s name from a rowdy sheet shall be objectively
examined by the competent authority after verifying the relevant criminal
records, outcomes of the proceedings, subsequent conduct and
continuing necessity for surveillance. A reasoned decision shall be
communicated to the individual within a reasonable period, preferably
within four weeks from the date of receipt of the representation.
P. Protection of personal liberty and privacy: The opening or
maintenance of a rowdy sheet shall not, by itself, authorise repeated
summoning or compulsory attendance at a Police Station, restriction of
movements, interference with occupation, or public humiliation or
harassment. Any such action shall have independent legal justification
and shall conform to the procedure established by law. Surveillance,
wherever lawfully warranted, shall be discreet and proportionate to its
legitimate preventive purpose.

24
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


Q. Maintenance of records and accountability: The SHO shall maintain
complete records relating to the opening, review, renewal and closure of
every rowdy sheet, including the supporting material, proposals and
orders passed. The SHO shall ensure the accuracy and verification of the
material submitted, while the competent Officer shall be responsible for
independent scrutiny and recording reasons for the decision.
R. Supervisory scrutiny and discontinuance: The Commissioners of
Police and Superintendents of Police concerned shall ensure the
implementation of these directions through their supervisory officers and
periodically scrutinise the rowdy sheets maintained in their respective
jurisdictions, particularly those continued for prolonged periods or in
respect of individuals against whom no criminal case has been registered
during the preceding five years. Wherever an individual no longer
satisfies the requirements of Standing Order No. 601 or sufficient material
does not exist to justify continued surveillance, the rowdy sheet shall be
discontinued and the consequential surveillance records appropriately
updated. Such discontinuance shall not preclude fresh action in
accordance with law if subsequent credible material warrants it.
S. Strict compliance: All police authorities shall scrupulously adhere to
the aforesaid procedure. No rowdy sheet shall be opened or continued
mechanically, routinely or merely on the basis of past criminal
antecedents. Every decision to open or continue a rowdy sheet shall be

25
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


founded upon relevant material, independent application of mind,
recorded reasons and due regard to the individual's constitutional rights to
personal liberty and privacy.

23. In view of the foregoing discussion and findings, the Writ Petition is
allowed. The continuation of the rowdy sheet against the petitioner,
without relevant and contemporaneous material establishing the
necessity for continued surveillance and without reasoned orders upon
periodic review in accordance with the applicable Police Standing Orders,
is declared arbitrary, disproportionate and violative of the petitioner’s
fundamental rights under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India.

24. Accordingly, the respondents are directed to forthwith close the
rowdy sheet maintained against the petitioner, delete his name from the
relevant surveillance records and update all consequential entries. This
shall not preclude the competent authorities from initiating fresh action in
accordance with law on the basis of any subsequent credible material.

25. To ensure uniform compliance with the applicable Police Standing
Orders and the constitutional safeguards governing personal liberty and
privacy, the following directions are issued to the police authorities
throughout the State of Telangana:

26
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


(i) The Director General of Police, Telangana (DGP), shall issue
appropriate instructions to all Commissioners of Police, Superintendents
of Police and other police authorities concerned, incorporating the
principles and safeguards laid down in this judgment.

(ii) The opening, continuation, periodic review, renewal and
discontinuance of rowdy sheets shall strictly conform to Standing Order
Nos. 601, 602, 735 and 742(2) of the Telangana State (Andhra Pradesh)
Police Manual and the directions issued herein.

(iii) Every proposal for opening a rowdy sheet shall be supported by
relevant material establishing the individual’s eligibility under Standing
Order No. 601 and the necessity for preventive surveillance. Mere
registration of criminal cases, involvement in an isolated case or past
criminal antecedents shall not, by themselves, justify the opening of a
rowdy sheet.

(iv) All existing rowdy sheets shall be periodically reviewed by the
competent authorities, taking into account the individual’s subsequent
conduct, the status and outcome of criminal proceedings, any fresh
incidents or complaints and the continuing necessity for surveillance.
Particular attention shall be given to long-standing rowdy sheets and
cases in which no criminal case has been registered during the preceding
five years.

27
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


(v) Every proposal for renewal shall be independently scrutinised by
the competent authority, which shall record reasons demonstrating the
continuing necessity for surveillance. Mechanical endorsements,
stereotyped orders, reliance solely on past antecedents or general
apprehensions of future unlawful activities shall not suffice.

(vi) Representations seeking deletion of names from rowdy sheets
shall be objectively considered and disposed of by a reasoned order,
preferably within six weeks of receipt.

(vii) The mere maintenance of a rowdy sheet shall not, by itself, result in
repeated summoning or compulsory attendance at a Police Station,
restriction of movement, interference with occupation, public humiliation
or harassment. Any such action must have independent legal justification
and conform to the procedure established by law.

(viii) Complete records shall be maintained in respect of the opening,
review, renewal and closure of every rowdy sheet, including the
supporting material, proposals and reasoned orders. The respective
Commissioners of Police and Superintendents of Police shall ensure
supervisory scrutiny and accountability.

(ix) The DGP shall ensure that these directions are communicated to
all police units and that the officers concerned are sensitised to the legal

28
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


requirements governing preventive surveillance and the constitutional
rights to personal liberty and privacy.

(x) The DGP shall issue the necessary circular instructions and
communicate the compliance framework to all Commissioners of Police
and Superintendents of Police within four weeks from the date of receipt
of a copy of this order. The jurisdictional authorities shall thereafter
undertake a comprehensive review of all existing rowdy sheets and
complete the exercise within three months from the date of receipt of the
said instructions.


26. The DGP, Telangana, shall ensure effective implementation of
these directions. The respective Commissioners of Police and
Superintendents of Police shall monitor compliance within their
jurisdictions and ensure that rowdy sheets are opened or continued only
in accordance with the applicable Police Standing Orders and this order.


27. It is expressly clarified that these directions are intended to
regulate, and not to restrict or curtail, the lawful exercise of preventive
police powers. The competent authorities shall remain at liberty to take
such preventive or other lawful action as may be warranted by any

29
NTR,J
W.P. No. 35654 of 2026


subsequent credible material, provided that such action is taken strictly in
accordance with law.

28. There shall be no order as to costs. All pending miscellaneous
petitions, if any, shall stand closed.

_______________
N.TUKARAMJI, J

Date: 12.11.2026
Note : 1. Registry is directed to serve a copy to the DGP,
Telangana State Police, for appropriate action.
2. L.R. copy to be marked.
B/o.
svl