THE SOUTHERN RAILWAY MAZDOOR vs MAZDOOR WELFARE TRUST
- Court
- Madras High Court
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON : 13-11-2026
PRONOUNCED ON : 20-11-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE N. SATHISH KUMAR
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE GK.MUTHUKUMAAR
OSA No. 230 of 2013
CNR:{HCMA010446832013}
AND
OSA NO. 345 OF 2013, OSA NO. 127 OF 2019, OSA NO. 197 OF 2022
and
CMP NO. 11308 OF 2019, CMP NO. 12019 OF 2022, CMP NO. 16879 OF
2025, CMP NO. 21577 OF 2025,
CMP NO. 22153 OF 2025, MP No.1 of 2013
OSA No.230 of 2013 :
1. The Southern Railway Mazdoor
Union, Rep By its General Secretary N.Kanniah
193-B Railway Colony, Egmore,
Chennai-600008.
2. C.A.Rajasridhar
S/o Cd.Anantha Krishnan No.35 Maleeshwarar
Koil St Mylapore Ch
3. P.Kumaresan
S/o P.M.Palanivelu 116-b Railway Colony
Egmore Ch
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. Mazdoor Welfare Trust
Rep By Its Managing Trustee N.V.Devi
No.11-A/27 Alamelumangapuram 2nd St.,
Chennai-600 004.
2. Smt N.V.Devi
Managing Trustee
__________
Page1 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
No.11-A/27 Alamelumangapuram 2nd St
Chennai-600 004.
3. G.Vadivelu
Trustee -mazdoor Welfare Trust
No.11-A/27 Alamelumangapuram 2nd St
Chennai-600 004.
4. Thirumathi N.V.Usha
Trustee Mazdoor Welfare Trust
227 Gardhawani Kochin House Road
Hemambika Nagar, Palghat, Kerala.
5. S.Thamilarasan
Trustee Mazdoor Welfare Trust
No.2 Xavier Street, Thanjavur
6. Anjalai Ammal Mahalingam Engineering
College, Rep By its Correspondent
Kovilvenni, Thiruvarur district.
..Respondent(s)
OSA No. 345 of 2013
CNR:{HCMA010448142013}
N.V.Usha
Trustee-Mazdoor Welfare Trust
227 Garudhwani Kochin House,
Hemambika Nagar, Palghat, Kerala
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. The Southern Railway
Mazdoor Union Rep By Its General Secretary
N.Kanniah
193-B Railway Colony,
Egmore, Chennai-600 008
2. C.A.Raja Sridhar
S/o C.D.Anantha Krishnan
No.35 Maleeshwarar Koil St.,
Mylapore Chennai-600004
__________
Page2 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
3. P.Kumaresan
S/o P.M. Palanivelu,
116-B Railway Colony Egmore,
Chennai-600008
4. Mazdoor Welfare Trust
Rep By Its Managing Trustee N.V.Devi
No.11-A/27 Alamelumangapuram 2nd Street
Chennai-600004
5. Smt N.V.Devi
Managing Trustee
No.11-A/27 Alamelumangapuram 2nd Street
Chennai-600004
6. Thiru G.Vadivelu
Trustee Mazdoor Welfare Trust
No.11-A/27 Alamelumangapuram 2nd Street
Chennai-600004
7. S.Thamilarasan
Trustee Mazdoor Welfare Trust
No.2 Xavier Street, Thanjavur
8. Anjalai Ammal Mahalingam
Engineering College
Rep By Its Correspondent, Kovilveni
Thiruvarur District
..Respondent(s)
OSA No. 127 of 2019
CNR:{HCMA013141852013}
G.Vadivelu
Trustee Mazdoor Welfare Trust,
No.11-A/27 Alamelumangapuram 2nd Street,
Chennai 600 004.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. The Southern Railway Mazdoor Union
Rep By Its General Secretary N.Kanniah,
__________
Page3 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
191-B, Railway Colony, Egmore,
Chennai 600 008.
2. C.A. Raja Sridhar
S/o. Anantha Krishnan,
No.35, Maleeshwarar Koil Street, Mylapore
Chennai 600 004.
3. P.Kumaresan
S/o. P.M. Palanivelu, 116-B, Railway Colony,
Egmore, Chennai 600 008
4. Mazdoor Welfare Trust,
Rep By Its Managing Trustees, N.V. Devi,
No.11-A/27, Alamelumangapuram 2nd St,
Chennai 600 004.
5. N.V. Devi
Managing Trustee,
No.11-A/27, Alamelumangapuram 2nd Street,
Chennai 600 004.
6. Thirumathi N.V. Usha
Trustee Mazdoor Welfare Trust
227, Garudhwani, Kochin House Road,
Hernamblga Nagar, Palghat, Kerala
7. S.Thamilarasan
Trustee Mazdoor Welfare Trust,
No.2, Xavier St, Thanjavur
8. Anjalai Ammal Mahalingam Engineering
College,
Rep By Its Correspondent, Kovilvenni
Thiruvarur Dist
..Respondent(s)
OSA No. 197 of 2022
CNR:{HCMA013142502013}
1. Mazdoor Welfare Trust
Rep. by its Managing Trustees, N.V.Devi,
__________
Page4 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
No.11-A/27, Alamelumangapuram 2nd Street,
Chennai-600004
2. N.V. Devi
Managing Trustee, Mazdoor Welfare Trust,
No.11-A/27, Alamelumangapuram 2nd Street,
Chennai-600004
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. The Southern Railway Mazdoor Union
Rep. by its General Secretary N.Kanniah,
191-B, Railway Colony, Egmore,
Chennai-600008
2. C.A. Raja Sridhar
S/o.Anantha Krishnan,
No.35, Maleeshwarar Koil Street, Mylapore,
Chennai-600004
3. P.Kumaresan
S/o. P.M.Palanivelu,
116-B, Railway Colony, Egmore,
Chennai-600008
4. Thiru G. Vadivelu
Trustee-Mazdoor Welfare Trust
No.11-A /27, Alamelumangapuram 2nd Street,
Chennai-600004
5. Thirumathi N.V. Usha
Trustee Mazdoor Welfare Trust,
227 Garudhwani, Kochin House Road,
Hernamblga Nagar, Palghat, Kerala
6. Thiru S. Thamilarasan
Trustee Mazdoor Welfare Trust,
No.2, Xavier Street, Thanjavur
7. Anjalai Ammal Mahalingam Engineering
College
Rep. by its Correspondent, Kovilvenni,
Thiruvarur District
..Respondent(s)
__________
Page5 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
OSA No.230 of 2013 is preferred under Order XXXVI Rule 1 of the Original
Side Rules read with Clause 15 of the Letters Patent seeking to allow the OSA
by modifying the judgment and decree dated 07.06.2013 passed in C.S.No.160
of 2004 on the file of this Court by modifying Sub clause III and VI(m) of the
Scheme and pass appropriate orders and thus render justice.
OSA No.345 of 2013 is preferred under Order XXXVI Rule II of the Original
Side Rules read with Clause 15 of the Letters Patent seeking to allow the
original side appeal by modifying the judgment and decree dated 07.06.2013
passed in C.S.No.160 of 2004 so far as the composition of the trust board is
concerned and pass appropriate orders and justice be rendered.
OSA No.127 of 2019 is preferred under Order XXXVI Rule 11 of the Original
side Rules read with clause 15 of the Letters Patent seeking to allow the OS
appeal by modifying the judgment and decree dated 07/06/2013 passed in
C.S.No.160/2004 on the file of this Hon’ble Court and pass such further or other
order as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the
case and thus render justice.
This OSA No.197 of 2022 is preferred under Order XXXVI Rule 1 of the
Original Side Rules read with Clause 15 of the Letters Patent seeking to allow
the OSA by modifying the judgment and decree dated 07.06.2013 passed in
C.S.No.160 of 2004 on the file of this Court and pass such further or other order
as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the case
and thus render justice.
__________
Page6 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
For Appellant(s): Mr.A.L.Somayaji, Senior Advocate
st
for Mr.A.Jenasenan for 1 appellant
Mr.R.Parthasarathy, Senior Advocate
nd rd
for Mr.A.Jenasenan for 2 and 3 appellants
in OSA No.230 of 2013
Mr.M.Balasubramanian in OSA No.345 of 2013
Mr.S.Mukunth, Senior Advocate
for Mr.P.Raja in OSA No.127 of 2019
Mr.P.Sesubalan Raja
for Mr.S.J.Mohamed Sathik
in OSA No.197 of 2022
For Respondent(s): Mr.P.Sesubalan Raja
for Mr.S.J.Mohamed Sathik
for RR1 and 2 in OSA No.230 of 2013;
for RR4 and 5 in OSA No.345 of 2013;
and for RR4 and 5 in OSA No.127 of 2019
Mr.M.Balasubramanian
for R4 in OSA No.230 of 2013
for R6 in OSA No.127 of 2019
Mr.K.Harishankar for R5 in OSA No.230 of 2013;
for R7 in OSA No.127 of 2019
for R-6 in OSA No.197 of 2022
Mr.V.K.Sathiamurthy for R-6
in OSA No.230 of 2013
Mr.C.K.Chandrasekar for R-1
in OSA Nos.345 of 2013 and 127 of 2019
Mr.R.Parthasarathy, Senior Advocate
for Mr.A.Jenasenan for RR2 and 3
in OSA Nos.345 of 2013 and 127 of 2019
Mr.A.L.Somayaji, Senior Advocate
for Mr.A.Jenasenan for R-1
in OSA No.197 of 2022
__________
Page7 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
Mr.R.Parthasarathy, Senior Advocate
for Mr.A.Jenasenan for RR2 and 3
in OSA No.197 of 2022
Common Judgment
N.Sathish Kumar J.
Challenging the judgment and decree of the learned single judge made in
C.S.No.160 of 2004 dated 07.06.2013 whereby a scheme was framed for the
effective administration and management of the affairs of the trust, the present
four original side appeals have been preferred by the respective parties against
some of the findings rendered in the above judgment and with regard to the
composition of trust board.
2.O.S.A.No.230 of 2013 has been filed by the Southern Railway Mazdoor
Union and two others seeking to modify the sub-clause III and VI(m) of the
scheme, while O.S.A.No.345 of 2013 has been preferred by one N.V.Usha, the
trustee of the Mazdoor Welfare Trust challenging the findings in issue no.2
providing one representative of the family of the founder to be on the board of
trustees, composition of the trust board and restricting the number of persons to
be on the Board representing the first plaintiff union. O.S.A.No.127 of 2019 is
filed by one G.Vadivelu, a trustee of the Mazdoor Welfare Trust and
O.S.A.No.197 of 2022 has been preferred by the Mazdoor Welfare Trust and
__________
Page8 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
one N.V.Devi, Managing Trustee of the Trust against the judgment and decree
of the learned single judge and for modification of the judgment and decree
dated 07.06.2013.
3.The parties in these original side appeals are referred to by their rank
before the learned Single Judge.
4.The brief facts of the case can be stated for the disposal of these four
appeals and they are as follows:
4.1.A trust, by name, Mazdoor Welfare Trust was founded by one
M.Namasivayam, who was the then General Secretary of the Southern Railway
Mazdoor Union, in the year 1987. The trust was founded to establish an
educational institution for the benefit of the railwaymen and it was a public
charitable trust. The members of the union have contributed to the trust. The
trust has purchased 60 acres of land for establishing an engineering college in
Thanjavur. Further, three acres of land belonging to the southern railway was
given to the trust. The first defendant Trust was managed by said Namasivayam
as its managing-cum-life trustee along with two vice presidents of the first
plaintiff union till 1996. After the death of the son of Namasivayam in the year
th
1997, the said Namasivayam co-opted the 5 defendant who is the son-in-law as
the trustee and he was also made as Correspondent of the Engineering college.
Thereafter, Namasivayam nominated defendants 2 to 4 as trustees.
Namasivayam had also resigned from the post of the Managing Trustee in the
year 2000 but continued as life trustee. In February, 2001, Namasivayam went
__________
Page9 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
to Haridhwar but never returned back. Thereafter, the defendants 2 to 5 started
to siphon the funds of the trust and mismanaged the institution.
4.2.There were acts of misfeasance and malfeasance on the part of
defendants 2 to 5. On noticing the maladministration of the college and the
trust, the plaintiffs have issued a registered legal notice on 01.09.2003 to
defendants calling upon them to induct at least three members of the union in
the board of trustees and also to make suitable amendments in the trust deed. A
reply notice, dated 24.09.2003 was received from the second defendant that the
first plaintiff union had nothing to do with the trust and further, the second
defendant claimed Rs.2.75 Crores towards expenses incurred by her for
performing some poojas for the return of Namasivayam. Therefore, due to
misappropriation, breach of trust and also mismanagement of the affairs of the
trust, the suit was filed by the union.
4.3.The stand of defendants 1 and 2 was that this court has no territorial
jurisdiction to entertain the suit as the registered office of the Trust is at
Thanjavur. The plaintiff union has no interest in the trust and in the engineering
college. That apart, the Trust was established by Namasivayam in his individual
capacity and not in the capacity as the leader of the plaintiff union. The trust is a
public charitable trust. Further, the object of the trust is not only to help the
mazdoors working in the railways but it is also to help the people belonging to
socially and educationally backward classes. The claim of the plaintiffs that 60
acres of land was purchased by using the contributions of the railwaymen was
__________
Page10 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
false but the entire sale consideration was paid out of trust funds. The trust is an
independent body and the union has no control over the same. The trust is
funded by various philanthropists. Further, the claim to amend the trust deed to
include the representatives of the union would go against the terms of the trust
deed. Further, the fifth defendant is colluding with the plaintiff. There is no
maladministration and breach of trust as averred by the plaintiffs. The third and
fourth defendants have adopted the stand of the defendants 1 and 2 in the
written statement.
4.4.The fifth defendant’s stand was that the trust was founded by
Namasivayam with the object of helping and serving the mazdoors working in
the railways and also to the people belonging to socially and educationally
th
backward classes. The 6 defendant college was established in Thiruvarur from
the contributions of the mazdoors in the southern railway. That apart, when the
said Namasivayam was alive, he had instructed the fifth defendant to get
instructions from plaintiffs 2 and 3 in respect of the running of the trust. The
defendants 2 and 3 wanted to divert the surplus funds of the trust to start a
school in Chennai. Despite having surplus funds, defendants 2 and 3 wanted to
borrow funds from the bank for construction of the institution. It was the
further stand of the fifth defendant that earlier, it was the said Namasivayam,
who wrote a letter dated 12.08.1999 requesting the fifth defendant to continue
as the Correspondent and wanted that the bank accounts are to be operated by
the managing trustee and the fifth defendant. But, after the institution of the suit,
__________
Page11 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
th
the 5 defendant was removed from the board of trustees and also from the post
of Correspondent. That apart, it was the stand of the fifth defendant that as
several acts committed by defendants 2 and 3 are detrimental to the smooth
functioning of the college and therefore, the administration of the trust shall be
under the supervision of the court and the same alone would satisfy the objects
of the founder of the trust. Therefore, for proper administration of the trust, a
scheme has to be framed by the court.
4.5.An interim administrator was appointed by this court during the
pendency of the suit, to take charge of the affairs of the trust. Thereafter,
criminal complaints were lodged against the second defendant and others for
alleged misappropriation, breach of trust, etc., Though the charge sheet has been
filed, the same has been stayed on a petition filed by the second defendant and
others. Further, the second defendant has also filed an application for the
removal of the interim administrator. Thereafter, the main suit was taken up for
hearing. Based on the pleadings, the learned single Judge has framed the
following issues:
(i)Whether a Scheme for the management and administration of
Mazdoor Welfare Trust, which is a public charitable Trust, be
framed or not?
(ii)If so, the persons who are entitled to be appointed as
Trustees and the nature of the provision to be made for
Trusteeship in the first defendant Trust? And
__________
Page12 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
(iii)Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to any other relief?
4.6.On behalf of plaintiffs, 120 documents were marked as Exs.P.1 to
P.120 and on the side of the defendants, 104 documents were marked as
Exs.D.1 to D.104 and out of these 104 documents, Exs.D.1 to D.98 were
marked by defendants 1 and 2 and on the side of defendant no.5, Exs.D.99 to
D.104 were marked. No oral evidence was adduced by the parties to the suit.
4.7.The learned single judge considered the entire documents and the
trust deed and held that the trust is the public charitable trust and therefore, it
cannot be allowed to become a family business and further, there was no unity
among the family members and hence a scheme needs to be framed and
accordingly, framed a scheme. The learned single judge was also of the view
that there must be only one representative from the family of the founder at any
given point of time in the board of trustees and the workers will be represented
in the board of trustees by a person nominated by the first plaintiff union.
Accordingly, the suit was decreed and a scheme was framed. These four
original side appeals have arisen out of the said preliminary judgment and
decree passed by the learned Single Judge.
5.Mr.A.L.Somayaji, learned senior advocate for the union and
Mr.R.Parthasarathy, learned senior advocate for Mr.Jenasenan, learned counsel
submitted that the Mazdoor Welfare Trust has been founded mainly for
establishing educational institution for the benefit of the railway employees by
the contribution of the mazdoor union. Each of the members of the union had
__________
Page13 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
contributed for the same. That being so, the inclusion and giving representation
to the family members of the founder in the board of trustees in the scheme is
not proper. It is the further contention of the learned senior counsel that when
the entire trust is founded for the benefit of the mazdoor union, more members
from the union should be included in the trust. That apart, the establishment of
the college was due to the contributions made by the members of the union.
Though the learned single judge did not permit defendants 2 to 4 to be the
trustees but giving nomination to their children on rotation basis is not fair and
th
proper and further, the appointment of 5 defendant in the trust representing the
family should not have been made and he ought not to have been included and
that proper representations from the union must be provided in the board of
trust.
6.Mr.S.Mukunth, learned senior counsel for defendant no.3 would
submit that the plaintiffs union in order to capture the control of the trust has
filed the suit. The plaintiffs have not submitted any materials to support their
contention of misappropriation and mismanagement of the trust. Further, there
is no criminal complaint against the third defendant. The founder has formed
the trust with the involvement of the family members. The documents submitted
by the defendants 1 and 2 was not properly taken into account.
7.Mr.M.Balasubramanian, learned counsel appearing for the appellant in
OSA No.345 of 2013/4th defendant, Trustee one N.V.Usha mainly submitted
th th
that absolutely, there is no serious allegations against the 4 defendant. The 4
__________
Page14 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
defendant has not filed any affidavit to consider her act as perjury to keep away
from the participation of the trust. According to the learned counsel, the
documents Exs.D.1 to D.98 filed on behalf of defendants 1 and 2 have not been
properly considered by the learned single judge. That apart, the learned single
judge has not considered the contributions made by the founder of the trust for
getting the vast extent of land from the villagers in the Kovilvenni. The learned
single judge ought to have considered the eligible members from the family of
the founder to be in the trust board and therefore, the learned counsel prayed for
modification of the judgment of the learned single judge with respect to the
composition of the trust board.
8.Mr.P.Sesubalan Raja, learned counsel for defendants 1 and 2 Trust
would submit that the entire suit has been filed to establish the private interest
rather than the public interest. The trade union President and Secretary are
trying to capture the trust which was objected by defendants 1 and 2 and others
which resulted in filing the scheme suit. The object of the trust is not only to
help and serve the mazdoors employed in the railways but it is also to help the
people belonging to socially and educationally backward classes. Even as per
the trust deed, there is no provision for the railwaymen to be made as trustees
and further, the trade union has no right to be the trustee. Further, the union
wanted to interfere with the administration of the trust, thereby intended to take
over the administration of the engineering college. That apart, the trust is an
__________
Page15 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
independent body and it is not connected with the trade union. Therefore, the
very suit itself is not maintainable.
9.Mr.K.Harishankar, learned counsel appearing for the fifth defendant
would submit that the learned single judge has considered the entire aspects of
the matter and the serious maladministration committed by defendants 2 to 4 in
the functioning of the trust and recorded the findings based on the documents.
Admittedly, a criminal case has been filed for misappropriation of huge amount
against second defendant. This has been clearly recorded by the learned single
judge. Hence, the learned counsel would submit that the scheme framed by the
learned single judge to be continued.
10.Further, the learned counsel Mr.Sesubalan Raja would submit that if
this court is of the view that the scheme framed has adequate number of
percentage of the composition, the family members would be given primacy,
whereas Mr.A.L.Somayaji, learned senior counsel and Mr.C.K.Chandrasekar,
learned counsel would submit that more members from the union should be
accommodated in the trust as trustees. It is further submitted that though the
learned single judge has named certain persons, due to passage of time, they are
more than 80 to 82 years and therefore, their composition as suggested by the
learned single judge may not be workable. Hence, it was submitted that a new
composition may be included in the trust.
11.In the light of the submissions made by the learned senior counsel and
the learned counsel and on perusal of the materials available, the points that
__________
Page16 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
arise for consideration in these four original side appeals are as follows:
(a)Whether the Mazdoor Welfare Trust is the public trust or the
private trust?
(b)Is there any breach of trust committed by the defendants 2 to 5?
(c)Whether the scheme framed by the learned Single Judge is
proper on considering the nature of the breach of trust alleged
against the persons in the helm of the trust?
Issue Nos.(a) to (c) :
12.This Court considering the nature of the matter and the issues involved
in this case, deems it appropriate to consider all the issues together.
13.The suit filed after obtaining leave under section 92 of the CPC is
normally termed as representative suit of special nature, since the object of
Section 92 is for the protection of public right in public trust and therefore, the
parties filing such suit invoking section 92 of CPC are considered to be
representatives of the public. Three conditions are required to be satisfied in
order to invoke Section 92 of the CPC to maintain an action under the said
provision, namely (i)the trust is created for the public purpose of a charitable or
religious nature; (ii)there is a breach of trust or a direction of the court is
necessary for the administration of such trust and (iii)the relief claimed is one or
the other reliefs as enumerated in the said section. If any one of the three
conditions is satisfied, the matter would be tested within the scope of section
92 of CPC. Therefore, if any breach of trust is proved or a direction of the court
__________
Page17 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
is necessary in the administration of such trust, the suit is very well
maintainable.
14.Admittedly, Ex.D.1 the trust deed makes it very clear that the trust is
founded by one Namasivayam, residing in Railway colony, Egmore, Chennai
and he is the founder of the trust. The other two trustees are one Srinivasan
residing in Railway Colony, Egmore, Cennai and one Govindarajan residing in
North Railway Colony, Villupuram. The intention of the founder of the trust
was only to help and serve the mazdoors working in the railways and the people
belonging to socially and educationally backward classes in general and for that
object, the founder was desirous of creating a public charitable trust. The very
object of the trust was to establish, maintain and administer educational
institutions, imparting general education, technical education, medical
education, nursing etc.; to organize specialised teaching in different branches of
Arts, Science, Medicine and Technology, give instructions in specialised
courses in the aforesaid and allied subjects that may be instituted in any of the
universities in India; to establish and administer the mazdoor school of trade
unionism and impart training and development in industrial relationship and
such other allied subjects; to undertake publication of research studies,
magazines, periodicals etc., produced by the institutions established by the trust;
to hold refresher course, short courses, seminars, conferences and the like on
current, social and socio economic problems and on social, economic cultural
and educational activity for the benefit of persons engaged in social work and/or
__________
Page18 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
in the teaching of the subject relating thereto; to stimulate in the staff and
students of the institutions a sense of social scientific and technical awareness
and cultural conscience; to organize special coaching and training to poor
children and/or provide for free distribution of books, study materials,
educational appliances, etc.,; to give financial assistance in the form of books,
scholarships, stipend etc., to poor and/or meritorious students and grant and
provide for such other financial assistance to the needy as may be considered
appropriate; further to give financial assistance or medical relief to the poor and
the needy people in distress and to establish, maintain and administer clinics
and/or hospitals by employing doctors and other staff to run the same.
15.The very object of the trust under Ex.D.1 makes it very clear that it is
only a public charitable trust. The Ex.D.1 was amended thrice under Exs.D.2 to
D.4 on 29.03.1988, 10.12.1994 and 28.11.1998 respectively. The first
amendment was brought to include certain provisions to bring it in tune with the
provisions of the Income Tax Act, 1961 to seek exemption under the Income
Tax Act. The second amendment was made with a view to enable the trustees to
borrow or accept the deposits from banks and financial institutions. The third
amendment dated 28.11.1998 was done to include three clauses in the original
deed of trust to enable the founder-cum-life trustee to resign from the office of
the managing trustee and to enable the remaining trustees to elect one among
them as the managing trustee. In the third amendment, it is also stated that even
if the managing trustee resigned from his office, he would continue to be a life
__________
Page19 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
trustee. The third amendment was made in the year 1998 under Ex.D.4, dated
28.11.1998 and it is only in the third amendment, defendants 2 to 4 were
inducted as trustees. From the date of inception of the trust deed in the year
1987 till 24.06.1996, only three were trustees, namely Namasivayam,
Govindarajan and Srinivasan. The defendants 2 to 4 got inducted into the trust
only on 06.06.1998 and the fifth defendant in the year 1996. Though the trust
was created as public charitable trust originally, after 1998 the family members
of the founder were included. It is evident that the trust is the public charitable
trust. Further, the very purpose for which the trust was established shows that it
is a public charitable trust.
16.When a dispute arose, this Court had appointed an interim
administrator in April, 2005 while the affairs of the trust was run by defendants
2 to 5. There were serious allegations raised against the managing trustee by
other family members. In fact, the fourth defendant also made serious
allegations against her sister and insisted a criminal complaint of
misappropriation and breach of trust be lodged against the second defendant.
However, later, she withdrew the complaint and joined hands with her own
sister in supporting their stand in the written statement. Further, the fifth
defendant son-in-law was inducted in the year 1996 and defendants 2 to 4 were
inducted in the year 1998. Though the tenure was two years, they got their term
extended thereafter frequently, be that as it may. That apart, after the allegations
of misappropriation and breach of trust, an interim administrator was appointed
__________
Page20 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
and he has unearthed the misappropriation in the trust and has filed a report and
as per the minutes of the meeting which was marked as Ex.P.82, one of the most
serious allegations raised was that about 100 persons were appointed as non
teaching staff without any orders of appointment. Further, it was seen that the
accounts for the year 2004-2005 could not be finalised by the auditor. The
reports of the auditor Exs.P.86, P.88 and P.89 indicated that bearer cheques
have been issued in the name of some employees and accounts were not
finalised. This has been established under various documents and they were
th
analysed by the learned single judge. The 4 defendant has given a letter dated
th
07.05.2006 and the 5 defendant’s wife has also given a letter dated 09.05.2006
for the interim administrator to take criminal action which resulted in filing
criminal case in Crime No.14 of 2006 for the alleged breach of trust of funds of
the trust to the tune of Rs.31,87,220/-. The second defendant and the employees
in whose favour cheques were issued were made as accused. This can be seen in
Ex.D.46, a copy of the FIR and a final report has also been filed in C.C.No.461
of 2007 on the file of the Judicial Magistrate No.1, Mannargudi.
17.Thereafter, it appears that the said proceedings have been challenged
before this court under section 482 of the Cr.P.C. and a stay has been obtained.
This fact has been clearly captured by the learned single judge holding that
there was misappropriation and maladministration of the trust. Further, it was
also established that the second defendant as the managing trustee has not
properly maintained the accounts and that records were missing. These facts in
__________
Page21 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
fact weighed the mind of the learned single judge to frame a scheme. Further, it
was the contention that the contributions were made not only from the members
but also from the private players and the very object of the trust is to serve the
mazdoor workers in the railways and the people belonging to social and
economic backward classes. Though under Ex.D.5, the General Body of the
Union dated 22.06.1998 resolved that the Mazdoor Welfare Trust is an
independent body and the union had no control over the trust, in the same
resolution it was also recorded that the members of the union had contributed
largely to the trust. The founder himself has circulated a booklet titled ‘Mazdoor
Welfare Trust (Reflections and Recollections)’ on the occasion of the launching
of the trust at the Railway community Hall which was also filed as Ex.P.1. At
that point of time, a sum of Rs.4,05,585/- was collection from the donations
made by the mazdoor members. The entire Rs.4,05,585/- came from the
employees of the railway at various branches and divisions. Later, from 1989 to
1994, the founder of the trust issued several circulars in his capacity as general
secretary of the Southern Railway Mazdoor union. These circulars are Exs.P.2
to P.8. Ex.P.2 proved the fact that the list of donations received from various
divisions including Madras, Mysore, Bangalore, Madurai, Trivandrum,
Tiruchirappalli and Palghat East and West divisions totalling to Rs.11,53,322/-.
Under Ex.P.3, a decision was taken in the meetings of the Central Working
Committee of the Union that the college proposed to be started by Mazdoor
Welfare Trust may be located in the Divisional Head quarters which stands
__________
Page22 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
constantly in first place in bonus donation collection in the ensuing years 1989
to 1991. That resolution was also signed by the founder as the General Secretary
of the union. Ex.P.4 the circular sent by Namasivayam as the General Secretary
indicates that a sum of Rs.13,24,366 had been collected from the railwaymen
for the trust. Ex.P.4 also contains a list showing details of donations division
wise and its evaluation of performance. Exs.P.5 and P.6 were also circulars.
Ex.P.6 even proved the fact that all the working committee members and all
branch secretaries should be available and ready at the Thanjavur railway
station to leave for Kovilvenni by 09.00 hours train. This fact clearly shows that
the educational institution was established only from the contributions made by
the members of the mazdoor union.
18.That apart, Ex.P.7 circular dated 16.04.2994 also was issued by the
founder of the trust to all Areas-In-charge calling upon them to account for the
collection and remittance of subscriptions and donations. Similarly Ex.P.8 is the
notice for the meeting of the Central Working Committee of the Union which is
th th
scheduled to be held on 4 and 5 July, 1994 at Thanjavur to enable the
members to visit the site purchased for the proposed engineering college. These
facts clearly establishes that the site was also purchased with the contribution
from the members These documents clearly shows that every branch secretary
and area in-charge and the members of the Central Working committee of the
union have contributed. That apart, the documents, namely Exs.P.9, P.15, P.16,
P.46, P.49, P.50, P.51, P.52, P.53, P.55, P.57 and P.60 proved the fact that an
__________
Page23 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
extent of 3 acres in S.No.510 was requested and finally, under Ex.P.55, an
extent of 4.39 acres railway land has been given. Later, it appears that under
Ex.P.60, the Managing Trustee had requested the District Collector to arrange
for the early acquisition and transfer of the land for the construction of the
college building. These documents were analysed threadbare by the learned
single judge and it was found that the institution was established with the sole
contribution made by the members. Even a further communication was also sent
by the Namasivayam also seeking for further donation, which was also sent by
him as the General Secretary of the union. Even thereafter, for the land
classification, a letter was addressed by Namasivayam not in the capacity as the
Managing Trustee, but in the capacity as the General secretary of the Union.
19.Even Ex.P.17 calendar of the engineering college shows that for the
first time in the history of the country, the workers formed a trust and started a
self financing engineering college. During the 1996-97 academic year, a
decision was also taken to admit two wards of the railwaymen in the college
started by the trust. Even the Souvenir Ex.P.20 proved the fact that
Namasivayam himself has given a message to the effect that it is the only self
financing engineering college managed by the workers in the whole of the Asia.
Ex.P.21 proved the fact that in fact, the family members welcomed the office
bearers of the union and acknowledged the involvement of the members of the
union in the affairs of the trust. Even for the grant of approval by the All India
Council for Technical Education, the letter under Ex.P.22 shows that the
__________
Page24 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
founder of the trust indicated that the college was funded by lakhs of
railwaymen. All the documents, namely Ex.P.1 to P.18 and P.20 to P.22 clearly
captured the role played by the workers and the union in the formation of the
trust and the establishment of the college. The audit certificate for the year
1988-89 of the college also included the receipts and payment of the Mazdoor
Welfare Trust. Further, Exs.P.43, P.47, P.56, P.62 and P.64 also proved the
collection of donations by the mazdoor welfare trust. Ex.P.38 described the
number of collections and who are the sponsors of the Mazdoor Welfare Trust,
etc., From the above documents, it is clearly found that Namasivayam, who was
the founder of trust, on his own words indicated that from the huge
contributions made by the members of the union, the institution came to be
established. This has been clearly recorded by the learned single judge by
analysing every document. For the first time, only in 1998, the family members
were made as trustees and there is absolutely no contributions from the family
members.
20.Though it is contended by defendants that apart from the contributions
made by the members, there were huge contributions received from various
persons and documents were filed as Ex.D.98 series to support the same and
though much emphasis was made under Ex.D.98 that various contributions have
been made by third parties, these payments were said to have been made 16 to
18 years ago. Absolutely there is no evidence whatsoever to show that these
payments were made with proper accounts and whether any exemptions were
__________
Page25 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
obtained under the Income Tax Act, etc., If really defendants wanted to prove
these documents, they ought to have examined the author of those documents.
However, they have not chosen to let in any oral evidence. Therefore, we are of
the view that merely on the basis of some self styled receipts, such huge
donations cannot be inferred to have been contributed by the third parties. The
alleged donations exceeding more than a crore rupees without any semblance
of evidence do not prove the donations for the trust. Therefore, without
examining any persons who have donated such huge sum, merely on the basis
of some self styled receipts, the contention of the defendants cannot be
countenanced. In this regard, the learned single judge has rightly rejected these
documents and disbelieved the documents. In the absence of any proof of actual
payments and parties who were said to have issued the same, without the
evidence of the actual payment by the persons who have donated, such
documents cannot be taken as proof for such huge donation. Further, absolutely
there is no accounts whatsoever filed to show that these amounts have come to
the accounts of the trust. Therefore, the learned single judge was right in
disbelieving the documents. Therefore, we are of the view that once the trust is
formed out of the contributions made by the members of the Mazdoors and
there is no contribution by the family members proved, such family members
cannot seek inherited right as if it is a private property of the family.
21.As there are serious allegations of misappropriation unearthed by the
administrator appointed by this court and in respect of which, criminal case has
__________
Page26 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
been given, taken cognizance by the court, which is pending, merely because
the same has been stayed, that will not wipe out the allegations of
misappropriation and the breach of trust. Further serious allegations have been
raised by defendants 2 and 4 against each of them. In fact, as rightly observed
by the learned single judge, the fourth defendant withdrew the complaint given
against the second defendant and managed to have ties with her and supported
the case. This fact clearly indicates that only in order to take the benefit from
the trust, which was founded with the blood and toil of the members of the
mazdoor union, the defendants have joined together and took the same stand.
The members of the union had due respect and sentiment on Namasivayam, the
founder of the trust. In fact, even to celebrate the commemorative memory of
the son of Namasivayam, the members of the workers in the railway had
donated blood. This fact stands clearly established and recorded by the learned
single judge in the judgment. That being the position, merely because during the
life time of the founder, defendants 2 to 4 were inducted as trustees which was
not objected by the members and that may be due to the respect the said
Namasivayam had commanded at the relevant point of time as the leader of the
union, that will not give absolute right and privilege to the family members to
usurp the property of the public charitable trust.
22.Though the documents as discussed above indicate that there was no
amount of contribution by the family members, except the hard work of
__________
Page27 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
Namasivayam in founding the trust and that he has garnered the support of all
the members which was due to the respect the members of the union had on
Namasivayam, that cannot be taken advantage by the family members to usurp
th
the property of the trust. The learned single judge also indicated that the 5
defendant is the son-in-law of the founder Namasivayam and during the life
time, he has addressed a letter under Ex.D.101, by which Namasivayam wanted
th
the 5 defendant to take charge of the college fully for all practical purposes. In
fact, Namasivayam directed the fifth defendant to be the signatory even to
operate the bank account. Under Ex.D.102 letter dated 17.03.2000 by
th
Namasivayam to 5 defendant, Namasivayam congratulated him for holding a
colourful first convocation of the college and the methodical approach of the
fifth defendant. By Ex.D.103, Namasivayam hailed the fifth defendant as better
administrator than him and praised him as having excelled the founder himself.
The defendants 2 and 3 joined together and removed the fifth defendant which
th
forced him to file two suits. Later, as per Ex.D.18, the 5 defendant had
conducted general council meeting on 22.09.2004 and the meeting was attended
by the former Vice Chancellors of Bharathiyar University and Annamalai
University, apart from the Director of CECRI who happened to be the Anna
University nominee. Even when the dispute was raised by the other daughters,
Namasivayam had addressed a letter Ex.D.105, wherein he has referred that the
th
5 respondent was running the college in an efficient manner and if there are
any problems in running and administering the college, the college could be
__________
Page28 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
handed over to Sri Ramakrishna Mutt, Mylapore. This document clearly shows
that the founder of the trust was very much satisfied in the manner in which the
th
5 defendant was continuing with the administration in running the college and
th
no adverse report whatsoever was established against the 5 defendant in the
entire document. Such being the position, we are of the view that the learned
single judge including the fifth defendant in the trust board for a period of three
years does not require any interference.
23.Considering the said aspect, as no contribution was made by the
family members and serious allegations were made against each of the
daughters and several misfeasance and malfeasance were noted by the interim
administrator and that there was serious allegation also made to remove the
interim administrator and the trust being the public charitable trust, this court
exercising its parens patriae jurisdiction with respect to the public charitable
trust is of the view that the institution has now also grown up and the same is
also not in dispute and therefore, the framing of the scheme by the learned
single judge does not require any interference. Though much emphasis is made
by the learned senior counsel appearing for the union that since the union
members have also contributed much to the growth of the trust, the
representatives of the union, namely the President and the General Secretary of
the Southern Railway Mazdoor Union also to be included as trustees, this court
vary of such submission for the simple reason that though contributions were
made by the members and it is also swelling in large amount and resulted in
__________
Page29 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
establishing the college, we cannot also lose sight of the prevailing situation in
every trade union. It cannot be disputed that every trade union has now political
affiliation. Therefore, if the President and the General Secretary of the plaintiff
union are included in the trust board, it will lead to further complications and
that such situation will further disturb the proper administration of the trust.
Therefore, we are of the view that the office bearers of the union, at no point of
time, could be appointed as trustees. Taking note of the large amount of
contribution by its members, we are of the view that the learned single judge
order excluding the office bearers does not require any interference.
24.Further, in respect of the inclusion of the children of the defendants 2
and 4, on rotation basis, we are of the view that the learned single judge has
taken note of various contributions made by Namasivayam, the founder of the
trust. Though the learned single judge removed defendants 2 and 4 from
trusteeship, but has permitted their children to be the trustees on rotation basis
once in three years. Therefore, this court is of the view that the same should be
continued.
25.Accordingly, the learned single judge’s decision that the trust shall be
administered by the Board of Trustees comprised by seven members does not
require any interference and the same would do well for the administration of
the trust. It is now brought to the notice of this court that after the administration
of the trust by the interim administrator who is the retired Judge of this Court,
the trust fund of Rs.50 Crores has been saved and he had entrusted the accounts.
__________
Page30 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
We appreciate the efforts of learned Interim Administrator, Former Judge of this
Court, for his valuable contribution in preserving the public trust with its
objects.
26.In the light of the above discussions, this court is of the considered
view that the scheme framed by the learned single judge in C.S.No.160 of 2004
dated 07.06.2013 does not require any interference, but the composition of the
Board of Trustees alone is modified comprising of seven persons in the Board.
Accordingly, the issues are answered.
27.In the light of the above, the scheme as framed by the learned single
Judge is confirmed. But this court is of the considered view that the composition
of the Board of Trustees requires modification. The same shall be as follows:
(i)Hon’ble Mr.Justice S.Rajeswaran, a retired Judge of this Court and
who hails from the Thanjavur district, shall be the Chairperson of the
Board of Trustee for a period of three years from the date of taking
charge;
(ii)Prof.S.Sriman Narayanan, former Vice Chancellor of a University
recognised by the University Grants Commission with good academic
background and clean record of service;
(iii)One trustee from the lineal descendants of Founder Namasivayam
shall be nominated to the trust board once in three years on rotation
basis. In other words, if one of the family members of Devi is
nominated for a period of three years, thereafter, the family members
__________
Page31 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
of Usha shall be nominated for another period of three years. As
th
stated supra, this court is of the view that the nomination of 5
defendant in the trust board by the learned single judge does not
require any interference. Accordingly, for the first term,
th
Dr.S.Tamilarasan, 5 defendant, will be in the Board of Trust as
trustee for a period of three years. After the completion of three years
th
by the 5 defendant, one of the family members of N.V.Devi shall be
nominated for the next three years period. Thereafter, one of the
family members of N.V.Usha shall be nominated for the next three
years period. This cycle shall continue likewise. It is clarified that the
family member means the children, preferably if a female child is
there, she should be given first preference.
(iv)One representative of the first plaintiff Union who is not an office
bearer of the union shall be in the Board of Trustees and he shall be
nominated by the first plaintiff Union. The person to be nominated by
the first plaintiff Union shall be of good reputation and shall not be
less than 50 years of age and he should possess at least the
qualification of a degree and should not have been implicated or
involved in any criminal case. The first plaintiff union shall send the
name, address and other details of a nominee of their choice to the
Chairperson appointed by this judgment;
(v)One Chartered Accountant to be chosen from the list of five
__________
Page32 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
persons sponsored by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India.
The Board may address a letter to the Institute in this regard for
sponsoring a list of five persons willing to offer voluntary services for
the cause of the education;
(vi)One serving or retired Professor/ Reader/ Assistant Professor with
a Doctorate degree and a minimum of 20 years of teaching
experience and should have served in any Engineering college or a
Polytechnic. It will be open to the Chairperson to get a list of eligible
and willing candidates from the Anna University, Chennai or
Regional Engineering College, Trichy as and when vacancies arise in
this category. While selecting a person under this category,
preference may be given to a person settled in the same Revenue
district in which the college is located.
(vii)The Principal of the College. The Principal of the College shall
be the Ex-Officio Member of the Board of Trustees.
One among the trustees in the Board of Trustees other than the Chairperson
shall be elected as the Secretary of the Trust. The term of the Board of Trustees
shall be for a period of three years from the date when the every trustee assumes
charge as Board of Trustees. The general conditions and tenure of the office
shall be the same as ordered by the learned Single Judge.
28.The duties and responsibilities of the Board of Trustees shall be
governed by the scheme already framed by the learned single judge and the
__________
Page33 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
Board of Trustees shall carry out their functions as per the scheme framed in
C.S.No.160 of 2004 dated 07.06.2013, as confirmed by this court in this
judgment. The Board of Trustees shall ensure that the special objects and
purpose for which the trust was formed are effectively implemented. That apart,
in all the educational institutions run by the trust, the 15% of the total student
intake shall be reserved for the children of railway workers subject to the
applicable reservation rules and other statutory requirements. The monthly
remuneration of the Chairperson is fixed at Rs.1,50,000/- (Rupees one lakh fifty
thousand only). The academicians in the Board of Trustees shall be paid
Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh only) per month as Honorarium. The other
members shall be paid reimbursement of the actual expenses incurred by them
in attending the affairs of the Trust. It is made clear that after the period of
tenure by the Chairperson is over, necessary orders shall be obtained from this
court as to the nomination of the next Chairperson to the Board of Trustees.
29.In the light of the above discussions, the judgment and decree of the
learned single judge dated 07.06.2013 made in C.S.No.160 of 2004 is confirmed
except the modification of composition of Board of Trustees as indicated above.
All the above four original side appeals are disposed of. There shall be no order
as to costs.
30.C.M.P.Nos.16879, 21577 and 22153 of 2025 have been filed by the
appellants Trust and Trustees to receive the documents as additional evidence
on the side of the appellants. The Court is of the view that majority of these
__________
Page34 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
documents have already been filed and considered by the learned single Judge.
Further, the appellants have also not canvassed any argument for receipt of
these documents and most of the documents have already been considered by
the learned single Judge. Therefore, this court is of the considered view that
these documents are not required for disposal of the lis. The other documents
are with regard to board meetings, letters, proceedings of the administrator and
some pertaining to criminal proceedings and they are not relevant for deciding
the issue. Further, most of the documents have already been relied on by the
learned single Judge. Hence, C.M.P.Nos.16879, 21577 and 22153 of 2025 are
dismissed. Consequently, other connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.
(N.S.K.,J.) (G.K.M.,J.)
20-11-2026
Index: Yes
Speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes
VVK
Note to office :
Registry shall send a copy of this judgment to
Hon’ble Mr.Justice S.Rajeswaran, a Former Judge of this Court
appointed as Chairperson of the Board of Trustees.
__________
Page35 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )
2026:MHC:4657
OSA No. 230 of 2013
N.SATHISH KUMAR J.
AND
GK.MUTHUKUMAAR J.
VVK
Pre delivery judgment in
OSA No. 230 of 2013
AND
OSA NO. 345 OF 2013,CMP NO. 11308 OF 2019,
CMP NO. 12019 OF 2022,CMP NO. 16879 OF 2025,
CMP NO. 21577 OF 2025,CMP NO. 22153 OF 2025,
OSA NO. 127 OF 2019,OSA NO. 197 OF 2022
20-11-2026
__________
Page36 of 36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 08:05:51 pm )