Ashok vs State of U.P.
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
Reserved On :- 03.08.2026
Delivered On :- 17.11.2026
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
CAPITAL CASES No. - 14 of 2021
Ashok
.....Appellant(s)
Versus
State of U.P.
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Abhay Kumar Singh, Braham Singh,
Brijesh Sahai(Senior Adv.), From Jail,
Shyam Lal, Sushil Kumar Tewari
Counsel for Respondent(s) : A.G.A., Rajrshi Gupta
Court No. - 43
HON'BLE SIDDHARTH, J.
HON'BLE VINAI KUMAR DWIVEDI, J.
(Delivered by Hon'ble Siddharth, J.)
Reference No. 11 of 2021
The above noted reference dated 03.09.2021 has been made for confirmation
of death sentence in S.C. No. 1504/2020, State vs. Ashok, U/s 302, 201, 363,
376AB IPC and 5M/6 POCSO Act, Case Crime No. 792/2020, P.S.-Khurja
Nagar passed by Special Judge (POCSO Act) / Additional Sessions Judge,
Bulandshahar vide judgment dated 03.09.2021.
&
Capital Case No. 14 of 2021
1. Heard Sri Shyam Lal, learned counsel for the appellant; Mr. Rajrshi
Gupta, learned Amicus Curiae appointed by this Court to argue the matter on
behalf of the complainant; Mr. Thakur Azad Singh, learned A.G.A. for the
State; perused the Trial Court record and the judgment of the Trial Court.
2. The above noted capital case has been preferred against the judgment and
orders dated 02.09.2021 and 03.09.2021 passed by Dr. Smt. Pallavi
Agarwal, the learned Special Judge (POCSO Act)/Additional Sessions
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
2
Judge, Bulandshahr have been assailed; whereby the appellant has been
convicted in S.T. No. 1504 of 2020, State of U.P. v. Ashok, on 02.09.2021
for committing offences punishable under Sections 363, 376AB, 302, 201
I.P.C., and Section 5m/6 of POCSO Act, arising out of Case Crime No. 792
of 2020, under Sections 302, 201, 376, 511 I.P.C., and Sections 6 and 18 of
POCSO Act, P.S. Khurja Nagar, District Bulandshahr and sentenced to death
for offence punishable under Section 302 I.P.C. with a fine of Rs.1,00,000/-
and in default of payment of fine to undergo one year simple imprisonment;
seven years rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs.20,000/- and in default
of payment of fine to undergo four months additional simple imprisonment;
seven years rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs.20,000/- and in default
of payment of fine to undergo four months additional simple imprisonment
and death under Section 5m/6 POCSO Act read with Section 376AB I.P.C.
It has further been directed that a sum of Rs. 1,40,000/- imposed as fine shall
be payable to the parents of the deceased.
3. The prosecution's case, in brief, is that the complainant, Mr. Vinod Singh,
son of Mr. Ramsaran Singh and a resident of village Sikri, PS Khurja Nagar,
District Bulandshahr, submitted a written complaint (Exhibit Ka-1) to the
Station House Officer, PS Khurja Nagar, District Bulandshahr. He stated
that he resides in village Sikri with his family. This morning, at
approximately 8:00 AM, his daughter / the victim, aged about 9, and his
younger daughter, Kanak, aged 6, left home to collect jamun (black plums)
from a tree located near the cooperative warehouse in the village. About an
hour later, the younger daughter, Kanak, returned home with some jamun .
When the complainant's nephew, Neeraj, asked Kanak about the victim's
whereabouts, she explained that a man named Ashok, a frequent visitor to
their home, had taken the victim along, promising to get her some corn cobs.
When the victim did not return home after a considerable amount of time,
the complainant and his family began searching for her. Despite an extensive
search, they could not locate her. They then began searching for Ashok, who
was soon found within the village. When questioned about the victim,
specifically, why he had taken her and where she was, Ashok became
evasive and refused to provide an answer. Consequently, the family dialed
112 to report the disappearance of the victim. Shortly thereafter, the police
arrived in the village. Upon being subjected to rigorous interrogation by the
police, Ashok apologized for his actions, admitting that he had committed a
grave error. He confessed to strangulating the victim to death, placing her
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
3
body inside a plastic sack, and concealing it within a sugarcane field. On the
indication of accused, Ashok, the victim's body was recovered from the
plastic sack. The complainant and his wife subsequently identified the
victim. He is firmly convinced that his daughter / the victim was taken away
by Ashok, son of Bhuti Singh, with the intent to commit rape. However, as
she cried out, he murdered her and concealed her body. He has requested
that a complaint be filed and appropriate legal action be taken. Acting on a
call made to the 112 emergency number, the police from the concerned
station arrived at the scene. There, they found that the complainant, Vinod
Singh with the assistance of Durgesh Kumar and other villagers, had
apprehended the accused, Ashok, after subduing him through physical force.
The accused was taken into police custody, and a memo at the spot was
prepared.
4. Based on the written complaint submitted by the complainant, a Chik First
Information Report, Exhibit Ka-2, against the accused, Ashok as Crime No.
792 / 2020, under section 302, 201, 376, 511 IPC and 6, 18 POCSO Act on
05.08.2020 at time 00.13 was registered at PS Khurja Nagar, District
Bulandshahr. Entry of which was made in GD related to case registration,
exhibit ka-03, at Report No. 002 at time 00.13. The investigation was
entrusted to Police Inspector, Shri Subhash Singh.
5. Memo regarding taking into police custody of one accused Ashok, Exhibit
Ka-6, recovery memo of the dead body of the deceased/victim, Exhibit Ka-7,
and memo regarding taking into police possession of clothes worn by the
accused at the time of the incident, Exhibit Ka-10, are also available on the
file.
6. The Panchayatnama of the minor deceased, Exhibit Ka-11, was prepared
on 05.08.2020 by the Sub-Inspector, Shri Ramji Lal Chauhan, Police Station
Khurja Nagar, District Bulandshahr at the mortuary of District Hospital,
Bulandshahr due to the situation of breach of public peace arising at the spot,
which started on 05.08.2020 at 00:35 hours and ended at 01:35 hours. In the
Panchayatnama, Vinod, Durgesh, Sethi, Sonu, and Lokesh were appointed as
panchas. It is mentioned in the Panchayatnama that upon observing injuries
on the body of the deceased, it was found that a cloth noose is tied on the
mouth around the head of the deceased, and contusion marks are present on
the thighs of both right and left legs, and blood stains are present around the
private parts. Additionally, it is also mentioned that keeping modesty in
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
4
mind, the body was turned over and examined with the help of female
Homeguard Rachna, and no apparent injury was found. According to the
opinion of the panchas, the death of the deceased appears to have been
caused by strangulation. However, it is mentioned to get the post-mortem
conducted to ascertain the exact cause of death. After filling the
Panchayatnama of the body of the deceased, Sub-Inspector Shri Ramji Lal
Chauhan, Police Station Khurja Nagar prepared all the necessary papers,
Exhibit Ka-12 to Exhibit Ka-15 i.e. challan of the dead body, photo of the
dead body, letter to C.M.O., sample seal, etc. respectively, and after taking
necessary action, handed over the dead body to Constable 872, Anupam
Kumar and H.G. 1320, Rachna for sending it for post-mortem.
7. Thereafter, the post-mortem of the dead body of the deceased was
conducted by a joint team of Dr. Sudha Sharma, Dr. Kapil Garg, and Dr.
Satish Kumar Singh at Babu Banarsi Das Government Hospital,
Bulandshahr on 05.08.2020, starting at 9:45 AM in the morning and
completed at 10:50 AM. The post-mortem report of the deceased, Exhibit
Ka-5, is available on the file.
8. Earlier, the investigation of the case was conducted by the initial
investigating officer Sub-Inspector Shri Subhash Singh, who prepared the
memo regarding taking into custody of the accused Ashok, Exhibit Ka-6,
and recovery memo of the dead body of the deceased, Exhibit Ka-7.
Thereafter, he prepared the site-plan of the place of recovery of the dead
body, Exhibit Ka-8, departure G.D. entry, Exhibit Ka-9, and the memo
regarding taking into possession of the clothes worn by the accused, Exhibit
Ka-10. Subsequently, upon his transfer, the investigation of the case was
taken over by the final investigating officer, Inspector Shri M.K. Upadhyay,
who collected all the evidence, recorded the statements of the witnesses, and
obtained the age proof certificate of the deceased.
9. Upon conclusion of the investigation, the final investigating officer
submitted a charge-sheet bearing his signature, Exhibit Ka-16, under
Sections- 302, 201, 376AB IPC and Section 5M/6 of the POCSO Act against
the accused Ashok before the court.
10. The court took cognizance of the case on the charge-sheet on 18.09.2020
and summoned the accused. Accused Ashok appeared in the court from
District Jail, Bulandshahr.
11. After complying with the provisions of Section 207 Cr.P.C., the court,
upon the question of framing charges against the accused, Ashok, heard the
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
5
accused and the learned Special Public Prosecutor, and found sufficient
grounds to frame the charges against the aforesaid accused under Sections
363, 376AB, 302, 201 IPC and Section 5M/6 of the POCSO Act, and
accordingly, the charges were framed against the accused on 05.10.2020
under Sections 363, 376AB, 302, 201 IPC and Section 5M/6 of the POCSO
Act. The charges were read over and explained to the accused. The accused
denied the charges and claimed to be tried.
12. In support of its case, the prosecution has examined P.W.-1, complainant
of the case Vinod; P.W.-2, Constable/Clerk 1754 Pradeep Kumar ( Chik and
rapat writer); P.W.-3, Kanak aged 6 years (eyewitness/younger sister of the
deceased); P.W.-4, Neeraj; P.W.-5, Durgesh (witness of arrest); P.W.-6, Dr.
Sudha Sharma (the doctor who conducted the post-mortem); P.W.-7, Sub-
Inspector Shri Subhash Singh (initial investigating officer); P.W.-8, Sub-
Inspector, Shri Ramji Lal Chauhan (who prepared the inquest) and P.W.-9,
Inspector Shri M.K. Upadhyay (final investigating officer).
Documentary Evidence of Prosecution:-
On behalf of the prosecution, Tehrir Exhibit Ka-1, Chik First Information
Report Exhibit Ka-2, copy of GD of registration of case Exhibit Ka-3,
statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C. Exhibit Ka-4, post-mortem report
Exhibit Ka-5, memo regarding taking into custody of the accused Exhibit
Ka-6, recovery memo of the dead body of the deceased Exhibit Ka-7, site-
plan of the place of recovery of the dead body Exhibit Ka-8, copy of
departure G.D. of initial investigating officer Exhibit Ka-9, memo regarding
taking into custody of clothes of the accused Exhibit Ka-10, Panchayatnama
Exhibit Ka-11, challan of the dead body of the deceased Exhibit Ka-12,
photo of the dead body Exhibit Ka-13, letter to C.M.O. Exhibit Ka-14,
sample seal Exhibit Ka-15, and charge-sheet Exhibit Ka-16 have been filed
on the record.
Forensic Evidence:-
Incident inspection report of the Forensic Science Laboratory, Lucknow
paper no. 13.A/1 to 2 and examination report of the Forensic Science
Laboratory UP, Ghaziabad regarding underwear and T-shirt paper no. 21A,
and examination report of the Forensic Science Laboratory UP, Lucknow
swab swab
regarding vaginal slide and , anal slide and , T-shirt, jeans, and blood
sample paper no. 45A/2 are also filed on record.
13. In the said case, a total of 5 formal witnesses have been examined in
evidence on behalf of the prosecution.
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
6
14. Witness, P.W.-2 Constable 1754 Pradeep Kumar (Constable/Clerk),
Police Station Khurja Nagar, District Bulandshahr has stated in his
examination-in-chief that on 05.08.2020, he was posted at Police Station
Khurja Nagar on the post of Constable/Clerk. On the said date, on the basis
of the complainant's tehrir , he got the Chik FIR of the case recorded
verbatim through Computer Operator Nitin Kumar. This witness further
stated that he made the G.D. entry of case registration No. 2 at 00:13 hours
on 05.08.2020, and proved the Chik FIR as Exhibit Ka-2 and the copy of
G.D. entry of case registration as Exhibit Ka-3 in his evidence.
15. Witness, PW-6, Dr. Sudha Sharma (who conducted the post-mortem), a
Senior Consultant, stated in her examination-in-chief that on 05.08.2020, she
was posted as a Senior Consultant at the District Women's Hospital,
Bulandshahr. She further stated that on that day, a joint team, comprising
herself, Dr. Kapil Garg, and Dr. Satish Kumar Singh, conducted a post-
mortem on the body of the deceased, aged approximately 9 years, which had
been received at 4:00 a.m. The examination began at 9:45 AM and
concluded at 10:50 AM. She stated that the following ante-mortem injuries
were observed on the body of the deceased:
Injury No. 1
2 cm x 1 cm to 4 cm x 2.5 cm of numerous contusions and abrasions were
found on the front of the neck, located on both sides of the trachea. Upon
dissection, ecchymosis was observed. The hyoid bone was found to be
fractured.
Injury No. 2
An abrasion 2 cm x 2 cm was present on the inner space of the right elbow
joint.
Injury No. 3
Multiple contusions present on the inner space of both thighs, ranging in size
from 3 cm x 2 cm to 9 cm x 6 cm.
Observations:-
Both eyes bulging outside. The tongue was protruding from the mouth.
Blood-stained fluid was discharging from the nostrils. Bubbles were
emerging from the mouth. Due to the accumulation of gases, an injury 1 cm
x 0.5 cm was observed in the vaginal area, at the 6 o'clock position. An
injury 2 cm x 1 cm at the 3 o'clock was observed at the anal opening. Anal
and vaginal swabs were collected; two slides were prepared for spermatozoa
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
7
testing, and one slide was prepared for DNA analysis.
In his examination-in-chief, this witness further stated that an internal
examination revealed congestion in the brain, both lungs, and the right
chamber of the heart; the left chamber was empty. The gallbladder and liver
were congested, and the uterus was empty. In his opinion, the death of the
deceased likely occurred approximately one day prior to the post-mortem
examination, specifically, sometime after 10:00 a.m on 04.08.2020. The
cause of death was asphyxiation due to strangulation. The witness also noted
the presence of rigor mortis throughout the deceased's body, with signs of
decomposition beginning near the chest area. In his view, it is possible that
the deceased was subjected to rape prior to her death. The witness further
stated that the post-mortem report was prepared in his own handwriting and
signed by him, as well as by Dr. Satish Kumar Singh and Dr. Kapil Garg; he
has proven the Post-portem report as Ext. ka-5 while submitting his
evidence.
16. In his examination-in-chief, PW-7, Sub-Inspector, Subhash Singh, the
preliminary investigating officer, stated that on 04.08.2020, he was posted as
the In-charge Inspector at the Khurja Nagar police station. On that day, at
9:50 AM, he recorded his departure entry in the GD No. 31 and was engaged
in patrolling and investigative duties within the station's jurisdiction. He
received information via the 112 emergency service that the daughter of one
Vinod, the victim, had gone missing in the village of Sikri. Upon receiving
this information, he proceeded to the village along with his accompanying
police personnel. There, he found that the complainant, Vinod, with the
assistance of a villager named Durgesh and others, had apprehended the
accused, Ashok. He subsequently questioned Ashok. Through this witness,
the memo regarding the taking of the accused, Ashok, into police custody,
following his confession, the contents of this memo were dictated aloud and
recorded under the light of a torch in the presence of the witness, Durgesh,
and that it was subsequently signed by both the accused and the witnesses,
was proven and marked as Ext. Ka-6. The witness further stated that upon
the arrival of the forensic team, the body of the deceased was recovered from
Somveer's sugarcane field, on the indication of the accused, Ashok, and was
subsequently identified. The memo regarding this recovery was dictated
aloud by Sub-Inspector Sandeep under the light of a torch and signed by the
accused, Ashok; the same was proven as Ext. Ka-7. The witness further
stated that, due to public outrage at the spot, and in the interest of
maintaining law and order, the body of the deceased was handed over to
Sub-Inspector Ramji Lal, Constable Anupam, and female Home Guard
Ranchana, and was then sent to the Bulandshahr mortuary for the
preparation of the inquest report. Furthermore, the witness stated that he
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
8
recorded the statement of the complainant and, based on the complainant's
identification, prepared a site map of the place where the body of the
deceased was recovered in his own handwriting and under his own
signature; the site map was proven as Ext. Ka-8. The witness further stated
that he brought the arrested accused, Ashok, to the police station along with
a written complaint, on the basis of which the case was registered. A
computerized copy of the departure GD, which mentions the recording of the
copy of the chik, copy of the report, and site-map in the case diary, was
proved as Ext. Ka-9. Furthermore, the witness stated to the completion of
other procedural formalities related to the investigation, including the
recovery of the accused Ashok's clothing, and proved the recovery memo,
signed by the witness, as Ext. ka-10. The witness also presented evidence
stating that, upon his own transfer on 09.08.2020, the investigation was
handed over for further proceedings.
17. Witness PW-8, Sub-Inspector Shri Ramji Lal Chauhan, who prepared the
inquest report, stated in his examination-in-chief that on 04.08.2020, he was
posted as a Sub-Inspector at the Khurja Nagar police station. This witness
stated that upon receiving information, he reached the spot, Sub-Inspector
Subhash Singh was present at the spot, the dead body of the deceased was
recovered at the pointing out of accused Ashok, the dead body of the
deceased was sent to the Mortuary at District Hospital, Bulandshahr due to
law and order situation, and the inquest was prepared by him in his own
handwriting and signature. He proved the inquest as Ext. Ka-11, and stating
that the challan of body, photo of body, letter to CMO, sample seal, etc.,
were prepared by him, and they were proven as Ext. Ka-12 to Ext. Ka-15
respectively while submitting his evidence.
18. Witness, PW-9, Inspector Shri M.K. Upadhyay (the last investigating
officer), stated in his examination-in-chief that on 11.08.2020, the
investigation of the said case was taken over by him upon the transfer of his
predecessor. On the same day, the case diary prepared previously were
perused by him. This witness, stating that after perusing all case diaries and
documents, recording the statements of witnesses, getting the section altered
in the case, obtaining the age certificate of the deceased, and completing all
proceedings, and upon the collection of all evidence, a chargesheet under his
own signature against accused Ashok was submitted, presented his evidence
by proving the chargesheet as Ext. Ka-16.
19. In the instant case, a total of 4 witnesses of fact have been got examined
in evidence from the side of the prosecution.
20. Prosecution Witness P.W.-1, the complainant, Vinod, has stated in his
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
9
examination-in-chief that the deceased aged about 8 years, was his daughter.
He knows the accused Ashok, who is present in court and is a resident of
village Sikri. On 04.08.2020, at about 8:00 a.m., the victim/deceased and his
younger daughter Kanak, aged 6 years, had gone to collect jamuns near the
cooperative go-down situated in the village. After one hour, his younger
daughter returned with jamuns , whereupon his nephew Neeraj asked her
where is the victim. Kanak told him that Ashok Bhaiya, who used to visit
their house, had taken the victim away on the pretext of getting her peanuts.
Waited for the victim for a long time, when she did not return, started
searching for her. Then searched everywhere in fields, go-down, jungle but
when not found then started searching for Ashok. Ashok was found in the
village itself after some time. When asked Ashok about the victim, he started
evasiveness. Thereafter, he and his family members called the emergency
number 112 and informed the police that the victim was missing. After some
time police arrived there. Police interrogated Ashok strictly. Ashok told the
police in front of him and his family members that he has committed a
mistake. He has committed rape with the victim and murdered her and has
concealed her dead body by putting it in a plastic sack in the sugar-cane
field. Thereafter, he went to get the dead body recovered. Ashok got the
dead body of the victim recovered from the sugar-cane field. He and his wife
Bhuri were called to identify the dead body. Upon reaching there, they
identified the dead body of the victim. At that time also, Ashok had stated
that he had taken the victim away with the intention of committing rape and
had murdered her when she screamed, thereafter concealing her dead body.
Regarding the said incident, the Sub-Inspector had taken into custody the
clothes of the accused Ashok - jeans, pant, T-shirt on the spot and had
prepared their memo. The memo was read over to him, and his signatures
were obtained thereon. The arrest memo of accused Ashok was prepared at
the spot and read over to him, whereupon he signed it. The Sub-Inspector
had also recovered the dead body of his daughter/victim from a plastic sack
at the spot, at the instance of the accused, and prepared a recovery memo
thereof, which bears his signatures. The Sub-Inspector had prepared the
inquest report of his daughter/deceased at the spot. The inquest report was
read over to the panchas , and their signatures were obtained thereon and his
signature is also thereon. This witness made the statement that he got the
written complaint (tehrir) of the incident prepared by Durgesh Kumar of the
village; that the written complaint (tehrir) was prepared exactly as dictated
by him; that Durgesh read it over to him; and that he thereafter signed it and
submitted it at Police Station Khurja Nagar. He proved the written complaint
(tehrir) as Exhibit Ka-1 and submitted his evidence.
21. Prosecution Witness P.W.-3, Kanak (the younger sister of the
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
10
victim/deceased, aged 6 years), after being found competent to testify on the
basis of her general intelligence, stated in her examination-in-chief that the
deceased was her elder sister. She knew Ashok, who was a resident of their
village. He used to come home. It is a matter of morning. They both had
gone to get jamuns . When she and the deceased were collecting jamuns ,
Ashok came there and told her to go home, stating that he is taking the
victim/deceased to get her a corn cob. Thereafter, Ashok took the deceased
to get her a corn cob. The boy who is bald today is Ashok. Then she came
home, where she met Papa, Mummy, aunt (tai) , Brother and Sister-in-law (b
habhi). They asked where is the victim / deceased. She told Mummy, Papa,
Brother, aunt (tai) everyone that the victim / deceased has been taken away
by Ashok. Then the victim was killed. On being shown her statement under
Section 164 Cr.P.C., this witness further stated that this is her photo. The
policemen had brought her in a vehicle along with aunt (tai) . Then wherever
they were brought, they had asked what had happened. Where had the victim
/ deceased gone. She had told. Then after making her thumb blue, they got it
affixed on this paper. This witness has given her statement stating that on
being asked by the police aunty what had happened, she had told them, and
proving her statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C. as Exhibit Ka-4.
22. Prosecution witness, PW-4, Neeraj, has stated in his examination-in-
chief that the deceased is the daughter of his uncle Vinod. The incident is
dated 04.08.2020. At around eight o'clock in the morning, both daughters of
his uncle Vinod, deceased and Kanak, had gone to collect jamuns from
under the jamun trees near the Society building. Only Kanak came home
after collecting jamuns . His aunt Bhuri Devi, Meenu Devi and he asked
where is the deceased, then Kanak told that Ashok Bhaiya who used to their
house has taken the deceased to the jungle to get her corn cob. He told this
thing to his family members. Then, he, family members and villagers
searched for the deceased a lot but the deceased was not found. Then they
searched for Ashok and Ashok was found. They asked Ashok where is the
deceased, then Ashok did not tell any correct thing. Then they called on
number 112, then police came from the police station. Inspector Sahab
interrogated Ashok strictly, then Ashok told that he had taken the deceased
to the jungle for committing rape. When the deceased screamed, he
strangulated her to death and concealed her dead body by putting it in a
plastic sack in the sugar-cane field of Somveer son of Bhoja. Police, he and
his family members went on the path told by Ashok and took out the dead
body of the deceased from the plastic sack from the sugar-cane field. Smt.
Bhuri Devi and Vinod and he also saw the dead body. Ashok confessed to
his crime in his presence and in the presence of the police and the villagers.
Ashok confessed that he had committed rape with the deceased and, when
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
11
she screamed he had murdered her and concealed her dead body by putting
in a plastic sack in the sugar-cane field. He also believes that Ashok after
committing rape with Muskan, murdered her and concealed the dead body
by closing it in a sack in the sugar-cane field. The dead body of the deceased
was found at about ten o'clock in the night. The witness has submitted his
evidence stating that police had torch and the dead body was identified in the
light of the torch.
23. P.W.-5, Durgesh stated in his examination-in-chief that the deceased was
the daughter of Vinod Singh of his village. Ashok is also a resident of his
village. The incident took place on 04.08.2020 at about 8 a.m. The daughter
of Vinod Singh had gone missing. He also went to his house when he came
to know about the same. After making inquiries in the village, he found that
everyone was searching for the deceased and he also began to search. When
the deceased could not be found, then Kanak, younger daughter of Vinod
Singh, stated that Ashok Bhaiya had taken the deceased with him to get a
kukdi . Thereafter, he searched for Ashok and eventually found him. Upon
being asked, Ashok did not give any satisfactory reply. Then, the family
members of deceased informed the police and they arrived at the spot.
S.H.O. Sir and his staff arrived. Ashok was then handed over to the SHO.
Thereafter, the police interrogated him in detail. Ashok stated that he had
taken the deceased to a sugarcane field with the intention of committing rape
upon her and, when she screamed out, he strangled her to death. He further
stated that he had kept the dead body in a plastic sack and concealed it in the
sugarcane field. Thereafter, the police took Ashok along with them to the
sugarcane field indicated by him. They also accompanied the police
personnel. Ashok then got the dead body recovered. The said field belongs
to Somraj S/o Bhojraj. The dead body was lying at around 22 to 23 steps
inside the field. Upon opening the sack, the dead body of deceased was
found inside it. Vinod Singh and his wife who were present at the spot,
identified the dead body. It was around 9:30 to 10 p.m. The dead body was
identified in a torchlight. The police carried out the paper work at the spot in
the light of torch. The paper work was read over to him. He had also signed
those documents. This witness, while identifying his signatures on the memo
available on the file as 8A / 3, further sated that paper work had also been
done when Ashok was handed over to the police, on which his signatures
were also obtained. After perusing Paper No. 8A / 2, the witness identified
his signatures on the original memo regarding taking into police custody of
the accused and stated that the clothes i.e., Jeans and T-Shirt, worn by the
accused at that time, had been taken into custody by the police in his
presence and a memo had been prepared accordingly. It is available on file
as Paper No. 8A / 1. He identified his signatures thereon and accepted the
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
12
memo after reading over the same. He further stated that the inquest report
of dead body was not prepared at the spot as there was a large crowd
gathered there and the people were agitated. Therefore, the inquest
proceedings were conducted at the mortuary, Bulandshahr. They had also
accompanied the police personnel there. This witness, while identifying his
signatures on the opinion of panch and on the original inquest report Paper
No. 11A/1 to 11A/4, submitted his testimony.
24. Upon conclusion of the prosecution's testimony, the statement of accused
was recorded u/s 313 Cr.P.C., wherein he denied the prosecution story as
false, and alleged that false evidence was submitted by witnesses and stated
that he had neither confessed any offence nor got any dead body recovered.
He also stated the prosecution document as false and alleged that they had
been prepared falsely and denied to give any statement in his defence. Along
with this, he also stated that he had a quarrel with Vinod over gambling.
Ajay Sharma etc. of his village had committed his father's murder, in which
they were punished. Ajay Sharma is on bail from the High Court. On the
night of 4 / 5.8.20 at about 12 or 1 a.m., the police picked him up from his
house and brought him to the police station. Sonu S/o Udayveer of his
village had already been kept detained there. The aforesaid Ajay Sharma and
Vinod were also present there. Both of them had a separate conversation
with the Inspector. Thereafter, the policemen released Sonu and falsely
implicated him in the case.
25. Learned counsel for the appellant, Sri S. Lal, has submitted that the
accused-appellant was not able to understand the incriminating
circumstances put to him under Section 313 Cr.P.C and was not able to
answer properly because of compound questions and thus serious prejudice
has been caused to the appellant-accused as has been held in para no. 12 of
Vandana vs. State of Maharashtra, AIR 2025 SC 4193 .
26. The statement of Kanak was recorded by the investigating officer
belatedly on 07.08.2020 and thus her statement cannot be relied upon. In
it has been held that
Shahid Khan vs. State of Rajasthan (2016) 4 SCC 96
delay in recording statement casts a serious doubt on prosecution case.
27. When evidence of prosecution witness is found untrustworthy and,
therefore, if no question was put to I.O then it would be immaterial vide law
laid down in Chotkau vs. State of U.P. (2023) 6 SCC 742 (3JJ) . Merely on
the basis of post mortem examination report the accused-appellant cannot be
convicted as has been held in para no. 09 of
Balaji Gunthu Dhule vs. State
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
13
of Maharashtra (2012) 11 SCC 685 .
28. Learned counsel for the first informant, Sri Rajrshi Gupta has
vehemently opposed the submissions and has submitted that the prosecution
has proved this case beyond reasonable doubt.
29. He has submitted that P.W.-3, Kanak, is a natural competent and reliable
witness. Medical evidence fully supports the prosecution case. The recovery
of dead body is a strong incriminating circumstance against the prosecution.
The investigation of this case does not suffers from any material /
irregularity. The appellant has failed to explain the incriminating
circumstances against him and the judgment of the trial court is based on
proper appreciation of the evidence on record.
30. After hearing the rival submissions, we find that the conviction rests on a
complete chain of circumstances, namely; last-seen evidence of PW-3
Kanak; immediate disclosure by PW-3 to the family; prompt search and
police information; recovery of the dead body pursuant to the appellant's
disclosure; medical evidence proving homicidal death; documentary and
scientific evidence; failure of the appellant to explain incriminating
circumstances under Section 313 Cr.P.C; each circumstance is independently
proved and, when taken together, forms an unbroken chain pointing only
towards the guilt of the appellant.
31. The entire prosecution case begins with PW-3 Kanak; before recording
her evidence, the trial Court satisfied itself regarding her competence; P.W.-
3 consistently deposed that:She and the deceased had gone to pluck jamun ;
the appellant came there; he lured the deceased by promising a corn; he took
the deceased with him; she immediately informed her family. Her testimony
remained intact on all material particulars despite lengthy cross-examination.
Her evidence is corroborated by:Statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C;
recovery of the dead body; medical evidence; conduct of the appellant.
Minor discrepancies in the testimony of a child witness are natural and do
not affect the core prosecution case.
32. P.W.-6, Dr. Sushma Sharma proved that the death was homicidal; cause
of death was asphyxia due to strangulation; hyoid bone was fractured;
injuries were present on the neck; genital injuries were noticed; medical
findings were consistent with forcible assault. Thus, the medical evidence
completely corroborates the ocular and circumstantial evidence. P.W.-5,
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
14
P.W.-7 and P.W.-8 have consistently proved that the dead body was
recovered during investigation pursuant to the information furnished by the
appellant. The prosecution relies only upon the admissible portion of the
disclosure statement under Section 27 of the Evidence Act. The recovery of
the dead body from the place pointed out by the appellant constitutes a vital
link in the chain of circumstances. The appellant has attempted to highlight
certain alleged defects in investigation. It is respectfully submitted that even
if certain procedural irregularities are assumed, the same cannot demolish an
otherwise reliable prosecution case. The conviction is founded not merely
upon the investigation but upon: reliable ocular testimony; medical
evidence; recovery; documentary evidence; scientific evidence. Therefore,
no prejudice has been caused to the appellant. The evidence on record
establishes that immediately after the deceased Muskan went missing, her
younger sister, Kanak (PW-3), returned home and informed the family
members that "
अशोक भैया जो घर आते हैं | वह अपने साथ मक्के की कुकड़ी दिलाने अपने
Acting upon this information, the family members
साथ ले गए हैं।".
immediately searched for the deceased but could not trace her. They also
questioned the appellant regarding her whereabouts; however, the appellant
deliberately avoided giving any satisfactory answer and attempted to evade
their queries.
33. Finding no trace of the deceased, the First Informant informed the police
through Dial-112 that his minor daughter was missing. Upon reaching the
village, the police interrogated the appellant. During the course of
investigation, the appellant furnished information leading to the recovery of
the dead body of the deceased from a sugarcane field. The recovery pursuant
to the information supplied by the appellant is admissible to the extent
permitted under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act and constitutes a vital
incriminating circumstance connecting him with the crime. Further, during
his examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C., the appellant stated that the
deceased was about 14 years of age. This answer clearly indicates that the
appellant was well acquainted with the deceased and knew her personally.
Despite such acquaintance, the appellant failed to offer any plausible
explanation regarding the last-seen circumstance, the disappearance of the
deceased, the recovery of her dead body, or the incriminating circumstances
proved by the prosecution. His defence consisted only of a bald denial and
an allegation of false implication, unsupported by any defence evidence. The
appellant's evasive conduct immediately after the disappearance of the
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
15
deceased, his failure to explain the incriminating circumstances, and his
inability to probabilise any defence provide additional assurance to the
otherwise cogent and reliable prosecution case. These circumstances, when
read along with the testimony of PW-3, the recovery, the medical evidence
and the other prosecution evidence, fully justify the findings recorded by the
trial Court. The trial Court has examined every prosecution witness
separately; discussed documentary evidence; appreciated medical
evidence;considered the defence submissions; analysed the law relating to
circumstantial evidence, child witnesses, Section 29 POCSO Act and
Section 106 of the Evidence Act. The findings recorded are neither perverse
nor contrary to law.
34. Now we consider the point as to whether the capital punishment awarded
by the learned Sessions Judge, Bulandshahar, against the appellant, Ashok,
is based on evidence and in accordance with the settled principles enunciated
by the Hon'ble Supreme Court from time to time, and whether this case falls
within the category of the rarest of rare cases. To determine this aspect, we
have gone through the landmark judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Jagmohan Singh v. State of U.P., (1973) 1 SCC 20, Bachan Singh v. State of
Punjab, AIR 1980 SC 898, Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab, (1983) 3 SCC
470, Swami Shraddananda v. State of Karnataka, (2008) 13 SCC 767, and
Santosh Kumar Satibhushan Bariyar v. State of Maharashtra, (2009) 6 SCC
498.
35. We have also perused the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
relied upon by the learned counsel for the appellant, which have no
application to the facts of the present case. What questions could not be
understood by appellant has not been explained. The conviction of appellant
is not solely based on post-mortem report of deceased. There is reliable eye-
witness account of P.W.-3 corroborated P.W.-4, Neeraj.
36. From a perusal of the above-mentioned pronouncements of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court, including the judgments relied upon by learned counsel for
the appellants, we find that capital punishment under Section 302 IPC should
be awarded only in the rarest of rare cases, and ordinarily, imprisonment for
life is the rule while the death sentence is an exception, being a proper and
sufficient punishment to serve the ends of the criminal justice delivery
system. Before awarding capital punishment to any convict, the Court is
duty-bound to weigh and draw up a balance sheet / chart of aggravating and
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
16
mitigating circumstances while strictly applying the doctrine of the rarest of
rare cases.
37. However, when we have perused and gone through the reasoning and
findings of the learned Sessions Judge, Bulandshahar, we find that the
Sessions Judge has not prepared any balance sheet or chart of aggravating
and mitigating circumstances based on the evidence available on record for
categorising the present case in the category of the rarest of rare cases. Since
it is a settled proposition of law that life imprisonment is the rule and the
death sentence is an exception, a perusal of the findings and reasoning given
by the learned Sessions Judge reveals that merely by referring to the injuries
of the deceased in her postmortem report and noting that the appellant raped
and killed the minor girl, the learned Sessions Judge concluded that this case
falls within the category of the rarest of rare cases and awarded the extreme
penalty of capital punishment to the appellant, Ashok.
38. From a perusal of the record of the present case, we also find that there is
no evidence of any nature which could show that the appellant is habitual
and hard-core criminal, or that he is a menace to society at large. There is no
documentary evidence regarding any criminal history of the appellant to
establish that he is habitual offender in the habit of committing heinous
offences like rape and murder. Thus, the prosecution was unsuccessful and
unable to produce any documentary evidence in the Trial Court to show and
prove that the appellant is hard-core criminal, professional hired killer,
dangerous, or a menace to society at large. Capital punishment can be
awarded in the rarest of rare category of cases only after preparing a chart or
balance sheet of aggravating and mitigating circumstances, and particularly
or when the accused found to be hired killer and a grave danger or menace to
society at large.
39. However, the learned Sessions Judge, Bulandshahar, without keeping in
mind the aforesaid legal aspects and contrary to the settled principles of law,
has erroneously categorized the present case under the category of the rarest
of rare cases and awarded the death sentence to the appellant, Ashok, for the
commission of the alleged crime. Hence, we are unable to affirm the
findings of the learned Trial Court recorded in this regard on the point of
sentence, by which the said appellant has been awarded the extreme penalty.
In other words, we are not in agreement with the findings of the Trial Court
sentencing the appellant to death.
CAPT No. 14 of 2021
17
40. Therefore, after a meticulous perusal of the entire evidence on record,
both oral as well as documentary, and keeping in view the law enunciated by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court from time to time, we find that the case at hand
does not falls within the category of the rarest of rare cases. We are of the
considered opinion that in the present case, sentencing the appellant to
imprisonment for life would serve the ends of justice far better than
awarding him capital punishment.
41. In view of the above facts and circumstances of the case we are of the
firm view that the death sentence awarded to the appellant is neither proper
nor justified. Instead, the appellant deserves to be sentenced to imprisonment
for life, which would best serve the ends of justice and the interests of
society.
42. Consequently, we set aside the findings and reasoning given by the Trial
Court awarding the death sentence to appellant and in place thereof, we
sentence him to imprisonment for life for committing the offence under
Sections 302 read with Sections 201, 363, 376 IPC and Section 5M/6 of
POCSO Act. Accordingly, we modify and convert the punishment of the
appellant from the death sentence to imprisonment for life.
43. Therefore, in the light of the above discussions, we reject the Reference
No. 11 of 2021 referred by the Trial Court for confirmation of the death
sentence awarded to the appellant, namely, Ashok.
44. Accordingly, we alter and commute the death sentence of appellant,
namely, Ashok from capital punishment to life imprisonment under Section
302 IPC, while affirming the findings and reasoning recorded by the Trial
Court in respect of other offences, which shall remain unchanged. Thus, we
partly allow the Capital Criminal Appeal No. 14 of 2021.
45. Let a copy of this judgment and order be communicated to the Trial
Court along with the Trial Court Record for necessary compliance forthwith.
46. Learned Amicus Curiae, Sri Rajrshi Gupta appearing for informant is
held entitled to his professional fee of Rs. 21,000/-.
November 17, 2026
Rohit
(Vinai Kumar Dwivedi,J.) (Siddharth,J.)
Digitally signed by :-
ROHIT DAS
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad