Parimal Bhanuprasad Pandit vs BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
: 1:
OA No.120/45/2025
CENTRAL ADMINISTRAT
TIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BE
ENCH
O.A. No.120/45/2
2025
th
Dated this the 06 day of
f November, 2026
Order Reserved On: 09.09.2026
6
Ord
er Pronounced On: 06.11.2026
CORAM:
Hon’ble Shri
i Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J
J)
Hon’ble Shri
i Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)
Parimal Bhan
Ex-Accounts
O/0. GMTD,
District: Saba
Residing at B
Berana Road
District: Saba
(By Advocat
nuprasad Pandit,
s Officer (cash)
, Himmatnagar
arkantha-383001.
B/79, Umiyanagar,
d, Himmatnagar
arkantha - 383001. ….App
plicant
tes:Shri Dileep B. Rana)
V
VERSUS
1. Secreta
Minist
Depart
Sancha
Ashok
2. Board
BSNL
Bharat
H.c. M
Janpath
3. Chairm
Bharat
Bharat
H.c. M
New D
4. Chief G
Gujara
Teleph
Ellis B
Ahmed
(By Advocat
ary (Telecom)
try of Communications
tment of Telecommunications
ar Bhavan, 20,
ka Road, New Delhi - 110 001.
of Directors (Appellate Authorit
ty)
Corporate office,
t Sanchar Bhavan,
Mathur Lane
h, New Delhi - 110 001.
man & Managing Director,
t Sanchar Nigam Ltd.
t Sanchar Bhavan,
Mathur Lane Janpath,
Delhi - 110 001.
General Manager,
at Telecom Circle,
hone Bhavan,
Bridge
dabad -380 006 …Resp
pondents
te: Shri H.D.Shukla)
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 2:
OA No.120/45/2025
O R D E R
Pe
er : Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V.Bh
hairavia, Member (J)
1. The g
grievance of the applicant in
n the instant OA is that the
e
Disciplinary
Authority, vide order dated 06
6.02.2023, has illegally imposed
d
upon him the
e penalty of 25% cut in his mont
thly pension for a period of five
e
years, which
h has subsequently been affirm
med by the Appellate Authority
y
vide order da
ated 21.09.2023 and further uph
held by the Reviewing Authority
y
vide order da
ated 07.10.2024 while rejecting
g his review petition. Therefore,
,
by filing the
present OA under Section 19 o
of the Administrative Tribunals
s
Act, 1985, th
he applicant is seeking the follow
wing reliefs:-
“(A) The Hon’ble Tribunal be pl
leased to quash and set
02.2023 passed by the
osing major penalty on
aside the order dated 06.0
disciplinary authority impo
the applicant, order dated 21
appellate authority and o
passed by the review auth
grounds and documents e
record.
1.09.2023 passed by the
rder dated 07.10.2024
hority considering the
evidences available on
(B) The Hon’ble Tribunal be pl
leased to pass any other
may be deemed fit and
and further orders that m
proper.”
2. BRIEF
F FACTS OF THE CASE
2.1 The a
applicant was initially appoint
ted as Senior Telecom Office
e
Assistant on
01.03.1982 and was subsequent
tly appointed as Junior Accounts
s
Officer on 14
4.06.2010 after qualifying the d
departmental examination. Upon
n
the formation
n of Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limi
ited (BSNL), he was absorbed in
n
the organisat
tion with effect from 01.10.200
00 under Rule 37A of the CCS
S
(Pension) Ru
ules ( Annexure A/2 refer). He
was subsequently promoted as
s
Accounts Of
fficer and, at the time of his volu
untary retirement on 31.01.2020,
,
was working
g as Accounts Officer (Cash)
in the office of the General
l
Manager Tel
ecom District, Himmatnagar, Gu
ujarat Telecom Circle BSNL.
2.2 After
applicant’s voluntary retireme
ent, the respondents issued a
a
Charge Mem
morandum dated 05.10.2020 unde
er Rules 36 and 61 of the BSNL
L
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 3:
OA No.120/45/2025
Conduct, Dis
scipline and Appeal Rules, 200
6 hereinafter referred to as ‘the
e
BSNL CDA
Rules, 2006’), in respect of all
leged irregularities pertaining to
o
the period fro
om 01.07.2017 to 31.01.2020 ( A
Annexure A/3 refer).
2.3 After t
the completion of the regular in
quiry, the Inquiry Officer asked
d
the Presentin
ng Officer to submit his brief a
and accordingly, the Presenting
g
Officer subm
mitted his brief on 27.01.2022,
wherein the Presenting Officer
r
categorically
y stated that the charges leveled
against the charged officer (the
e
applicant) as
"NOT PROVED" ( Annexure A
A/4 refer).
2.4 Therea
after, the applicant submitted
detailed defense brief to the
e
Inquiry Offic
cer on 28.02.2022 objecting th
he charges levelled against him
m
( Annexure-A
A/5 refer). However, the Inqu
uiry Officer submitted inquiry
y
report on 12.
.05.2022 ( Annexure A/6 ) to the
e Disciplinary Authority holding
g
that the charg
ges are proved though the Prese
enting Officer after due analysis
s
of the eviden
nces reached to the conclusion t
that the charges levelled against
t
the charge of
fficer i.e. applicant has not been p
proved.
2.5 The D
Disciplinary Authority furnishe
ed the inquiry report to the
e
applicant vid
de Memorandum dated 13.06.2
022 ( Annexure A/7 refer) and
d
invited his re
epresentation. The applicant sub
bmitted a detailed representation
n
dated 08.08.
.2022 ( Annexure A/8 refer),
disputing the findings of the
e
Inquiry Offi
cer and asserting, inter alia ,
that the duties relating to the
e
collection an
nd deposit of cheques receive
ed from franchisees had been
n
assigned to t
the concerned Customer Servic
ce Centre (CSC) in-charges and
d
that the mon
itoring of franchisee transaction
ns fell within the responsibilities
s
of the Accou
unts Officer (CMTS).
2.6 The ap
pplicant further contended that
the ERP system had not been
n
configured in
n conformity with the applicable
e Sales and Distribution Policy,
,
2018, as it
permitted the issuance of C-
TOP UP material to multiple
e
franchisees a
against a single cheque and en
nabled transactions beyond the
e
prescribed b
bank-guarantee limits. Accord
ding to him, these systemic
c
deficiencies,
together with the allocation of
f duties under the departmental
l
order dated 0
01.05.2015, had not been properl
ly considered during the inquiry.
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 4:
OA No.120/45/2025
2.7 The D
Disciplinary Authority neverth
heless imposed the aforesaid
d
pension cut
vide order dated 06.02.2023
3 ( Annexure A/1 refer). The
e
applicant's a
appeal ( Annexure A/10 refer)
) was rejected on 21.09.2023
3
( Annexure
A/11 refer), and his review
w petition dated 22.10.2023
3
( Annexure A
A/12 refer) was rejected on 07.1
10.2024 ( Annexure A/13 refer).
.
Hence, this O
OA.
3. Pursua
ant to notice issued by this Tribu
unal, the respondents have filed
d
their reply to
which the applicant has also file
ed rejoinder.
4. CONT
TENTIONS OF THE APPLICA
ANT
4.1 Learne
ed counsel Mr.Dileep B Rana fo
or the applicant submits that the
e
impugned or
rders suffer from non-application
n of mind, disregard of material
l
evidence and
d failure to appreciate the distin
nction between the duties of the
e
Accounts Of
fficer (Cash), the Accounts Off
ficer (CMTS) and the CSC in-
-
charges.
4.2 It is s
submitted that the applicant wa
as working as Account Officer
r
(Cash) the f
following procedure was prevai
iling in respect to handling the
e
receipt of c
cash and deposition of cheq
que and its reconciliation at
t
Himmatnaga
ar BSNL and the same was follo
owed by the staff of the BSNL
L
including the
e applicant :-
(a)
All the work of cash and
d cheque depositing and its
s
reconc
ciliation was being done by the
Accounts Officer (Cash) sitting
g
at Him
matnagar office till 30.4.2015.
Due to curtail the expenditu
ure to bring the cheques to
o
Himatn
nagar SSA the Himatnagar Adm
ministration issued an order dated
d
1.5.20
15 (Annexure A/14) and accord
dingly the work of cheque and
d
cash d
depositing was handed over to t
the CSC incharges of the entire
e
Distric
ct.
(b)
There were 11 such CSCs in Him
matnagar SSA and the incharges
s
of thes
se CSCs were JTO level officer
r (Gr.B) and all cheques which
h
were b
being received by them in the ca
sh counter were being deposited
d
to the B
BSNL account at their places.
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 5:
OA No.120/45/2025
(c)
Due to the introduction PAN
India clearance, these cheques
s
were c
cleared from that CSC areas. Th
he CSC incharges will intimate
e
the dep
position of cheques and its clear
rance to the concerned Accounts
s
Office
rs.
(d)
It is submitted that BSNL wa
as receiving payments from the
e
custom
mers of Landline/broadband,
Post-paid subscribers, Mobile
e
franch
isee payments, Leased Line pay
yments etc balance payment of
f
the tem
mporary advances and staff paym
ment by cheque or cash.
(e)
To look after the payments of
Landline/Broad band segments,
,
one Ac
ccounts Officer (TR) was posted
d, who will look after the receipt
t
of pay
yment and as such for Mobile po
ost paid subscribers and Mobile
e
franch
isee payment one AO(CMTS) w
was posted and both were sitting
g
in Him
matnagar. They will look after
r the clearance of the cheques
s
which
were deposited by the CSC and
d if any cheques bounced due to
o
non-av
vailability of funds, they will
intimate the same to the AO
O
(Cash)
) for issuing notice to the subsc
cribers and its reconciliation of
f
BSNL
Accounts.
4.3 It is su
ubmitted that the subject matter o
of the chargesheet was in respect
t
of non-depos
sit of cheques received by the ap
pplicant from the franchisees of
f
BSNL. In thi
is regard, it is stated that the che
eques were received by CSC In-
-
charge of Hi
imatnagar CSC and it was the
duty of the CSC in-charge of
f
Himatnagar
i.e. Himatnagar Civil CSC, to
deposit the cheques and cash
h
received by t
them.
4.4 It is s
stated that ERP system was in
n full force in Gujarat and in
n
Himatnagar
also. The details of the che
ques and cash received were
e
available in
the ERP system and it can b
be verified by the AO(CMTS),
,
AO(Cash), A
AO(TA), CAO, DGM(Fin.),
DGM(CM-Mktg), GMTD, of
f
Himatnagar
and GM (Mktg-CM) , DGM
M(CA), PGM(Fin), CGMT, of
f
Gujarat Circ
le, Ahmedabad and the necessa
ary CM Marketing and Finance
e
officers of BS
SNL Corporate Office in BSNL.
.
4.5 Learne
ed counsel contended that, purs
suant to the departmental order
r
dated 01.05
.2015, the responsibility for
depositing cash and cheques
s
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 6:
OA No.120/45/2025
collected at t
the CSCs had been assigned to
the respective CSC in-charges.
.
The applican
nt's role, according to him, w
was confined to the functions
s
assigned to th
he Accounts Officer (Cash), incl
luding reconciliation and related
d
accounting f
functions. The responsibility
for monitoring the collection,
,
deposit and r
realisation of cheques relating to
o franchisee transactions was, he
e
asserts, assig
gned to the Accounts Officer (CM
MTS).
4.6 Learne
ed counsel further submits that
the applicant's office had been
n
circulating m
monthly statements showing the
e outstanding cash and cheque
e
balances und
der the signatures of the applica
ant and the superior officer. It is
s
the prime du
uty of the AO(CMTS) to ensu
ure that the cheques and cash
h
received by
the CSC Incharges in respect
of the franchisee payments are
e
deposited in
the Bank and intimate the status
s to the higher officers of BSNL
L
Himatnagar a
and also to AO(Cash) for recon
nciliation. He was intimating the
e
facts continu
uously about the non-depositio
on of the cheques to IFA and
d
GMTD. But
t no action was taken by the high
her authorities.
4.7 It is fa
act that as per clause (d) at page N
No.7 of the Sales & Distribution
n
policy, 2018(
(Annexure-A/16), the duty of ch
heque deposition of CM material
l
was the duty
y of Accounts Officer. It is subm
mitted that the word “Accounts
s
Officer” is n
not AO(Cash), but it is AO(CM
MTS) as per the order placed at
t
Annexure A/
/14, as all the CSC Incharges tho
ough were reporting to their DE
E
concerned, i
in respect of CM activities, th
hey report to AO(CMTS) and
d
DGM(CM-M
Mktg) of the District.
Therefore, le
earned counsel for the applicant s
submits that the charges levelled
d
against the ap
pplicant that the cheques were n
not deposited by applicant in the
e
time, is not te
enable and the same is against th
he policy in vogue.
4.8 It is su
ubmitted that as per clause 9(iii
i) of S & D policy The officers
s
concerned w
who will accept payment by c
cheque will be responsible for
r
monitoring th
he cheque as per time frame giv
ven in para(ii) of the policy and
d
they will also
o ensure that the value of chequ
ues outstanding does not exceed
d
the value of b
bank guarantee at any time’.
4.9. Further,
it is the duty of CSC Incharge
e concern to receive and credit
t
cheques to th
he bank and not by the applicant.
.
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 7:
OA No.120/45/2025
4.10 It is su
ubmitted that the GMTD order t
the CSCs to deposit the cheques
s
pending with
h them i.e. around 189 chequ
ues from months’ together on
n
25.9.2018 an
nd cheques were deposited on 2
27.8.2018 and all cheques were
e
bounced back
k on 28.9.2018.
4.11 In this r
regard, it is stated that when the
AO (Cash), the applicant herein
n
received the b
bounced cheque on 30.9.2018, h
he issued notice under 138 of the
e
Negotiable In
nstruments Act after taking the a
approval from GMTD.
4.12 To buttr
ress the aforesaid submission, le
earned counsel for the applicant
t
also argued th
hat :
(a) That, th
he disciplinary authority, appe
llate authority and Reviewing
g
Authority ser
riously erred in not appreciating
g the fact that the applicant was
s
working as
AO( Cash) during the allege
ed period and is not anyway
y
connected in
respect of the receipt of cheque
e from the franchisee, its deposit
t
and its moni
itoring as the CM materials we
ere issued by CSC in charge or
r
respective CS
SC and the cheque were collecte
ed by them and deposited in the
e
bank.
(b) It is fu
urther submitted that as per claus
se No.C (d) on page no.7 of CM
M
sales and dis
stribution policy, 2018, it will be
e the responsibility of Accounts
s
Officer to re
emit the collection from franch
hisee to the credit of collection
n
Account of C
Company on as and when purc
chase of BSNL product (except
t
post paid pr
roduct) are made by franchisee
e and ensure the realization of
f
cheques. It i
is also narrated in similar clau
use stating that “It will be the
e
responsibility
y of Accounts officer to remit th
he collection from franchisee to
o
credit the col
llection Account of company on
n daily basis and also realization
n
of cheques”
as stipulated in Clause No.C (e)
) on page N0.6 of CM sales and
d
distribution p
policy-2012.
(c) It is s
ubmitted that to look after the
ese activities, another Accounts
s
Officer i.e. A
AO(CMTS) was posted in the Him
matnagar SSA and the applicant
t
is not at all re
esponsible for this activity.
(d) That, the
disciplinary authority, the appel
llate authority and the reviewing
g
authority ser
riously erred in not appreciatin
ng the fact that to monitor the
e
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 8:
OA No.120/45/2025
cheque coll
ection and its deposit and
its clearance, one Accounts
s
Officer(CMT
TS) under DGM (CM-Mktg) i
is posted and he should have
e
monitored th
he cheque collection, its deposit
and its clearance as the same is
s
not the work
of the applicant who was workin
ng as AO(Cash).
(e) That, t
the respondent authorities ough
ht to have appreciated that the
e
collection of
f cheque, its entry in the ERP an
d its deposit are not the work of
f
the Account
Officer(Cash) and the same wor
rk was transferred to the CSC In
n
charge from
the year 2015 vide order dated
d 01.05.2015 and the same was
s
being follow
wed in Himmatnagar SSA from
m the date of the order dated
d
1.5.2015 (An
nnexure-A/14).
(f) The r
respondent No.2 didn’t consid
der that the applicant was not
t
supposed to
deposit the cheques received fr
rom the franchisees as per order
r
dated 1.5.201
15 (Annexure A/14.)
Further, it is
stated that the cheques were ly
ying with the CSC incharge and
d
he had not h
handed over the cheques to AO
O(Cash) as the duty of cheque
e
deposition is
s lying with the CSC incharge f
for which many staff who were
e
doing the wo
ork were transferred from AO(C
Cash) section to SDE (prov) and
d
subsequently
y they had given the same work a
at CSC Himatnagar.
(g) That t
the office of the applicant was
issuing monthly information in
n
respect of th
he cash and cheque balances
under DGM’s signature every
y
month for the
e information of all concerned. (A
Annexure A/15).
(h) The
investigating officer in thi
s case i.e. the SW-1, the
e
SDE(Vigilan
nce) of Himatnagar SSA confi
firmed the delay in deposit of
f
cheques in H
Himatnagar SSA was not becaus
se of AO(Cash) and there is no
o
evidence to p
prove that due to delay in depo
ositing the cheques, the cheques
s
got dishonou
ured.
(i) The r
espondent No.2 didn’t consider
r the fact that the ERP systems
s
were not con
nfigured as per the S&D policy, 2
2018.
(j) The re
espondent No.2 didn’t consider
the fact that as per S&D policy
y
2018 and as
per clause g(i), (ii), (iii) and (iv
v) at page No.15 of the policy, it
t
is very clear
rly stated that “to purchase mat
terial against cheque franchisee
e
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 9:
OA No.120/45/2025
will have to
provide a separate bank guara
antee with validity of 180 days
s
more than th
he period of agreement and also
o stated that the franchisees can
n
then purchas
se material of value up to th
he Bank guarantee. The bank
k
guarantee is
separate from PBG. Circles wi
ill have to decide upper cap on
n
this bank g
guarantee which may be equ
uivalent to 7 days inventory
y
requirement
in the multiple of Rs.50,000/-.
Here the Bank Guarantee was
s
given for Rs.
.30 lakhs against which material
up to Rs.2.39 crores were given
n
to the franch
hisee against the cheque. Moreov
ver, there is another rule that all
l
franchisee ar
re individual and if all franchisee
e wanted credit r 13 facility, they
y
should give
separate PBG. Here in this cas
se, through the main franchisee
e
had 2 othe
er franchisee-ship at Bayad
and Himatnagar, they were
e
incorporated
with the main franchisee and i
ssued material on credit and all
l
their account
ts were jointly done and the ma
in franchisee issued one cheque
e
for all the th
hree franchisees (as explained i
in Para 5(L) of the application
n
along with A
Annexure A/17).
(k) It is th
he duty of the Inquiry officer to
o analyse the case with all facts
s
and figures a
and also take into consideration
the facts, which he had brought
t
into the inqu
uiry, as well as the deposition of
f the State witnesses in the case,
,
and explain t
them in his report, before concl
luding his analysis. Here in this
s
case, the sta
ate witness, SW-1, who was th
he investigating officer I.e. Sub
b
Divisional E
Engineer (Vigilance) stated befo
re the Inquiry that the delay in
n
deposit of th
e cheques is not because of AO
O(Cash) and there is no evidence
e
is available t
that the cheques got dishonoured
d due to the applicant as well he
e
deposed that
the delay in depositing the cheq
ques in Himatnagar is a common
n
practice since
e 2016. Moreover, the other depo
osition of SW-4 and SW-6, both
h
categorically
y stated that the ERP system w
was not configured incorporate
e
much relevan
nt guidelines available in S&D P
Policy regarding extending credit
t
facility to th
he franchisees up to their PBG/
/taking approval from the SSA
A
Head while e
exceeding the credit limit etc an
nd also the system should have
e
prevented th
he CSC Incharge to give C
TOP UP balance to infinite
e
franchisees o
on a sing cheques, which is t
the basic problem of the case.
.
Moreover, al
ll these witnesses confirmed tha
at if the ERP system configured
d
properly thes
se types of irregularities could ha
ave been avoided.
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 10:
OA No.120/45/2025
(l) Moreo
over, the working employees
like the CSC incharge, the
e
Franchisee M
Manager got stoppage of two
increments for two years, the
e
AO(CMTS)
got a minor penalty and got stop
ppage of two increments for two
o
years, the DG
GM(Fin) got 5% deduction of p
pension for two years. But some
e
officers who
o were actually involved viz.,
DGM, GMTD, were not even
n
charge sheete
ed.
(m) That,
the appellate authority oug
ght to have appreciated that
t
AO(CMTS) w
was supposed to look after all th
hese works of collection, deposit
t
with the ban
nk and realization of the bank b
but the said officer namely Shri
i
Atul Bhanda
ari AO (CMTS) was given a min
nor chargesheet and stoppage of
f
two increme
nts for two years by the same
inquiry officer as Disciplinary
y
Authority wh
hich clearly shows discriminator
ry treatment by the authority to
o
impose majo
or penalty on the applicant who
o is not responsible for the said
d
charge. It is f
further submitted that all other si
imilarly situated officers against
t
whom the d
disciplinary proceedings were t
taken by the department were
e
punished w
with minor penalties which
clearly proves discrimination
n
treatment, he
ence requires to be quash and set
aside in the interest of justice.
(n) That t
the rules which had been brough
ht by the respondents are of very
y
old and it wa
as for the Government organisa
ation. Due to become a business
s
organisation
and implementation of ERP, an
nd being a Government of India
a
undertaking a
and had the power to take their o
own decision for the business at
t
the field leve
el, the GMTD on 1.5.2015 (Ann
nexure- A/14) changed the rules
s
of depositing
g the cheques and the same was
entrusted to the CSC incharges.
.
In Himatnag
gar SSA, there is one CSC nam
mely Himatnagar Civil and one
e
Junior Teleco
om Officer, who is class II offic
cer posted as CSC incharge and
d
the duty of th
his officer was to deposit the ch
heque in respect of CM material.
.
To verify and
d monitor another Accounts Offi
icer I.e. AO(CMTS) was posted.
.
The AO(Cas
sh) came to know when the C
SC incharge gave the monthly
y
report and ac
ccordingly the bank reconciliatio
on was done by the AO(Cash). A
A
report in resp
pect of the non-deposition of che
eques were issued by AO(Cash)
)
to all higher
r authorities including AO(CMT
TS). With respect to the charge
e
that while fo
forfeiting the bank guarantee th
he applicant divided into three
e
franchisees i
s wrong. Everything was done t
through ERP and the only input
t
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 11:
OA No.120/45/2025
is the cheque
e number. When the cheque num
mber (O) inserted in the system it
t
automatically
y bifurcated with the three fran
nchisees, because in ERP while
e
issuing C TO
OP UP to the franchisee, the C
CSC incharge made such entry,
,
which was ex
xplained by me in detail in para 5
5(L).
(o) That,
the Presenting Officer (PO) afte
er due analysis of the evidences
s
reached to th
he conclusion that the charges le
eveled against the charge officer
r
i.e. applicant
t herein has not been proved. In
n such cases, the inquiry should
d
have been cl
losed at that point of time itself
f as the Presenting Officer who
o
was presentin
ng the case on behalf of the disc
ciplinary authority categorically
y
stated that t
the charge leveled against the
Charged Officer as not been
n
proved.That
the Presenting officer submitted
d the brief stating the charges are
e
NOT PROVE
ED. But when the Presenting O
Officer and the Charged Officer
r
stated in thei
r brief that the charges are not pr
roved, it is the prime duty of the
e
Inquiry Offi
cer to give charge-wise reason
ns why he had concluded the
e
inquiry repor
rt as “PROVED”.
(p) That,
the inquiry officer should have
e given reasons as to why he is
s
not accepting
g the finding of presenting off
ficer as well as the defense of
f
charge offic
cer, but the inquiry officer b
eing a HAG level officer of
f
Government
of India and working in BSN
NL had just concluded without
t
giving any re
easons for his conclusion that th
he charges are proved, which is
s
against the pr
rovisions of BSNL CDA Rules,
2006and CCS (CCA) Rules.
(q) That t
the IO in his report ignored man
ny important facts and evidences
s
put forward b
by the applicant vide his defense
e brief. One among the very fact
t
that, there w
as no control / restrictions avail
lable in the ERP system to safe-
-
guard the int
terest of BSNL. This aspect is v
very much transpired during the
e
deposition /
cross examination by the S
SW-1, SW-4 and SW-6, they
y
categorically
y stated that, the system was not
t configured incorporating much
h
relevant guid
delines available in the S&D po
olicy regarding extending credit
t
facility to th
he franchisees up to their PBG/
taking approval from the SSA
A
head while
exceeding the credit limit etc.
Also the system should have
e
prevented th
he CSC incharge to give C-
-TOP UP balance to infinite
e
franchisees o
on a single cheque, which is the
basic problem of the case, Even
n
all the State W
Witnesses confirmed that if the E
ERP system configured properly
y
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 12:
OA No.120/45/2025
this type of i
irregularity could have been avo
oided not only in Himmatnagar
r
but also in ot
ther SSAs of India also.
(r) That,
the authority ought to have app
preciated that the deposition of
f
SW-1 (Inve
estigating officer) i.e. SDE(v
vigilance), Himmatnagar who
o
confirmed th
hat the delay in deposit of cheq
que in Himmatnagar SSA is not
t
because of A
AO(Cash). Moreover, there is no
o documentary evidence placed
d
on record to
prove that due to delay in dep
posit of cheque, the cheque got
t
dishonored a
and therefore it was concluded
d by observing that the charge
e
officer is not
guilty for delay in depositing th
he cheque.
(s) It is subm
mitted that:
(i) the
the BS
PBG g
e configuration of ERP was not
SNL, where the credit facility to b
according to the S&D Policy of
be extended up to the amount of
f
f
given by them and not “infinite”
(ii) On
bifurca
ne franchisee- one cheque form
ating one cheque into three franc
mula to be observed instead of
chisees,
f
(iii) th
charge
1.5.20
incharg
AO(CM
he Inquiry Officer didn’t give
es, when the PO had “Not prove
any reasons while proving the
ed” the case (4) the order dated
e
d
C
15 on which the work of chequ
ges and in respect of Mobile rec
MTS) and not AO(Cash).
e deposit was given to the CSC
charge the work was entrusted to
o
(t) That
as per General Financial Rules
s, the DDO is the authority to
o
deposit the
cheques and making payment
ts to the parties etc. And the
e
reconciliation
n of the accounts are to be done
e by the Accounts Officer (TA).
.
Here in this
case, due to introduction of ER
RP, the work of cheque deposit
t
was given to
o the CSC incharges .e.f. 1.4.20
015 as per Annexure A/14. To
o
monitor the
receipt of the cheques and its
deposition in the bank was the
e
work of AO(
(CM TS) of the District. The rec
onciliation work was to be done
e
by the AO(T
elecom Accounts).
(u) In the
e facts of the present case, the
e bank guarantee given by the
e
franchisee w
was for Rs.30,00,000/- (Thirty la
akhs) and as per this clause, the
e
franchisee w
was supposed to get the C-TOP
P up for that amount only. It is
s
further subm
mitted that in BSNL, the C TOP
P UP delivery was being done
e
through the
ERP system, through the CS
C and the AO(CMTS) has to
o
monitor daily
y about the issuance and the rece
eipt of the cash/cheque properly.
.
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 13:
OA No.120/45/2025
But in the ER
RP system, the amount of C TOP
P UP recharge kept as “infinite”.
.
Therefore, in
n Himatnagar SSA as per th
e advice of the then General
l
Manager, C
TOP UP recharges were being d
done for more than Rs.2 crores,
,
whereas actu
ually it would have been only
y Rs.30,00,000/-. Therefore the
e
configuration
n of ERP is not according to t
the policy decided as per S&D
D
policy, which
h is annexed as Annexure A/16.
(v) That w
whenever the franchisee purchase
e the C TOP UP recharge, every
y
franchisee ha
as to issue one cheque. There
were 6 franchisees working in
n
Himatnagar d
during the period from 2016 to
o 2019. In Himatnagar the main
n
franchisee M
M/s.Reliance communications
(two units) and M/s.A.R.
.
Communicat
tions (total 3 franchisee) issued
one cheque and requested for C
C
TOP UP for
different franchisee. The ERP s
system allowed this and marked
d
the cheque N
No.XXX/A, XXX/B and XXX/C
C. This fact was not knowing to
o
the AO(Cash
h) and other finance officers. W
When the office started to forfeit
t
the bank
guarantee against the o
outstanding of M/s.Reliance
e
Communicat
tions, the amount outstanding
of other franchisees were also
o
cleared again
nst that cheque. It is also clearly
y speaks the wrong configuration
n
of the ERP n
not according to the policy. A co
opy of the details of the cheques
s
received fro
om the franchisees and its c
learance for the period from
m
14.02.2018 to
o 31.03.2020 (Annexure A/17).
(w) That, th
he disciplinary authority absolut
tely ignored the fact about the
e
system to all
low unlimited C TOP UP Balan
nce to the franchisee beyond the
e
PBG submitt
ted on cheque and not restricted
d the CSC in charge from doing
g
so and the
disciplinary authority punishe
ed the charge officer i.e. the
e
applicant he
rein for other’s fault. This pro
oves that SD Module of ERP
P
system was n
not configured as per the S&D
policy, which creates all these
e
anomalies an
nd the applicant is made scape-g
goat for imposing major penalty
y
without verif
fying the record and evidences av
vailable on record.
(x) That, th
he respondent authority ought
to have appreciated that the
e
deposition of
f SW-1 (Presenting officer) who
o categorically stated that delay
y
in depositing
g of franchisee cheque was com
mmon practice in Himmatnagar
r
SSA since 20
016.
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 14:
OA No.120/45/2025
(y) That, th
e respondent authority ought
to have appreciated that ERP
P
system allow
wed giving C-TOP UP Balance
to three franchisee in a single
e
cheque which
h is a major drawback of the con
nfiguration of the ERP system.
(z) That not
only finance wing but all offe
rs of Himatnagar SSA, Gujarat
t
Telecom Cir
rcle and BSNL Corporate Off
fice knows very well that the
e
cheques bein
ng collected by the CSC incharg
ge was not being deposited. The
e
PGM(F) had
d also talked to GMTD Hi
imatnagar in this connection.
.
Moreover, th
he Chief General Manager of Gu
ujarat Telecom Circle, convened
d
a meeting wi
ith the franchisees for early clea
arance of the cheques along with
h
the officers
of Himatnagar SSA and Finan
nce Wing of Circle Office on
n
10.8.2018. U
Under these circumstances, the a
applicant being a junior officer
r
and had no a
authority to ask the technical pe
erson to do this and do that who
o
was under th
he full control of the GMTD, Him
matnagar. The applicant brought
t
these facts al
lso before the respondent No.2 to
o 4 but in vain.
(aa) That, the
e respondent authorities ought to
o have appreciated that PBG was
s
forfeited on
11.09.2018 and within 11
days i.e. from 30.08.2018 to
o
10.09.2018,
the AO(Cash) and other mark
keting personnel could collect
t
around Rs.64
4 Lakhs from the Himmatnagar F
Franchisee.
(bb) That, th
e appellate authority has not rec
corded any findings for rejecting
g
the appeals b
by order dated 21.09.2023 and th
he order is a non-speaking order
r
to confirm th
he decision of the disciplinary au
uthority.
(cc) An emp
ployee (applicant) who worked
in BSNL and drawing pension
n
from Secreta
ary (Telecommunications), Gove
ernment of India are ruled by the
e
Secretary (C
C) i.e. respondent No.1 herein.
Any disciplinary action to be
e
initiated aga
inst an employee who was dra
awing pension from respondent
t
No.l, the sam
me can be initiated by respondent
t No.l only.
After i
investigation, the respondent No
o.2 had to submit the case to the
e
respondent N
No.1 and subsequently, the resp
pondent No.1 will authorise the
e
respondent N
No.2 to issue chargesheet and a c
copy of the authorisation should
d
have been giv
ven along with the chargesheet.
This procedure not followed by
y
the responde
ents. Here in this case, the resp
ondent No.2 issued chargesheet
t
and before
issuing the punishment order
r, they took the approval of
f
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 15:
OA No.120/45/2025
respondent N
No.l, which can be seen from the
e last sentence of the punishment
t
order. This i
is unnatural and therefore, the
applicant denies the averments
s
made by the
e respondents in this connection
n. It is further submitted that in
n
such a case f
filed before this Hon’ble Tribun
nal, in O.A. No.265 of 2024, the
e
Hon’ble Trib
bunal had stayed the proceeding
gs I.e. issuing the orders by the
e
respondent .
No.2 (Zakaria Thomas V/s. Se
ecretary (C) and BSNL and the
e
matter is pen
nding before this Hon’ble Tribun
al.
(dd) That,
as per the well settled princ
ciple of law, no disciplinary
y
proceedings
can be initiated after the delinq
quent employee or officer retires
s
from service
. The applicant craves leave to r
rely on the said judgment at the
e
time of hear
ring of the application i.e. Stat
te Bank of India versus Navin
n
Kumar Sinha
a decided by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in Civil Appeal No. 1279
9
of 2024.
(ee) That th
e respondents without applicat
tion of mind and mechanically
y
decided the
case and had been issued pun
nishment order for 25% of the
e
pension cut f
for 5 years.
4.13 Learne
ed counsel argues that the Inq
quiry Officer failed to provide
e
adequate rea
asons for disagreeing with the
Presenting Officer's conclusion
n
that the char
rges were not proved. The appl
icant maintains that the inquiry
y
report substa
antially reiterated the allegations
s without properly analyzing the
e
documentary
y evidence, the testimony of the
departmental witnesses and the
e
explanation f
furnished by him.
4.14 The ap
pplicant also relies upon the d
depositions of the departmental
l
witnesses, pa
articularly SW-1, SW-4 and SW
W-6, to contend that the delay in
n
depositing ch
heques was not attributable to
him and that the ERP system
m
lacked the n
necessary safeguards prescribed
d by the Sales and Distribution
n
Policy.
4.15 Learne
ed counsel also questions the fai
irness of the proceedings on the
e
ground that
t the Disciplinary Authority
y's Memorandum/letter dated
d
13.06.2022 r
recorded its agreement with the
findings of the Inquiry Officer
r
even before
consideration of the applicant'
s representation on the Inquiry
y
Report. Furth
her, it is submitted that the subs
sequent penalty order, as well as
s
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 16:
OA No.120/45/2025
the appellate
e and reviewing orders, failed
to deal meaningfully with the
e
material grou
unds raised by the applicant.
4.16 Learne
ed counsel for the applicant furt
ther submits that the respondent
t
has given dis
scriminatory treatment, contend
ding that the CSC in-charge, the
e
Franchisee
Manager and the Accounts
s Officer (CMTS) received
d
comparativel
ly lesser penalties, while the
applicant was subjected to a
a
substantial re
eduction in pension. He also ra
aises an objection regarding the
e
competence
and authorization of the autho
orities to initiate and conclude
e
proceedings a
affecting his pension after retirem
ment.
4.17 Learne
ed counsel for the applicant subm
mits that the applicant herein is a
a
pensioner w
with having Rs.45,000/- pensio
on per month and out of this
s
Rs.14,000 w
were being deducted for non f
fault on his part which caused
d
serious finan
ncial crunch to manage the fam
mily. According to the learned
d
counsel, the
PO in his written brief admitt
ed that there is no evidence to
o
sustain the ch
harges levelled against the appli
cant, and in fact this is a case of
f
no evidence,
therefore, the impugned orders
s are bad in law and required to
o
be quashed a
and set aside.
5. CONT
TENTIONS OF THE RESPON
NDENTS
5.1 Per co
ontra, the respondents’ learned c
counsel opposes the instant OA
A
and submits
that the disciplinary proceeding
s were conducted in accordance
e
with the BSN
NL CDA Rules, 2006, after aff
fording the applicant reasonable
e
opportunities
s to defend himself. According
to learned counsel, the inquiry
y
report was fu
urnished to the applicant, his rep
presentation was considered, and
d
the Disciplin
nary Authority thereafter passed
d the final order on the basis of
f
the material o
on record.
5.2 The re
espondents’ learned counsel sub
bmits that the conclusion of the
e
Presenting O
Officer is not binding upon the
e Inquiry Officer. The latter is
s
required to i
independently assess the oral a
and documentary evidence, the
e
submissions
of the Presenting Officer and the
e defence of the charged officer.
.
Therefore, th
he mere fact that the Presenting
g Officer considered the charges
s
not proved
does not invalidate the contra
ary conclusion reached by the
e
Inquiry Offic
cer.
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 17:
OA No.120/45/2025
5.3 The re
espondents’ learned counsel furth
her maintains that the applicant,
,
while functio
oning as Accounts Officer (Cash
h) and Drawing and Disbursing
g
Officer, was
s responsible for overall mo
onitoring of cash and cheque
e
collections, th
heir deposit and the reconciliatio
on of bank transactions.
Learne
ed counsel also contends that th
he applicant failed to discharge
e
his responsib
bilities and did not exercise due c
care in relation to the franchisee
e
transactions
and the subsequent adjustment
of outstanding amounts against
t
the bank guar
rantee.
5.4 It is su
ubmitted that Applicant while ca
arrying out his official duties as
s
the overall m
monitoring of cash/cheque collect
tion and its deposition as well as
s
Bank Reconc
ciliation Statement is required t
to be carried out by AO (Cash)
)
being the DD
DO of Himatnagar SSA. Moreo
over the Applicant should have
e
been more ca
areful while forfeiting the PBG o
of other firm.
5.6 It is s
submitted that upon careful rev
view of the inquiry report, the
e
Disciplinary
Authority provided the report t
to the charged officer, allowing
g
them to subm
mit a representation against the I
Inquiry Officer's findings. After
r
considering t
the charged officer's representat
tion, the Disciplinary Authority
y
issued the f
final order based on the grav
vity of the charges that were
e
substantiated
d.
5.7 It is s
submitted that the Inquiry Offi
icer, in the inquiry report, has
s
provided a d
detailed assessment on each poi
int of allegation, along with the
e
remarks of b
both the Presenting Officer (PO)
) and the Charged Officer (CO).
.
The Disciplin
nary Authority has found the I
nquiry Officer's report to be in
n
accordance w
with Rule 36(21)(d) of the BSN
NL CDA Rules, and therefore,
,
there was no
o requirement to return the rep
port to the Inquiry Officer. The
e
respondent
BSNL has conducted the
departmental proceedings in
n
compliance w
with the rule of law, ensuring
adherence to the principles of
f
natural justic
ce, which are fundamental to t
the proceedings. Therefore, the
e
submissions
made by the charged officer are
incorrect and misleading.
5.8 Learne
ed counsel also submitted that th
he Appellate Authority examined
d
the relevant r
records, the order of the Discipli
inary Authority and the grounds
s
raised in the
appeal and found the penalty to
o be supported by the evidence.
.
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 18:
OA No.120/45/2025
The Review
wing Authority, after considerin
ng the review petition and the
e
relevant reco
ords, likewise found no ground fo
or interference.
5.9 Relyin
ng upon Union of India v. Parm
ma Nanda , reported in (1989) 2
2
SCC 177, an
d B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of I
India , reported in (1995) 6 SCC
C
749, the resp
pondents’ learned counsel submit
ts that this Tribunal cannot sit in
n
appeal over t
the findings recorded in a depar
rtmental inquiry or substitute its
s
own assessm
ment of the evidence merely becau
use another view is possible.
6. Rejoin
nder by the Applicant
6.1 In reb
buttal, the applicant’s learned
counsel besides reiterating the
e
submissions,
as noted above, submits tha
at it is the prime duty of the
e
AO(CMTS)
to ensure that the cheques an
nd cash received by the CSC
C
Incharges in
respect of the franchisee paym
ments are deposited in the Bank
k
and intimate
the status to the higher officers
s of BSNL Himatnagar and also
o
to AO(Cash)
for reconciliation. This was not
done.
Though
h the facts of the non-depositio
on of the cheques for atleast 3
3
months, bein
ng a junior officer, no action cou
uld be taken by the applicant. He
e
was intimatin
ng the facts about the non-depos
sition of the cheques to IFA and
d
GMTD ever
ry and then. But no action w
was taken by the said higher
r
authorities.
6.2 He sub
bmits that the departmental orde
r dated 01.05.2015, the monthly
y
statements, th
he Sales and Distribution Polic
cy, 2018, and the records of the
e
franchisee t
transactions were material d
documents requiring specific
c
consideration
n.
6.3 Learne
ed counsel further submits that
t it is the duty of the Inquiry
y
officer to ana
alysis the evidence surfaced duri
ing the departmental inquiry and
d
not beyond i
it. He cannot act as Prosecutor
r. In the present case, the state
e
witness, SW
W-1, who was the investigatin
ng officer i.e. Sub Divisional
l
Engineer (Vi
igilance) stated before the Inquir
ry that the delay in deposit of the
e
cheques is n
not because of AO(Cash) and th
here is no evidence is available
e
that the chequ
ues got dishonoured due to the a
applicant as well he deposed that
t
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 19:
OA No.120/45/2025
the delay in
depositing the cheques in Him
matnagar is a common practice
e
since 2016.
Moreov
ver, the other deposition of SW-
-4 and SW-6, both categorically
y
stated that th
he ERP system was not configu
ured incorporate much relevant
t
guidelines av
vailable in S&D Policy regarding
g extending credit facility to the
e
franchisees u
up to their PBG/ taking appro
val from the SSA Head while
e
exceeding th
e credit limit etc and also the sy
ystem should have prevented the
e
CSC Incharg
ge to give C TOP UP balance t
to infinite franchisees on a sing
g
cheques, whi
ich is the basic problem within t
the system. Moreover, all these
e
witnesses con
nfirmed that if the ERP system
configured properly these types
s
of irregularit
ies could have been avoided. Th
herefore, the applicant cannot be
e
held to be r
responsible for any fault or de
efault in the departments’ ERP
P
system. The
very said aspect has not been co
onsidered in its true spirit by the
e
Disciplinary
Authority and erroneously p
passed the impugned order of
f
penalty, whic
ch is bad in law.
6.4 The ap
pplicant’s counsel further conten
nds that the respondents have not
t
adequately e
explained how the alleged misco
onduct was attributable to him,
,
particularly,
when the departmental wi
itnesses are stated to have
e
acknowledge
ed the deficiencies in the ERP
system and the prevalence of
f
delayed che
que deposits. He maintains t
that the impugned orders are
e
unsustainable
e because the authorities did no
ot address the material grounds
s
raised by the
applicant in his representation, a
appeal and review petition.
7. We ha
ave heard learned counsel for
r the parties and perused the
e
pleadings as
s well as the judgments on wh
hich reliance is placed by the
e
respondents;
counsel.
ANALYSIS
8. Since t
this matter pertains to departmen
ntal proceedings, we deem it apt
t
to observe th
hat it is settled principle of law th
hat in departmental proceedings,
,
the Disciplin
nary Authority is the sole judge
of facts. Once findings of fact,
,
based on app
preciation of evidence are recorde
ed by the Disciplinary Authority
y
and Appellat
te Authority, normally the Court/
/Tribunal may not interfere with
h
those factual
l findings unless it finds that th
he recorded findings were based
d
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 20:
OA No.120/45/2025
either on no
o evidence or that the findings
s were wholly perverse and/or
r
legally unten
nable. The adequacy or inade
equacy of the evidence is not
t
permitted to
be canvassed before the High
Court/Tribunal, since the High
h
Court/Tribun
nal does not sit as an Appella
ate Authority, over the factual
l
findings reco
orded during departmental pro
oceedings, while exercising the
e
power of jud
dicial review. The Tribunal canno
ot, normally speaking, substitute
e
its own conc
clusion, with regard to the guilt o
of the delinquent, for that of the
e
departmental
l authorities.
8.1 In this
s regard, it is profitable to men
ntion that by referring catena of
f
judgments on
n the point of scope of judicial
review by the Courts/Tribunals,
,
the Three Ju
udges Bench of the Hon’ble A
Apex Court in the case of B.C.
Chaturvedi v
v. Union of India [(1995) 6 SC
CC 749 : 1996 SCC (L&S) 80]
held as under
r:
“13. The disciplinary authority is t
Where appeal is presented, the
coextensive power to reapprecia
nature of punishment. In a discipl
proof of legal evidence and findin
not relevant. Adequacy of evid
evidence cannot be permitted to b
court/tribunal. In Union of India
India v. H.C. Goel, (1964) 4 SCR 7
this Court held at SCR p. 728 (AIR
the conclusion, upon considera
reached by the disciplinary aut
suffers from patent error on the
based on no evidence at all, a wr
issued .”
the sole judge of facts.
appellate authority has
ate the evidence or the
linary enquiry, the strict
ngs on that evidence are
dence or reliability of
be canvassed before the
v. H.C. Goel [Union of
718 : AIR 1964 SC 364]
R p. 369, para 20) that if
ation of the evidence
thority, is perverse or
e face of the record or
rit of certiorari could be
(emphasis supplied)
8.2 It eme
erges from the records that the a
applicant was initially appointed
d
as Senior Te
elecom Office Assistant on 01.
.03.1982 and was subsequently
y
appointed as
Junior Accounts Officer on 14.0
06.2010. Upon his absorption in
n
BSNL under
Rule 37A of the CCS (Pension)
) Rules, he continued to serve in
n
the organisat
tion and was eventually promot
ted as Accounts Officer. At the
e
time of his vo
oluntary retirement on 31.01.202
20, he was working as Accounts
s
Officer (Cas
sh) in the office of the Gener
ral Manager Telecom District,
,
Himmatnaga
ar, Gujarat Telecom Circle.
8.3 It is a
also an admitted position that,
after the applicant's voluntary
y
retirement, th
he respondents initiated disciplin
nary proceedings against him by
y
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 21:
OA No.120/45/2025
issuing a cha
arge memorandum dated 05.10.2
2020 under Rules 36 and 61 of
f
the BSNL Co
onduct, Discipline and Appeal R
Rules, 2006, in respect of certain
n
alleged irregu
ularities pertaining to the period
from 01.07.2017 to 31.01.2020.
8.4 In the
present case, undisputedly, the
Presenting Officer by referring
g
and consider
ing the evidence adduced during
g the inquiry categorically stated
d
in his written
n brief that charges levelled agai
inst the applicant “Not Proved”.
.
On receipt o
f the said written brief, the Cha
arged Officer endorsed the same
e
analysis and
averments of the Presenting O
Officer and explained in details
s
about his in
nnocence by submitting his de
efence brief before the Inquiry
y
Authority. H
However, as noted herein abov
ve, the Inquiry Authority, in its
s
Inquiry repo
rt dated 12.05.2022 held that t
the charges levelled against the
e
applicant sta
ands proved. Further, it is n
noticed that before inviting the
e
representatio
on on the said Inquiry report fro
om the Charged Officer i.e. the
e
applicant her
rein, the Disciplinary Authority
y at the time of forwarding the
e
copy of the
e said Inquiry report to the C
CO has recorded its complete
e
agreement w
with the finding of the Inquiry
Authority and called upon the
e
applicant to
submit his representation. Th
his factual matrix has not been
n
refuted by th
e respondent.
In o
other words, the departmenta
al inquiry culminated in the
e
submission o
of the inquiry report dated 12
2.05.2022, wherein the Inquiry
y
Officer held
the charges against the applican
nt as proved, notwithstanding the
e
fact that the P
Presenting Officer, in his brief d
dated 27.01.2022, had concluded
d
that the char
rges were not proved. The inqu
uiry report was furnished to the
e
applicant vi
de memorandum dated 13.06
6.2022, pursuant to which he
e
submitted his
s detailed representation dated 08
8.08.2022.
8.5 Therea
after, the Disciplinary Authority
y, vide order dated 06.02.2023,
,
imposed upo
on the applicant the penalty of 2
25% cut in his monthly pension
n
for a period
of five years. The applicant's ap
ppeal against the said order was
s
rejected by t
the Appellate Authority vide or
rder dated 21.09.2023, followed
d
by rejection
of his review petition by the R
Reviewing Authority vide order
r
dated 07.10.2
2024.
9. Having
g regard to the submissions adva
anced by learned counsel for the
e
applicant tha
at the Inquiry Authority acted
as Prosecutor and beyond the
e
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 22:
OA No.120/45/2025
scope of qua
si-judicial authority, the State W
Witness the Presenting Officer by
y
referring the
e deposition of the state witne
ess and the material on record
d
declared in h
his written brief that the charg
ges are not proved against the
e
applicant an
nd as such, there is no evide
nce against the applicant, the
e
respondent h
have erroneously imposed the pen
nalty upon the applicant and the
e
submission o
of the respondent that the CO wa
as granted opportunity to submit
t
his defence a
and have followed the principle
of natural justice as well as the
e
Disciplinary
Authority by considering the
representation of the applicant
t
passed the im
mpugned order and thus, same
e is just and proper, apart this
s
Tribunal hav
ve also considered , the pleadings
s on record and the principles of
f
law laid dow
wn by the Hon’ble Supreme Cou
urt in B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union
n
of India , (sup
pra), the issues arise for our adju
udication in the instant case:
(i)
Whether the Inquiry Officer
acted beyond his quasi-
judici
ial role and whether the findin
ngs recorded by him are
sustai
inable in law?
(ii)
Whether the findings recorde
ed against the applicant
suffer
r from perversity or are based on
n no evidence?
(iii)
Whether the disciplinary pro
oceedings initiated after
retire
ement are legally sustainable in
n the absence of requisite
statut
tory sanction? and
(iv)
Whether the penalty imposed u
upon the applicant suffers
from
arbitrariness, discrimination or d
dis-proportionality?
10. So far
r as issue No.(i) as noted in p
para 9 above, i.e., whether the
e
Inquiry Offic
cer acted beyond his quasi-judici
ial role and whether the findings
s
recorded by h
him are sustainable in law, is co
oncerned, particularly in view of
f
the fact tha
at the Presenting Officer, afte
er examining the departmental
l
evidence, had
d categorically concluded in his
s written brief dated 27.01.2022
2
that the charg
ges against the applicant were no
ot proved. We may clarify at the
e
outset that th
he conclusion of the Presenting
Officer is not binding upon the
e
Inquiry Offic
cer. The Inquiry Officer is requi
ired to independently assess the
e
evidence add
duced during the inquiry and
arrive at his own conclusions.
.
However, wh
here the Presenting Officer, re
epresenting the department, has
s
himself conc
cluded that the charges are not
t proved, the Inquiry Officer is
s
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 23:
OA No.120/45/2025
expected to u
undertake a particularly careful a
and reasoned examination of the
e
evidence bef
fore recording findings contrar
ry thereto. Such findings must
t
demonstrate,
through an objective assessmen
nt of the material on record, the
e
evidentiary b
basis upon which the charges hav
ve been held proved.
10.1 In the
present case, the applicant has
specifically contended that the
e
Inquiry Offi
icer failed to undertake such
an independent and objective
e
assessment a
and instead substantially reiterat
ted the allegations contained in
n
the charge m
memorandum without adequate
ely analysing the documentary
y
evidence, the
e depositions of the departmen
ntal witnesses and the defence
e
advanced by
the applicant. We find conside
erable substance in the aforesaid
d
contention. A
A perusal of the material referre
ed to by the applicant indicates
s
that the fin
ndings recorded by the Inqui
iry Officer required a proper
r
examination
of the departmental order date
ed 01.05.2015, the allocation of
f
responsibiliti
ies amongst the concerned office
ers, the testimony of SW-1, SW-
-
4 and SW-6
and the manner in which the ER
RP/SAP system was configured
d
and operated
d. These were not peripheral ma
atters but directly concerned the
e
attribution of
f responsibility for the alleged irr
regularities.
10.2 The In
nquiry Officer, while functionin
ng as a quasi-judicial authority,
,
was required
d to maintain impartiality and c
confine himself to an objective
e
evaluation of
f the evidence adduced by the
parties. He could not substitute
e
the absence o
of evidence by conjectures or su
urmises, nor could he construct a
a
theory of mi
isconduct unsupported by the m
material brought on record. The
e
principle enu
unciated by the Hon’ble Suprem
me Court in SBI v. Ajay Kumar
r
Srivastava (s
supra) squarely applies in this r
regard, wherein it has been held
d
that even in
departmental proceedings, a fin
nding of guilt must be founded
d
upon evidenc
ce which would reasonably enab
ble an objective person to arrive
e
at such a con
nclusion.
10.3 We are
e, therefore, of the considered v
view that the mere fact that the
e
Inquiry Offic
cer differed from the conclusion
of the Presenting Officer would
d
not, by itself
f, vitiate the inquiry. However,
where such disagreement is not
t
supported by
y a cogent analysis of the materi
al evidence and the findings are
e
rendered wit
thout adequately addressing the
relevant defence and evidence,
,
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 24:
OA No.120/45/2025
the same w
ould fall within the permissib
ble grounds of judicial review
w
contemplated
d in B.C. Chaturvedi (supra) and
d P. Gunasekaran (supra).
11. Now c
coming to Issue No. (ii), as noted
d in para 10 above, i.e., whether
r
the findings
recorded against the applicant
t suffer from perversity or are
e
based on no
evidence, in our considered op
pinion, the most material issue
e
relates to the
e attribution of responsibility t
to the applicant for the alleged
d
irregularities
concerning the collection, dep
posit and realisation of cheques
s
received from
m franchisees. The applicant's sp
pecific defence is that, pursuant
t
to the depart
tmental order dated 01.05.2015
, the responsibility for physical
l
receipt, custo
ody and deposit of cheques and
d cash collected at the Customer
r
Service Cent
tres had been assigned to the r
respective CSC in-charges. The
e
applicant ha
as further contended that th
the monitoring of franchisee
e
transactions
and credit sales was assigned to
o the Accounts Officer (CMTS)
)
and the con
ncerned marketing authorities u
under the applicable Sales and
d
Distribution P
Policy, 2018.
11.1 The re
espondents, on the other hand, ha
ave contended that the applicant,
,
while functio
oning as Accounts Officer (Cash
h) and Drawing and Disbursing
g
Officer, was
s responsible for overall mo
onitoring of cash and cheque
e
collections, t
their deposit and reconciliation o
of bank transactions, and that he
e
failed to exer
rcise due diligence in the dischar
rge of such responsibilities.
11.2 In this
regard, we find that the question
n of allocation of duties assumes
s
considerable
significance. Where the depart
tmental instructions specifically
y
assign certain
n operational responsibilities to
designated officers, the liability
y
of another of
fficer cannot be inferred merely f
from his designation or from the
e
general natu
ure of his accounting function
ns. His responsibility must be
e
established w
with reference to the duties
actually assigned to him, the
e
evidence dem
monstrating his involvement and
d the specific acts or omissions
s
constituting t
the alleged misconduct.
11.3 The ap
pplicant has placed reliance upo
on the departmental order dated
d
01.05.2015, w
which, according to him, divest
ted the Accounts Officer (Cash)
)
of the respon
nsibility for physical receipt, cu
ustody and banking of cheques
s
collected at
the CSCs and assigned the sa
ame to the respective CSC in-
-
charges. He h
has also relied upon the provisio
ons of the Sales and Distribution
n
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 25:
OA No.120/45/2025
Policy, 2018
8, to contend that monitoring
of credit extended to mobile
e
franchisees w
was assigned to the Accounts Off
fficer (CMTS) and the concerned
d
marketing au
uthorities.
11.4 We fu
rther notice that the applicant h
has relied upon the testimony of
f
SW-1, the
Sub-Divisional Engineer
(Vigilance), who allegedly
y
acknowledge
ed that the delay in depositing
cheques was not attributable to
o
the applican
nt and that delayed presentati
ion of cheques had been an
n
operational p
practice at the CSC level. Similar
rly, the depositions of SW-4 and
d
SW-6 have b
been relied upon to demonstrate
e that the ERP/SAP system was
s
not configure
ed to restrict franchisee credit tra
ansactions within the prescribed
d
bank-guarant
tee limits and that certain ad
djustments were automatically
y
effected throu
ugh the system.
11.5 The ap
pplicant has also asserted that
his office regularly circulated
d
monthly stat
tements indicating outstanding
and uncleared cheque balances
s
under the sig
gnatures of the applicant and th
he superior officer to the higher
r
administrativ
ve authorities, including the IFA
A and GMTD. Such material, if
f
established f
from the inquiry record, wou
uld be relevant to determining
g
whether the
e applicant had discharged t
the accounting and reporting
g
responsibiliti
ies assigned to him and whethe
r the alleged irregularities were
e
attributable to
o any deliberate omission or fail
lure on his part.
11.6 We ha
asten to clarify that this Tribunal
l is not required to undertake an
n
independent
re-appreciation of the testimony
y of SW-1, SW-4 and SW-6 or to
o
substitute its
s own assessment of the depart
tmental evidence. Nevertheless,
,
where materi
ial evidence bearing directly upo
on the attribution of misconduct
t
is allegedly
ignored or not considered, t
the resulting findings may be
e
examined wi
thin the limited parameters of ju
udicial review.
11.7 In the
e instant case, the applicant's
s defence is not confined to
o
challenging
the adequacy of evidence. R
Rather, it raises a fundamental
l
question as t
to whether the alleged miscond
duct was attributable to him in
n
view of the d
departmental allocation of respon
nsibilities, the functioning of the
e
ERP/SAP sy
ystem and the evidence conce
erning the actual handling and
d
deposit of ch
heques at the CSC level.
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 26:
OA No.120/45/2025
11.8 We fin
nd that these aspects were requi
ired to be specifically examined
d
by the Inqui
ry Officer and the Disciplinary
y Authority before arriving at a
a
conclusion th
hat the applicant had failed to
discharge his duties. However,
,
upon perusa
al of the orders passed by th
he Disciplinary, Appellate and
d
Reviewing A
Authorities, we find that such m
material aspects have not been
n
dealt with in
n a meaningful or reasoned ma
anner. The authorities have not
t
adequately e
explained how the alleged delay
y in deposit of cheques or the
e
irregular ext
tension of franchisee credit wa
as attributable to the applicant,
,
notwithstand
ding the departmental instruction
ns and the evidence relied upon
n
by him.
11.9 In this
context, the observations of the
e Hon’ble Supreme Court in SBI
I
v. Ajay Kum
ar Srivastava (supra) assume pa
articular relevance. The Hon’ble
e
Apex Court h
has categorically held that findin
ngs in departmental proceedings
s
cannot be s
sustained merely on conjectur
res or surmises and that the
e
allegations m
must be established by such
evidence as would enable a
a
reasonable pe
erson acting objectively to arrive
e at a finding of misconduct.
11.10 We ar
re, therefore, of the considered
view that the findings recorded
d
against the a
applicant, insofar as they fail t
to establish a reasonable nexus
s
between the
alleged irregularities and the d
duties actually entrusted to him,
,
cannot be su
ustained merely on the basis o
of his designation as Accounts
s
Officer (Cas
sh) or Drawing and Disbursing
g Officer. The material defence
e
raised by hi
im required a specific and obj
jective consideration, which is
s
conspicuousl
ly lacking in the impugned ord
ders. Thus, we find substantial
l
force in the
e submission of the learned
counsel for the applicant that
t
evidence surf
faced during the inquiry does no
ot prove the alleged mis-conduct
t
of the applic
ant and the PO had rightly reco
orded in its written brief that the
e
charges were
e not proved against the applic
cant. At this stage, it is apt to
o
mention that
t inabsence of evidence to su
ustain the charges against the
e
applicant the
e finding record by the Disciplin
nary Authority suffers from the
e
legal infirmit
ties.
12. With r
regard to issue No.(iii) as noted
d in para 10 above, i.e., whether
r
the disciplina
ary proceedings initiated after re
etirement are legally sustainable
e
in the absen
nce of requisite statutory sanct
tion, as the applicant has also
o
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 27:
OA No.120/45/2025
questioned t
the jurisdictional competence
of the respondents to initiate
e
disciplinary
proceedings after his volunta
ary retirement on 31.01.2020,
,
contending t
that the charge memorandum
dated 05.10.2020 was issued
d
without obta
aining the requisite prior sanctio
on of the President under Rule
e
9(2)(b)(i) of t
the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.
12.1 The re
espondents were required to e
stablish the statutory authority
y
under which
disciplinary proceedings affecti
ng the applicant's pension could
d
be instituted
d and continued after his reti
irement. Where the applicable
e
pension rule
es prescribe a mandatory req
quirement of sanction by the
e
competent a
authority for institution of d
departmental proceedings after
r
retirement, co
ompliance with such requiremen
nt is a condition precedent to the
e
valid initiatio
on of proceedings.
12.2 In the
present case, the applicant ha
as specifically pleaded that the
e
charge memo
orandum dated 05.10.2020 was
issued more than eight months
s
after his volu
untary retirement and that no pri
ior sanction of the President was
s
obtained bef
fore initiation of the proceeding
gs. The respondents, therefore,
,
were required
d to demonstrate the existence o
of the requisite statutory sanction
n
or otherwise
establish the legal authority und
der which the proceedings were
e
instituted aga
ainst the applicant after his retire
ement.
12.3 We find
d that the aforesaid objection go
oes to the root of the jurisdiction
n
of the author
rities to initiate disciplinary proc
ceedings affecting the pension of
f
the applican
nt. The question cannot be t
treated as a mere procedural
l
irregularity, p
particularly where the proceedin
ngs culminated in the imposition
n
of a substanti
ial cut in his monthly pension fo
or five years. Accordingly, in the
e
absence of
a demonstrated compliance
with the applicable statutory
y
requirements
s governing post-retirement
disciplinary proceedings, the
e
initiation and
d continuation of the proceedings
s against the applicant cannot be
e
sustained in l
law.
13. With r
regard to issue No. (iv), as noted
d in para 10 above, whether the
e
penalty impo
osed upon the applicant suffers fr
rom arbitrariness, discrimination
n
or disproport
tionality, as the applicant has fu
urther contended that the penalty
y
imposed upo
on him is discriminatory and dis
sproportionate, inasmuch as the
e
CSC in-char
rges, franchisee managers and A
Accounts Officer (CMTS), who
o
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 28:
OA No.120/45/2025
were alleged
dly entrusted with the operationa
al responsibilities relating to the
e
transactions
in question, were visited with
comparatively lesser penalties,
,
whereas the
applicant, who had retired from
m service and had no physical
l
custody of th
he cheques, was subjected to a su
ubstantial reduction in pension.
13.1 We ar
re conscious of the settled pr
rinciple that different penalties
s
imposed up
pon different officials do n
not, by themselves, establish
h
discriminatio
on or entitle an employee to cl
laim parity in punishment. The
e
respective ro
oles, responsibilities, nature o
of misconduct and degree of
f
culpability o
of the officials concerned ar
re relevant considerations for
r
determining
whether the treatment meted ou
ut to an employee is arbitrary or
r
discriminator
ry.
13.2 Howev
ver, where the applicant spe
cifically alleges that officials
s
entrusted wit
th the actual operational respons
sibilities were subjected to lesser
r
penalties, wh
hile a retired employee whose r
role was confined to accounting
g
and reconcili
iation functions was visited with
h a substantially higher penalty,
,
the authoritie
es were required to examine the c
comparative responsibilities and
d
the nature o
f the alleged misconduct befor
re determining the quantum of
f
punishment.
13.3 We fu
urther observe that the proportio
onality of punishment has to be
e
considered i
in the context of the misco
onduct established against the
e
employee. A
As held by the Hon’ble Supre
eme Court in P. Gunasekaran
n
(supra) and
State of Karnataka v. Umesh
h (supra), interference with the
e
quantum of
punishment is permissible wit
thin the limited parameters of
f
judicial revie
ew, particularly where the pen
nalty is disproportionate to the
e
proven misco
onduct.
13.4 In the
present case, having regard to
the deficiencies noticed in the
e
attribution o
f responsibility and the failure
e to meaningfully consider the
e
applicant's d
defence, the penalty imposed u
upon him cannot be sustained
d
independentl
ly of the findings upon which it i
is founded.
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'
: 29:
OA No.120/45/2025
14 . In vie
ew of the foregoing analysi
s and findings, the Original
l
Application i
is allowed in the following terms
s:-
(i) Th
he charge memorandum dated 0
5.10.2020, the Inquiry Officer's
s
rep
port dated 12.05.2022, the Discip
plinary Authority's penalty order
r
dat
ted 06.02.2023, the Appell
ate Authority's order dated
d
21.
.09.2023 and the Reviewing Au
uthority's order dated 07.10.2024
4
are
e hereby quashed and set aside;
(ii) Th
he applicant shall stand exonerate
ed of the charges framed against
t
him
m under the charge memorandum
m dated 05.10.2020;
(iii) Th
he respondents are directed to res
store the applicant's full monthly
y
pen
nsion without the deduction imp
posed pursuant to the impugned
d
pen
nalty order and to refund the am
mount already deducted from his
s
pen
nsion in consequence thereof, w
within a period of two months
s
fro
om the date of receipt of a certifie
ed copy of this order;
(iv) Th
he applicant shall also be enti
itled to consequential benefits
s
ari
sing out of the setting aside
of the impugned penalty, in
n
acc
cordance with the applicable rule
es.
15. There sh
hall be no order as to costs.
16. All pend
ding MAs, if any, shall also stan
d disposed of accordingly.
(Sanjiv Ku
Member
SKV
umar)
r (A)
(Jayesh V. Bhairavia)
Member (J)
SEEMA 2026.11.06
SANTHOSH 15:09:17+05'30'