SMT. L UMA BAI vs A PATTABIRAMAN
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 6 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.T. NARENDRA PRASAD
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 228 OF 2017 (INJ)
BETWEEN:
SMT. L UMA BAI
W/O V.A.LAKSHMIPATHY
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
TH TH
R/AT NO.5/12, 4 E BLOCK, 10 A MAIN
RAJAJINAGAR, BANGALORE-10.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. G BALAKRISHNA SHASTRY (NOC).,ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. A PATTABIRAMAN
SINCE DEAD REPRESENTED BY
RESPONDENT NO.3 AS LR
2. SRI V GOPALA KRISHNAN
S/O SRI VENKATARAMAN
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
R/AT NO.1774, SAMPIGE ROAD
MALLESWARAM, BANGALORE-560 003.
3. SMT. RAJESHWARI
W/O V GOPALA KRISHNAN
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS
R/AT NO.1774, SAMPIGE ROAD
MALLESWARAM, BANGALORE-560 003
…RESPONDENTS
(V/O DATED:31.07.2024 R3 IS TREATED AS LRS
OF DECEASED R1: V/O DATED:24.05.2021
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
NOTICE TO R2 & R3 IS HELD SUFFICIENT)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC.,
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED: 7.1.2017
PASSED IN OS NO.3315/2011 ON THE FILE OF THE XVIII
ADDL. CITY CIVIL JUDGE, BENGALURU, DISMISSING THE SUIT
FOR PERMANENT INJUNCTION.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.T. NARENDRA PRASAD
ORAL JUDGMENT
This Regular First Appeal is filed by the plaintiff
under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for
short, 'CPC'), challenging the judgment and decree dated
07.01.2017 passed by the XVIII Additional City Civil and
Sessions Judge, Bengaluru City (for short, 'Trial Court'), in
O.S.No.3315/2011, whereby the suit filed by the plaintiff
for permanent injunction has been dismissed.
2. For the sake of convenience, the parties are
referred to as per their ranking before the Trial Court.
3.The brief facts of the case are as follows:
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
The land bearing Sy.No.25, measuring 1 acre 20
guntas, situated at Basavanapura Village, K.R. Puram
Hobli, Bengaluru, originally belonged to one Annappa. One
K.M.Rajendran purchased 30 guntas of land from Annappa
under a registered sale deed dated 25.05.1995 and
thereafter formed residential sites in the said land. The
plaintiff purchased the suit schedule property from
K.M.Rajendran under a registered sale deed dated
15.10.2001. It is the case of the plaintiff that, pursuant to
the said sale deed, she was put in possession of the suit
schedule property and has been in peaceful possession
and enjoyment of the same.
4. It is further contended that the defendants, who
are strangers to the suit schedule property and have no
manner of right, title or interest therein, attempted to
interfere with the plaintiff's peaceful possession and
enjoyment of the property. In this regard, the plaintiff
lodged a complaint before the jurisdictional police on
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
20.10.2010. Since no action was taken on the said
complaint and the defendants continued their alleged
interference, the plaintiff instituted the suit on 09.05.2011
seeking the relief of permanent injunction.
5. On service of summons, defendant Nos.1 to 3
entered appearance. Defendant No.1 filed the written
statement denying the plaintiff's right, title and possession
over the suit schedule property. Defendant Nos.2 and 3
did not file their written statements.
6. On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the
Trial Court framed the following issues:
(i) Whether the plaintiff proves that she is
in lawful possession of the suit schedule
property as on the date of the suit?
(ii) Whether the plaintiff further proves
that the defendants are interfering with the use
and enjoyment of the suit schedule property by
the plaintiff?
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
(iii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the
reliefs sought for?
(iv) What order or decree?
7. The parties adduced oral and documentary
evidence in support of their respective contentions. Upon
appreciation of the evidence on record, the Trial Court
answered issue Nos.1 to 3 in the negative and
consequently dismissed the suit by judgment and decree
dated 07.01.2017. Being aggrieved by the same, the
plaintiff has preferred the present appeal.
8. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant/
plaintiff has raised the following contentions:
(i) Firstly, the plaintiff purchased the suit schedule
property under a registered sale deed dated 15.10.2001.
The said sale deed clearly describes the property, its
measurements and boundaries. The defendants have not
specifically disputed the boundaries mentioned therein.
The plaintiff has also produced photographs to establish
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
the existence and identity of the suit schedule property.
During the cross-examination of DW.1, the relevant
documents were confronted to the witness. However,
without properly appreciating the oral and documentary
evidence, the Trial Court has erroneously held that the
plaintiff has failed to establish the identity and existence of
the suit schedule property.
(ii) Secondly, during the pendency of the suit, one
Smt.Nirmala Sripathi instituted O.S.No.26770/2012
against the plaintiff herein. In the said suit, the present
plaintiff filed a counterclaim seeking permanent injunction
in respect of the very same suit schedule property.
Subsequently, the said suit came to be dismissed and the
counterclaim was decreed, granting permanent injunction
in favour of the plaintiff herein. The judgment and decree
passed in O.S.No.26770/2012 have now been produced
before this Court along with an application filed under
Order XLI Rule 27 of CPC.
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
(iii) Thirdly, learned counsel contended that the
plaintiff has also produced additional documents, including
the khata extract and registered sale deeds pertaining to
the neighbouring properties, to establish the identity,
existence and boundaries of the suit schedule property.
These documents have a direct bearing on the controversy
involved in the suit. The Trial Court, without properly
appreciating the evidence available on record, has
dismissed the suit principally on the ground that the
identity of the suit schedule property has not been
established and that proceedings in O.S.No.26770/2012
were pending. Since the subsequent judgment and decree
in the said suit and the other relevant documents are now
available, learned counsel submits that the impugned
judgment and decree are liable to be set aside and the
matter requires reconsideration.
9. Though the respondents have been served with
notice, they have remained unrepresented.
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
10. I have considered the submissions made by
learned counsel appearing for the appellant and perused
the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court, the
evidence available on record and the additional documents
produced along with the application filed under Order XLI
Rule 27 of CPC.
11. The following points arise for consideration in this
appeal:
(i) Whether the additional documents
produced by the appellant/plaintiff are
necessary for effective adjudication of the
controversy involved in the suit?
(ii) Whether the Trial Court was justified in
dismissing the suit on the ground that the
plaintiff failed to establish the identity and
existence of the suit schedule property?
(iii) Whether the impugned judgment and
decree call for interference and whether the
matter requires remand for fresh consideration?
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
12. The specific case of the plaintiff is that she
purchased the suit schedule property from K.M. Rajendran
under a registered sale deed dated 15.10.2001. According
to the plaintiff, the suit schedule property measures 2,400
square feet and is bounded on the east by Site Nos.18A
and 19A, on the west by road, on the north by road and
on the south by road. In support of her claim, the plaintiff
has relied upon the registered sale deed, photographs and
oral evidence.
13. It is not in dispute that the plaintiff has instituted
the suit seeking the relief of permanent injunction. In a
suit of this nature, the plaintiff is required to establish her
lawful possession over the identifiable suit schedule
property as on the date of institution of the suit and the
alleged interference by the defendants. The question of
possession has to be determined on the basis of the
pleadings and the oral and documentary evidence
available on record.
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
14. The Trial Court has dismissed the suit primarily
on the ground that the plaintiff has failed to establish the
identity and existence of the suit schedule property. While
arriving at the said conclusion, the Trial Court has also
taken note of the pendency of O.S.No.26770/2012 and the
injunction proceedings therein.
15. It is relevant to note that, during the pendency of
the present suit, Smt. Nirmala Sripathi instituted
O.S.No.26770/2012 against the plaintiff herein. The
plaintiff herein filed a counterclaim in the said suit seeking
permanent injunction in respect of the property claimed by
her. It is submitted that the said suit has subsequently
been dismissed and the counterclaim has been decreed,
granting permanent injunction in favour of the plaintiff
herein. The judgment and decree passed in the said suit
have now been produced before this Court by filing an
application under Order XLI Rule 27 of CPC.
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
16. Apart from the said judgment and decree, the
plaintiff has also produced the khata extract and
registered sale deeds of the neighbouring property
owners. According to the plaintiff, these documents are
necessary to establish the existence, identity and
boundaries of the suit schedule property.
17. Order XLI Rule 27 of CPC provides for production
of additional evidence before the Appellate Court in
specific circumstances. It is well settled that additional
evidence cannot be permitted merely to fill up lacunae in
the case of a party. However, where the Appellate Court
requires such evidence to enable it to pronounce judgment
or for any other substantial cause, additional evidence
may be permitted, subject to satisfaction of the statutory
requirements.
18. The controversy between the parties
substantially relates to the identification of the suit
schedule property and the plaintiff's alleged possession
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
over the same. The additional documents produced by the
plaintiff, particularly the judgment and decree in
O.S.No.26770/2012 and the registered sale deeds
pertaining to the neighbouring properties, have a material
bearing on the said controversy.
19. The judgment and decree in O.S.No.26770/2012
are subsequent developments which require examination.
The effect of the decree passed on the counterclaim, the
identity of the property involved in the said proceedings
and its relevance to the present suit are matters which
require proper consideration. The said decree cannot, by
itself, be treated as conclusive proof of the plaintiff's
possession against the present defendants without
examining the identity of the properties, the parties to the
proceedings and the legal effect of the decree in
O.S.No.26770/2012.
20. Likewise, the khata extract and the sale deeds of
the neighbouring property owners may assist in
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
determining the location and boundaries of the suit
schedule property. However, their evidentiary value can be
assessed only after affording an opportunity to the
defendants to dispute the documents and adduce rebuttal
evidence, if any.
21. It is also necessary to observe that the mere
production of registered sale deeds of neighbouring
properties does not, by itself, conclusively establish actual
possession of the property. Nevertheless, the description
of the property, its boundaries, the surrounding
circumstances and the other evidence produced by the
parties are relevant factors which require consideration to
determine whether the plaintiff has established her
possession over an identifiable property.
22. The plaintiff has specifically relied upon the
registered sale deed dated 15.10.2021 and the boundaries
mentioned therein. She has also produced photographs
and adduced oral evidence. The defendants have disputed
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
her claim of possession. Therefore, the identity of the
property and the question of lawful possession require
consideration upon a proper appreciation of the entire
evidence.
23. The Trial Court has recorded a finding against the
plaintiff regarding the identity and existence of the suit
schedule property. However, in view of the subsequent
judgment and decree in O.S.No.26770/2012 and the
additional documents now produced, the said finding
requires reconsideration. The documents sought to be
produced are directly relevant to the principal controversy
involved in the suit.
24. Having regard to the nature of the dispute and
the additional documents produced, this Court is satisfied
that the said documents are required for effective
adjudication of the matter. The application filed under
Order XLI Rule 27 of CPC therefore deserves to be
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
allowed, subject to proof, admissibility and relevancy of
the documents before the Trial Court.
25. The next question is whether this Court should
itself appreciate the additional evidence or remit the
matter to the Trial Court for fresh consideration.
26. Since the dispute involves the identification of
the suit schedule property, the boundaries mentioned in
the registered sale deed, the alleged possession of the
plaintiff and the effect of the judgment and decree passed
in O.S.No.26770/2012, the additional documents produced
by the plaintiff require examination and the defendants
must be afforded an opportunity to contest their
admissibility, authenticity and evidentiary value. The
parties may also be required to adduce further evidence
regarding the identity and possession of the property.
27. In these circumstances, this Court is of the
considered opinion that merely receiving the additional
documents and deciding the appeal on the existing record
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
may not be sufficient for complete and effective
adjudication of the controversy. Since the Trial Court has
dismissed the suit on the ground that the identity and
existence of the suit schedule property have not been
established, and as the additional evidence produced
herein has a direct bearing on the said finding, a fresh
consideration of the matter is warranted.
28. Therefore, having regard to the facts and
circumstances of the case, this Court is satisfied that the
judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court require
interference and that the matter deserves to be remitted
to the Trial Court under Order XLI Rule 23-A of CPC for
fresh consideration, after affording reasonable opportunity
to both parties to adduce additional evidence.
29. It is made clear that this Court has not expressed
any opinion on the merits of the respective claims of the
parties or on the ultimate entitlement of the plaintiff to the
relief of permanent injunction. All contentions of the
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
parties are kept open to be considered by the Trial Court
in accordance with law.
Accordingly, the points framed for consideration are
answered in favour of remand, and the following:
ORDER
(i) The appeal is allowed.
(ii) The judgment and decree dated 07.01.2017
passed by the XVIII Additional City Civil and
Sessions Judge, Bengaluru City, in
O.S.No.3315/2011 are hereby set aside.
(iii) The application filed by the appellant/plaintiff
under Order XLI Rule 27 of CPC is allowed.
The additional documents produced along
with the said application shall be transmitted
to the Trial Court for consideration in
accordance with law, subject to their proof,
admissibility and relevancy.
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
(iv) The matter is remitted back to the Trial
Court for fresh consideration and disposal in
accordance with law.
(v) The Trial Court shall afford reasonable
opportunity to both parties to produce
additional documents and adduce further oral
and documentary evidence, if any,
particularly with regard to the identity,
boundaries and possession of the suit
schedule property.
(vi) The Trial Court shall also consider the
judgment and decree passed in
O.S.No.26770/2012, its legal effect and its
relevance to the controversy involved in the
present suit.
(vii) The Trial Court shall reconsider the matter
afresh, on the basis of the entire evidence
available on record, including the additional
evidence, without being influenced by any
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61981
RFA No. 228 of 2017
CNR: KAHC010537192017
observations made by this Court on the
merits of the dispute.
(viii) All contentions of the parties on merits are
kept open.
(ix) In view of the disposal of the appeal, all
other pending applications, if any, stand
disposed of.
(x) Registry is directed to transmit the Trial
Court records along with the additional
documents to the concerned Trial Court,
forthwith.
Digitally Signed by NARENDRA PRASAD
HAREKOPPA THIMMANNA GOWDA
(H.T. NARENDRA PRASAD)
JUDGE
CM
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 57