Lachhmi Devi & Ors. vs Municipal Council & Ors.
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
and COCP Nos. 2147-2012
and 1037-2022 (O&M) 1 of 12
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
201 (3 cases)
Date of Decision: 12.11.2026
1. CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
Lachhmi Devi widow of Ram Bhaj and others ...Petitioner(s)
Vs.
Municipal Council Kharar and others ...Respondent(s)
2. COCP-2147-2012 (O&M)
Karam Singh and others ...Petitioner(s)
Vs.
Sarabjit Singh, Executive Officer and another ...Respondent(s)
AND
3. COCP-1037-2022 (O&M)
Karam Singh and others ...Petitioner(s)
Vs.
Jaspreet Singh Longia, Municipal Council Chief
and others ...Respondent(s)
CORAM: HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE NIDHI GUPTA
Present:- Mr. Gopal Sharma, Ms. Palak Jain, and
Mr. Amit Kumar, Advocates for the petitioners
in CWP-12205-2004.
Mr. J.S.Toor, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Adhiraj Toor, Mr. B.R.Rana and
Mr. Jasbir Singh, Advocates for respondent No.1.
Mr. D.K.Singal and Mr. Manav Sengal, Advocates
for the respondent in COCP-1037-2022
Mr. Manmeet Singh Teji, A.A.G., Punjab.
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.16 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
and COCP Nos. 2147-2012
and 1037-2022 (O&M) 2 of 12
NIDHI GUPTA, J.
CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
Present Civil Writ Petition under Articles 226/227 of the
Constitution of India has been filed by the petitioners for the issuance of a
writ in the nature of certiorari quashing order of ejectment of the
petitioners from the land measuring 38 Kanals 14 Marlas detailed in the
impugned orders dated 10.05.2002 (Annexure P-3) passed by the Sub
Divisional Magistrate exercising power of Collector under the Punjab
Public Premises Act; and order dated 21.01.2004 (Annexure P-4) passed
by the Deputy Commissioner as Commissioner dismissing appeal of
petitioners.
COCP-2147-2012
Present Contempt Petition under Section 12 of the Contempt
of Courts Act, 1971 has been filed by the petitioners for punishing the
respondents for committing civil contempt of the order of this Court dated
29.01.2007 in CWP No.12205 of 2004 by the respondents.
COCP-1037-2022
Present Contempt Petition under Sections 10 and 12 of the
Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 has been filed by the petitioners against the
respondents for willful disobedience of the orders dated 29.01.2007
(Annexure P-1) and 24.05.2007 (Annexure P-2) passed by this Court in Civil
Writ Petition No. 12205 of 2004.
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.16 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
and COCP Nos. 2147-2012
and 1037-2022 (O&M) 3 of 12
2. With the consent of learned counsel for both the parties, all
the aforesaid 3 proceedings are being decided by this common order as all
these 3 proceedings are interconnected/interrelated and have a bearing on
each other. For the sake of facility, facts are being drawn from CWP-12205-
2004 titled as Lachhmi Devi widow of Ram Bhaj and others vs. Municipal
Council Kharar and others.
3. It is inter alia submitted by ld. Counsel for the petitioners that
the present subject land measuring 38 kanals 14 marlas bearing Khewat
/Khatauni Nos. 921/1007 Khasra No. 28/2, 3 and 26/2, Kittas 3 as per
Jamabandi 1994-95 situated in Village Mundi Kharar, Tehsil Kharar, District
Ropar and owned by the Municipal Council, Kharar (Respondent No.1) was
taken on rent in the year 1975 by Ram Bhaj husband of the petitioner No.1
and father of the petitioners No.2 to 4; and after his death, petitioners are
continuing in joint cultivating possession thereof and duly paying the rent.
4. It is submitted that thereafter, the respondent No.1/Municipal
Council, Kharar sought eviction of the petitioners from the subject land by
filing application before the Collector-cum-Regional Deputy Director, Local
Government, Ludhiana. Accordingly, a notice dated 06.11.1998 (Annexure
P-1) was issued to the petitioners under Section 4 of the Punjab Public
Premises and Land (Eviction and Rent Recovery) Act, 1973 (hereinafter ‘Act,
1973’) to show cause as to why they should not be evicted from the subject
land.
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.16 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
and COCP Nos. 2147-2012
and 1037-2022 (O&M) 4 of 12
5. It is submitted that during the pendency of the said
proceedings, Sh. Harjit Singh, Clerk of respondent No.1 appeared before the
Collector and made a statement that the petitioners were tenants on the
subject land and were not unauthorized persons and sought to withdraw
the proceedings. On the said statement made by Sh. Harjit Singh, Clerk, ld.
Collector passed order dated 08.02.1999. A copy of the said order dated
08.02.1999 has not been appended with the Writ Petition however, it has
been reproduced in para 4 of the present Writ Petition, which reads as
under: -
"8.2.99 - The file was produced. The parties were called
Shri Rajinder Singh, Advocate and Shri Harjit Singh gave in
writing on behalf the Nagar Council that as per their record the
suit land had been given on Rent. Therefore, he prayed to
withdraw the case. Keeping in view the prayer of the
petitioner, there is no need to proceed with the matter, so, the
case is dismissed".
6. Ld. Counsel submits that thereafter, the Municipal Council
Kharar/respondent No.1 filed another application dated 07.05.2001
(Annexure P-2) seeking ejectment of the petitioners from the subject land
under Sections 5 and 7 of the Act, 1973 and recovery of rent for
unauthorized possession. It is contended that without going into the merits
of the matter, the said application was allowed by the Collector/respondent
No.2 vide impugned order dated 10.05.2002 (Annexure P-3).
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.16 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
and COCP Nos. 2147-2012
and 1037-2022 (O&M) 5 of 12
7. Ld. Counsel submits that an Appeal was filed by the petitioners
against the above said order dated 10.05.2002 (Annexure P-3); which is also
dismissed by Deputy Commissioner exercising powers of the Commissioner
under the Act, vide non-speaking order dated 21.01.2004 (Annexure P-4).
8. It is further argued by ld. Counsel for the petitioners that both
the impugned orders dated 10.05.2002 (Annexure P-3) and 21.01.2004
(Annexure P-4) are illegal and deserve to be quashed. Although, the
Municipal Council had withdrawn the earlier petition on 8.2.1999 admitting
the petitioners to be tenants on the suit land under them neither the
Collector nor the learned Commissioner in their impugned orders have
given any finding as to when the tenancy was terminated and the
petitioners became unauthorised occupants thereof. So, much so even the
ejectment petition filed by the Municipal Council is silent on this point.
Therefore, the impugned orders are beyond the pleadings and bad in law
being non-speaking on the most crucial issue involved in the matter and are
illegal being without jurisdiction.
9. Ld. Counsel for the petitioner further submits that the learned
Collector based his order mainly on the fact that the petitioners had lost
their suit for permanent injunction in the civil court which was based on the
fact that since the petitioners had not proved payment of rent by them
beyond 1992 they were treated to be in unauthorised possession of the
premises and were not entitled to the relief of permanent injunction which
was a discretionary remedy. However, the fact remains that the impugned
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.16 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
and COCP Nos. 2147-2012
and 1037-2022 (O&M) 6 of 12
order passed by respondent No.2 (Annexure P-3) is a non-speaking order on
the most crucial and core issue of the matter.
10. It is accordingly prayed that the present Writ Petition be
allowed; and following prayer be accepted: -
“(ii) issue a writ in the nature of certiorari quashing the
impugned orders dated 10.5.2002 (Annexure P-3) and order
dated 21.01.2004 (Annexure P-4), passed by the Collector and
Commissioner respectively.”
11. Per contra, ld. Senior Counsel appearing for respondent No.1
has strongly controverted submissions of the petitioner and has submitted
that petitioners are in illegal occupation of the subject land. Petitioners
were requested several times to handover the public premises to the
respondent No.1 but to no effect. Petitioners have even failed to pay
chakota money to the respondent No.1 since 1991-1992 i.e. for the last
more than 36 years. As such, present Writ Petition deserves to be outrightly
dismissed.
12. No other argument is raised on behalf of the ld. Counsel for
the parties. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
case file in great detail. I find no merit in the submissions of the petitioners.
13. In the present Writ Petition, petitioners have pleaded in para 2
thereof that subject land was taken on rent by Ram Bhaj husband of
petitioner No.1 and father of petitioners No. 2 to 4 in 1975. However, in the
replication dated 25.09.2006 filed by the petitioners, it has been pleaded
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.16 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
and COCP Nos. 2147-2012
and 1037-2022 (O&M) 7 of 12
that subject land was allotted to Ram Bhaj in lieu of his land holding in
village Rurkee, which was acquired for the Capital Project of Chandigarh; in
respect of which present subject land in dispute was allotted to the
grandfather of the petitioners No.2 to 4 on which he constructed a house
and took electricity connection in the year 1990. It has further been
pleaded that municipal limits were extended in the year 1975; whereafter
subject land came within the Municipal Council/respondent No.1. It has
also been contended that petitioners have been regularly paying chakota @
Rs.550 per annum to the respondent No.1; and that “ earlier petition for
eviction was dismissed as withdrawn on 8.2.99 admitting the petitioners as
tenants.” In this regard, petitioners had sought to rely upon the Receipts
(Annexures P-5 and P-6) dated 26.08.2003.
14. Notwithstanding the aforesaid contradictory case set up by the
petitioners, the conscience of this Court is shocked to see the extent to
which the petitioners have sought to misuse due process of law and mislead
the Court. The entire issue is clarified from the judgment dated 17.09.1997
(Annexure P-8) rendered by the ld. Additional District Judge, Rupnagar;
whereby Civil Appeal dated 02.03.1994 filed by the petitioners against the
judgment and decree dated 01.02.1994 passed by the ld. Trial Court
whereby the Civil Suit filed by the petitioners/plaintiffs for permanent
injunction, was dismissed. The relevant findings of the ld. First Appellate
Court in judgment dated 17.09.1997 (Annexure P-8) read as follows: -
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.16 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
and COCP Nos. 2147-2012
and 1037-2022 (O&M) 8 of 12
“12. The plaintiff was given the suit land for the year 1991-92
by way of open auction. He paid an amount of Rs.3,600/- for
the year 1991-92 vide receipt Ex.P7 by way of balance amount
of Theka. The total amount of lease money for the year 1991-
92 was Rs.4,800/-. In order to forestall the auction of land the
plaintiff filed the present suit on 17.3.1992. In the plaint, he did
not make even an oblique mention regarding the land having
been given to him in open auction on year to year basis. It was
only in the written statement that the status of the plaintiff qua
the suit land came to surface. Thus, he is guilty of suppression
of material facts and had not come to the Court with clean
hands: a sine qua non requirement for seeking the
discretionary relief of injunction. He filed the suit a few days
before the expiry of the period of lease and successfully abused
the process of the Courts for continuing in illegal possession till
his death perpetuated by illegal cultivating possession of his
legal representatives without paying a single penny to the
Local Body. The respondent Municipal Committee has not
disturbed their possession due to the pendency of the appeal.
The plaintiff Ram Bhaj succeeded by his legal representatives
have become emboldened to continue in illegal possession of
the land in suit. They have not paid any Chakota to the
Municipal Committee, Kharar beyond the year 1991-92 and are
enjoying the fruits of the land which measures almost five
acres of land without paying anything to the Municipal
Committee. In this situation, the plaintiff cannot be heard to
say that they are entitled to the discretionary relief of
perpetual injunction against their dispossession from the suit
land. It is not possible for the Local Bodies to function for the
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.16 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
and COCP Nos. 2147-2012
and 1037-2022 (O&M) 9 of 12
welfare of the residents if illegal possession is interminately
prolonged with impunity.
13. In order to evolve the possibility of an amicable
settlement of the matter between the parties by payment of
arrears of rent to the Municipal Committee, I called the
Executive Officer, Municipal Committee, Kharar, who appeared
in the court twice. He gracefully agreed to the payment only an
amount of Rs.50,000/- in lump sum by the respondent to
regularize their possession upto 1997-98 whereafter they
would be at liberty to avail themselves of an opportunity to
make a bid in the open auction if they so advised. But they
declined this offer of the Executive Officer. All this shows that
the plaintiff succeeded by his legal representatives are
obsessed by their greed to continue in illegal possession of the
suit land without making any payment to the Municipal
Committee. The land in suit measures about five acres and
going by the present standards the land in suit would not fetch
less than Rs.15,000/- per annum as the bid had escalated to
Rs.9,000/- in the year 1993. There has been a remarkable rise
in lease money in these five years. Unfortunately, the legal
representatives of Ram Bhaj declined this generous offer made
by the Executive Officer, Municipal Committee, Kharar to
liquidate the arrears of five years with an amount of
Rs.50,000/- only. Shri Harbant Singh, the learned counsel for
the appellants also made sincere efforts to prevail upon them
to accept this offer but without any fruitful results. In this
situation, the subsequent events also speak volumes against
the dubious conduct of the appellants which goes a long way in
disentitling them to the benefit of discretionary relief of
injunction against their possession. It appears that the
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.16 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
and COCP Nos. 2147-2012
and 1037-2022 (O&M) 10 of 12
appellants are determined to take the respondent Municipal
Committee for a ride and without any qualms of conscience
they are tenaciously clinging to the suit land without paying a
single rupee to the respondent Municipal Committee for their
illegal possession. In this situation, I am unable to find any fault
with the findings of the learned trial Court on issue No.1 and
the same are affirmed. By same reasoning the findings of the
learned trial Court on issue No.3 do not call for any
interference.”
15. The aforesaid findings are self-speaking and explain the entire
position. It is relevant to note that the aforesaid facts do not find mention in
the present writ petition.
16. Even in respect of the order dated 08.02.1999, petitioners have
not stated the correct facts. A perusal of order dated 10.05.2002 (Annexure
P-3) whereby application filed by respondent No.1 under sections 5 and 7 of
the Act, 1973 was allowed by the Collector, Kharar, shows that it has been
recorded as under: -
“.....The earlier petition in the court of Deputy Director,
Local Bodies, Ludhiana, which was dismissed was not
withdrawn by the Council, but was consigned on the basis of
statement of the clerk regarding the rent only. The case was
not decided on merits. Shri Harjit Singh has got recorded his
statement to the effect that the suit land was owned by the
Nagar Council, and respondents are in illegal possession
thereof.
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.16 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
and COCP Nos. 2147-2012
and 1037-2022 (O&M) 11 of 12
The whole of the record was perused and the counsel
were heard. After considering the record, I have reached the
conclusion that the respondents are in illegal possession of the
land in dispute. The respondents being illegal possession of the
land are ordered to be evicted therefrom immediately.”
17. Appeal against the aforesaid order dated 10.05.2002 was
dismissed by the ld. Deputy Commissioner vide order dated 21.01.2004
(Annexure P-4) holding that petitioners “ are in illegal possession of the land
in question as they have miserably failed to produce any documents in
token of having deposited the CHAKOTA money. There is no ground to
interfere in the learned Court order since it has been passed as per
provisions of the Act. In view of this appeal of the appellants is dismissed
and the order the lower court Lower dated 10.5.2002 is upheld .” On a Court
query, learned counsel for the petitioners has admitted that no payment
has been made by the petitioners to the respondent-Municipal Council
since 2003.
18. Keeping in view the aforesaid position, there is no merit to the
present Writ Petition and the same stands dismissed .
19. By way of the abovesaid Contempt Petitions, petitioners have
alleged violation of the order dated 29.1.2007 and 24.05.2007; whereby
stay against dispossession was granted to the petitioners. It has been
contended that despite the stay granted vide the orders dated 29.1.2007
and 24.5.2007, the respondents have constructed upon the subject land.
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.16 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-12205-2004 (O&M)
and COCP Nos. 2147-2012
and 1037-2022 (O&M) 12 of 12
However, perusal of the reply dated 07.02.2013 filed by way of Affidavit of
Sarabjeet Singh, Executive Officer, Municipal Council, Kharar dated
07.02.2013 shows that there is no violation of the stay orders as it has been
categorically stated therein that “ the Respondents constructed the road
16.5 feet wide as per the revenue record and no land has been taken of the
petitioner for the construction of road and the petitioner has wrongly
alleged that the order has been violated.” No material has been brought on
record by the petitioners controverting the aforesaid factual assertion of
the respondents.
20. Consequentially, both the Contempt Petitions also stand
dismissed .
21. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
12.11.2026 (NIDHI GUPTA)
Divyanshi JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.16 17:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document