RASLIN vs KURUDANKANDI SHAMEER
- Court
- Kerala High Court
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
1
2026:KER:73656
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. KRISHNA KUMAR
TH
SATURDAY, THE 26 DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026 / 4TH ASWINA, 1948
MAT.APPEAL NO. 581 OF 2022
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 07.05.2021 IN OP NO.807 OF 2017 OF
FAMILY COURT, MALAPPURAM
APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
RASLIN
AGED 30 YEARS
D/O. MUHAMMED SHEREEF, PALLIPPARAMBAN HOUSE, EAST
CHATHALLUR, CHATHALLUR POST, EDAVANNA AMSOM, CHATHALLUR
DESOM, ERNAD TALUK, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN-676541.
BY ADVS.
SRI.P.SAMSUDIN
SMT.MILAN RACHEL MATHEW
SMT.LIRA A.B.
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT:
KURUDANKANDI SHAMEER
AGED 35 YEARS, S/O. RAHEEM, SAMEEGAR HOUSE, ANIYARAM
AMSOM DESOM, CHOKLI, ANIYARAM P.O., THALASSERI TALUK,
KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN-670672.
BY ADV SRI.R.RAJESH KORMATH
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
16.09.2026, ALONG WITH MAT.APPEAL.84/2022, THE COURT ON 26.09.2026
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
2
2026:KER:73656
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. KRISHNA KUMAR
TH
SATURDAY, THE 26 DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026 / 4TH ASWINA, 1948
MAT.APPEAL NO. 84 OF 2022
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 7.5.2021 IN OP NO.807 OF 2017 AND
COUNTERCLAIM IN O.P.NO.807 OF 2017 OF FAMILY COURT, MALAPPURAM
APPELLANT/RESPONDENT:
KURUDANKANDI SHAMSEER
AGED 34 YEARS
(CORRECT NAME SHAMSHEER KURUDAN CANDY), SON OF RAHEEM
KURUDAN CANDY, AGED 34 YEARS,PERMANENT RESIDENT AT
"SAMEEGHAR", ANIYARAM (PO), CHOKLI VIA., THALASSERY
TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT, PRESENTED EMPLOYED AT QATAR,
REPRESENTED BY POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER ZAITHOON BEEGAM
V.K., AGED 57 YEARS, DAUGHTER OF V.K.K.ALI, RESIDENT AT
"SAMEEGHAR", ANIYARAM (PO), CHOKLI VIA., THALASSERY
TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN - 670 672.
BY ADV SRI.R.RAJESH KORMATH
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
RASLIN
AGED 29 YEARS
DAUGHTER OF MUHAMMED SHEREEF, PALLIPARAMBAN HOUSE, EAST
CHATHALLUR, CHATHALLUR (PO), EDAVANNA AMSOM, CHATHALLUR
DESOM, ERNAD TALUK, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN - 676 541.
BY ADVS.
SRI.M.ANUROOP
SRI.P.SAMSUDIN
SHRI.SHYAM NAIR
SMT.LIRA A.B.
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
16.09.2026, ALONG WITH MAT.APPEAL.581/2022, THE COURT ON
26.09.2026 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
3
2026:KER:73656
CR
SATHISH NINAN & P. KRISHNA KUMAR, JJ.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Mat.Appeal Nos.84 & 581 of 2022
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
th
Dated this the 26 day of September, 2026
JUDGMENT
P.Krishna Kumar, J.
The petition for return of gold ornaments and money, and
for maintenance, filed by the wife against the husband, was decreed
in part by the Family Court. Both sides are in appeal, against the
respective parts of the decree to the extent it is adverse to them.
2. The parties will hereinafter be referred to as they were
arrayed in the petition. The respondent married the petitioner on
15.09.2012 in accordance with Mohammadan law. According to the
petitioner, when she was taken to the residence of the respondent
after the marriage, she was in possession of 85 sovereigns of gold
ornaments. However, before she went abroad along with the
respondent, he obtained 80 sovereigns of her gold ornaments for the
purpose of keeping them safely in a locker. The respondent obtained
Rs.5,50,000/- from the father of the petitioner, allegedly for
renovating his house. While they were living abroad, the father of
the petitioner deposited 5,000 Saudi Riyals (around Rs.85,000/-) in
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
4
2026:KER:73656
the bank account of the respondent for his needs. Owing to the ill-
treatment meted out to her by the respondent, their marital
relationship fell apart and that, ultimately, following a
mediation, the respondent deposited Rs.3,00,000/- in her father's
bank account.
3. The petitioner further states that, on 09.11.2015, her
father provided funds and purchased a residential property having
an extent of 7 cents in Manjeri Municipality for the petitioner, in
the names of the petitioner and the respondent by availing a loan
from the Nilambur Co-operative Urban Bank, Edavanna Branch.
4. The petitioner claimed recovery of 80 sovereigns of gold
ornaments or their market value, together with Rs.3,35,000/-, being
the amount allegedly given by her father. She also claimed
Rs.15,00,000/-, being the value of the half share of the respondent
in the immovable property, the other half being already registered
in her name. Alleging that the respondent had failed to maintain
her for the preceding 13 months, she further claimed past
maintenance for the said period at the rate of Rs.15,000/- per
month.
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
5
2026:KER:73656
5. The respondent refuted the above allegations and contended
that the petitioner herself had been keeping all her gold
ornaments. According to him, at the request of the petitioner, he
deposited Rs.2,00,000/- on 12.02.2017 and Rs.1,00,000/- on
02.07.2017 in the account of her father, who was then in dire
financial straits. Accordingly, the respondent filed a counterclaim
for recovery of the said amount from the petitioner. The respondent
further contended that he purchased the residential plot in
question near his mother's house by utilising his own funds, since
the petitioner was reluctant to reside in the respondent's family
house. He further contended that the property was purchased in
their joint names in the best interests of the family. Contending
that the petitioner had been residing separately from him without
any reasonable or justifiable cause, the respondent disputed his
liability to pay maintenance.
6. During the trial, the Family Court jointly tried two other
petitions, one filed by the wife seeking divorce and the other
filed by the husband seeking restitution of conjugal rights, along
with the above petition, and disposed of all three petitions by a
common order. The present appeals are confined to O.P.No.807/2017,
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
6
2026:KER:73656
wherein the petitioner claimed return of gold ornaments and money
and maintenance.
7. Upon appreciation of the evidence, the trial court
concluded that the petitioner had failed to establish her claims in
respect of the gold ornaments, money and maintenance. The court
also dismissed the counterclaim filed by the respondent. However,
the court held that, since it was proved that the property had been
purchased exclusively with the money raised by the father of the
petitioner, the petitioner was entitled to recover Rs.15,00,000/-
from the respondent.
8. We have heard Sri. Rajesh R. Kormath, the learned counsel
appearing for the respondent, and Sri. P. Samsudin, the learned
counsel appearing for the petitioner.
9. The following points arise for consideration:
1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to recover 80
sovereigns of gold ornaments from the respondent?
2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to recover
Rs.3,35,000/- from the respondent?
3. Whether the respondent is entitled to recover
Rs.3,00,000/- from the petitioner?
4. Whether the petitioner is entitled to past maintenance
for a period of 13 months?
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
7
2026:KER:73656
5. Whether the property in question was purchased by
utilising the money given by the father of the
petitioner?
6. If so, what relief is the petitioner entitled to?
10. To prove the claims made by her, the petitioner examined
herself as PW1. PW2 and PW3, the Secretaries of the respective
Mahal Committees, and PW4, her father. According to the petitioner,
she had adorned 85 sovereigns of gold ornaments at the time of her
marriage. In support of this contention, she produced Ext.A2 series
issued by Malabar Gold Jewellery, Nilambur. She also produced
Ext.A8 series marriage photographs. Though the genuineness of
Ext.A2 series documents was challenged by the learned counsel
appearing for the respondent on the ground that they are only
‘quotations’ and not bills, we do not propose to delve deeper into
that aspect, having regard to the view we propose to take on the
matter.
11. The petitioner claims that, just before she went abroad
along with the respondent, she entrusted 80 sovereigns of gold
ornaments to him for keeping them in a locker. According to her,
the gold ornaments were entrusted on 20.04.2015 and thereafter she
went abroad on 23.04.2015. During cross-examination, she was
confronted with Ext.B3 photograph, and she conceded that the
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
8
2026:KER:73656
photograph was taken on the occasion of the marriage of the
respondent's brother. It was further brought out in cross-
examination that the marriage of the respondent's brother was held
two days before she went abroad. It could be seen from the
photograph that she was wearing only one chain at that time. Though
it is stated in the petition that they went abroad on 23.04.2015,
during cross-examination she stated that they had gone abroad on
21.04.2015. She further admitted that, until 20.04.2015, all her
gold ornaments were in her possession. If that be so, it is
difficult to accept that she would not have worn any ornaments
other than the one short chain seen in Ext.B3 photograph, in such a
function. Significantly, she also stated in cross-examination that,
immediately after the said marriage function, they went to her own
family house and that both of them went abroad from there. The
relevant part of her statement reads thus:
“
2015 April 21- ന് ഭർത്താവുമൊ ത്ത് ഞാൻ വിദേശത്തു പോ യി 18/4/2015-ന് ഭർത്താവ്
വന്നു. എന്ന് പറഞ്ഞാൽ തീയതി ഓർമ്മയില്ല പോ കുന്നതിന് ഏതാനും ദിവസങ്ങൾക്കു മുൻപ്
വന്നു അനുജന്റെ വിവാഹം കഴിഞ്ഞ് 2 ദിവസം കഴിഞ്ഞ് ഞങ്ങൾ വിദേശത്ത് പോ യി.
അനുജന്റെ കല്യാണം കഴിഞ്ഞ് പിറ്റേ ദിവസം രാത്രി ഞങ്ങൾ എന്റെ വീട്ടിൽ വന്ന് അവിടെ
നിന്നും കരിപ്പൂർ വഴി ഞങ്ങൾ വിദേശത്ത് പോ യി. എന്നെ കാണിച്ചത് ഭർത്താവിന്റെ
അനുജന്റെ കല്യാണ ദിവസം എടുത്ത ഫോ ട്ടോയാണ് എന്നെ കാണിച്ചത് (marked as Ext.
B3) അതിൽ നീല ചുരിദാർ ധരിച്ച് നിൽക്കുന്നത് ഞാനാണ്. കൂടെ ഉള്ളത് അനുജന്റെ
ഭാര്യയാണ്. ഞാൻ ഫോ ട്ടോ മൊ ബൈ ൽ ഫോ ണിൽ എടുത്തില്ല. Ext. B3 ഫോ ട്ടോയിൽ
ഞാൻ ഒരു മാല ധരിച്ചിട്ടുണ്ട്. ഞാൻ വിദേശത്ത് പോ യ സമയം ഒരു വള കാണാനില്ല എന്ന്
ഞാൻ ഭർത്താവിന്റെ ഉമ്മയെ വിളിച്ചു. പറഞ്ഞിരുന്നു എന്ന് പറഞ്ഞാൽ ശരിയല്ല 2015 April
മാസം 20-ാം തീയതി വരെ എന്റെ ആഭരണങ്ങൾ എന്റെ സുരക്ഷിതമായ സൂക്ഷത്തിലും
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
9
2026:KER:73656
”
കൈവശത്തിലും ആണ് എന്ന് ഹർജിയിലും അഫിഡവിറ്റിലും പറഞ്ഞു.
12. The only evidence adduced to prove the entrustment of
the gold ornaments with the respondent is the oral testimony of the
petitioner. That evidence stands stoutly controverted by the
testimony of RW1, the respondent. When the petitioner admits that
she had worn only one chain at the marriage function of her
husband's brother, despite claiming that all her gold ornaments
were then in her possession, and when she further admits that she
went abroad along with her husband from her parental home, we do
not find her claim that she had entrusted her gold ornaments to the
respondent, to be a probable version. The trial court, having had
the advantage of observing the demeanour of the witnesses, found
her claim improbable for the various reasons set out in the
judgment. We fully concur with the view taken by the trial court.
We therefore conclude that the petitioner is not entitled to
recover any gold ornaments from the respondent.
13. Though the petitioner contended that her father had given
Rs.5,50,000/- to the respondent, we do not find any reliable
material in support of the said claim. Apart from the oral evidence
of PW1 and PW4, there is nothing on record to substantiate the
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
10
2026:KER:73656
allegation. If PW4 had given such a substantial amount to the
respondent, he ought to have been in a position to produce some
material to show that he had sufficient funds to raise such an
amount at the relevant point of time. In respect of this claim
also, the trial court did not find the oral testimony of PW1 and
PW4 to be reliable. No material has been placed before us to
warrant a contrary finding. We therefore conclude that the
petitioner is not entitled to recover the said amount from the
respondent.
14. The counterclaim set up by the respondent, contending that
he had deposited Rs.3,00,000/- in the account of the father of the
petitioner, is also not sustainable. The respondent has not proved
that the said amount was paid on behalf of the petitioner. In the
absence of any evidence substantiating such a case, the respondent
cannot be permitted to recover from the petitioner any amount
allegedly paid by him to her father. It is also significant that
the father of the petitioner is not a party to the proceedings.
15. As regards the claim for past maintenance made by the
petitioner, the respondent contended that she had been earning a
monthly income of Rs.50,000/-. The trial court rejected the claim
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
11
2026:KER:73656
for past maintenance, observing that the petitioner had admitted
during cross-examination that she used to stay abroad for most of
the time and that, despite admitting that her bank account would
disclose her income, she had not produced the bank passbook for the
perusal of the court. The petitioner has not placed any material
before us to substantiate or justify her claim for past
maintenance. We therefore find no reason to interfere with the
finding of the trial court in that regard. Accordingly, the decree
on that aspect is also upheld.
16. We now come to the question relating to the property
purchased in the joint names of the petitioner and the respondent.
The petitioner contended that, on 09.11.2015, her father raised
funds and purchased 2.8 Ares (7 cents) of land, together with the
building standing thereon for her, for a consideration of
Rs.30,00,000/-. According to the petitioner, though the entire sale
consideration was provided by her father, the property was
purchased in the joint names of the petitioner and the respondent
in the best interests of their marital relationship. PW4, the
father of the petitioner, deposed that he raised the funds by
availing a loan from the Nilambur Co-operative Urban Bank, Edavanna
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
12
2026:KER:73656
Branch. Ext.A3 statement of account issued by the Nilambur Co-
operative Urban Bank in the name of PW4 on 12.12.2017 shows that,
on 09.11.2015, i.e., the date on which the sale deed was executed,
an amount of Rs.25,00,000/- was debited from his account. Ext.A3
further shows that, on 02.11.2015, an amount of Rs.25,00,000/- had
been credited to his account, seemingly as a loan.
17. Though the respondent stoutly contended that the property
was purchased by him by utilising his own funds, no evidence has
been brought before the court to show the source from which he
raised the amount paid towards the sale consideration. During
cross-examination, he was confronted with that aspect. He then
admitted that the amount had not been withdrawn from any bank
account, but had been given to him by his brother-in-law, who was
working abroad along with him. The relevant part of his statement
is as follows:
“
ഇത് വാങ്ങാനുള്ള പണം ഞാൻ ബാങ്ക് accountൽ നിന്ന് എടുത്തതല്ല. എന്റെ പണം
എന്റെ അളിയന്റെ അടുത്ത് ഉണ്ടായിരുന്നു. അളിയൻ തന്നതാണ്. ഞാൻ
അളിയനുമൊ ത്ത് സൗദിയിൽ ഒരുമിച്ച് ജോ ലി ചെയ്തിരുന്നു. ആ സമയം എന്റെ പണം
കൈകാര്യം ചെയ്തിരുന്നത് അളിയനാണ്. ഭാര്യയ്ക്ക് പണമയച്ചു കൊ ടുത്തത്
അളിയനല്ല. അളിയന്റെ അടുത്ത് എന്റെ കാശുണ്ടായിരുന്നു എന്നാണ് പറഞ്ഞത്.
എന്റെ പണം അളിയന്റെ അടുത്ത് ഇരുന്നത് വാങ്ങി ഞാൻ പണം കൊ ടുത്തുവെന്ന്
”
ഞാൻ പത്രികയിൽ പറഞ്ഞില്ല.
First of all, the respondent did not examine the said person to
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
13
2026:KER:73656
prove the source of the funds. He also failed to produce any
documents to show how the money was brought to India for purchasing
the property. If he had paid the consideration or any part of it,
definitely, he would have had some material to prove the same,
especially since he was abroad at that time. Thus, he failed to
prove the payment of any such amounts.
18. Significantly, the respondent admitted during cross-
examination that the original title deed of the property is in the
possession of the petitioner. He also conceded that it was the
petitioner who obtained the sale deed from the Sub-Registry. In
view of the above discussion, the petitioner’s claim regarding the
purchase of property for her with the funds provided by her father,
but in the joint names in the best interests of the family, stands
proved.
19. Nevertheless, Sri. Rajesh R. Kormath, the learned counsel
appearing for the respondent, strenuously contended that the claim
made by the petitioner in relation to the above property could not
be allowed in view of the bar contained in Section 92 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872. According to him, when the sale consideration
shown in Ext.B1 is only Rs.7,58,000/-, the trial court was not
justified in awarding Rs.15,00,000/- as the value of the half share
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
14
2026:KER:73656
of the property, as such a finding would offend Section 92.
20. Section 92 of the Indian Evidence Act prohibits the
parties to a document from adducing oral or other evidence in
variation of the terms of a contract, grant or disposition of
property. The relevant part of Section 92 reads thus:
“92. Exclusion of evidence of oral agreement.
When the terms of any such contract, grant or other disposition
of property , or any matter required by law to be reduced to the
form of a document, have been proved according to the last
section, no evidence of any oral agreement or statement shall be
admitted , as between the parties to any such instrument or their
representatives in interest, for the purpose of contradicting,
varying, adding to or subtracting from, its terms : ….”
(emphasis added)
No doubt, a recital regarding payment of consideration is a recital
of fact and not a term of the contract. It is not so when it comes
to the quantum of consideration. To that extent, the contention
advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the respondent is
relevant. However, Section 14 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 ('the
Act', for short) expressly provides that the Family Court may
receive in evidence any “report, statement, documents, information
or matter” , whether or not the same would otherwise be relevant or
admissible under the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, if the court
considers that such evidence would assist it in dealing effectually
with the dispute. Section 14 reads thus:
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
15
2026:KER:73656
“14. Application of Indian Evidence Act, 1872.-
A Family Court may receive as evidence any report,
statement, documents, information or matter that may, in
its opinion, assist it to deal effectually with a dispute,
whether or not the same would be otherwise relevant or
admissible under the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of
1872).”
Indeed, Section 92 of the Indian Evidence Act states that no such
oral agreement or statement shall be admitted if it would vary from
the terms of any contract, grant or other disposition of property.
Nevertheless, in view of the specific enabling provision referred
to above, the Family Court can take into consideration any such
statement, information or document if it finds that the same is
necessary for effectively resolving the dispute. Once the Family
Court arrives at such conclusion, it can rely on any such evidence
dehors Section 92, in the light of Section 14 of the Act, which
gives an overriding effect to the provisions relating to relevancy
and admissibility under the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
21. We hasten to add that, while Section 14 of the Act gives
discretion to the Family Court, in a given case, to admit evidence
which may otherwise be inadmissible under Section 92 of the Indian
Evidence Act, such discretion should be exercised with due care and
caution, having regard to the laudable objects underlying Section
92. The reliability and probative value of such materials are also
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
16
2026:KER:73656
to be tested in the light of the facts and circumstances of each
case. This Court has held that the Family Courts are bound to
adhere to the fundamental rules of evidence founded on logic,
fairness and expediency, as well as the principles of natural
justice, even when Section 14 of the Act permits them to receive
evidence which may otherwise be irrelevant or inadmissible under
the Indian Evidence Act [See Pramod E.K. v. Louna V.C. , (2019 (1)
KHC 292)].
22. Coming to the disputed questions before us, we have no
hesitation in holding that the oral evidence of PW1 and PW4, which
is substantially corroborated by Ext.A3, is sufficient to establish
that the actual consideration paid for purchasing the property was
not the amount shown in Ext.B1 and that the entire sale
consideration was paid by the father of the petitioner. The purpose
for which the property was purchased, namely, the welfare of his
daughter, the petitioner, is beyond dispute, and is established by
his evidence as PW4. Significantly, the jurisdictional Family
Court, having a better understanding of the local circumstances,
upon evaluating the oral and documentary evidence, concluded that,
considering that the property in question admittedly lies by the
side of a Municipal Road and that the building situated therein is
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
17
2026:KER:73656
a two-storied residential house, the petitioner's claim that its
actual consideration is much more than what is recited in the deed,
is highly probable.
23. However, it is contended by the learned counsel appearing
for the respondent that this Court, in Shereefa Shanavaz v.
Shanavaz , (2026 (4) KLT 597), held that, in the absence of any
specification in the sale deed regarding the respective shares of
the parties in the property, the parties are to be treated as co-
owners in equal shares. On perusing the decision cited above, we
find that the said conclusion was rendered in the peculiar factual
circumstances of that case. In paragraph 13, Their Lordships
observed that “ .... the possibility that it was in recognition of
the wife's contributions to the matrimonial relationship that she
was made a co-owner of the property ”. The Court further observed in
paragraph 12 as follows:
“As has already been noticed in the decisions referred above,
the intention of the parties at the time of execution of the
sale deed in relation to the property, has to be gathered from
an overall consideration of the surrounding circumstances,
including the relationship between parties, their conduct
previous and subsequent to the transaction, source of money
for purchase, possession of the property, possession of title
documents etc.”
Further, the application of Section 45 of the Transfer of Property
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
18
2026:KER:73656
Act, 1882, was not under consideration in that case. Section 45
provides that, where consideration is paid out of a separate fund
belonging to the persons in whose favour the property is
transferred, they are, in the absence of a contract to the
contrary, respectively entitled to interests in such property in
proportion to the shares of the consideration which they
respectively advanced. This Court, in Vasanthakumary v. Omanakuttan
Nair , (2009 (2) KHC 1049), had explained the legal position in that
regard. In the present case, it is proved that the entire
consideration was provided by the father of the petitioner in the
best interests of his daughter and for her benefit and that it
belongs to her.
24. In the impugned order, the trial court observed that the
petitioner was actually entitled to get a declaration of exclusive
ownership of the above property, but she has, instead, prayed only
for return of the money paid for the half share of the property
standing in the name of the respondent and hence the court is
granting that limited relief. In this regard, Sri. P. Samsudin, the
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, submitted that the
petitioner has already filed an application for amendment of the
original petition so as to enable her to seek a declaration of her
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
19
2026:KER:73656
right over the said property as well for a mandatory injunction
directing the respondent to vacate the property, instead of merely
obtaining the value of the half share of the respondent in the said
property. The learned counsel further submitted that, even without
effecting such amendment, the petitioner is entitled to the said
relief if this Court exercises its jurisdiction under Order VII
Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as it is open to the court
to mould the relief in a just and reasonable manner, on the basis
of the materials pleaded and proved.
25. The said application for amendment is stoutly opposed by
the learned counsel appearing for the respondent on the ground that
it is highly belated and, therefore, not maintainable in view of
the prohibition contained in the proviso to Rule 17 of Order VI of
the Code of Civil Procedure. It is well settled that, in family
disputes, the role of the court is somewhat different from that in
ordinary civil litigation. In matters involving technicalities of
the above nature, Section 10(3) of the Act also provides that,
notwithstanding the provisions contained in the Code of Civil
Procedure, which is made applicable to Family Courts by sub-section
(1) of Section 10, the Family Court may lay down its own procedure
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
20
2026:KER:73656
with a view to arriving at the truth of the facts alleged by one
party and denied by the other. Having been satisfied that the
property was purchased for the petitioner, we do not find any
impediment in declaring the petitioner's exclusive title in respect
of the said property, even without allowing the application for
amendment. We have noticed that, in paragraph 13 of the original
petition, what the petitioner has essentially pleaded is as
follows:
“
എതൃകക്ഷി നിരന്തരമായി ആവശ്യപ്പെടുകയും ഹരജിക്കാരിയെ വീട് വാങ്ങുന്നതിനെ പറ്റി
പറഞ്ഞു ബുദ്ധിമുട്ടിച്ചതിനെ തുടർന്ന് 09 -11 -2015 -ന് ഹരജിക്കാരിയുടെ ബാപ്പ 30 ലക്ഷം
രൂപ കൊ ടുത്തു മഞ്ചേരി മുനിസിപ്പാലിറ്റിയിലെ റീ സർവ്വേ നമ്പർ 4 ൽ പെട്ട 7 സെ ൻറ്
സ്ഥലവും വീടും ഹരജിക്കാരിയുടെയും എതൃകക്ഷിയുടെയും പേരിൽ വാങ്ങി തരുകയുണ്ടായി.
ഹരജിക്കാരിയുടെ ഭാവി ഭദ്രതക്കും സുരക്ഷിത ജീവിതത്തിനും വേണ്ടിയാണ് പിതാവ് 30
ലക്ഷം രൂപ കൊ ടുത്തു വീട് വാങ്ങിയത്. മേൽ വീട് വാങ്ങുന്നതിലേക്കായി എതൃകക്ഷി ഒരു
സംഖ്യയും ചിലവഴിച്ചിട്ടില്ല. എന്നാൽ മേൽ വീടിലെ പകുതി അവകാശം എതൃകക്ഷി
പേരിലാണ്. ആയതിനാൽ ഹരജിക്കാരിക്ക് വേണ്ടി ബാപ്പ ചിലവഴിച്ച 30 ലക്ഷം രൂപയിൽ
”
15 ലക്ഷം രൂപ എതൃകക്ഷി ഹരജിക്കാരിക്ക് നൽകേണ്ടതുണ്ട്.
The above pleading essentially raises a claim to exclusive right
over the said property. It is in that context that the petitioner
pleaded that the respondent had not contributed any amount towards
the sale consideration. The relief sought by the petitioner in
respect of the said property is also referable to her right over
the entire property. It reads thus:
“
(c) ഹരജിക്കാരിയുടെയും എതൃകക്ഷിയുടെയും പേരിൽ ഹരജിക്കാരിയുടെ ബാപ്പ 30 ലക്ഷം
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
21
2026:KER:73656
രൂപ നൽകി വാങ്ങിയ 7 സെ ൻറ് സ്ഥലത്തിന്റെയും വീടിന്റെയും പകുതി അവകാശത്തിന്റെ
വിലയായ 15,00,000/- രൂപ (പതിനഞ്ച് രൂപ മാത്രം) ഹരജിക്കാരിക്ക് തരുവാൻ
”
എതൃകക്ഷിയോ ട് കല്പിച്ചു.
In the light of the above pleadings, and having regard to the
specific and emphatic denial by the respondent of the said claim in
his written objection, it is evident that the respondent defended
the case with full knowledge of the true nature of the petitioner's
claim. Therefore, no prejudice will be caused to him if we mould
the relief in the above manner.
26. The relief of mandatory injunction sought is only
ancillary to the declaration of title. Evidently, a plea of adverse
possession does not arise and the respondent is not entitled to
defend his possession. Remitting the matter to the Family Court at
this distance of time, solely for deciding that question would only
be a futile exercise, as there is virtually nothing further to be
adjudicated in that regard. Once this Court finds that the title to
the property is exclusively vested in the petitioner, there is no
scope for the respondent to set up an independent right over the
said property.
27. In Syamini S. Nair and Others v. Sreekanth R ., (2022 (3)
KHC 145), while referring to Rule 7 of Order VII, this Court held
that it shall not be necessary to ask for a general or other relief
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
22
2026:KER:73656
which may always be given as the Court may think just, to the same
extent as if it had been asked for. Having found the circumstance
in which the name of the respondent came to be included in the
title deed, and the nature and duration of the respondent's
possession over the said property, we are compelled to conclude
that, in the interests of justice, the relief in the present case
has to be moulded, declaring the exclusive ownership of the
property upon the petitioner, while incidentally permitting her to
obtain vacant possession thereof.
28. It is, therefore, concluded that the decree passed by the
Family Court is liable to be modified by declaring the exclusive
right of the petitioner over the said property and permitting her
to obtain vacant possession thereof from the respondent.
In the result, Mat.Appeal No.84/2022 is dismissed. Mat.Appeal
No. 581/2022 is allowed in part. It is declared that the petitioner
has exclusive ownership over the 2.8 Ares of land and the building
standing therein, as described in Ext. B1 sale deed, lying in Re-
Survey No.104/50, Block No. 50, Narukara Village, Eranad Taluk. The
respondent is further directed to vacate the said property within 3
months. The schedule of Ext.B1 tile deed will form part of the
Mat.Appeal Nos.581/2022, 84/2022 CNR : KLHC010552152022
23
2026:KER:73656
decree. The decree passed by the trial court granting ₹15,00,000/-
to the petitioner as the share of the said property is modified
accordingly. The remaining part of the decree is upheld.
Sd/-
SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
Sd/-
P. KRISHNA KUMAR
JUDGE
sv