Rambabu Singh vs The State of Bihar
- Court
- Patna High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.11743 of 2026
CNR No. BRHC010753322026
======================================================
Rambabu Singh Son of Chandeshwar Singh, Resident of Village and P.O.-
Bharwari, Via- Silaut, P.S. Silaut, District- Muzaffarpur.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar Through Additional Chief Secretary, Public Health
Engineering Department, Govt. of Bihar, Patna.
2. The Engineer-in-Chief-cum-Special Secretary, PHED, Bihar, Patna.
3. The Chief Engineer (Mechanical), PHED, Bihar, Patna.
4. The Regional Chief Engineer (Mechanical), PHED, Muzaffarpur.
5. The Superintending Engineer, PHED Mechanical Circle, Muzaffarpur.
6. The Executive Engineer, PHED Mechanical Division, Muzaffarpur.
7. The Treasury Officer, Muzaffarpur.
8. The Secretary (Finance/Expenditure), Govt. of Bihar, Patna.
9. The Accountant General, Bihar, Patna.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Sunil Kumar, Advocate
For the AG (Bihar) : Mr.Arun Kumar Arun, Advocate
For the Respondent/s : Ms.Priya Gupta, GP 6
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PURNENDU SINGH
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 03-11-2026
Heard Mr. Sunil Kumar, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioner; Mr. Arun Kumar Arun, learned counsel
for Accountant General (Bihar) and Ms. Priya Gupta, learned
GP 6 for the State.
Patna High Court CWJC No.11743 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
2/11
2. The petitioner in paragraph no. 1 of the present writ
petition has sought inter alia following relief(s), which is
reproduced hereinafter:-
“a) For quashing Office Order No.66 dated
25.08.2025 along with Office Order No.64 dated 01.08.2025
issued by the Superintending Engineer, Public Health
Mechanical Circle, Muzaffarpur (Respondent No.5). By the
impugned order, Respondent No.5 has again partially amended
Office Order No.15 (read with Memo No.90 dated 26.02.2020)
and revised the petitioner’s pay, annual increments and
pension by arbitrarily treating his qualifying service as
commencing only from 07.03.1990. Earlier, under the same
Office Order No.15, the petitioner's annual increments, first
ACP, second MACP and pension had been revised, and
Rs.7,32,487/- was recovered from his gratuity. The said order
was declared illegal and set aside by the Hon’ble Patna High
Court in CWJC no.5786 of 2024.
b) For a direction to the respondents to reckon the
petitioner’s qualifying service from 27.05.1987, w.e.f the date
of his joining in service, under Office Order No.108 dated
25.05.1987 issued by the Chief Engineer (Mechanical), Public
Health Engineering Department, Bihar, Patna, in pursuance of
Departmental Letter No.1007 dated 17.07.1986, for all
purposes including pay fixation, pension, gratuity and other
retiral benefits.
c) For a direction to the respondents to revise and
rd
re-fix the petitioner’s pay and grant him the 3 MACP by
reckoning his qualifying service from 27.05.1987, with effect
from the date it became due, together with all consequential
service and monetary benefits.
d) For a direction to recompute and release
gratuity and leave encashment by counting the petitioner’s
service from 27.05.1987.
e) For a direction to pay interest on the
delayed/withehld payment of gratuity, which was illegally
recovered on the ground of non-passing of departmental
examination, in violation of the law laid down by the Full
Bench of this Hon’ble Court in Kalanand Thakur Vs. The State
of Bihar (CWJC No.18727 of 2013) and other binding
precedents.
(f) For a direction to revise the petitioner’s pension
upon re-determination of qualifying service from 25.05.1987
and to pay the consequential arrears thereof.
g). For any other relief(s) to which the petitioner is
found entitled in the facts and circumstances of the case.”
Patna High Court CWJC No.11743 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
3/11
3. Before claiming the above relief in the present writ
petition, the petitioner had filed CWJC No.5786 of 2024. The
case of the petitioner was heard along with the other analogous
cases and final order was passed vide order dated 18.09.2024
passed in CWJC No.20503 of 2021. The case of the petitioner
has been discussed in the said judgment in paragraph No.30 and
31, which I find inter alia to produce as under :
“30. In C.W.J.C. No. 5786 of 2024, it is found that the
petitioner was appointed as Typist initially on 25th of May,
1987. He joined his service on 27th of May, 1987. He was
terminated on the ground of excess employees in the cadre.
Again on 25th of February, 1990, they were taken back in
the service. Since then, the petitioner had been working in
Public Health Engineering Department. Therefore, the date
of service of the petitioner ought to be held w.e.f. 28th of
February, 1990, The petitioner was entitled to 1" A.C.P.
after 12 years of his service. Thus, he was entitled to get 1"
th
A.C.P. on or from 28 of February / 1" of March, 2002. The
petitioner, however, was granted the I" A.C.P. vide office
order no. 44, dated 3rd June, 2006. The said benefit was
cancelled vide order dated 30 of September, 2018 on
account of the petitioner's not passing accounts
examination. The said order, dated 30th of September, 2008
was unjust and illegal as this Court holds that the petitioner
was entitled to 1" A.C.P. on completion of his 12 years of
service. Thereafter, the petitioner was entitled to get 2nd
A.C.P. on completion of 20 years of service. However, as the
petitioner was promoted to the post of Head Clerk, he was
granted 2nd A.C.P. w.e.f. 11 January, 2009. The petitioner is
entitled to get 3d M.A.C.P. on completion of 30 years of
service, meaning thereby, he was entitled to get 3rd
M.A.C.P. on and from 28th of February, 2020. This Court
fails to understand as to how the 3rd M.A.C.P. of the
petitioner was due w.e.f. 29th of May, 2017. The petitioner
counted his service from his initial appointment which was
terminated on 10th of July, 1987. He cannot claim 3rd
M.A.C.P. from 27th of May, 2017. As he retired from service
on 31 of January, 2020, he was not entitled to get 3rd
M.A.C.P.
31. In such view of the matter, this Court holds that the
petitioner of C.W.J.C. No. 5786 of 2024 was entitled-to-
A.CP. we.f. 28th February / 1" of March, 2002 and the 2nd
Patna High Court CWJC No.11743 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
4/11
M.A.C.P. w.e.f. 28th of February / 1" of March, 2012.
However, since he got 2nd A.C.P. w.e.f. 1 of January, 2009
on his promotion to the post of Head Clerk, he was entitled
to get 2nd A.C.P. w.e.f. 1" January, 2009.”
4. In the present case, the petitioner has challenged
the office order No.64 dated 01.08.2025, which has been passed
on submission of the report of the Screening Committee dated
29.07.2025 to consider the case of the petitioner and other
employees to extend and review the benefit of ACP/MACP.
Thereafter, the Memo dated 01.08.2025 read with memo no. 90
dated 26.02.2020 issued in respect to the petitioner by which,
partially modified the earlier decision and the petitioner was
st
extended the benefit of 1 ACP w.e.f. 07.03.2002 in the pay
nd
scale of 5000-150-8000 and 2 MACP w.e.f. 07.03.2010 in the
pay scale of 9300-34800, corresponding Grade pay- 4600.
5. Learned counsel further submitted that the actual
implementation of judgment dated 18.09.2025 passed in CWJC
No.20503 of 2021 is required to be examined in the light of the
finding and relevant departmental circular including the letter
no.353 dated 28.02.1990 for determining seniority from the date
of joining i.e . from 27.05.1987 and by losing site of the same,
the respondents have failed to fix the correct pay scale of the
petitioner.
6. Learned counsel further submitted that the
Patna High Court CWJC No.11743 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
5/11
judgment expressly held that the petitioner was entitled to
second ACP/MACP w.e.f. 01.01.2009 and the same was
extended w.e.f. the said date in view of his promotion to the post
of Head Clerk, therefore, the respondents committed an error in
fixation of his first ACP w.e.f. 07.03.2002 and second MACP
from 07.03.2010, leading to fixation of incorrect pay scale and
pension to which the petitioner is entitled to. Further, the learned
counsel in his rejoinder to the counter affidavit filed on behalf of
respondent no.5. has denied the statements made by the
respondent with respect to paragraph no. 44 in reply
retieterating that the judgment expressly held that the petitioner
nd
was entitled to the 2 ACP/MACP w.e.f. 01.01.2009 and the
same is required to be extended w.e.f. the said date in view of
his promotion to the post of Head Clerk. The impugned order
st nd
that fixed the 1 ACP from 07.03.2002 and the 2 MACP from
07.03.2010 does not reflect those findings, and the respondents
are bound to correct the impugned fixation accordingly.
7. Per contra , learned counsel for the State and
Respondent No. 5 submits that the impugned orders were passed
in compliance with the judgment dated 18.09.2024, after
analysing the claim of the petitioner for his entitlement of
pension on higher pay scale as a result of financial progression.
Patna High Court CWJC No.11743 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
6/11
It has been submitted that specific information has been given in
the counter affidavit filed on behalf of Respondent No. 5, that
the petitioner, who was declared surplus in Bihar State
Construction Corporation Ltd. and absorbed as Typist in the
Public Health Engineering Department vide Office Order No.
108 dated 25.05.1987, was terminated vide Office Order No.
152 dated 10.07.1987 and was reinstated in terms of Letter No.
353 dated 28.02.1990, which provided for seniority from the
date of joining but he was not entitled for any monetary benefit
for the intervening period. This Court vide order dated
18.09.2024 held the date of service of the petitioner to be
reckoned w.e.f. 28.02.1990 and after proper calculation, the
excess amount of Rs. 7,32,487/- which was paid to the
petitioner on account of 1st ACP and 2nd MACP and was
recovered from the gratuity of the petitioner has already been
refunded to the petitioner, as has also been admitted by him.
Hence, as per the counter affidavit, the claim of the petitioner to
reckon his service from 27.05.1987 is misconceived, and the
petitioner, having accepted the said order dated 18.09.2024,
cannot be permitted to raise the same issue again in the present
writ petition.
8. Heard the parties.
Patna High Court CWJC No.11743 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
7/11
9. The object and purpose of ACP/MACP scheme has
been held by the Apex Court time and again and again reiterated
in Union of India and Ors. Vs. C. R. Madhava Murthy and
Anr. reported in (2022) 6 SCC 183 , that the purpose of the ACP
Scheme/MACP Scheme is to relieve the frustration on account
of stagnation and the Scheme does not involve the actual grant
of promotional post to the employees, but to merely monetary
benefits in the form of next higher grade.
10. Subsequent to the above judgment, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has reiterated the above view regarding the
purpose of ACP/MACP scheme in the case of Amresh Kumar
Sinha and Ors. Vs. State of Bihar and Ors. (SLP(C) Nos.
8219-8226 of 2019) in the following paragraphs, which are
reproduced herein under:
“13. At the cost of repetition, it must be
borne in mind that the object of ACP is to
avoid stagnation where no promotional
avenues are available. The grant of ACP is
not technically a grant of promotion but
increase in the pay scale to the next higher
grade retaining the employee on the post
held by him. This is only to accord monetary
benefit without disturbing any seniority or
actually effectuating promotion to any
higher post to avoid
stagnation on a particular post or pay scale
for a very long period.
14. The object and purpose of ACP/MACP
Scheme has been reiterated by this Court in
Patna High Court CWJC No.11743 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
8/11
Union of India & Others Vs. C.R. Madhava
Murthy & Anr. (2022) 6 SCC 183, as one to
relieve the frustration on account of
stagnation
and it does not involve actual grant of
promotional post but merely monetary
benefits in the form of next higher grade
subject to fulfilment of qualifications and
eligibility criteria.
15. In sum and substance, both ACP and
MACP Schemes are schemes devised with
the object of ensuring that the employees
who are unable to avail of adequate
promotional opportunities, get some relief in
the form of financial benefits. Accordingly,
the schemes provide for regular financial
upgradation on completion of 12-24 years
and 10-20-30 years of service without
promotion. They are incentive schemes for
the employees who complete a particular
period of service but without getting
promotion for lack of promotional avenues.
The effect of the schemes must be judged
keeping in view the object and the purport of
the scheme.”
11. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of State of
Jharkhand & Ors. v. Jitendra Kumar Srivastava & Anr. ,
reported in (2013) 12 SCC 210 , reiterating the principles laid
down in case of D.S. Nakara & Ors. v. Union of India,
reported in (1983) 1 SCC 305 , has categorically held that
pension is not a bounty or gratuitous payment, but a valuable
and vested right earned by an employee through his service,
which partakes the character of property under Article 300-A of
Patna High Court CWJC No.11743 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
9/11
the Constitution of India. The relevant paragraph of the same is
produced herein:
“7. It is an accepted position that gratuity and pension are
not the bounties. An employee earns these benefits by dint
of his long, continuous, faithful and un-blemished service.
Conceptually it is so lucidly described in D.S. Nakara and
Ors. Vs. Union of India; (1983) 1 SCC 305 by Justice D.A.
Desai, who spoke for the Bench, in his inimitable style, in
the following words:
“The approach of the respondents raises a vital and none
too easy of answer, question as to why pension is paid. And
why was it required to be liberalised? Is the employer,
which expression will include even the State, bound to pay
pension? Is there any obligation on the employer to provide
for the erstwhile employee even after the contract of
employment has come to an end and the employee has
ceased to render service?
What is a pension? What are the goals of pension? What
public interest or purpose, if any, it seeks to serve? If it does
seek to serve some public purpose, is it thwarted by such
artificial division of retirement pre and post a certain date?
We need seek answer to these and incidental questions so as
to render just justice between parties to this petition.
The antiquated notion of pension being a bounty a
gratituous payment depending upon the sweet will or grace
of the employer not claimable as a right and, therefore, no
right to pension can be enforced through Court has been
swept under the carpet by the decision of the Constitution
Bench in Deoki Nandan Prasad v. State of Bihar and Ors.
[1971] Su. S.C.R. 634 wherein this Court authoritatively
ruled that pension is a right and the payment of it does not
depend upon the discretion of the Government but is
governed by the rules and a Government servant coming
within those rules is entitled to claim pension. It was further
held that the grant of pension does not depend upon any
one’s discretion. It is only for the purpose of quantifying the
amount having regard to service and other allied maters
that it may be necessary for the authority to pass an order
to that effect but the right to receive pension flows to the
officer not because of any such order but by virtue of the
rules. This view was reaffirmed in State of Punjab and Anr.
V. Iqbal Singh (1976) IILLJ 377SC”.
8. It is thus hard earned benefit which accrues to an
employee and is in the nature of “property”. This right to
property cannot be taken away without the due process of
law as per the provisions of Article 300 A of the
Patna High Court CWJC No.11743 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
10/11
Constitution of India.
11. Reading of Rule 43(b) makes it abundantly clear that
even after the conclusion of the departmental inquiry, it is
permissible for the Government to withhold pension etc.
ONLY when a finding is recorded either in departmental
inquiry or judicial proceedings that the employee had
committed grave misconduct in the discharge of his duty
while in his office. There is no provision in the rules for
withholding of the pension/ gratuity when such
departmental proceedings or judicial proceedings are still
pending.”
12. In view of the above proposition of law and the
facts of the given case, the petitioner had earlier approached this
Court in CWJC No. 5786 of 2024, which was heard along with
CWJC No. 20503 of 2021 and decided vide order dated
18.09.2024, wherein it has been held that the date of service of
the petitioner is w.e.f. 28.02.1990 and that he is not entitled to
the 3rd MACP. Nothing has been brought to the notice of this
Court that the said finding has been set aside or modified. The
pension and gratuity being in the nature of property under
Article 300-A of the Constitution of India is required to be
determined in accordance with the order dated 18.09.2024
passed in CWJC No.5786 of 2024.
13. The respondents have refunded a sum of Rs.
7,32,487/-, which was recovered in compliance of the order
dated 18.09.2024. The petitioner is now at liberty to file
representation before the competent authority for redressal of
his claim, as prayed for in the present writ petition.
Patna High Court CWJC No.11743 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
11/11
14. Accordingly the present writ petition stands
disposed.
(Purnendu Singh, J)
chn/-
AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE NA
Uploading Date 11.11.2026
Transmission Date NA