N PANDIAN vs M/o Defence

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1 of 12
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CHENNAI BENCH
OA No. 310/00754 of 2022
.
nd
DATED MONDAY, THE 02 DAY OF NOVEMBER, TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
CORAM :
HON'BLE MS. VEENA KOTHAVALE, MEMBER (J)
HON'BLE MR. M.L. SRIVASTAVA, MEMBER(A)
BETWEEN
N Pandian, aged about 62 years old,
S/o. Late Shri VS Nagu,
T. No. 203 Vehicle Mechanic (MV) HS Grade -1
(Retired from Vehicle Depot Workshop EME Avadi)
th
No. 351, 6 Cross Street,
Prakash Nagar, Thirunindravur-602024. …...Applicant
(Advocate: Mr. S. Kumar)
Versus
1. The Union India,
Ministry of Defence,
Rep. by its Joint Secretary (Establishment)
Room No. 234, South Block, New Delhi-110011;
2. The Director General of EME
Directorate of EME
Master General's Branch
Integrated Headquarters of Ministry of Defence (Army)
New Delhi-110 011;
3. The Commandant, Headquarters
Base Workshop Group EME
Meerut 250 001;
4. The Officer Commanding
Vehicle Depot Workshop EME
Avadi,
Chennai - 600 055. …….Respondents
(Advocate: Mrs. K.M. Valsala Kumari)
CAV ON : 21.09.2026

2 of 12
O R D E R
(Hon'ble Ms. Veena Kothavale, Member(J)

This Original Application is filed by the applicant under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals' Act, 1985 seeking the following relief:-
“(i) To set aside the impugned speaking order dated 18 June 2022 of
th
the 4 Respondent.
(ii) To place me in the vacant post of Vehicle Mechanic (MV)
th
Highly Skilled Grade-I in the Grade Pay of Rs. 2800/- (6 CPC Pay)
w.e.f. 01/04/2006 under the Scheme of Restructuring of Artisans in
th
Defence Establishments in modification of 6 CPC, ordered vide
Office Memorandum No. 11(5)/2009-D (Civ-l) dated 14 June 2010
issued by the Government of India, Ministry of Defence and
consequently pay due arrears of salary accrued thereon and all other
terminal, attendant and monetary benefits as applicable to employees
of Vehicle Mechanic Highly Skilled Grade-I in the Grade Pay of Rs.
th
2800/- (6 CPC) w.e.f. 01/04/2006 and to consider the subsequent line
th
promotion MCM in the Grade Pay Rs. 4200/- (6 CPC) w.e.f.
01/04/2012 on completion of qualifying residency period of 6 years in
the HS Grade 1 in compliance with DoPT Office Memorandum No.
AB.14017/61/2008-Estt. (RR) dated 24 March 2009 and consequently
pay due arrears of salary accrued thereon and all other terminal,
attendant and monetary benefits as applicable to employees of MCM
th
in the Grade Pay Rs. 4200/- (6 CPC) w.e.f. 01/04/2012.
(iii) To accomplice the above action within a stipulated period of
time as prescribed by this Hon'ble Tribunal.

3 of 12
(iv) To pass such further order or other order or orders deems fit and
proper in the circumstances of the case and thus render justice.”
2. The case of the applicant in brief is that he was appointed as a Messenger in the
Vehicle Depot Workshop, EME, Avadi, Chennai on 04/02/1984. The said post was
reclassified as Vehicle Mechanic (MATE) and he was promoted as Vehicle Mechanic
(Motor Vehicle) on 27/07/1993.

3. The Scheme of Restructuring the Cadre of Artisans Staff in Defence
th
Establishment, in modification of the 6 CPC recommendation, was issued by the
Government of India in the Ministry of Defence vide Letter No.11(5)2009-D (Civ-I)
dated 14/06/2010. As per the said MoD order, the placement of the individuals in the
posts resulting from the restructuring shall be made with effect from 01/01/2006, in
relaxation of the conditions, if any, i.e., trade test, qualifying service, etc., as one-time
measure. The placement in newly created vacancies as per the MoD order was
carried out in Vehicle Depot Workshop, EME, Avadi in the year 2013. As a result of
restructuring, there were two vacancies created for Highly Skilled-II with effect from
01/01/2006 and one vacancy and another vacancy for HS-I w.e.f. 01/01/2006. The
post of VM (HS-I) became vacant due to the retirement of Arunachalam VM (HS-I)
w.e.f. 01/04/2006. Consequently, applicant was entitled for grant of placement in the
said post of VM (HS-I) with effect from 01/04/2006 itself, but the applicant was
granted placement as VM (HS-II) with effect from 01/01/2006.

4 of 12
4. It is submitted by the applicant that though there was one vacancy for HS-II
w.e.f. 01/01/2006 and one vacancy for HS-I w.e.f. 01/04/2006, the DPC Board (2013)
of the department placed the applicant in HS-II only, w.e.f. 01/01/2006 in
contravention of the MOD orders. The applicant immediately submitted an appeal
th
dated 03/09/2013 to the 4 respondent, but he was informed that as there is ambiguity
in the MoD letter regarding relaxation of qualifying service, the placement would be
provided after obtaining clarification from the headquarters. Though the applicant
made several representations to the concerned higher officials, he was informed time
and again that clarifications from the higher officers is needed. However, the
applicant was placed as VM (HS-I) w.e.f. 22/06/2015 instead of placing him as VM
(HS-I) with effect from 01/04/2006. The objections and representations submitted by
the applicant have not been considered by the respondents.

5. The applicant states that in January 2020, he came to know through Trade
Union representatives that necessary clarification for relaxation of qualifying service
had been issued by MoD to Headquarters (Army/EME) vide their ID No. 11(5)/2009-
D (Civ-I) dated 29/12/2011 and in all departments under the Army, the officials had
been placed in the vacancy posts accrued between 01/01/2006 to 14/06/2010 by
treating the same as placement and not promotion. The applicant submitted several
applications dated 05/02/2020, 02/03/2020, 03/06/2020, 16/06/2020, 22/06/2020,
13/07/2020, 28/07/2020 raising several queries and making several submissions and

5 of 12
requesting the fourth respondent to hold review the DPC and place him in the vacant
post of HS-I with effect from 01/04/2006, to grant him promotion as Master
th
Craftsman, etc. The 4 respondent replied vide letter dated 05/09/2020 that since
applicant had already got HS-II promotion w.e.f. 01/01/2006 under restructuring of
Artisan Staff, there is no provision to grant two promotions at one go and that since
HS-I post was created for the first time by SRO 54 dated 21/08/2014, and the same
was implemented with effect from the date of publication of the said rules on
21/08/2014, there is no provision to grant promotion to HS-I prior to implementation
of the said rules.
6. Meanwhile, the applicant retired from service on 31/11/2020 and thereafter, he
gave detailed representation dated 04/12/2021 to Respondents 1, 2, and 3 requesting
them to give him placement and fixation of pay scale of Highly Skilled Grade-I with
effect from 01/04/2006 under the scheme of restructuring dated 14/06/2010 and
consequently pay due arrears of salary accrued thereon and all other terminal,
attendant, and monetary benefits as applicable to employees of Highly Skilled Grade-
I with effect from 01/04/2006. As there was no response from the respondents, he
filed OA. No. 269/2022 before this Tribunal for the relief as above. The OA was
disposed of by this Tribunal vide order dated 30/03/2022 directing the competent
authority among the respondents to consider his representation dated 04/12/2021 and
pass a reasoned and speaking order in accordance with law within a period of 3

6 of 12
months.
7. In compliance of the order dated 30/03/2022, a speaking order dated
th
18/07/2022 was passed by the 4 respondent stating that applicant was promoted to
the post of VM (MV) HS-I only on 22/06/2015 as per SRO 54 dated 21/08/2014 on
occurrence of vacancy and qualifying for the trade test. Since promotion to the post
of HS-I was created by SRO 54 w.e.f. 21/08/2014, it was to be given effect on the
date of its implementation and conducting of DPC Board thereafter, and accordingly
applicant was placed correctly as VM (MV) HS-I w.e.f. 22/06/2015. Being
aggrieved, the applicant has filed this OA seeking the aforementioned relief.
8. The applicant who is Party-in-person submitted that though the relief/ benefit
th
sought by him is based on the 6 CPC recommendation which was implemented with
effect from 01/01/2006, the same is still pending for more than 19 years in his case.
He has filed this OA seeking for his placement in the resultant vacancy of Vehicle
Mechanic High Skilled Grade-I w.e.f. 01/04/2006 in the Grade pay of Rs. 2,800/-
under the Restructuring of Cadre of Artisan Staff in Defence Establishments Order
dated 14/06/2010 and follow-up promotion to Master Craftsman post (non-functional
post) w.e.f. 01/05/2011. The applicant relies on the judgment dated 05/12/2024
passed by the Coordinate Bench of this Tribunal at Bangalore in OA 395/2023 in the
case of Kalavati S vs Ministry of Defence wherein the difference between placement

7 of 12
and promotion has been clearly explained and submits that the said judgment
squarely applies to his case.
9. Learned counsel for the respondent has reiterated the averments in the reply
statement wherein it is stated by the respondents that the applicant has been correctly
promoted to the post of VM (MV) HS-I with effect from 22/06/2015 in the pay scale
of 5,200-20,200+ Grade pay Rs. 2800/- and has retired in the same pay scale on
30/11/2020. The claim of the applicant that he is entitled to grade pay of Rs. 4,200
has no merit as per the extant rules. Moreover, promotion to the post of MCM is
done on Corps Roster basis and not by VDW, EME, Avadi. The DPC for MCM, with
effect from 15/06/2010 onwards, has to be conducted based on the recruitment rules
of MCM, which are under formulation with the Ministry of Defence. Therefore, he
prayed for dismissal of this OA.
10. We have considered the submissions made by the Party-in-person and the
learned counsel for the respondents, Mrs. K. M. Valsala Kumari and perused the
materials placed on the record.
11. It is observed that in the Circular dated 14/06/2010 on "Restructuring of Cadre
th
of Artisan staff in Defence Establishments in modification of recommendations of 6
CPC" issued by the Ministry of Defence, it is stated in para 2 that the grade structure

8 of 12
and the pay scales of artisan staff stood modified with effect from 01/01/2006 into
four trades of Skilled, Highly Skilled Grade-II, Highly Skilled Grade-I and Master
Craftsman. It was further provided in item (b) that placement of individuals in the
posts resulting from restructuring shall be made with effect from 01/01/2006 by
relaxation of conditions, if any, i.e., trade test, etc., as a one-time measure. Para 4 (ii)
thereof states that in case of Defence Establishments where there is no category of
Skilled Workers and direct recruitment's made 100% at the level of Highly Skilled,
the posts of Master Craftsman existing as on 01/01/2006 will be placed in PB-2+GP
4200 and the remaining posts of Highly Skilled workers may be bifurcated into HS-I
and HS-II in the ratio of 50:50.
12. The Annexure ‘C’ is the convening order dated 20/01/2013 issued to the Board
of Officers for the purpose of restructuring of cadre of Artisan Staff in Defence
Establishment in Vehicle Depot Workshop, Avadi. Appendix ‘A’ to Annexure ‘C’ is
the Seniority Roll of industrial personnel on assumption of the trade (locally
controlled) as on 31/12/2005 which is as under: -
Unit Trade/Rank T.No. &
DOB DOA with
trade
Date of
Mate
Date of
Skilled
Remarks
Name
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
I Cadre
VDW
EME
VM (AFV) 209 Shri R.
24 Jul 1980 14 Oct
2005/VM
(AFV)
NA 14 Oct
2005
Guruprasad
II CADRE

9 of 12
VDW
EME
MCM(VM
MV)
193 Shri P.
Swaminathan
22 Jun 1959 11 Mar
1983/VM
(MV)
NA 11 Mar
1983
Promoted
MCM on
01/10/04
VDW
EME
MCM(VM
MV)
196 Shri. S.
Raja
04 Jan 1960 11 Feb
1984/VM
(MV)
NA 11 Feb
1984
Promoted
MCM on
01/10/04
VDW
EME
TCS HS 199 Shri C.
Jagasirpian
23 Aug
1961
12 May
1984/B/
Smith
NA 12 May
1984
VDW
EME
VM( MV) 204 VM
(MV) Shri S.
Arunachalam
01 Apr
1946
01 Aug
1989/VM
(MV)
NA 01 Aug
1989
Ex-Servicemen
VDW
EME
VM (MV) 203 Shri N.
Pandian
22 Nov
1960
04 Feb
1984/
Messenger
01 May
1989
29 Jul
1993
VDW
EME
Elect HS 208 Shri K.
Mastan
Saheb
05 Aug
1964
07 Jan
1988/Elec
(MV)
NA 07 Jan
1988
Indl posted
from Eqpt
Depot Wksp
EME Agar
from 01 Aug 03
on
compassionate
grounds.
Promoted
MCM on
01/10/07
13. The grievance of the applicant is that Sri. P. Swaminathan and Sri. S Raja were
already MCM before December 2005 as they were promoted with effect from
01/10/2004. Therefore, the applicant submitted his objections dated 03/12/2012 to
the respondents contending that since HS-I and HS-1I grades had to be bifurcated in
the ratio of 50:50 w.e.f 01/01/2006 as per MoD order dated 14/06/2010, without
calculating and bifurcating the posts into HS-I and HS-II in the revised ratio of 50:50,
and without filling up HS-I vacancy, he could not have been placed in HS-II with
effect from 01/01/2006. It is his case that there were two HS-I vacancies created

10 of 12
against 55% ratio for the period from 01/01/2006 to 14/06/2010 and the same is
th
admitted by the 4 respondent. The Calculation sheet also reflects this position.
These vacancies were created in 2013 with retrospective effect from 01/01/2006
pursuant to MOD order dated 14/06/2010 and there is no bar in filling up resultant
vacancies accrued out of the revised ratio under the scheme of restructuring of cadres.
However, the contention of the respondents is that the restructuring scheme has been
correctly implemented and the vacancies have been filled up based on the calculation
of vacancies and recommendation of the DPC Board. The applicant has already been
promoted to the post of HS-II w.e.f. 01/01/2006 under restructuring of artisan staff
and there is no provision to grant two promotions at one go.

14. It is to be noted that the applicant was placed in HS-II w.e.f. 01/01/2006
pursuant to the restructuring order dated 14/06/2010 and the same cannot be termed
as promotion. The Co-ordinate Benches of this Tribunal at Ernakulam, Kolkata,
Gauhati and Bengaluru have already considered various aspects arising out of the
cadre restructuring pursuant to the Ministry of Defence order dated 14/06/2010 and
have held that such placement cannot be termed as promotion.
15. It is observed that in OA No.395/2023, in similar circumstances as this case,
the Co-ordinate Bench of this Tribunal at Bengaluru has held as under: -

11 of 12
“(ii) Clearly, as we have discussed above, the said circular of
14.6.2010 in No.11(5)2009-D(Civ.I) with subject ‘Restructuring of
grade of Artisan Staff in Defence Establishments in modification of
th
recommendations of 6 CPC’ envisaged promotion only from Pay
Band I to Pay Band II, i.e., in para 4(i) meaning the post of Master
Craftsman shall be part of the hierarchy and the placement of Highly
Skilled Grade I in the grade of Master Craftsman will be treated as
promotion. All other three grades which were in Pay Band I were not
treated as promotion but it was considered merely restructuring and
placement. Hence by the order dated 19.2.2013 vide which the
applicant was placed in Highly Skilled Grade I mentioning it as
promotion from 29.5.2009 in the Grade Pay of Rs.2800/- was
essentially a placement in that Grade and was not a Promotion as
mentioned in the said order."
16. Therefore, it is clear that the placement of applicant in the grade of HS-II could
not have been considered as a promotion but it was merely a placement. Therefore,
the stand of the respondents that there is no provision to grant two promotions at one
go does not hold any water. It is also stated by the respondents that since the
promotion to the post of HS-I was created by SRO 54 wef 21/08/2014, it was to be
effected on the date of implementation of SRO 54 and conduct of DPC board
thereafter and therefore applicant was correctly placed as VM (MV) HS-I w.e.f.
22/06/2015. In the speaking order dated 18/07/2022 also, it is stated by the
respondents that the applicant was promoted to the post of VM (MV) HS-I only on
22/06/2015 as per SRO 54 dated 21/08/2014, on occurrence of vacancy and after he
qualified the trade test. This stand is also contrary to the circular dated 14/06/2010

12 of 12
and the decision of CAT Bangalore that the circular dated 14/06/2010 envisaged
promotion only from Pay Band I to Pay Band II, i.e., placement of Highly Skilled
Grade I in the grade of Master Craftsman, and all other three grades which were in
Pay Band I were not treated as promotion, but merely as restructuring and placement.

17. Thus, in the facts and circumstances as stated above, we are of the view that
the respondents failed to consider the Circular dated 14/06/2010 on ‘Restructuring of
grade of Artisan Staff in Defence Establishments in modification of recommendations
th
of 6 CPC’ in its correct perspective. It is further observed that the speaking order
dated 18/07/2022 was issued by 4th respondent prior to the order dated 05/12/2024
passed by CAT Bengaluru in OA 395/2023.
th
18. In view of the above, the impugned order dated 18/07/2022 passed by the 4
respondent is hereby quashed and set aside. The respondents are directed reconsider
the case of the applicant in the light of the order dated 05/12/2024 passed by the
Coordinate Bench of this Tribunal at Bengaluru in OA 395/2023 and pass appropriate
order thereon within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of
this order. The OA is disposed of accordingly with no order as to costs.
(M.L. Srivastava) (Veena Kothavale)
Member(A) Member(J)
02.11.2026
asvs
Digitally signed by
ASAPU SRINIVASA
VIDYASAGAR
Date: 2026.11.20
16:40:32 +05'30'
A.S.V. Sagar
P.S., CAT,
Chennai Bench.