Munovar Hussain Khan vs State Of Maharashtra

Court
Bombay High Court

CNR No : HCBM020055602026

Digitally
signed by
RUPALI
RAJESH
WAKODIKAR
Date:
2026.11.21
16:26:07
+0530
W.P. No.2315.2026
RUPALI
RAJESH
WAKODIKAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION

WRIT PETITION NO.2315 OF 2026
Munovar Hussain Khan … Petitioner
Versus
State of Maharashtra And Ors. … Respondents
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO.2515 OF 2026
Ahmar Talat Khan … Petitioner
Versus
State of Maharashtra And Ors. … Respondents
…..
Mr. V. Sridharan, Senior Advocate a/w Adv. Devanshi Sharma,
Trinayani Iyer i/b Sriram Sridharan for the Petitioner.
Mr. Himanshu Takke, A.G.P. for Respondent No.1-State in Writ
Petition No.2315 of 2026.
Mr. Amar Mishra, A.G.P. for Respondent No.1-State in Writ Petition
No.2515 of 2026.
…..
CORAM: M.S. KARNIK &
SANDESH D. PATIL, JJ.
th
DATED : 4 NOVEMBER 2026

JUDGMENT (Per SANDESH D. PATIL, J.)
1. By the present Writ Petition, the Petitioners are challenging the
th
Order dated 17 December, 2025, issued by Respondent No.3
(Exhibit ‘A”) confirming recovery of dues from the Petitioners and the
1/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
nd
recovery letter dated 2 January 2026, which is at Exhibit ‘B’ to the
Petition issued by Respondent No.3.
rd
2. The Petitioners were issued a show cause notice dated 23
March, 2022, for the purpose of recovery of Rs.10,49,56,043/- being
outstanding dues of M/s Prophyla Biologicals Private Limited (‘PBPL’
for short) for the period from FY 2005-06 to FY 2010-11 that the
Company PBPL had failed to discharge its statutory liability on the
grounds that :
(a) the company failed to discharge its statutory tax liability;
(b) recovery from the Company was not possible despite multiple
statutory recovery actions; and
(c) such non-recovery is attributable to gross neglect, misfeasance,
and breach of statutory duty on the part of the Noticee (Petitioner
herein), who was the Director during the relevant period.
The Petitioner in Writ Petition No.2315 of 2026 had earlier preferred
a Writ Petition bearing (L) No.38561 of 2024 before this Court. This
th
Court vide Order dated 20 December, 2024, directed the Deputy
Commissioner of Sales Tax to decide the said show cause notice
strictly in accordance with law.
2/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
3. It is the case of the Petitioners that hearing was given to the
Petitioners pursuant to judgment passed by this Court and ultimately
the show cause notice was decided. It is pursuant to this show cause
notice that the recovery proceedings were initiated by way of the
recovery letter impugned in this Petition, which is at Exhibit ‘B’.
4. The learned Counsel for the Petitioners submitted that the
Petitioners were the Director of M/s Prophyla Biological Private
Limited now renamed as M/s Dr. Ashley Labs Limited, during the
th
period from 1982 to 11 September, 2009. The Petitioner in Writ
Petition No.2515 of 2026, who is the son of the Petitioner in Writ
Petition No.2315 of 2026, was also a Director in the said Company
th
during the period from 2001 to 11 September, 2009. He submitted
nd
that the both the Petitioners on 22 April, 2009 sold their shares to
M/s Universal Medicament Private Limited vide Share Purchase
th
Agreement. On 11 September, 2009, the Petitioners submitted their
resignation letter and resigned from the Company and therefore,
they were not liable for the affairs of the company. He submitted
that, apparently the assessment proceedings under the Maharashtra
Value Added Tax, 2002 (‘MVAT Act’ for short) initiated by
3/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
th
Respondent No.4 on 20 August, 2023, culminated into Assessment
Order. The Petitioners were not, in any way, concerned with the
company and therefore, they had no knowledge of the further
proceedings. He submitted that Respondent No.5 initiated
rd
proceedings on 23 March, 2022, against the Petitioners for non-
payment of the VAT/CST dues and issued show cause notice on the
even date for the purpose of recovery of amount from the Petitioners.
The Petitioners have received a demand notice in Form-I under
Section 267 of the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966 and in a
notice under section 74(2) of the MVAT Act for not paying the dues.
The Petitioners have filed a detailed reply against the show cause
notice, refuting all the allegations made therein. The Respondent
th
No.3 issued bank attachment on 5 November, 2024 in Form-318 to
the Manager of the Axis Bank and the accounts of the Petitioners
were freezed. Being aggrieved by the coercive action of the
Respondents, the Petitioners filed Writ Petition (L) No.38561 of
2024, in which petition this Court directed the Respondents vide
th
Order dated 18 December, 2024 to dispose the show cause notice
rd
dated 23 March, 2022, in accordance with law. The Petitioners have
nd
filed detailed written submissions on 22 January, 2025. Without
4/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
considering the submissions made by the Petitioners vide replies
th nd
dated 27 April, 2022 and 22 January 2025, the Respondent No.3
th
passed the Order on 17 December, 2025. Hence, the present
proceedings were initiated. He submitted that Section 18 of the
Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 (“CST” for short) is not invocable in the
present case as the company is not wound up. Therefore, recovery of
dues of the company from the Petitioners under Section 18 of the
Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 is illegal. He further submitted that the
Company has not been wound up. He submitted that as per the
website of Ministry of Corporate Affairs (‘MCA’ for short), the status
of the company is "Active". He further submitted that recovery of CST
dues amounting to Rs.6,76,45,662/- confirmed by the Respondents is
contrary to Section 18 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, without
th
jurisdiction and patently illegal. The Impugned Order dated 17
December, 2025 is liable to be set aside on this ground itself.
nd
Accordingly, the Recovery Letter dated 2 January, 2026 is also liable
to be quashed on this ground itself.
5. As far as Section 44(6) of the MVAT Act is concerned, he
submitted that the conditions therein are not fulfilled in the present
5/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
case. He submitted that to invoke recovery of dues from directors of
a company, the following conditions must be satisfied:
i. The dues recoverable from a private company, whether existing
or wound up cannot be recovered from the company.
ii. There is gross neglect, misfeasance or breach of duty by the
director of the private company during the relevant period.
iii. The non-recovery of dues of the company is attributable to
such gross neglect, misfeasance or breach of duty by the
director.
6. He placed reliance on the judgment in the matter of Mukesh
Ramani v. State of Maharashtra and Others [Writ Petition (L)
No.2121 of 2022, Prakash B. Kamat v. Principal Commissioner of
Income Tax and Others (2023) 457 ITR 150] and the judgment in
the matter of Indubhai T. Vasa v. Income Tax Officer, Ward 4(3)
(2006) 282 ITR 120 (Guj), Amit Suresh Bhatnagar v. Income Tax
Officer (2009) 308 ITR 113 (Guj), Arun Kapoor v. Assistant Collector
and Another 1998 (9) TMI 647 Punjab and Haryana High Court in
support of his case. He submitted that there are no findings on
merits, and accordingly, provisions of Section 44(6) cannot be
6/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
invoked. He submitted that there cannot be the recovery of dues of
company against the Petitioners post-resignation for the assessment
th
period 2010-11. He submitted that the impugned Order dated 17
December, 2025 was passed after 10 months of conclusion of
personal hearing which is fatal to the impugned Order.
7. He submitted that the impugned Order be quashed and set
aside and the Petition be allowed.
8. Learned A.G.P. for the State-Revenue Mr. Himanshu Takke,
supported the impugned Order. He submitted that the Petition is not
maintainable. The Petitioners were directors in M/s Prophyla
Biologicals Pvt. Ltd, and were actively involved in the management
and day to day affairs of the company. He submitted that the
statutory liabilities in question pertain entirely to the period when
the Petitioner was admittedly a Managing Director and responsible
for statutory compliance of the company. He submitted that as per
nd
Agreement dated 22 April, 2009 which is at ‘Exhibit C’ on page 120
of the Petition, the Petitioner and another have executed an
unregistered Share Purchase Agreement in favor of M/s. Universal
7/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
Medicament Pvt. Ltd. for transfer of their shareholding. The said
agreement specifically recorded, under its indemnity clauses at 5.1
and 5.2, that the sellers (including the Petitioner) were in effective
control and management of PBPL and undertook responsibility to
indemnify the purchaser against statutory liabilities arising out of
misfeasance or gross neglect during their tenure including the sales
tax liability for the relevant period. Subsequently, by a Deed of
th
Assignment dated 29 October, 2009, the business of PBPL company
was assigned to M/s. Aanjaneya Biotech Pvt. Ltd., with a private
indemnity clause governing inter se liabilities between the parties.
9. He further submitted that although the Petitioners claim that
they have resigned from the PBPL Company, the Petitioners failed to
produce a Board Resolution accepting their resignation or
documentation evidencing a lawful cessation of responsibilities and
also on the ground that Section 44(6) of MVAT Act provides that a
Director's statutory liability remains attached for all dues incurred
during their tenure. He invited our attention to the impugned Order
in detail and tried to justify the same. He submitted that the
impugned Order is neither arbitrary nor without jurisdiction, but a
8/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
reasoned and speaking Order passed in due compliance of the Order
th
dated 20 December, 2024, passed by this Court in earlier Writ
Petition. He submitted that the liability has been lawfully fastened
th
upon the Company vide Order dated 17 December, 2025, hence, the
same cannot be interfered with, at this stage in this Petition. He
submitted that the Petitioner was a Managing Director of PBPL
during the assessment periods FY 2006-07 to FY 2010-11, which are
the periods for which substantial statutory dues have arisen. The
existence of other directors on the Board does not dilute or
extinguish the Petitioners’ joint and several liability under the statute,
particularly when the non-recovery of dues from the Company has
been found to be attributable to gross neglect, misfeasance and
breach of statutory duty on the part of the Directors, including the
Petitioners. He submitted that under Section 44(6) of the MVAT Act,
2002, liability is joint and several, and the Department is not
required to establish that a particular director was the sole or
dominant decision-maker. Once it is shown that the person was a
Director during the relevant period and that the statutory dues could
not be recovered from the Company, the burden squarely lies on such
Director to prove absence of gross neglect or breach of duty.
9/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
10. He further invited our attention to the Affidavit-in-reply filed
by Respondent Nos.2 to 4 and submitted that the Petition be
dismissed.
11. We have heard the learned Counsel appearing for the parties.
We have perused the documents on record. Before adverting to the
facts of the matter, the relevant provisions of law with which we are
concerned in this matter are Section 18 of the CST Act, 1956 and
Section 44(6) of MVAT Act.
th
12. The Petitioners claim to have resigned on 11 September, 2009
from the Company. The Petitioners, however, do not deny that they
were the Directors of the Company prior to date of resignation, i.e.
th
11 September, 2009. The Petitioners have not challenged the Order
th
of assessment. It is also relevant to note that on 9 September, 2010,
Form-18 was filed by the Company for change of its registered
address from 157, Modi Street, Fort, Mumbai-400 001 to W 91-92-
st
93, MIDC Taloja, District Raigad- 410 208 with effect from 01
th
March, 2010 and further on 4 June, 2011, the name of the company
th
was changed to ‘M/s Dr. Ashley Labs Private Limited’. On 8
10/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
September, 2011, M/s Dr. Ashley Labs Private Limited was further
converted into a limited company and renamed as 'M/s Dr. Ashley
Labs Limited'. As per the MCA, the status of the Company is "Active"
as of today. In other words, Dr. Ashley Labs Limited is an existing
company as on the date of filing of the present Petition, and has not
th
been struck off from the register of MCA. On 28 August, 2013, the
assessment proceedings under MVAT Act were initiated by the
Respondent No.4 for the period 2006-07. The VAT and CST
Department passed ex-parte Orders against the Company for the
period from 2006-07 to 2010-11 amounting to Rs.10,49,56,043/-.
13. Thereafter, from 2015 to 2022, i.e. for 7 years, no further
intimation was received by the Petitioners and to the best of the
Petitioners’ knowledge, Sales Tax Department took up the
proceedings with the Company.
rd
14. On 23 March, 2022, proceedings were initiated against the
Petitioners for non-payment of VAT / CST dues by the Respondent
No.5. The same eventually culminated into issuance of Show Cause
rd
Notice dated 23 March, 2022 vide which it was proposed to recover
Rs.10,49,56,043/- from the Petitioners for the A.Y. 2005-06 to 2010-
11/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
11 under Section 44(6) of MVAT Act. Parallelly, the Petitioners
received Demand Notice in Form-1 under Section 267 of the
Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966 for recovery of Sales Tax
dues of Rs.10,49,56,043/-. The Petitioners further received a Notice
under Section 74(2) of Maharashtra Value Added Tax Act, 2002 for
not paying dues of Rs.10,49,56,043/- for the AY 2005-06 to 2010-11
and was required to Show Cause as to why prosecution action should
th
not be initiated against the Petitioners. The Petitioners on 27 April,
2022 filed a detailed reply against the Show Cause Notice refuting all
the allegations made. After the Respondent No.3 issued a bank
th
attachment letter dated 5 November, 2024, to the Manager of Axis
Bank where the Petitioners had a bank account, to freeze the bank
account of the Petitioners, the Petitioners had filed Writ Petition (L)
No.38561 of 2024 before this Court. The notices of bank attachment
were quashed by this Court and the Respondents were directed to
rd
dispose of the Show Cause Notice dated 23 March, 2022 in
accordance with law. The Petitioners had filed detailed written
submissions, and ultimately, by the impugned Order the recovery of
Rs.10,49,56,043/- was confirmed. Hence, the present Writ Petitions
are filed.
12/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
th
15. The impugned Order dated 17 December, 2025 has confirmed
the recovery of dues amounting to Rs.10,49,56,043/- of the
Company under Section 44(6) of the MVAT Act and Section 18 of the
CST Act.
16. Section 18 of the CST Act reads as under :-
“ 18. Liability of directors of private company in liquidation-
Notwithstanding anything contained in the Companies Act, 1956
(1 of 1956), when any private Company is wound up after the
commencement of this Act, and any tax assessed on the
company under this Act for any period, whether before or in the
course of or after its liquidation, cannot be recovered, then,
every person who was a director of the private company at any
time during the period for which the tax is due shall be jointly
and severally liable for the payment of such tax unless he proves
that the non-recovery cannot be attributed to any gross neglect,
misfeasance or breach of duty on his part in relation to the
affairs of the company. ”
17. We have gone through document at Exhibit 'I' which is the
screenshot of the official website of MCA, shows the status of the
Company as “Active”. On perusal of Section 18 of the CST Act, it is
clear that when a company has been 'wound up' after the
commencement of the Act and any tax assessed on the company
13/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
under the CST Act for any period, whether before or in the course of,
or after its liquidation cannot be recovered, then every person who
was the Director of the company, at any time during the period for
which tax was due shall be jointly and severally liable for the
payment of such tax unless he proves that the non-recovery cannot
be attributed to any gross neglect, misfeasance or breach of duty on
his part in relation to the affairs of the company. In other words,
Section 18 of the CST Act only bestows powers upon the
Respondents to attempt to recover the CST dues of the Company
from the Director after the private company is wound up.
18. The impugned Notice is issued under Section 44(6) of MVAT
Act. Section 44(6) of the MVAT Act reads as under :-
“44. Special provision regarding liability to pay tax in
certain cases:-
…...
(6) Subject to the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013,
where any tax or other amount recoverable under this Act
from a private company, whether existing or wound up or
under liquidation, for any period, cannot be recovered, for
any reason whatsoever, then, every person who was a
director of the private company during such period shall be
jointly and severally liable for the payment of such tax or
other amount unless, he proves that the non-recovery
cannot be attributed to any gross neglect, misfeasance or
breach of duty on his part in relation to the affairs of the
said company."
14/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
(Emphasis Supplied)
Thus, in order to invoke recovery of dues from directors of a
company, the following conditions must be satisfied:
(i) The dues recoverable from a private company, whether
existing or wound up cannot be recovered from the
company
(ii) There is gross neglect, misfeasance or breach of duty by the
director of the private company during the relevant period
(iii) The non-recovery of dues of the company is attributable to
such gross neglect, misfeasance or breach of duty by the
director.
19. We have gone through the impugned Order, which is at Exhibit
'A' to the Petition. It appears that the Petitioners had filed a
rd
voluminous reply to the Show Cause Notice dated 23 March 2022
issued to the Petitioners under Section 44(6) of MVAT Act and
Section 18 of the CST Act. The submissions in reply to the the Show
Cause Notice are voluminous. In addition to that the Petitioners had
also submitted detailed submissions before the Deputy Commissioner
of Sales Tax, who was adjudicating the matter.
15/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
20. The Petitioners had relied upon the judgment of Satish D.
Sanghvi v. Union of India & Ors. [(2012) 14 GSTR 264 (Bom.)]
wherein it was held as follows:
"3. The settled position in law is that liability for duty of the
company cannot be fastened upon the director of a company
unless there is a statutory provision to that effect. Such an issue
came up for consideration before this court in the matter of of
Sunil Parmeshwar Mittal Versus Dy. C.(Recovery Cell), C.EX,
Mumbai, wherein the court took a view that liability of members
is limited to the extent of face value of shares subscribed by each
member and amount remaining unpaid on them for time being,
former director of the company cannot be held responsible for
payment of liabilities of company in the absence of any specific
provision. This was reiterated in unreported judgment delivered
on 5.5.2009 in the case of Chandrakant Bhalchandra Garware
Versus Union of India & Ors. In writ petition no.4117 of 2009.
We are of the opinion that duty demand of the company cannot
be recovered from the director in the absence of statutory
provisions in the Central Excise Act, 1944.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
The said judgment was relied upon by the Petitioners to buttress the
contention that duty demand of the Company cannot be recovered
from the directors in absence of statutory provisions in the CST Act.
21. The Petitioners also relied upon the judgment of Narinder
Singh v. Union of India [2019 367 ELT 775 (P&H)] wherein it was
held as follows:
"5. It is well-settled that in the absence of any specific provision
in the statute, the duty/penalty liability of the company cannot
be recovered from the assets of its Director. The Director is not
16/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
personally liable towards liability of the company. This Court
while delving into an identical issue in Subhash Goyal v. State of
Haryana and Others, 2014 (4) PLR 343 held that in the absence
of taking any specific recourse to proceedings under Section 18
of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 and any valid order for
effecting recovery of arrears of sales tax from the directors of a
private limited company in liquidation, the proceedings relating
to recovery of arrears of tax from the Noticee being a director
were not permissible in law.
…
7. In view of the above, the action of the respondents in
compelling the Noticee to clear the dues of the company cannot
be sustained. The petition is allowed. However, the respondents
shall be at liberty to proceed against the company for clearance
of its dues in accordance with law."
(Emphasis Supplied)
22. As far as arguments on the liability under Section 44(6) of
MVAT Act are concerned, the Petitioners had relied upon the
judgment of Indubhai T. Vasa v. Income Tax Officer, Ward (2006) 282
ITR 120 (Guj.). The relevant portion of the judgment is produced
herewith for ready reference:
"11. In these circumstances, it is not possible to accept the stand
of the respondent that despite best efforts the taxes due from the
company cannot be recovered. As laid down by this court the
phrase "cannot be recovered" requires the Revenue to establish
that such recovery cannot be made against the company and
then and then alone would it be permissible for the Revenue to
initiate action against the director or directors responsible for
conducting the affairs of the company during the relevant
accounting period. Hence, the prerequisite condition stipulated
by section 179 of the Act remains unfulfilled in the context of
the facts available on record by virtue of the impugned order as
well as the affidavit-in-reply.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
17/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
23. The Petitioners also relied upon the judgment of Amit Suresh
Bhatnagar v. Income Tax Officer (2009) 308 ITR 113 (Guj.). The
relevant portion of the judgment is produced herewith for ready
reference:
"6. Having heard the learned advocates for the parties, it is
apparent that the controversy raised in the petitions stands
concluded by judgment of this Court. The record reveals that
except for accepting the amount paid by the Company from time
to time, respondent-authority has not taken any steps to effect
recovery from the Company. This High Court in the case of
Indubhai T. Vasa (HUF) v. Income-Tax Officer (2006) 282 ITR
120 has stated that the phrase "cannot be recovered" requires
the Revenue to establish that such recovery could not be made
against the Company and then and then alone would it be
permissible for the Revenue to initiate action against the
Director or Directors responsible for conducting the affairs of the
Company during the relevant accounting period.
7. Thus in effect, before action under Section 179 of the Act can
be initiated against the Director or Directors of a private
Company, Revenue has to first of all show that such a Director or
Directors were responsible for the conduct of the business
during the previous year in relation to which the liability exists.
Revenue has also to establish that it has taken effective steps to
recover the outstanding dues from the Company and has not
been able to recover the entire outstanding liability. Applying the
aforesaid ratio to the facts of the case, it is apparent that except
for calling upon the Company and/or the Noticees-Directors to
discharge the liability, Revenue has taken no effective steps to
effect recovery of outstanding dues from the Company. In the
circumstances, the impugned order dated 19-8-2008 made in
case of each of the three Noticees, cannot be permitted to
operate. Order dated 19-8-2008 made under Section 179 of the
Act is, therefore, quashed and set aside."
18/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
24. The Petitioners have also relied upon the judgment of the
Punjab & Haryana High Court, in the case of Arun Kapoor v. Assistant
Collector and Another 1998 (9) TMI 647 - Punjab and Haryana High
Court, which held that liability of Directors would arise if the amount
of tax assessed on the company under the CST Act cannot be
recovered. Section 18 of CST Act is pari materia to Section 44(6) of
MVAT Act. The relevant portion of the judgment is produced
herewith for ready reference:
“7. There is no dispute amount the Noticees’ assertion that they
were directors of the company. Under section 18 of the Central
Sales Tax Act, 1956, when any private company is wound up
and any tax assessed on the company under the said Act cannot
be recovered, then every person, who was a director of the
private company at any time during the period on which tax is
due, shall be jointly and severally liable for the payment of tax
unless he proved that the nonrecovery cannot be attributed to
any gross negligence, misfeasance or prejudice of duty on his
part. In the case in hand, it is not shown by the Respondents as
to what is the amount of tax assessed on the company under the
Central Sales Tax Act. It is also not shown as to what efforts
were made to recover the arrears of tax from the assets of the
company. Liability of the directors would arise if the amount of
tax was assessed on the company under the Central Sales Tax
Act and it cannot be recovered from the company. Since the
respondents have shown neither the amount of tax recoverable
under the Central Sales Tax Act nor they have brought any
material on record to establish that the amount of tax cannot be
recovered from the company, the proceeding relating to recovery
of arrears of tax from the Noticees are held to be not permissible
in law."
(Emphasis Supplied)
19/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
25. The Petitioners have also relied upon various other judgments.
None of them were considered by the adjudicating authority while
passing of the impugned Order. The submissions which are made by
the Petitioners are annexed at Page No.319 to the present Petition.
We have gone through them. We have also gone through the various
judgments which are referred in the said written submissions. The
Petitioners have also advanced voluminous submissions on facts as
well as on law. This Court in the matter of Mukesh Ramani v. State
of Maharashtra and Others [(2024) 125 GSTR 464 (Bom.)] has held
as under :-
"23. This provision, i.e., Section 18 of the CST Act which is
analogous to Section 89 of the MGST Act in fact provides for
vicarious liability of the Directors of the Company for payment
of tax dues which cannot be recovered from the company. Such
liability could be avoided if the Director proves that non-
recovery cannot be attributed to any gross neglect, misfeasance
or breach of the duty on his part in relation to the affairs of the
company. Of course, responsibility of establishing such facts is
cast upon the Directors. Once the Director places before the
authority his reasons why it should be held that non-recovery
cannot be attributed to any of the three factors, the authority
would have to examine such grounds and come to a conclusion
in this respect. As long as the Director establishes that non-
recovery of the tax cannot be attributed to his gross neglect or
misfeasance or breach of his duty in addition to the affairs of the
company, his liability under Section 18 of the CST Act or Section
89 of the MGST Act would not arise. We have to note that the
legislature at the same time used the words gross neglect and
not mere neglect on his part. We find support for this view in the
judgment of the Gujarat High Court in Maganbhai Hansrajbhai
Patel vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax & 1, relied upon
20/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
by Mr. Sridharan, where the High Court has dealt with
provisions of Section 179 of the Income Tax Act. Section 179 is
pari-materia to Section 18 of the CST Act and Section 89 of the
MGST Act.....
24. We also find support for our view in another judgment of
Gujarat High Court, in Ram Prakash Singeshwar Rungta vs.
Income Tax Officer (2015) 59 taxmann.com 174 (Gujarat) relied
upon by Mr. Sridharan……”
(Emphasis Supplied)
26. There is no discussion on the decisions relied upon which were
submitted for consideration before the Respondents-Authorities. It is
not even alleged by the Respondents that the Directors were holding
active control over the affairs of the Company inspite of their
th
resignation on 11 September, 2009. The Legislature, in its wisdom,
has used the words ‘gross neglect’ as opposed to ‘neglect’ on the part
of the Directors for the purpose of invoking Section 44(6) of MVAT
Act. Although it is true that the burden is cast upon the Directors,
however, there has to be some foundational basis, which the
department must incorporate in the notice that the Petitioners were
Directors of the Company on the relevant date and they were in
active control of the affairs. Given the stand of the Petitioners that
they had sold their shares to M/s Universal Medicament Private
nd
Limited vide Share Purchase Agreement dated 22 April, 2009, and
further taking into consideration their stand that, the Petitioners
21/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
th
submitted the resignation and resigned from the Company on 11
September, 2009, it was for the Respondents to be satisfied that
inspite of the fact that the Petitioners had resigned, they were in
control of the affairs even after the resignation was given.
27. The impugned Order miserably fails to consider the
submissions made by the Petitioners. None of the arguments of the
Petitioners were dealt with. None of the documents relied upon by
the Petitioners are considered to illustrate a finding at clause (b)
th
regarding the resignation dated 11 September, 2009, and filing of
Form-32 is concerned. The finding only records what was mentioned
in the Show Cause notice. There were several submissions made by
the Petitioners on this point. Not only that, the Petitioners had even
annexed the copies of the resignation letters and relevant extracts
from the website of the Ministry of Corporate Affairs. None of them
were considered. All that was expected was that there should be
consideration of submissions made by the Petitioners on law and
facts while adjudicating the Show Cause Notice.
28. In this case, the heading of every submission is recorded,
without recording the detailed submissions on the said heading, and
22/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
finding is rendered without discussing the case of the Petitioners
under that heading. In the result, we have no hesitation in quashing
th
and setting aside the impugned Order dated 17 December, 2025
passed by the Respondent No.3 annexed at Exhibit 'A' to the Petition.
We, however, make it clear that we have not gone into the issue of
delay which is raised by the Petitioners and other contentions raised
by the Petitioners in this Petition. Hence, the following Order :-
: O R D E R :
th
(i) The impugned Order dated 17 December, 2025, passed by
Respondent No.3, annexed at Exhibit 'A' to the Petition, is
quashed and set aside.
nd
(ii) As a consequence of the same, the recovery letter dated 2
January, 2026, issued by Respondent No.3 annexed at
Exhibit 'B' to the Petition, is quashed and set aside.
(iii) Respondent No.3 is directed to adjudicate the Show Cause
rd
Notice dated 23 March, 2022, issued under Section 44(6)
of the MVAT Act, 2002 and Section 18 of CST Act, 1956
after considering in detail the submissions made by the
Petitioners as well as after dealing with the same and giving
reasons.
23/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44

W.P. No.2315.2026
(iv) This exercise be carried out within a period of 12 weeks
from the date of communication of this Order.
(v) All the contentions of all the parties are kept open.
(vi) The Petitions are disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
(SANDESH D. PATIL, J.) (M.S. KARNIK, J.)
24/24
RaJesh Chittewan, PS
Uploaded on - 21/11/2026 Downloaded on - 21/11/2026 16:32:44
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)