J Mukund vs Union Of India

Court
Madhya Pradesh High Court

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
1 MCRC-14443-2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR

BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE HIMANSHU JOSHI
th
ON THE 18 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
MISC. CRIMINAL CASE No. 14443 of 2026
CNR No.: MPHC010216402026
S.P. CHOUDHARY
Versus
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Anirban Roy, Shri Bhavesh Parmar and Shri Rajeev Mishra -Advocates for
the petitioner
Shri Suyash Mohan Guru - Deputy Solicitor General with Shri Sanjay Kumar Patel
- Advocate for respondent No.1/UOI.
Shri Neelesh Yadav - Additional Advocate General with Shri Sharad Sharma -
G.A. for the respondent No.2/State.
Shri Vikram Singh - Advocate for the respondent No.3/ C.B.I.
WITH
MISC. CRIMINAL CASE No. 14613 of 2026
CNR No.: MPHC010218752026
J MUKUND
Versus
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Anirban Roy, Shri Bhavesh Parmar and Shri Rajeev Mishra -Advocates for
the petitioner.
Shri Suyash Mohan Guru - Deputy Solicitor General with Shri Sanjay Kumar Patel
- Advocate for respondent No.1/UOI.
Shri Neelesh Yadav - Additional Advocate General with Shri Sharad Sharma -
G.A. for the respondent No.2/State.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
2 MCRC-14443-2026
Shri Vikram Singh - Advocate for the respondent No.3/ C.B.I.

MISC. CRIMINAL CASE No. 14621 of 2026
CNR No.: MPHC010218822026
KISHOR S KAMDAR
Versus
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Anshuman Singh - Advocate with Shri Rajeev Mishra - Advocate for the
petitioner.
Shri Suyash Mohan Guru - Deputy Solicitor General with Shri Sanjay Kumar Patel
- Advocate for respondent No.1/UOI.
Shri Neelesh Yadav - Additional Advocate General with Shri Sharad Sharma -
G.A. for the respondent No.2/State.
Shri Vikram Singh - Advocate for the respondent No.3/ C.B.I.
ORDER
Heard On - 30.10.2026
Pronounced On - 18.11.2026
Since all three petitions arise out of the same common order dated
28.11.2025 passed by the Sessions Court, Bhopal, involve identical questions
of law and substantially similar facts and reliefs, they are being heard
together and decided by this common order. The decision in this order shall
govern all three petitions.
2. The present petitions under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 have been preferred by the petitioners seeking quashment of
the order dated 28.11.2025 passed by the learned Sessions Court, Bhopal,
whereby the application preferred by the petitioner under Section 464 of
Cr.P.C. in pending Criminal Appeal No. 364-366/2010 were disposed of,
holding that such an application is required to be heard and decided along
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
3 MCRC-14443-2026
with the final hearing of the criminal appeal and cannot be adjudicated

independently before commencement of hearing of the appeal. The
petitioners have, therefore, sought a direction to the appellate Court to decide
his applications under Section 464 Cr.P.C. on merits before proceeding with
the final hearing of the criminal appeals.
3. The facts giving rise to the present petition are that the petitioners
are one of the accused persons in the criminal case arising out of the Bhopal
Gas Tragedy of December 1984. The prosecution was initiated in connection
with the escape of Methyl Isocyanate (MIC) gas from the plant of Union
Carbide India Limited at Bhopal. Initially, charges were framed against the
petitioners and other accused persons under Section 304(II) of the IPC.
However, pursuant to the order dated 13.09.1996 passed by the Supreme
Court, the matter was remitted for proceeding in accordance with the
observations made therein, and subsequently, charges under Section 304-A
of the IPC came to be framed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Bhopal, on 29.08.1997.
4. After conclusion of the trial, during which the prosecution examined
178 witnesses and exhibited approximately 3000 documents, the petitioner
and other accused persons were convicted by judgment dated 07.06.2010
passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bhopal. Aggrieved thereby,
the petitioners preferred Criminal Appeal No. 364-366/2010 before the
Sessions Court, Bhopal, which are still pending consideration.
5. During pendency of the aforesaid appeals, the petitioners, preferred
an application under Section 464 Cr.P.C. on 25.04.2022, alleging that the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
4 MCRC-14443-2026
charges framed against them were fundamentally defective, vague and

general in nature and that the omission and irregularities in framing of
charges had resulted in failure of justice and prejudice to their defence. The
applications were opposed by the CBI and other parties permitted to assist
the prosecution.
6. After successive changes of the Presiding Officers of the Sessions
Court, the applications under Section 464 Cr.P.C. were heard in different
phases and ultimately, by the impugned order dated 28.11.2025, the learned
Sessions Court declined to decide the application independently on merits
and held that the question relating to omission or irregularity in framing of
charge under Section 464 Cr.P.C. was required to be considered along with
the final hearing of the criminal appeal. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid
order, the petitioners have approached this Court by way of the present
petitions.
7. Learned counsels for the petitioner submit that the impugned order
is contrary to the express language of Section 464 Cr.P.C., as the provision
does not prescribe any restriction regarding the stage at which an application
thereunder can be heard and decided. It is contended that there is no statutory
mandate requiring such an application to be necessarily adjudicated along
with the final hearing of the criminal appeal, and the appellate Court is
competent to decide the same independently, as and when it is filed.
8. It is further submitted that the application under Section 464 Cr.P.C.
raises issues which are preliminary in nature and fundamentally distinct from
the issues involved in adjudication of the criminal appeal. The consideration
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
5 MCRC-14443-2026
under Section 464 Cr.P.C. essentially involves examining whether there was

any omission, error or irregularity in framing of charges and whether the
same resulted in failure of justice. If such failure is established, the appellate
Court may take appropriate remedial measures, including directing retrial or
quashing the proceedings, as contemplated under the provision. Therefore,
insisting upon simultaneous consideration of the application and the criminal
appeal would serve no useful purpose and may result in unnecessary wastage
of judicial time.
9. Learned counsels further submit that, in the present case, the
charges framed against the accused persons were vague and general and did
not disclose specific allegations or the precise acts attributable to each
accused. According to the petitioner, there were two categories of defects,
described as 'Macro Error' and 'Micro Error'. The former related to the very
framing of charges despite absence of material warranting the same, whereas
the latter related to the failure to frame specific and precise charges in
accordance with law and the directions issued by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in its judgment dated 13.09.1996. It is argued that such defects impaired the
defence of the accused and resulted in failure of justice, as the trial Court
proceeded to consider irrelevant and extraneous issues while recording
conviction.
10. It is also submitted that the petitioner and his co-accused had
undertaken an independent enquiry into the incident and prepared an enquiry
report concerning the actual cause of the escape of MIC gas. The petitioner
intends to rely upon the said report as additional evidence. Therefore, the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
6 MCRC-14443-2026
outcome of the application under Section 464 Cr.P.C. would have a direct

bearing on the course of further proceedings, particularly whether the
petitioner would be required to produce such material in a retrial or by
invoking Section 391 Cr.P.C. for adducing additional evidence in the
pending appeal.
11. Learned counsel further submits that the application had already
undergone extensive hearings before different Presiding Officers of the
Sessions Court and that the arguments had been concluded after 36 days of
hearing. If the application is deferred for consideration along with the final
hearing of the appeal, there would be a possibility of the entire exercise
having to be undertaken afresh in the event of transfer, elevation or
retirement of the Presiding Officer. Such a course would result in avoidable
wastage of judicial time and cause prejudice to the petitioner. Placing
reliance upon the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Asim alias
Munmun alias Asif Abdulkarim Solanki v. State of Gujarat, Criminal Appeal
No.184/2020, decided on 28.01.2020, concerning an application under
Section 391 Cr.P.C., learned counsel submits that the Hon'ble Supreme Court
has held that the provision does not impose any restriction as to the stage at
which such an application may be heard and that it is desirable to decide the
same immediately after its filing. According to the petitioner, the same
principle ought to apply to an application under Section 464 Cr.P.C. as well.
12. It is lastly contended that the learned Sessions Court has
erroneously relied upon the decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Kalicharan and Others v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (2023) 2 SCC 583 and State
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
7 MCRC-14443-2026
of Andhra Pradesh v. Thakkidiram Reddy and Others, (1998) 6 SCC 554, as

well as the decision of the Calcutta High Court in Tapan Hambir v. Kashi
Nath Khamaru and Others {CRR No. 2662 of 2013, dated 31.07.2013}, to
hold that an application under Section 464 Cr.P.C. must necessarily be
decided along with the criminal appeal. According to the petitioner, the
aforesaid decisions merely deal with the consideration of defects in charges
during appellate adjudication and do not lay down any mandatory rule
prohibiting independent consideration of an application under Section 464
Cr.P.C. before final hearing of the appeal.
13. On the aforesaid grounds, learned counsel prays that the impugned
order be set aside and the learned Sessions Court be directed to decide the
application under Section 464 Cr.P.C. on its merits before commencement of
final hearing of the criminal appeal.
14. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the Union of India, CBI
and the State support the impugned order and submit that determination of
failure of justice under Section 464 of Cr.P.C. requires consideration of the
entire trial record, including the evidence, depositions and statements of the
accused recorded under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. It is contended that the
applications have not been rejected on merits but their consideration has
merely been deferred to the final hearing of the appeals, where all relevant
aspects can be examined comprehensively.
15. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
produced before this Court.
16. The principal question which arises for consideration in the present
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
8 MCRC-14443-2026
petition is whether an application invoking Section 464 of the Code of

Criminal Procedure, 1973, preferred during the pendency of a criminal
appeal, is required to be adjudicated independently and before
commencement of the final hearing of the appeal, or whether the appellate
Court can consider the objection relating to omission, error or irregularity in
the charge while deciding the appeal itself.
17. The petitioner has placed considerable emphasis on the fact that
Section 464 Cr.P.C. does not expressly provide that an application
thereunder must necessarily be heard along with the final hearing of the
appeal. It is contended that, in the absence of such a restriction, the appellate
Court is obliged to entertain and decide the application as and when it is
filed. The submission, though attractive at first blush, cannot be accepted in
the broad and absolute terms in which it has been advanced. Before
proceeding further, it would be apposite to reproduce the provisions of
Section 464 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, which read as under:
"464. Effect of omission to frame, or absence of, or error in,
charge.—
(1) No finding, sentence or order by a Court of competent
jurisdiction shall be deemed invalid merely on the ground that no
charge was framed or on the ground of any error, omission or
irregularity in the charge including any misjoinder of charges,
unless, in the opinion of the Court of appeal, confirmation or
revision, a failure of justice has in fact been occasioned thereby.
(2) If the Court of appeal, confirmation or revision is of opinion
that a failure of justice has in fact been occasioned, it may—
(a) in the case of an omission to frame a charge, order that a
charge be framed, and that the trial be recommenced from the
point immediately after the framing of the charge;
(b) in the case of an error, omission or irregularity in the
charge, direct a new trial to be had upon a charge framed in
whatever manner it thinks fit:
Provided that if the Court is of opinion that the facts of the case
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
9 MCRC-14443-2026
are such that no valid charge could be preferred against the
accused in respect of the facts proved, it shall quash the
conviction."

18. On perusal, section 464 Cr.P.C. is intended to prevent a conviction
from being set aside merely on account of an omission to frame a charge or
an error, omission or irregularity in the charge, unless such defect has in fact
occasioned a failure of justice. The provision, therefore, does not treat every
defect in the charge as fatal to the trial. The determinative consideration is
whether the accused was prejudiced and whether such defect resulted in a
failure of justice. The provision further empowers the appellate, revisional or
confirmation Court to adopt appropriate remedial measures where such
failure of justice is found to have occurred.
19. A plain reading of Section 464 Cr.P.C. does not disclose any
statutory requirement that an objection concerning defect in the charge must
invariably be decided through a separate application, independently of the
appeal. Equally, the provision does not confer upon an accused an
indefeasible right to insist that such an application must be decided as a
preliminary issue before the appellate Court proceeds to hear the appeal on
merits. The absence of an express prohibition, by itself, cannot be construed
as creating an affirmative right to a separate and prior adjudication in every
case. The manner and stage at which such an issue is to be considered must
depend upon the nature of the objection, the material required for its
determination and the circumstances of the particular case.
20. The scheme of Section 464 Cr.P.C. also assumes that the question
of prejudice arising from a defect in the charge would ordinarily be
examined by the appellate Court with reference to the evidence and the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
10 MCRC-14443-2026
proceedings of the trial. The Court is not required to set aside the conviction

merely upon noticing an omission or irregularity in the charge. It must
further examine whether the accused was, in fact, prejudiced and whether
such prejudice has resulted in a failure of justice. Thus, the inquiry under
Section 464 is not confined to the formal examination of the charge; it may
necessarily involve consideration of the evidence, the nature of the
prosecution case, the defence taken by the accused and the findings recorded
by the trial Court. These aspects substantially overlap with the matters which
arise for consideration in the criminal appeal.
21. The aforesaid interpretation finds support from the decision of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Andhra Pradesh v. Thakkidiram Reddy,
(1998) 6 SCC 554, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court emphasised that the
controlling consideration under Section 464 Cr.P.C. is whether failure of
justice has actually been occasioned on account of the defect in the charge.
The relevant paras are quoted hereinunder :
"10. Sub-section (1) of Section 464 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure 1973 (“Code” for short) expressly provides that no
finding, sentence or order by a court of competent jurisdiction
shall be deemed invalid merely on the ground that no charge was
framed or on the ground of any error, omission or irregularity in
the charge including any misjoinder of charges, unless in the
opinion of the court of appeal, confirmation or revision, a failure
of justice has in fact (emphasis supplied) been occasioned thereby.
Sub-section (2) of the said section lays down the procedure that
the court of appeal, confirmation or revision has to follow in case
it is of the opinion that a failure of justice has in fact been
occasioned. The other section relevant for our purposes is Section
465 of the Code; and it lays down that no finding, sentence or
order passed by a court of competent jurisdiction shall be reversed
or altered by a court of appeal, confirmation or revision on
account of any error, omission or irregularity in the proceedings,
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
11 MCRC-14443-2026
unless in the opinion of that court, a failure of justice has in fact
been occasioned. It further provides, inter alia, that in determining
whether any error, omission or irregularity in any proceeding
under this Code has occasioned a failure of justice, the Court shall
have regard to the fact whether the objection could and should
have been raised at an earlier stage in the proceedings.

11. This Court in Willie (William) Slaney v. State of M.P. [AIR
1956 SC 116 : (1955) 2 SCR 1140] elaborately discussed the
applicability of Sections 535 and 537 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1898 which correspond respectively to Sections 464
and 465 of the Code, and held that in judging a question of
prejudice, as of guilt, courts must act with a broad vision and look
to the substance and not to technicalities, and their main concern
should be to see whether the accused had a fair trial, whether he
knew what he was being tried for, whether the main facts sought
to be established against him were explained to him fairly and
clearly and whether he was given a full and fair chance to defend
himself. Viewed in the context of the above observations of this
Court, we are unable to hold that the accused persons were in any
way prejudiced due to the errors and omissions in the charges
pointed out by Mr Arunachalam. Apart from the fact that this
point was not agitated in either of the courts below, from the fact
that the material prosecution witnesses (who narrated the entire
incident) were cross-examined at length from all possible angles
and the suggestions that were put forward to the eyewitnesses we
are fully satisfied that the accused persons were not in any way
prejudiced in their defence. While on this point we may also
mention that in their examination under Section 313 of the Code,
the accused persons were specifically told of their having
committed offences (besides others) under Sections 148 and
302/149 IPC. For all these reasons we reject the threshold
contention of Mr Arunachalam."


22. Similarly, in Kamil v. State of Uttar Pradesh, Criminal Appeal
No.1568 of 2015, decided on 31.10.2018, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
reiterated that absence of a charge would not, by itself, vitiate the conviction
unless prejudice resulting in failure of justice is established. These decisions
make it clear that the question under Section 464 is to be determined by
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
12 MCRC-14443-2026
examining the effect of the alleged defect in the context of the entire trial and

the material on record.
23. In Kalicharan and Others v. State of Uttar Pradesh, (2023) 2 SCC
583, the Hon'ble Supreme Court also considered the question of defect in the
charge in the course of appellate scrutiny and examined whether such defect
had occasioned failure of justice. The said decision, read with Thakkidiram
Reddy (supra), undoubtedly recognises the jurisdiction of the appellate Court
to grant appropriate relief under Section 464 Cr.P.C. while dealing with the
criminal appeal. However, it would not be appropriate to read these decisions
as laying down an inflexible rule that an application under Section 464
Cr.P.C. can never be taken up or decided separately. Equally, they do not
recognise an absolute right in the accused to demand its adjudication as a
preliminary issue before the appeal is heard.
24. The petitioners have placed reliance upon the order of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Asim @ Munmun @ Asif Abdulkarim Solanki v. State of
Gujarat, Criminal Appeal No.184 of 2020, decided on 28.01.2020, wherein,
while dealing with an application under Section 391 Cr.P.C., the Hon'ble
Supreme Court observed that such an application should preferably be heard
immediately after it is filed without waiting for final hearing of the appeal.
The said decision, however, was rendered in the context of Section 391
Cr.P.C., which confers a specific power upon the appellate Court to take
additional evidence or direct such evidence to be taken where it considers the
same necessary. The nature of the inquiry under Section 464 Cr.P.C. is
materially different. Under Section 464, the appellate Court is required to
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
13 MCRC-14443-2026
examine not merely the existence of an error or omission in the charge but

also whether such defect has actually occasioned a failure of justice.
Consequently, the principle stated in Asim (supra) cannot, without more, be
applied as a binding rule requiring every application under Section 464
Cr.P.C. to be decided immediately and independently of the appeal.
25. The further submission of the petitioner that, if the application
under Section 464 Cr.P.C. is allowed, the criminal appeal would become
infructuous and the hearing of the appeal on merits would result in wastage
of judicial time, also does not furnish a sufficient ground to recognise a
mandatory right to preliminary adjudication. The possibility of such a
consequence may certainly be a relevant consideration for the appellate
Court while determining the appropriate sequence of hearing. However, the
convenience of the parties or the possibility of avoiding duplication of
proceedings cannot, by itself, determine the scope of the statutory provision.
The appellate Court is competent to regulate its own proceedings and may,
depending upon the nature of the objection and the material necessary for its
determination, decide the issue separately, defer it or consider it along with
the final hearing of the appeal.
26. The petitioners have also sought to distinguish between what has
been described as “Macro Error” and “Micro Error” in the framing of
charges. According to him, the former concerns the very absence of a legally
sustainable basis for framing charges, whereas the latter relates to the alleged
vagueness and generality of the charges framed against him. It is further
contended that the charges ought to have been confined to two specific
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
14 MCRC-14443-2026
aspects relating to the entry of water or contaminants into the MIC tank and

the alleged deficiency in maintaining positive nitrogen pressure. These are,
however, the substantive grounds on which the petitioner seeks relief under
Section 464 Cr.P.C. Their merits cannot be examined in the present
proceedings, which are confined to the legality of the order regulating the
stage at which the said application is to be considered.
27. It is pertinent to observe that even where the accused alleges that
no valid charge could have been framed, the proviso to sub-section (2) of
Section 464 Cr.P.C. requires the appellate Court to form its opinion with
reference to the facts of the case as proved. Therefore, the contention that no
valid charge could have been preferred, as well as the alternative contention
that the charges were vague or defective and resulted in prejudice, would
require consideration of the relevant evidence and the findings recorded by
the trial Court. The petitioner cannot claim that such questions must
necessarily be determined in isolation from the appellate scrutiny of the
judgment of conviction.
28. The fact that the application under Section 464 Cr.P.C. was heard
for 36 days and that the petitioner, as well as the prosecution and the
assisting organizations, had advanced detailed oral and written submissions,
is undoubtedly a circumstance which deserves consideration. The petitioner
has also expressed apprehension that, in the event of transfer or elevation of
the Presiding Officer, the application may have to be reheard, resulting in
further delay. However, these circumstances, though relevant for the purpose
of case management, cannot confer a statutory right which is otherwise not
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
15 MCRC-14443-2026
available under Section 464 Cr.P.C. Nor can the length of hearing, by itself,

compel the appellate Court to pronounce a separate decision if it considers
that the issues raised are intrinsically connected with the grounds of appeal
and can be more appropriately adjudicated upon at the time of its final
hearing.
29. At the same time, it would not be correct to construe Section 464
Cr.P.C. as imposing an absolute embargo upon the appellate Court from
deciding an application invoking the said provision before taking up the
appeal for final hearing. The provision does not prescribe any such
mandatory sequence. There may be cases where the objection is confined to a
specific and demonstrable defect, the material necessary for its determination
is readily available, and its decision at an earlier stage would facilitate the
just and expeditious disposal of the appeal. In such circumstances, the
appellate Court would not be precluded from considering and deciding the
issue separately. The decision in this regard would, however, depend upon
the facts and circumstances of each case and the judicial discretion of the
appellate Court.
30. Thus, the correct legal position is that an application under Section
464 Cr.P.C. is not required, as a matter of statutory mandate, to be decided
independently before the final hearing of the criminal appeal. Equally, there
is no absolute prohibition against its separate adjudication. The appellate
Court is required to exercise its judicial discretion after considering the
nature of the objection, the material necessary for its determination, the
extent to which the issue overlaps with the grounds of appeal and the overall
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
16 MCRC-14443-2026
interests of justice. The applicant cannot insist upon a separate preliminary

adjudication merely because an application under Section 464 Cr.P.C. has
been filed during the pendency of the appeal.
31. While exercising such discretion, the appellate Court may, inter-
alia, take into consideration the following relevant factors:
(i) whether the objection regarding the framing of charges
had been raised at an earlier stage of the proceedings, including
before any superior Court, and, if so, whether the issue was
considered or any directions were issued in that regard;
(ii) whether the objection now raised is substantially a
repetition of the grounds previously urged or raises any distinct
and legally sustainable defect;
(iii) whether determination of the alleged defect can be
undertaken independently on the basis of the charge and the
relevant record, or whether it necessitates an examination of the
evidence adduced during trial and the findings recorded by the trial
Court;
(iv) whether the alleged defect has occasioned, or is likely
to have occasioned, an actual failure of justice, as contemplated
under Section 464 Cr.P.C.;
(v) whether the issue substantially overlaps with the
grounds raised in the criminal appeal and its separate adjudication
would result in duplication of proceedings; and
(vi) whether, having regard to the stage and history of the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
17 MCRC-14443-2026
proceedings, separate adjudication would advance the cause of

justice or would merely lead to fragmentation and delay in the
disposal of the appeal.
32. It is, however, clarified that the mere fact that an objection to the
charge was raised earlier or that the matter had travelled before a superior
Court would not, by itself, render an application under Section 464 Cr.P.C.
non-maintainable. The effect of the earlier proceedings, the nature of the
objection and the relief, if any, granted therein must be duly considered.
Ultimately, the discretion must be exercised judicially, having regard to the
facts and circumstances of each case, and not mechanically or merely on the
basis of the stage at which the application has been filed.
33. In the present case, the application preferred by the petitioner does
not raise an isolated or purely formal objection concerning the description of
the charge. The petitioner has questioned the very basis of the prosecution,
the material relied upon by the trial Court, the findings recorded in the
judgment of conviction and the manner in which the alleged incident
occurred. He has also sought, in the alternative, reconsideration and
reframing of the charges on the basis of his own formulation of the alleged
cause of the incident. These issues are closely interwoven with the grounds
which would arise for consideration in the pending criminal appeal. Their
determination would necessarily require the appellate Court to examine the
evidence and the findings of the trial Court. In such circumstances, the
decision of the Sessions Court to consider the objections raised under
Section 464 Cr.P.C. along with the final hearing of the criminal appeal
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
18 MCRC-14443-2026
cannot be said to be wholly without jurisdiction or contrary to the statutory

scheme.
34. It is also pertinent to note that the issue relating to the framing and
nature of charges in the present criminal case has already travelled up to the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, and the charges were thereafter framed in the light
of the directions issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The petitioner,
having faced the trial on the basis of such charges and suffered a judgment of
conviction, has now sought to reopen the very issue by invoking Section 464
of the Cr.P.C. at the appellate stage. Though the statutory remedy under
Section 464 Cr.P.C. cannot be denied merely on the ground that the issue of
charges had been raised earlier, the Court cannot lose sight of the fact that
repeated attempts to reopen the same issue, without demonstrating any
legally sustainable ground warranting such interference, may result in
protracting the criminal proceedings and obstructing their final adjudication.
The power under Section 464 Cr.P.C. is intended to remedy a failure of
justice occasioned by an error or omission in the charge; it cannot be
permitted to become an instrument for repeatedly reopening issues already
subjected to judicial scrutiny or for delaying the disposal of the appeal. In
the facts and circumstances of the present case, the petitioner’s insistence
that the application under Section 464 Cr.P.C. must necessarily be decided as
a preliminary proceeding, independently of the appeal, does not appear to be
supported by any such mandatory requirement under the provision. The
same, therefore, cannot be accepted as a matter of right.
35. It is also necessary to clarify that the observations made herein are
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
19 MCRC-14443-2026
confined to the question of the stage and manner of consideration of the

application under Section 464 Cr.P.C. This Court has not examined the
correctness of the charges framed against the petitioner, the alleged defects
therein, the question of prejudice or failure of justice, or the merits of the
conviction. All such contentions are left open to be considered by the
appellate Court in accordance with law, without being influenced by any
observation made in the present order.
36. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the petitioner has failed to establish any legal right to seek an
independent adjudication of his application under Section 464 Cr.P.C. as a
preliminary issue and before commencement of the final hearing of the
criminal appeal. The impugned order, insofar as it directs consideration of
the objections raised under Section 464 Cr.P.C. along with the final hearing
of the criminal appeal, does not warrant interference in the extraordinary
jurisdiction of this Court. The petition, therefore, deserves to be and is hereby
dismissed.
37. "The victims of the Bhopal Gas Tragedy have waited long enough
for the criminal law to take its course to a logical conclusion. The judicial
process must not become an endless journey; it must remain a path towards a
lawful and just determination." In view of the aforesaid, the appellate Court
is directed to make every endeavour to decide the pending criminal appeal as
expeditiously as possible, preferably within a period of 30 days from the date
of receipt of a copy of this order. The appellate Court shall, however,
consider all the grounds raised by the petitioner under Section 464 of the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91782
20 MCRC-14443-2026
Cr.P.C. on their own merits, in the light of the evidence available on record

and the law governing the subject, while deciding the criminal appeal. It shall
also endeavour to avoid unnecessary adjournments and ensure that the appeal
is decided within the stipulated period.
38. The Registry is directed to communicate a copy of this order to the
concerned appellate Court forthwith for necessary compliance.
(HIMANSHU JOSHI)
JUDGE
Prachi
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: PRACHI PANDEY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
18:29:48