P NAGARAJ S/O DURUGAPPA vs STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021



IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD


TH
DATED THIS THE 18 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF

WRIT PETITION NO.104708 OF 2021 (LB-UC)

BETWEEN:

1. P. NAGARAJ S/O. DURUGAPPA,
AGE. 38 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,

2. G. ADIVAJJAR RANGAPPA S/O. CHANNAPPA,
AGE. 66 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,

3. VEERUPAKSHAPPA S/O. HANAMANTAPPA,
AGE. 35 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,

4. YALLAPPA S/O. GDDYALLAPPAR KALLAPPA,
AGE. 58 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,

5. BARMAPPA S/O. HANUMANTAPP,
AGE. 57 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,

ALL ARE RESIDENT OF CHIKKAKERIYAGINAHALLI,
TQ. SANDUR, DIST. BALLARI – 583101.

…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. AMAREGOUDA M., ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. STATE OF KARNATAKA,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
TO DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
VIDHANA SOUDHA, BENGALURE - 560001.

2. THE ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER OFFICE,
MINOR IRRIGATION AND INLAND/GROUND WATER











Digitally signed by
THEJAS KUMAR N
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


DEVELOPMENT, SUB-DIVISION-KUDLIGI-583135.

3. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF REVENUE RECORDS,
SANDUR, DIST. BALLARI-583119.

4. THE ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE OFFICER,
MINOR IRRIGATION DEPARTMENT
KUDLIGI - 583135.

5. THE TAHASILDHAR,
SANDUR-583119.

6. THE GRAMAPANCHAYATHI DEVELOPMENT OFFICER,
CHIKKAKERIYAGINAHALLI,
TQ. SANDUR, DIST. BALLARI - 583101.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. RATNAMALA G.H., HCGP FOR R1 TO R5;
NOTICE TO R6 IS SERVED)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO I)
ISSUE A WRIT IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARI THEREBY
QUASH THE NOTICE BY THE RESPONDENT NO.2 ON
17.07.2021
¸À.PÁ.¤.EA/¸À.¤Ã.&CA.C.G.«/PÀÆrèV/vÁ.±Á/¹.PÉ. ºÀ½î PÉgÉ/
AS ANNEXURE-H,

2021-22/723 ¸À.PÁ.¤.EA/¸À.¤Ã.& CA.C.G.«/
AS ANNEXURE-H1,

PÀÆrèV/vÁ.±Á/¹.PÉ. ºÀ½î PÉgÉ/2021-22 /724
¸À.PÁ.¤.EA/¸À.¤Ã.& CA.C.G.«/PÀÆrèV/vÁ.±Á/¹.PÉ. ºÀ½î PÉgÉ/2021-22
AS ANNEXURE-H2,
/725 ¸À.PÁ.¤.EA/¸À.¤Ã.& CA.C.G.«/PÀÆrèV/
AS ANNEXURE-H3,
vÁ.±Á/¹.PÉ. ºÀ½î PÉgÉ/2021-22/716
¸À.PÁ.¤.EA/¸À.¤Ã.& CA.C.G.«/PÀÆrèV/vÁ.±Á/¹.PÉ. ºÀ½î PÉgÉ/2021-22
AS ANNEXURE-H4 TO THE WRIT PETITION, IN THE
/717
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY. II. PASS ANY OTHER
ORDER OR DIRECTION AS THIS HON’BLE COURT DEEMS FIT IN
VIEW OF THE FACTS AND CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE AS
STATED ABOVE, IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.

THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,
ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021



CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF
ORAL ORDER

This petition is filed seeking following reliefs:
“ i) Issue a writ in the nature of certiorari
thereby quash the Notice by the respondent
No.2 on 17.07.2021
¸À.PÁ.¤.EA/¸À.¤Ã.&CA.C.G.«/PÀÆrèV/vÁ.±Á/¹.PÉ.ºÀ½î
as Annexure-H,
PÉgÉ/2021-22/723 ¸À.PÁ.¤.EA/
¸À.¤Ã.&CA.C.G.«/PÀÆrèV/vÁ.±Á/¹.PÉ.ºÀ½î PÉgÉ/2021-
/724
as Annexure-H1,
22 ¸À.PÁ.¤.EA/
¸À.¤Ã.&CA.C.G.«/PÀÆrèV/vÁ.±Á/¹.PÉ.ºÀ½îPÉgÉ/2021-
/725 as Annexure-H2,
22 ¸À.PÁ.¤.EA/¸À.¤Ã.&
/716
CA.C.G.«/PÀÆrèV/vÁ.±Á/¹.PÉ. ºÀ½î PÉgÉ/2021-22
as Annexure-H3,
¸À.PÁ.¤.EA/¸À.¤Ã.& CA.C.G.«/
/717 as
PÀÆrèV/vÁ.±Á/¹.PÉ. ºÀ½î PÉgÉ/2021-22
Annexure-H4 to the writ petition, in the interest
of justice and equity.

ii. Pass any other order or direction as this
hon’ble court deems fit in view of the facts and
circumstances of the case as stated above, in
the interest of justice and equity.”

2. The lis involved in this matter is covered by the
Judgment of Division Bench of this Court in Writ Appeal
No.1333 of 2025 (KLR-RES) disposed of on 04.06.2026. The
Judgment passed by the Division Bench reads as under:
“This intra court appeal is by the State and its
instrumentalities under Section 4 of the Karnataka High
Court Act, 1961 challenging the order dated

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


27.11.2024 passed by the Writ Court in
W.P.No.24304/2021.
2. By the impugned order, the Writ Court
disposed of the Writ Petition holding that the petitioner
acquired title by means of declaration of title by Civil
Court which reached up to Supreme court and directed
the fourth respondent to enter the name of the
petitioner in the revenue records including the RTC
extracts to enable the petitioner to get compensation
from the fifth respondent for acquisition of lands by it
in a time bound manner with further directions.
3. The parties are referred to as per their
rankings before the Writ Court.
4. Facts leading to file the present appeal are
as under:
4.1 The case of the petitioner as put forth by them
before the Writ Court was that, one Sheragar Laxma
Bhovi was in possession of land bearing Sy.Nos.82, 52
and 61 to an extent of 13 Acres 29 Guntas in Dattagalli
Village, Mysore Taluk. It is further stated that land has
been granted in favor of said Sheragar Laxma Bhovi as
per the Grant Order dated 31.03.1954 (Annexure-B).
After the death of Sheragar Laxma Bhovi, the name of
the petitioner being the legal representative of said
Sheragar Laxma Bhovi came to be entered in the
revenue records as per IHR No.4/1983-84 (Annexure-
C).
4.2 At the earlier point of time, in view of certain
disputes by the State Government denying the title of
the petitioner, a suit in O.S.No.96/1997 came to be
filed against the Government entities viz., State of
Karnataka represented by its Chief Secretary, the
Assistant Commissioner, Mysore Sub-Division, Mysore
1
and Mysore Urban Development Authority . The suit on
contest, came to be decreed on 30.07.2001 declaring
the petitioner and other plaintiffs as absolute owner of
suit schedule property.

1
MUDA, for short

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


4.3 The State and other defendants aggrieved by the
Judgment and decree stated supra in suit
O.S.No.96/1997, filed R.A.No.257/2009 along with an
application seeking condonation of delay. The said
application came to be allowed after contest. That was
the subject matter before the Writ Court in
W.P.No.27735/2010 contending that the appeal filed
belatedly by five years, and the Appellate Court
erroneously allowed the application. The Writ Court
vide order dated 30.08.2011 (Annexure-E) allowed the
Writ Petition and set-aside the order passed by the
Appellate Court in R.A.No.257/2009 allowing the I.A
seeking condonation of delay. Consequently, the
appeal filed by the State was dismissed. The order in
Writ Petition unsuccessfully carried before the Supreme
Court in Special Leave Petition.
4.4 It is further stated in the Writ Petition that
respondent No.5 has utilized the land belonging to the
petitioner without initiating any acquisition proceedings
and accordingly, the petitioner presented the Writ
Petition before the Writ Court.
4.5 It was contended before the Writ Court that the
petitioner acquired his right through his ancestor
Sheragar Laxma Bhovi and by means of declaration of
the Civil Court, his title to the land declared, the
respondent No.5 without initiating any acquisition
proceedings utilized the land for the purpose of laying
of road. An application was filed seeking compensation
which was not considered on the ground that the
petitioner's name was not found in the RTC.
Accordingly, a representation was filed requesting the
State authorities to enter the name of the petitioner
and his family members in the RTC records as the
request was not favoured and the petition filed seeking
relief with further direction against respondent No.5 to
grant compensation in respect of the portion of land
utilized belonging to the petitioner.
4.6 This contention of the petitioner was refuted by
both the Government as well as MUDA, stating that
there is a cloud in so far as title of the property in

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


question and also disputed the grant made in favor of
Sheragar Laxma Bhovi.
4.7 Before the Writ Court, learned counsel appearing
for the MUDA submitted that in terms of the order
passed by the Writ Court dated 29.01.2014 and
12.02.2024, respondent No.5 has deposited
Rs.51,50,161/- for the portion of the land utilized
belonging to the petitioner and further contended that
entire extent of land as claimed by the petitioner has
not been acquired in view of the report made by
Assistant Director of Land Records produced along with
the memo dated 26.02.2024 and sought to dispose of
the Writ Petition.
4.8 The Writ Court having considered the rival
submissions was of the opinion that the petitioner
acquired title under the Grant Order to Sheragar
Laxma Bhovi dated 31.03.1954 as per Annexure-B and
the same is confirmed in the suit by declaring title of
the petitioner against the Government, which though
challenged in R.A.No.257/2009 along with application
for delay condonation, which was allowed by the
Appellate court and subsequently set-aside by the Writ
Court in W.P.No.27735/2010 consequently dismissing
the appeal and attained finality and unsuccessfully
called before the Supreme Court.
4.9 Further, the Writ Court observed that the
Government preferred RSA No.2026/2012 against the
Judgment dated 24.11.2011 in R.A.No.257/2009 which
came to be dismissed by this Court on the submission
made by learned counsel appearing at the bar that
portion of land has been utilized by respondent No.5
for the purpose of formation of road and drainage
facility and to make way for the general public. In view
of the order passed by the competent Civil Court which
has attained finality regarding the right of the
petitioner in respect of the land on the basis of Grant
order, the Writ Court on the basis of survey report
regarding the extent of land which has been utilized by
respondent No.5, in terms of direction issued on
12.02.2024, produced report as per memo dated
26.02.2024 stating the position of the land and in the

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


backdrop of these documents, held that respondent
No.5 utilized the land belonging to the petitioner for
the purpose of formation of road and drainage facility
and to make way for the general public, directed
respondent No.4 to enter the name of the petitioner in
the revenue records including RTC extracts to enable
the petitioner to get the compensation from respondent
No.5 in a time bound manner. Further, directed the
Registry to return the deposit made by respondent
No.5 through RTGS with an intimation to the learned
counsel for the respondent No.5. Further kept it open
for the petitioner to approach respondent No.5 seeking
enhancement of compensation if so advised since no
acquisition proceedings has been initiated by
respondent No.5. Accordingly, the Writ Petition was
disposed of. It is this order passed by the Writ Court is
called in question in this Writ Appeal.
5. Heard, Sri.M.N.Sudev Hegde, learned
Additional Government Advocate for the appellants,
Sri.S.P.Shankar, learned Senior counsel assisted by
Sri.Manjunath G.Kandekar, learned counsel for
respondent No.1, Sri.T.P.Vivekananda, learned counsel
for respondent No.2 and Sri.M.B.Chandrachooda,
learned counsel for proposed respondent 3 to 7 on
I.A.No.4/2025 for impleading.
6. Sri.M.N.Sudev Hegde, learned AGA placing
reliance on the written submission filed on 23.03.2026,
copy of which was served on the opponent long back,
submits that the land claimed to be granted in favor of
Sheragar Laxma Bhovi was in the land classified as
Sarkari Kere i.e., Government Lake and the same was
also shown and entered in the RTC from 1970-71 as B-
Kharab and Sarkari Kere in respect of Sy.No.52, 61
and 82 of Dattagalli Village, Kasaba Hobli, Mysore
Taluk and District. He further stated regarding history
of the land in the written submissions, which reads as
under:

II. History of Sy.No.52 of Dattagalli Village,
Kasaba Hobli, Mysore Taluk
and District.

•
Land measures 1 Acre and 34 Guntas.

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


•
RTC extract from 1970-71 shows the land as
B-Kharab land or "Kharabu Katte".
•
MUDA utilized 34 Guntas for construction of
storm water drain for its adjoining layout.
•
Remaining 1 acre is occupied by water
spread area.
•
The said land is never granted to anyone.

III. History of Sy.No.61 of Dattagalli Village,
Kasaba Hobli, Mysore Taluk
and District.

•
Land measures 1 Acre and 35 Guntas.
•
Revenue records from 1970-71 shows the
land as "Kharabu Katte".
•
Land has never been granted to anyone.

IV. History of Sy.No.82 of Dattagalli Village,
Kasaba Hobli, Mysore Taluk
and District.

•
Land measures 161 Acres and 10 Guntas.
•
It originally measured 168 Acres and 30
Guntas. Out of this extent, a total of 07 Acres
and 20 Guntas were bifurcated through
Durasti.
•
It is classified as "Sarkari Kere" of
Government Lake. RTC from the years 1970
to around 1980 shows that the land is
classified a Government Tank Bed.
•
From the year 1980 onwards, an illegal entry
was made in MR No.20/53-54 and RTC stood
in the name of Shergar Laxma Bhovi, the
late father of the petitioner.
•
The illegal entry so made is cancelled vide
the order of the Assistant commissioner in
case no. Audit.4/85-86 dated 05/08/1989.
Thereafter, from the year 1994-95, the RTC
shows the name "Sarkari Kere" or
Government Lake.
•
Petitioner filed O.S.No.96/1997 for
Declaration that he is the owner of the suit
schedule property and for permanent
injunction. The said suit came to be decreed

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


on 30.07.2001 in favour of the petitioner/
plaintiff.
•
State Government filed R.A.No.257/2009
(Old No.135/2006). I.A. 1 for condonation of
delay was filed to condone the delay of 6
years in filing of the appeal. The said I.A was
allowed.
•
The petitioner challenged the same before
the Hon'ble High Court vide Writ Petition
No.27735/2010 (GM-CPC). The said Writ
Petition was allowed vide order dated
30.08.2011.
•
Based on the said order, the
R.A.No.257/2009 stood dismissed.
•
The said order of the Hon'ble High court in
W.P.No.27735/2010 was challenged before
the Hon'ble Apex Court by filing a Civil
Appeal No.20866/2012. The same came to
be dismissed.
•
The State filed RSA No.2026/2012 against
the Judgment and Decree passed in
R.A.No.257/2009. The said RSA came to be
dismissed on 22.04.2012, relying on the
order passed in W.P.No.27735/2010."
6.1 It was further argued by Mr.Hegde, that as per
the Government Letter bearing No.RD 86 LGN
2001 dated 08.07.2003, the Deputy
Commissioner/ Appellant No.2, has issued an
Official Memorandum dated 28.08.2003
excluding 25 Acres out of 161 Acres and 10
Guntas in Sy.No.82 and the remaining extent o
136 Acres and 10 Guntas are transferred to the
Forest Department after notifying them as
Reserved forest. This action of the Government
was the subject matter of the suit in
O.S.No.84/2015 filed by the petitioner against
the Forest Department. An application seeking
temporary injunction-I.A.No.1 in the said suit
came to be rejected vide order dated 04.07.2015
and ended unsuccessfully in M.A filed against the
said order by means of order passed by the
Appellate Court on 19.06.2016. Subsequently,
the suit also came to be dismissed.

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


6.2 He further submits that in respect of the same
set of land as claimed by the petitioner, another
person by name Srinivas filed a suit for
declaration, possession and permanent injunction
in O.S.No.321/1995. The said suit was a
collusive suit as the petitioner herein himself
testified and said that the said land belonged to
the State and thereafter was granted to one
Chinnabhovi, father of Srinivas. The petitioner
further stated as a witness that the lands were
granted in the 1956 in favor of predecessor of
Srinivas, as such the land remained under the
ownership of Srinivas.
6.3 Mr.Sudev Hegde, further submitted that this
stance of the petitioner goes against his claim
itself staking rights as absolute owner in respect
of the very same land which he has sought in the
earlier suit stated supra. The suit in
O.S.No.321/1995 was decreed, ended in
dismissal in R.A and RSA i.e., R.A.No.7/2004 and
R.S.A.No.588/2011. The said Judgment was
assailed before the Supreme Court in SLP (Civil)
Diary No.32076/2018 and the same is pending
consideration, wherein the Supreme Court
directed both the parties to maintain status-quo
vide order dated 05.10.2018.
6.4 It is further argued by Mr.Sudev Hegde, that
both the R.A and R.S.A filed by the State in
respect of suit filed by the petitioner in
O.S.No.96/1997 ended in dismissal only on the
ground of delay, as such the contentions of fraud
taken by the State has not been considered. This
fact is also not considered by the Writ Court. He
further submits that mere entry of name of the
petitioner in RTC will not confer any right, title in
respect of the land. Admittedly, lands are Sarkari
Kere i.e,. Government Lake, as such comes
under B-Kharab land and no grant order can be
made in respect of B-Kharab land i.e.,
Government Lake and submits that the Writ

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


Court has failed to consider these settled
principles of law.
6.5 Mr.Hegde, further submitted that the grant order
on the basis of which the petitioner got
declaration in his favor does not finds place in
any of the record, as such the same is fabricated
and created and by means of playing fraud on
the Court got the decree, as such, the said
Judgment and Decree is non-est in law.
6.6 Learned AGA in order to support his contention,
relied on the Judgment of the Supreme Court in
HINCH LAL TIWARI VS. KAMALA DEVI AND
2
OTHERS to contend that material resources of
the community like forests, tanks, ponds, hillock,
mountain, etc, are natures bounty and need to
be protected for a proper and healthy
environment which enables people to enjoy a
quality life which is the essence of the
guaranteed right under Article 21 of the
Constitution and relied on Paragraph No.13 of
the said Judgment.
6.7 Further, he has taken support of the Judgment in
JAGPAL SINGH AND OTHERS VS. STATE OF
3
PUNJAB AND OTHERS and relied on
Paragraphs No.13, 14 and 23 to contend that
merely because unauthorized occupation is
subsisting for several years, the same cannot be
regularized and the lands should be restored to
the Government and illegal occupants should be
evicted.

6.8 He further relied on the Judgment in VISHNU
VARDHAN @ VISHNU PRADHAN VS. STATE
4
OF UTTAR PRADEHS AND OTHERS to
contend that fraud unravels everything.

2
AIR 2001 SC 3215
3
AIR 2011 SC 1123
4
2025 SCC ONLINE SC 1501

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


Accordingly, learned AGA sought to dismiss the
Writ Petition.
7. In contrast, Sri.S.P.Shankar, learned
Senior counsel appearing for the contesting
respondent/ petitioner submits that the Writ Court is
right in concluding that the petitioner has perfected his
title by means of declaration by the competent Civil
Court which attained finality up till Supreme Court. The
petitioner has perfected his right by means of Grant
order in favor of his ancestor as well as declaration by
the competent Civil Court on the basis of subsequent
order. Once there is a declaration by the competent
Civil Court declaring the rights which has attained
finality by means of unsuccessful challenge up till
Supreme Court, the State is now estopped from
staking any stand on the Grant Order or the title of the
petitioner. Once the title has been declared, the
revenue authorities are bound under law to effect the
name of the petitioner in the RTCs to enable them to
claim compensation for the portion of land utilized by
respondent No.5. The Grant order was passed in 1954
and till date, the said order has not been challenged by
anyone including the Government Authorities and
standing still today and the name of the petitioner finds
place in the RTC by means of Mutation in the year
1983-84 and continued, as such the claim by the
Government as the lands claimed by the petitioner
coming within the survey number which is Government
Lake cannot be countenanced, when the same was
contended and negated against the State by the Civil
Court. Learned Senior counsel further submits that the
Judgments relied on by the appellant-Government are
not applicable to the facts of the present case, as they
are clearly distinguishable on facts and in view of the
declaration by competent Civil Court declaring the
rights of the petitioner. Accordingly, he sought to
dismiss the appeal.
8. Sri.T.P.Vivekananda, learned counsel
appearing for the MUDA argued in line with the
Government Advocate. However, has stated that the
MUDA had already deposited amount in terms of the

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


direction before the Writ Court though ordered to be
returned is ready to deposit the amount for the portion
of land utilized by it.
9. The impleading applicants herein are the
legal representatives Srinivas, who initiated suit in
O.S.No.325/1995. They have contended that they are
also entitled for the lands in the very same survey
number in terms of judicial pronouncements by the
competent Civil Court in their favor which has attained
finality.
10. Having heard the rival submissions, we
have directed the learned AGA to produce the entire
records pertaining to the lands claimed by the
Government as well as the petitioner and impleading
applicants. Accordingly, Sri.M.N.Sudev Hegde, learned
AGA produced entire records pertaining to the lands on
17.04.2026 before us. We have perused the original
records produced by learned AGA. After careful
perusal, nothing is there to reflect the name of the
petitioner or their predecessor as grantees of the land
in question, the same applies to the impleading
applicants also.
11. At this juncture, to the query of the Court
regarding the original Grant Order, learned Senior
counsel Sri.S.P.Shankar, except showing the order at
Annexure-B which is photocopy of the order, has not
produced any original Grant Order. The photocopy
produced at Annexure-B and the Certified copy of the
same produced by AGA subsequently obtained from the
records of the Civil Court in O.S.No.96/1997 are the
photocopies of the order and not the original. The
documents does not bear the Signature of the
competent authority in respect of the order, but shows
signed as Amaldar. Nothing has been placed by the
petitioner to contend in support of his contention
regarding grant of land. However, a feeble attempt is
made by producing certain documents such as Copy of
FIR, B Report, Copy of Order sheet and other
documents, along with affidavit by learned Senior
counsel on behalf of Sri.K.Sreedhar, learned counsel
for the petitioner, to contend that all the actions taken

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


by the Government ended in favor of the petitioner. As
such, the appeal filed by the appellant required to be
dismissed.
12. In the absence of original Grant Order, we
have made enquiry with the Government Advocate and
directed him to produce the entire documents
pertaining to the lands. No corresponding entries are
found in the documents produced by the authorities
with respect to alleged grant order at Annexure-B. We
have perused the entire records pertaining to the
lands. Nothing is found to show the names of either the
petitioner or his ancestors reflecting their names as
grantees of the land in question. Same also applies to
impleading applicants. As such the application does not
survive to consider and is accordingly, rejected.
13. In the absence of corresponding record by
means of register and the corresponding order of grant
produced as Annexure-B to this Writ Petition, we have
no other option than to accept the contention of the
learned AGA that the order produced is a fake, dubious
and on the basis of such fake and dubious order by
playing fraud on the Civil Court, the decree has been
obtained.
14. We find force in the argument of
Mr.M.N.Sudev Hegde, learned AGA that fraud unravels
everything. The Supreme Court in the case of VISHNU
VARDHAN supra at Paragraph No.60 has held as
under:
"60. Be that as it may, obtaining of the impugned
order by Reddy in his favour by playing fraud on the High
Court is conspicuous by its presence. Thus, we find
Vishnu's core argument to be creditworthy and compelling
for us to hold that judicial orders procured by Reddy by
subverting the judicial process through fraud and
concealment of material facts cannot be permitted to
stand."
15. In the said Judgment, the Supreme Court
referred to several decisions in Paragraph No.61 and
concluded in Paragraph No.64 holding that given the
deception involved, the impugned order and the
decision of the Court procured are tainted by fraud and

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


thus, lack legal sanctity and validity. The said
paragraphs read as under:

"61. In decisions abound, the Courts have consistently
nullified orders obtained through fraudulent means. Key
excerpts from some of these decisions read thus:
a. In United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Rajendra Singh,
this Court reiterated that fraud unravels everything:
3. “Fraud and justice never dwell together” (fraus et jus
nunquam cohabitant) is a pristine maxim which has
never lost its temper over all these centuries. Lord
Denning observed in a language without equivocation
that “no judgment of a court, no order of a Minister can
be allowed to stand if it has been obtained by fraud, for,
fraud unravels everything” (Lazarus Estates
Ltd. v. Beasley, [[1956] 1 Q.B. 702 : [1956] 1 All ER 341
: [1956] 2 WLR 502 (CA)]).
b. In Shrisht Dhawan (Smt) v. Shaw Bros, it was held:
20. Fraud and collusion vitiate even the most solemn
proceedings in any civilised system of jurisprudence. It is
a concept descriptive of human conduct. Michael Levi
likens a fraudster to Milton's sorcerer, Comus, who
exulted in his ability to, ‘wing me into the easy-hearted
man and trap him into snares’. It has been defined as an
act of trickery or deceit. In Webster's Third New
International Dictionary fraud in equity has been defined
as an act or omission to act or concealment by which one
person obtains an advantage against conscience over
another or which equity or public policy forbids as being
prejudicial to another. In Black's Legal Dictionary, fraud
is defined as an intentional perversion of truth for the
purpose of inducing another in reliance upon it to part
with some valuable thing belonging to him or surrender a
legal right; a false representation of a matter of fact
whether by words or by conduct, by false or misleading
allegations, or by concealment of that which should have
been disclosed, which deceives and is intended to
deceive another so that he shall act upon it to his legal
injury……..
c. In A.V. Papayya Sastry v. Govt. of A.P., this Court
held:
21. Now, it is well-settled principle of law that if any
judgment or order is obtained by fraud, it cannot be said
to be a judgment or order in law. Before three centuries,
Chief Justice Edward Coke proclaimed:
“Fraud avoids all judicial acts, ecclesiastical or
temporal.”

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


22. It is thus settled proposition of law that a
judgment, decree or order obtained by playing fraud on
the court, tribunal or authority is a nullity and non est in
the eye of the law. Such a judgment, decree or order—
by the first court or by the final court—has to be treated
as nullity by every court, superior or inferior. It can be
challenged in any court, at any time, in appeal, revision,
writ or even in collateral proceedings.
23. *
24. In Duchess of Kingstone, Smith's Leading Cases,
th
13 Edn., p. 644, explaining the nature of fraud, de
Grey, C.J. stated that though a judgment would be res
judicata and not impeachable from within, it might be
impeachable from without. In other words, though it is
not permissible to show that the court was “mistaken”, it
might be shown that it was “misled”. There is an
essential distinction between mistake and trickery. The
clear implication of the distinction is that an action to set
aside a judgment cannot be brought on the ground that
it has been decided wrongly, namely, that on the merits,
the decision was one which should not have been
rendered, but it can be set aside, if the court was
imposed upon or tricked into giving the judgment.
25. It has been said: fraud and justice never dwell
together (fraus et jus nunquam cohabitant); or fraud and
deceit ought to benefit none (fraus et dolus nemini
patrocinari debent).
d. The judgment by Denning, L.J. in Lazarus Estates
Ltd. (supra), which has since been quoted with approval
by this Court in a catena of decisions including Nidhi
Kaim (supra), asserted intolerance for fraud in legal
proceedings in the following words:
No court … will allow a person to keep an advantage
which he has obtained by fraud. […] Fraud unravels
everything. The court is careful not to find fraud unless it
is distinctly pleaded and proved; but once it is proved, it
vitiates judgments, contracts and all transactions
whatsoever….
64. In light of the above discussion, we feel no
hesitation to hold that given the deception involved, the
impugned order and the decision of this Court dated
th
5 May, 2022 in Reddy Veerana (supra) procured by
Reddy are tainted by fraud and, thus, lack legal sanctity
and validity."

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


16. The Supreme Court in the case of
MEGHAMALA AND OTHERS VS. G.NARASIMHA
5
REDDY AND OTHERS , at paragraphs No.28 to 36 has
held that the fraud is an intrinsic, collateral act, and
fraud of an egregious nature would vitiate the most
solemn proceedings of courts of justice. Fraud is an act
of deliberate deception with a design to secure
something, which is otherwise not due. The said
Paragraphs read as under:
"28. It is settled proposition of law that
where an applicant gets an order/office by making
misrepresentation or playing fraud upon the competent
Authority, such order cannot be sustained in the eyes of
law.
"Fraud avoids all judicial acts ecclesiastical or temporal."
(vide S.P.Chengalvaraya Naidu (dead) by L.Rs. Vs.
Jagannath. In Lazarus Estate Ltd. Vs. Besalay, the Court
observed without equivocation that "no judgment of a
Court, no order of a Minister can be allowed to stand if it
has been obtained by fraud, for fraud unravels
everything."
29. In Andhra Pradesh State Financial Corporation
Vs. M/s. GAR Re-Rolling Mills and State of Maharashtra &
Ors. Vs. Prabhu this Court observed that a writ Court,
while exercising its equitable jurisdiction, should not act as
to prevent perpetration of a legal fraud as the courts are
obliged to do justice by promotion of good faith. "Equity
is, also, known to prevent the law from the crafty evasions
and sub-letties invented to evade law."
30. In Smt. Shrisht Dhawan Vs. M/s. Shaw
Brothers. it has been held as under:- (SCC p.553, para
20)
"20. Fraud and collusion vitiate even the most solemn
proceedings in any civilised system of jurisprudence. It is
a concept descriptive of human conduct."
31. In United India Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Rajendra
Singh, this Court observed that "Fraud and justice never
dwell together" (fraus et jus nunquam cohabitant) and it is
a pristine maxim which has never lost its temper over all
these centuries.
32. The ratio laid down by this Court in various
cases is that dishonesty should not be permitted to bear

5
(2010) 8 SCC 383

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


the fruit and benefit to the persons who played fraud or
made misrepresentation and in such circumstances the
Court should not perpetuate the fraud. (See District
Collector & Chairman, Vizianagaram Social Welfare
Residential School Society. Vs. M. Tripura Sundari
Devi ; Union of India Vs. M. Bhaskaran, Kendriya
Vidyalaya Sangathan Vs. Girdharilal Yadav; State of
Maharashtra v. Ravi Prakash Babulalsing Parmar ; Himadri
Chemicals Industries Ltd. Vs. Coal Tar Refining
Company and Mohammed Ibrahim Vs. State of Bihar.
33. Fraud is an intrinsic, collateral act, and fraud of
an egregious nature would vitiate the most solemn
proceedings of courts of justice. Fraud is an act of
deliberate deception with a design to secure something,
which is otherwise not due. The expression "fraud"
involves two elements, deceit and injury to the person
deceived. It is a cheating intended to get an advantage.
(Vide Dr. Vimla Vs. Delhi Administration, Indian Bank Vs.
Satyam Fibres (India) Pvt. Ltd., State of Andhra Pradesh
Vs. T.Suryachandra Rao ; K.D. Sharma Vs. SAIL and
Central Bank of India Vs. Madhulika Guruprasad Dahir.
34. An act of fraud on court is always viewed
seriously. A collusion or conspiracy with a view to deprive
the rights of the others in relation to a property would
render the transaction void ab initio. Fraud and deception
are synonymous. Although in a given case a deception
may not amount to fraud, fraud is anathema to all
equitable principles and any affair tainted with fraud
cannot be perpetuated or saved by the application of any
equitable doctrine including res judicata. Fraud is proved
when it is shown that a false representation has been
made (i) knowingly, or (ii) without belief in its truth, or
(iii) recklessly, careless whether it be true or false.
Suppression of a material document would also amount to
a fraud on the court. (Vide S.P. Changalvaraya
Naidu; Gowrishankar Vs. Joshi Amba Shankar Family
Trust. Ram Chandra Singh Vs. Savitri Devi, Roshan Deen
Vs. Preeti Lal, Ram Preeti Yadav Vs. U.P. Board of High
School & Intermediate Education and Ashok Leyland Ltd.
Vs. State of T.N ).
35. In kinch Vs. Walcott, it has been held that
"....mere constructive fraud is not, at all events after long
delay, sufficient but such a judgment will not be set aside
upon mere proof that the judgment was obtained y
perjury."

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


Thus, detection/discovery of constructive fraud at a much
belated stage may not be sufficient to set aside the
judgment procured by perjury.
36. From the above, it is evident that even in
judicial proceedings, once a fraud is proved, all
advantages gained by playing fraud can be taken away. In
such an eventuality the questions of non-executing of the
statutory remedies or statutory bars like doctrine of res
judicata are not attracted. Suppression of any material
fact/document amounts to a fraud on the court. Every
court has an inherent power to recall its own order
obtained by fraud as the order so obtained is non est."
17. When the law laid down by the Supreme
Court in the above two cases and other cases referred
by the Supreme Court applied to the case on hand, it
becomes empathetically clear that in view of absence
of original order of Grant and in the absence of
corresponding records in the records maintained by the
Government in respect of the lands wherein the
petitioner staking a claim, on the order of Grant
produced at Annexure-B required to be stated as
dubious, fake and created and fabricated document.
The Judgment procured on such a shady document
would not stand in law as the same goes to the roots of
claim.

18. Learned Senior counsel is unable to
counter this aspect of the matter when queried again
and again with respect to the document produced at
Annexure-B and the documents produced i.e., land
records maintained by the concerned authority before
this Court. This fact has deceived the Civil Court and
the said fact deceived the Writ Court, but nothing
deceives more than an obvious fact. In that view of the
matter, we are of the view that the Writ Court ignored
these aspects of the matter, though the same was
pleaded and contended before the Writ Court by the
Government and failed to consider the same and held
that in view of the declaration of title by the competent
Civil Court, the petitioner has perfected his title and as
such the revenue authorities are under obligation to
enter the name in the revenue records. In these
circumstances, in the absence of grant order, the

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


petitioner has no legs to stand to claim a right over the
property.
19. There is one more reason for us to allow
this appeal and dismiss the Writ Petition, and that is,
the land stated to have been granted even as per the
document produced at Annexure-B (which we have
already held as false document) stated to be in the
land in Survey number which is Government Lake i.e.,
Sarkari Kere. The point on grant of land in the
properties belonging to the Government which are
essentially material resources of the community like
forests, tanks, ponds, hillock, mountain, etc, are
natures bounty and need to be protected for a proper
and healthy environment which enables people to
enjoy a quality life which is the essence of the
guaranteed right under Article 21 of the Constitution is
no more res integra as no grant be made in respect of
natural resource available to the public at large. Our
stand gain strength from the Judgment relied on by the
learned AGA in HINCH LAL TIWARI supra, wherein
the Supreme Court in the concluding paragraph held as
under:
"It is important to notice that the material
resources of the community like forests, tanks, ponds,
hillock, mountain etc. are nature's bounty. They maintain
delicate ecological balance. They need to be protected for
a proper and healthy environment which enables people to
enjoy a quality life which is the essence of the guaranteed
right under Article 21 of the Constitution. The
Government, including the Revenue Authorities i.e.
Respondents 11 to 13, having noticed that a pond is
falling in disuse, should have bestowed their attention to
develop the same which would, on one hand, have
prevented ecological disaster and on the other provided
better environment for the benefit of the public at large.
Such vigil is the best protection against knavish attempts
to seek allotment in non-abadi sites.For the
aforementioned reasons, we set aside the order of the
High Court, restore the order of the Additional Collector
dated 25-2-1999 confirmed by the Commissioner on 12-3-
1999. Consequently, Respondents 1 to 10 shall vacate the
land, which was allotted to them, within six months from
today. They will, however, be permitted to take away the
material of the houses which they have constructed on the
said land. If Respondents 1 to 10 do not vacate the land

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


within the said period the official respondents i.e.
Respondents 11 to 13 shall demolish the construction and
get possession of the said land in accordance with law.
The State including Respondents 11 to 13 shall restore the
pond, develop and maintain the same as a recreational
spot which will undoubtedly be in the best interest of the
villagers. Further it will also help in maintaining ecological
balance and protecting the environment in regard to which
this Court has repeatedly expressed its concern. Such
measures must begin at the grass-root level if they were
to become the nation's pride."
20. In view of the judicial pronouncement
stated supra, even if there is a Grant by means of
Annexure-B (which we have already held as fake), the
Government ought not to have ventured to grant lands
out of the lands reserved for Government Lake i.e.,
Sarkari Kere. Such an action goes against the statutory
mandate of preserving natural sources as held by the
Supreme Court in HINCH LAL TIWARI supra. The
Government is duty bound and obliged to protect and
develop the lakes in order to prevent any ecological
disaster and to provide better environment for the
benefit of the public at large.
21. For the above said reasons, we deem it
appropriate to allow the appeal and set-aside the order
passed by the Writ Court.
22. We place our appreciation for the able
assistance provided by Sri.M.N.Sudev Hegde, learned
AGA for his painstaking work in collecting all the
records to protect the Government lands from the
hands of the persons who are seeking their claims on
forged documents. Though we are inclined to impose
cost while allowing the appeal, however, considering
the financial position of the contesting
respondent/petitioner as contended by his counsel, in
the interest of justice, we refrain ourselves from
imposing any costs on the contesting
respondent/petitioner. With these observations, the
Writ Appeal is allowed . The order passed by the Writ
Court is set-aside. Consequently, the Writ Petition filed
is dismissed.

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


23. In view of disposal of Writ Appeal, pending
interlocutory applications, if any, stand disposed of.”

3. Coming to the facts of this case, it is not in dispute
by the petitioners, the land granted even according to them
as per Annexure-F (Form No.VII), stated to be in respect of
land in survey number is shown as ‘Lake’ in the Government
records.
4. Learned HCGP appearing for respondents No.1 to
5/State submits that the State has taken a specific
contention that land in respect of survey number is
earmarked for ‘Lake’ in the map. The Division Bench in its
Judgment passed in Writ Appeal stated supra , especially at
paragraph No.19 relying on the Judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the case of Hinch Lal Tiwari vs. Kamala
Devi and Others , reported in AIR 2001 SC 3215 , held that
the properties belonging to the Government, which are
essentially material resources of the community like forests,
tanks, ponds, hillock, mountain, etc. are nature’s bounty and
need to be protected for a proper and healthy environment,
which enables people to enjoy a quality life, which is the

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


essence of the guaranteed right under Article 21 of the
Constitution of India. Even if, it were to be considered as a
grant by means of Annexure-F dated 13.11.1995 (which
according to the Government is a fake document) the
Government ought not to have ventured to grant lands out
of the lands reserved for the Government Lake.
5. The learned HCGP further points out that in
paragraph No.2 of Annexure-F, there is nothing stated
regarding payment of amount and the date. In paragraph
No.1 of Annexure-F states as under:
“C¢ü¨sÉÆÃUÀzÀ°ègÀzÀ ¸ÀPÁðj ¨sÀÆ«ÄAiÀÄ£ÀÄß
¸ÁUÀĪÀ½UÁV «4É ªÀiÁqÀĪÀzÀPÉÌ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ C¢ü¨sÉÆÃUÀzÀ
ºÀPÀÄÌUÀ¼À£ÀÄß PÉÆqÀĪÀÅzÀPÉÌ ¸ÀA§AzsÀ¥ÀlÖ ¤AiÀĪÀÄUÀ¼À ªÉÄÃgÉUÉ
PɼÀV£À C£ÀĸÀÆaAiÀÄ°è ¤¢üðµÀÖ¥Àr¹zÀ ¨sÀÆ«ÄAiÀÄ£ÀÄß,
C.K.
ªÀiÁgÁl ªÀiÁqÀ4ÁVzÉ, ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ºÀ½î UÁæªÀÄzÀ ²æÃ UÉÆ®ègÀ
CrªÉdÓ gÀAUÀ¥Àà vÀAzÉ-vÁ¬Ä-UÀAqÀ ZÀ£ÀߥÀà JA§ÄªÁvÀ£À
PÉAiÀÄÄ CzÀ£ÀÄß §»gÀAUÀ ºÀgÁf£À°è CxÀªÁ ¤UÀ¢vÀ ¨É4ÉUÉ
PÉÆAqÀÄ PÉÆArzÁÝ£É-¼É ªÀÄvÀÄÛ CzÀ£ÀÄß PÀæªÀħzÀÞªÁV
C.K.
¹ÜjÃPÀj¸À4ÁVzÉ, ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ºÀ½î UÁæªÀÄzÀ ²æÃ vÀAzÉ-
vÁ¬Ä-UÀAqÀ JA§ÄªÁvÀ£ÀÄ-PÉAiÀÄÄ CzÀgÀ RjâzÁgÀ£ÉAzÀÄ-
¼ÉAzÀÄ WÉÆÃ¦¸À4ÁVzÉ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ¸ÀzÀj ²æÃ UÉÆ®ègÀ CrªÉdÓ
gÀAUÀ¥Àà JA§ÄªÁvÀ£ÀÄ-PÉAiÀÄÄ Rjâ ºÀtzÀ ¥ÀÆwð
ªÉƧ®UÁzÀ gÀÆ. £ÀÄß ¸ÀgÀPÁj ReÁ£ÉUÉ £ÀA§gï ªÀÄvÀÄÛ
¢£ÁAPÀ 199 gÀ°è ¸ÀAzÁAiÀÄ ªÀiÁrzÁÝ£É-¼É, ¸ÀAqÀÆgÀÄ
T.
vÁ®ÆQ£À vÀºÀ²Ã4ÁÝgÀ£ÁzÀ ¸ÀħâtÚ ¨sÁUÉ JA§ £Á£ÀÄ ²æÃ

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:19021
WP No. 104708 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020237252021


UÉÆ®ègï CrªÉdÓ gÀAUÀ¥Àà JA§ÄªÁvÀ¤UÉ-PÉUÉ ¸ÀzÀj ¨sÀÆ«Ä
AiÀÄ£ÀÄß C¢ü¨ÉÆÃV¸À®Ä C£ÀĪÀÄw PÉÆnÖzÉÝÃ£É ªÀÄvÀÄÛ
¨sÀÆPÀAzÁAiÀÄ C¢ü¤AiÀĪÀÄzÀ G¥À§AzsÀUÀ¼À ªÉÄÃgÉUÉ C¦Ã°£À°è
CxÀªÁ ¥ÀÅ£ÀjÃPÀëuÉAiÀİè DUÀ§ºÀÄzÁzÀ gÀ¢ÝAiÀiÁw CxÀªÁ
ªÀiÁ¥ÁðrUÉ M¼À¥ÀlÄÖ E£ÀÄß ªÀÄÄAzÉ £ÀªÀÄÆ¢¹zÀ G¥À§AzsÀPÉÌ
M¼À¥ÀlÄÖ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ vÀvÁÌ®zÀ°è eÁjAiÀİègÀĪÀ ¤AiÀĪÀÄUÀ¼À ªÉÄÃgÉUÉ
UÉÆvÀÄÛ ªÀiÁqÀ4ÁzÀAvÉ D ¨sÀÆ«ÄAiÀÄ §UÉV£À ¨sÀÆ
PÀAzÁAiÀĪÀ£ÀÄß ¤AiÀÄ«ÄvÀªÁV ¸ÀAzÁAiÀÄ ªÀiÁqÀĪÀÅzÀPÉÌ ¸ÀºÀ
C.K.
M¼À¥ÀlÄÖ, ¸ÀzÀj ¨sÀÆ«ÄAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ºÀ½î UÁæªÀÄzÀ ²æÃ
UÉÆ®ègï CrªÉdÓ gÀAUÀ¥Àà vÀAzÉ-vÁ¬Ä-UÀAqÀ ZÀ£ÀߥÀà
JA§ÄªÁvÀ¤UÉ-PÉUÉ CªÀ£À-¼À ªÁgÀ¸ÀÄzÁgÀjUÉ, CªÀ£À-¼À
ªÉÊAiÀÄQÛPÀ ¥Àæw¤¢üUÀ½UÉ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ CªÀ¤AzÀ-½AzÀ ºÀPÀÌ£ÀÄß
ªÀ»¹PÉÆAqÀªÀjUÉ, F ªÀÄÆ®PÀ ªÀÄAdÆgÀÄ ªÀiÁrzÉÝãÉ, ªÀÄvÀÄÛ
¹ÜjÃPÀj¹zÉÝãÉ.”

6. This clearly indicates that the document at
Annexure-F is a shady document. In view of the Judgment of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court, followed in Writ Appeal stated
supra by the Division Bench of this Court, the relief sought in
this writ petition cannot be accepted and granted. The writ
petition is being devoid of merits accordingly is dismissed .

Sd/-
(T.M.NADAF)
JUDGE

CKK
CT: UMD
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 31