DUDDAWWA AND ORS vs BHIMASHA S/O PEERAPPA NAIKODI
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
KALABURAGI BENCH
TH
DATED THIS THE 30 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 200078 OF 2017 (DEC)
BETWEEN:
1. DUNDAWWA W/O NINGAPPA NAIKODI,
SINCE DECEASED THROUGH BY LRS.,
LAXMIBAI W/O BANDEPPA JAMBAGI,
AGE: 60 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE, & HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. NEELUR, TQ. AFZALPUR,
DIST. KALABURAGI.
2.
i.
PRABHU S/O KALLAPPA,
AGE: 56 YEARS, OCC: GOVT. SERVANT,
(WORK INSPECTOR IN PWD ),
R/O. GUDUR, TQ.AFZALPUR,
DIST. KALABURAGI.
SINCE DECEASED BY LRS.,
ANSUBAI W/O PRABHU,
AGE: 59 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. NEELUR VILLAGE,
TQ. AFZALPUR, DIST. KALABURAGI.
ii. GUNDAMMA W/O YALLALING,
AGE: 37 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. BHATARKI VILLAGE,
TQ. ALAND, DIST. KALABURAGI.
iii. KALLAPPA S/O PRABHU,
AGE: 36 YEARS, OCC: GOVT. SERVANT,
Digitally signed
by B NAGAVENI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
R/O. GUDUR VILLAGE,
TQ. AFZALPUR, DIST. KALABURAGI.
iv. YALLALING S/O PRABHU,
AGE: 30 YEARS, OCC: PVT. SERVICE,
R/O. GUDUR VILLAGE,
TQ. AFZALPUR, DIST. KALABURAGI.
v. NAGAMMA W/O BEERAPPA (D/O PRABHU),
AGE: 26 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. GOUDGAON,
TQ. ALAND, DIST. KALABURAGI.
3.
A)
SABAWWA
SINCE DECEASED THROUGH LRS., BY,
NAGAPPA S/O VITHAL MADNAHALLE,
AGE: 32 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
B) BASAWARAJ S/O VITHAL MADNAHALLE,
AGE: 40 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
BOTH R/O. TONASAHALLI TQ. CHITTAPUR,
DIST. KALABURAGI.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. RAVI B. PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. V. G. BIRADAR, ADVOCATE)
AND:
BHIMASHA S/O PEERAPPA NAIKODI,
AGE: 70 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. VILLAGE NEELUR, TQ. AFZALPUR,
DIST. KALABURAGI-585102.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. AMEET KUMAR DESHPANDE, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI. GANESH S. KALBURGI, ADVOCATE)
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 100 OF CPC, PRAYING TO
ALLOW THE APPEAL AND SET ASIDE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
PASSED IN R.A.NO.45/2015, DATED: 02-02-2017 BY I ADDL.
DISTRICT JUDGE AT KALABURAGI AND BE PLEASED TO DECREE THE
SUIT OF THE PLAINTIFFS/PRESENT APPELLANTS WHOLLY IN
O.S.NO.175/2012, DATED:30-05-2015 BY SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AT
AFZALPUR.
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
ORAL JUDGMENT
1. This Regular Second Appeal is filed by the appellants
challenging the judgment and decree dated
02.02.2017 passed in R.A.No.45 of 2015 by the
learned I-Additional District Judge, Kalaburagi.
2. For the sake of convenience, parties are referred to
based on their ranking before the Trial Court. The
appellants were the plaintiffs and the respondent was
the defendant.
3. Brief facts giving rise to filing of this appeal are as
under:
4. The plaintiffs filed a suit for declaration of title and
declaration that the Will Deed dated 15.11.1983
executed by the deceased-Dundawwa W/o Ningappa
Naikodi in favour of the defendant as null and void
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
and is not binding upon the plaintiffs and for
direction to the revenue authorities to rectify the
revenue records. It is contended that the suit
schedule property is left behind by their mother
Smt. Dundawwa. It is contended that she died
intestate. The defendant is no way concerned to the
suit property. The defendant has created a false and
bogus Will in the name of Dundawwa and got
mutated his name in the record of rights of the suit
land. The said entries were challenged before the
Assistant Commissioner by the plaintiffs. The
Assistant Commissioner directed the plaintiffs to
approach the Civil Court. Hence, the cause of action
arose for the plaintiffs to file the present suit. It is
further contended that the plaintiffs, being class-I
legal heirs of deceased-Dundawwa, have possessed
and inherited the suit property after her demise.
5. The defendant filed a written statement denying the
averments made in the plaint and it is stated that the
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
defendant is the son of Peerappa Naikodi, who is the
son of brother of Dundawwa's husband. In her
lifetime, the defendant has rendered service to her
and out of love and affection, she has executed a Will
bequeathing the suit schedule property in favour of
the defendant. It is submitted that after the demise
of Dundawwa, the name of the defendant was
entered based on the Will executed by Dundawwa in
favour of defendant. It is contended that the suit
filed by the plaintiffs is barred by limitation. Hence,
the defendant prayed to dismiss the suit.
6. The Trial Court, based on the rival pleadings of the
parties, framed the following issues:
“1. Whether the plaintiffs prove that they are
the only successors of the suit schedule
property to hold the ownership of the same
equally after the death of deceased
Dundawwa w/o Late Ningappa Naikodi?
2. Whether the plaintiffs further prove that
defendant is in no way concerned to the suit
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
schedule property and got mutated the suit
schedule property in his name by submitting
false and bogus will after the death of
Dundawwa?
3. Whether the plaintiffs further prove that
the alleged interference by the defendant in
respect of the suit schedule property?
4. Whether the plaintiffs further prove that
they are entitle for the relief to make
appropriate correction and entry of their
names as only legal representatives and
successor of deceased Dundawwa in RORS?
5. Whether plaintiffs further prove that the
alleged will dated 15.11.1983 is null and void
and not binding on them as it is a forged and
fabricated one?
6. Whether the defendant proves that the
deceased Dundawwa bequeathed the suit
schedule property in his favour and executed
will dated 15.11.1985?
7. Whether the defendant further proves that
based on the will dated 15.11.1985 his name
has been entered in revenue documents?
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
8. Whether the defendant proves that the suit
of the plaintiff is hopelessly time barred?
9. Whether the plaintiffs are entitle for the
relief sought?
10. What order or decree?”
7. In order to substantiate the case, plaintiffs examined
plaintiff No.1 as PW1 and plaintiff No.2 was
examined as PW2 and marked 19 documents as
Exs.P1 to P19. In rebuttal, the defendant examined
himself as DW1 and marked 61 documents as Exs.D1
to D61.
8. The Trial Court, after recording the evidence, hearing
both sides, after assessing the verbal and
documentary evidence, answered issue Nos.1, 2, 5
and 7 in the affirmative, issue Nos.3, 4, 6 and 8 in
the negative, issue No.9 partly in the affirmative and
issue No.10 as per the final order and the suit of the
plaintiffs was decreed in part with costs. It was
declared that the plaintiffs are the owners of the suit
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
property by succession and it was also declared that
the Will deed dated 15.11.1983 executed by the
deceased-Dundawwa W/o Ningappa Naikodi in favour
of the defendant is null and void and not binding
upon the plaintiffs and dismissed the suit in regard to
the rectification of the revenue records and
permanent injunction by judgment dated
30.05.2015.
9. The defendant aggrieved by the judgment and
decree dated 30.05.2015 passed in O.S.No.175 of
2012 preferred an appeal in R.A.No.45 of 2015 on
the file of I-Additional District Judge, Kalaburagi.
10. The First Appellate Court, after hearing the learned
counsel for the parties, framed the following points
for consideration:
“(1) Whether the appellant-defendant proves
that the reasons recorded by trial Court for
declaring the will deed as null and void,
document is perverse, arbitrary and illegal,
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
but there is evidence of the plaintiff to prove
the execution of the will deed by Smt.
Dundawwa during her lifetime?
(2) Whether the defendant further proves
that the part of the decree granted by trial
Court only for declaration of title of plaintiffs
in the suit property without there being relief
sought for recovery of possession is perverse,
arbitrary and illegal, but court is required to
dismiss the suit in its entirety?
(3) What order?”
11. The First Appellate Court, after re-appreciating the
entire evidence on record, answered point No.1 in
the negative, point No.2 in the affirmative and point
No.3 as per the final order and the appeal was
allowed. The judgment and decree dated 30.05.2015
passed in O.S.No.175 of 2012 was set aside by
judgment dated 02.02.2017.
12. The plaintiffs aggrieved by the judgment and decree
dated 02.02.2017 passed in R.A.No.45 of 2015 by I-
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
Additional District Judge, Kalaburagi, filed this
Regular Second Appeal.
13. Heard the arguments of Sri Ravi B. Patil, learned
counsel for the plaintiffs and Sri Ameet Kumar
Deshpande, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
Sri Ganesh S.Kalburgi, learned counsel for the
defendant.
14. Learned counsel for the plaintiffs submits that the
defendant has got created the Will alleged to have
been executed by Dundawwa in favour of the
defendant. He submits that Dundawwa died intestate
and the plaintiffs being class-I legal heirs of
Smt.Dundawwa, after her demise, have succeeded to
the suit schedule property. The First Appellate Court,
without considering the said aspect, has reversed the
judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court. He
submits that the impugned judgment passed by the
First Appellate Court is arbitrary and erroneous.
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
Hence, on these grounds, he prays to allow the
appeal.
15. Per contra , learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
defendant submits that mere suit for declaration
without seeking consequential relief of possession is
not maintainable as per proviso to Section 34 of the
Specific Relief Act, 1963. To buttress his arguments,
he has placed reliance on the judgment of the
Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Vasantha (Dead)
through Legal Representative v. Rajalakshmi alias
1
Rajam (Dead) through Legal Representatives . He
submits that the First Appellate Court was justified in
passing the impugned judgment. Hence, on these
grounds, he prays to dismiss the appeal.
16. This Court vide order dated 12.02.2021 admitted the
appeal to consider the following substantial questions
of law:
1
(2024) 5 SCC 282
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
“i. Whether the First Appellate Court justified
in reversing the judgment and decree of the
Trial Court?
ii. Whether the First Appellate Court justified
in dismissing the suit on the ground that the
plaintiffs have not sought the relief of
recovery of possession?”
Reg. Substantial Questions of Law (i) & (ii):
17. Both the substantial questions of law are interlinked
and hence, they are taken up together for common
discussion in order to avoid repetition of the facts.
18. The plaintiffs have filed a suit for declaration to
declare that they are the owners and to declare that
the Will Deed alleged to have been executed by
Dundawwa in favour of the defendant as null and
void. To substantiate their case, legal representatives
of plaintiff No.1 was examined as PW1 and she has
reiterated the plaint averments in the examination in
chief. In order to prove that the suit schedule
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
property was owned and possessed by Dundawwa,
the plaintiffs have produced the RTC extract marked
as Ex.P3. The plaintiffs have produced the genealogy
marked as Ex.P1, Death Certificate of Dundawwa
marked as Ex.P4, mutation extracts marked as
Exs.P5, P14 and P15, and RTC extracts marked as
Exs.P7 to P9, P13 and P16 to P19.
19. After her demise, the plaintiffs being class-I heirs
have succeeded to the suit schedule property. It is
contended that the defendant has got created the
Will alleged to have been executed by Dundawwa in
favour of the defendant bequeathing the suit land. It
is contended that the defendant has no right, title or
interest over the suit schedule property.
20. During the course of cross examination, PW1 has
clearly admitted that the plaintiffs are not in
possession of the suit schedule property. Even after
examination of PW1, the plaintiffs have not made
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
any application for amendment to the plaint seeking
a relief of possession.
21. In rebuttal, the defendant examined himself as DW1
and he has deposed that the property was owned
and possessed by Smt. Dundawwa and father of the
defendant was taking care of Smt. Dundawwa.
Therefore, out of love and affection, Dundawwa
executed a Will bequeathing the suit land in favour of
the defendant. The defendant has produced the
Original Will Deed marked as Ex.D47. After the
demise of Dundawwa, the defendant based on
Ex.D47 got transferred the property in his name and
the mutation entry is marked as Ex.D31. The said
mutation was effected in 1986. Land revenue
payment receipts are marked as Exs.D1 to D13. The
defendant has produced the record of rights extracts
marked as Exs.D14 to D30.
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
22. The plaintiffs challenged the mutation order before
the Assistant Commissioner in 2008 and the
Assistant Commissioner directed the plaintiffs to
approach the Civil Court.
23. From the perusal of the cross-examination of PW1, it
is clear that the plaintiffs are out of possession of the
suit schedule property. The plaintiffs ought to have
filed a suit for declaration and consequential relief of
possession. Admittedly, the plaintiffs have not sought
a consequential relief of possession. In order to
consider the case on hand, it is necessary to examine
Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, which
reads as follows:
“ 34. Discretion of court as to declaration
of status or right.— Any person entitled to
any legal character, or to any right as to any
property, may institute a suit against any
person denying, or interested to deny, his
title to such character or right, and the court
may in its discretion make therein a
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
declaration that he is so entitled, and the
plaintiff need not in such suit ask for any
further relief:
Provided that no court shall make any
such declaration where the plaintiff, being
able to seek further relief than a mere
declaration of title, omits to do so.”
24. From the bare reading of proviso to Section 34 of the
Specific Relief Act, it is clear that no Court shall make
any such declaration where the plaintiff being able to
seek further relief than a mere declaration of title,
omits to do so.
25. Admittedly, in the instant case, the plaintiffs have
omitted to claim a relief of possession.
26. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Vasantha
supra in paragraphs-49 to 52 has held as under:
"49. We now proceed to examine the law on
this issue. As submitted by the learned Senior
Counsel for the appellant, in Vinay Krishna v.
Keshav Chandra [Vinay Krishna v. Keshav
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
Chandra, 1993 Supp (3) SCC 129] (two-Judge
Bench), this Court while considering Section
42 of the erstwhile Specific Relief Act, 1877 to
be pari materia with Section 34 of SRA, 1963
observed that the plaintiff's not being in
possession of the property in that case ought
to have amended the plaint for the relief of
recovery of possession in view of the bar
included by the proviso.
50. This position has been followed by this
Court in Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin (two-
Judge Bench), elaborated the position of a
suit filed without the consequential relief. It
was observed : (SCC p. 173, paras 55-58)
“55. The section provides that courts
have discretion as to declaration of
status or right, however, it carves out
an exception that a court shall not make
any such declaration of status or right
where the complainant, being able to
seek further relief than a mere
declaration of title, omits to do so.
56. In Ram Saran v. Ganga Devi [Ram
Saran v. Ganga Devi, (1973) 2 SCC 60]
this Court had categorically held that
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
the suit seeking for declaration of title
of ownership but where possession is
not sought, is hit by the proviso to
Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act,
1963 and, thus, not maintainable. In
Vinay Krishna v. Keshav Chandra [Vinay
Krishna v. Keshav Chandra, 1993 Supp
(3) SCC 129] this Court dealt with a
similar issue where the plaintiff was not
in exclusive possession of property and
had filed a suit seeking declaration of
title of ownership. Similar view has been
reiterated observing that the suit was
not maintainable, if barred by the
proviso to Section 34 of the Specific
Relief Act. (See also Gian Kaur v.
Raghubir Singh [Gian Kaur v. Raghubir
Singh, (2011) 4 SCC 567 : (2011) 2
SCC (Civ) 366] .)
57. In view of the above, the law
becomes crystal clear that it is not
permissible to claim the relief of
declaration without seeking
consequential relief.
58. In the instant case, the suit for
declaration of title of ownership had
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
been filed, though Respondent 1-
plaintiff was admittedly not in
possession of the suit property. Thus,
the suit was barred by the provisions of
Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act and,
therefore, ought to have been dismissed
solely on this ground. The High Court
though framed a substantial question on
this point but for unknown reasons did
not consider it proper to decide the
same.”
51. In Venkataraja v. Vidyane
Doureradjaperumal [Venkataraja v. Vidyane
Doureradjaperumal, (2014) 14 SCC 502 :
(2015) 1 SCC (Civ) 360] (two-Judge Bench),
the purpose behind Section 34 was elucidated
by this Court. It was observed that the
purpose behind the inclusion of the proviso is
to prevent multiplicity of proceedings. It was
further expounded that a mere declaratory
decree remains non-executable in most cases.
This Court noted that the suit was never
amended, even at a later stage to seek the
consequential relief and therefore, it was held
to be not maintainable. This position of law
has been reiterated recently in Akkamma v.
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
Vemavathi [Akkamma v. Vemavathi, (2021)
18 SCC 371] (two-Judge Bench).
52. This Court in Arulmigu Chokkanatha
Swamy Koil Trust v. Chandran [Arulmigu
Chokkanatha Swamy Koil Trust v. Chandran,
(2017) 3 SCC 702 : (2017) 2 SCC (Civ) 334]
(two-Judge Bench), while reversing the High
Court decree, observed that because of
Section 34 of the SRA, 1963, the plaintiff not
being in possession and claiming only
declaratory relief, ought to have claimed the
relief of recovery of possession. It was held
that the trial court rightly dismissed the suit
on the basis that the plaintiff has filed a suit
for a mere declaration without relief for
recovery, which is clearly not maintainable.”
27. From reading of the above judgment, it is clear that
mere suit for declaration of title and permanent
injunction without seeking relief of possession is not
maintainable. The First Appellate Court, considering
the said aspect, has rightly held that the suit for
declaration of title is not maintainable. Further, the
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
Trial Court has dismissed the suit for permanent
injunction. The plaintiffs did not prefer any appeal
challenging dismissal of the suit for perpetual
injunction. Therefore, the judgment and decree of
the Trial Court dismissing the suit for perpetual
injunction has attained finality.
28. The First Appellate Court, after re-appreciating the
entire evidence on record, has rightly reversed the
judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court and
rightly dismissed the suit as per proviso to Section
34 of the Specific Relief Act. The impugned judgment
and decree passed by the First Appellate Court is just
and proper and the same do not call for any
interference.
29. In view of the above discussion, I answer substantial
questions of law Nos.1 and 2 in the negative.
30. Accordingly, I proceed to pass the following:
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11748
RSA No. 200078 of 2017
CNR: KAHC030014112017
ORDER
i. The appeal is dismissed .
ii. The judgment and decree dated
02.02.2017 passed in R.A.No.45/2015
by the learned I-Additional District
Judge, Kalaburagi, is hereby
confirmed.
iii. No order as to the costs.
Sd/-
(ASHOK S. KINAGI)
JUDGE
NB
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 3
Ct:pk