STATE OF WEST BENGAL vs ASHOK SINGH
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction
(Appellate Side)
DR 2 of 2025
State of West Bengal
v.
Ashok Singh
With
CRA (DB)/328/2025
Ashok Singh
v.
State of West Bengal & Anr.
Before: The Hon’ble Justice Arijit Banerjee
&
The Hon’ble Justice Apurba Sinha Ray
For the Appellant/convict
: Mr. Amit Ranjan Pati, Adv.
Ms. Swastika Chowdhury, Adv.
Ms. Ilika Nag, Adv.
Mr. Yavik Singhal, Adv.
Mr. Avijit Chatterjee, Adv.
Advocates who are appointed by
Calcutta High Court Legal Services
Committee
: Mr. Kaushik Gupta, Sr. Adv,
Mr. Apalak Basu, Adv.
For the State : Mr. Jayanta Narayan Chatterjee,
Spl. PP,
Mr. Santanu Talukdar, Adv.
Ms. Moumita Pandit, Adv.
Mr. Supreme Naskar, Adv.
Ms. Ritushree Banerjee, Adv.
……Advocates
CAV on : 06.10.2026
For Judgment : 17.11. 2026
Page 1 of 72
Apurba Sinha Ray, J.:-
1. By a judgment and order dated January 15/17, 2025, the learned Judge,
Exclusive POCSO Court, Chinsurah, Hooghly, convicted the appellant for
committing offence under Sections 65(2)/64(2)(1)/66 and 163 (1) of the
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (in Short ‘BNS’) and under Section 6(1) of
the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (in short
‘POCSO Act’) and sentenced the appellant to suffer imprisonment for the
remainder of his natural life for commission of offence under Section
64(2)(1) of the BNS. The learned Judge imposed the death sentence on
the appellant for commission of offences under Sections 103(1)/66/65(2)
of the BNS and under Section 6(1) of the POCSO Act. This has resulted in
the present death reference at the State’s instance and the appeal at the
instance of the convict.
2. The prosecution case, briefly stated, is that the victim girl’s (in short
‘V.G’) family and the appellant reside in the same locality. In fact, they
are almost neighbours. The appellant’s house is a few houses away from
the house of the V.G.
1/2
3. On November 24, 2024, when the V.G was about 5/5 years old, the
mother of the V.G asked her husband to purchase meat for the V.G. The
father of the V.G (P.W.1), accordingly went to the market in the afternoon
to purchase meat for his daughter. When he returned home he found his
daughter and son were present and his wife was cooking rice. He again
Page 2 of 72
went to the market in the evening as was his regular routine. At about
7/7.30 P.M. he returned home from the market. He found only his wife
and son in the house. He inquired about his daughter from his wife. He
was told that their daughter had gone to the house of Mandira Jethima.
The V.G used to visit Mandira Jethima’s house frequently. P.W. 1 asked
his wife to bring back their daughter from Mandira Jethima’s house. His
wife went to Mandira’s house but came back alone and informed P.W. 1
that their daughter had left Mandira’s house quite some time before. At
the time when the wife of P.W. 1 was going to Mandira’s house in the
search of their daughter, she saw the appellant standing at the entrance
of his house wearing a gamcha. The appellant told the wife of P.W. 1 that
her daughter had not visited his house.
4. In the above circumstances, P.W. 1 and his wife started searching for
their daughter here and there. They went to all the houses which the V.G
frequently visited. However, the V.G could not be traced. Then they went
to the house of the appellant accompanied by other people of the locality
who were also searching for the V.G. The appellant refused them entry to
his house. They forcefully entered the appellant’s house. Inside the
appellant’s room they found the V.G lying on a ‘balaposh’ on the floor.
She had no clothes on her body. She was covered with a mosquito net.
She was bleeding from her vagina. She was in an unconscious state. The
wearing apparels of the V.G were stacked next to the ‘balaposh’.
Chandana Mondal, a neighbour of the V.G’s family, took the V.G on her
lap and handed over the V.G to her mother. The V.G’s mother in turn
Page 3 of 72
handed over the V.G to her father (P.W.1) and hurried to fetch clothes for
the V.G. The V.G’s mother brought some clothes and dressed up the V.G.
Another neighbour, Biplab Roy brought his motorbike and took P.W 1
and the V.G on the motorbike to Dhaniakhali Hospital. The doctor
examined the V.G and declared her to be dead.
5. The police started an investigation. The appellant was taken into custody.
A chargesheet was issued. The charge was framed by the Trial Court
under 5 heads, i.e., under Sections 65(2), 64(2)(1), 66, 103 of the BNS
and Section 6 of the POCSO Act.
6. The appellant pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
7. The prosecution examined 27 witnesses. The defence examined none.
8. In his evidence, P.W. 1, being the father of the V.G. and the de-facto
complainant, reiterated more or less what he stated in the written
complaint which is substantially what I have discussed above as the
prosecution case.
9. P.W. 2, Subrata Ruidas was a resident of the neighbourhood. He deposed
that he was one of the persons who forcefully entered the house of the
appellant and discovered the V.G. in a bleeding condition. His deposition
corroborates that of P.W. 1.
10. P.W. 3 is the mother of the V.G. Her evidence was in tune with that of
P.W.s 1 and 2. Additionally she said that when she was returning from
the house of Mandira after being told that the V.G. had left Mandira’s
house long before, she saw the appellant standing on the ‘Dhalai’ Road.
Page 4 of 72
On seeing her, the appellant, who used to address the V.G. as ‘jethu’, on
his own volition told her that “jethu did not come to my house”.
11. P.W. 4 is Mandira Singh, whose house the V.G. had visited on the
fateful day. Mandira confirmed the factum of such a visit and that upon
being told that Mandira’s daughter was not at home, the V.G. left her
house. Mandira was one of the members of the group which started
looking for the V.G. and ultimately discovered the V.G. in the appellant’s
house. The evidence of P.W. 4 is in consonance with the evidence of
P.W.s 1 to 3.
12. P.W. 5, Chaitali Pandit is a resident of the neighbourhood. She
deposed that on the date of the occurrence, she had gone to fetch water
from the local tubewell in the evening. There is a lamp post beside that
tube well. She saw the victim girl was near the tubewell. She had come
from the left side of the ‘dhalai’ road where the houses of the appellant,
Bifol Samui and Mandira Singh are situate. The appellant came to the
spot and told the V.G. to accompany him to his house saying that he will
give her chocolates. The V.G. followed the appellant to his house. P.W. 5
did not stop the V.G. from going to the appellant’s house as she did not
apprehend anything untoward. The V.G. used to call the appellant ‘jethu’
and she did not find anything wrong in the appellant calling the V.G. to
his house. After returning home when she was in the bathroom she
heard the V.G.’s mother calling her by name. She could not respond from
the bathroom and was not in a position to come out from the bathroom
immediately. At about 7/7.30 p.m. she heard hue and cry in her locality.
Page 5 of 72
She went outside and saw the V.G.’s mother coming out from the house
of the appellant with her daughter being the V.G. She said that at that
point of time she was so perplexed and frightened that she could not tell
the fellow villagers that she had seen the appellant taking the V.G. to his
house. In cross examination she said that she never told the police or the
Magistrate that she saw the appellant on the day of the occurrence, in
the evening, taking the V.G. with him. Nor did she tell the same to the
fellow villagers.
13. P.W. 6 is Chandana Mondal, another member of the search party
which discovered the V.G. in the appellant’s house. Her evidence
corroborates the evidence of P.W.s 1 to 4.
14. P.W. 7 Biplab Roy is the person who took V.G. and her father to the
hospital on his motorbike.
15. P.W. 8 Bulu Mondal was another member of the search party which
discovered the V.G. in the appellant’s house. His evidence is in
consonance with the evidence of other prosecution witnesses who were
also members of the search party.
16. P.W. 9 and P.W. 10 are seizure witnesses who supported the
prosecution case.
17. P.W. 11 was a Sub-Inspector of Police, Bapi Halder according to whose
instruction a G.D. entry was made as regards the incident. P.W. 12 is
another Sub-Inspector of Police, who deposed that he along with his
Page 6 of 72
colleagues rescued the appellant who was being beaten up by fellow
villagers and admitted the appellant to Polba Hospital.
18. P.W. 13 is a photographer who took photos of the scene of crime.
19. P.W. 14 and P.W. 15 are not very important witnesses.
20. P.W. 16, Dr. Sandip Ghosh, was the Assistant Director, (Biology
Division), State Forensic Science Laboratory, Belgachia, Kolkata. He
conducted the requisite forensic test on the wearing apparels and other
seized items. The long and short of the evidence of P.W. 16 is that “DNA
of the accused is found in swab collected from labia right and perineum
of the victim.”
21. P.W. 17 is the doctor who conducted the post mortem of the V.G.’s
dead body. He deposed in detail the injuries found on the private parts of
the V.G. as also on her scapula. He said that such genital injuries are
only possible in case of a 5 years old girl if she is subjected to sexual
assault. He also said that the kind of injury that was noticed on the V.G’s
scapula is possible if the victim is forced against any wall or floor. He
said that “all the injuries were recent and some of them were life
threatening. The crux of his evidence is that “death of deceased was due
to effects of intracranial haemorrhage associated with signs of recent
forceful penetration of vagina and anus. The manner of death is found
homicidal.”
22. P.W. 18 is a Clinical Psychologist who was at the relevant time,
attached to Chandannagore Sub-divisional Hospital and Imambara Sadar
Page 7 of 72
Hospital, Chinsurah. She examined the appellant on December 3, 2024.
The gist of his deposition is as follows:-
“On examination I found no thought or perceptual disturbance, he
was found jittery in his general appearance, he was able to
communicate needs.
I found poor insight of said Ashok Singh which means he was able to
communicate his requirements but his requirements in parlance with
practical field or reality.
I put NIMHANS mental health screening questionnaire to Ashok Singh
and I did not find any disorientation, or any presence of his mental
illness.
I did not get any history of his physical or mental illness nor I found
any such illness in him after examination.
This is a report prepared and signed by me.
The report is marked as Exhibit-P-26 .”
23. P.W. 19 is the Doctor, who at the relevant point of time was attached
to Imambara Sadar Hospital, Chinsurah as Clinical Biochemist. Under her
instruction blood sample of the appellant was drawn.
24. P.W. 20 was a staff nurse at Imambara Sadar Hospital on the night
the appellant was admitted to the hospital after having been lynched by
fellow villagers. Her evidence is not of much significance.
25. P.W. 21 is the inquest Doctor.
Page 8 of 72
26. P.W. 22 is the Investigating Officer. He supported the prosecution
case.
27. P.W. 23, Dr. Partha Bose, was posted as Medical Officer at District
Hospital, Chinsurah, on November 27, 2024, when he examined the
appellant. He deposed, inter alia, as follows:-
“I finally opined that the accused was capable of performing sexual
intercourse mentioning that nothing is revealed against the normal sexual
capability. I found him physically and mentally fit”.
28. P.W. 24 is another Police Officer. P.W. 25 was the Superintendent of
Chinsurah, Imambara Sadar Hospital, at the relevant point of time. The
evidence of these two witnesses are not of much significance.
29. P.W. 26, Dr. Soumya Sarkar was the Medical Officer of the
Dhaniakhali Rural Hospital on November 24, 2024, when the V.G. was
taken to that hospital from the appellant’s house. This witness examined the
V.G. and declared her to be dead. P.W. 27 is the Staff Nurse of Dhaniakhali
Rural Hospital in whose presence and with whose help P.W. 26 examined
the V.G.
30. The appellant was examined under Section 351 of BNSS (Section 313
of Cr.P.C.). His case was one of complete denial. He said that on the day of
the incident he returned to his home from work at 6.45 p.m. and after
keeping his cycle and changing his dress, he sat outside on the ‘Dhalai’
Road in front of the house. He does not know what happened in the locality.
He denied having told the V.G.’s mother (P.W. 3) that the V.G. has not
Page 9 of 72
visited his house. While admitting that the search party found the V.G.
inside his house, he said that he does not know how the V.G. was found
there. He further said that he never prevented anyone from entering his
house. He also said that he does not know in what condition the victim was
found in his house. He was beaten up by the villagers. He does not know
what happened thereafter.
31. Learned Trial Judge on an assimilation of the evidence on record held
that there is sufficient evidence to sustain the prosecution case. The
depositions of P.W. 1 to P.W. 8 corroborate each other. The circumstances of
the case indubitably indicate the appellant as the perpetrator of the crime.
The V.G. was last seen with the appellant by P.W. 5. The forensic evidence
conclusively establishes that the appellant committed penetrative sexual
assault on the V.G. The omission on the part of P.W. 1 (complainant) to
state certain facts in the written complaint is in-consequential. The written
complaint or FIR is not meant to be an encyclopaedia of all relevant facts.
32. The learned Trial Judge referred to the following decisions:-
(i) Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, reported at
(1984) 4 SCC 116 : the facts established should be consistent only with the
hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should not be
explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is guilty. There
must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any reasonable
grounds for the conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and
must show that in all human probability the act must have been done by
the accused.
Page 10 of 72
(ii) Bhim Singh v. State of Uttarakhand reported at (2015) 4 SCC 281 :
Court can act on the basis of circumstantial evidence only when the
circumstances proved are complete and of such conclusive nature that it is
fully inconsistent with the innocence of the accused and are not explainable
on any other hypothesis except the guilt of the accused. No link in
circumstantial evidence should be missing. The chain has to be complete in
all respects so as to indicate the guilt of the accused and also exclude any
other theory of the crime.
(iii) SailendraRajdevPasvan v. State of Gujarat reported at AIR 2020 SC
180 : An important aspect to be considered in a case resting on
circumstantial evidence is the lapse of time between the point when the
accused and deceased were seen together and when the deceased is found
dead. It ought to be so minimal as to exclude the possibility of any
intervening event involving the death at the hands of some other person. The
last seen theory comes into play where the time gap between the point of
time when the accused and deceased were seen last alive and when the
deceased is found dead is so small that the possibility of any person other
than the accused being the author of crime becomes impossible.
33. Learned Trial Judge also relied on the presumption of commission of
offence and presumption of culpable mental state as provided in Sections 29
and 30 of the POCSO Act. Learned Judge summed up her findings in the
following words:-
“21. In the light of the above discussion it is proved that the accused
Ashok Singh committed rape upon an innocent, helpless minor girl aged
Page 11 of 72
about 5 years 10 months taking advantage of her faith and trust on
him. The accused did it with well planning. He was aware of movement
of the victim girl who happened to be his neighbour. He also calculated
it that his house is located in such position where movement of villagers
is less specially in the evening, at a distance from 'dhalai’ road of their
para and his rooms are not visible from his nearby houses. He took the
immature, innocent victim girl to his such house on the pretext of giving
chocolate and raped her there. The victim trusted the accused whom
she used to address as 'Jethu' by village courtesy. Prosecution further
proved it by adducing medical evidence that when the victim was
subjected to rape she was brutally tortured by the accused in such
fashion that she had subdural haemorrhage on her scalp. He also
forcefully penetrated into her vagina and anus. Such torture became
unbearable to a little girl of 5 years and she died. The manner in which
the victim was subjected to physical and sexual torture every sane and
reasonable person would be sure of her death. The accused without
showing any mercy to her continued that brutality and ultimately
eradicated her from the world. 22. In view of the above discussion I am
constrained to hold that the totality of the evidence leads to come to an
irresistible conclusion that prosecution has proved the charges against
the accused person beyond all reasonable doubts and the accused
person is liable to be convicted in this case for the offences punishable
U/s 65(2)/64(2)(1)/66/103(1) of the B.N.S and u/s-6(1) of the POCSO
Act. 23. Accordingly, this court convicts the accused person namely
Page 12 of 72
Ashok Singh for the offence punishable U/s 65(2)/64(2) (1)/66/103(1)
of the BNS and U/s 6(1) of the POCSO Act.”
Argument advanced on behalf of the appellant:
34. Learned Counsel Mr. Pati submits that the conviction of the appellant
is based exclusively on circumstantial evidence. There was no eye-witness.
In such cases the prosecution must satisfy a five-fold test:- (i) the
circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn must be
fully established; (ii) the facts so established must be consistent only with
the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused; (iii) the circumstances must be of
a conclusive nature and tendency; (iv) they must exclude every possible
hypothesis except the one to be proved; and (v) there must be a chain of
evidence so complete as to leave no reasonable ground for a conclusion
consistent with the innocence of the accused.
35. The prosecution has failed to satisfy any of the aforesaid
requirements. The chain of circumstances, as sought to be woven by the
prosecution, is replete with material gaps, irreconcilable contradictions and
suspicious improvements, each of which has the cumulative effect of
snapping the chain at multiple junctures. The present case does not merely
raise a reasonable doubt- it raises a profound and reducible uncertainty
regarding the guilt of the appellant. The ‘Last Seen Together’ theory is
unreliable and legally inadmissible as a conclusive link in the chain of
circumstances. The prosecution seeks to rely on the testimony of P.W. 5 as
the ‘Last Seen Together’ witness, which constitutes the foundational
circumstance of the prosecution case. The said testimony is wholly
Page 13 of 72
unreliable, legally suspect and unsafe to form the basis of conviction for the
following reasons:
(a) The allegation that the appellant was seen taking the victim to his
house on the pretext of offering chocolate finds no mention in the
written complaint lodged by P.W.1, the de facto complainant and the
victim’s father. This is a fatal infirmity going to the root of the
prosecution case.
(b) The allegation also does not find reflection in the statements of
P.W.3, P.W.6, P.W.7 and P.W.8 who are equally material prosecution
witnesses.
(c) P.W. 5 has admitted in the course of cross-examination that she did
not disclose the said alleged fact either before the learned Magistrate
recording her statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C. or before the
Investigating Officer (P.W.22). This admission constitutes a material
omission of the gravest character which amounts to a contradiction
within the meaning of Section 162 Cr.P.C. and is sufficient to impeach
the creditworthiness of the witness as has been held by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in State of Rajasthan v. Raja Ram reported at
(2003) 8 SCC 180 . An improved version introduced for the first time at
trial, calculated to fill a lacuna in the chain of circumstances, cannot
be accepted as reliable evidence forming a link in a chain that must be
forged beyond reasonable doubt.
36. The prosecution has failed to establish one of the most elementary
facts in the chain of circumstances, viz , how P.W.1, the de facto
complainant, came to know or had reason to believe that the victim was
Page 14 of 72
present in the house of the appellant. This gap in the narrative is not a
minor irregularity; it is a chasm that swallows the entire prosecution
edifice.
37. P.W.1 has categorically deposed that it was P.W.3 who informed him
that the victim had gone to the house of one Tapas Singh. The identity of
Taposh Singh has been left in the dark. He has not been examined by the
prosecution as a witness and no explanation has been offered for such
omission. Deliberate non-examination of a witness who is a crucial link in
the chain of circumstances entitles the Court to draw an adverse inference
against the prosecution.
38. The depositions of the post-occurrence witnesses, i.e., P.W.1, P.W.3 to
P.W. 8, who claim to have either participated in the discovery of the victim
or to have been present at the scene, are fundamentally inconsistent with
each other on material particulars, rendering their collective testimony
wholly unreliable. In particular, P.W. 4 has admitted in cross-examination
that she did not state before the Investigating Officer that she had seen the
victim lying on a ‘balaposh’ covered with a mosquito net inside the
appellant’s house. A material omission of this nature, pertaining to a
specific, vivid and significant detail, constitutes a contradiction within the
meaning of Section 162 Cr.P.C. and must be treated as casting serious
doubt on the prosecution case. Learned Trial Court committed a grave error
in treating the mutually contradictory and omission – ridden testimonies of
the said witnesses as corroborative evidence.
39. Assuming for the sake of argument that recovery of the victim from
the appellant’s house is accepted, even then, the prosecution has failed to
Page 15 of 72
establish that the said house was in the exclusive possession or occupation
of the appellant at the relevant time or that the appellant was present
therein when the alleged incident occurred. In the absence of cogent proof of
his exclusive presence at the place of the alleged offence, the mere factum of
recovery cannot be treated as a circumstance conclusively pointing to the
guilt of the appellant. The hypothesis of the appellant being falsely
implicated -–which has been constantly pressed by the defence remains a
perfectly plausible alternative and has not been ruled out by the
prosecution.
40. In view of the aforesaid, the prosecution has failed to establish the
guilt of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt, much less to prove a
complete and unbroken chain of circumstances leading inevitably to the
guilt of the appellant and excluding every other hypothesis consistent with
his innocence. In a capital case, where an irreversible penalty has been
imposed, the standard of proof must be applied with utmost vigour. If two
views are reasonably possible on the basis of the evidence on record- one
pointing to the guilt of the accused and the other to his innocence- the
Court is bound to adopt the view favourable to the accused. The existence of
serious doubts and loopholes in the prosecution case as discussed above
makes this a textbook case for acquittal. Hence, this Court should set aside
the appellant’s conviction under Sections 65(2)/64(2)(i)/66/103 of the BNS
read with Section 6 of the POCSO Act.
41. Without prejudice to the primary prayer for acquittal and the
submissions made in support thereof, and strictly in the alternative- in the
event this Court declines to interfere with the conviction- it was submitted
Page 16 of 72
that the death sentence imposed upon the appellant is unsustainable in
law, vitiated by multiple legal infirmities and deserves to be commuted to
imprisonment for life for the following reasons:
(a) Section 354 (3) of the Cr.P.C., as interpreted by the Constitution
Bench in Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC 684 ,
mandates that the sentence of imprisonment for life is the rule and
death is the exception. The sentencing Court must record ‘special
reasons’ before imposing the death penalty. This requirement is not a
mere procedural formality; it is a substantive constitutional safeguard
against arbitrary or mechanical sentencing. The reasons assigned by
learned Trial Court in the sentencing order impugned in this appeal,
are wholly generic, exclusively crime-centric, bereft of individualised
assessment of the appellant and therefore do not constitute ‘special
reasons’ within the meaning of Section 354(3) of the Cr.P.C.
(b) In Bachan Singh, Supra , the Supreme Court held that the
sentencing Court must, as a mandatory constitutional requirement,
balance the aggravating circumstances relating to the crime against the
mitigating circumstances relating to the criminal. This dual balancing
exercise- attending both to the crime and to the individual-is the
irreducible minimum that the Constitution demands before the
irrevocable step of taking a human life by judicial order. The impugned
sentencing order reflects a complete failure to undertake this
mandatory exercise. The learned Trial Court has focused exclusively on
the nature and gravity of the alleged offence, without any attempt
whatsoever to assess the mitigating circumstances peculiar to the
Page 17 of 72
appellant as an individual. No inquiry was made into his socio-
economic background, family circumstances, educational attainment,
prior conduct, psychological condition or reformative potential. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court deprecated the practice of balancing ‘numbers’
of aggravating and mitigating circumstances and emphasised that the
exercise must be qualitative, not quantitative, and must be founded on
a complete factual record. No such record was assembled or considered
here.
42. In Swamy Shraddananda (2) vs State of Karnataka reported at
(2008) 13 SCC 767 , the Hon’ble Supreme Court recognised and constituted
a third sentencing category- a sentence of life imprisonment with the specific
stipulation that the convict shall not be released or granted remission for
the remainder of his natural life or for a specified term. This intermediate
category exists as an alternative to death for cases that are grave but which
may not meet the true threshold of the ‘ rarest of rare’ doctrine. Learned Trial
Court has entirely failed to advert to this option, to consider whether it
would adequately serve the ends of justice and to assign reasons for
declining to accept that option. This omission constitutes an independent
legal error vitiating the sentencing order.
43. The Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Manoj and Ors., v.
State of Madhya Pradesh reported at (2023) 2 SCC 353 laid down an
elaborate, comprehensive and binding framework for capital sentencing. The
Constitution Bench held that the sentencing Court is under an absolute
duty to call for and consider reports concerning the social, educational
economic and familial background of the accused; obtain a psychological
Page 18 of 72
evaluation of the accused; meaningfully consider the probability or
impossibility of rehabilitation and reformation of the accused; and ensure
that the evidence regarding mitigating circumstances is placed before the
Court and assessed with the same rigour as aggravating circumstances. The
failure to undertake this exercise is not a procedural irregularity but a
constitutional infirmity vitiating the sentence. In the present case, whilst
relevant reports may have been placed before the learned Trial Court, there
is a complete absence in the sentencing order of any meaningful
engagement with or discussion of contents of those reports, the appellant’s
personal background, his mental and psychological condition or his
reformative potential.
44. The present case is squarely covered by the ratio decidendi of
Mohmmad Firoz v. State reported at (2022) 7 SCC 443 , wherein the
Hon’ble Supreme Court commuted the sentence of death to life
imprisonment in a case involving the rape and murder of a four-year old girl.
The Court commuted the sentence upon finding that: i) The prosecution had
failed to establish that the accused was wholly beyond the possibility of
reform or rehabilitation; ii) the mitigating circumstances had not been
adequately considered by the Trial Court; and iii) the case did not satisfy the
stringent threshold of the ‘ rarest of rare’ doctrine. The factual matrix of that
case is, in all material respects, identical to the present case- involving a
child victim, similar charges and analogous evidentiary infirmities in the
sentencing exercise. On the principle of parity and consistency, which the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has emphasized as a constitutional imperative in
capital sentencing, the appellant is entitled to the same relief of
Page 19 of 72
commutation. The ‘ rarest of rare’ doctrine enunciated in Bachan Singh,
Supra , clarified in a long line of subsequent decisions, requires the Court to
make a positive finding- based on evidence and not assumption- that the
accused is beyond any redemption, that no lesser alternative sentence can
adequately serve the twin purposes of deterrence and justice and that the
case stands entirely apart from all other cases of its genre in terms of sheer
depravity and irredeemable culpability. This high standard has not been
satisfied in the present case. Learned Trial Court has not recorded any
finding- supported by evidence or material- that the appellant is incapable of
reform or rehabilitation. This lacuna is not merely a procedural deficiency; it
is a pre-condition for the exercise of capital sentencing jurisdiction and its
absence is fatal to the validity of the death sentence.
Argument of the State:-
45. Learned Special Public Prosecutor Mr. Jayanta Narayan Chatterjee
(in short ‘SPP’) representing the State pointed out that the victim was last
seen with the appellant by P.W. 5. Although P.W. 5 in her deposition before
the learned Trial Court, in cross examination said that she never told the
police or the Magistrate that she saw the appellant on the day of the
occurrence, taking the V.G., in fact, while recording her statement under
Section 164 Cr.P.C., she told the Magistrate about such fact.
46. Learned SPP submitted that a number of prosecution witnesses
discovered the V.G. in the appellant’s house. Their depositions corroborate
each other. The appellant could not offer any explanation as to how the V.G.
landed up in his house and was found in an almost dead condition. The
Page 20 of 72
explanation offered by the appellant in his examination under Section 313
Cr.P.C. is utterly incredible.
47. Learned SPP then drew our attention to the evidence of the post
mortem doctor which clearly indicates severe sexual assault of the V.G. He
deposed that the manner of death of the V.G. was homicidal.
48. Learned SPP pointed out that the Assistant Director (Biology Division),
State Forensic Science Laboratory, Belgachia, Kolkata had forensically
tested the wearing apparels of the V.G. His report showed the presence of
DNA of the accused in swabs collected from labia right and perineum of the
V.G.. This conclusively establishes rape of the V.G. by the appellant.
49. Learned SPP submitted that in view of the overwhelming incriminating
evidence against the appellant, there is absolutely no scope for interfering
with the order of conviction. Mr. Chatterjee has relied upon the following
judgments in support of his contention that the accused Ashok Singh had
committed heinous offences against the minor victim and his position,
status, mental set up show that he is beyond reformation.
i. Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab reported in reported in
(1980) 2 SCC 684
ii. Machhi Singh and Anr Vs State of Punjab reported in (1983 )
3 SCC 470
iii. Santosh Kumar SatisbhushanBariyar vs State of
Maharashtra, Criminal Appeal no. 1478 of 2005
iv. Dhananjoy Chatterjee alias Dhana vs State of West Bengal
reported in (1994)2 SCC 220
Page 21 of 72
v. Purushottam Dashrath Borate vs The State of Maharashtra
reported in (2015)6 SCC 652
vi. Bantu vs The State of Uttar Pradesh reported in
(2008)11SCC113
vii. Vasant Sampat Dupare vs State of Maharashtra reported in
(2015) 1 SCC 253
viii. Shankar Kisan RoaKhade Vs State of Maharashtra reported
in (2013) 5 SCC 546
ix. Manoj Pratap Singh vs. State of Rajasthan reported in (2022)
9 SCC 81
x. ShatrughnaBabanMeshram Vs State of Maharashtra in
Criminal Appeal No. 763-764 of 2016
Submission of the learned Counsel appointed from High Court Legal
Services Committee :
50. Mr. Koushik Gupta, learned Senior Advocate and Mr. ApalakBasu,
learned Advocate have submitted that the decision of Dhananjoy (supra) has
been diluted in the subsequent decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court in several judgments have laid down that if the
option of the alternative punishment is not foreclosed, then the sentencing
Court should not give capital punishment to the convict. Mr. Basu has
further submitted that the convict is an illiterate and poor person and had
no scope for receiving value education from any school or society and as
such he has not attained the knowledge of the benefit of values in life.
Overall consideration of the crime and criminal is to be undertaken by the
Page 22 of 72
sentencing Court, and so far as the present convict is concerned, there is a
scope for his reformation. He has relied upon the following judgments in
support of his contention.
i. Bachan Singh vs. State of Punjab reported in reported in
(1980) 2 SCC 684
ii. Machhi Singh and Anr Vs State of Punjab reported in (1983)3
SCC 470
iii. Swamy Shraddananda @ Murali Manohar Mishra v. State of
Karnataka reported in (2008) 13 SCC 767
iv. Santosh Kumar SatishbhushanBariyar v. State of
Maharashtra reported in (2009) 6 SCC 498
v. Sangeet v. State of Haryana reported in (2013) 2 SCC 452
vi. Mohinder Singh v. State of Punjab reported in (2013) 3 SCC
294
vii. Shankar KisanraoKhade v. State of Maharashtra reported in
(2013) 5 SCC 546
viii. Rajendra PralhadraoWasnik v. State of Maharashtra
reported in (2019) 12 SCC 460
ix. Chhannu Lal Verma v. State of Chhattisgarh reported in
(2019) 12 SCC 438
x. Dattatraya @ Datta Ambo Rokade v. State of Maharashtra
reported in (2020) 14 SCC 290
xi.Sachin Kumar Singhraha v. State of Madhya Pradesh
reported in (2019) 8 SCC 371
Page 23 of 72
xii.Irappa Siddappa Murgannavar v. State of Karnataka
reported in (2022) 2 SCC 801
xiii.Mofil Khan v. State of Jharkhand reported in (2021) 20 SCC
162
xiv.Lochan Shrivas v. State of Chhattisgarh reported in (2022)
15 SCC 401
xv.Pappu v. State of Uttar Pradesh reported in (2022) 10 SCC
321
xvi.Manoj v. State of Madhya Pradesh reported in (2023) 2 SCC
353
xvii.In Re: Framing Guidelines regarding potential mitigating
circumstances to be considered while imposing death
sentences in Suo Moto WP (Crl.) No. 1 of 2022
xviii.Vasanta Sampat Dupare v. Union of India reported in 2025
SCC OnLine SC 1823
xix.Aman Singh v. State of Bihar reported in 2026 SCC OnLine
SC 720 (2026 INSC 424)
xx.Waris v. State of Madhya Pradesh reported in 2026 SCC
OnLine SC 2001
Court’s View:-
51. The ruling of five judges' bench in Bachan Singh's case is still the
foundation stone of the sentencing policy in India in so far as the death
penalty of a convict is concerned. Although the abolitionists’ claim for
abolition of the death penalty from the statute book was turned down, the
Page 24 of 72
retentionists' demand was granted subject to severe restrictions and
conditions.
52. According to the said ruling, the death penalty can be awarded:
Firstly, if the offence comes under the ‘rarest of the rare cases’ category,
andSecondly, in selecting sentence between life and death, due regard must
be paid to the circumstances of offence as well as those of the offender.
53. Para 197 of Bachhan Singh's is reproduced hereunder:
“In Jagmohan, this Court had held that this sentencing
discretion is to be exercised judicially on well-recognised
principles, after balancing all the aggravating and mitigating
circumstances of the crime. By "well-recognised principles" the
Court obviously meant the principles crystallised by judicial
decisions illustrating as to what were regarded as aggravating
or mitigating circumstances in those cases. The legislative
changes since Jagmohan - as we have discussed already - do
not have the effect of abrogating or nullifying those principles.
The only effect is that the application of those principles is now
to be guided by the paramount beacons of legislative policy
discernible from Sections 354(3) and 235(2), namely: (1) The
extreme penalty can be inflicted only in gravest cases of
extreme culpability: (2) In making choice of the sentence, in
addition to the circumstances of the offence, due regard must
be paid to the circumstances of the offender also.”
54. Needless to mention under section 354(3) of Cr. P. C / Section 393(3)
BNSS, the court is under a statutory obligation to give 'special reason' for
of
awarding death sentence to any convict. Aggravating circumstances shall, as
per this ruling, form the basis of 'special reason' as envisaged under section
354(3) of the Code. Aggravating circumstances means that there must be
evidence of aggravation of an abnormal or special degree. Relevant excerpts
of para 205 is quoted below:
“205. In several countries which have retained death penalty,
pre-planned murder for monetary gain, or by an assassin hired
for monetary reward is, also, considered a capital offence of
the first degree which, in the absence of any ameliorating
Page 25 of 72
circumstances, is punishable with death. Such rigid
categorisation would dangerously overlap the domain of
legislative policy. It may necessitate, as it were, a redefinition
of 'murder' or its further classification. Then, in some decisions,
murder by fire-arm, or an automatic projectile or bomb, or like
weapon, the use of which creates a high simultaneous risk of
death or injury to more than one person, has also been treated
as an aggravated type of offence. No exhaustive enumeration of
aggravating circumstances is possible. But this much can be
said that in order to qualify for inclusion in the category of
"aggravating circumstances" which may form the basis of
'special reasons' in Section 354(3), circumstance found on the
facts of a particular case, must evidence aggravation of an
abnormal or special degree. "
55. The above judgment further lays down that an effort must be made to
weigh the aggravating circumstances as well as mitigating circumstances for
deciding the appropriateness of the sentence proposed to be passed against
the convict. The mitigating circumstances were also hinted in para 206 of
the judgement, and the same is hereunder:
“206. Dr. Chitaley has suggested these mitigating factors:
Mitigating circumstances:- In the exercise of its discretion
in the above cases, the Court shall take into account the
following circumstances:
(1) That the offence was committed under the influence of
extreme mental or emotional disturbance.
(2) The age of the accused. If the accused is young or old,
he shall not be sentenced to death.
(3) The probability that the accused would not commit
criminal acts of violence as would constitute a continuing
threat to society.
(4) The probability that the accused can be reformed and
rehabilitated. The State shall by evidence prove that the
accused does not satisfy the conditions 3 and 4 above.
(5) That in the facts and circumstances of the case the
accused believed that he was morally justified in
committing the offence.
(6) That the accused acted under the duress or domination
of another person.
(7) That the condition of the accused showed that he was
mentally defective and that the said defect unpaired his
capacity to appreciate the criminality of his conduct.”
Page 26 of 72
56. The concluding para of Bachan Singh's case (Supra) issues a note of
caution by observing that taking a life through law's instrumentally ought
not to be done save in the rarest of rare cases when the alternative option is
unquestionably foreclosed. Thereafter, many cases dealt with the issues
relating to death penalty of several offenders and the Apex court in each and
every occasion has expressed its view that the capital punishment in India
can be imposed only if the offence is within the category of rarest of rare
cases and in no other cases. However, so far as regards the second condition
that the sentencing court is to ascertain not only circumstances of the
offence but as well those of the offender, the record shows that there are at
least seven cases where the Apex court didn't consider the circumstances of
the offender, in the light of the observations of Bachhan Singh's case
(Supra) and they are, according to the Apex court's decision reported in
(2009)6 SCC498 (Santosh Kumar Satish Bhushan Bariyar v. State of
Maharashtra) are not binding precedents. These seven decisions are : Ravji
v. State of Maharashtra reported in (1996)2 SCC 175 , Shivaji v. State of
Maharashtra reported in (2008) 15 SCC 269, Mohan Anna Chavan v.
State of Maharashtra reported in (2008)7 SCC 561, Bantu v. State of U.
P reported in (2008) 11SCC 113, Surja Ram v. State of Rajasthan
reported in (1996) 6 SCC 271, Dayanidhi Bisoi v. State of Orissa reported
(2003) 9 SCC 310 and State of U. P v. Sattan (2009)4 SCC
in reported in
736. It is a trite law that in awarding capital punishment, the sentencing
court is under a strict obligation to ascertain not only the heinousness and
Page 27 of 72
other circumstances of the crime but also the circumstances of the criminal
under which he committed such offence. Keeping in mind the broad
principle laid down in Bachan Singh's case, some of the subsequent case
laws of 2 or 3 Judges Bench have pointed how such circumstances relating
to the convict can be obtained or how such circumstances would be
evaluated by the sentencing Court. The said case laws have reinforced the
dictum of Bachan Singh's case to ascertain further whether there are
materials suggestive of awarding an alternative sentence of life
imprisonment instead of capital punishment.
57. The present law of land suggests that even if the case is of rarest of
the rare case category the Court should not award death penalty unless the
Court finds that there is no scope of reformation of the convict. In other
words, if the reformation of the convict is possible, the death penalty cannot
be awarded even if the case is of rarest of the rare cases. In view of the above
let us examine the crime as well as the criminal.
The Crime Test:
58. The case is based on purely circumstantial evidence. No eye-witness
was there who saw the convict to commit the heinous crime of rape of a
child aged about 5 years 10 months and to murder her inside his room.
Needless to mention a conviction on circumstantial evidence can be awarded
if the chain of events is complete in such a manner that there is no
possibility of holding any person other than the accused as guilty. However,
if the chain of events is broken or there is a missing link, the conviction
cannot be pronounced.
Page 28 of 72
59. In this case, the allegation is that the child victim was allured by the
convict to give her chocolate if she came with him. The child victim
remained untraceable for quite sometime and as a result her parents and
neighbours started searching for the victim and ultimately the victim’s body
was found inside the room of convict covered with a mosquito net and a
balaposh (little weight blanket). She was found naked inside the balaposh
with bleeding injuries from her private parts along with other injuries on her
body. She was taken to hospital in a motorbike and on examination the
hospital authority declared her as brought dead. The FIR was lodged
immediately. The accused was rescued by the Police at the time when he
was being beaten up by the villagers and was hospitalized. The medical
evidence disclosed that the victim was brutally raped by the convict. There is
evidence that the convict also committed anal sex with the said child and it
is further alleged that subsequently the convict thrashed the head of the
victim child either against the wall or the floor of the room to ensure the
evidence of the best witness is removed forever. Investigation of the case was
started immediately and a Special Investigation Team was formed by the
Superintendent of Police (Rural, Hooghly). Chargesheet was submitted on
09/12/2024 against the accused and the charge was framed on 11.12.2024.
Out of 35 witnesses the prosecution has examined 27 witnesses and the
prosecution evidence was closed on 13.01.2025. The statements of the
accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C. were recorded on 03.01.2025 and
04.01.2025. Arguments from both sides were heard and learned Trial Judge,
Exclusive POCSO Court by her judgment dated 15.01.2025 convicted the
appellant under Section 64 (2) (1)/65(2)/66/103 (1) of BNS and also under
Page 29 of 72
Section 6(1) of the POCSO Act and sentenced the accused with capital
punishment by the order of sentence dated 17.01.2025. Within a period of
less than 2 months of the occurrence, the appellant was convicted and
sentenced by the learned Trial Judge.
60. To understand the gravity and seriousness of the offence we have to
look into the medical evidence, that is, the Post Mortem Report of the victim.
In this regard, the deposition of the doctor who conducted the post mortem
upon the victim girl is also to be looked into. As per his deposition being PW
17 Dr. Saswata Biswas deposed before the Court that on 25.11.2024 he
received the dead-body of the female child on 2.15 pm. in Kolkata Police
Morgue, Calcutta Medical College. A Medical Board was formed by the Head
of the Department of Forensic Medicine, Medical College, Kolkata consisting
of three doctors including himself, Dr. Sanjay Bandopadhyay and
Dr.NabanitaAdhikary. Autopsy was started at 5.10 pm., on 25.11.2024 and
it was completed at 8.20 pm. on the same day. The whole post mortem
process was video-graphed by Constable C-2118 Soumen Dey, Hooghly
(Rural) Police District. The excerpts of PW 17’s deposition is reproduced
hereinbelow:
“ I found red coloured printed cotton frock of the deceased
which was stained with dried reddish stain likely that of
blood on the lower back part of the frock of the deceased.
The stain mark was measuring about 20 cm x 11 cm.
The area of the said blood stain mark was marked and
signed by one of the autopsy surgeons of the Board.
nd
In 2nd Column of the 2 row injuries which we found on
the deadbody are clearly mentioned by us.
During examination we found lacerated wound
measuring about 0.8 cm x 0.8 cm. muscle (which means
depth) involving the hymen, navicular fossa, fourchette
and posterior commisure of the external genitalia and
partial thickness tear of anal sphincter. On further
Page 30 of 72
dissection we also found extravasation of blood measuring
about 5 cm x 5 cm noted involving the posterior vaginal
wall.
I also found abrasion measuring about 1 cm x 1 cm in the
rim of anal opening and another abrasion measuring
about 0.5 cm x 0.5 cm at 7 O'clock and 10 O'clock
respectively.
We found said 7 O'clock injury and 10 O'clock injury at the
opening of the anus.
That kind of injury may be possible when any hard
substance is inserted or attempted to be inserted.
In case of a 5 years old girl if force applied or not during
insertion or attempt, there will be such injury.
We found extravasation of blood 1.5 cm x 1.2 cm involving
the mucosa of the posterior anal canal of the deceased.
These were the injuries found in genitalia of the
deceased.
These kind of genital injuries are only possible in case of a
5 years old girl if she is subjected to sexual assault.
Other than said injuries we also found other external
injuries on body of the deceased such as abrasion
measuring about .3 cm x .3 cm over the back of the
deceased near the right scapula, extravasation of blood
1.2 cm x .8 cm in the right temporal region of scalp,
extravasation of blood .8 cm x .6 cm in the left temporal
region of scalp, diffuse subdural haemorrhage was noted
over the supero-lateral surface of entire left cerebral
hemisphere including its base, subarachnoid haemorrhage
9 cm x 7 cm noted over the left parietal lobe of brain.
Scapula is a bone located at the back.
Such kind of injury on scapula is possible if the victim is
forced against any wall or floor.
The scalp injuries as mentioned in point Nos. 6, 7 and 8 is
possible in body of 5 years old girl only if the victim is
banged on a wall or she is shaken violently.
Subdural haemorrhage and subarachnoid haemorrhage
are generally caused due to trauma to the head. It may be
caused due to application of blunt force on head (To court).
This kind of haemorrhage happens in between brain and
dura mater.
The injury mentioned in point No. 9 is life threatening.
All the injuries were recent injury.
st
Finally, opinion is mentioned in last row, 1 column as
death of deceased was due to effects of intracranial
hemorrhage associated with signs of recent forceful
penetration of vagina and anus. The manner of death is
found homicidal.
Page 31 of 72
Such intracranial hemorrhage might be due to banging of
head on the wall or floor. Further opinion is kept reserved
for report from FSL of viscera.
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………....
We also collected swabs and smears from different parts
of the deceased including her genitalia and anus as
mentioned in point No. 8 in paper envelope.”
61. The above Post Mortem Report shows that there was penetration of
the child’s vagina and anus and further her head was thrashed or banged
against the wall or the floor.
62. The evidence is clear that the victim’s body was recovered from the
room of the convict where he used to reside. There are several witnesses to
that effect. Even the convict states during his 313 Cr.P.C. examination that
the body of the victim was recovered from his room, but he did not know
who committed the said crime or who kept her inside his room. It is also
evident that the room of the convict had no door plank. One parda (curtain)
was hanging in place of a door. The convict has taken the plea as there was
no door, he did not know who brought the victim there and committed the
offence because at the relevant point of time he was sitting outside of his
room by the side of the metal road. Taking the opportunity of not having the
door plank, the convict pleaded his utmost innocence and apathy. Now, the
question is whether such plea is acceptable or not. The chemical
examination, medical examination and DNA test reports divulge that the
semen of the convict was found in the vagina of the victim and also in her
Page 32 of 72
anus, therefore, the convict’s plea that he did not know anything about the
commission of offence upon the victim does not impress me.
63. Defence has also tried to ventilate that there was improvement of
prosecution case by PW 5 who deposed before the Court during trial that
she saw the convict to allure the victim on the pretext that he would give
chocolate to the victim girl if she followed him. In other words, the
prosecution has relied upon the deposition of PW 5 who deposed before the
Court that the convict and the victim were last seen together but this
deposition in fact, according to the defence, has no merit since neither at the
time of recording her statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C nor before the
Magistrate under Section 164 Cr.P.C., this witness stated that she saw the
convict to allure the victim by chocolate. I have considered the materials on
record and I have found that the defence’s submission is correct so far as
regards that she did not narrate such incident to the IO at the relevant point
of time but the statement of PW 5 under Section 183 BNSS show that she
certainly disclosed that fact before the Judicial Magistrate recording the
statement. However, the said PW has tried to convince the Court that as she
was perturbed after seeing the condition of the victim at the hand of her
mother, she could not divulge the actual fact to anybody, but this
explanation cannot be thrown out particularly when the record shows that
she indeed made much statement before the Magistrate, and, therefore, she
might have missed to make such statement before the I.O.
64. Even if I brush aside the said deposition, the prosecution case would
not suffer since the victim was found in the room of the convict in an injured
condition. Blood stains were found in the floor as well as in the wall of the
Page 33 of 72
room and most importantly the semen of the convict was found in the
private parts of the victim. In my considered opinion there is no missing link
in this case. The chain of events are entangled with each other and the
chain is not at all broken.
65. After giving an anxious consideration to the facts and evidence I find
that the convict had committed several serious illegalities. First of all, there
is a breach of trust on the part of the convict. Secondly, he has committed
rape upon the child victim and thereafter, he had also made anal sex with
the minor victim or vice-versa and thereafter, he banged her head against
wall or floor or hit her head by any hard substance otherwise such type of
life threatening injuries on her head would not have occurred. The child
sustained so many injuries on her vagina and anus due to the brutal sexual
desire of the convict. In spite of knowing that such type of brutal sex with a
child might take her life, he did not resist himself although he was a mature
and sensible person. It appears the convict was craving for the child and at
one point of time she was most desirable and lucrative to him. To gain
control over the child’s body he allured her and took her to his room.
Thereafter, he pounced on the body of the little baby and had frontal sex
with her after rupturing her vagina. After releasing his semen in the vagina,
he again penetrated the anus of the child showing his barbaric mentality
and inhuman attitude. The ordeal which the child experienced or passed
through at the relevant point of time cannot be explained in any language.
The private parts which, at one point of time, were most lucrative to the
convict suddenly became the most disturbing element to him after his
purpose was over. The most desirable body became a nuisance to him and
Page 34 of 72
for that reason he did not care to end the life of the child and for that
purpose he thrashed the head of the victim against the wall of or the floor of
the room ensuring that the victim was not able to say before anybody
against the ghastly act of the convict who was her ‘Jethu’ (uncle) by village
courtesy. The manner of raping a 5 years 10 months old child through her
vagina and also her anus were sufficient to take the life of the child but to
ensure her total collapse he banged her head against hard substance. In my
view, the death of the victim was done with extreme depravity and this
brutal nature of rape and murder of the 5 years 10 months old child, is in
my view, qualifies as one of the rarest of the rare cases. Not only the
incident shocked the judicial conscience but also shocked the public
conscience as well.
66. In Vasanta Sampat Dupare vs. State of Maharashtra reported in
(2015) 1 SCC 253 the charge against the petitioner was that the victim a
minor girl of 4 years, was raped and battered to death by the petitioner. The
petitioner allegedly lured the victim by giving her chocolates, kidnapped her
and after satisfying his lust, caused crushing injuries to her with the help of
stones weighing about 8.5 kg and 7.5 kg.
67. The Hon’ble Apex Court in confirming the sentence of death was
pleased to observe in the review of the above said case reported in Vasanta
Sampat Dupare v. State of Maharashtra , (2015) 1 SCC 253. Paragraph
57 and 58 are quoted hereunder:
“57. Keeping in view the aforesaid authorities, we shall
proceed to adumbrate what is the duty of the Court when
the collective conscience is shocked because of the crime
committed. When the crime is diabolical in nature and
Page 35 of 72
invites abhorrence of the collective, it shocks the judicial
conscience and impels it to react keeping in view the
collective conscience, cry of the community for justice and
the intense indignation at the manner in which the brutal
crime is committed. We are absolutely conscious that
Judges while imposing sentence, should never be swayed
away by any kind of individual philosophy and
predilections. It should never have the flavour of Judge-
centric attitude or perception. It has to satisfy the test laid
down in various precedents relating to the rarest of the
rare case. We are also required to pose two questions that
have been stated in Machhi Singh case [Machhi Singh v.
State of Punjab, (1983) 3 SCC 470 : 1983 SCC (Cri) 681] .
58 . Presently, we shall proceed to dwell upon the manner
in which the crime was committed. Materials on record
clearly reveal that the appellant was well acquainted with
the inhabitants of the locality and as is demonstrable he
had access to the house of the father of the deceased and
the children used to call him “uncle”. He had lured the
deceased to go with him to have chocolates. It is an act of
taking advantage of absolute innocence. He had taken the
deceased from place to place by his bicycle and eventually
raped her in a brutal manner, as if he had an insatiable
and ravenous appetite. The injuries caused on the minor
girl are likely to send a chill in the spine of the society and
shiver in the marrows of human conscience. He had
battered her to death by assaulting her with two heavy
stones. The injured minor girl could not have shown any
kind of resistance. It is not a case where the accused had
a momentary lapse. It is also not a case where the minor
child had died because of profuse bleeding due to rape but
because of the deliberate cruel assault by the appellant.
After the savage act was over, the coolness of the
appellant is evident, for he washed the clothes on the tap
and took proper care to hide things. As is manifest, he
even did not think for a moment the trauma and torture
that was caused to the deceased. The gullibility and
vulnerability of the four year girl, who could not have
nurtured any idea about the maladroitly designed
biological desires of this nature, went with the uncle who
extinguished her life-spark. The barbaric act of the
appellant does not remotely show any concern for the
precious life of a young minor child who had really not
seen life. The criminality of the conduct of the appellant is
not only depraved and debased, but can have a menacing
effect on the society. It is calamitous.”
Page 36 of 72
68. In the case at hand it appears that the factual matrix are akin to the
facts of Vasanta Sampat Dupare (supra).
69. In Panchhi and Ors. Vs. State of UP reported in (1998) 7 SCC 177
the Hon’ble Apex Court by a Bench of 3 Judges was pleased to observe that
brutality or the manner in which a murder was perpetrated may be a
ground but not the sole criterion for judging whether the case is one of the
“rarest of rare cases” as indicated in Bachan Singh (supra). However, I have
already mentioned that the 5 Judges Bench of Bachan Singh (supra) in para
202 was pleased to mention that a Court may impose penalty of death in its
discretion if the murder involves extreme brutality or exceptional depravity.
70. It is now settled law that there must be a balance sheet of aggravating
and mitigating circumstances. In laying down the mitigating factors the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Bachan Singh (supra) case was pleased to quote the
suggestion of Dr.Chitale as hereunder:
“ 206. Dr Chitale has suggested these mitigating factors:
“Mitigating circumstances.—In the exercise of its discretion
in the above cases, the court shall take into account the
following circumstances:
(1) That the offence was committed under the influence of
extreme mental or emotional disturbance.
(2) The age of the accused. If the accused is young or old,
he shall not be sentenced to death.
(3) The probability that the accused would not commit
criminal acts of violence as would constitute a continuing
threat to society.
(4) The probability that the accused can be reformed and
rehabilitated. The State shall by evidence prove that the
accused does not satisfy the conditions (3) and (4) above.
(5) That in the facts and circumstances of the case the
accused believed that he was morally justified in
committing the offence.
Page 37 of 72
(6) That the accused acted under the duress or domination
of another person.
(7) That the condition of the accused showed that he was
mentally defective and that the said defect impaired his
capacity to appreciate the criminality of his conduct.”
71. I have already considered the circumstances of the crimes in the
foregoing paragraphs. Now, I shall consider the circumstances of the
appellant.
The Criminal Test :
72. The appellant was aged about 45 years and it appears that he was a
drummer (Dhaki) by profession. He is an illiterate person. The allegation
against him was that on the relevant date and time he allured the victim
and took her to his room where he committed brutal sex with the victim
aged about 5 years 10 months and thereafter, killed her by banging her
head against the wall or floor. The appellant had taken the plea that
somebody raped and murdered the victim and thereafter kept her body
inside his room. According to him he did not know who did this.
73. Although I have already discussed that such a defence has no leg to
stand upon since the report of Assistant Director of State Forensic
Assistance Laboratory (Biology), PW 16 Dr. Sandip Ghosh is very much clear
that such a plea has been made to misguide the investigation as well as the
Judicial process. The excerpt of deposition of PW 16 is reproduced
hereinbelow:
“ I concluded that profile generated from Exhibit X which is
blood sample of accused is found similar to be profiles
generated from Exhibit- 9, R, L and A.
Page 38 of 72
Following all the formalities analysis was made and
finally I opined that sour of Exhibit-B which is blood
sample of victim was included as contributor of the blood
stain which is found present in Exhibit H which is frock of
the victim, Exhibit K, Exhibit L which is balaposh, Exhibit
S which is mosquito net and Exhibit N which is gamcha.
The source of Exhibit B was also included as the
contributor of the hair sample found from balaposh
marked as Exhibit-T.
That means blood sample of the victim is found in Exhibit
H, K, S, N and L and the hair which was found in
balaposh is found to be of victim.
Source of Exhibit X which is blood sample of accused was
included as the contributor of the semen stains found from
Exhibit L which is balaposh and Exhibit g and R which are
frock and panty.
The source of Exhibit X which is blood sample of accused
was included as the male contributor in the swab sample,
said to be taken from the labia right and perineum of the
victim marked as Exhibit A as referred in Table 2 which
means DNA of accused is found in swab collected from
labia right and perineum of the victim. ”
74. The above report shows that the plea taken by the accused was out
and out false, since the scientific experiment shows that the convict is
responsible for the ghastly act as indicated above.
75. During investigation, PW 18 Dr. Shreya Chakraborty a Clinical
Psychologist at Chinsurah Sub-Divisional Hospital along with additional
charge of Clinical Psychologist at Imambara Sadar Hospital, Chinsurah
examined the accused on 03.12.2024 in the Out Patient Department of
Imambara Sadar Hospital and on examination she found no thought or
perceptual disturbance of the accused. She put NIMHANS Mental Health
Screening questionnaire to the accused and she did not find any
disorientation or any presence of his mental illness. She did not get any
history of his physical or mental illness nor did she find any such illness in
him after examination. From the above, it transpires that the convict was
Page 39 of 72
not suffering from any physical or mental illness at the relevant point of
time.
76. By order dated 08.07.2025 under DR No. 02 of 2025, this Court
directed the State respondents to file a report in light of observation made by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Manoj vs. State of MP reported in
(2023) 2 SCC 353 with reference to paragraph no. 250 of the said
st
judgment. Accordingly, the State Authority filed a report on 31 July, 2025
enclosing several documents, such as, the copy of mental status report of
the convict, the report of the Probation cum after Care Officer, Hooghly
District and also the statement/declaration of de-facto complainant
regarding the knowledge of the pendency of the death reference /appeal.
From the said report of the medical Board, it appears that medical board
consisting Head Of The Department And Professor, Department of
Psychiatry, BMCH Board, Senior Resident Department of Psychiatry, BMCH
(East Burdwan), and Clinical Psychologist, Department of Psychiatry and
De-addiction, Burdwan Medical College and Hospital, PurbaBardhaman,
Government of West Bengal examined the convict on 24.07.2025 and after
examination the Medical Board records the following opinions:-
“ A medical board was formed on 24/07/25 at the
psychiatry OPD BMC at 11 AM in compliance to the order
bearing memo no 7272/MO dated 18/07/2025, and the
board opinions as follows
1. History, mental status examination and psychological
assessment were done, no obvious psychopathology
was detected at present. Psychological assessments
were done by the clinical Psychologist that also found
no significant psychopathology at present (GHQ-12
score was 0).
2. Based on above evaluation, the board opines that
there is no diagnosable mental illness at present which
affects his functioning.
Page 40 of 72
3. The subject has competency to understand the nature
of crime and punishment with comprehension of the
nature and reason of the sentence and impending
execution.
4. Enclosed herewith the OPD ticket containing the
assessment (BWNM/RG2500513386) ”
77. The report submitted by the Probation Cum After Care Officer,
Hooghly, Government of West Bengal dated 28.07.2025 shows that the
convict is aged about 45 years. He is an illiterate person. He is convicted
under Section 64(2)(1)/103 of BNSS and 6 of POCSO Act. He is now in
custody in Burdwan Central Correctional Home. He has no family at all at
present. In the column of early family background, the probation officer
reported that :
“ The convict was a Dhaki (Drammer). He was a drunkard.
His morning used to start with Haria (one kind of village
made wine. He was married with a woman but due to the
convict's inhuman behaviour she fled away. Then the
convict married another woman who had two children and
they also fled away. The convict has his sibling brother
and his family but they would not like to provide neither
any information nor any documents. ”
78. It is further reported that the convict was a Dhaki and the same was
an irregular profession. He was very lethargic. According to the Probation
Officer, the convict was very libertine and lethargic. No report is received
regarding his criminal antecedents.
79. From the above reports it has transpired that the convict was not
suffering from any psychological or mental illness. Therefore, he did not
commit the said offence under any mental or emotional set back. Apart
from these clinical psychologists as well as Medical Boards of Doctors from
Department of Psychiatry, Burdwan (East) reporting that the convict has not
Page 41 of 72
been suffering from any mental disease or mental defect, this court also
finds that he is in sound state of mind and has the ability to understand to
resist the allegation levelled against him. If his answers to questions put by
the learned Trial Court during his 313 Cr.P.C. examinations are taken into
consideration, it shall be found that in each and every question, he has
given a very thoughtful, rational and balanced answer in support of his
defence. He may be illiterate and poor, but he knows how to defend his
cause. If we peruse the said 313 Cr.P.C. examination we shall find that he
knows where to say “I do not know,” or where to say “it is false” or “it is
falsely done.” As he committed the ghastly offence, he knew where his
minus point was and how to guard his cause. In my 30 years’ experience in
the Judicial Office, I do not find these types of rational and balanced
answers from an accused charged with serious offences. It might be argued
that he had the benefit of competent counsel, but had he been tutored, he
likely would have fumbled when giving answers.
80. The answers given by the accused depict his mental strength to evade
the incriminating circumstances brought against him.
81. Therefore, the offences against the victim were not committed by the
convict under the influence of any extreme mental or emotional
disturbances. It is also found that the convict is neither young nor an old
one. He is in mid 40's. The convict did not commit the offence under any
duress and domination of another person. The condition of the convict
showed that he was not mentally defective or he had any defect which
impaired his capability to appreciate the criminality of his conduct.
Therefore, the above factors or points do not favour the convict in any way.
Page 42 of 72
However, in para 206 in serial no. 3 and 4 of the said judgment of Bachan
Singh it is mentioned that if there is probability that the accused would not
commit criminal acts of violence which would constitute a continuing threat
to the society or the probability that the accused can be reformed and
rehabilitated, then such grounds can mitigate the circumstances in favour
of the convict. It is also laid down that the State should prove by producing
evidence that the accused does not satisfy the above conditions. Hence, we
have reached a stage of discussion where the most important circumstances
will be taken up for consideration and, that is, whether the convict can be
reformed/rehabilitated or there is probability that the accused would not
commit criminal acts of violence which would constitute a continuing threat
to the society.
Is the convict reformable or is the option of alternative punishment
foreclosed?
82. It is settled law now, even if an accused commits an offence under the
category of rarest of rare cases, the court should consider whether the
alternative punishment can be substituted for capital punishment if there is
a scope for his reformation.
83. In this case, we have already discussed that clinical psychologists, the
medical board of Psychiatry have clearly noted down that the convict has
not been suffering from any mental disease or mental defect. He has no
emotional set back also nor is he suffering from any psychological or mental
illness. The mental soundness and alertness of the convict are so much so
Page 43 of 72
that he could give rational answers to defend his cause of innocence. If a
person has a criminal instinct it is very difficult for the person to get rid of
that. Moreover, it is further true that unless the convict wants that his
instinct should be reformed, readjusted to the wellbeing for himself as well
as for others, in that case, the attempt of reforms cannot be fruitful. If we
see the conduct and the social character of the convict as reflected in the
report of the Probation Officer, we shall find that his relation with his two
consecutive wives was not at all good. They had left him. Two children had
also left him. Therefore, his wives were not happy to live with him. He has
no family at all.
84. During his examination under Section 313 CrPC it is found that he
had no sign of remorse or repentance that he violated a child brutally and
thereafter killed her. The conduct of the convict can be ascertained from his
answers under Section 313 Cr.P.C. He had given the false impression that
he did not commit the offence although his semen was found in the private
parts of the victim. This attitude shows that for the purpose of his defence
he could pretend that he is innocent. Although, the DNA test report,
chemical examination report, medical report etc. show that his presence was
all over the body of the victim, he has vehemently pleaded for his innocence.
The question and answer no. 140 is very much relevant to understand the
nature of the convict. Question and answer no. 140 is quoted hereinbelow:
“140. Q. The PW 7 Biplab Roy further stated to the
Magistrate that the witness then advised the de facto
complainant/father of victim to go to hospital and he took
the victim girl and her father to hospital where doctor
declared the victim girl dead and on his way to hospital
father of the victim girl informed him that the victim girl
Page 44 of 72
was found in your room and you did bad act with her.
What do you say?
Ans. It is false. I did nothing wrong with the victim. I could
not follow where she was taken.”
85. From the said answer it is found that although he committed the
brutal sex upon the victim of a 5 years 10 months old child by rupturing her
vagina and penetrating anus he still believed that he had not done anything
wrong to the victim. From this attitude of the convict coupled with other
evidence on record it is clear that he has no repentance or remorse and he is
a very hard nut to crack. The attitude of the convict shows that criminal
instinct is embedded in his mind set and he always considered that he did
nothing wrong with the child although the said child was raped, murdered
and her private parts contained his semen. Further, evidence was brought
by the State showing another aspect of the social character of the convict.
PW 6, Chandana Mondal, deposed before the court that she had made a
statement before the learned Judicial Magistrate, which was recorded and
marked as Exhibit No. P-9. Consequently, her statement before the learned
Magistrate qualified as substantive evidence. Although this statement was
challenged by the defence, it cannot be brushed aside, particularly when we
are trying to ascertain the social character of the convict. PW 6 stated before
the learned Magistrate that at the relevant time she became suspicious of
the convict Ashok Singh since he inappropriately touched other village
girls and tried to commit bad things with them.
86. PW 8 Bulu Mondal has also deposed that he made statements before
the Judicial Magistrate and his statement was marked as Exhibit P-11.
Page 45 of 72
Similarly, his statement before the learned Magistrate also qualified as a
substantive piece of evidence. If we peruse Exhibit P-11 we shall find that he
has also stated that Ashok Singh was under suspicion since he tried to
outrage the modesty of another village girl after touching
inappropriately . He also stated before the Magistrate that the age of the
said village girl was also 5 years at the relevant time.
87. Therefore, there is sufficient evidence on record that the convict Ashok
Singh has the mentality to outrage the modesty of the village girls, and in
the present case, after getting full opportunity he had committed the ghastly
acts which have been already discussed above.
88. In view of such conduct, social character of the convict, I find that
there is no possibility that the convict having such a mindset can be
reformed.
89. Reformation entails a fundamental shift in attitude, action, and
mindset. Whether a convict has been genuinely reformed can only be tested
by allowing him to mingle with the general public and observing whether he
refrains from committing further crimes despite having opportunity to do so.
In the present case, even if the death penalty of the convict is commuted to
life imprisonment for the remainder of his natural life, this question remains
unascertainable; confined within the four corners of a correctional home, it
is impossible to determine whether the appellant has truly gained control
over his criminal instincts and nature.
90. In Mohan Anna Chavan v. State of Maharashtra, reported in
(2008) 7 SCC 561 , the factual matrix reveals that the accused had been
previously convicted twice for raping minor girls. He received a lenient
Page 46 of 72
sentence of two years on the first occasion and ten years of rigorous
imprisonment on the second. Upon release, the accused proceeded to
commit the rape and murder of two more minor girls. While it is
acknowledged that mitigating circumstances were not evaluated in that
specific precedent and it is thus not strictly binding, the case is cited by
me to highlight that a habitual offender, if inadequately punished at the
appropriate stage, is given renewed opportunity to perpetrate heinous
crimes.
91. This underscores the practical impossibility of reforming criminals
whose anti-social instincts are deeply embedded. It cannot be stated with
any degree of certainty that the convict will refrain from similar acts if
presented with an opportunity. While courts do not possess a prophetic
vision, the conduct and ingrained criminal propensity of the convict fail to
inspire any confidence that he would not repeat such offences if given the
chance.
92. Consequently, this Court finds no mitigating circumstances operating
in favour of the petitioner. Viewed comprehensively, the aggravating
circumstances of this case heavily outweigh the mitigating factors.
The victim test ??
93. In criminal jurisprudence, courts are entrusted with the solemn duty
of imposing an appropriate sentence. The concept of an "appropriate
sentence" cannot be restricted solely to the mitigating or aggravating
circumstances surrounding the accused; it must intrinsically account for
Page 47 of 72
the plight, trauma, and circumstances of the victim and his/her grieving
relatives. While procedural law mandates hearing both the prosecution and
the convict on the quantum of sentence, true sentencing justice remains
incomplete if the impact on the victim's family is overlooked. The gravity of a
crime, particularly the tragic loss of a child, inflicts an irreparable void upon
the surviving members, whose lives are permanently shattered, leaving them
to bear lifelong grief while looking toward courts of law for solace.
94. Over the past few decades, Indian jurisprudence has witnessed a
paradigm shift with the advent of victimology, recognizing that victims were
historically marginalized spectators in criminal trials. A major turning point
arrived with the Code of Criminal Procedure (Amendment) Act, 2009 (w.e.f.
31.12.2009), which statutorily defined the term "victim," granted them the
right to engage counsel of their choice to assist the prosecution, and
introduced a crucial proviso to Section 372 of the Cr.P.C conferring a
substantive right to appeal against acquittals, inadequate sentences, or
convictions for lesser offences.
95. Reinforcing this legislative intent, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Jagjeet Singh v. Ashish Mishra @ Monu, (2022) 9 SCC 321, unequivocally
held that a victim has an unbridled, participatory right to be heard at every
stage of the proceedings. Although landmark rulings like Bachan Singh v.
State of Punjab, (1980) 2 SCC 684 were delivered at a time when victim
rights were not as prominently integrated into sentencing calculus, the legal
landscape has since evolved considerably. Furthermore, statutory reforms
following the Nirbhaya tragedy, such as amendments to the Juvenile Justice
Page 48 of 72
Act permitting juveniles aged 16 to 18 to be tried as adults for heinous
offences, reflect a heightened societal and legislative concern for victim
justice. Therefore, the circumstances and rights of the victim are no longer
peripheral and now they form an indispensable consideration that cannot be
ignored when determining the proportionality and appropriateness of a
sentence.
96. A close scrutiny of the deposition of the victim's mother reveals a
harrowing picture of profound grief and trauma. During her examination
before the Court, she was overwhelmed by unbearable agony, crying
inconsolably to the extent that the judicial proceedings had to be
temporarily halted. On another occasion, the intensity of her anguish
caused her to faint right in the middle of recording her testimony. Such
harrowing scenes raise a fundamental and disturbing question within our
criminal justice system: when the immediate family of a victim is subjected
to such catastrophic suffering, who bears the responsibility of accounting
for their circumstances? While the criminal process meticulously weighs the
rights and background of the accused, true institutional empathy and legal
consideration must extend equally to those who are left behind to endure a
lifelong sentence of mourning.
97. It is a well-settled principle in probate and testamentary jurisdiction
that a Judge, while construing a will, must place himself in the "armchair of
the testator" to discern his true intent. By parity of reasoning, a Judge
presiding over a criminal court, particularly in cases involving heinous
atrocities, must be equally attuned to placing himself, in judicial
contemplation, beside the deathbed of the victim or within the harrowing
Page 49 of 72
environment of the victim's grieving family, so as to truly comprehend the
profound trauma and devastation inflicted. When this judicial empathy and
objective assessment are applied, the unspeakable ordeal suffered by the
minor victim and her family vastly outweighs any abstract scope for the
reformation of a hardened convict who displays complete absence of remorse
or repentance, and who brazenly denies any wrongdoing or knowledge of the
tragedy. Having carefully weighed the daily agony, enduring anguish, and
unyielding grief of the victim's parents alongwith the gravity of the crime,
this Court finds no legal or factual infirmity to warrant any interference with
the judgment and sentence of punishment inflicted by the learned Trial
Court. Consequently, the judgment and order of the Trial Court are hereby
confirmed.
98. There is a profound and perverse irony in commuting a death
sentence to imprisonment for the remainder of a natural life. If such a
commutation is granted, the unavoidable question arises: who bears the
financial burden of his sustenance? It is funded entirely from the public
exchequer, that means, compelling a society that has utterly condemned the
convict to finance his survival day after day. Most tragically, this means the
parents, relatives, and co-villagers of the innocent victim are forced to
contribute, however miniscule their share, toward the upkeep of a predator
who savagely and barbarically extinguished the life of a helpless child. The
public at large can hardly be expected to sanction the subsidization of a
heinous criminal’s existence when the Statepossesses far more pressing
social welfare and developmental mandates. Society has no stake in
transforming a brutal child-killer into a state-maintained ward, nor does it
Page 50 of 72
harbour any collective desire to enshrine a convicted predator as a perverse
monument to misplaced mercy.
99. Last but not the least, the learned counsel Mr. Pati submitted that PW
1 was told by PW 3 that the victim went to the house of one Tapas Singh but
the said Tapas Singh was not cited as a witness. After going through the
record, I do not find any such deposition either of PW 1 or PW 3. They never
deposed that the victim went to the house of Tapas Singh. All the time they
have deposed that the victim visited the house of Mandira Singh. Therefore,
the argument of the learned Counsel of the appellant has no leg to stand
upon. However, for the purpose of clearing the confusion, I would like to say
that Mandira Singh is the wife of Tapas Singh. If anybody says that the
victim visited Tapas Singh’s house that also means that the victim visited
the house of Mandira Singh. There is no obscurity or confusion as
highlighted wrongly by the learned Counsel for the appellant.
100. Hence, I am constrained to affirm the judgment of conviction and
order of sentence dated January 15/17, 2025, passed by the learned Judge,
Exclusive POCSO Court, Chinsurah, Hooghly, convicting the appellant for
committing offence under Sections 65(2)/64(2)(1)/66 and 163 (1) of the
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (in Short ‘BNS’) and under Section 6(1) of
the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (in short ‘POCSO
Act’) and sentencing the appellant to suffer imprisonment for the remainder
of his natural life for commission of offence under Section 64(2)(1) of the
BNS and the learned Judge imposed death sentence on the appellant for
commission of offences under Sections 103(1)/66/65(R) of the BNS and
Page 51 of 72
under Section 6(1) of the POCSO Act. The death reference being no. DR 2
of 2025 imposing the sentence of death by the learned Trial Judge as
aforesaid is hereby confirmed. Consequently, CRA (DB) 328 of 2025 filed
by the death row convict Ashok Singh is dismissed.
101. The learned Registrar General, High Court, Calcutta is directed to
send a copy of this judgment to the convict through the
Superintendent of the concerned Correctional Home at once,whoshall
inform the convict that the convict can prefer Appeal before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court against the present judgement, and he can avail
the facility of legal aid free of costs. The Superintendent is to file a
compliance report by 7 days without fail to the learned Registrar
General, High Court, Calcutta.
102. From the record as well as from the submission of the learned Special
Public Prosecutor we came to know that the victim compensation of Rs. 10
lakh was not received by the parents of the victim. It is very much
unfortunate that although the State is clamouring for capital punishment of
the convict but has failed to comply with the direction of paying the victim
compensation to the parents of the deceased. As there is a long delay in
payment of the compensation, I direct the State to enhance the victim
compensation from Rs. 10 lakhs to Rs.15 lakhs and the same should be
paid to the parents of the victim within 2 months from this day
without fail. A compliance report in this regard be submitted to the
th
learned Registrar General, High Court at Calcutta by 30 January 2027.
Page 52 of 72
Learned Registrar General, High Court at Calcutta is also directed to
communicate this order to the concerned offices of the
Government,the Secretary, SLSA, West Bengal for necessary
compliance of the order in letter and spiritwithout fail. Learned
Registrar General, High Court at Calcutta is further requested to send a
copy of this judgment to the parents of the victim free of cost at once
for their information and necessary action.
103. The Trial Court records alongwith a copy of this judgment be sent to
the learned Trial Court at once for information and necessary action.
104. All parties shall act in terms of the server copy of the order
downloaded from the official website of this Court.
105. Urgent certified photocopy of this judgment and order, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of necessary formalities.
I agree.
(Arijit Banerjee, J.) ( Apurba Sinha Ray, J. )
Arijit Banerjee J .
106. While agreeing with the conclusion arrived at by my learned Brother
and the reasons recorded in support thereof, I would like to add a few
words.
107. In so far as conviction of the appellant is concerned, I have absolutely
no doubt in my mind that learned Trial Court has returned the correct
Page 53 of 72
verdict. The victim girl and the appellant were “last seen together” by PW-5.
Soon thereafter the body of the victim was discovered by the villagers in the
appellant’s house. The appellant could offer no explanation as to how the
victim girl’s body was in his house. Under Section 106 of the Evidence Act,
1872, the burden was on the appellant to explain the presence of the
victim’s body in his house. He failed to discharge such burden. Forensic
examination showed the presence of appellant’s semen in the private parts
of the victim girl. Nothing more was required for convicting the appellant
under Section 6 of the POCSO Act and Section 103 of the BNS.
108. In all fairness to learned Counsel for the appellant, while formally
advancing argument in support of innocence of the appellant, the real crux
of his argument was on the sentencing part. He, along with Mr. ApalakBasu,
learned Advocate appointed by the State Legal Services Authority in terms of
the direction in the case of Aman Singh & Anr. v. State of Bihar reported
at 2026 INSC 424 , argued that the present case does not come within the
category of “rarest of rare cases”. Therefore, the death sentence should be
commuted to life imprisonment. It may also be ordered that the appellant
would serve out imprisonment for the remainder of the natural term of his
life without any remission as was contemplated by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Swamy Shraddananda @ Murali Monahar Mishra vs State of
Karnataka, reported at (2008) 13 SCC 767 . It was submitted that the
present case is not one which can be said to have shocked the collective
conscience of the society.
109. I am unable to agree with learned Advocate for the appellant and Mr.
Basu.
Page 54 of 72
110. Firstly, the appellant was in a position of trust vis-à-vis the victim girl
who was less than 6 year old. He was a neighbour of the victim girl’s family.
Little girl trusted him and addressed him as “Jethu”. Taking advantage of
such innocent trust, faith and belief, the appellant in a calculated manner,
lured the little girl by offering chocolate and took her to his house. There the
appellant raped the little girl mercilessly both in the vagina and in the anus
and inflicted after grievous injuries on her body, as appears from the
evidence on record. The girl died as a result. This amounted to the most
heinous kind of breach of trust. The protector turned into a predator to
satisfy his extremely deprave lust.
111. Secondly, the manner in which the little girl was ravished and
assaulted is scary. The injuries found not only in the private parts of the girl
but also on her head are testimony to the brutal sexual assault that the girl
was subjected to by the appellant. The crime was committed in an extremely
diabolical manner.
112. Thirdly, in my opinion, if the facts of the present case do not shock
the collective conscience of the society, I do not know what kind of facts will.
A vulnerable child girl, less than 6 years of age, unable to protect herself, is
mercilessly raped and brutally murdered by a person who was in a position
of trust vis a vis the girl and in whose benevolence the girl had full faith. My
conscience is shocked. The conscience of my learned Brother is also
shocked as would be evident from his judgment. Before writing this
judgment, I narrated the facts of the case, without disclosing the identities
of the parties, to my friends from all walks of life. The uniform response that
the facts of the case elicited from them was: “Oh my God! absolutely
Page 55 of 72
shocking”. I have no doubt in my mind that the ghastly facts of this case are
bound to shock the collective conscience of the society.
113. Fourthly, I have considered the report filed by the State in terms of the
direction in the case of Manoj v. State of M.P., ( 2023) 2 SCC 353 . The
report and the totality of the evidence on record do not indicate that the
appellant has any modicum of remorse for having blown out life from the
little girl in beastly manner. This would demonstrate the inhuman nature of
the appellant.
114. Fifthly, a psychologist was one of the prosecution witnesses before the
Trial Court. She had examined the accused person. She deposed that the
appellant was not suffering from any psychological disorder. Therefore, the
appellant committed the crime consciously, in a planned manner, realising
fully the probable consequences thereof. It was not that he was under any
disability which can provide some exculpatory reason behind commission of
the crime. It was a cold blooded rape and murder. One can imagine the
excruciating pain that the little girl felt when she was being assaulted and
violated by the appellant to satisfy his diabolical carnal desire.
115. In Vasanta Sampat Dupare v. State of Maharashtra, (2017) 6 SCC
631, a four year old girl was raped and battered to death by a 47 year old
man. The death sentence was upheld by the Supreme Court and confirmed
in the review petition filed before it. The Hon’ble Court noted the extreme
depravity and barbaric manner in which the crime was committed and the
fact that the victim was a helpless girl of four years. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that such aggravating circumstances clearly outweighed the
mitigating circumstances including the appellant’s post-conviction conduct
Page 56 of 72
in jail which was brought on record. A three Judge Bench of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court observed inter alia as follows:-
“ 2. The facts leading to the filing of criminal appeals in this Court
including the nature and quality of evidence on record have been
dealt with and considered in the judgment of this Court dated 26-
11-2014 [ v. , (2015)
Vasanta Sampat Dupare State of Maharashtra
1 SCC 253 : (2015) 1 SCC (Cri) 624] . The charge against the
petitioner was that the victim, a minor girl of four years, was raped
and battered to death by the petitioner. The petitioner allegedly
lured the victim by giving her chocolates, kidnapped her and after
satisfying his lust, caused crushing injuries to her with the help of
stones weighing about 8.5 kg and 7.5 kg. The prosecution relied
upon the evidence of PW 2 Manisha, PW 3 Minal, PW 5 Vandana
and PW 6 Baby Sharma who had seen the petitioner taking away
the victim on a bicycle on the fateful day. In his disclosure
statement under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, the petitioner had
shown the place where dead body of the victim was lying and the
tap where he had washed his bloodstained clothes.
… ……………..
6. In the light of the principles as stated above, the facts of the
present matter were considered by this Court in the judgment
[ Vasanta Sampat Dupare v. State of Maharashtra , (2015) 1 SCC
253 : (2015) 1 SCC (Cri) 624] under review as under: ( Vasanta
Sampat case [ Vasanta Sampat Dupare v. State of Maharashtra ,
Page 57 of 72
(2015) 1 SCC 253 : (2015) 1 SCC (Cri) 624] , SCC pp. 283-85,
paras 57-58 & 60-61)
“ 57 . Keeping in view the aforesaid authorities, we shall proceed to
adumbrate what is the duty of the Court when the collective
conscience is shocked because of the crime committed. When the
crime is diabolical in nature and invites abhorrence of the
collective, it shocks the judicial conscience and impels it to react
keeping in view the collective conscience, cry of the community for
justice and the intense indignation at the manner in which the
brutal crime is committed. We are absolutely conscious that
Judges while imposing sentence, should never be swayed away by
any kind of individual philosophy and predilections. It should
never have the flavour of Judge-centric attitude or perception. It
has to satisfy the test laid down in various precedents relating to
the rarest of the rare case. We are also required to pose two
questions that have been stated in Machhi Singh case [ Machhi
Singh v. State of Punjab , (1983) 3 SCC 470 : 1983 SCC (Cri) 681].
58 . Presently, we shall proceed to dwell upon the manner in which
the crime was committed. Materials on record clearly reveal that
the appellant was well acquainted with the inhabitants of the
locality and as is demonstrable he had access to the house of the
father of the deceased and the children used to call him “uncle”.
He had lured the deceased to go with him to have chocolates. It is
an act of taking advantage of absolute innocence. He had taken
the deceased from place to place by his bicycle and eventually
Page 58 of 72
raped her in a brutal manner, as if he had an insatiable and
ravenous appetite. The injuries caused on the minor girl are likely
to send a chill in the spine of the society and shiver in the
marrows of human conscience. He had battered her to death by
assaulting her with two heavy stones. The injured minor girl could
not have shown any kind of resistance. It is not a case where the
accused had a momentary lapse. It is also not a case where the
minor child had died because of profuse bleeding due to rape but
because of the deliberate cruel assault by the appellant. After the
savage act was over, the coolness of the appellant is evident, for he
washed the clothes on the tap and took proper care to hide things.
As is manifest, he even did not think for a moment the trauma and
torture that was caused to the deceased. The gullibility and
vulnerability of the four year girl, who could not have nurtured any
idea about the maladroitly designed biological desires of this
nature, went with the uncle who extinguished her life-spark. The
barbaric act of the appellant does not remotely show any concern
for the precious life of a young minor child who had really not seen
life. The criminality of the conduct of the appellant is not only
depraved and debased, but can have a menacing effect on the
society. It is calamitous.
*
60 . In the case at hand, as we find, not only was the rape
committed in a brutal manner but murder was also committed in a
barbaric manner. The rape of a minor girl child is nothing but a
Page 59 of 72
monstrous burial of her dignity in the darkness. It is a crime
against the holy body of a girl child and the soul of society and
such a crime is aggravated by the manner in which it has been
committed. The nature of the crime and the manner in which it
has been committed speaks about its uncommonness. The crime
speaks of depravity, degradation and uncommonality. It is
diabolical and barbaric. The crime was committed in an inhuman
manner. Indubitably, these go a long way to establish the
aggravating circumstances.
61 . We are absolutely conscious that mitigating circumstances are
to be taken into consideration. The learned counsel for the
appellant pointing out the mitigating circumstances would submit
that the appellant is in his mid-fifties and there is possibility of his
reformation. Be it noted, the appellant was aged about forty-seven
years at the time of commission of the crime. As is noticeable,
there has been no remorse on the part of the appellant. There are
cases when this Court has commuted the death sentence to life
finding that the accused has expressed remorse or the crime was
not premeditated. But the obtaining factual matrix when unfolded
stage by stage would show the premeditation, the proclivity and
the rapacious desire. The learned counsel would submit that the
appellant had no criminal antecedents but we find that he was a
history-sheeter and had a number of cases pending against him.
That alone may not be sufficient. The appalling cruelty shown by
him to the minor girl child is extremely shocking and it gets
Page 60 of 72
accentuated, when his age is taken into consideration. It was not
committed under any mental stress or emotional disturbance and
it is difficult to comprehend that he would not commit such acts
and would be reformed or rehabilitated. As the circumstances
would graphically depict, he would remain a menace to society, for
a defenceless child has become his prey. In our considered
opinion, there are no mitigating circumstances.”
The abovequoted observations of this Court in the judgment under
review show that the aggravating facts were considered in paras 58
and 60 and the entirety of the matter including the mitigating
circumstances were dealt with more particularly in para 61. The
aggravating facts not only showed the extreme depravity but in the
opinion of this Court they brought to the fore the diabolical and
barbaric manner in which the crime was committed. The Court did
not find any mitigating circumstances in favour of the accused to
tilt the balance in his favour for awarding lesser punishment.
………………………….
9. The assessment and the consideration bestowed by this Court
in Machhi Singh [ Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab , (1983) 3 SCC
470: 1983 SCC (Cri) 681] shows that the aggravating
circumstances, namely, the manner in which the crime was
committed, the brutality and barbaric manner of execution, the
status and helplessness of victims and the fact that the crime was
gruesome and cold blooded were given due weightage. These facts
themselves were found to be tilting the balance against the
Page 61 of 72
accused concerned. In the present case, a minor girl of four years
was raped and battered to death by the petitioner. The brutality
and diabolical nature of the crime and the fact that the victim had
reposed trust and confidence in the petitioner was taken into
account and this Court found the aggravating circumstances
completely outweighing the other factors. The evidence and
circumstances were dealt with in the judgment under review in
great detail and this Court had no hesitation in affirming the death
sentence.
… ……………………………………..
19. In Ramnaresh v. State of Chhattisgarh [ Ramnaresh v. State of
Chhattisgarh , (2012) 4 SCC 257: (2012) 2 SCC (Cri) 382] this Court
considered the import of governing principles regarding death
sentence and summed up that it is the cumulative effect of both
the aggravating and mitigating circumstances that need to be
taken into account. Paras 76 to 81 of the decision are as under:
(SCC pp. 284-87)
“ 76 . The law enunciated by this Court in its recent judgments, as
already noticed, adds and elaborates the principles that were
stated in Bachan Singh [ Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab , (1980) 2
SCC 684: 1980 SCC (Cri) 580] and thereafter, in Machhi
Singh [ Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab , (1983) 3 SCC 470: 1983
SCC (Cri) 681] . The aforesaid judgments, primarily dissect these
principles into two different compartments—one being the
“aggravating circumstances” while the other being the “mitigating
Page 62 of 72
circumstances”. The court would consider the cumulative effect of
both these aspects and normally, it may not be very appropriate
for the court to decide the most significant aspect of sentencing
policy with reference to one of the classes under any of the
following heads while completely ignoring other classes under
other heads. To balance the two is the primary duty of the court. It
will be appropriate for the court to come to a final conclusion upon
balancing the exercise that would help to administer the criminal
justice system better and provide an effective and meaningful
reasoning by the court as contemplated under Section 354(3)
Cr.P.C.
Aggravating circumstances:
( 1 ) The offences relating to the commission of heinous crimes like
murder, rape, armed dacoity, kidnapping, etc. by the accused with
a prior record of conviction for capital felony or offences committed
by the person having a substantial history of serious assaults and
criminal convictions.
( 2 ) The offence was committed while the offender was engaged in
the commission of another serious offence.
( 3 ) The offence was committed with the intention to create a fear
psychosis in the public at large and was committed in a public
place by a weapon or device which clearly could be hazardous to
the life of more than one person.
( 4 ) The offence of murder was committed for ransom or like
offences to receive money or monetary benefits.
Page 63 of 72
( 5 ) Hired killings.
( 6 ) The offence was committed outrageously for want only while
involving inhumane treatment and torture to the victim.
( 7 ) The offence was committed by a person while in lawful custody.
( 8 ) The murder or the offence was committed to prevent a person
lawfully carrying out his duty like arrest or custody in a place of
lawful confinement of himself or another. For instance, murder is
of a person who had acted in lawful discharge of his duty under
Section 43 CrPC.
( 9 ) When the crime is enormous in proportion like making an
attempt of murder of the entire family or members of a particular
community.
( 10 ) When the victim is innocent, helpless or a person relies upon
the trust of relationship and social norms, like a child, helpless
woman, a daughter or a niece staying with a father/uncle and is
inflicted with the crime by such a trusted person.
( 11 ) When murder is committed for a motive which evidences total
depravity and meanness.
( 12 ) When there is a cold-blooded murder without provocation.
( 13 ) The crime is committed so brutally that it pricks or shocks not
only the judicial conscience but even the conscience of the society.
Mitigating circumstances
( 1 ) The manner and circumstances in and under which the offence
was committed, for example, extreme mental or emotional
Page 64 of 72
disturbance or extreme provocation in contradistinction to all
these situations in normal course.
( 2 ) The age of the accused is a relevant consideration but not a
determinative factor by itself.
( 3 ) The chances of the accused of not indulging in commission of
the crime again and the probability of the accused being reformed
and rehabilitated.
( 4 ) The condition of the accused shows that he was mentally
defective and the defect impaired his capacity to appreciate the
circumstances of his criminal conduct.
( 5 ) The circumstances which, in normal course of life, would
render such a behaviour possible and could have the effect of
giving rise to mental imbalance in that given situation like
persistent harassment or, in fact, leading to such a peak of human
behaviour that, in the facts and circumstances of the case, the
accused believed that he was morally justified in committing the
offence.
( 6 ) Where the court upon proper appreciation of evidence is of the
view that the crime was not committed in a preordained manner
and that the death resulted in the course of commission of another
crime and that there was a possibility of it being construed as
consequences to the commission of the primary crime.
( 7 ) Where it is absolutely unsafe to rely upon the testimony of a
sole eyewitness though the prosecution has brought home the
guilt of the accused.
Page 65 of 72
77 . While determining the questions relatable to sentencing policy,
the court has to follow certain principles and those principles are
the loadstar besides the above considerations in imposition or
otherwise of the death sentence. (Emphasis added)
Principles
( ) The court has to apply the test to determine, if it was the
1
“rarest of rare” case for imposition of a death sentence.
( 2 ) In the opinion of the court, imposition of any other punishment
i.e. life imprisonment would be completely inadequate and would
not meet the ends of justice.
( 3 ) Life imprisonment is the rule and death sentence is an
exception.
( 4 ) The option to impose sentence of imprisonment for life cannot
be cautiously exercised having regard to the nature and
circumstances of the crime and all relevant considerations.
( 5 ) The method (planned or otherwise) and the manner (extent of
brutality and inhumanity, etc.) in which the crime was committed
and the circumstances leading to commission of such heinous
crime.
78 . Stated broadly, these are the accepted indicators for the
exercise of judicial discretion but it is always preferred not to fetter
the judicial discretion by attempting to make the excessive
enumeration, in one way or another. In other words, these are the
considerations which may collectively or otherwise weigh in the
mind of the court, while exercising its jurisdiction. It is difficult to
Page 66 of 72
state it as an absolute rule. Every case has to be decided on its
own merits. The judicial pronouncements, can only state the
precepts that may govern the exercise of judicial discretion to a
limited extent. Justice may be done on the facts of each case.
These are the factors which the court may consider in its
endeavour to do complete justice between the parties.
79 . The court then would draw a balance sheet of aggravating and
mitigating circumstances. Both aspects have to be given their
respective weightage. The court has to strike a balance between
the two and see towards which side the scale/balance of justice
tilts. The principle of proportion between the crime and the
punishment is the principle of “ just deserts ” that serves as the
foundation of every criminal sentence that is justifiable. In other
words, the “doctrine of proportionality” has a valuable application
to the sentencing policy under the Indian criminal jurisprudence.
Thus, the court will not only have to examine what is just but also
as to what the accused deserves keeping in view the impact on the
society at large.
80 . Every punishment imposed is bound to have its effect not only
on the accused alone, but also on the society as a whole. Thus, the
courts should consider retributive and deterrent aspect of
punishment while imposing the extreme punishment of death.
81 . Wherever, the offence which is committed, manner in which it
is committed, its attendant circumstances and the motive and
status of the victim, undoubtedly bring the case within the ambit
Page 67 of 72
of “rarest of rare” cases and the court finds that the imposition of
life imprisonment would be inflicting of inadequate punishment,
the court may award death penalty. Wherever, the case falls in any
of the exceptions to the “rarest of rare” cases, the court may
exercise its judicial discretion while imposing life imprisonment in
place of death sentence.” (Emphasis added)
20. It is thus well settled, “the court would consider the
cumulative effect of both the aspects (namely, aggravating factors
as well as mitigating circumstances) and it may not be very
appropriate for the Court to decide the most significant aspect of
sentencing policy with reference to one of the classes completely
ignoring other classes under other heads and it is the primary
duty of the Court to balance the two”. Further, “it is always
preferred not to fetter the judicial discretion by attempting to make
excessive enumeration, in one way or another; and that both
aspects, namely, aggravating and mitigating circumstances have to
be given their respective weightage and that the Court has to strike
the balance between the two and see towards which side the
scale/balance of justice tilts”. With these principles in mind, we
now consider the present review petition.
21. The material placed on record shows that after the judgment
[ Vasanta Sampat Dupare v. State of Maharashtra , (2015) 1 SCC
253 : (2015) 1 SCC (Cri) 624] under review, the petitioner has
completed Bachelors Preparatory Programme offered by Indira
Gandhi National Open University enabling him to prepare for
Page 68 of 72
Bachelor level study and that he has also completed the Gandhi
VicharPariksha and had participated in drawing competition
organised sometime in January 2016. It is asserted that the jail
record of the petitioner is without any blemish. The matter is not
contested as regards Conditions (1), (2), (5), (6) and (7) as stated in
para 206 of the decision in [ v.
Bachan Singh Bachan Singh State of
Punjab , (1980) 2 SCC 684 : 1980 SCC (Cri) 580] , but what is now
being projected is that there is a possibility of the accused being
reformed and rehabilitated. Though these attempts on part of the
petitioner are after the judgment [ Vasanta Sampat Dupare v. State
of Maharashtra , (2015) 1 SCC 253 : (2015) 1 SCC (Cri) 624] under
review, we have considered the material in that behalf to see if
those circumstances warrant a different view. We have given
anxious consideration to the material on record but find that the
aggravating circumstances, namely, the extreme depravity and the
barbaric manner in which the crime was committed and the fact
that the victim was a helpless girl of four years clearly outweigh
the mitigating circumstances now brought on record. Having taken
an overall view of the matter, in our considered view, no case is
made out to take a different view in the matter. We, therefore,
affirm the view taken in the judgment [ Vasanta Sampat
Dupare v. State of Maharashtra , (2015) 1 SCC 253 : (2015) 1 SCC
(Cri) 624] under review and dismiss the present review petitions. ”
[Emphasis added]
Page 69 of 72
116. The facts of the present case are very similar to the facts of Vasanta
Sampat Dupare v. State of Maharashtra, Supra .
117. I am conscious that in a case of this kind, the Court is required to
weigh mitigating circumstances against the aggravating circumstances.
Honestly speaking, I do not find any mitigating circumstance in the present
factual matrix. The aggravating circumstances are overwhelming as has also
been discussed by my learned Brother in the judgment that he has
authored. Any kindness shown to the appellant will be misplaced mercy .
The appellant cannot expect any leniency, indulgence or claim any
human right having committed an inhuman wrong. While ensuring that
an accused gets ‘just’ treatment, the courts must also not be oblivious
to victim justice and the agony suffered by the victim’s family
members.
118. I am also conscious that there are decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court on how the shift is taking place from retributive justice to reformative
justice. However, in the present case, I am of the view that reformation of
the appellant would be a far cry. Any attempt at that, would be an exercise
in futility. This I say because the extreme depravity and meanness of mind
that the appellant has demonstrated by committing the crime in the
barbaric manner, are his ingrained instincts and characteristics. In my
opinion, it is highly improbable that a person like the appellant can be
reformed.
Page 70 of 72
119. In Vasanta Sampat Dupare, (Supra) , the Supreme Court while
considering the petition for review of its judgment and order affirming the
death sentence, noted that after confirmation of the death sentence, the
convict had completed Bachelors Preparatory Programme offered by Indira
Gandhi National Open University. It also completed the Gandhi
VicharPariksha and had participated in drawing competition organised
sometime in January 2016. It was asserted that the jail record of the convict
was without any blemish. What was projected before the Supreme Court is
that there was a possibility of the convict being reformed and rehabilitated.
In spite of the same, the Supreme Court dismissed the review petition in
view of the extreme depravity and the barbaric manner in which the crime
was committed and the fact that the victim was a helpless girl of four years.
The Supreme Court noted that the aggravating circumstance of the case
clearly outweighed the mitigating circumstances which were brought on
record along with the review petition.
120. In conclusion, I can unhesitatingly say that in the gory facts of this
case, the appellant deserves capital punishment. Any other kind of
punishment including incarceration for the remainder of the appellant’s
natural life without remission, will be inadequate and not commensurate
with the depraved, heinous and inhuman crime that the appellant has
committed. My conscience does not permit me to commute the death
penalty to any other punishment. I accordingly confirm the judgment of
conviction and order of sentence that learned Trial Court has passed.
Page 71 of 72
121. All parties shall act in terms of the server copy of the order
downloaded from the official website of this Court.
122. Urgent certified photocopy of this judgment and order, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of necessary formalities.
I agree.
(Apurba Sinha Ray, J.) ( Arijit Banerjee, J. )
Later:-
After the judgments are pronounced, learned Advocates appointed by the
Calcutta High Court Legal Services Committee, pray for stay operation of the
judgment and order. We have no doubt in our mind that the appellant
deserves death penalty. However, since the matter involves the question of
life and death, we stay the operation of the judgment and order for three
months to enable the appellant to approach the Hon’ble Apex Court, if he is
so advised.
(Apurba Sinha Ray, J.) ( Arijit Banerjee, J. )
Page 72 of 72