The Malkapur Urban Co-Operative Bank Ltd. (Under Liquidation ) vs State Of Maharashtra And Ors
- Court
- Bombay High Court
CNR No : HCBM010413812026
2026:BHC-AS:39956-DB
WP- 4734-2026.doc
Rohit Ghuge
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Digitally
signed by
ROHIT
RAMDAS
GHUGE
Date:
2026.10.01
11:08:36
+0530
ROHIT
RAMDAS
GHUGE
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 4734 OF 2026
The Malkapur Urban Co-operative Bank Ltd.
(under liquidation),
Head Office at “Dhanashri”, Buldhana Road,
Malkapur, Tah. Malkapur, Dist. Buldhana,
Through its Authorised officer,
Pravin S/o Sudhakar Lashkare,
Age: 50 years, Occ. Service. …Petitioner
Versus
1. State of Maharashtra,
Through Department of Home,
Mantralaya, Mumbai
2. Dhanshree Developers,
Having its principal place of business at Office No.101, Plot
No. 30, Jeevandeep Apartment, Suryodaya Chs, S.P.
Mukharji Road, Ambarnath (East), Thane 421501.
Though its Partners
a. Sunil s/o Waman Chaudhari,
b. Gunvantkumar S/o Sohanlal Kherodiya.
3. Sunil S/o Waman Chaudhari,
Age: Major, Occu :- Business,
Partner of Dhanshree Developers,
R/o Flat No. 502/A, Trinetra Apartment,
Near Sibbu Place Hotel, Ambarnath (E), Thane,
4. Gunvantkumar Sohanlal Kherodiya,
Age: Major, Occu. Business,
R/o Flat No. 504, A-3 Wing Indraraj Apartment, Sai Section
Road, Swami Dev Prakash Garde, Near Batale Hospital,
Ambarnath East, Thane.
1/7
Uploaded on - 01/10/2026 Downloaded on - 01/10/2026 12:07:51
WP- 4734-2026.doc
5. M/s Shreenath Developers
Office No. 101, Plot No. 30, Jeevandeep
Apartment, Suryodaya CHS, S.P, Mukharji Road,
Ambarnath (East), Thane-421501.
a. Sunil S/o Waman Chaudhari,
b. Gunvatkumar Sohanlal Kherodiya
6. Nirmala Gunvantkumar Kherodiya
Age: Major, Occu. Business,
R/o Flat No. 504, A-3 Wing Indraraj Apartment, Sai Section
Road, Swami Dev Prakash Garde, Near Batale Hospital,
Ambarnath East, Thane.
7. Nikhil Sunil Chaurdhari
Age: Major, Occu. Business,
R/o Flat No.502/A Trinetra Apartment, Shiv Dham Complex,
Near Sibbu Palace Hotel, Ambarnath (East), Thane.
8. Janardhan Namdeo Gawali
Age: Major, Occ. Business,
R/o Pale, Tq. Ambarnath (East), Dist. Thane.
9. Jagdish Dinkar Bhoir
Age: Major, Occ. Business,
R/o Newali, Tq.Ambarnath (East), Dist.Thane.
…Respondents
Mr. Sanjeev Deshpande, a/w Mr. Avinish Deshpande a/w Mr.
Akshay Bhalerao for the Petitioner.
Ms. Sangeeta D. Shinde, A.P.P. for Respondent No.1-State.
CORAM : BHARATI DANGRE &
ASHISH S. CHAVAN, JJ.
th
DATE : 24 SEPTEMBER 2026
2/7
Uploaded on - 01/10/2026 Downloaded on - 01/10/2026 12:07:51
WP- 4734-2026.doc
JUDGMENT [Per Ashish S. Chavan J.] :
1. Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith with the
consent of the parties and is taken up for final disposal. Learned
counsel appearing for the Respondents waive notice on behalf of
the respective Respondents.
2. The Petitioner, a Co-operative Bank registered under the
Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act,1960 has filed the aforesaid
Writ Petition impugning two concurrent orders dated 02.01.2026
and 22.07.2026 both passed by Joint Civil Judge, Senior Division
and ACJM, Thane, (“Trial Court”) inter alia directing the Petitioner
to deposit Commission fee payable to the Court Commissioner to
the extent of Rs. 15,00,000/- in an action of recovery initiated by
the Petitioner under the Securitisation and Reconstruction of
Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002
(“SARFAESI Act, 2002”), by approaching the Trial Court u/s 14 of
the SARFAESI Act, 2002 to obtain possession of the secured assets.
3. Heard Mr. Deshpande for the Petitioner, and Ms. Shinde, APP
for Respondent No.1-State
3/7
Uploaded on - 01/10/2026 Downloaded on - 01/10/2026 12:07:51
WP- 4734-2026.doc
4. On behalf of the Petitioner bank it is submitted that the
Respondent Nos. 2-9 are the borrowers and guarantors who have
defaulted in repayment of financial assistance availed by them from
the Petitioner Bank. Upon filing an application u/s 14 of SARFAESI
Act, 2002 the Trial Court vide the impugned order dated
02.01.2026 allowed the same appointing an advocate as the Court
Commissioner for taking possession of the secured assets and
directed the Petitioner to deposit an amount of Rs. 15,00,000/-
[Rupees Fifteen lakhs] towards the Commissioner’s fee. The
Petitioner once again approached the Trial Court seeking
modification of the earlier impugned order on the ground that the
amount was excessive and arbitrary. The Application seeking
modification also came to be rejected vide impugned order dated
22.07.2026. The Ld. Counsel for the Petitioner Bank contends that
the impugned order dated 22.07.2026 is arbitrary, irrational and
exorbitant since the only justification given by the Trial Court for
such high remuneration seems to be that possession of 167 flats is
required to be taken by the Court Commissioner without
appreciating that number of flats by itself cannot constitute a
criterion for fixation of the remuneration of the Court
Commissioner. The Trial Court did not appreciate whether the flats
4/7
Uploaded on - 01/10/2026 Downloaded on - 01/10/2026 12:07:51
WP- 4734-2026.doc
were situated in the same project, the time likely to be consumed in
taking possession and most importantly the fact that the Petitioner
Bank being under liquidation was not in a position to deposit an
amount of Rs. 15,00,000/- towards the Court Commissioner’s
remuneration.
5. The Respondent No. 1 - State has opposed grant of any relief
to the Petitioner Bank justifying the impugned orders.
6. In the light of the fact that the Petitioner has assailed the
impugned orders only to the limited extent of the quantification of
the remuneration of the Court Commissioner, the core issue that
arises for our consideration is whether the order quantifying the
Court Commissioner’s fees is a reasoned order and whether the fees
are exorbitant and excessive as contended by the Petitioner Bank.
Although, the SARFAESI Act, 2002 does not prescribe any schedule
of fees to be paid to the officer who is authorized to take possession
of assets to aid the District Magistrate or the CJM, it would be
necessary for the Trial Court to take into consideration several
factors including the financial capacity of the Applicant Bank while
quantifying the fees of the Court Commissioner. The only
5/7
Uploaded on - 01/10/2026 Downloaded on - 01/10/2026 12:07:51
WP- 4734-2026.doc
justification that the Learned CJM gives in the impugned order
dated 02.01.2026 is that the remuneration is commensurate to the
efforts required by the Court Commissioner to take possession of
167 flats and hence, the quantum of remuneration is higher. We also
note that the Petitioner had sought modification of the impugned
order placing on record the financial constraint of the Petitioner and
pointing out that the Petitioner bank is under liquidation and an
official liquidator has been appointed since 2023 by the Competent
Authority. The total liability payable to depositors under liquidation
is approximately Rs 404 Crores. However, despite this submission
of the Petitioner-Bank, the Trial Court refused to revisit the
impugned order or to modify the same. We are of the view that out
of the several factors to be taken into consideration while
quantifying the remuneration of the Court Commissioner, the Trial
Court must certainly pay heed to the financial position of the
Applicant Bank and balance it with the efforts required by the Court
commissioner to take possession of the secured assets. In the facts of
the present case, we are of the view that the amount of Rs.
15,00,000/- is rather excessive and requires to be modified to Rs.
2,00,000/- [Rupees Two Lakhs].
6/7
Uploaded on - 01/10/2026 Downloaded on - 01/10/2026 12:07:51
WP- 4734-2026.doc
We must also clarify that in the event that Smt. Sneha Vinod
Kamble, Advocate, who is appointed as the Court Commissioner
expresses inability to discharge her function as a Court
Commissioner, the Trial Court is at liberty to appoint another
competent person as the Court Commissioner to give effect to the
Application u/s 14 of SARFAESI Act, 2002 preferred by the
Petitioner Bank.
7. With these observations, the Petition is allowed. Rule is made
absolute.
ASHISH S. CHAVAN, J. BHARATI DANGRE, J.
7/7
Uploaded on - 01/10/2026 Downloaded on - 01/10/2026 12:07:51
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)