JAWAHAR SINGH DUA vs AGGARWAL CHARITABLE TRUST
- Court
- Uttarakhand High Court
UKHC010149052026
2026:UHC:10676
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
CIVIL REVISION No. 107 of 2026
(under Section 25 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, 1887)
th
Dated : 20 November, 2026
Shri Jawahar Singh Dua and others ..Revisionists
Versus
Aggarwal Charitable Trust and Others --Respondents
---------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:-
Mr. T.S. Bindra, learned counsel (through V.C.) and Ms. Disha
Vashistha, learned counsel for the revisionists.
Mr. Sagar Kothari, learned counsel for the respondents.
---------------------------------------------------------------
1. The present Civil Revision is directed against
rd
an order dated 16.05.2026, passed by the learned 3
Additional District Judge / Judge Small Cause Court,
Dehradun in SCC Suit No.51 of 2016. By the said order,
the suit filed by the respondents / plaintiffs was decreed.
The operative portion of the said order dated 16.05.2026
reads as hereunder:-
“ वादीगण का वाद प्रितवादीगण के िव ŝȠ आंिशक ŝप से स ʩय
आ ǒɑ िकया जाता है।
प्रितवादीगण को आदेिशत िकया जाता है िक वह एक माह के भीतर
िववादा ˙द स ɼिȅ (िजसका िववरण वाद पत्र के अ ȶ म विण Ő Ŋत है) का क ɥा -
वादीगण को प्रदान कर Ő। प्रितवादीगण Ȫारा िनयत समय पर क ɥा न देने की
İस्थित म Ő वादीगण िनयमानुसार प्रितवादीगण से क ɥा लेने का अिधकारी होंगे।
प्रितवादीगण, वादीगण को िदनांक 12.06.2016 से िववािदत स ɼिȅ का
वा ˑिवक क ɥा वादीगण को देने की ितिथ तक ₹1000/- प्रितिदन की दर से
अ ȶःकालीन लाभ अदा कर Őगे।
प्रितवादीगण को यह भी आदेिशत िकया जाता है िक वह वादीगण को
नोिटस खचा Ŋ₹ 3,500/- ŝपये अदा कर Ő।
तद्नुसार आ ǒİɑ तैयार की जाय। ”
1
UKHC010149052026
2026:UHC:10676
2. In the present Civil Revision, an affidavit has
been filed by the revisionists as well as by the
respondents herein. As per the affidavit, filed by the
respondents / plaintiffs, which has been sweared by Mr.
Ghanshyam Kumar Agarwal, the following averments
have been made in the paragraph no.4, which reads as
follows:-
“4. That in order to put a quiet end to the protracted litigation
between the parties, and without prejudice to the rights and
contentions of the answering respondents, the deponent, on
behalf of the answering respondents, is ready and willing to settle
the matter with the revisionist on the following terms and
conditions: -
(a) That the revisionist shall vacate the shop in question and hand
over the vacant, peaceful and physical possession thereof to the
answering respondents within a period of three months, i.e. on or
before 09.01.2027.
(b) That in the event the revisionist agrees to and complies with
the condition contained in clause (a) above and vacates the shop
in question and handover peaceful possession thereof within the
said period of three months, the answering respondents shall
accept payment of damages / mesne profits calculated at the rate
of Rs. 500/- (Rupees Five Hundred only) per day with effect from
12.06.2016 till 09.01.2027 i.e. the last date of handing over of
vacant possession, in place of Rs.1,000/- (Rupees One Thousand
only) per day, and the answering respondents hereby forgo the
balance to that extent. In that situation, detail of the amount to
2
UKHC010149052026
2026:UHC:10676
be payable by the revisionist to the answering respondent is as
follows:
i. Arrears of rent and taxes Rs.12,640.80/-
ii. Mesne profit from 12.06.2016
till 09.01.2027 i.e. 3865 days @
Rs.500/- per day,
Rs.19,32,500/-
iii. Cost of Notice Rs.3,500/-
iv. Court fees on plaint Rs.16,480/-
Total Rs.19,65,120.80/-
Answering Respondent hereby forego the balance to that extent.
(c) That in the event the revisionist agrees to comply with the
condition contained in clause (a) above but thereafter seeks or
demands any extension of time for vacating the shop in question,
the concession contained in clause (b) above shall stand
automatically withdrawn and shall be treated as having never
been granted, and in such eventuality the revisionist shall be
liable to pay damages / mesne profits at the rate of Rs.1,000/-
(Rupees One Thousand only) per day with effect from 12.06.2016
till the date of actual handing over of possession, and the
answering respondents shall further be at liberty to initiate and
pursue all such appropriate legal action and proceedings against
the revisionist as may be available to them in law for non-
compliance of the said condition.
(d) That out of the amount deposited by the revisionist before the
Learned Court below, a sum of Rs. 3,50,000/- (Rupees Three
Lakhs Fifty Thousand only) has already been withdrawn by the
answering respondents, and the revisionist shall provide the
complete details of the remaining deposited amount, as stated by
the revisionist i.e. Rs 2,00,000/- by providing copies of challans
within 15 days from today. The said sum of Rs. 2,00,000/-
(Rupees two Lakhs only) shall be withdrawn by respondents in
respect whereof the revisionist shall extend his full cooperation
and shall raise no objection whatsoever to the release/withdrawal
thereof in favour of the answering respondents from the court
below. This amount of Rs. 5,50,000/-shall be adjusted with the
3
UKHC010149052026
2026:UHC:10676
total amount mentioned in clause (b).
(e) That the balance payment as aforesaid shall also be made /
released to the answering respondents within a period of three
months from today, that is to say, simultaneously with the
handing over of the peaceful vacant possession of the shop in
question.
(f) That upon the revisionist complying with the aforesaid terms in
their entirety, namely, upon handing over of the vacant
possession of the shop in question and upon receipt of the entire
balance payment by the answering respondents within the said
period of three months, the answering respondents shall withdraw
the execution proceedings being SCC execution case no. 14 of
2026 pending against the revisionist. In case revisionist fail to
comply the aforesaid terms, the answering respondents shall have
right to continue the SCC execution case no. 14 of 2026 and
execute the decree as it is.
”
3. It has been stated in paragraph no.5 that the
aforesaid terms are being offered by the answering
respondents by way of composite settlement, and the
same shall be binding upon the parties only if accepted
and complied with by the Revisionist in their entirety.
4. The revisionists/ respondents have also filed
an affidavit, wherein in paragraph nos.1 to 4 of the said
affidavit, following averments have been made:-
“1. That the deponent is the Revisionist No. 1 in the present Civil
Revision. The deponent is the Partner of the Revisionist no.2 and
he is the Sole Proprietor of Revisionist no. 3. The deponent is fully
acquainted with the facts and circumstances of the case.
2. That the Revisionist no.3 was not a party to the litigation but
due to error and mistake a decree has been passed against it. The
Revisionist no.3 has never been in possession of the property in
suit nor has it been its tenant. The tenancy was in the name of the
4
UKHC010149052026
2026:UHC:10676
Revisionist no.2 which is a partnership firm and the Revisionist
no.2 was sued through the deponent.
3. That in order to put a quiet end to the protracted litigation
between the parties, the deponent, on behalf of the Revisionists,
is ready and willing to settle the matter with the Respondents on
the following terms and conditions:-
a) That the Revisionist nos. 1 and 2, shall vacate the shop in
question and hand over the vacant peaceful and physical
possession thereof to the answering respondents on or before
9/1/2027.
b) That damages/ mesne profits awarded by the learned Trial
Court shall stand reduced to Rs. 500/- (Rupees Five Hundred
only) per day with effect from 12.06.2016 till the date of handing
over of vacant possession, in place of Rs. 1,000/- (Rupees One
Thousand only) per day.
c) That the sum of Rs. 7,50,000/- deposited by the Revisionist no.
1 and 2 in the learned Trial Court, shall stand adjusted in the
decretal amount. Out of this sum, the Respondents have
apparently withdrawn part of the amount and the Revisionists
shall not oppose the withdrawal of the balance amount. In case
there is any mistake in the head of deposit, the Revisionists shall
cooperate with the Respondents for correction of the mistake and
withdrawal of the amount.
3. That in the event of non vacation of the property on or before
the stipulated date i.e. 9/1/2027, the respondents shall be entitled
to pursue all their rights and remedies, including execution of the
decree, in accordance with law against the Revisionist nos. 1 and
2.
4. That the deponent undertakes to abide by the aforesaid terms
and conditions and prays that the same may kindly be taken on
record.”
5. Learned counsel for the revisionists submits
that an amount of Rs.19,65,120.80/- is to be paid by the
revisionists to the respondents after adjusting the
5
UKHC010149052026
2026:UHC:10676
amount already paid. He submits that an amount of
Rs.3,50,000/- has already been withdrawn by the
respondents and the same has to be adjusted in the
total amount of Rs.19,65,120.80/-. Learned counsel
for the revisionists submits that an amount of
Rs.7,50,000/- was deposited by the revisionist nos.1 and
2 before the trial court out of which part of the amount
has been withdrawn by the respondents and the
revisionists shall not oppose the withdrawal of the
balance amount. In case there is any mistake in the
head of deposit the revisionists shall cooperate with the
respondents for correction of mistake and withdrawal of
the amount. The revisionists submits that, in case, an
application is filed for withdrawal of the balance amount
by the respondents / plaintiffs then full corporation shall
be extended on behalf of the revisionists, so that the
amount of Rs.4,00,000/- is released in their favour.
Thus, an amount of Rs.12,15,120.80 (Rs.19,65,120.80/
minus Rs.7,50,000/-) would be paid by the revisionists
to the respondents, and the revisionists shall vacate the
shop-in-question and handover the vacant, peaceful and
physical possession thereof to the respondents on or
before 09.01.2027 as stated in the affidavit.
6. In view of the submission made by the learned
6
UKHC010149052026
2026:UHC:10676
counsel for the parties and taking into consideration the
affidavit filed by the revisionists and respondents, the
civil revision is disposed of in terms of the settlement
reached between the parties.
7. The judgment and order dated 16.05.2026,
rd
passed by the learned 3 Additional District Judge/
Judge Small Cause Court, Dehradun in SCC Suit No.51 of
2016 is modified in terms of the settlement reached
between the parties.
(Subhash Upadhyay, J.)
20.11.2026
Pant/
7