Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam & Ors vs Chiman Lal Singla & Anr

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

-1-
RSA-3684-2026(O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
RSA-3684-2026(O&M)
RESERVED ON : 04.11.2026
PRONOUNCED ON : 17.11.2026
UPLOADED ON: 17.11.2026
Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam and others ....Appellants
Versus
Chiman Lal Singla and another ...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPINDER SINGH NALWA
Present: Mr. Sanjeev Kaushik, Advocate,
Ms. Divyanshu Kaushik, Advocate and
Ms. Nishtha Raghav, Advocate for the appellants.
*
DEEPINDER SINGH NALWA, J.
1. The present Regular Second Appeal has been filed by the ap-
pellants/defendants No.1 to 3, i.e. Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam
(hereinafter referred to as the ‘Nigam’), challenging the judgment and
decree dated 26.07.2024 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division), Hisar (hereinafter referred to as the “trial Court”), whereby the
suit filed by respondent No.1-plaintiff was decreed and he was held
entitled to counting of his service rendered on daily-wage and work-
charged basis as a qualifying service for the purpose of computing his
pensionary benefits. The appellants-Nigam were directed to recalculate
the pensionary benefits of respondent No.1-plaintiff along with arrears
and interest @ 6% per annum from the date the said benefits became due
till the date of actual realization. The appellants-Nigam have also
challenged the judgment and decree dated 22.04.2026 passed by the
DIWAKER GULATI
learned District Judge, Hisar (hereinafter referred to as the “Lower
2026.11.17 16:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-2-
RSA-3684-2026(O&M)
Appellate Court”), whereby the appeal preferred by the appellants-Nigam
was partly allowed and the judgment and decree dated 26.07.2024 passed
by the trial Court was modified to the extent that respondent No.1-
plaintiff was held entitled to the benefit of his daily wage period and
work-charged service after deduction by the appellants-Nigam of the
employee provident fund share along with interest, by relying upon the
judgment passed by this Court titled as Ishwar Dass Vs. The Managing
Director, Uttar Pradesh Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited and others, CWP
No.14218 of 2017, decided on 12.09.2022 .
2. The brief facts of the case are that the respondent No.1-
plaintiff was appointed as a daily wager in Haryana Vidyut Prasaran
Nigam (hereinafter referred to as 'Nigam') from 15.11.1979 to
31.07.1987. The respondent No.1-plaintiff continued as a work-charge
employee from 01.08.1987 to 20.02.1989. Thereafter, the respondent
No.1-plaintiff was appointed on a regular basis on the post of Lower
Divisional Clerk (LDC) and joined the abovesaid post on 21.02.1989.
The respondent No.1-plaintiff retired on attaining superannuation on
30.04.2019 from the post of Upper Divisional Clerk (UDC) after putting
in more than 39 years of service. The respondent No.1 - plaintiff
approached the appellants-Nigam for counting of his daily wage/work
charge period as qualifying service for the purpose of pensionary benefits.
The case of the respondent No.1-plaintiff was sent to the competent
authority for counting of his daily wage/work charged service as
qualifying service for pensionary benefits; however, the Accounts
Department of the appellants-Nigam raised an objection vide Memo dated
DIWAKER GULATI
2026.11.17 16:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-3-
RSA-3684-2026(O&M)
11.05.2020 that as the service rendered by the respondent No.1-plaintiff
on daily wage/work-charged basis was not followed by regularization, as
such, the previous service rendered by the respondent No.1-plaintiff on
daily wage/work-charged basis cannot be taken into consideration as a
qualifying service for the purpose of grant of pensionary benefits.
3. As the request made by the respondent No.1-plaintiff for
counting of his earlier service as a daily wager/work-charged service was
not taken into consideration as qualifying service for the purpose of
pensionary benefits, the respondent No.1-plaintiff filed a suit for
declaration to the effect that respondent No.1-plaintiff was entitled to get
his revised benefits of DCRG (Death-cum-retirement gratuity) after
counting the qualified service period, rendered with the appellants-
defendants as daily wager from 15.11.1979 to 31.07.1987 and in
continuation with as work charged from 01.08.1987 to 20.02.1989 i.e.
from the date of his initial appointment till the date of regularization of
service i.e. 21.02.1989 and further entitled for quashing of memo No.927
dated 11.05.2020 of AO/Pension HVPNL, Panchkula and for further
declaration to the effect that respondent No.1 - plaintiff was entitled to get
revised his pensionary benefits viz. DCRG alongwith interest @ 18% per
annum, from the date when these benefits fell due, till its actual
realization and mandatory injunction, directing the appellants-defendants
to grant the benefit of qualifying service period of respondent No.1-
plaintiff, which was already sanctioned by the competent authority and
entered in his service record as rendered by the respondent No.1-plaintiff
from 15.11.1979 to 20.02.1989 and the appellants-defendants be further
DIWAKER GULATI
2026.11.17 16:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-4-
RSA-3684-2026(O&M)
directed to release the arrears of DCRG alongwith interest @ 18% per
annum from due date till its actual realization, on the basis of evidence
oral and documentary' of all kinds. The case of the respondent No.1-
plaintiff in the suit was that as the respondent No.1-plaintiff was
appointed as a daily wager from 15.11.1979 to 31.07.1987, and thereafter
on work-charged basis from 01.08.1987 to 20.02.1989, followed by
regular appointment on the post of Lower Divisional Clerk, as there was
no interruption in service, the previous service rendered by the
respondent-plaintiff as a daily wager and on work-charged basis prior to
regular appointment on the post of Lower Divisional Clerk has to be
taken into consideration as qualifying service for pensionary benefits.
4. The appellants-Nigam duly filed a written statement in the
suit. It was the case of the appellants-Nigam that as the period of service
rendered by the respondent No.1-plaintiff on daily wage basis was not
followed by regular appointment, as such, the service rendered by
respondent No.1-plaintiff on daily wage from 15.11.1979 to 31.07.1987
could not be taken into consideration as qualifying service for the purpose
of pensionary benefits The Provident Fund Department (hereinafter to be
referred as ‘the Department’) also filed a reply through the Regional
Provident Fund Commissioner. It was the case of the Department that as
the respondent No.1-plaintiff was a member of the old PF number of the
establishment. It was the case of the Department that the employee's
share and employer's share were already settled on 13.09.1990, and there
was no pending amount due to the respondent-plaintiff as per the record.
DIWAKER GULATI
2026.11.17 16:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-5-
RSA-3684-2026(O&M)
5. From the pleading of the parties, following issues were
framed by the trial Court :-
1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of
declaration alongwith consequential relief of
mandatory injunction, as prayed for? OPP
2. Whether the plaintiff has no cause of action or locus
standi to file the present suit? OPD
3. Whether the suit is time barred? OPD
4. Whether the suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable in
the present form? OPD
5. Whether the plaintiff has not come to the Court with
clean hands? OPD
6. Relief.
6. The trial court decided the suit in favor of respondent No.1 -
plaintiff vide judgment and decree dated 26.07.2024. A perusal of the
judgment and decree dated 26.07.2024 passed by the trial Court would
show that respondent No.1-plaintiff was held entitled for counting of his
previous service rendered by him as a daily wager and on work-charged
basis as a qualifying service for computing the pensionary benefits. The
appellants-Nigam was directed to recalculate the pensionary benefits of
respondent No.1- plaintiff along with interest @ 6% per annum from the

date such benefits were due till the actual realization. A perusal of the
judgment and decree dated 26.07.2024 passed by the trial Court would
show that on the basis of admission made by DW-1 Saluddin, SDO,
Authorized Signatory of the office of Executive Engineer/HVPNL,
DIWAKER GULATI
2026.11.17 16:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-6-
RSA-3684-2026(O&M)
Vidyut Nagar, Hisar, during his cross-examination that the respondent
No.1-plaintiff had worked as a daily wager from 15.11.1979 to
31.07.1987 and thereafter worked on a work-charged basis from
01.08.1987 to 20.02.1989, and his service was to be regularized from
21.02.1989, as such, the service rendered by respondent No.1-plaintiff as
a daily wager and work-charged basis had to be counted as a qualifying
service for the purpose of pensionary benefits. Reliance was also placed
upon the Full Bench judgment of this Court in Kesar Chand v. State of
Punjab and others, AIR 1988 P&H 265 .
7. Aggrieved against the judgment and decree dated 26.07.2024
passed by the trial Court, the appellants-Nigam filed an appeal before the
Lower Appellate Court. The abovesaid appeal was partly allowed by the
Lower Appellate Court vide judgment and decree dated 22.04.2026 and
the judgment and decree dated 26.07.2024 passed by the trial Court was
modified to the extent that respondent No.1-plaintiff is entitled to get
benefit of his work-charge service after deduction by the appellants-
Nigam of the employee provident fund share along with interest, in light
of the judgment passed by this Court in the case titled as Ishwar Dass Vs.
The Managing Director, Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited &
others, CWP No. 14218 of 2017, decided on 12.09.2022 . A perusal of the
judgment dated 22.04.2026 passed by the Lower Appellate Court would
further show that the Court took into consideration Rule 3.17-A of the
Punjab Civil Services Rules, Volume-II, as applicable to the State of
Haryana (hereinafter to be referred as ‘the Rules’), duly adopted by the
‘Nigam’ and held that the service rendered by respondent No.1-plaintiff
DIWAKER GULATI
2026.11.17 16:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-7-
RSA-3684-2026(O&M)
as a daily wager and on work-charged basis has to be taken into
consideration as a qualifying service for the purpose of pensionary
benefits.
8. Aggrieved against the judgments and decrees dated
26.07.2024 passed by the trial Court and 22.04.2026 passed by the Lower
Appellate Court, the appellants-Nigam filed the present appeal.
9. The only contention raised by learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the appellants-Nigam is that as the service rendered by
respondent No.1- plaintiff as a daily wager was not followed by regular
appointment, as such, in light of the Rule 3.17-A (f) (d) of the Rules as
applicable to the appellants-Nigam, the service rendered by respondent
No.1-plaintiff as a daily wager cannot be taken into consideration as a
qualifying service for the purpose of pensionary benefits.
10. I have heard learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellants-Nigam at length; perused the paper-book and have gone
through the evidence led by the parties and the record placed before me.
11. In regard to the contention raised by learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the appellants-Nigam that the service rendered by
respondent No.1-plaintiff as a daily wager cannot be taken into
consideration as a qualifying service for the purpose of pensionary
benefits is concerned, it would be appropriate to reproduce the relevant
Rule for adjudication of the issue involved in the present case:-
“3.17-A. (a) All service interrupted or continuous followed
by confirmation shall be treated as qualifying service; the
period of break shall be omitted while working out
aggregate service.
DIWAKER GULATI
2026.11.17 16:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-8-
RSA-3684-2026(O&M)
(b) Extraordinary leave counted towards increments under
rule 4.9 (b)(ii) of Punjab Civil Services Rules, Volume-I,
Part-I, will be accounted towards service qualifying for
pension.
(c) Periods of suspension, dismissal, removal, compulsory
retirement followed by re-instatement will count for
pension to the extent permissible under rule 4.17 of
Punjab Civil Services Rules Volume-II read with rule 7.3
of the Punjab Civil Services Rules, Volume-I, Part-I.
(d) Resignation from the public service or dismissal or
removal from it for misconduct, insolvency, inefficiency,
not due to age, or failure to pass a prescribed examination
will entail forfeiture of past service in terms of rule 4.19
(a) of Punjab Civil Service Rules Volume-II.
(e) An interruption in the service of a Government
employee caused by willful absence from duty and
unauthorised absence without leave will as hitherto entail
forfeiture of past service.
[Explanation: The willful refusal to perform duties by a
Government employee by any means including pen down
strike shall be deemed to be willful absence from duty.]
(f) Employees retiring from Government service without
confirmation (as temporary employees) in any post on or
after 5th February, 1969 will be entitled to
invalid/retiring/superannuation pension and death-cum-
retirement gratuity on the same basis as admissible to
permanent employees. In case of death of temporary
employee in service his family will also be entitled to
similar benefits as are admissible to the families of
permanent employees. This concession will, however, not
apply to:
(i) Persons paid from contingencies; provided that half of
the period of service of such persons paid from
DIWAKER GULATI
contingencies rendered from 1st January, 1973 onwards
2026.11.17 16:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-9-
RSA-3684-2026(O&M)
for which authentic records of service is available will
count as qualifying service subject to the following
conditions:
(a) Service paid from contingencies should have been in a
job involving whole time employment and not part time for
a portion of day.
(b) Service paid from contingencies should be in a type of
work or job for which regular post should have been
sanctioned e.g. malis, chowkidars, khalasis etc.
(c) The service should have been such for which the
payment is made either on monthly or daily rates
computed and paid on a monthly basis and which though
not analogous to the regular scale of pay should bear
some relations in the matter of pay to those being paid for
similar jobs being performed by staff in regular
establishments.
(d) The service paid from contingencies should have been
continuous and followed by absorption in regular
employment without a break.
Note: While bringing contingent paid employee to the
regular establishment an entry for verification of
contingent service should be made at the appropriate
place in his service book, preferably before making any
entry regarding his regular service in the following
manner:-
"Service from ........ to ........ paid out of contingencies
verified from acquittance rolls and office copies of
contingent bills". This entry should be signed by the Head
of Office with date.
(ii) [Deleted]
(iii) Casual Labour;
(iv) Contract Officers; and
(v) Persons borne on Contributory Provident Fund
DIWAKER GULATI
Establishment.
2026.11.17 16:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-10-
RSA-3684-2026(O&M)
(g) The entire service rendered by an employee as work
charged shall be reckoned towards retirement benefits
provided:-
(i) Such service is followed by regular employment;
(ii) There is no interruption in the two or more spells of
service or the interruptions fall within condonable limits;
and
(iii) Such service is a whole time employment and not
part-time or portion of day.”
12. A perusal of the abovesaid Rules would show that as per
Rule 3.17-A (a), all service, whether interrupted or continuous, followed
by confirmation, is to be treated as qualifying service, while the period of
break is to be excluded while calculating the aggregate service. Further,
as per Rule 3.17-A(f)(d), service paid from contingencies can be taken
into consideration for the purpose of qualifying service, subject to the
condition that the same is continuous and followed by regular
appointment without a break.
13. A perusal of the facts of the present case would show that it
is not in dispute that respondent No.1-plaintiff had rendered service on a
daily-wage basis from 15.11.1979 to 31.07.1987 and thereafter on a
work-charged basis from 01.08.1987 to 20.02.1989 and was not paid out
from contingencies. Thereafter, respondent No.1-plaintiff was regularly
appointed to the post of Lower Divisional Clerk on 21.02.1989. The
service rendered by respondent No.1-plaintiff as a daily-wager and
thereafter continued on work-charged basis followed by regular
appointment was without any break in service. As the respondent
DIWAKER GULATI
No.1/plaintiff was not paid from contingencies for the service rendered by
2026.11.17 16:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

-11-
RSA-3684-2026(O&M)
respondent No.1/plaintiff on daily wage or on work-charged basis, as
such, Rule 3.17-A (f) (d) will not be applicable in the case of respondent
No.1/plaintiff. Accordingly, the abovesaid service rendered by respondent
No.1/plaintiff as a daily wager and on work-charged basis is liable to be
taken into consideration as a qualifying service for the purpose of
pensionary benefits. The mere fact that respondent No.1-plaintiff was
initially engaged on a daily-wage basis and thereafter on a work-charged
basis, followed by appointment on a regular basis, would not disentitle
him from claiming the benefit of his previous service for the purpose of
pensionary benefits.
14. Taking into consideration the abovesaid facts, the evidence
led by the parties and the relevant provisions of the Rules reproduced
above, this Court finds no illegality or infirmity in the judgments and
decrees dated 26.07.2024 and 22.04.2026 passed by the Courts below.
Both the Courts below have rightly appreciated the evidence available on
record and applied the relevant provisions of the Rules. The findings
recorded by the Courts below do not warrant any interference by this
Court.
15. Consequently, the present Regular Second Appeal, being
devoid of any merit, is dismissed. No order as to costs.
16. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand(s) disposed of.
17.11.2026 (DEEPINDER SINGH NALWA)
d.gulati
JUDGE
Whether speaking / reasoned : Yes No
Whether Reportable : Yes No
DIWAKER GULATI
2026.11.17 16:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document