N Saravanane vs JAWAHARLAL INSTITUTE OF POST GRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION AND RESEARCH
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1 OA 310/01044/2026
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CHENNAI BENCH
OA 310/01044/2026
th
Dated Monday, the 26 day of October, Two Thousand and Twenty Six
CORAM :
HON'BLE MR. M. SWAMINATHAN, Member (J)
N.Saravanane
No.8, 1st Main Road,
Gandhiji Nagar,
Ariyankuppam,
Puducherry - 605 010. … Applicant
By Advocate M/s. V. Ajayakumar
Vs
1. Jawaharlal Institute of Post Graduate
Medical Education & Research (for short JIPMER),
rept. by its Director,
Dhanwantari Nagar,
Puducherry- 605 006.
2. The Senior Administrative Officer,
Jawaharlal Institute of Post Graduate Medical
Education & Research,
Dhanwantari Nagar,
Puducherry- 605 006. …Respondents
By Advocate Mr. M.T. Arunan
2 OA 310/01044/2026
ORAL ORDER
(Pronounced by Hon'ble Mr. M. Swaminathan, Member(J))
In the instant OA, the applicant seeks the following relief:
"To call for the records of the second respondent with No.
Estt.17(4)/2012 dated 31.7.2026 and to quash the same and
consequently to direct the respondents to consider and
appointment the applicant on compassionate grounds to any
post on the basis of the demise of the applicant's brother on
27.6.2014 and to pass such other or further orders in the
interest of justice and thus render justice.”
2. Brief facts of the case as submitted by the applicant is as follows:
The applicant submits that his brother Adibalane joined service of the
respondents on 30.7.1994 as Safaiwala and subsequently was promoted to the
post of Nursing Attendant. He met with an accident and expired on 27.6.2014
and at that time he was unmarried and the entire family was depending upon
him. The applicant has submitted an application for compassionate appointment
on 30.7.2014 along with death certificate of his brother and the first respondent
has issued a list of candidates shortlisted for consideration for appointment on
compassionate ground and his name was placed at Sl.No.5 and the placement in
the list was based on the date of death of the employee. It is submitted that
another list was published by the respondents on 01.7.2026 wherein the name of
the applicant was shown in the ineligible candidates list and it is stated that the
deceased Adibalane was unmarried and his sister is having mental illness and the
applicant is younger brother and is not direct dependant of the employee. The
3 OA 310/01044/2026
respondents have waited for more than 12 years to come to the conclusion that
the applicant is not entitled to get appointment on compassionate ground and
hence is liable to be rejected. Moreover, in a similar matter, one Amsaveni who
is sister of the deceased employee namely D.Ayyanarappan declared as eligible
for appointment on compassionate grounds in the recommendation submitted by
the Appoints Committee on 13.3.2025, eventhough, she is already married and is
having son who is major. Hence, denying appointment on compassionate
grounds to the applicant alone by stating that he is at present married is a clear
case of discrimination. Hence the applicant has filed this OA seeking the above
relief.
3. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the applicant’s brother was
a regular employee of the respondents Institute and had rendered more than 20
years of service as on the date of accident. Hence the applicant is entitled to be
considered for compassionate appointment to any suitable post. It is submitted
that as per the impugned order, the applicant submitted his application on
07.05.2016 which is factually incorrect, whereas the applicant made his
application on 30.07.2014. The impugned order dated 31.07.2026 is a non-
speaking order and hence it is liable to be quashed. Further, as per the report
submitted by the Revenue Authorities on 05.01.2015, the applicant was
unmarried and hence denying appointment on compassionate grounds is
arbitrary and illegal. Further in a similar case of one Amsaveni who is sister of
4 OA 310/01044/2026
deceased D. Ayyanarappan who is already married and also is having a son who
is major was declared as eligible for appointment on compassionate grounds
whereas on the same ground, the name of the applicant has been rejected stating
that the applicant is married at present and the marital status of the applicant at
the time of death of his brother nor at the time of submitting application and
consideration of the application by the Department has not been considered and
hence declaring that the applicant is not eligible for appointment on
compassionate grounds is liable to be quashed.
4. Heard the learned counsel for the applicant and Mr. M.T. Arunan who
takes notice on behalf of the respondents.
5. The impugned order dated 31.07.2026 reads as under:
“With reference to the representation cited above, the grievance
submitted by you has been examined in detail by the
Compassionate Appointment Committee with reference to the
relevant records and the extant Government of India
instructions/guidelines governing appointments on
compassionate grounds.
st
During the examination, it was observed that your 1 application
for compassionate appointment dated 07.05.2016 was examined.
The applicant was married on the date of application. Therefore,
the applicant doesn’t meet the eligibility fixed by the DoPT and
the committee decided not to consider the request.”
6. This Tribunal find that courts have consistently held that marriage cannot
be a ground for rejection of compassionate appointment. In the above
5 OA 310/01044/2026
circumstance, the impugned order passed by the respondents is a cryptic order.
Accordingly, the impugned order dated 31.07.2026 is set aside and the
respondents are directed to reconsider the issue in the light of the latest
Judgments and in accordance with the extant rules for compassionate
appointment. It is made clear that this Tribunal is not entering into the merits of
the case.
7. With the above direction, the OA is disposed of at the admission stage.
(M. Swaminathan)
Member (J)
26.10.2026
Digitally signed
by P ARUNA
SOWBHAGYA
Date: 2026.11.03
17:08:21 +05'30'
P ARUNA SOWBHAGYA
COURT MASTER
CAT,MADRAS BENCH