SRI. BHIMASHI S/O HANAMANT METI vs MR. AMISH NIRANJANBHAI MOMAY

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD

TH
DATED THIS THE 17 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE USHARANI

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 102990 OF 2018

(MV-I)

C/W

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 102991 OF 2018

(MV-I)



IN MFA No. 102990/2018
BETWEEN:


SMT. SRIDEVI W/O BHIMASHI METI
AGE. 29 YEARS
OCC. AGRICULTURE AND COOLIE
NOW NIL
R/O. MAKKALAGERI,
TQ. GOKAK
DIST. BELAGAVI-591344
…APPELLANT








(BY SRI. HARISH S MAIGUR, ADVOCATE)
YASHAVANT
NARAYANKAR
AND:

MR. AMISH NIRANJANBHAI MOMAY
AGE. MAJOR, OCC. BUSINESS
R/O. 102
ELITE SWASTIC SOCIETY
NAVARANGPUR
DIST AHMEDABAD
GUJARAT-380001



Digitally signed by
YASHAVANT
NARAYANKAR
Date: 2026.11.17
16:48:00 +0530

- 2 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


2.
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER
THE NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
THROUGH ITS DIVISIONAL OFFICE
RAMDEV GALLI
BELAGAVI-590001

3. MR. ABDULRASHID NIJAMUDDIN PATEL
AGE.MAJOR
OCC. BUSINESS
R/O. PLOT NO.3
LAXMI VASAHAT, AJWAR NAGAR
"B" WARD,
KOLHAPUR-416001
MAHARASHTRA

4. THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER
THE UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO.TD.,
THROUGH ITS DIVISIONAL OFFICE
MARUTI GALLI, BELAGAVI-590002

…RESPONDENTS
(NOTICE TO R1 IS SERVED;
SRI. S.S. GUNDI, ADV. FOR R2;
SRI. BHAGYASHREE N. BIKKANNAVAR, ADV. FOR R3;
SRI. C.V. ANGADI, ADV. FOR R4)

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.173 (1) OF MOTOR VEHICLES
ACT, PRAYING TO, ENHANCE THE COMPENSATION BY
MODIFYING THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD PASSED IN M.V.C.
NO. 2011/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE V ADDL. DISTRICT AND
SESSIONS JUDGE AND M.A.C.T. VI, BELAGAVI DATED
06.04.2018 BY ALLOWING THIS APPEAL WITH COSTS, IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.

- 3 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


IN MFA NO. 102991/2018
BETWEEN:

SRI. BHIMASHI S/O HANAMANT METI
AGE: 34 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE, NOW NIL,
R/O: MAKKALAGERI,
TQ: GOKAK,
DIST: BELAGAVI-591344.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. HARISH S MAIGUR, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. MR. AMISH NIRANJANBHAI MOMAY
AGE: MAJOR,
OCC: BUSINESS,
R/O: 102, ELITE SWASTIC SOCIETY,
NAVARANGPUR,
DIST: AHMEDABAD,
GUJARATH-380001.

2. THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER
THE NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
THORUGH ITS DIVISIONAL OFFICE,
RAMDEV GALLI,
BELAGAVI-590001.

3. MR. ABDULRASHID NIJAMUDDIN PATEL
AGE: MAJOR,
OCC: BUSINESS,
R/O: PLOT NO.3,
LAXMI VASAHAT,
JAWAR NAGAR,
"B" WARD,
KOLHAPUR-416001,
MAHARASHTRA.

- 4 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


4.
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER
THE UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
THROUGH ITS DIVISIONAL OFFICE,
MARUTI GALLI,
BELAGAVI-590002.
...RESPONDENTS
(NOTICE TO R1 IS SERVED;
SRI. S.S. GUNDI, ADV. FOR R2;
NOTICE TO RESPONDENT NO. 3 IS SERVED;
SRI. C.V. ANGADI, ADV. FOR R4)

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.173(1) OF MOTOR VEHICLES
ACT, PRAYING TO, ENHANCE THE COMPENSATION BY
MODIFYING THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD PASSED IN M.V.C.
NO. 2010/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE V ADDL. DISTRICT AND
SESSIONS JUDGE AND M.A.C.T. VI, BELAGAVI DATED
06.04.2018 BY ALLOWING THIS APPEAL WITH COSTS, IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THESE APPEALS, HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
ON 11.11.2026, COMING FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF
JUDGMENT, ON THIS DAY, THE COURT PRONOUNCED THE
FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE USHARANI

CAV COMMON JUDGMENT


1. MFA No.102990/2018 is filed by the claimant in
MVC No.2011/2014 and MFA No.102991/2018 is filed by the
claimant in MVC No.2010/2014 seeking enhancement of
compensation awarded by the V Additional District and

- 5 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


Sessions Judge and VI Additional MACT, Belagavi (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the Tribunal’ for short).

2. MVC No.2010/2014 and 2011/2014 were filed
under Section 166 of the M.V. Act and both are arising out of
same cause of action. There is no dispute with regard to
occurrence of accident and liability fixed on respondent No.2
and 4 (insurance companies of truck and car) at the ratio of
60:40, respectively in both the cases.

3. The facts in brief as averred by the claimants are
that the claimants were travelling via motorcycle on
25.07.2014, when the truck bearing registration No. GJ-01-AY-
8811 crashed from behind into the said motorcycle in rash and
negligent manner. When the said vehicles fell down
consequently, a car bearing registration No. MH-10-C-0070,
which was in the process of overtaking the truck crashed into
the said motorcycle.

4. The Tribunal, after considering oral and
documentary evidence, awarded compensation in MVC
No.2010/2014 and MVC No.2011/2014 under the following
heads:

- 6 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


MVC No.2010/2014
Head Amount in
Rs.(₹)
Future earning capacity 2,12,160/-
Pain and suffering 40,000/-
Medical Expenses 9,282/-
Food, nutrition, attendant charges 25,000/-
Loss of income during laid up period 16,000/-
Total 3,02,442/-
Rounded off to 3,02,500/-
MVC No.2011/2014
Head Amount in
Rs.(₹)
Pain and suffering 50,000/-
Medical expenses 1,20,855/-
Total 1,70,855/-
Rounded off to 1,71,000/-


5. Learned counsels for the appellants-claimants, in
both the appeals, contend that the appellant-claimant in MFA
No.102990/2018 was an agricultural coolie, who had suffered
100% disability and was in hospital for a period of 50 days. The
Tribunal by observing that, the doctor who had issued disability
certificate was not the treating doctor, erred in not considering
the disability suffered by her. It is further contended that, since
claimant has lost five fingers, the Tribunal ought to have
referred to Schedule I of Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923
(for short ‘W.C.Act’), while ascertaining disability. The Tribunal,

- 7 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


without considering the said aspects, awarded compensation
under the head of ‘pain and suffering’ on a lower side and has
not awarded compensation under other heads i.e., ‘loss of
amenities’, ‘travel expenditure’, ‘nourishment’, ‘future medical
expenses’ etc.

6. Further, learned counsel for appellant in MFA
No.102991/2018 contended that, the Tribunal has rightly
ascertained disability suffered by the appellant at 13.3%, but
has not awarded compensation under the head of ‘loss of
amenities’ and has failed to consider the ‘laid up period’ as
three months and awarded meager compensation under the
head of ‘pain and suffering’.

7. Counsel for respondent No.2-Insurance Company of
the truck bearing No.GJ-01/AY-8811 contended that, the
Tribunal has rightly not considered the photographs of
appellant in MFA No.102990/2018 and held that since the
doctor, who has issued Ex.P9 was not examined, the contents
of Ex.P9 i.e., disability certificate cannot be accepted. It is
further contended by learned counsel that Tribunal has wrongly
considered the income of claimant in MFA No.102991/2014 as
₹8,000/- instead of ₹7,500/- and has awarded compensation
on higher side. It was also pointed out that, the Tribunal has

- 8 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


rd
wrongly calculated 1/3 of 25% disability at 13.3% and it
should have been 8.3%. Without considering the evidence of
PW1 that, he had married 8 to 9 years ago at the of age of 25-
26 years, the Tribunal has wrongly taken his age as 30 years
and applied multiplier ‘17’, which ought to have been ‘16’.

8. The learned counsel for the respondent No.4-
Insurance Company of the car bearing No.MH-10/C-0070 has
adopted the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for
respondent No.2.

9. Heard the arguments advanced by counsels for the
claimants, insurance companies and I have given anxious look
to the materials on record. The point that arises for my
consideration are:

(i) Whether the judgment and award passed in
M.V.C.2011/2014 requires interference?

(ii) Whether the judgment and award passed in
M.V.C.2010/2014 requires interference

(iii) What Order?

- 9 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


MFA No.102990/2018

10. In respect of the appellant in MFA No.102990/2018,
it is to be ascertained that, whether the appellant has suffered
any disability and if so, what is the percentage of functional
disability suffered by her. Tribunal has observed that the
appellant has not examined the doctor, who has issued Ex.P9-
disability certificate, but has believed the contents in the wound
certificate-Ex.P6 and also the medical bills at Ex.P10 to 36
amounting to ₹1,20,855/-. It is relevant to extract the injuries
mentioned in Ex.P6, which are as follows:
(i) Left forearm crush injury upto elbow,
hand muscles cut, Bleeding, tendons
cut, bones exposed.
(ii) Left hand crush injury upto base of
finger, left thumb dislocated, wrist joint
exposed, part of bones lost, all tendons
at dorsum CUT.

11. Further, it is also relevant to extract a portion in
Ex.P9-disability certificate wherein the injuries said to have
been suffered by the appellant have been explained. They are
as follows:
(i) Deformed left hand, fingers unable to
move, left hand fingers pain always in
left upper limb, unable to hold objects,

- 10 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


unable to do any work, unable to do
routine daily activities from left hand.
(ii) Pain itching at left thigh. On and off
redness and discharge from left thigh.


2. Thereafter, the doctor has opined as follows:
“Opinion: I am of opinion that considering
clinical examination and radiological
findings and crush injury to left hand, wrist
and forearm and analysis of thumb, fingers
and wrist joint total permanent physical
disability of 80% in relation to left upper
limb and 10% in relation to left lower limb
(ALIMCO, WHO Gazette)”

12. Moreover, the doctor, who has issued Ex.P9 was
examined before the Tribunal as PW2 and he has deposed
regarding injuries recorded in Ex.P6 as well as observation
made by him in Ex.P9. Even though PW2 was cross-examined
by the counsel for Insurance Company at length, nothing was
elicited in their favor. It is discernable even from Ex.P6 alone
that appellant had suffered deformation of upper limb which
has no movements. Since the doctor, who has issued Ex.P9,
has been examined before the Tribunal and he has
corroborated the contents in Ex.P9, the same has to be
considered. Moreover, as per the wound certificate at Ex. P6

- 11 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


and medical bill at Ex P 10, it can be concluded that PW2 is the
treated doctor. Hence, viewed from any angle, the Tribunal
ought not to have discarded the contents of Ex. P9 and I concur
with the argument of the appellant in this regard.


13. Therefore, in order to assess just compensation,
understand medical evidence, ascertain the physical and
functional disability, I have gone through I Schedule of the
W.C. Act, which stipulates 60% of permanent disability in case
of loss of thumb and four fingers of one hand.


14. In the case of Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar and
1
another , various illustrations were provided to explain
the manner in which the concerned Tribunals and Courts
have to assess permanent disability in relation to injuries
and future prospects. In case of a driver who suffered
amputation of hand and was terminated subsequently,
upon considering 60% permanent disability, loss of future
earning capacity was assessed at 75%. The nature of job
and chances of employment were considered while
assessing the same. In case of a 25 year old final year
engineering student who suffered amputation of right hand

1
2011 (1) SCC 343

- 12 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


and impairment of vision, considering assessment of 70%
permanent disability, loss of earning capacity was
assessed as 70%. The injury that had incapacitated her
from pursuing her career was factored in, while assessing
such loss of earning capacity.

15. Therefore, taking into consideration above
illustrations, the principles laid down therein and in view of
the fact that the appellant has suffered permanent
disability of 80% in relation to upper limb and 10% in
relation to lower limb, I opine that she has suffered
permanent disability of 75%. The possibility of continuing
her coolie work is bleak and she would even require
assistance to wear clothes and to carry out daily routine.
Since she is an agricultural coolie who met with an
accident in the year 2014, her income is fixed as ₹7,500/-
per month as per notional income chart issued by the
Karnataka State Legal Services Authority. There is no
dispute with regard to age of the claimant and hence,
multiplier applicable is ‘18’.

- 13 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018



16. As per Discharge Summary-ExP.8, appellant was
hospitalized on 25.07.2014 and was treated as an inpatient for
a period of 49 days. In light of such hospitalization, the
compensation under heads such as ‘conveyance’, ‘medical
expenses’, ‘food and nourishment’, ‘loss of income during laid
up period’, has to be considered. Therefore, the appellant is
entitled for compensation under the following modified heads:
Head Amount in
Rs.(₹)
Pain and suffering 1,50,000/-
Loss of income due to disability 12,15,000/-
(7,500x12x18x75%)
Medical expenses 1,20,855/-
Loss of income during laid up period 18,375/-
Conveyance, food, nourishment. attendant 40,000/-
charges etc.,
Loss of amenities 2,00,000/-
Total 17,44,230/-


17. According to the learned counsel for the appellant,
the interest awarded by the Tribunal is on lower side and
sought interest @ 12% per annum. It is important to refer here
the case of Puttamma and others Vs. K.L. Narayana Reddy
2
and Another , wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held
that relevant factors such as inflation, changes in the economy
and the policy being adopted by the Reserve Bank of India are

2
(2013)15 SCC 45

- 14 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


required to be considered while awarding interest. Further, a
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in United India Insurance
3
Company Vs. Malyadari M , has opined that awarding
interest at the rate of 9% per annum is more appropriate in
cases involving death and serious injuries. In light of the same,
I opine that the rate of interest claimed by the appellant is on
higher side and it would be appropriate to award interest @ 9%
per annum since the instant case involves permanent disability.
Accordingly, the enhanced compensation shall also carry
interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of petition
till realization. Hence, Point No. (i) is answered in the
affirmative.
MFA No.102991/2018

18. The appellant in MFA No.102991/2018 is an
agriculturist. He approached this Court seeking enhancement of
compensation awarded under the heads of ‘loss of income
during laid up period’ and ‘pain and suffering’, and grant of
compensation under the head of ‘loss of amenities’.

19. However, in the case at hand, the Insurance
Companies have neither preferred any appeal nor filed any
cross-objection against the impugned award. In the case of

3
MFA 3895/2018 (Bengaluru bench)

- 15 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


Satya Prakash Dwivedi Vs. Munna alias Chandrabhan
4
Yadav and Others , the Hon’ble Apex Court, in an appeal filed
by the injured claimant seeking enhancement, has held that the
finding of the Tribunal on disability could not have been
reduced, in the absence of an appeal or cross-objection by the
Insurance Company, and that the claimant could not have been
worse off in his own appeal.

20. Though there is an arithmetical error in computing
the disability, as pointed out by the counsel for insurance
company, this Court will not venture into the same. This Court
considers it appropriate to reserve liberty to the insurance
companies to approach the Tribunal with appropriate
application seeking necessary correction. Hence, point No. (ii)
is answered in the negative .

21. Point No.(iii), in view of the discussions made supra
on Point No. (i) and (ii), I proceed to pass the following:
ORDER IN MFA NO. 102990/2018

(i) MFA No. 102990/2018 is allowed-in-part .

(ii) The judgment and award dated 06.04.2018
passed in MVC No. 2011/2014 by V

4
2021 INSC 491

- 16 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


Additional District and Sessions Judge and
MACT VI, Belagavi, is hereby modified.

(iii) The appellant is entitled to the
compensation of ₹17,44,230/- with interest
at the rate of 9% per annum from the date
of petition till realization.

(iv) The respondent no. 2 and 4-Insurance
Companies shall deposit the compensation,
together with accrued interest in the ratio of
60:40, before the jurisdictional Tribunal
within a period of eight weeks from the date
of receipt of a certified copy of this
judgment.

(v) The Registry to transmit amount in deposit,
if any, along with the trial court records to
the tribunal forthwith.

(vi) Registry to draw modified award
accordingly.

- 17 -
MFA No. 102990 of 2018
C/W MFA No. 102991 of 2018


ORDER IN MFA NO. 102991/2018

(i) MFA No. 102991/2018 is dismissed with
liberty to the respondent No. 2 and 4 to file
appropriate application under Section 152
of CPC before the Tribunal.

(ii) The Registry shall transmit the Trial Court
records forthwith.


Sd/-
(USHARANI)
JUDGE




YAN