Shanti Devi Etc. vs Dharam Singh Etc.
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
-1-
119 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 11.11.2026
(i) FAO-520-1999
SHANTI DEVI (SINCE DECEASED) THROUGH HER LRS
...Appellant
Versus
DHARAM SINGH AND ORS.
...Respondents
(ii) FAO-519-1999
SHANTI DEVI AND ORS
...Appellants
Versus
DHARAM SINGH AND ORS.
...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PARMOD GOYAL
Present: Ms. Deepshikha, Advocate for
Mr. Anil Kumar Gahlawat, Advocate
for the appellant(s) (in both appeals).
Mr. Vinod Kumar Gupta, Advocate
for respondent No.3-Insurance Company (in both appeals).
PARMOD GOYAL, J. (ORAL)
CM-13346-CII-2026 in FAO No.520 of 1999
LRs of appellant-Shanti Devi have sought condonation of delay
of 3656 days in filing application for restoration of FAO-520-1999 which
was dismissed for non-prosecution vide order dated 13.03.2014.
2. It is the case of applicant/appellant that learned Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal, Rewari (hereinafter referred to as ‘Tribunal’) had awarded
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
-2-
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
compensation to applicant-appellant on account of death of her son in motor
vehicular accident dated 13.01.1993.
3. Applicant-Shanti Devi had preferred FAO-520-1999 seeking
enhancement of compensation awarded by the Tribunal vide award dated
09.11.1998. The said appeal was taken up for hearing on 13.03.2014,
however, none could appear on behalf of appellant and therefore, appeal was
dismissed for non-prosecution. It is the case of applicants that after the
accident the family of applicants which is headed by none else but applicant-
Shanti Devi was in bad shape and was under distress as they had lost the
earning member of family in motor vehicular accident. That the applicant-
mother of deceased was simply relying upon Sh. Rajpal Yadav, Advocate
who was engaged by her for prosecuting her appeal before this Court.
4. However, the said counsel had always informed the family that
case is still pending before the High Court, he never informed that the case
was dismissed in default on 13.03.2014. That on 23.05.2026, applicants
themselves had gone to counsel’s house and came to know that Sh. Rajpal
Yadav, Advocate had left practice since long and no information was
forthcoming. They accordingly, engaged a new counsel to enquire about the
status of appeal and that is when they came to know that the same stood
dismissed on 13.03.2014.
5. It is asserted that since applicants were having no knowledge
about dismissal of their appeal and had simply relied upon their counsel who
was at fault as he failed to appear and inform about dismissal of case.
Therefore, it is prayed that delay in filing application for restoration of
appeal be condoned.
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
-3-
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
6. Learned counsel for respondent No.3-Insurance Company has
opposed the restoration application on the ground that appeal was dismissed
more than 11 years back and it was duty of applicants to enquire about status
of the appeal and failure to do so shows that the reasons stated by applicants-
appellants are neither sufficient nor justified.
7. On consideration, I find that reasons given by applicants are just
for restoration of present appeal. It is pertinent to note that vide order dated
04.05.1999, the appeal was admitted by Division Bench of this Court,
thereafter, vide order dated 01.10.1999, appeal was sent back by Lok Adalat
to this Court for its decision on merits on the ground that finding of
contributory negligence are in issue. Thereafter, matter was taken up on
13.03.2014 by the Court and was dismissed for non-prosecution as learned
counsel for appellant had failed to appear.
8. No doubt, it is the duty of the concerned counsel to appear in
the appeal in which he has put in appearance as and when same is fixed.
However, the party cannot be penalized for acts of his counsel especially
when case was taken up after 05 years, without fixation of actual date.
9. The appropriate course in such cases would have been to issue
notices to applicants and if there was no representation it ought to have been
dismissed for non-prosecution. Court can dismiss the appeal when a counsel
fails to appear and it can also issue notices to appellants instead of
dismissing the appeal on first default. It all depends on facts and
circumstances of each case. Keeping in view facts and circumstances of
present case, wherein case was taken up after 05 years, I feel that the reasons
given by appellants are just reasons and accordingly, appeal is restored back
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
-4-
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
to its original number.
10. However, the appellants cannot be absolved fully from their
duty to keep track of the case. They ought to have been more vigilant in
making regular enquiries/visits to the concerned counsels to know fate of
their case. Therefore, to balance the equities, restoration of appeal is
allowed, subject to the condition that appellants shall not be entitled to
interest from date of dismissal of appeal for non-prosecution till date of
filing of application for restoration of appeal on enhanced amount, if any.
CM-13367-CII-2026 in FAO No.519 of 1999
11. Applicants-appellants have sought condonation of delay of
3712 days in filing application for restoration of FAO-519-1999.
12. In view of above discussion, CM-13367-CII-2026 is allowed,
subject to the condition that appellants shall not be entitled to interest from
date of dismissal of appeal for non-prosecution till date of filing of
application for restoration of appeal on enhanced amount, if any.
FAO No.520 of 1999 & FAO No.519 of 1999
1 . Present appeals have been preferred by the appellants-claimants
being aggrieved by award dated 19.11.1998 passed by learned Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Rewari (hereinafter referred to as ‘ Tribunal ’) for
enhancement of compensation . Since the present appeals have arisen from
common impugned award passed by learned Tribunal vide which the claim
petitions preferred on account of motor vehicular accident which had
occurred on the intervening night of 12/13.01.1993 caused by rash and
negligent driving of truck bearing registration No.DNG-1221 were decided
and since the dispute involved in both the appeals is identical, they are being
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
-5-
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
decided by way of this common judgment. Gist of claim petitions is given as
under:-
Sr. Case title before MACT Case Claim Compensation
No. the MACT No./Appeal No. pertains to awarded by
the Tribunal
1. Shanti Devi and
Ors. Vs. Dharam
Singh & Ors.
MACT Case No.
91 of 1993/FAO
No.519 of 1999
Compensation
on account of
death of Om
Prakash by
widow,
children(4) and
parents
Rs.1,17,000/-
2. Shanti Devi (since
deceased) through
her LRs Vs.
Dharam Singh &
Ors.
MACT Case
No.92 of 1993/
FAO No.520 of
1999
Compensation
on account of
death of
Kailash Chand
by mother.
Rs.87,000/-
2. Learned counsel for the appellants-claimants has challenged
finding of contributory negligence recorded by learned Tribunal. In present
case, accident had taken place between truck bearing registration No.DHL-
1186 driven by Om Parkash (hereinafter referred to as ‘ deceased ’) and truck
bearing registration No.DNG-1221 driven by Sucha Singh. Both the drivers
had died in accident. Learned counsel for the appellants-claimants has
argued that learned Tribunal has erred in ignoring evidence of PW-5 and
relying upon contents of FIR to wrongly conclude contributory negligence
on the part of deceased-Om Parkash. The accident was result of sole
negligence of driver of truck No.DNG-1221.
3. On re-appreciation of evidence, I do not find any error in the
findings recorded by learned Tribunal in para Nos.12, 13 and 14 of
impugned award wherein after appreciating testimonies of Balwinder (PW-
4) and Mohan (PW-5) who had claimed themselves to be eye-witnesses of
the accident as well as contents of FIR (Ex.P1) lodged by person traveling
in truck bearing registration No.DNG-1221, namely Tirsem Singh, learned
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
-6-
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
Tribunal had concluded that accident was a result of head on collision and
therefore, both the drivers of trucks were equally liable for causing the
accident. Accordingly, it was held that the accident was result of
contributory negligence on part of drivers of both the trucks. Learned
Tribunal had rightly appreciated the evidence of PW-4 as well as contents of
FIR (Ex. P1) which was lodged promptly.
4. Learned counsel for the appellants-claimants has made
reference to evidence of Mohan (PW-5) who had stated that it was truck
bearing registration No.DNG-1221 which was at fault. It is to be noticed that
as far as testimony of PW-4 is concerned, he had clearly stated that he was
traveling in the ill-fated truck bearing registration No.DNG-1221. He also
claimed that both the trucks had struck against each other and both the
drivers and one other person had died in the said accident. He however, in
his cross-examination could not disclose as to who was at fault. Similarly, in
FIR(Ex.P1), another occupant of truck bearing registration No.DNG-1211,
namely Tirsem Singh had disclosed before the police immediately after the
occurrence that accident was result of rash and negligent driving of truck
bearing registration No.DHL-1186 which was being driven by deceased-Om
Parkash, at high speed and accident was a result of head on collision.
5. To counter their own-witness i.e. PW-4 who had not stated sole
fault of truck No.DNG-1221, appellants-claimants had also examined
another eye-witness as PW-5. Learned Tribunal, however, had rightly not
taken testimony of PW-5 in its consideration as his presence at the time of
occurrence is not corroborated by any means. He claimed that he was
traveling in a truck and had stopped to get tea on the road side when the
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
-7-
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
accident took place. He had claimed that truck coming from Delhi side
bearing registration No.DHL-1186 was being driven at slow speed whereas
the other truck was being driven rashly and negligently. The presence of
PW-5 had come to light only at the time of examination of witnesses in
claim petition. He is neither author of FIR (Ex.P1) nor has been shown to be
one of the witnesses by police as regards to accident. The contents of FIR
(Ex.P1) and evidence of PW-4, therefore, had rightly been relied upon by
learned Tribunal and no fault with the findings of learned Tribunal can be
found. The evidence of PW-4 and manner in which accident had taken place,
head on, goes to show that both the drivers were equally responsible for
causing accident. Findings of learned Tribunal on this issue are accordingly
affirmed.
FAO No.519 of 1999
6. The claimants i.e. widow, children (4) and parents of deceased-
Om Parkash have filed the present appeal seeking enhancement in
compensation. The learned Tribunal had assessed the income of the
₹
deceased as 1,500/- per month and had awarded following compensation
accordingly :-
Income of deceased Rs.1,500/- per month
Deduction 1/3rd
Multiplier 17
Loss of dependency Rs.2,04,000/-
(Rs.1,000/- x 17 x 12)
Loss of consortium Rs.15,000/-
Total Compensation awarded Rs.1,17,000/-
(50% deducted on account of
contributory negligence out of
Rs.2,04,000/- + Rs.15,000/-)
7. The appellants-claimants have sought enhancement in
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
-8-
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
compensation awarded by the learned Tribunal on the following grounds:
•
That the learned Tribunal had failed to apply the correct
multiplier, as per age of deceased.
•
That no addition towards future prospects has been made
while calculating the loss of dependency. Future prospects
ought to have been added, as per the age of deceased.
•
That the learned Tribunal has also failed to award just and
appropriate compensation under the conventional heads,
namely funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of spousal,
parental, and filial consortium, in accordance with the law laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
8. Appellants-claimants had claimed that the deceased was 25 years old
and was earning Rs.2,000/- per month while working as a driver of a truck.
In order to prove pleaded income and vocation of deceased, appellants-
claimants had only relied upon self-serving oral assertions and had not
placed reliance on any cogent and reliable evidence, which may show that
deceased was earning Rs.2,000/- per month. Therefore, in these
circumstances minimum wages ought to have been taken by learned
Tribunal for determining income of deceased. In present case, learned
Tribunal had taken income of deceased to be Rs.1,500/- per month which is
higher than minimum wages payable to skilled worker in the year 1993.
Accordingly, income of deceased is taken as Rs.1,500 /- per month. The age
of deceased was not mentioned in PMR (Ex.PA), however the age of the
deceased was taken to be 32 years by the learned Tribunal on the basis of
age of Shanti Devi who stated her age to be 30 years, which is upheld. Since
deceased was aged 32 years at the time of accident, he would be entitled to
addition of 40% towards future prospects in view of judgment passed by
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
-9-
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
Hon’ble Supreme Court in National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay
Sethi and Ors. , 2017 (16) SCC 680 and keeping in view of age of deceased
to be 32 years, multiplier of ‘16’ would be applicable as per judgment
passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Smt. Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi
Transport Corporation & Anr. , 2009(6) SCC 121. Similarly, deduction
towards personal expenses has to be made on the basis of number of
dependents which are seven in present case i.e. wife, children(4) and parents.
Accordingly, deduction to the extent of 1/5th shall be applicable.
9. The loss of dependency, therefore, has to be determined by
taking monthly income of deceased to be Rs.1,500/- , by applying future
prospects to the extent of 40% , multiplier of ‘ 16 ’ and by making deduction
of 1/5th towards personal expenses.
10. Apart from compensation for loss of dependency, appellants-
claimants shall also be entitled to Rs . 15,000 /- towards funeral expenses and
Rs . 15,000 /- towards loss of estate . Appellant-claimant No.1 shall be entitled
to compensation of Rs . 40,000 /- towards loss of spousal consortium .
Appellants-claimants No.2 to 5 shall be entitled to compensation of
Rs . 40,000 /- each towards loss of parental consortium . Appellants-
claimants No.6 and 7 shall be entitled to compensation of Rs . 40,000 /- each
towards loss of filial consortium . It is however made clear that in case
Hon’ble Supreme Court answers the reference regarding quantum of
compensation under conventional heads made in Hasina Yasmin & Ors.
Vs. National Insurance Co. Ltd. , 2025 SCC Online SC 2919 in favour of
appellants-claimants, appellant-claimants shall be free to seek said amount
by moving appropriate application in this regard.
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
-10-
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
11. Accordingly, reworked compensation is as under :-
Income Rs.1,500/- Rs.1,500/-
per month per month
Future Prospects 40% Rs.2,100/-
(Rs.1,500/-+ 600)
Deduction 1/5th Rs.1,680/-
(Rs.2,100/- – 420)
Multiplier 16 16
Total loss of Rs.1,680/-x 12x 16 Rs.3,22,560/-
dependency
Loss of Estate Rs. 15,000/-
Funeral Expenses Rs.15,000/-
Loss of spousal
consortium to
claimant No. 1
Rs.40,000
Rs.40,000 x 4 Rs.1,60,000/-
Loss of parental
consortium to
claimant Nos. 2 to 5
Rs.40,000 x 2 Rs.80,000/-
Loss of filial
consortium to
claimants Nos. 6 &7
Total Compensation Rs.6,32,560/-
Total compensation 50% of Rs. 6,32,560
awarded in appeal (Deduction on account of
findings of contributory
negligence)
Rs.3,16,280
Total Compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal
Rs.1,17,000/-
Enhanced amount of Rs.3,16,280/- (awarded in
compensation appeal) – Rs.1,17,000/-
(awarded by the Tribunal)
Rs.1,99,280/-
FAO No.520 of 1999
12. The claimant i.e. mother of Kailash Chand (hereinafter referred
to as ‘ the deceased ’) has filed the present appeal seeking enhancement in
compensation. The learned Tribunal had assessed the income of the
deceased as Rs.900/- per month and had awarded following compensation
accordingly :-
Income of deceased Rs.900/- per month
Deduction 1/3rd
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
-11-
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
Multiplier 12
Loss of dependency Rs.86,400/-
(Rs.600/- x 12 x 12)
Total Compensation awarded Rs.87,000/-
(rounded-off)
13.
The appellants-claimants have sought enhancement in
compensation awarded by the learned Tribunal on the following grounds:
•
That the Learned Tribunal had erred in not assessing the
income of deceased as pleaded by the claimants.
•
That the learned Tribunal had failed to apply the correct
multiplier, as per age of deceased.
•
That no addition towards future prospects has been made
while calculating the loss of dependency. Future prospects
ought to have been added, as per the age of deceased.
•
That the learned Tribunal had also failed to award just and
appropriate compensation under the conventional heads,
namely funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of spousal,
parental, and filial consortium, in accordance with the law laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
14. Appellant-claimant had claimed that the deceased was 18 years old at
the time of accident and was earning Rs.1,200/- per month by working as a
conductor on a truck. In order to prove pleaded income and vocation of
deceased, appellant-claimant had only relied upon self-serving oral
assertions and had not placed any cogent and reliable evidence, which may
show that deceased was earning Rs.1,200/- per month. Since, in present
case, minimum wages payable to unskilled worker in the year 1993 when the
accident had taken place were Rs.1,034/-, therefore, income stated orally
which is close to minimum wages ought to have been taken by learned
Tribunal. Accordingly, income of deceased is taken as Rs.1,200/- per
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
-12-
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
month. The age of deceased was not mentioned in PMR (Ex.PB), however
the age of the deceased was taken to be 20 years by the learned Tribunal,
which is upheld. Since deceased was aged 20 years at the time of accident,
he would be entitled to addition of 40% towards future prospects in view of
judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in National Insurance
Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors. , 2017 (16) SCC 680 and
keeping in view of age of deceased to be 20 years, multiplier of ‘18’ would
be applicable as per judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Smt.
Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr. , 2009(6)
SCC 121. Similarly, deduction towards personal expenses has to be made on
the basis of number of dependents which is one in present case i.e. mother.
Accordingly, deduction to the extent of 1/2 shall be applicable as the
deceased was unmarried and is survived by his mother..
15. The loss of dependency, therefore, has to be determined by
taking monthly income of deceased to be Rs.1,200/- by applying future
prospects to the extent of 40%, multiplier of ‘18’ and by making deduction
of 1/2 towards personal expenses.
16. Apart from compensation for loss of dependency, appellant-
claimant shall also be entitled to Rs . 15,000 /- towards funeral expenses and
Rs . 15,000 /- towards loss of estate . Appellant-claimant No.1 shall be entitled
to compensation of Rs . 40,000 /- towards loss of filial consortium . It is
however made clear that in case Hon’ble Supreme Court answers the
reference regarding quantum of compensation under conventional heads
made in Hasina Yasmin & Ors. Vs. National Insurance Co. Ltd. , 2025
SCC Online SC 2919 in favour of appellants-claimants, appellant-claimants
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
-13-
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
shall be free to seek said amount by moving appropriate application in this
regard.
17. Accordingly, reworked compensation is as under :-
Income Rs.1,200/- Rs.1,200/-
per month per month
Future Prospects 40% Rs.1,680/-
(Rs.1,200/- + 480)
Deduction 1/2 Rs.840/-
(Rs.1,680/- – 840)
Multiplier 18 18
Total loss of Rs.840/-x 12 x 18 Rs.1,81,440/-
dependency
Loss of Estate Rs. 15,000/-
Funeral Expenses Rs.15,000/-
Loss of filial
consortium to
claimant No.1
Rs.40,000/-
Total Compensation Rs.2,51,440/-
awarded in appeal
50% of compensation
after making
deduction towards
contributory
negligence
Total Compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal
Rs.87,000/-
Enhanced amount of Rs.2,51,440/- (awarded in
compensation appeal) – Rs.87,000/-
(awarded by the Tribunal)
Rs.1,64,440/-
18. Appellants-claimants shall be entitled to enhanced
compensation awarded in appeal along with 7.5% interest from the date of
filing of claim petition till realization except for the period from date of
dismissal of appeal till date of filling of application for restoration of appeal
as held above (except under the conventional heads i.e. loss of consortium,
funeral expenses, loss of estate). Under conventional heads interest shall be
payable from date of filing application for restoration onwards till
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-520-1999 (O&M)
-14-
FAO-519-1999 (O&M)
realization. Apportionment and liability to pay compensation shall be as per
award.
19. Appeals are accordingly allowed in above terms. Pending
application(s), if any, is/are disposed of accordingly.
(PARMOD GOYAL)
11.11.2026 JUDGE
Ravinder
Whether Speaking/Reasoned : Yes/No
Whether Reportable : Yes/No
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document