Sabbi Shashikiran Reddy vs The State of Telangana
- Court
- High Court for the State of Telangana
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
*
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.527 of 2020
Between :
Sabbi Shashikiran Reddy and another ...Appellants
AND
The State of Telangana ...Respondent
th
DATE OF ORDER: 17 NOVEMBER, 2026
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE JUVVADI SRIDEVI
1 Whether Reporters of Local
newspapers may be allowed to see
Yes/No
the Judgment?
2 Whether the copies of judgment
may be marked to Law
Yes/No
Reporters/Journals
3 Whether HER Lordship wish to see
the fair copy of the Judgment?
Yes/No
___________________
JUVVADI SRIDEVI, J
2
* THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE JUVVADI SRIDEVI
+ CRIMINAL APPEAL No.527 of 2020
TH
% Date: 17 November, 2026
Between :
Sabbi Shashikiran Reddy and another ...Appellants
AND
The State of Telangana ...Respondent
! Counsel for the Appellants: Sri M. Rathan Singh
! Counsel for the Respondent: Sri M. Vivekananda Reddy,
learned Assistant Public Prosecutor for the State
>HEAD NOTE:
? Cases referred:
( 2017) 1 SCC 101
3
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE JUVVADI SRIDEVI
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.527 of 2020
(CNR No. HBHC010369342020)
Reserved on: 18-AUG-2026 Pronounced on: 17-NOV-2026
Uploaded on: 17-NOV-2026
Between :
Sabbi Shashikiran Reddy and another ...Appellants
AND
The State of Telangana ...Respondent
J U D G M E N T :
This Criminal Appeal is preferred by the appellants-accused
Nos.1 and 2, challenging the Judgment dated 08.12.2020 passed
in S.C.No.804 of 2017 by the learned XVI Additional District and
Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy District at Malkajgiri (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the learned trial Court’), whereby they were found
guilty and convicted for the offences under Sections 498A and
304B of the Indian Penal Code (for short, ‘IPC’) and they were
sentenced to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for a period of one
(1) year each and to pay a fine of Rs.1,000/- each, in default, to
undergo Simple Imprisonment for a period of fifteen (15) days
each, for the offence punishable under Section 498A IPC. They
4
were further sentenced to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for a
period of seven (7) years each and to pay a fine of Rs.5,000/-
each, in default, to undergo Simple Imprisonment for a period of
two (2) months each, for the offence punishable under Section
304B IPC. Both the substantive sentences were directed to run
concurrently.
02. Heard Sri M. Rathan Singh, learned counsel for the
appellant-accused Nos.1 and 2 and Sri M. Vivekananda Reddy,
learned Assistant Public Prosecutor for the State-respondent and
perused the material available on record.
03.1. The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that the
marriage of the deceased, namely, Sabbi Leelavathi, was
solemnized with the accused No.1 on 31.10.2015. At the time of
marriage, her father, who was examined as PW.1, allegedly gave
an amount of Rs.10,00,000/- in cash, 10 tulas of gold ornaments
and three acres of mango garden towards dowry, besides
household articles. Accused No.2 is the mother-in-law of the
deceased.
5
03.2. It is further alleged that, initially, the deceased and
the accused No.1 led a happy marital life for about one month.
Thereafter, both the accused started subjecting the deceased to
physical and mental harassment, demanding additional dowry of
Rs.5,00,000/- in cash, 15 tulas of gold ornaments and transfer of
three acres of mango garden in favour of accused No.1. When
PW.1 intended to bring the deceased and accused No.1 to his
house for the Sankranthi festival, the accused allegedly insisted
upon fulfilment of their demands. Thereupon, PW.1, accompanied
by PW.5, visited the house of the accused and allegedly paid an
amount of Rs.1,00,000/- and sought time to fulfil the remaining
demands.
03.3. The prosecution further alleged that, even thereafter,
the accused continued to harass the deceased and insisted upon
fulfilment of their demands. It is also alleged that the deceased
informed her father and other witnesses about the harassment
being meted out to her. On 13.06.2016, the deceased was found
dead by hanging in her matrimonial home at Malkajgiri. On the
following day, PW.1 lodged a complaint alleging that the accused
6
had subjected his daughter to dowry harassment and were
responsible for her death.
03.4. On receipt of the complaint, PW.12, the then Sub-
Inspector of Police, Malkajgiri Police Station, registered a case in
Crime No.346 of 2016 initially for the offence under Sections 302
and 304B IPC and issued the First Information Report.
Thereafter, PW.13, the then Assistant Commissioner of Police,
Malkajgiri Sub-Division, took up investigation, visited the scene of
offence, conducted scene observation proceedings, seized certain
material objects and caused an inquest to be conducted over the
dead body of the deceased. PW.10, the Medical Officer,
conducted the post-mortem examination and opined that the
cause of death was asphyxia due to hanging. After completion of
investigation, the charge sheet was filed against the appellants-
accused Nos.1 and 2 for the offences punishable under Sections
498-A and 304-B IPC.
04. The learned trial Court framed charges against the
appellants-accused Nos.1 and 2 for the aforesaid offences. They
pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
7
05. During the course of trial, the prosecution examined
PWs.1 to 13 and marked Exs.P1 to P8 and MOs.1 to 3. Ex.D1 was
marked during the cross-examination of PW.7. On completion of
the prosecution evidence, the appellants were examined under
Section 313 Cr.P.C., wherein they denied the incriminating
circumstances appearing against them and pleaded their
innocence. No defence evidence was adduced.
06. Upon appreciation of the oral and documentary
evidence, the learned trial Court found the appellants guilty of
the offences punishable under Sections 498-A and 304-B IPC and
convicted and sentenced them as stated supra. Aggrieved
thereby, the present Criminal Appeal has been preferred.
07.1. Learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the
learned trial Court committed a grave error in convicting the
appellants for the offences charged against them without
properly appreciating the oral and documentary evidence
available on record. It is contended that the conviction and
sentence imposed against the appellants are contrary to law and
the evidence on record.
8
07.2. It is further contended that the learned trial Court
grossly erred in invoking the presumption under Section 113-B of
the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, for recording the conviction of the
appellants for the offence punishable under Section 304-B IPC,
without first establishing all the essential ingredients of the said
offence. Mere proof that the death of the deceased occurred
within seven years of her marriage is not sufficient to attract the
statutory presumption unless the prosecution establishes that,
soon before her death, she was subjected to cruelty or
harassment in connection with a demand for dowry.
07.3. It is further submitted that the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses, who are predominantly relatives and
persons closely associated with the family of the deceased, does
not establish the alleged demand for additional dowry or the
cruelty allegedly meted out to the deceased soon before her
death beyond reasonable doubt. It is contended that the material
contradictions and omissions in their evidence, particularly those
elicited during the cross-examination of PWs.1, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7,
were not properly appreciated by the learned trial Court.
9
07.4. It is also contended that the prosecution witnesses
had not witnessed any specific incident of physical cruelty and
that their evidence, insofar as it relates to the alleged
harassment, is substantially based upon the statements allegedly
made by the deceased. The learned trial Court failed to properly
consider the evidentiary value of such statements and the
absence of independent corroboration.
07.5. It is further submitted that the learned trial Court
erroneously placed the burden upon the appellants to explain the
circumstances leading to the death of the deceased. The initial
burden of establishing the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable
doubt squarely rests upon the prosecution and cannot be shifted
to the accused merely on account of the unnatural death of a
married woman. Hence, he prayed to allow the Criminal Appeal
and acquit the appellants of the charges levelled against them.
08. On the other hand, learned Assistant Public
Prosecutor submitted that the learned trial Court, upon proper
appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence, rightly
convicted the appellants for the offences established against
10
them. It is contended that the evidence of PW.1, the father of the
deceased, and PW.3, her brother, is corroborated by the evidence
of PWs.4 to 7, who spoke about the harassment and additional
dowry demands made by the appellants. It is further submitted
that the evidence clearly establishes that the appellants continued
to demand additional dowry and subjected the deceased to
harassment till shortly before her death. The deceased died an
unnatural death within eight months of her marriage, and
therefore, the learned trial Court rightly invoked the presumption
under Section 113-B of the Indian Evidence Act. Accordingly, he
prayed that the Criminal Appeal be dismissed by confirming the
conviction and sentence imposed by the learned trial Court.
09. Having regard to the rival submissions made by the
learned counsel on either side and the material available on
record, the points arise for consideration are whether the
prosecution has established beyond reasonable doubt that the
appellants-accused Nos.1 and 2 subjected the deceased to
cruelty within the meaning of Section 498-A IPC; whether the
prosecution has established all the essential ingredients of the
11
offence of dowry death under Section 304-B IPC, particularly that
soon before her death, the deceased was subjected to cruelty or
harassment in connection with a demand for dowry, thereby
attracting the presumption under Section 113-B of the Indian
Evidence Act; whether the judgment of conviction and sentence
passed by the learned trial Court warrants interference by this
Court.
10. Before proceeding to appreciate the evidence on
record, it is appropriate to refer to the essential ingredients of the
offences with which the appellants have been charged. Section
498-A IPC deals with cruelty by the husband or relative of the
husband of a woman. The explanation appended to the said
provision defines cruelty to mean: (a) any wilful conduct which is
of such a nature as is likely to drive the woman to commit suicide
or to cause grave injury or danger to her life, limb or health,
whether mental or physical; or (b) harassment of the woman
where such harassment is with a view to coercing her or any
person related to her to meet any unlawful demand for any
property or valuable security, or is on account of failure by her or
12
any person related to her to meet such demand. Thus, to
constitute an offence under Section 498-A IPC, the prosecution
must establish the nature of the conduct attributed to the
accused and demonstrate that such conduct falls within either of
the clauses of the explanation appended to the said provision.
Mere matrimonial discord, differences of opinion or ordinary wear
and tear of marital life, without more, would not constitute
cruelty within the meaning of the said provision.
11. Section 304-B IPC provides that where the death of a
woman is caused by burns or bodily injury, or occurs otherwise
than under normal circumstances, within seven years of her
marriage, and it is shown that soon before her death she was
subjected to cruelty or harassment by her husband or any
relative of her husband in connection with any demand for
dowry, such death shall be called a dowry death and such
husband or relative shall be deemed to have caused her death.
The essential ingredients required to be established by the
prosecution for attracting Section 304-B IPC are: (i) The death of
a woman should have been caused by burns or bodily injury or
13
should have occurred otherwise than under normal
circumstances; (ii) Such death should have occurred within seven
years of her marriage; (iii) Soon before her death, the woman
should have been subjected to cruelty or harassment by her
husband or his relative; and (iv) Such cruelty or harassment
should have been in connection with a demand for dowry.
12. It is settled principle of law that only after the
prosecution establishes the aforesaid foundational facts that the
presumption under Section 113-B of the Indian Evidence Act can
be drawn against the accused. The presumption is not automatic
merely because a married woman died an unnatural death within
seven years of her marriage. The prosecution must establish the
foundational facts, including cruelty or harassment in connection
with a demand for dowry soon before the death, before the
statutory presumption can be invoked. In Baijnath v. State of
1
Madhya Pradesh , the Hon’ble Supreme Court at Paragraph
Nos.32, 33 and 35 that:
“32. This Court while often dwelling on the scope
and purport of Section 304-B of the Code and
1
(2017) 1 SCC 101
14
Section 113-B of the Act have propounded that the
presumption is contingent on the fact that the
prosecution first spell out the ingredients of the
offence of Section 304-B as in Shindo v. State of
Punjab [Shindo v. State of Punjab, (2011) 11 SCC
517 : (2011) 3 SCC (Cri) 394] and echoed in Rajeev
Kumar v. State of Haryana [Rajeev Kumar v. State
of Haryana, (2013) 16 SCC 640 : (2014) 6 SCC (Cri)
346] . In the latter pronouncement, this Court
propounded that one of the essential ingredients of
dowry death under Section 304-B of the Code is
that the accused must have subjected the woman
to cruelty in connection with demand for dowry
soon before her death and that this ingredient has
to be proved by the prosecution beyond reasonable
doubt and only then the Court will presume that the
accused has committed the offence of dowry death
under Section 113-B of the Act. It referred to with
approval, the earlier decision of this Court in K.
Prema S. Rao v. Yadla Srinivasa Rao [K. Prema S.
Rao v. Yadla Srinivasa Rao, (2003) 1 SCC 217 :
2003 SCC (Cri) 271] to the effect that to attract the
provision of Section 304-B of the Code, one of the
main ingredients of the offence which is required to
be established is that “soon before her death” she
was subjected to cruelty and harassment “in
connection with the demand for dowry”.
33. Tested on the judicially adumbrated parameters
as above, we are of the unhesitant opinion that the
prosecution has failed to prove beyond reasonable
doubt, cruelty or harassment to the deceased for or
in connection with any demand for dowry as
contemplated in either of the two provisions of the
Code under which the accused persons had been
charged. Noticeably, the alleged demand centres
around a motorcycle, which as the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses would evince, admittedly did
15
not surface at the time of finalisation of the
marriage. PW 5, the mother of the deceased has
even conceded that there was no dowry demand at
that stage. According to her, when the husband
(who is dead) had insisted for a motorcycle,
thereafter he was assured that he would be
provided with the same, finances permitting.
Noticeably again, the demand, as sought to be
projected by the prosecution, if accepted to be true
had lingered for almost two years. Yet admittedly,
no complaint was made thereof to anyone, far less
the police. Apart from the general allegations in the
same tone ingeminated with parrot-like similarity by
the prosecution witnesses, the allegation of cruelty
and harassment to the deceased is founded on the
confidential communications by her to her parents
in particular and is not supported by any other
quarter.
35. A cumulative consideration of the overall
evidence on the facet of dowry, leaves us
unconvinced about the truthfulness of the charge
qua the accused persons. The prosecution in our
estimate, has failed to prove this indispensable
component of the two offences beyond reasonable
doubt. The factum of unnatural death in the
matrimonial home and that too within seven years
of marriage therefore is thus ipso facto not
sufficient to bring home the charge under Sections
304-B and 498-A of the Code against them.”
13. Keeping the aforesaid principle in view, this Court
proceeds to re-appreciate the evidence adduced by the
prosecution.
16
14. The marriage of the deceased with the accused No.1
was solemnized on 31.10.2015, and she died on 13.06.2016.
Thus, the death occurred within seven years of her marriage.
There is also no serious dispute regarding the fact that the
deceased died an unnatural death by hanging at her matrimonial
home. PW.10, Dr. K.V. Ramana Murthy, who conducted the
post-mortem examination over the dead body of the deceased,
deposed that he noticed multiple self-inflicted injuries on the
anterior surfaces of both wrists, covered with dried bloodstains.
He also noticed an oblique, non-continuous ante-mortem ligature
mark measuring approximately 25 x 3 centimetres on the front
and both sides of the neck. The skin beneath the ligature mark
was brownish and parchment-like, and the subcutaneous tissues
and muscles were contused. The hyoid bone and thyroid
cartilage were intact. PW.10 ultimately opined that the cause of
death was asphyxia due to hanging and that the approximate
time of death was within 24 hours prior to the post-mortem
examination. Ex.P6 is the requisition-cum-post-mortem
examination report issued by him. During his cross-examination,
PW.10 stated that he had conducted post-mortem examinations
17
in approximately 5,000 cases and had come across several cases
wherein persons had inflicted injuries on themselves before
committing suicide by hanging. He further stated that, in the
absence of physical signs, he could not comment upon the
mindset of a person who commits suicide.
15. PW.9, Nune Laxman, deposed that the police
conducted the scene-of-offence proceedings in his presence and
showed him a ceiling fan to which a chunni was tied, a piece of
chunni lying on the floor, door bolts and a razor blade. He
identified Ex.P4 as the scene-of-offence panchanama and
identified MOs.1 to 3, namely, two pieces of chunni, a door bolt
and a razor blade. PW.8, Regalla Naresh Reddy, and PW.11, Ch.
Vijaya, the then Tahsildar, deposed about the inquest
proceedings conducted over the dead body of the deceased.
Ex.P3 is the inquest report.
16. On a cumulative consideration of the evidence of
PWs.8 to 11, coupled with the post-mortem examination report
and the scene-of-offence proceedings, it is established that the
deceased died by hanging and that the death was otherwise than
18
under normal circumstances. The fact that such death occurred
within seven years of her marriage is also established. The
prosecution is further required to establish that soon before her
death, the deceased was subjected to cruelty or harassment by
the appellants in connection with a demand for dowry.
17. PW.1, G. Krishna Reddy, is the father of the deceased
and the complainant in the present case. According to him, at the
time of marriage, he gave Rs.10,00,000/- in cash, 10 tulas of
gold and agreed to give three acres of mango garden towards
dowry. He further stated that household articles worth
Rs.1,00,000/- were also given at the time of sending his daughter
to the matrimonial home. PW.1 deposed that, after about one
month of the marriage, the accused started demanding additional
dowry of Rs.5,00,000/- in cash and 15 tulas of gold. He further
stated that, when he invited the accused to his house for the
Sankranthi festival, they insisted upon fulfilment of their demands
as a condition for visiting his house. Thereupon, he, along with
PW.5, visited the house of the accused and paid Rs.1,00,000/- in
cash, requesting them to grant time to fulfil the remaining
19
demands. PW.1 further deposed that, after the Sankranthi
festival, the accused continued to pressurise the deceased for
additional dowry and immediate registration of the mango garden
in favour of accused No.1. He stated that he again visited the
house of the accused and requested them to grant time until the
harvesting season. He also stated that, during the last week of
February, 2016, he paid another amount of Rs.1,00,000/- to the
accused. PW.1 further stated that, in May, 2016, the accused
complained about the non-provision of a cot and almirah.
Accordingly, he arranged a cot, purchased an almirah and paid an
amount of Rs.30,000/- towards the purchase of a mattress. He
also spoke about sending mangoes to the house of the accused
through PWs.6 and 7, which the accused allegedly refused to
accept.
18. During his cross-examination, PW.1 admitted that he
had not furnished any documentary evidence to the police to
establish his ownership of agricultural lands. He stated that he
owned 12 acres of agricultural land and had an annual
agricultural income of approximately Rs.4,50,000/-, with a net
20
income of about Rs.3,50,000/-. He also admitted that he had not
produced any documentary proof regarding the purchase of the
10 tulas of gold allegedly given at the time of marriage. PW.1
further stated that he had pooled the amount of Rs.10,00,000/-
from his brothers, namely, Sambasiva Reddy and Anji Reddy, and
other relatives and paid the same to the accused in two
instalments. However, he admitted that he had not disclosed the
names of his brothers and relatives from whom he had collected
the amount either in Ex.P1 complaint or during his examination
before the police. The said persons were also not cited as
witnesses in the case.
19. PW.1 also admitted that he had no documentary
proof to establish that he had pooled an amount of
Rs.20,00,000/- for payment to the accused towards dowry in
October, 2015. He further admitted that he had not specifically
mentioned in Ex.P1 complaint the manner in which the deceased
informed him about the alleged harassment.
20. Another important admission made by PW.1 is that,
in January, 2016, he paid an amount of Rs.1,00,000/- to the
21
accused in connection with the sale of the usufruct of the mango
garden. He further stated that he had sold mangoes in the year
2016 to one Katari Ramu of Khammam Padu village, though he
could not remember the date of sale. The above admission
assumes significance in view of the prosecution case that the
amount of Rs.1,00,000/- paid by PW.1 during the relevant period
was towards satisfaction of the additional dowry demand. The
evidence of PW.1, therefore, requires careful scrutiny regarding
the nature and purpose of the payments allegedly made by him.
21. PW.1 further admitted that he could not remember
the exact dates and times when his daughter informed him about
the alleged demands made by the accused or when he invited
them to his house for the Sankranthi festival. He also admitted
that he had not specifically stated before the police or in Ex.P1
complaint that he and PW.5 had decided to visit the house of the
accused on 16.06.2016 to resolve the dispute. The aforesaid
admissions assume relevance when considered along with the
other material discrepancies in the evidence relating to the
alleged dowry transactions and the subsequent payments.
22
22. PW.3, G. Venkateshwara Reddy, is the brother of the
deceased. He supported the version of PW.1 regarding the
payment of Rs.10,00,000/- in cash, 10 tulas of gold and three
acres of mango garden at the time of marriage. He also spoke
about the alleged additional demands made by the accused
during the Sankranthi festival and the subsequent visits made by
PW.1 along with PW.5. PW.3 further deposed that, in March,
2016, his sister telephoned him and requested him to find
employment for her so that she could come out of the problems
and pressure allegedly created by the accused. He stated that, in
May, 2016, he contacted PW.4, who arranged an interview for
the deceased on 31.05.2016. PW.3 further deposed that, after
attending the interview, his sister returned to his house and
appeared weak. On enquiry, she informed him that the accused
were not even providing her with proper food and were harassing
her. He also stated that, about three days prior to the death of
his sister, she telephoned PW.1 and complained about the
continued harassment and requested him to fulfil the demands of
the accused. However, during his cross-examination, PW.3
admitted that he had not stated anything before the police
23
regarding the incidents allegedly taking place between February
and June, 2016, among the family members and that he narrated
all those facts for the first time during his deposition before the
Court.
23. More particularly, PW.3 admitted that he had not
informed the police about his sister's request to find a job due to
the pressure allegedly created by the accused, his visit to the
village in May, 2016, his meeting with PW.4 in connection with
arranging employment for his sister, or the interview allegedly
arranged on 31.05.2016. He further admitted that he had not
stated before the police about the deceased visiting his house
before attending the interview, her appearance of weakness, his
enquiry regarding the same, the alleged complaint made by her
about the harassment and failure of the accused to provide
proper food, or the visit of PW.7 to his house on that occasion.
24. The aforesaid admissions are not minor omissions
relating to insignificant details. They relate to the very
circumstances relied upon by the prosecution to establish that the
deceased was subjected to continued harassment in the months
24
immediately preceding her death. The failure of PW.3 to disclose
these material circumstances during investigation affects the
evidentiary weight of his subsequent testimony.
25. PW.3 also admitted that his paternal uncle,
Sambasiva Reddy, had informed the press that four acres of land,
Rs.20,00,000/- in cash and gold worth Rs.5,00,000/- were given
at the time of marriage. The said version is at variance with the
prosecution case regarding Rs.10,00,000/- in cash, 10 tulas of
gold and three acres of mango garden. It is true that PW.3
denied the suggestion that the accused had never demanded
additional dowry or harassed the deceased. Nevertheless, the
material omissions elicited during his cross-examination cannot
be ignored while evaluating the reliability of the prosecution
version.
26. PW.5, V. Brahmananda Reddy, is projected as an
independent witness who accompanied PW.1 on certain occasions
to the house of the accused. He supported the version of PW.1
regarding the alleged demands for additional dowry and the
payment of Rs.1,00,000/- during the Sankranthi period. He also
25
spoke about the subsequent payment of another amount of
Rs.1,00,000/- during February, 2016. However, during his cross-
examination, PW.5 admitted that he could not describe the gold
ornaments allegedly presented at the time of marriage. He also
admitted that there was a customary practice in their community
of presenting lands and valuables, particularly gold ornaments, to
the bride and bridegroom from both sides at the time of
marriage.
27. PW.5 further admitted that he did not remember the
exact dates of his visits to Malkajgiri. He also admitted that he
had not specifically stated before the police about the payment of
Rs.1,00,000/- on the second occasion by PW.1 after borrowing
Rs.50,000/- from his brother. More importantly, PW.5 admitted
that the deceased had never personally complained to him about
the alleged harassment by the accused and that he came to know
about the alleged ill-treatment only through PW.1. His evidence
regarding the alleged telephone call received by PW.1 two days
prior to the death is also based upon the information allegedly
conveyed to him by PW.1.
26
28. PW.5 further admitted that, when he was confronted
with the audio and video clipping of TV10, the statement shown
to him did not contain any reference to the payment of dowry or
the additional demands made by the accused as the cause of
death. He also admitted that he had stated before the media that
the disputes between the accused and the family of the deceased
were on trivial issues and petty complaints. Though he explained
that the full text of his statement was not recorded, the said
admission is a relevant circumstance to be considered while
assessing the reliability of his evidence.
29. It is also significant that PW.5 admitted that he had
not specifically stated before the police about the alleged threat
given by the accused to the deceased, either to kill her or to
contract a second marriage. Such an allegation, if true, would
constitute a material circumstance in support of the prosecution
case, and the omission to disclose the same during investigation
affects the weight to be attached to the subsequent testimony.
30. Thus, the evidence of PW.5 provides some support to
the prosecution version regarding the earlier visits and alleged
27
payments. However, his testimony does not independently
establish the alleged continuing harassment or the specific
threats said to have been made by the accused shortly before the
death of the deceased.
31. PW.2, S. Veera Venkata Reddy, is the uncle of
accused No.1. He deposed that he was running a curry point at
Malkajgiri for about 15 years and that his house was situated at a
distance of approximately half a kilometre from the house of the
deceased and accused No.1.
32. PW.2 expressed ignorance about the details of the
amounts, if any, given by the parents of the deceased towards
dowry. He further stated that, to his knowledge, there were no
disputes between accused No.1 and the deceased and that they
were cordial throughout their marital life. He also stated that he
had never witnessed any disputes between them. PW.2 was
declared hostile as he did not support the case of the
prosecution.
28
33. PW.4, R. Gautham Kumar Reddy, deposed that,
during May, 2016, PW.3 requested him to look for employment
for the deceased. Accordingly, he contacted her over the
telephone and requested her to forward her resume. PW.4
further deposed that, when he informed the deceased about an
interview scheduled on 31.05.2016, he noticed that her voice was
weak. On enquiry, the deceased allegedly informed him that she
was being tortured by her husband and mother-in-law, who were
insisting upon payment of dowry and transfer of land in their
favour, and that she wanted to secure employment to lead a
peaceful life.
34. However, during his cross-examination, PW.4
admitted that he had not specifically informed the police that,
during his telephonic conversation with the deceased, he noticed
that her voice was weak or that she had narrated the alleged
harassment by the accused. He further admitted that he had not
stated before the police about handing over the resume of the
deceased to the Investigating Officer. He also admitted that he
had not furnished any documents to establish that the deceased
29
had attended the alleged interview on 31.05.2016 or to prove her
educational qualifications in connection with the said interview.
35. PW.4 also admitted that he could not remember the
exact date on which he had the alleged telephonic conversation
with the deceased during the first week of May, 2016. Though
he stated that the deceased attended the interview on
31.05.2016, the Investigating Officer admitted that no
documentary evidence relating to the alleged interview was
collected during investigation. The evidence of PW.4, therefore,
does indicate that the deceased was allegedly seeking
employment during May, 2016. However, the specific disclosure
regarding the alleged dowry harassment, which is an important
circumstance relied upon by the prosecution, was not disclosed
by him to the police during investigation. In the absence of any
contemporaneous material relating to the alleged interview or the
relevant communication, his testimony requires cautious
evaluation.
36. PW.6, R. Ganesh Reddy, deposed that, four days
prior to the occurrence, PW.1 informed him about the illegal
30
demands made by the accused and the harassment allegedly
meted out to the deceased. On that occasion, PW.1 requested
him and another witness, Tirupathi Reddy, to visit the house of
the deceased and deliver mangoes. According to PW.6, when
they visited the house of the accused, the accused did not permit
them to speak to the deceased and stated that they did not want
the mangoes unless their demands were fulfilled. He further
stated that the accused abused the family members of PW.1 and
threw away the box containing the mangoes. He also claimed to
have noticed that the deceased was weak and was not in a
position to speak to them. The above evidence is relied upon by
the prosecution as an important circumstance to establish the
alleged harassment shortly before the death of the deceased.
37. However, during his cross-examination, PW.6
admitted that, in his interview before TV9, he had stated that
four acres of agricultural land, Rs.5,00,000/- in cash and gold
ornaments were given as dowry at the time of marriage. On the
other hand, during his examination by the police, he stated that
Rs.10,00,000/- in cash, 10 tulas of gold and three acres of land
31
were given as dowry. Thus, there is a discrepancy regarding the
particulars of the alleged dowry transaction. More importantly,
PW.6 admitted that he did not remember whether he had
informed the police about the information allegedly furnished to
him by PW.1 four days prior to the occurrence regarding the
illegal demands made by the accused. The Investigating Officer,
PW.13, categorically admitted that PW.6 had not disclosed during
investigation his knowledge about the alleged harassment
suffered by the deceased, particularly four days prior to her
death, through PW.1. Though PW.6 denied the suggestion that
he had not informed the police about the incident in which the
accused allegedly prevented them from speaking to the
deceased, the admission of the Investigating Officer regarding
the omission of this material circumstance assumes significance.
38. The alleged incident of refusing to accept mangoes,
preventing the witnesses from speaking to the deceased and
abusing them, is projected as a specific incident of harassment
immediately preceding the death. Such a material circumstance
would ordinarily have found a place in the statement of the
32
witness during investigation, particularly when the incident is
alleged to have occurred only four days prior to the death.
Therefore, the omission of this important circumstance in the
earlier statement of PW.6 creates a reasonable doubt regarding
the exact manner in which the alleged incident occurred and the
subsequent embellishments in his testimony.
39. PW.7, S. Shravani, deposed that she met the
deceased during the Sankranthi festival and noticed that she was
weak. On enquiry, the deceased allegedly informed her that the
accused were physically and mentally harassing her in connection
with their demands for transfer of three acres of mango garden,
15 tulas of gold and Rs.5,00,000/- in cash.
40. PW.7 further stated that she met the deceased again
at the house of PW.3 in May, 2016, when the deceased once
again complained about the physical and mental harassment
allegedly meted out to her by the accused. During her cross-
examination, PW.7 admitted that she first met the deceased after
her marriage during the Sankranthi festival. She further admitted
that she could not state precisely when the deceased visited the
33
village for Sankranthi, the period for which she stayed with her
parents or her movements during the said visit. PW.7 also
admitted that she did not know with whom the deceased had
visited the house of PW.3 on 31.05.2016 at about 11.00 A.M. for
attending an interview. She further admitted that she had not
informed the police about the visit of the deceased along with
accused No.1 to the house of PW.3 on the said date. When
confronted with her previous statement, the relevant portion was
marked as Ex.D1.
41. The aforesaid omission is relevant because PW.7 is
relied upon by the prosecution to establish that the deceased met
her at the house of PW.3 in May, 2016 and disclosed the alleged
harassment. The circumstances surrounding the meeting and the
alleged disclosure, therefore, require careful scrutiny. Though
PW.7 denied the suggestion that the deceased had never
informed her about the alleged harassment, the omission
recorded in Ex.D1 and the absence of other contemporaneous
material to substantiate the alleged disclosure affect the weight
to be attached to her testimony.
34
42. PW.13, M. Ravichandan Reddy, the then Assistant
Commissioner of Police, Malkajgiri, conducted the investigation in
the present case. He deposed about visiting the scene of offence,
conducting the scene observation proceedings, seizing the
material objects, causing the inquest to be conducted and
examining the witnesses.
43. During his cross-examination, PW.13 admitted that
he did not enquire into the source of the amounts allegedly paid
by PW.1 to the accused towards dowry and additional demands
or the exact dates on which such amounts were paid. He also
admitted that he did not enquire into the place from which the
gold ornaments presented at the time of marriage were
purchased or the persons to whom they were given. PW.13
further admitted that he did not collect any documentary
evidence to establish the payment of cash and gold at the time of
marriage or the ownership of the agricultural lands allegedly
owned by PW.1. He also did not make any attempt to recover the
gold and other valuables allegedly presented at the time of
marriage.
35
44. It is also relevant that PW.13 admitted that Ex.P1
complaint did not contain any specific mention regarding the
manner in which the deceased informed PW.1 about the alleged
harassment. He further admitted that the complaint did not
contain any reference to the alleged telephone conversations
between PW.1 and the deceased concerning the demands made
by the accused.
45. PW.13 also admitted that he had not collected the
call detail records of the mobile phones of PW.1 and the
deceased to verify the alleged telephone conversations. He
further admitted that he had not examined the neighbours of the
deceased residing at Malkajgiri during the investigation.
46. With regard to the alleged second payment of
Rs.1,00,000/- in February, 2016, PW.13 admitted that PW.1 had
not specifically mentioned the said payment in Ex.P1 complaint.
He also admitted that PW.1 had not specifically mentioned in his
complaint the presentation of an almirah, cot and mattress on the
alleged demands of the accused after marriage.
36
47. With regard to PW.3, PW.13 admitted that the said
witness had not disclosed during investigation the deceased's
request to him to find a job, his meeting with PW.4, the interview
allegedly arranged on 31.05.2016, the deceased's visit to his
house before attending the interview, her appearance of
weakness or the alleged complaint regarding the harassment and
failure of the accused to provide food.
48. PW.13 further admitted that he had not collected any
documentary evidence regarding the alleged interview arranged
by PW.4 for the deceased or the call detail records of the mobile
phones of PW.4 and the deceased to establish the alleged
telephonic conversations between them.
49. With regard to PW.6, PW.13 categorically stated that
the said witness had not disclosed during investigation his
knowledge about the alleged harassment suffered by the
deceased, particularly four days prior to her death, through PW.1.
50. However, where the prosecution case substantially
depends upon the alleged communications made by the deceased
37
to different witnesses and the alleged payments of substantial
amounts towards dowry, the failure to verify the material
particulars assumes significance, particularly when the witnesses
themselves have admitted omissions concerning those very
circumstances.
51. The cumulative effect of the admissions made by
PW.13 is that several material circumstances subsequently relied
upon by the prosecution witnesses during their depositions were
not disclosed during investigation. The Investigating Officer also
failed to verify the alleged telephone conversations and the
circumstances surrounding the alleged payments and dowry
transactions. Thus, though the evidence of PW.13 establishes
the conduct of the investigation and collection of certain material
objects, the investigation does not provide sufficient independent
corroboration to the disputed circumstances forming the
foundation of the prosecution case.
52. On an overall appreciation of the evidence, it is
apparent that the deceased died within a short period of her
marriage and that there were certain matrimonial differences
38
between the deceased and the accused. However, for recording
a conviction under Section 498-A IPC, the prosecution must
establish that the conduct attributed to the accused falls within
the meaning of cruelty as defined in the explanation appended to
the said provision. In the present case, the prosecution alleged
that the accused demanded cash, gold ornaments and transfer of
three acres of mango garden and subjected the deceased to
physical and mental harassment for non-fulfilment of the said
demands. It was also alleged that the accused failed to provide
proper food to the deceased.
53. As already discussed, the evidence of PW.1 and PW.3
regarding the alleged dowry transactions and subsequent
payments suffers from material omissions and discrepancies.
PW.5, though supporting certain earlier payments, admitted that
the deceased had never personally complained to him and that
he came to know about the alleged harassment through PW.1.
The evidence of PWs.4, 6 and 7 regarding the specific incidents
of harassment and disclosures made by the deceased is also
39
affected by material omissions brought out during their cross-
examination.
54. Further, the allegations against the accused No.2
require independent consideration. Merely because the accused
No.2 is the mother-in-law of the deceased, she cannot
automatically be held guilty along with the accused No.1. The
prosecution must establish her specific participation in the alleged
unlawful demands or acts of cruelty. In the present case, though
general allegations have been made against both the appellants,
the material evidence does not satisfactorily establish the specific
acts attributable to the accused No.2, particularly in the context
of the alleged continuing harassment in the period proximate to
the death of the deceased.
55. Having regard to the material omissions and
discrepancies discussed above, this Court is of the considered
view that the prosecution has not established beyond reasonable
doubt the specific acts of cruelty attributable to both the
appellants within the meaning of Section 498-A IPC. The
allegations, though raising suspicion regarding the existence of
40
matrimonial disputes, do not inspire sufficient confidence to
sustain the conviction under the said provision.
56. The next question is whether the prosecution has
established the essential ingredients of dowry death punishable
under Section 304-B IPC. As already discussed, the first two
ingredients stand established, inasmuch as the deceased died an
unnatural death by hanging on 13.06.2016, within seven years of
her marriage solemnized on 31.10.2015. However, the crucial
requirement is whether soon before her death, the deceased was
subjected to cruelty or harassment by the appellants in
connection with a demand for dowry. The expression ‘soon
before her death’ does not necessarily mean immediately before
her death. The expression is relative and depends upon the facts
and circumstances of each case. Nevertheless, there must be a
proximate and live link between the cruelty or harassment
relating to the demand for dowry and the death in question. The
expression ‘soon before’ is not synonymous with ‘immediately
before’ and that the proximity of the alleged harassment to the
death has to be determined with reference to the circumstances
41
of the case. The presumption under Section 113-B of the Indian
Evidence Act can be invoked only after the prosecution
establishes the essential ingredients of Section 304-B IPC. The
burden does not shift to the accused merely because the death
occurred within seven years of marriage.
57. In the present case, the prosecution relies upon the
alleged telephone conversations between the deceased and
PW.1, the disclosures allegedly made by the deceased to PWs.3,
4 and 7, and the alleged incident involving PW.6 four days prior
to the death. PW.1 stated that his daughter telephoned him
about three days prior to her death and complained about the
continued harassment. However, the Investigating Officer
admitted that Ex.P1 complaint did not contain any reference to
the alleged telephone conversations between PW.1 and the
deceased. He further admitted that the call detail records of their
mobile phones were not collected. PW.5 also spoke about the
alleged telephone conversation between the deceased and PW.1
two days prior to the death. However, he admittedly did not
personally speak to the deceased on that occasion. His evidence
42
regarding the said communication is based upon the information
allegedly furnished by PW.1. Further, PW.5 admitted that he had
not specifically stated before the police about the alleged threats
given by the accused to the deceased that they would kill her or
that the accused No.1 would contract a second marriage if their
demands were not fulfilled. PW.3 also spoke about the deceased
telephoning PW.1 about three days prior to her death. However,
the material circumstances relating to the alleged employment
opportunity, the interview on 31.05.2016 and the deceased's
alleged complaint regarding harassment between February and
June, 2016 were not disclosed by him during investigation, as
admitted by PW.13.
58. PW.4 claimed that the deceased informed him during
May, 2016 that she was being tortured by the accused on
account of dowry demands and transfer of land. However, he
admitted that he had not informed the police about the specific
disclosure made by the deceased during their telephone
conversation. The Investigating Officer also admitted that no
documentary evidence relating to the alleged interview or the
43
relevant telephone conversations was collected. PW.7 also spoke
about the alleged disclosure made by the deceased in May, 2016.
However, her evidence regarding the circumstances of the
meeting and the alleged visit of the deceased to the house of
PW.3 on 31.05.2016 was affected by the omission marked as
Ex.D1. The prosecution has also relied upon the evidence of
PW.6, who claimed that the accused prevented him and another
witness from speaking to the deceased and refused to accept the
mangoes sent by PW.1 four days prior to the occurrence. This
Court is conscious of the fact that, if established through reliable
evidence, the aforesaid incident would constitute an important
circumstance in determining whether the deceased was subjected
to dowry-related harassment soon before her death. However,
PW.6's evidence regarding this particular incident is affected by
the admission of PW.13 that the said witness had not disclosed
the incident during investigation.
59. The omission is material because the incident is not a
mere detail relating to an earlier occurrence but is relied upon as
a specific instance of harassment immediately preceding the
44
death of the deceased. In the absence of a satisfactory
explanation for the omission, the said circumstance cannot be
accepted without caution. Thus, though the prosecution has
adduced evidence regarding certain alleged disclosures made by
the deceased and certain matrimonial disputes, the material
omissions and inconsistencies in the testimony of the prosecution
witnesses affect the reliability of the alleged continuing
harassment, particularly in the period immediately preceding the
death.
60. The fact that the deceased allegedly sought
employment during May, 2016, or that she appeared weak when
she met PW.3, PW.4 and PW.7, by itself, cannot establish that
the accused subjected her to cruelty in connection with a demand
for dowry soon before her death. Those circumstances have to
be considered along with the reliability of the alleged disclosures
and the other evidence on record. It is also relevant that the
evidence of PW.2, who was residing near the matrimonial home
and used to visit the house of the accused, does not support the
prosecution regarding any disputes or harassment. The
45
prosecution has not satisfactorily established the alleged
telephone conversations through contemporaneous material. It
has also not examined the neighbours residing in the vicinity of
the matrimonial home, though the alleged harassment is stated
to have continued for several months. In the present case, the
above deficiencies assume significance because they are
accompanied by material omissions in the statements of the
prosecution witnesses, inconsistencies regarding the alleged
dowry transactions and the absence of satisfactory corroboration
concerning the specific incidents relied upon to establish
harassment soon before the death.
61. The learned trial Court, while appreciating the
evidence, proceeded on the premise that the alleged demand for
transfer of three acres of mango garden and the additional dowry
demands continued from the first month of marriage until the
date of death. However, such a conclusion must necessarily be
supported by reliable evidence establishing the specific demands,
the acts of harassment attributable to each of the appellants and
their proximity to the death of the deceased. In the present
46
case, the evidence of PW.1 and PW.3 regarding the alleged
telephone communications and subsequent incidents is affected
by material omissions. The evidence of PW.5 regarding the
alleged threats and payments is also not free from doubt. The
evidence of PWs.4, 6 and 7, which is relied upon to establish the
alleged harassment during May and June, 2016, is affected by
the omissions brought out during cross-examination.
Consequently, though the prosecution has established that the
deceased died an unnatural death within seven years of her
marriage and has also brought on record certain circumstances
indicating matrimonial disputes, it has not satisfactorily
established the necessary proximate and live link between the
alleged dowry-related cruelty and the death of the deceased. In
the absence of reliable proof of the foundational ingredient of
cruelty or harassment soon before death, the statutory
presumption under Section 113-B of the Indian Evidence Act
cannot be invoked against the appellants.
62. The learned trial Court also observed that the
appellants failed to furnish a satisfactory explanation as to why
47
the deceased committed suicide. Such an approach cannot be
sustained in law in the absence of proof of the foundational facts
required for drawing the statutory presumption. It is well settled
that the burden of establishing the guilt of the accused beyond
reasonable doubt rests upon the prosecution. The accused are
not required to establish their innocence or furnish an explanation
for every circumstance unless the prosecution first establishes the
facts necessary to invoke the statutory presumption. The
absence of a satisfactory explanation from the accused cannot be
treated as a substitute for proof of the essential ingredients of
Section 304-B IPC. The presumption under Section 113-B of the
Indian Evidence Act can be drawn only after the prosecution
establishes that the deceased was subjected to cruelty or
harassment in connection with a demand for dowry soon before
her death.
63. This Court is conscious of the fact that an appellate
Court, while dealing with an appeal against conviction, is required
to independently re-appreciate the entire evidence on record and
arrive at its own conclusions. The presumption of innocence
48
continues to operate in favour of the accused, and where two
views are reasonably possible on the evidence available, the view
favourable to the accused is required to be adopted. In the
present case, the learned trial Court placed considerable reliance
upon the evidence of PW.1 and PW.3 and treated the testimony
of PWs.4 to 7 as corroborative evidence. However, the material
omissions elicited during the cross-examination of PWs.3, 4, 5, 6
and 7, particularly with regard to the alleged payments, threats,
telephone conversations and specific incidents of harassment,
were not adequately considered.
64. The learned trial Court also failed to sufficiently
consider the admissions of PW.13 regarding the non-collection of
documentary evidence relating to the alleged dowry transactions,
the failure to verify the alleged telephone conversations and the
material omissions in the statements of the prosecution
witnesses. Further, the evidence of PW.10 establishes the
medical cause of death as asphyxia due to hanging. The scene-
of-offence proceedings and the evidence of PWs.8, 9 and 11
establish the circumstances in which the dead body was found
49
and the conduct of the inquest. However, these circumstances do
not independently establish the alleged dowry demands or the
acts of cruelty attributed to the appellants.
65. The learned trial Court also placed reliance upon the
circumstance that the appellants had not furnished any
satisfactory alternative explanation for the suicide committed by
the deceased. As already discussed, such an approach would
result in shifting the burden of proof to the accused before the
prosecution establishes the foundational facts required under
Section 113-B of the Indian Evidence Act.
66. It is also pertinent to note that the allegations against
the accused No.2 have not been independently examined with
reference to her specific role in the alleged acts of cruelty. The
mere relationship of the accused No.2 with the deceased as her
mother-in-law cannot, by itself, establish her criminal liability.
67. This Court is conscious of the fact that the death of
the deceased is tragic and that the circumstances surrounding
her death warranted a thorough investigation. However, criminal
50
liability must be determined on the basis of legally admissible and
reliable evidence and not merely on the basis of suspicion arising
from the unfortunate and unnatural death of a married woman.
The prosecution is required to establish its case beyond
reasonable doubt. The circumstances relied upon by the
prosecution, when considered individually and cumulatively, do
not establish with the required degree of certainty that the
appellants subjected the deceased to cruelty or harassment in
connection with a demand for dowry soon before her death.
68. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of
the considered opinion that the prosecution has failed to establish
beyond reasonable doubt that the deceased was subjected to
cruelty or harassment by the appellants in connection with a
demand for dowry soon before her death. Though the unnatural
death of the deceased within seven years of her marriage is
established, the evidence of PWs.1, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 suffers from
material omissions and inconsistencies regarding the alleged
demands and incidents of harassment. Their testimony is not
supported by satisfactory contemporaneous or independent
51
evidence. The investigating officer (PW.13) also admitted that no
documentary evidence was collected to establish the alleged
payment of dowry, the participation of the alleged elders in the
panchayats or the relevant telephone conversations, and that
several material particulars deposed to by the witnesses were not
stated during investigation. The evidence of PW.2 does not
support the allegations of harassment. Thus, the prosecution has
failed to establish the foundational facts necessary to attract the
presumption under Section 113-B of the Indian Evidence Act. The
mere fact of an unnatural death within seven years of marriage
cannot, by itself, sustain a conviction under Section 304-B IPC.
Further, the evidence on record is insufficient to establish the
ingredients of Section 498-A IPC against the appellants beyond
reasonable doubt. The learned trial Court, therefore, erred in
recording the conviction without properly appreciating the
material omissions and inconsistencies in the prosecution
evidence. Accordingly, the appellants-accused Nos.1 and 2 are
entitled to the benefit of doubt. The conviction and sentence
imposed against them for the offences punishable under Sections
498A and 304B IPC are liable to be set aside.
52
69. Accordingly, this Criminal Appeal is allowed. The
Judgment dated 08.12.2020 passed in S.C.No.804 of 2017 by the
learned XVI Additional District and Sessions Judge, Rangareddy
District at Malkajgiri, convicting and sentencing the appellants-
accused Nos.1 and 2 for the offences punishable under Sections
498-A and 304-B IPC, is hereby set aside. The appellants-
accused Nos.1 and 2 are acquitted of the charges punishable
under Sections 498A and 304B IPC by extending the benefit of
doubt. Their bail bonds shall stand cancelled, subject to
compliance with Section 437-A Cr.P.C. The fine amounts, if
already paid by the appellants-accused Nos.1 and 2, shall be
refunded to them in accordance with law.
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous applications, if any,
shall stand closed.
__________________
JUVVADI SRIDEVI, J
Date: 17-OCT-2026
KHRM