M. Ganeshan vs Union Of India .

Court
Supreme Court

NON-REPORTABLE
2026 INSC 823

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION


CIVIL APPEAL No. 12201 OF 2016



M. GANESHAN …APPELLANT


VERSUS


UNION OF INDIA AND ORS. …RESPONDENTS



J U D G M E N T

DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
1 th
1. M. Ganeshan is in appeal by special leave, granted on 14
th
December, 2016, questioning an order dated 19 July, 2013 passed
by a Division Bench of the High Court at Calcutta, Circuit Bench at
2
Port Blair, allowing a review application of the respondents.
3
2. The jurisdiction of the Central Administrative Tribunal, Calcutta was
successfully invoked by the appellant. The Tribunal, vide order dated
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
MANIK KUMAR
Date: 2026.08.10
17:03:31 IST
Reason:

1
appellant
2
R.V.W. No. 15 of 2010
3
Tribunal
1

th 4
14 December, 2009, allowed the respondent’s original application
by directing as follows:
”18. In that view of the matter, we hold that the appointment of
the applicant to LGC from Gr. D category is to be treated as a case
st
of direct recruitment and accordingly, he is entitled to get 1 ACP and
nd
2 ACP as per rules and at par with his contemporaries and the
clarificatory circular of the DOP&T quoted above is not applicable to
his case.
19. Accordingly, the OA is disposed of with a direction to the
respondents decides his case for ACP benefits in the light of above
order within a period of 3 months. No costs.”

3. Challenge was laid by the respondents to the Tribunal’s aforesaid
order before the High Court in its writ jurisdiction. Vide order dated
th 5
16 March, 2010, the writ petition was dismissed by a Division
Bench.
4. Having failed to obtain reversal of the order of the Tribunal, the
respondents applied for a review. The petition came to be disposed
th
of by the impugned order dated 19 July, 2013. It reads as follows:
“We allowed the petition on the ground that six similarly
circumstanced employees have been extended the benefit. After we
passed the order, the Administration, by a review DPC, recalled the
benefit from chose six employees, hence they are seeking review of
the order in the present case. The Administration admits they
committed mistake in extending the benefits to six employees. We
extended the benefit to the petitioner on the sole ground, similarly
circumstanced persons were extended the benefit. Once such
position is altered, this application for review should succeed.
We recall the judgment and order dated March 16, 2010 with the
rider the pecuniary benefit which these six employees got, must also
be extended to the present petitioner, being the respondent in the
review application.
R.V.W. 15 of 2010 is, thus, disposed of along with the applications
without any order as to costs.
Urgent xerox certified copy of this order, if applied for, be given to
the parties, on priority basis.”


4 th
OA No. 131/AN/09 dated 14 December, 2009
5
W.P.C.T. No. 927 of 2010
2

5. Upon perusal of the impugned order, we are satisfied that the
Division Bench committed serious error in exercising its review
jurisdiction. It is revealed that the Division Bench proceeded on a
mistaken notion that it had dismissed the writ petition of the
respondents solely on the ground of parity. However, we have found
th
from the order dated 16 March, 2010 of the Division Bench, while
it dismissed the respondents’ writ petition, the following finding:
“…
We asked Mr. Mandal to produce records pertaining to the
recruitment of respondent and his colleagues. We find from the
record that the respondent participated in the recruitment process in
10% reserved quota as in house candidate. However, for other
purposes he was treated as direct recruit. Hence his past status of
Group-D was of no consequence beyond 1983. The appointment as
Group-C was a fresh appointment. Hence he was entitled to claim
benefit of ACP on expiry of 12 years’ period being in 1995.
Admittedly, in 1995 there was no such scheme prevalent. The
respondent also did not claim such benefit. Hence we need not
deliberate on the said issue. Such benefit was extended to him in
2006 with retrospective effect from 1999 when the scheme came into
st
existence. Such benefit in our view, must be considered as the 1
nd
ACP and not the 2 ACP. We also find on examination of the records
produced by Mr. Mandal that at least three persons namely, … were
similarly circumstanced with the respondent as they were appointed
as Group-C employees through the same selection process in the
reserved quota for Group-D employees. The respondent categorically
contended in pages 33-34 that those three persons amongst others
st
were extended the benefit of 1 ACP. We do not see any reason why
the respondent was excluded. The Tribunal approached the problem
in a right direction.
… ”

6. It is clear from the aforesaid extract that the ground of parity was
assigned by the Division Bench as an additional ground. It was not
the sole ground, as erroneously referred by the Division Bench in
the impugned order.
7. The findings of the Division Bench accepting the claim of the
appellant that his appointment as a Group ‘C’ staff in 1983 was a
3

fresh appointment and that benefit of Assured Career Progression,
which was extended to him in 2006 with retrospective effect from
st nd
1999, was the 1 benefit and it was not the 2 benefit, were not
subjected to challenge in the review petition by the respondents.
8. In such view of the matter, we are of the considered opinion that
th
the impugned order of the Division Bench dated 19 July, 2013
granting the prayer for review and allowing the respondents’ writ
petition suffers from an error which is apparent on the face of the
record. We, thus, have no other option but to set aside the said
th
order and restore the order dated 16 March, 2010 dismissing the
respondents’ writ petition.
th
9. The appeal, thus, succeeds. The impugned order dated 19 July,
2013 is set aside and dismissal of the respondents’ writ petition vide
th
order dated 16 March, 2010 is restored.
10. Respondents are directed to give effect to the order of the Tribunal,
within three months from date. No costs.


………..……………………………J.
(DIPANKAR DATTA)




…….……..…………………………J.
(SHEEL NAGU)
NEW DELHI;
AUGUST 04, 2026.

4