Birmani Mishra @ Birmani Prasad @ Virmani Mishra vs The State of Bihar
- Court
- Patna High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.13398 of 2026
CNR No. BRHC010840732026
======================================================
Birmani Mishra @ Birmani Prasad @ Virmani Mishra Son of Late Dip
Narayan Mishra, Resident of Village Neema, P.S. Dhanarua, P.O. and District-
Patna.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar Through the Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar,
Patna.
2. The Principal Secretary, General Administration Department, Government
of Bihar.
3. The Principal Secretary, Finance Department, Government of Bihar.
4. The District Magistrate-cum-Collector, Patna.
5. The Director of Census Operations, Bihar
6. The Establishment Deputy Collector, Patna, District- Patna.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Dinu Kumar, Advocate
Mrs. Ritika Rani, Advocate
Mr. Vardhan Mangalam, Advocate
Ms. Shambhavi, Advocate
Mr. Tejaswi Anand, Advocate
For the Respondent/s : AC to Government Pleader (14)
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PURNENDU SINGH
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 03-11-2026
Heard learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner and learned counsel for the State.
2. The petitioner in paragraph no. 1 of the present writ
petition has sought, inter alia, following relief(s), which is
reproduced hereinafter:-
" I. For direction to the respondents to
recommend/ treat the services of the petitioner from
01.06.1992 for providing retirement benefits, that is,
pension, gratuity and other admissible benefits in favour of
the petitioner.
Patna High Court CWJC No.13398 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
2/9
II. Also for directing the respondents for
payment of 10% interest over the areas of retirement benefit
of the petitioner, who is entitled to get as per law decided by
Patna High Court in the Full Bench case of Jai Govind
Prasad versus State of Bihar, reported in 1992 (2) PLJR 65,
and order dated 21.12.2015 passed in CWJC No. 21921 of
2011 (Lal Mohan Singh versus State of Bihar).
III. Also for necessary relief, order or direction
for which the petitioner is entitled in the eyes of law as well
as on the facts of the case."
3. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner submits that the petitioner was initially engaged under
the Census Department and he was a retrenched Census
employee of the 1981 Census having rendered service from
12.04.1971 to 22.10.1982 and again from 20.02.1984. Under the
policy decision of the State Government, retrenched Census
employees were entitled for consideration of their appointment
against available vacancies. The petitioner was served office
order contained in Memo No. 1982 dated 08.10.1997 issued
under the signature of the Collector, Patna, by which, he was
appointed on the post of Clerk in the office of the Deputy
Collector, Establishment, Patna, considering the petitioner to be
a retrenched employee of Census, 1981 in accordance with the
Government decisions. The petitioner gave his joining on
08.10.1997 along with Lal Mohan Singh, pursuant to the
appointment Letter No. 2172 dated 31.10.1997 under the
signature of the Deputy Collector, Establishment, Patna.
Patna High Court CWJC No.13398 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
3/9
Thereafter, the petitioner and one Lal Mohan Singh were served
office order contained in Memo No. 2054 dated 20.10.1997
issued under the signature of the District Magistrate, Patna by
which the petitioner was deputed to Belchi Block. The petitioner
superannuated on 31.12.2000. He had earlier approached this
Court in CWJC No. 3556 of 2001 (Annexure-P/4 to the writ
petition) for counting of his service in Census Department as
qualifying service for pensionary benefits, which was disposed
of on 19.03.2001 with a direction to make a representation and
for its disposal by the authority concerned. The Collector
rejected the claim on 19.07.2001, against which, the petitioner
had preferred CWJC No. 1704 of 2002 challenging the same,
which was rejected by this Court on 19.11.2008.
4.Learned counsel further submitted that, one
similarly situated Lal Mohan Singh had approached this Court
vide CWJC No. 21921 of 2011 for grant of pensionary benefits
w.e.f. 01.06.1992, which was allowed by a co-ordinate Bench of
this Court vide order dated 21.12.2015 and in compliance of the
said order, the petitioner of the said writ petition (Lal Mohan
Singh), who was appointed along with the petitioner by a
common order, was granted the pensionary benefits from the
date of his joining vide office order contained in Memo No.
Patna High Court CWJC No.13398 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
4/9
1452 dated 23.05.2011, however, the petitioner has not been
granted the same benefits.
5. Learned counsel further submits that the case of the
petitioner being similar to that of Lal Mohan Singh, the
petitioner is also entitled for pensionary benefits. The petitioner
has already filed a detailed representation before the District
Magistrate-cum-Collector, Patna communicated vide Speed Post
dated 26.02.2026. He further submits that without any deliberate
ignorance on the part of the petitioner in approaching this Court
belatedly after a period of twenty five years from his date of
superannuation i.e. 30.06.2000 will not come in a way
considering that the petitioner, in the present writ petition, is
claiming his retirement benefits, which is property in
accordance with Article 300-(A) of the Constitution of India.
6. Per contra , learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the State, at the outset, submitted that the petitioner not being
conscious of his right having approached this Court after a
period of 25 years, is not entitled for the relief(s) as prayed for
in the present writ petition.
7. Heard the parties.
8. Petitioner had approached this Court for the similar
relief by filing CWJC No. 1704 of 2002 after his retirement,
Patna High Court CWJC No.13398 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
5/9
which was dismissed by a coordinate Bench of this Court on
19.11.2008 by passing inter alia following order:
"The claim of the petitioner is that he had
worked under the Census Department, Government of India
for certain period starting in the year, 1971. This
engagement was purely casual/temporary in nature and
keeping the nature of work in the Census Department, on
completion of the census, he and many other persons were
retrenched. A legal battle was waged by many a persons
based on a circular of Government of India. It was asserted
that retrenched employees of 1981 census deserve
preference in matter of appointment under the State
Government. A Division Bench, thereafter a Full Bench in
its decision rendered in the case of Jai Govind Prasad &
Ors vrs. The State of Bihar & Ors reported in 1992 (2)
PLJR 65 did hold that such retrenched employees would be
given preference in recruitment by the State Government
when occasion for appointment on substantive post arose.
Petitioner earned his employment under the District
Magistrate, Patna on 8.10.1997 on a substantive post. He
superannuated in about three years time from 31.12.2000.
After retirement he asserted his right for grant of pension
by including such period of service which he had rendered
under Census Department from time to time. When he did
not get any relief he approached the High Court in CWJC
No. 3556 of 2001 which was disposed of vide order dated
19.3.2001 directing the District Magistrate to pass a
reasoned order which finally came to be done on 19.7.2001
and is annexure-10 to the writ application which the
petitioner challenges. According to the petitioner if the
period he had rendered service under Census Department
in whatever capacity is added up read with the direction of
the Full Bench that the retrenched employees of 1981
census would be given preference in the matter of
appointment with effect from 1.6.1992 is considered
coupled with the provisions relating the qualifying service
as has been brought on record as annexure-6, the petitioner
adds up the figure of 12and half years. But needs only 10
years of service to beget him the benefit of pro-rata
pension. The Court has gone through the decision rendered
by the District Magistrate. It does not find any error of
judgment or logic in reaching conclusion. Only a trapeze
artist can fill in gap between the vast period when the
petitioner had rendered service in snatches before the
Census Department till he finally got a substantive
appointment, the Court has difficulty in declaring the order
passed by the District Magistrate to be erroneous.
Petitioner wants the Court to create a legal fiction based on
Full Bench decision that even if he was appointed on the
Patna High Court CWJC No.13398 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
6/9
substantive post from 8.10.1997 his appointment ought to
be treated from 1.2.1992. The Court does not appreciate the
position of such submission because the observation of the
Full Bench to give preference in appointment from 1.6.1992
does not mean that all such persons ought to be appointed
from 1.6.1992. Appointment had to follow thereafter. As the
petitioner has rendered only three years of service after
substantive appointment under State authority, he cannot be
allowed benefit of pension by any interpretation. This writ
application has no merit. It is dismissed accordingly.
However, there will be not order as to cost."
9. Now, the petitioner has filed the present writ petition
claiming in paragraph no. 15 of the writ petition that both the
petitioner and Lal Mohan Singh were appointed vide office
Letter No. 2172 dated 31.10.1997, as such, the petitioner is
also required to be granted similar relief for which the
petitioner has filed representation before the District
Magistrate-cum-Collector, Patna communicated vide speed
post dated 26.02.2026.
10. In case of Lal Mohan Singh, who had filed CWJC
No. 21921 of 2011, which was disposed of on 21.12.2015, a
coordinate Bench of this Court had passed inter alia following
order:
"Pursuant to order dated 09.12.2015, the officers
namely Mr. Sanjay Kumar Singh, Dr. N. Saravana Kumar,
Mr. Manish Kumar Verma, Mr. Abhay Kumar Singh, Dr.
Pratima and Mr. Sanjay Kumar Agarwal are present in
Court. The Court is not repeating the discussions made in
order dated 09.12.2015 which led to a direction for the
personal appearance of the officers present today. At the
very outset, Mr. Lalit Kishore, learned Principal Additional
Advocate General for the State of Bihar and representing
the officers, who have filed separate show cause, submits
that initially under a bona fide impression that the order of
appointment of the petitioner was with prospective effect
Patna High Court CWJC No.13398 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
7/9
and the same having been issued in the year 1997 without
there being any note before the then District Magistrate-
cum-Collector, Patna to take any other view, the order
refusing notional benefit to the petitioner with effect from
1st June, 1992 was issued. All the officers have tendered
unconditional apology and the author of the original
impugned order dated 20.06.2011 has submitted to the
Court that it appears to be one of those exceptional cases
which was not brought to his notice otherwise he would
have at least started some action based on the averments
and materials in the writ application. However, he has
assured that it has been a learning experience for him and
in future he shall be cautious and careful in matters,
especially relating to Court proceedings.
The other incumbents have submitted through
learned State Counsel that the present matter was never
brought to their personal notice and as such they have been
made aware only when the order dated 09.12.2015 of the
Court was communicated to them. After having considered
the stand of the officers present today, the Court giving
them benefit of doubt and accepting the apology consigns
the issue with regard to fixing responsibility and taking
action against them. The Court is hopeful that they shall be
cautious and careful in future with regard to discharge of
their duties, moreso concerning proceedings pending before
the Courts. Coming to the merits, the present incumbent,
who has filed his show cause, has also annexed copies of
various orders which indicate that the grievance of the
petitioner stands redressed and actual payment has also
been made. The Court would like to indicate that the
present incumbent who took charge of his office on 6th
December, 2015 and having passed necessary orders within
a week of the order dated 09.12.2015 has shown
promptness and the Court appreciates such conduct. In
view of the discussions made above, the grievance of the
petitioner having been redressed, as has been accepted by
learned counsel appearing on his behalf, the writ petition
stands disposed off. Personal appearance of the officers
present today stand dispensed with"
11. There is no question of entertaining of the writ
petition in light of the order dated 19.11.2008 passed in CWJC
No. 1704 of 2002 and the matter of appointment of retrenched
employee of 1981 Census appointed under the State
Government has also been decided by a Division Bench and
Patna High Court CWJC No.13398 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
8/9
the Full Bench of this Court in its decision rendered in the case
of Jai Govind Prasad versus State of Bihar reported in (1992)
2 PLJR 65 by holding that they deserve to be given preference
in recruitment by the State Government when occassion for
appointment of substantive posts arose.
12. The petitioner had joined his employment in Belchi
pursuant to the office order contained in Memo No. 2054
dated 20.10.1997 issued under the signature of District
Magistrate, Patna on a substantive post and superannuated on
31.12.2000. Petitioner instead of challenging the order dated
19.11.2008 passed in CWJC No. 1704 of 2002, has belatedly
filed his representation before the District Magistrate-cum-
Collector, Patna communicated vide speed post dated
26.02.2026 claiming parity with Lal Mohan Singh to count his
service from 01.06.1992 and information is given in paragraph
no. 18 of the present writ petition that no decision has been
taken till date.
13. I can only direct the District Magistrate-cum-
Collector, Patna to communicate his decision in respect of the
entitlement of the petitioner for pension, expeditiously.
14. The writ petition is not maintainable for the
aforesaid reasons.
Patna High Court CWJC No.13398 of 2026 dt.03-11-2026
9/9
15. Accordingly, the present writ petition stands
disposed of.
(Purnendu Singh, J)
Niraj/-
AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE
Uploading Date 11.11.2026
Transmission Date