KHUSHI MOLLICK@JAMSED HOSSAIN vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Jay Sengupta
CRA (SB) 149 of 2022
CRAN 2 of 2025
(via video conference)
Khushi Mollick @ Jamsed Hossain
Vs.
The State of West Bengal& Ors.
For the appellant : Ms. Minoti Gomes
Md. Hafiz Ali
Mr. Kausik Biswas
Mr. Debojyoti De
.....Advocates
For the State : Mr. Somopriyo Chowdhury
Ms. Anindita Mukherjee
.....Advocates
For the SLSA : Ms. Soma Chowdhury Bandhu
.....Advocate
For the de facto complainant
through HCLSC : Ms. Sreyashee Biswas
.....Advocate
Heard lastly on : 13.11.2026
Judgment on : 17.11.2026
2
Jay Sengupta, J:
1. This is an appeal directed against the judgement and order of
conviction and sentence dated 06.09.2022 and 07.09.2022 passed by the
learned Judge, Special Court under the POCSO Act, Kandi, Murshidabad in
Sessions Trial No. 02(04), 2017 arising out of Burwan Police Station Case
No. 440 of 2016 dated 04.12.2016, thereby convicting the appellant and
sentencing him to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 3 years under Section
363 of the Penal Code and to pay fine with a default clause and to suffer
rigorous imprisonment for committing offence under Section 366 of the
Penal Code and to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 3 years and further to
suffer rigorous imprisonment for 7 years along with a fine with a default
clause under Section 4 of the POCSO Act and to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for 3 years and to pay fine with default under Section 8 of the
POCSO Act, all sentences having to run concurrently.
2. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner has submitted
and has relied on the written notes as follows. The alleged victim girl was
aged about 17 years and the accused was aged about 21 years at the time of
occurrence. Admittedly, they were in a love relation. The alleged victim in
her 164 Cr.P.C. statement admitted she knew the appellant and marriage
took place in the house of appellant. There are many contradictions in the
statements of the alleged victim under Sections 161 Cr.P.C., 164 Cr.P.C.
and the evidence. It is evident that the victim girl went with the petitioner at
her own volition and co-habited. The victim girl reached the age of
discretion. The appellant is in custody for more than 4 years. The appellant
3
being 21 years old and victim girl being 17+ years old were in love and as
per 164 Cr.P.C. statement, the V.G. got married to the petitioner while
staying in his house. The prosecution story is absolutely vague as the victim
girl in her Section 161 statement stated that on being scolded by her father,
she went away from her house. In the Section 164 Cr.P.C. statement she
stated she went to meet her friend and she knew the appellant before going
with him.
3. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the de facto complainant has
submitted and has relied on the written notes as follows. The victim was 15
years old girl as per FIR. She went missing on 26.11.2016. FIR was lodged
on 04.12.2016 under Sections 363, 365 IPC. The victim was recovered on
08.12.2016 from Burwan Bus Stand. The FIR was registered on 04.12.2016
on the basis of a written complaint lodged by the PW-1, being the father of
the victim against unknown accused. The FIR in a nutshell is that on
26.11.2016 the minor daughter of the complainant went missing. He tried to
search for her in every possible place.However, he could not find any trace of
her. Burwan Police Station Case No. 440/2016 dated 04.12.2016 was
registered against unknown accused on the basis of the aforesaid complaint
and the same culminated into S.T. No. 02(04)2017 arising out of C. Special
Case No. 10 of 2017. Duringtrial, PW1 was the de facto complainant, the
father of the victim. PW2 was the victim. PW3 was the scribe of the FIR. PW4
was a neighbour. PW5 was the doctor who examined the victim. PW6 was an
ASI.PW7 was an SI.The victim girl being examined as PW-2 in her
evidencehad stated that she was kidnapped by the appellant and then she
4
was kept confined at the room of the appellant where she was subjected to
rape and her this version has been corroborated by her statement made
before the Learned Magistrate and before the Police. Hence, the order of
conviction and sentence passed by the Learned Judge Special Court under
the POCSO Act is liable to be upheld. The victim was recovered after 12 days
from the date of her kidnapping and the medico-legal examination was
conducted on 26.01.2017, i.e., after 1 month and 18 days of her recovery
and the attending doctor being examined as PW-5 deposed that she noticed
that the hymen was torn and it was an old healed tear.As such, her medico-
legal examination also corroborated her version. The victim girl stated before
the treating doctor being PW-5 herein that she last met the appellant about
a month ago. Such statement of the victim girl before the doctor at the first
opportunity along with the medical evidence goes to show the credibility of
her evidence. The version of Doly Begum being examined as PW-4, the
neighbour of the victim who had heard the incident from the victim herself
has also corroborated the victim’s evidence. The age of the minor victim has
remained unchallenged through out and even if the story of the prosecution
is considered as gospel truth that the victim was a consenting party, then
also it can be presumed that the consent of a minor is no consent. The
appellant has also failed to overcome the rebuttable presumption under
Section 29 of the POCSO Act. The appellant has also failed to overcome the
presumption of “Culpable mental state” as laid down under Section 30
st
POCSO Act. The PW-6 being the 1 IO deposed that the victim had been
recovered from the Burwan bus stand. However, the victim had deposed that
5
she was recovered from the house of the appellant.However, such
discrepancy is a minor one and shall not lessen the veracity of the entire
prosecution case and hence, the order of conviction and sentence is liable to
be upheld. The prosecution has succeeded in proving its case beyond all
reasonable doubt. Reliance is placed on State of Himachal Pradesh Vs
Manga Singh, (2019) 16 SCC 759; State of Rajasthan Vs. N.K., (2000) 5 SCC
13, 3J; Nawabuddin Vs. State of Uttarkhand, (2022) 5 SCC 419.
4. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State has submitted and
has relied on the written notes as follows. The 17 years old victim stated
that she was taken from the bus stand by the accused to the house of his
brother at Rajgram. She was confined in a room and raped by the
accused/appellant. Thereafter, she was taken to the house of the accused,
where she was kept for 18/19 days and rape was committed upon her. The
victim’s evidence remains unimpeached in the cross-examination. The
victim’s statement under Section 164 Cr.PC before the Magistrate was
proved as Exhibit 3. PW-5/Medical Evidence corroborated that the victim
was subjected to sexual intercourse. Hymen was found torn. PW-6 gave
Corroborative Evidence. The first I.O. stated that the victim girl was
recovered from Burwan bus stand on 08.12.2016. Her statement was
recorded under Section 164 Cr.P.C. on 09.12.2016. PW-7/Second I.O.
seized the birth certificate of the victim (D.O.B.16.03.1999). The victim was
therefore aged 17 years at the time of the incident. PW-4/Neighbour
corroborated PW-1 and PW-2. The victim’s evidence remains unimpeached
and is corroborated by the medical evidence. No further evidence is required
6
to convict the accused. One of the arguments of the defence is that there
may have been consent. However, consent of the victim is immaterial under
the POCSO Act. The victim vouched in her Section 164 Cr.P.C. statement
and the evidence that she was raped by the accused. Section 30 of POCSO
Act applies. The accused has failed to discharge the burden to prove that he
was not guilty of sexual assault. The victim also stated that she was
kidnapped from Sunderpur bus stand. Hence, Section 363 and Section 366
IPC are also made out. The conviction has rightly been recorded by the
Learned Trial Court and the same deserves to be upheld by this Court.
5. I heard the learned counsels appearing on behalf of the parties and
perused the petitioner of appeal, the evidence adduced, the other materials
on record and the written notes of submission filed.
6. First, there is hardly any doubt about the age of the victim.Clearly,
she was a minor at the time of the alleged occurrence. The birth certificate of
the victim showed that she was a little more than 17 years of old at the time
of occurrence.
7. The appellant’s contentions that the victim went to the petitioner at
her own volition and co-habited and that she had reached an age of
discretion have no legs to stand. The question of consent of a minor cannot
arise, especially vis-à-vis offences under the POCSO Act.
7
8. The father of the victim (PW 1) lodged the FIR on 04.12.2016 about his
minor daughter going missing on 26.11.2016. The victim was recovered on
08.12.2016. Thereafter, the convicted was arrested.
9. In the statement before the learned Magistrate as well as before the
learned Trial Court, the minor victim consistently stated that she was
kidnapped by the appellant. She categorically deposed during trial that she
was raped by the appellant. Such stand of her could not be impeached in
the cross. In fact, in the statement before the learned Magistrate, she also
mentioned that the parents of the victim were quite nice. This lends
credence to the proposition that the victim was not making up this story. It
is the prosecution case that after the victim was kidnapped, she was taken
to the house of a relative of the accused where the two stayed for a day and
thereafter the victim was taken to the house of the appellant where allegedly
there was a sham marriage conducted. The appellant allegedly entered into
physical relationship with the alleged victim during this period.
10. Not only did the victim, after her recovery, confide the above referred
facts in her father, but also told this to a neighbour being PW 4.
11. As regards the purported discrepancy between the versions of the
alleged victim and the investigating officer about from where the victim was
recovered, it is not clear whether the bus stand in question was too far away
from the residence of the accused. In any event, as had been claimedby the
victim that she was staying with the appellant at the appellant’s house, she
must have come to the bus stand from the said house. If, as per the
8
investigating officer, the victim was recovered from such bus stand and the
victim in her evidence stated that she was recovered from the house of the
appellant from where she might have gone to the bus stand, the consequent
apparent anomaly cannot be treated as fatal to the prosecution case. It has
to be treated as a minor discrepancy, especially in view of the categorical
stand taken by the minor victim about the commission of the offences
during trial as also before the learned Magistrate.
12. The medical evidence adduced also supports the prosecution case.
13. Therefore, this Court finds no reason to disbelieve the version of the
minor girl giving out the necessary details about the commission of such
crimes.
14. On the other hand, the defence failed to rebut the presumptions
under Sections 29 and 30 of the POCSO Act.
15. In view of the above discussions, this Court finds that the prosecution
has been able to prove its case beyond all reasonable doubt.
16. Even on the question of the sentences, the approach of the learned
Trial Court has been quite measured and reasonable.
17. This Court does not find any legal or factual infirmity in the impugned
judgement and order of conviction and sentence awarded by the learned
Trial Court.
18. Therefore, the appeal is dismissed and the impugned judgement and
order of conviction and sentence is upheld.
9
19. Let a copy of this judgement be sent back along with the trial court
records forthwith to the learned Trial Court.
20. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied
to the parties upon compliance with requisite formalities.
(Jay Sengupta, J.)