Esahaqe Ali vs The State Of Assam
- Court
- Gauhati High Court
Page No.# 1/15
GAHC010094382024
2026:GAU-AS:16484
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.A./138/2021
ESAHAQE ALI
S/O- LATE HAKIM ALI
R/O- VILL.- BARAMARA
P.S. AND DIST.- BARPETA
ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM
REP. BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
ASSAM
2:AFAZ MIAH
S/O- LATE SULTAN MIAH
R/O- VILL.- BARAMARA
P.S. AND DIST.- BARPETA
ASSAM
------------
Advocate for : MR. J AHMED
Advocate for : PP
ASSAM appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM
Page No.# 2/15
BEFORE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SHAMIMA JAHAN
Advocate for the petitioner(s): Mr. J. Ahmed, Advocate
Advocate for the respondent(s): Ms. B Choudhury, Amicus Curiae
Mr. B. Sarmah, learned APP
Date on which judgment was reserved : NA
Date of pronouncement of judgment : 10.11.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the :
operative part of the judgment?: NA
Whether the full judgment has been : Yes
pronounced?
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
(Justice, J. Shamima Jahan)
Heard Mr. J. Ahmed, learned Counsel for the appellant and Ms. B.
Choudhury, learned Amicus Curiae for the informant. Also heard Mr. B. Sarmah,
learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State.
2. This is a Criminal Appeal filed under Section 374 of the CrPC, by the
convicted appellant, challenging the judgment and order dated 20.03.2021
Page No.# 3/15
passed by the Special Sessions Judge, Barpeta in Special (POCSO) Case No.
29/2018, by which the appellant was convicted under Section 450 of the IPC as
well as Section 4 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act,
(hereinafter shortly referred to as the “POCSO Act”). The appellant by the said
judgment was sentenced to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for one (1) year
with fine and default stipulation under Section 450 IPC as well as to undergo
Rigorous Imprisonment for a period of seven (7) years with fine and default
stipulation under Section 4 of the POCSO Act.
FACTS
3. The brief facts of the case is that an ejahar was lodged by the father of
the victim stating inter alia that on 08.08.2017 at around 06:00 pm, while he
was away from his home and his wife was washing clothes behind the house,
his five-year-old minor daughter, who was present in the house, was raped by
the appellant, by entering into his house and by taking advantage of their
absence. It was further stated that when his daughter raised alarm, his wife and
some neighbouring people arrived at the place of occurrence, subsequent to
which, the appellant fled from the same. It was also stated that later on his
daughter narrated the entire incident.
4. On receipt of the said ejahar, the Police registered the case, as Barpeta PS
Case No. 1379/2017, under Section 450 IPC read with Section 6 of the POCSO
Act. Upon completion of the investigation, the Police submitted charge sheet on
09.07.2018 arraying the appellant as the accused person on the ground that
sufficient evidence was found against him, under Section 450 IPC read with
Section 6 of the POCSO Act. Thereafter, on completion of necessary
requirements, the Court of Special Judge, Barpeta, framed charges against the
appellant under Section 450 of the IPC as well as under Section 4 of the POCSO
Page No.# 4/15
Act, which was read over and explained to the appellant who pleaded not guilty
and claimed to be tried. During the trial, the prosecution examined eleven (11)
witnesses and thereafter, the appellant was examined under Section 313 of the
CrPC and after hearing the arguments, the Court of Special Judge, Barpeta
passed the aforesaid judgment and order convicting the appellant and
sentencing him as mentioned above.
EVIDENCE
5. The informant was examined as PW1 and he stated before the Trial Court
that at the time of occurrence, he was in Guwahati and his wife was washing
clothes in the backyard of the house and that his five-year-old daughter was
inside the house. He further stated that upon hearing hue and cry of his
daughter, his wife rushed towards the place of occurrence and saw his daughter
and the appellant naked as the appellant raped his daughter. He also stated that
upon hearing the cries, neighbours gathered and that the appellant fled from
the place and that he came back from Guwahati and on the next day, he lodged
the ejahar.
This witness was cross-examined and during the said examination,
he stated that his daughter was examined by the doctor on the next day of the
occurrence and that his daughter was examined by the Police very late. He also
stated that he noticed injury marks on the private part of his daughter. He also
stated that he had no dispute with the appellant.
6. The mother of the victim was examined as PW2 and she stated that at the
relevant point of time, she was washing clothes in the backyard of the house
and upon hearing hue and cry of her daughter, she rushed to the house and
Page No.# 5/15
saw appellant committing rape upon her daughter. She also stated that
appellant upon seeing her, fled from the place and that she informed the
neighbours and also that her daughter was crying at that juncture.
This witness was cross-examined and during the same, she denied of
not stating before the Police that she was washing clothes in the backside of the
house and that she found her daughter in a naked condition and also that she
informed the neighbours about the incident and further that her daughter was
weeping at that point of time.
7. A neighbour of the informant was examined as PW3 and he stated that he
heard from a co-villager that appellant committed rape upon the minor daughter
of the informant. During his cross-examination, he stated that he did not speak
to the victim girl and that he also did not state before the Police that a boundary
dispute was going on between the appellant and the informant.
8. Another neighbour of informant was examined as PW4 and he stated that
when upon hearing, he enquired with the appellant, the appellant confessed his
guilt of committing rape upon the daughter of the informant but this witness
also stated that later on, the appellant denied. During cross-examination, he
stated that he did not state before the Police about the appellant confessing his
guilt or denying it later and also about the boundary dispute.
9. The grandmother of the victim was examined as PW5 and she stated that
the appellant entered the house and committed rape upon the victim causing
injuries on her private part. She also stated that upon hearing cries of the
victim, she went near her and that the accused fled away. She further stated
that the villagers questioned the appellant and the appellant admitted of visiting
the house of the informant. During her cross-examination, she stated that after
Page No.# 6/15
the incident she was in the residence and further stated that the appellant was
near her house but she did not speak with him and that she stated before Police
that she offered betel nut to the appellant. She denied of not stating before the
Police that on the day of occurrence, the victim was playing inside the house
when the appellant came and committed rape upon her and also that the
appellant admitted his guilt.
10. A relative of the informant was examined as PW6 and he stated that upon
hearing hue and cry, he reached the place of occurrence and saw the victim
weeping and narrating the incident to other villagers. He also stated that the
appellant had admitted his guilt. During cross-examination, he stated that on
the day of incident, the grandmother of the victim and the wife of the informant
was present in the house and he denied of not stating before the Police about
the village meeting held with regard to the offence.
11. One of the Investigating Officer who was examined as PW7 stated before
the Court that he had sent the victim for medical examination and had recorded
the statement of the witnesses and the victim. However, due to his transfer, he
handed over the Case Diary to his successor. During the cross-examination, this
witness stated that the mother of the victim did not state before him that she
was washing clothes and that she saw her daughter in naked condition and also
that she informed the neigbours and narrated the story to them. This witness
further stated that PW3 i.e. the neigbour stated before him that there was a
boundary dispute between the informant and appellant and that informant had
filed a false case. This witness further stated that the other neighbor, PW4 did
not state before him that appellant admitted his guilt.
12. The doctor who examined the victim deposed as PW8 and she upon
examination stated that she did not find any sign of sexual intercourse but
Page No.# 7/15
found swelling of labia majora and minora, which was again found to be tender.
However, the doctor opined of no injury on the private part of the victim. During
cross-examination, this witness stated that the victim girl had named the
accused person as Yasad Ali and further stated that since the examination was
done within 24 hours of the incident, symptoms of rape should have been
present.
13. The other Investigating Officer, who took over the case from PW7 was
examined as PW9 and he apart from stating the duties he did reiterated in his
cross-examination that the mother of the victim had not stated about the
statements as narrated above by PW7. He further stated that the grandmother
of the victim did not state before him that while the victim was playing inside
the house, appellant raped her and that the victim sustained injuries on her
private part. Contradictions were also stated with regard to the statement of
PW6.
14. The victim was examined as PW10 and the Trial Court after testing her
intelligence and understanding by putting certain questions, to which she gave
rational answers, recorded her statement on camera, wherein the victim stated
that while she was playing in her house, the appellant came and kissed her
private parts and while saying so, the victim had pointed to her vagina. The
victim further stated that the appellant put his private parts into her vagina and
that she cried and that her mother reached and the appellant left seeing her
mother.
This witness was cross-examined wherein she stated that when
appellant came inside the house, her grandmother was present and she spoke
with him and she also stated that when the appellant put his penis into her
vagina, her grandmother was present.
Page No.# 8/15
15. The Magistrate, who recorded the statement of the victim under Section
164 CrPC was examined as PW11 and she stated that she recorded the said
statement on 01.06.2018.
These are the evidences put forth by the prosecution. The appellant
was thereafter examined under Section 313 of the CrPC, wherein he completely
denied the allegations and stated that he had been falsely implicated.
16. The appellant did not adduce any defence witness and after hearing the
argument on behalf of both the sides, the Court of Special Judge, Barpeta had
convicted the appellant as stated above.
SUBMISSIONS
17. Mr. J. Ahmed, learned Counsel for the appellant submits that there was
admittedly a land dispute between the appellant and the informant and the said
case was lodged by the informant to wreak vengeance. He further submits that
there are contradictions in the statement of the witnesses and the said
contradictions are proved by the Investigating Officers during their
examinations. He also stated that the grandmother of the victim, whose
presence is stated by the victim at the time of occurrence, did not state before
the Police that appellant had raped the victim. He further submits that the
mother of the victim, who claims to have seen the victim in a naked condition
and who also claims to have seen the appellant raping the victim, had not
stated the same before the Police. He further submits that the appellant who
was inflicted with the punishment of seven-year incarceration under Section 4 of
the POCSO Act, has already served out the sentence for more than five years
and that by taking into account, the remission period that a convict is entitled,
the convict has almost completed his sentence.
Page No.# 9/15
18. On the other hand, Mr. B. Sarmah, learned Additional Public Prosecutor
submits that the victim was barely of five years of age and that the appellant
had sexually assaulted her, which resulted in injuries in the private part of the
victim girl. He relied on the report of the doctor, who on examination found
swelling in the private parts. He also submitted that little discrepancies in the
statement of the victim are natural since she was very young. He submitted that
contradictions with regard to other witnesses will not matter in the instant case.
19. Ms. B. Choudhury, learned Amicus Curiae for the informant supports the
argument of the learned Additional Public Prosecutor and further submits that
the instant case reveals a very ghastly incident being committed upon a five-
year-old child by a man of around 70 years. She submits that the mother of the
victim had seen the victim in a naked state who had further stated that she saw
the appellant committing rape upon the victim. She also relied on the statement
of the villagers, who stated that the appellant confessed his guilt. She also
submitted that the victim had given statements which are consistent with regard
to the root of the case.
These are the submissions of the learned Counsels for all the parties.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
20. In cases involving sexual offences, the clinching evidence is the evidence
of the prosecutrix as has been held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. In such
cases, seldom any ocular evidence can be found and it is no longer res-integra
that if the statement of the victim is found to be consistent before all the
authorities inspiring confidence of the Court, conviction can be awarded on the
sole basis of the same. It is held in Rai Sandeep Vs State of NCTof Delhi ,
reported in (2012) 8 SCC 21 as under:
Page No.# 10/15
“ 15. In our considered opinion, the 'sterling witness' should be of a very high quality
and caliber whose version should, therefore, be unassailable. The Court considering the
version of such witness should be in a position to accept it for its face value without any
hesitation. To test the quality of such a witness, the status of the witness would be
immaterial and what would be relevant is the truthfulness of the statement made by
such a witness. What would be more relevant would be the consistency of the
statement right from the starting point till the end, namely, at the time when the
witness makes the initial statement and ultimately before the Court. It should be natural
and consistent with the case of the prosecution qua the accused. There should not be
any prevarication in the version of such a witness. The witness should be in a position
to withstand the cross-examination of any length and strenuous it may be and under no
circumstance should give room for any doubt as to the factum of the occurrence, the
persons involved, as well as, the sequence of it. Such a version should have co-relation
with each and everyone of other supporting material such as the recoveries made, the
weapons used, the manner of offence committed, the scientific evidence and the expert
opinion. The said version should consistently match with the version of every other
witness. It can even be stated that it should be akin to the test applied in the case of
circumstantial evidence where there should not be any missing link in the chain of
circumstances to hold the accused guilty of the offence alleged against him. Only if the
version of such a witness qualifies the above test as well as all other similar such tests
to be applied, it can be held that such a witness can be called as a 'sterling witness'
whose version can be accepted by the Court without any corroboration and based on
which the guilty can be punished. To be more precise, the version of the said witness on
the core spectrum of the crime should remain intact while all other attendant materials,
namely, oral, documentary and material objects should match the said version in
material particulars in order to enable the Court trying the offence to rely on the core
version to sieve the other supporting materials for holding the offender guilty of the
charge alleged."
21. It is therefore seen from above that the statement of the victim has to be
examined right from the beginning till the end i.e. her statement before the
Police, thereafter her statement before the Magistrate and then her statement
before the Trial Court.
22. It is therefore imperative upon this Court to examine the statement of the
victim recorded by the Police at the very first instance. The victim was examined
by the Police under Section 161 of the CrPC on 28.05.2018 and the said
examination was in question-and-answer form, wherein it is seen that the victim
was asked as to whether she knows the appellant to which she answered as
Yes and she was further asked as to whether anything had taken place with
Page No.# 11/15
her, to which she also answered as Yes.
23. In her statement before the Magistrate recorded under Section 164 of the
CrPC, the victim stated after she was examined of her capacity to understand
the implications, that the appellant had hurt her on her anus and that the
appellant had committed bad act by applying saliva on her anus and that when
she cried, he pressed her mouth. She also stated that thereafter she came
home and told her grandmother about the incident and that her grandmother
asked her whether she had fallen upon something.
24. During her examination before the Trial Court, which had taken place after
two years of the incident, the victim stated that while she was playing in her
house, the appellant came to her house and kissed her private parts, which she
indicated by pointing her finger towards her vagina. She also stated that the
appellant had put his penis into her vagina and that she cried and that when her
mother came, she told her the incident and that the appellant left.
25. The discrepancies are writ large in the statement of the victim as narrated
above. During her examination by the Police, she simply stated that something
was done to her by the appellant and in the examination by the Magistrate, she
stated that appellant committed bad act in her anus and in the trial, she stated
that appellant kissed her private parts and put his penis into her vagina.
Although, the victim was only five years of age at the time of the incident but
her examination by the Police was done on 28.05.2018 i.e. almost after a year
and her examination by the Magistrate was done on 01.06.2018 and finally her
examination by the Trial Court was done on 02.09.2019. Further, although it can
safely be held that the victim being of such a minor age, cannot be expected to
give consistent statement, to the exact sense of the term, before all the
authorities but at the same time, the discrepancies seen in her statement
Page No.# 12/15
cannot by any stretch, can be said to be connected or similar to each other. As
such, this Court is duty bound to look into the other evidence on record.
26. It is a settled position of law that in case the statement of the prosecutrix
or the victim does not inspire confidence, the Court will look into other
corroboration to the prosecution story. In the instant case, the corroboration at
best can come from the statement of the mother of the victim. The mother of
the victim stated that upon hearing cries of her daughter, she rushed inside the
house and saw appellant committing rape upon her daughter and also saw her
daughter naked and that seeing her, the appellant fled from the house. She also
stated that she informed the neighbours and told them the incident. However, in
her cross-examination, she was confronted with her statement made before the
Police, to which she replied that she stated before the Police the said statements
of seeing the incident or informing the neighbours. With the placing of the said
statement, which is denied by the said witness, the contradiction is brought on
record. It is thereafter proved by examining the Investigating Officer, who had
stated in clear terms that the mother of the victim had not stated the same and
as such, the contradiction stood proved. Accordingly, the statement of the
mother of the victim cannot have the potentiality to support the version of the
victim.
27. The other corroboration that can be deduced to the statement of the
victim is the statement of the grandmother of the victim. It is stated by the
victim herself in her statement before the Magistrate that after the incident, she
told it to her grandmother. However, the grandmother stated that upon hearing
cries of the victim, she came nearby and that the appellant fled away. Although
in her examination in chief, she stated that appellant committed rape upon the
victim but in her cross-examination, she stated that after the incident, she was
Page No.# 13/15
in the residence. The further contradiction is noticed by this court, when she
was confronted with the statement before the Police, to which she replied that
she stated before the police thaton the day of incident, the victim was playing
inside the house and the appellant came and raped her and also that appellant
admitted his guilt. However, the said contradiction was thereafter placed before
the Investigating Officer and the Investigating Officer stated that the
grandmother of the victim did not state the said statements. As such, the
contradiction stood proved and the statement of the grandmother also cannot
corroborate the prosecution case.
28. The law relating to proving of contradictions has been enunciated by the
Apex Court in V.K. Mishra Vs. State of Uttarakhand, reported in (2015) 9
SCC 588 . It has been held as under:
"18. Under Section 145 of the Evidence Act when it is intended to contradict the
witness by his previous statement reduced into writing, the attention of such witness
must be called to those parts of it which are to be used for the purpose of contradicting
him, before the writing can be used. While recording the deposition of a witness, it
becomes the duty of the trial court to ensure that the part of the police statement with
which it is intended to contradict the witness is brought to the notice of the witness in
his cross-examination. The attention of witness is drawn to that part and this must
reflect in his cross-examination by reproducing it. If the witness admits the part
intended to contradict him, it stands proved and there is no need to further proof of
contradiction and it will be read while appreciating the evidence. If he denies having
made that part of the statement, his attention must be drawn to that statement and
must be mentioned in the deposition. By this process the contradiction is merely
brought on record, but it is yet to be proved. Thereafter when investigating officer is
examined in the court, his attention should be drawn to the passage marked for the
purpose of contradiction, it will then be proved in the deposition of the investigating
officer who again by referring to the police statement will depose about the witness
having made that statement. The process again involves referring to the police
statement and culling out that part with which the maker of the statement was intended
to be contradicted. If the witness was not confronted with that part of the statement
with which the defence wanted to contradict him, then the court cannot suo moto make
use of statements to police not proved in compliance with Section 145 of Evidence Act
that is, by drawing attention to the parts intended for contradiction."
29. Contradictions are also seen with regard to the sequence of events as
Page No.# 14/15
narrated by the witnesses. The victim stated before the Magistrate that after the
incident, she came back home and told her grandmother about the incident,
whereas the grandmother said that upon hearing cries of the victim, she went
near the victim. Further, the evidence in the instant case shows that it was the
mother of the victim, who reached the place of occurrence first and she
informed the villagers, which is also stated by the father of the victim examined
as PW1. With regard to the further fact as to whether there is any extra judicial
confession on the part of the appellant, there is further contradiction in the
statement of the villagers as stated above. It is also seen that the victim during
her medical examination stated the name of the accused person as Yasad Ali
and not the appellant, which also demolishes the case of the prosecution.
Therefore, looking at the aforesaid discrepancies as well as the contradictions,
this Court deems it fit to interfere with the Judgment and Order passed in the
present case convicting the appellant.
CONCLUSIONS
30. As such, the Judgment and Order dated 20.03.2021 passed by the Court
of Special Judge, Barpeta in Special POCSO Case No. 29/2018 is set aside and
quashed.
31. The appellant is accordingly acquitted of the charges and is directed to be
released forthwith, if not required in any other case.
32. Send back the LCR.
33. No order as to costs.
34. Further this Court directs the Legal Services Authority to pay the
remuneration, which is required to be given to the Amicus Curiae, for rendering
her appreciable service to this Court, with regard the present case.
Page No.# 15/15
35. Accordingly, the Criminal Appeal is disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant