Mahender Singh vs Sulakhan Singh Etc.
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
-1-
107 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
FAO-1235-2003 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 18.11.2026
MAHENDER SINGH (SINCE DECEASED) THROUGH LRS
...Appellant
Versus
SULAKHAN SINGH AND ORS.
...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PARMOD GOYAL
Present: Mr. M. S. Virk, Advocate
for the appellant.
Mr. Rajneesh Malhotra, Advocate (through VC) and
Ms. Manvi Verma, Advocate
for respondent No.3/Insurance Company.
PARMOD GOYAL, J. (ORAL)
Present appeal has been preferred by appellant-claimant
seeking enhancement in compensation awarded vide award dated
04.02.2002 passed by learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sirsa
(hereinafter referred to as ‘ Tribunal ’) on account of injuries sustained by
him in motor vehicular accident dated 06.05.1998 allegedly caused due to
rash and negligent driving of respondent-driver while driving bus bearing
registration No.HR-39/2828 (hereinafter referred to as ‘ offending vehicle ’).
2. Since in the present appeal the only issue raised by the
appellants-claimants is with regard to the quantum of compensation and no
appeal or cross-objection has been preferred by any of the respondents to
challenge findings of learned Tribunal as regards to rash and negligent
driving of offending vehicle driven by respondent-driver, therefore, the
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-1235-2003 -2-
detailed facts regarding the manner of accident are not being noticed herein
for the sake of brevity.
3. In the present case, learned Tribunal had awarded the following
compensation to appellant-claimant:
Medical expenses Rs.24,000/-
Pain and sufferings Rs.5,000/-
Loss of income Rs.6,000/-
Special diet and attendant charges Rs.5,000/-
Compensation on account of
Rs.40,000/-
permanent disability
Total compensation awarded Rs.80,000/-
4. Learned c ounsel for appellant-claimant has sought enhancement
in compensation on the following grounds that :
•
Learned Tribunal had erred in not granting compensation on
the basis of functional disability (as permanent disability is
32%);
•
Learned Tribunal has erred in not taking the income of
appellant-claimant as was pleaded by the appellant-claimant;
•
Future prospects were not added while determining loss of
earning capacity. Future prospects to the extent 25 % of
monthly income needs to be added as appellant-claimant was
45 years of age at the time of accident.
•
Appropriate multiplier was not applied by learned Tribunal;
•
Compensation for loss of future prospects and future
amenities, and for future medical expenses has not been
granted to which appellant-claimant is entitled to; and
•
Enhancement of compensation for pain and sufferings,
medical expenses, special diet, transportation attendant
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-1235-2003 -3-
charges, etc. and for loss of income during treatment,. is
warranted being insufficient in view of nature of injuries,
nature of treatment and period of hospitalisation.
5. In the present case appellant-claimant while appearing as PW-1
had claimed that he had suffered multiple injuries including injury on his
leg, right side of thigh and entire chest region. He further claimed that his
right leg was fractured and he was treated by Dr. M. K. Soni. He claimed to
have spent Rs.1,50,000/- on his treatment and had also claimed to have
suffered loss of earning capacity, loss of earning during period of treatment,
loss of future prospects and future amenities of life including pain and
sufferings. He also claimed to have suffered permanent disability to the
extent of 32%.
6. In order to prove nature of injuries, nature of treatment, period
of hospitalization, extent of permanent disability and expenses incurred on
treatment, appellant-claimant had examined Dr. M. K. Soni as PW-3, who
had duly stated to have treated the appellant-claimant who was diagnosed
with fracture of right femur of both bones of right leg. PW-3 further stated to
have operated appellant-claimant on 18.05.1998 and claimed that appellant-
claimant was discharged on 28.05.1998 after hospitalization for three weeks.
MLR was duly placed on record as Ex.P-100 and discharge card was placed
on record as Ex.P-101. OPD slip, opinion of Doctor and medical bill
regarding treatment were also placed on record as Ex.P-103, Ex.P-104 and
Ex.P-105 respectively. Dr. Joginder Singh appeared as PW-1 and stated that
appellant-claimant had suffered disability to the extent of 32% on account of
limitation of right ankle and knee joint and adduced the disability certificate
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-1235-2003 -4-
in evidence as Ex.P-99.
7. As far as nature of injuries and period of hospitalization is
concerned, appellant-claimant had succeeded in proving that he had suffered
multiple fractures for which he was operated upon and had remained
admitted in hospital from 06.05.1998 till 28.05.1998. It is also proved from
Ex.P-105 and Ex.P-120 that appellant-claimant had spent more than
Rs.12,000/- on his treatment.
8. From the nature of injuries, nature of treatment and period of
hospitalization, it is made out that apart from expenses on treatment,
appellant-claimant must have spent amount on special diet, attendant
charges as well as transportation. Therefore, appellant-claimant shall be
entitled to consolidated compensation of Rs.20,000/- under the head
medical expenses, special diet, transportation and attendant charges,
etc . Keeping in view nature of injury it is clearly made out that the
appellant-claimant must have undergone immense pain and sufferings on
account of multiple injuries/fractures, accordingly, appellant-claimant is
entitled to enhanced compensation of Rs.75,000/- for pain and sufferings.
From the evidence of Dr. Joginder Singh (PW-1) as well as disability
certificate Ex.P-99, appellant-claimant has succeeded in proving that he had
suffered disability to the extent of 32%. The disability is in the nature of
limitations of movements of right ankle and knee joint as well as foot drop.
It is the case of appellant-claimant that he was working as an agriculturist.
The fact that appellant-claimant was a labourer/agriculturist has gone
unrebutted, therefore, in the present case, where appellant-claimant is
required to do manual labour it would have become difficult for him to
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-1235-2003 -5-
pursue same on account of the permanent disability suffered by him.The
functional disability is therefore, taken as 32%.
9. Appellant-claimant had claimed that he is owner of 15 acres of
land and was earning Rs.15,000/- per month. However, except for oral
statements, no material/evidence was placed on record to justify the claim of
ownership over 15 acres. No revenue records or J-forms were produced. In
absence of any cogent and reliable evidence, appellant-claimant at the most
can be taken as agriculturist/labourer and accordingly, his income has to be
determined by keeping in view minimum wages payable to unskilled worker
in year 1998 when the accident had taken place. Accordingly, monthly
income of deceased is taken as Rs.2,000/- taking in consideration minimum
wages payable to unskilled worker in year 1998.
10. Appellant-claimant is stated to be 45 years old at the time of
accident, this fact has gone unrebutted. Therefore, appellant-claimant is
entitled to addition of future prospects to the extent of 25% for the purposes
of determining loss of earning capacity in view of judgment passed by
Hon'ble Supreme Court in National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay
Sethi and Ors. , 2017 (16) SCC 680. Multiplier of ‘14’ shall be applicable as
per the age of injured in view of judgment passed by Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Smt. Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation &
Anr. , 2009(6) SCC 121.
11. Accordingly, loss of earning capacity payable to appellant-
claimant has to be determined by taking functional disability equivalent to
32% after taking monthly income of the injured to be Rs.2,000/- , by adding
future prospects to the extent of 25% and by applying multiplier of ‘ 14 ’.
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-1235-2003 -6-
12. Since, appellant-claimant had suffered disability to the extent of
32%, he would be deprived of loss of future prospects and future
amenities of life , accordingly, compensation of Rs.75,000/- is awarded
under this head. Keeping in view nature of injury in view of multiple
fractures suffered by appellant-claimant, he must have remained out of work
for at least 06 months. Accordingly, appellant-claimant is entitled to
compensation of Rs.12,000 /- (Rs.2,000- X 6) towards loss of income. Since,
appellant-claimant had not pleaded and proved any requirement for the
future medical treatment, therefore, he is not entitled to any compensation
under this head.
13. Re-worked compensation payable to appellant-claimant is as
under:-
Income Rs.2,000/-
Rs.2,000/-
per month
per month
Future prospects 25%
Rs.2,500/-
(Rs.2,000 + 500)
Functional disability 32% of Rs.2,500/- Rs.800/-
Multiplier 14 14
Total loss of earning
Rs.800 X 12 X 14 Rs.1,34,400/-
capacity
Loss of income during
Rs.2,000 X 6 Rs.12,000/-
treatment
Compensation for
Rs.20,000/-
medical expenses,
transportation, special
diet and attendant
charges
Compensation for pain
Rs.75,000/-
and sufferings
Compensation for loss of
Rs.75,000/-
future prospects and
future amenities of life
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-1235-2003 -7-
Total compensation
Rs.80,000/-
awarded by the Tribunal
Total compensation
Rs.3,16,400/-
awarded in appeal
Rs.2,36,400/-
Enhanced compensation Rs.3,16,400/- (awarded in
appeal) – Rs.80,000 /-
(awarded by the Tribunal)
14. Appellant-claimant shall also be entitled to interest over en-
hanced amount to the extent of 7.5% from the date of filing of claim petition
till its realization. The liability of respondents to pay compensation shall be
as per award.
15. Present appeal is allowed in above terms.
16. Pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of.
(PARMOD GOYAL)
18.11.2026 JUDGE
Ravinder
Whether Speaking/Reasoned : Yes
Whether Reportable : Yes/No
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.20 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document