MOUSUMI MALAKAR AND ORS vs NATIONAL INS CO LTD AND ANR
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
1
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Biswaroop Chowdhury
F.M.A. 20 of 2023
With
CAN 1 of 2023
Mousumi Malakar & Ors.
VERSUS
The National Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr.
For the Appellants:
Mr. Amit Ranjan Roy, Adv.
Mr. Pradyut Roy, Adv.
Mr. Deb Narayan Roy, Adv.
For the Respondent No. 1/Insurance
Co.:
Last Heard on: October 08, 2026
Judgment on: November 16, 2026
Biswaroop Chowdhury, J:
The appellants before this Court were claimants in a case under Section
166 of the Motor Vehicles Act 1988 and are aggrieved by the Judgment and
th
Award dated 14 September 2022 passed by Learned Additional District Judge
rd
3 Court Tamluk Purba Medinipur in MAC Case No. 88 of 2019.
2
The case of the claimants/appellants before the Learned Trial Court may
be summed up thus:
On 17-08-2018 at about 10.30 a.m. the victim Suman Malakar was
coming from Tamluk side and proceeded towards Panskura side through the
left side of Tamluk Panskura road by a motor cycle WB-30E/9933 alongwith
another person. The said motor cycle was proceeding slowly carefully sincerely
through extreme left side of the said road and deceased Suman Malakar was
sitting on the motor cycle with helmet on his head. When the said motor cycle
reached at Damadarpur village at that time the offending bus WB-29/8619 was
coming from Panskura side and proceeded towards Tamlukside with very
excessive high speed and recklessly. The driver of the said offending vehicle
could not control the same which knocked the said motor cycle along with
Suman Malakar and other person with great force on the wrong side of the said
road. For that Suman Malakar and Ashok Maji were grievously injured, after
accident. Suman Malakar after accident was taken to Purba Medinipur District
Hospital at Tamluk. There after he was taken to SSKM Hospital Kolkata, as an
indoor patient. He died at that hospital due to the said accidental injuries.
The accident took place due to rash and negligent driving by driver of
vehicle no-WB-29/8619.
Pursuant to filing of this case notice was issued upon the opposite
parties. Opposite party vehicle owner did not contest the case. However
3
opposite party National Insurance Company contested the case by filing written
statement.
ISSUES were framed and evidence was adduced. Learned Trial Judge
upon considering the evidence adduced and upon hearing the Learned
Advocates was pleased to dispose the claim case by observing and directing as
follows:
‘Hence it is ORDERED that the instant MAC Case be and the same is
allowed an contest against the OP No. 2/National Insurance Company Ltd. and
Ex-parte against OP No. 1/SK. Abdul Jabbar owner of the offending ‘Bus’
bearing registration no. WB/29/8619 but without any order as to costs.
The petitioners do get an award of 8,76,400/- (Rupees eight lakh seventy
six thousand four hundred only) along with interest @6% p.a. from filing of the
instant claim application till the payment by the OP No-2/National Insurance
Company Ltd.
The OP No. 2/National Insurance Company Ltd. is directed to pay the
awarded amount with interest by issuing (5) A/C payee cheques in the name of
petitioners in the manner herein below:
[Rs. 1,67,280/-+Rs. 40000/(towards consortium) in the name of the
claimant/petitioner no-1 Mousumi Malakar along with interest as ordered.
Cheque amounting to Rs. 1,67,280/- in the name of claimant/petitioner
no. 3 (minor) Amit Malakar along with interest as ordered.
4
Cheque amounting to Rs. 1,67,280/- in the name of claimant/petitioner
no-4 Shephali Malakar along with interest as ordered.
Cheque amounting to Rs. 1,67,280/- in the name of claimant/petitioner
no-5 Lakshan Malakar along with interest as ordered.
Claimant/petitioner No. 1 Mousumi Malakar being the mother and
natural guardian of claimant/petitioner Sumitra Malakar (minor petitioner) is
directed to receive the cheques issued in the name of minor petitioners Sumitra
Malakar and Amit Malakar and she is further directed to keep the said
awarded amount in the long term Fixed Deposit Scheme in the name of the
respective petitioners Sumitra Malakar and Amit Malakar in any Nationalized
Bank or Post Office benevolent for the minors within one month from the date
of receipt of the cheques. The amount so deposited in the name of minors shall
not be withdrawn/encashed until the minors attain majority or without the
permission of the Tribunal in urgent medical purpose.
After showing proper receipt of depositing of amounts in the respective
name of minor petitioners Sumitra Malakar and Amit Malakar as ordered, the
Petitioner no. 1 Mousumi Malakar will be able to withdraw her cheque.
The OP No. 2/NATIONAL Insurance Co. Ltd. is further directed to issue
aforesaid cheques within forty five days from the date of this order failing which
the awarded amount shall carry further interest @8% p.a. from the date of this
order till realization of the amount.’
5
The Appellants/claimants being aggrieved by the Judgment and Award
passed by the Learned Trial Judge have come up with the instant appeal.
Heard Learned Advocate for the appellants/claimants and Learned
Advocate for the Respondent Insurance Company. Perused the evidence
adduced and materials on record.
Learned Advocate for the appellants submits that learned Trial Judge
erred in considering the notional income of the victim as Rs. 4,000/- per
month. Learned Advocate further submits that the victim was a marketing
manager thus income cannot be Rs. 4,000/- per month. Learned Advocate also
submits that compensation awarded should be enhanced. Learned Advocate
relies upon the following Judicial decision:-
FMA 1005 of 2024.
Bazaz Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. VS Aparna Mondal and ors.
With
COT 141 of 2024.
Aparna Mondal and ors. VS Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd.
Learned Advocate for the respondent National Insurance Company
Limited submits that the appellants/claimants could not prove the income of
the victim thus the learned Judge rightly proceeded on the basis of notional
income. Learned Advocate further submits that the claimants could not
6
produce any document to prove income nor they examined the employer of the
victim. Learned Advocate also submits that the compensation awarded by the
Learned Trial Court should not be interfered with.
In the instant case although the claimants/appellants did not examine
the employer or filed document in support of income of the victim but
considering the fact that the claimants mentioned specifically the
establishment where victim worked as marketing manager and the proprietor
of the said business the said statements should not be disbelieved. Moreover
there is no cross-examination by Insurance Company about the victim working
in Biri Factory as Marketing Manager. Only there was a suggestion with regard
monthly earning of Rs. 4,000/- in Biri factory. Thus the employment as
manager in Biri factory is established. Hence considering the nature of work
and the total number of members of victims family it would be reasonable to fix
the monthly income of the victim as Rs. 8,000/-.
In the event monthly income of the victim is Rs. 8,000/- yearly income
th
comes to Rs. 96,000/-. 1/4 being Rs. 24,000/- deducted on account of
personal expenses, net monthly income comes Rs. 72,000/-. 40% future
prospect being added Annual dependency loss comes to Rs. 100,800/-. The
multiplier of 16 applied total dependency loss comes to Rs. 16,12,800/-.
Further the claimants/appellants are entitled to compensation of Rs. 70,000/-
on account of loss of consortium, loss of estate, and funeral expenses.
7
Thus total compensation comes to Rs. 16,82,000/- (Rupees Sixteen lac
eighty two thousand) by arithmetical calculation. However this Court is of the
view that compensation of Rs. 17,00,000/- (Rupees Seventeen lacs only) is just
and reasonable.
Hence this FMA No. 20 of 2023 stands disposed. The Judgment and
th
Award dated 14 September 2022 passed by Learned Additional District Judge
rd
3 Court Tamluk Purba Medinipur in MAC Case No-88/2019 stands modified
to the extent that the appellants/claimants are entitled to compensation of Rs.
17,00,000/- (Rupees Seventeen Lac). The respondent National Insurance
Company Limited shall deposit before the Registrar General High Court
Calcutta Rs. 17,00,000/- along with interest @ 6% p.a. annum from the date of
filing claim case till today. Such deposit shall be made within 8 weeks from the
date of communication of this order. In the event compensation awarded by
Trial Court is paid or deposited balance deposit be made.
The appellants/claimants will be entitled to withdraw the compensation
upon compliance of necessary formalities and on payment of deficit Court fees.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, should be
made available to the parties upon compliance with the requisite formalities.
(Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)