Chhaju And Anr vs State Of Haryana And Anr

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CRM-M-24908-2019 (O&M) - 1-

128
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CRM-M-24908-2019 (O&M)
Date of Decision:13.11.2026
Chhaju and Anr. …Petitioners
Vs.
State of Haryana and Anr. …Respondents
Coram : Hon’ble Mr. Justice N.S.Shekhawat
Present: Mr. Ankush Chaudhary, Advocate
for the petitioner.
Mr. Rajinder Kumar Banku, Sr. DAG, Haryana.
Mr. Jagdeep Singh Rana, Advocate
Ms. Preeti Jha, Advocate
Mr. Arvind Kumar Bangar, Advocate
for respondent No.2.
*
N.S.Shekhawat J.
1. The petitioners have filed the present petition under Section 482
Cr.P.C with a prayer to set aside the impugned judgment dated 05.03.2019
(Annexure P-1) passed by the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Gurugram as
well as the impugned order dated 21.11.2018 (Annexure P-7) passed by the
Court of Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Gurugram, whereby, the application
under Section 319 Cr.P.C filed by the prosecution was allowed and the
petitioners were ordered to be summoned as additional accused for the offences
punishable under Sections 323,354,341 of IPC.
2. The F.I.R in the present case was registered on the basis of the
complaint filed by Sunita, respondent No.2 and the relevant extract of the said
complaint has been reproduced below:-
HITESH
2026.11.18 09:46
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CRM-M-24908-2019 (O&M) - 2-

“To SHO, Police Station, Sector 10-A, Gurgaon, so it is
most respectfully submitted that I Sunita, wife of Kamal
Singh, am a resident of Village Garhi Harsaru, Gurugram.
Today, around 7:30 AM, members of my in-laws family beat
me up after entering my place of residence. My father-in-
law, husband's elder brothers and my husband were a part
of this group. I have an ongoing case against them in the
court under dvrs 498 and I am presently staying in a house,
along with my children, provided under the directions of the
Hon’ble Court. There is already a F.I.R against them for
similar offence and despite that they continued to beat me in
the violation of law. Today morning, my husband and two of
his elder brothers, Chajju Ram and Krishan Kumar gave me
beatings and molested me. When my husband's elder brother
touched by breast and tried to break the "rope the group of
honour" of my "Salwaar". I told my husband pointing out to
as to what they were doing. My husband replied they were
doing the right thing and I deserved it. But I struggled to
check them they hit my head against the wall, kicked and
slapped me and also dragged me to a window of the house
while continuing to hit me with chappals. They also broke
window glasses I got injured close to my eye and later there
was swelling close to my eye and over my hands. I then
called police helpline 100 and 40 police of the incident
emphasizing that my father-in-law has been bragging that
police and Court could do him no wrong since he was
Village Sarpanch. They have been repeatedly beating me in
violating the law of land. It is requested that the strict action
be taken against them. Sd/-Sunita”.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioners has vehemently argued that the
respondent No.2/complainant is the sister-in-law (Bhabhi) of the petitioners and
HITESH
2026.11.18 09:46
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CRM-M-24908-2019 (O&M) - 3-

is married to Kamal, their brother. A matrimonial dispute was already pending
between Kamal, brother of the petitioners and his wife, Sunita, respondent No.2.
Respondent No.2 had lodged a F.I.R No.170 dated 16.03.2014, under Sections
323,341,506 of IPC, Police Station Sector-10 Gurugram against her husband as
well as the petitioners. It was specifically mentioned by respondent No.2 that
she had instituted a dowry case against her in-laws, which is pending in the
Court. Inspite of the fact that a case was pending in the Court, the petitioners
along with Kamal had allegedly beaten her up. During the course of
investigation, it was found that the petitioners were innocent and the challan was
presented only against Kamal, husband of respondent No.2. During the course
of trial, respondent No.2 was examined as PW-5 and after her examination-in-
chief, the prosecution moved an application under Section 319 Cr.P.C for
summoning the petitioners as additional accused. Vide the order dated
05.03.2018 (Annexure P-5), the Trial Court dismissed the application filed by
respondent No.2 as a previous matrimonial litigation was already pending
between Kamal and respondent No.2. Respondent No.2 filed a revision and the
case was remanded back by the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Gurugram
for passing a fresh order, in accordance with law. Vide the impugned order
dated 21.11.2018, the Court of Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Gurugram ordered
the summoning of the petitioners as additional accused in the present case. The
petitioners filed a revision petition before the Sessions Court and vide the
impugned order dated 05.03.2019 (Annexure P-1), the summoning of the
petitioners has been upheld.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioners submit that nearly a
dozen matters were pending between respondent No.2 and her husband. Even,
HITESH
2026.11.18 09:46
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CRM-M-24908-2019 (O&M) - 4-

on several occasions also in the past, the petitioners were also arrayed as an
accused in other F.I.R as well. However, on investigation, the allegations
levelled against the petitioners were found to be false and rather it was found
that they had been falsely involved only because of their relationship with
th
Kamal, husband of respondent No.2. In fact, this was the 5 F.I.R instituted by
respondent No.2. Both the petitioners were found to be live separately and were
maintaining separate ration Cards and there was no evidence to show their
involvement in the crime.
5. On the other hand, learned counsel appearing on behalf of
respondent No.2 has vehemently opposed the submissions made by learned
counsel for the petitioners on the ground that the names of the petitioners find
mention in the F.I.R itself, which is the initial version of respondent No.2. Even
while appearing in the witness box, the respondent No.2 had named both the
petitioners and specific roles were assigned to them. Thus, the petitioners were
rightly summoned by the Trial Court as well as by the Revisional Court to face
trial along with Kamal, who is already before the Court.
6. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record
carefully.
7. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, while discussing the powers under
Section 319 Cr.P.C held in the matter of “ Hardeep Singh Vs.State of Punjab,
(2014) 3 SCC 92 as follows:-
“ 105. Power under Section 319 Cr.PC is a
discretionary and an extraordinary power. It is to be exercised
sparingly and only in those cases where the circumstances of the
case so warrant. It is not to be exercised because the Magistrate or
the Sessions Judge is of the opinion that some other person may
HITESH
2026.11.18 09:46
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CRM-M-24908-2019 (O&M) - 5-

also be guilty of committing that offence. Only where strong and
cogent evidence occurs against a person from the evidence led
before the court that such power should be exercised and not in a
casual and cavalier manner.
106. Thus, we hold that though only a prima facie case is to be
established from the evidence led before the court, not necessarily
tested on the anvil of cross-examination, it requires much stronger
evidence than mere probability of his complicity. The test that has
to be applied is one which is more than prima facie case as
exercised at the time of framing of charge, but short of satisfaction
to an extent that the evidence, if goes unrebutted, would lead to
conviction. In the absence of such satisfaction, the court should
refrain from exercising power under Section 319 CrPC. In Section
319 CrPC the purpose of providing if 'it appears from the evidence
that any person not being the accused has committed any offence'
is clear from the words 'for which such person could be tried
together with the accused. The words used are not 'for which such
person could be convicted'. There is, therefore, no scope for the
court acting under Section 319 CrPC to form any opinion as to the
guilt of the accused."
8. Still further, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held in the matter of
“ Omi @ Omkar Rathore & Anr. Vs.State of Madhya Pradesh & Anr., SLP
(Crl.) No.(s) 17781 of 2024 held that the powers under Section 319 Cr.P.C
empowers the trial court to summon persons to face trial, even they were not
named in the charge-sheet, however, this power has to be exercised
extraordinarily and must be exercised sparingly and not in a casual manner and
held as follows:-
“ 21.The principles of law as regards Section 319 of the Cr.P.C
may be summarised as under:
HITESH
2026.11.18 09:46
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CRM-M-24908-2019 (O&M) - 6-

a. On a careful reading of Section 319 of the CrPC as well as the
aforesaid two decisions, it becomes clear that the trial court has
undoubted jurisdiction to add any person not being the accused
before it to face the trial along with other accused persons, if the
Court is satisfied at any stage of the proceedings on the evidence
adduced that the persons who have not been arrayed as accused
should face the trial. It is further evident that such person even
though had initially been named in the F.I.R. as an accused, but
not charge sheeted, can also be added to face the trial.
b. The trial court can take such a step to add such persons as
accused only on the basis of evidence adduced before it and not on
the basis of materials available in the chargesheet or the case
diary, because such materials contained in the charge sheet or the
case diary do not constitute evidence.
c. The power of the court under Section 319 of the CrPC is not
controlled or governed by naming or not naming of the person
concerned in the FIR. Nor the same is dependent upon submission
of the chargesheet by the police against the person concerned. As
regards the contention that the phrase 'any person not being the
accused' occurred in Section 319 excludes from its operation an
accused who has been released by the police under Section 169 of
the Code and has been shown in column No. 2 of the charge sheet,
the contention has merely to be stated to be rejected. The said
expression clearly covers any person who is not being tried
already by the Court and the very purpose of enacting such a
provision like Section 319(1) clearly shows that even persons who
have been dropped by the police during investigation but against
whom evidence showing their involvement in the offence comes
before the Criminal Court are included in the said expression.
d. It would not be proper for the trial court to reject the
application for addition of new accused by considering records of
the Investigating Officer. When the evidence of complainant is
found to be worthy of acceptance then the satisfaction of the
HITESH
2026.11.18 09:46
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CRM-M-24908-2019 (O&M) - 7-

Investigating Officer hardly matters. If satisfaction of Investigating
Officer is to be treated as determinative then the purpose of
Section 319 would be frustrated”.
9. In the present case also, it is apparent that Sunita, respondent No.2
was admittedly having a litigation with Kamal, her husband/brothers of the
petitioners. Even, in the present case, it is also apparent that respondent No.2
had only suffered some superficial injuries, which could be result of some
scuffle between her and her husband. Even, during the course of investigation,
the police found that respondent No.2 had an altercation with her husband
Kamal, with whom she was already having several cases in different Courts of
law. Apart from that, it was found that the petitioners were elders brothers of
Kamal and had not even participated in the occurrence as they had no concern
with matrimonial life of respondent No.2 and her husband. Rather, both the
petitioners were living separately in a separate portion and had no reason to
participate in the alleged occurrence. Still further, even the allegations levelled
by respondent No.2 in F.I.R and in her testimony, were not corroborated by the
medical evidence. Rather, from the allegations levelled by the complainant, it is
apparent that she had exaggerated the allegations and tried to involve both the
petitioners as well. Apart from that, there is a normal tendency on the part of the
complainant now-a-days to involve all the family members of the husband of
the complainant. Thus, in the considered opinion of the Court, both the
petitioners have been involved by respondent No.2 as they happened to be
brothers of Kamal, husband of respondent No.2. Apart from that, it is also
apparent from the impugned orders that the trial was at the fag end and the
discretion under Section 319 Cr.P.C has been wrongly exercised by both the
HITESH
2026.11.18 09:46
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document

CRM-M-24908-2019 (O&M) - 8-

Courts. In fact, apart from self-suffered statement of respondent No.2, there was
no fresh evidence to show that the petitioners could be involved in the crime
and were aggressors. Even, in the past, the respondent No.2 had lodged other
FIRs also against the petitioners as well and no involvement of the petitioners
was found.
10. Thus, keeping in view the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the matters of Hardeep Singh Vs.State of Punjab and Omi @ Omkar
Rathore & Anr. Vs.State of Madhya Pradesh & Anr . (supra) as well the
findings recorded above, the present petition deserves to be accepted by this
Court.
11. As a consequence, the present petition is allowed and impugned
judgment dated 05.03.2019 (Annexure P-1) passed by the Court of Additional
Sessions Judge, Gurugram as well as the impugned order dated 21.11.2018
(Annexure P-7) passed by the Court of Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Gurugram
are set aside.
12. Pending application(s), if any, stand(s), disposed of, accordingly.
(N.S.SHEKHAWAT)
13.11.2026 JUDGE
hitesh
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
HITESH
2026.11.18 09:46
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document