Dhirendra Narain Kumar and Anr vs State Of Bihar and Anr

Court
Patna High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS No.35296 of 2016
CNR No. BRHC010664172016
Arising Out of PS. Case No.-1561 Year-2006 Thana- DARBHANGA COMPLAINT CASE
District- Darbhanga
======================================================
1. Dhirendra Narain Kumar, Son of Late Upendra Narain Kumar.
2. Bimal Kumar @ Bimla Devi, wife of Dhirendra Narain Kumar,
Both are resident of Mohalla-Balbhadrapur, Near Congress Office, P.S.-
Laheriasarai, District- Darbhanga.
... ... Petitioners
Versus
1. The State of Bihar
2. Reeta Kumar, Wife of Pankaj Kumar (daughter of Prabhakar Choudhary),
resident of Mohalla- Balbhadrapur, in front of Congress Office, P.S.-
Laheriasarai, District- Darbhanga.
... ... Opposite Party/s
======================================================
with
CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS No. 35588 of 2016
CNR No. BRHC010664172016
Arising Out of PS. Case No.-1561 Year-2006 Thana- DARBHANGA COMPLAINT CASE
District- Darbhanga
======================================================
1. Achalendra Nath Jha, son of Late Kameshwar Jha
2. Praveena Jha, wife of Achalendra Nath Jha
3. Sumit Kumar Jha @ Ashwani Kumar Jha, son of Achalendra Nath Jha
All serial Nos. 1 to 3 are resident of Mohalla- Laxmipur, Raj Tank, P.S.-
Laheriasarai, District- Darbhanga.
4. Dilip Kumar Jha, son of Upendra Jha
5. Rozy Jha @ Anjana Jha, wife of Dilip Kumar Jha
Serial Nos.- 4 and 5 are resident of Mohalla- Lalbagh, Near M.R.M.
College, P.S.- Town, District- Darbhanga.
... ... Petitioners
Versus
1. The State of Bihar
2. Reeta Kumar, wife of Pankaj Kumar (daughter of Prabhakar Choudhary)
resident of Mohalla-Balbhadrapur, in front of Congress office, P.S.-
Laheriasarai, District- Darbhanga.
... ... Opposite Parties

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
2/17
======================================================
Appearance :
(In CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS No. 35296 of 2016)
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Prem Kumar Jha, Advocate
Mr. Rajesh Kumar Jha, Advocate
Mr. Mukesh Kumar Jha, Advocate
For the State : Mr. Anuj Kumar Srivastava, APP
For the O.P. No.2 : Mr. Pankaj Kumar Das, Advocate
(In CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS No. 35588 of 2016)
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Prem Kumar Jha, Advocate
Mr. Rajesh Kumar Jha, Advocate
Mr. Mukesh Kumar Jha, Advocate
For the State : Mr. Navin Kumar Pandey, APP
For the O.P. No.2 : Mr. Pankaj Kumar Das, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE CHANDRA SHEKHAR JHA
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 19-11-2026
Both these applications arise out of the same
matrimonial dispute and relate to the same Complaint Case
No. 1561 of 2006 pending before the learned court below.
Since the facts involved in both the applications are
interconnected and the allegations arise out of the same
matrimonial dispute, both the applications have been heard
together and are being disposed of by this common order.
2. At the outset, it is submitted by learned counsel
that Petitioner No. 2, namely, Bimla Devi, (in Cr. Misc. No.
35296 of 2016) who was mother-in-law of the complainant,
has died during the pendency of the petition. Likewise,
Petitioner No. 4, namely, Dilip Kumar Jha, (in Cr. Misc. No.
35588 of 2016) has also died during the pendency of the

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
3/17
petition. Accordingly, no further adjudication is required in
respect of the aforesaid deceased petitioners and the present
order is confined to the surviving petitioners.
3. Both petitions have been filed by the petitioners
for setting aside the order dated 03.05.2016 passed by the
learned S.D.J.M., Darbhanga in connection with C.R. Case
No.1561 of 2006 (T.R. No.670 of 2016), whereby the
learned jurisdictional Magistrate has dismissed the petition
filed u/s 245 of the Code of Criminal Procedure for
discharge.
4. The prosecution case, in brief, is that the
marriage of the complainant, Rita Kumar, was solemnized
with Pankaj Kumar on 21.06.1995 according to Hindu rites
and customs. It is alleged that after marriage, the husband
and his in-laws demanded different articles and cash and
subjected the complainant to torture. It is further alleged
that on 23.10.2006 at about 8.30 A.M., the accused persons
came to the complainant and assaulted her and, when she
protested, her brother arrived there. It is alleged that
accused Nos. 5 to 8 assaulted her brother and threw him

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
4/17
into a gutter, whereas accused Nos. 1 to 4 allegedly
attempted to kill the complainant. Allegations regarding
taking away of ornaments and other articles have also been
made.
5. On the basis of the aforesaid allegations,
Complaint Case No. 1561 of 2006 dated 23.11.2006 was
instituted against eight accused persons for offences
including Sections 498-A, 307, 380 and 120-B of the Indian
Penal Code and Sections 3 and 4 of the Dowry Prohibition
Act.
6. During enquiry, the learned court below
examined the complainant on solemn affirmation and the
enquiry witnesses and thereafter took cognizance, inter alia,
of the offence under Section 498-A of the Indian Penal
Code.
7. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners
submits that the allegations against the petitioners are
general, vague and omnibus in nature and there is no
specific allegation of overt act against any of the petitioners.
It is submitted that the petitioners are near and distant

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
5/17
relatives of the husband of the complainant and they have
been unnecessarily dragged into the matrimonial dispute. It
is further submitted that the same occurrence had earlier
resulted in registration of Laheriasarai P.S. Case No. 381 of
2006, wherein, after investigation, the allegations against
the in-laws were not found substantiated and charge-sheet
was submitted against the husband, Pankaj Kumar only.
8. Learned counsel further submits that the
informant had challenged the said charge-sheet before this
Court in Cr.W.J.C. No. 85 of 2008, which came to be
dismissed by order dated 03.07.2008. It is thus submitted
that the earlier investigation in relation to the same
occurrence is also a relevant circumstance while considering
the continuance of the present prosecution against the
relatives of the husband of the complainant.
9. It has further been submitted that there have
been several litigations between the parties. The petitioners
have brought on record proceedings arising out of the
matrimonial dispute, including other police cases, complaint
proceedings, maintenance proceedings and matrimonial

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
6/17
litigation.
10. It is also submitted that during pendency of
another proceeding, namely, Mahila P.S. Case No. 68 of
2013, the dispute between the parties was amicably settled
and the complainant received three bearer cheques
amounting to Rs.6,00,000/- towards settlement. It is stated
that the complainant had also represented before the learned
court below that she had no grievance against the petitioners
and that she was ready to withdraw the cases pending
between the parties on the basis of compromise.
11. Learned counsel has also relied upon the
earlier order dated 01.10.2012 passed by this Court in Cr.
Misc. No. 29145 of 2009 and the subsequent proceedings
before the learned court below. It is submitted that the
petitioners had thereafter approached the learned court
below for discharge, but their discharge petitions were
rejected vide order dated 03.05.2016.
12. Learned counsel appearing for the State, on
the other hand, has opposed the prayer for quashing and has
submitted that the allegations made in the complaint disclose

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
7/17
commission of cognizable offences and, therefore, the
criminal proceeding may be allowed to continue in
accordance with law.
13. I have considered the rival submissions and
have gone through the materials available on record.
14. The jurisdiction under Section 482 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure is undoubtedly required to be
exercised sparingly and with circumspection. At the same
time, the very object of conferring inherent jurisdiction upon
the High Court is to prevent abuse of the process of law and
to secure the ends of justice.
15. It is equally well settled that while exercising
such jurisdiction, this Court is not required to conduct a mini
trial or appreciate the evidence as would be done at the
stage of final adjudication. However, where the allegations,
even if taken at their face value, do not disclose the
necessary ingredients of the alleged offence against a
particular accused, continuation of such criminal proceeding
would amount to abuse of the process of the Court.
16. Section 498-A IPC is undoubtedly a salutary

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
8/17
provision intended to protect a married woman from cruelty
at the hands of her husband or his relatives. At the same
time, the provision cannot be construed to mean that every
relative of the husband is required to face a criminal trial
merely because matrimonial relations between the spouses
have become strained.
17. The criminal liability under Section 498-A IPC
is personal. The Court is required to examine whether the
allegations disclose the ingredients of the offence against the
particular accused. Mere relationship with the husband
cannot take the place of an allegation constituting the
offence.
18. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Abhishek v.
State of Madhya Pradesh, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1083 ,
while dealing with allegations under Section 498-A IPC
against the mother-in-law and brothers-in-law, noticed that
the allegations against the relatives were general and
omnibus and lacked specific details as to the manner in
which they had subjected the complainant to harassment for
dowry. The Hon'ble Supreme Court held that where the

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
9/17
allegations against the relatives are wholly insufficient and so
far-fetched and improbable that no prudent person can
conclude that sufficient grounds exist to proceed against
them, continuation of the criminal process would result in
clear and patent injustice.
19. The principle laid down in Abhishek (supra) is
of particular relevance in the present matter. The Court is
required to guard against a situation where, in the heat of
matrimonial discord, every member of the family of the
husband is arrayed as an accused without attributing any
distinct criminal act to each of them.
20. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kahkashan
Kausar @ Sonam & Ors. v. State of Bihar & Ors.,
(2022) 6 SCC 599 , has also cautioned against the
tendency of implicating relatives of the husband in
matrimonial disputes on the basis of omnibus allegations and
has held that relatives should not be roped in unless specific
instances of their involvement in the crime are made out.
21. The principle has received further reiteration in
Dara Lakshmi Narayana & Ors. v. State of Telangana

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
10/17
& Anr., (2025) 3 SCC 735 , wherein the Hon'ble Supreme
Court observed that a mere reference to the names of family
members in a criminal case arising out of matrimonial
dispute, without specific allegations indicating their active
involvement, should be nipped in the bud. The Court further
observed that generalised and sweeping accusations,
unsupported by concrete evidence or particularised
allegations, cannot form the basis for criminal prosecution.
22. The recent judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Arti Mehta & Ors. v. State of Madhya Pradesh
& Anr., 2026 SCC OnLine SC 933 , also reiterates the
same principle. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has emphasised
that the Courts are required to exercise greater caution and
carefully scrutinise whether the allegations genuinely disclose
commission of cognizable offences against each accused.
Criminal law cannot be set in motion against every relative
of the husband merely on the basis of generalised and
omnibus allegations lacking a specific factual foundation.
23. Thus, the consistent principle emerging from
the aforesaid judgments is that while the law must protect a

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
11/17
woman against genuine cruelty, the same law cannot
become a means for mechanically prosecuting every relative
of the husband. The Court has to strike a balance between
the two competing considerations.
24. In the present case, on a careful consideration
of the complaint petition, the allegations against the
petitioners do not disclose the necessary particulars showing
their individual involvement in the alleged offence under
Section 498-A IPC. The allegations are substantially omnibus
in nature. There is no sufficient factual foundation disclosing
as to which surviving petitioner committed what particular
act, on what occasion and in what manner such act
constituted cruelty within the meaning of Section 498-A IPC.
25. The circumstance that the petitioners are
relatives of the husband, by itself, cannot be treated as
sufficient to sustain the prosecution. Relationship may
explain why a person has been named; it cannot, by itself,
establish why that person should be criminally prosecuted.
26. The record also assumes significance because
the same broad occurrence had earlier resulted in

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
12/17
registration of Laheriasarai P.S. Case No. 381 of 2006. The
petitioners have brought on record that after investigation
the allegations against the in-laws were not found
substantiated and the charge-sheet was submitted against
the husband, Pankaj Kumar. The informant had challenged
the said charge-sheet before this Court, but the challenge
was dismissed.
27. This Court is conscious that the result of an
earlier police investigation, by itself, may not furnish an
absolute bar to an independent complaint. Nevertheless,
when the earlier investigation concerns the same occurrence
and the allegations against the relatives were not found
substantiated, the said circumstance becomes relevant while
examining whether the present complaint contains sufficient
specific material to justify continuation of prosecution against
them.
28. The petitioners have also placed on record
several proceedings arising out of the matrimonial dispute.
The materials indicate prolonged litigation between the
complainant, her husband and members of the matrimonial

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
13/17
family. The record further indicates that in another
proceeding the parties had reached a settlement and the
complainant had expressed her willingness to withdraw the
pending cases.
29. These circumstances, taken cumulatively with
the nature of allegations made against the petitioners, make
it apparent that the present prosecution against the surviving
relatives cannot be allowed to continue merely on the basis
of their relationship with the husband.
30. It is necessary to remember that a criminal
proceeding is not a mere formality. The accused is required
to undergo the rigours of investigation and trial, and the
very pendency of a criminal case carries consequences upon
reputation, liberty and social standing. Therefore, where the
foundational allegations against a relative do not discloses
the ingredients of the offence, the Court should not compel
such person to undergo the entire process of trial.
31. The maxim “Actus non facit reum nisi
mens sit rea” , though subject to the statutory scheme of
the particular offence, reminds the Court that criminal

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
14/17
culpability must arise from conduct attributable to the
accused and not merely from his or her status or
relationship. In the context of the present case, the relevant
consideration is therefore not merely whether the petitioners
are relatives, but whether any specific criminal conduct
constituting cruelty has been attributed to them.
32. Likewise, the principle embodied in “Quando
aliquid prohibetur ex directo, prohibetur et per
obliquum” —what cannot be done directly cannot be
permitted to be done indirectly—also assumes significance in
the present context. The statutory protection intended for
genuine victims cannot indirectly be converted into a means
for subjecting every member of the matrimonial family to
criminal prosecution without the necessary factual
foundation.
33. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has repeatedly
emphasised that sweeping allegations against relatives in
matrimonial cases should be scrutinised with care and
circumspection. The object is not to dilute the protection
afforded by Section 498-A IPC but to ensure that the

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
15/17
criminal process is invoked against those against whom the
ingredients of the offence are actually disclosed.
34. In the present matter, the allegations against
the surviving petitioners, even if taken at their face value, do
not discloses such specific and individual acts of cruelty as
would justify their prosecution under Section 498-A IPC. The
continuation of the proceeding, therefore, would not advance
the cause of justice but would rather result in unnecessary
harassment of the petitioners.
35. The long pendency of the dispute also cannot
be ignored. The matrimonial dispute dates back to the year
1995, the alleged occurrence is of October, 2006 and the
complaint was instituted in November, 2006. The
proceedings have continued for a considerable period. During
this long pendency, Bimla Devi, Petitioner No. 2 in Cr. Misc.
No. 35296 of 2016, and Dilip Kumar Jha, Petitioner No. 4 in
Cr. Misc. No. 35588 of 2016, have died.
36. Considering the allegations as a whole, the
nature of the role attributed to the petitioners, their
relationship with the husband, the previous proceedings

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
16/17
arising out of the same matrimonial dispute, the earlier
investigation and the law consistently laid down by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, this Court is of the considered view
that continuation of the criminal proceeding against the
surviving petitioners would amount to abuse of the process
of the Court.
37. It is, therefore, a fit case for exercise of the
inherent jurisdiction of this Court under Section 482 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure.
38. Accordingly, the impugned order dated
03.05.2016 passed by the learned S.D.J.M., Darbhanga in
connection with C.R. Case No. 1561 of 2006 (T.R. No.670
of 2016) with all its consequential criminal proceedings
arising therefrom, are hereby quashed and set aside insofar
as the surviving petitioners in both the present applications
are concerned.
39. So far as Bimla Devi, Petitioner No. 2 in Cr.
Misc. No. 35296 of 2016, and Dilip Kumar Jha, Petitioner
No. 4 in Cr. Misc. No. 35588 of 2016, are concerned, both
having died during pendency of the proceedings, no further

Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.35296 of 2016 dt.19-11-2026
17/17
order is required in respect of them.
40. Both the applications stand allowed and
disposed of accordingly.
41. Pending interlocutory application(s), if any,
shall stand disposed of.
42. Let a copy of the judgment be communicated
to the learned trial court forthwith.

(Chandra Shekhar Jha, J.)
Sanjeet/-
AFR/NAFR NAFR
CAV DATE NA
Date of Pronouncement 19.11.2026
Uploading Date 19.11.2026
Transmission Date 19.11.2026